Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Legal/state focus bad

PR’s relationship with autonomy is dictated by the US, Puerto Ricans lack sovereignty on their own terms

Bustos 20 ( Camilla, law professor and expert in human/environmental rights. The Third Space of Puerto Rican Sovereignty: Reimagining Self-Determination Beyond State Sovereignty. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism. 2020. . DOA 7/23/23)//NPR

Sovereignty in the Puerto Rican context has often been debated as a goal that is strictly achieved through political and legal changess; a discussion about national boundaries and membership. Leaders and activists such as Pedro Albizu Campos, Lolita Lebr6n, the Fuerzas Armadas de Liberaci6n Nacional (Armed Forces of National Liberation), Oscar L6pez Rivera, Marie Haydde Beltrin Torres, and others have sought a transformation in the relationship between the island and the United States. Since 1898, there have been over two thousand political prisoners arrested for their resistance to U.S. rule over the island.74 Sovereignty, however, is a complicated concept that encompasses issues beyond the legal status of a territory. This focus on state sovereignty or legal status obscures other important struggles for self-determination. At the same time, it "reflects and imposes a hegemonic way of seeing and knowing the political world," where colonized and marginalized people seem "mute politically when it comes to claims about people, power, and space." 75 This dominant notion of statist sovereignty presumes that "legitimate, viable sovereignty can be secured and expressed only through statist institutions."7 6 Puerto Ricans, however, have claimed a third space of sovereignty. They move across and push against political boundaries "to gain the fullest possible expression of political identity, agency, and autonomy."7 7 The third space of sovereignty questions the notion that expressions of citizenship and sovereignty are limited by dominant political boundaries.78 This is particularly relevant in the context of Puerto Rico, where self-determination has been defined in the context of its relationship with the United States. The history behind the concept of self-determination is beyond the scope of this text, but the end of World War II marked an important moment for colonies around the world and, thus, for common understandings about political sovereignty. In 1945, countries declared through the UN Charter their intention to foster the "creation of conditions of stability and well-being which are necessary for peaceful and friendly relations among nations based on respect for the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples."79 Similarly, UN General Assembly Resolution 1514, also known as the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples, declared that "all peoples have the right to self-determination; by virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development." 80 Both the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights have an article that recognizes the right to self-determination.8 1 In these documents, the international community has characterized self-determination as "the gateway for the full enjoyment of human rights," both economic, social, and cultural rights as well as civil and political rights.82 Sovereignty is more complicated than the question of political status. Professor Kevin Bruyneel defines sovereignty as "the ability of a group of people to make their own decisions and control their own lives in relation to the space where they reside and/or that they envision as their own."8 Bruyneel's work focuses on the struggles of indigenous peoples and their relationships with the U.S. political system, arguing that the imposition of U.S. colonial rule and the indigenous struggles against it constitute a conflict over boundaries. The resistance of indigenous people to this process creates what Bruyneel calls the third space of sovereignty, which "resides neither simply inside nor outside the American political system but rather exists on these very boundaries, exposing both the practices and contingencies" of U.S. domination. I argue that a similar space has existed and continues to exist as Puerto Ricans resist colonialism and reimagine their own sovereignty. While this comparison is by no means perfect, it captures the similar experience of groups who have been subjected to the logic of imperialism. It also serves as another option "for defining and seeing expressions of citizenship and sovereignty that are not confined by dominant political boundaries."84 This third space encompasses resistance to the current status and all its implications for everyday life, spanning beyond the legal and political realm. It exists as a space that Puerto Ricans build and inhabit everyday. The third space occurs when people resist the lack of sovereignty over their own food production, energy generation, evictions, and visitor economy. It manifests itself when people resist the economic and political spaces created by over a century of colonial rule over the island. The spatial boundaries are not inflexible or static. They are contested precisely because Puerto Ricans-and colonized people generally-seek to move forward by challenging colonial impositions and colonial rule to "gain fuller expression of their agency and autonomy." This contestation is "not only about state-sanctioned geographic boundaries, which, although violent and oppressive, are also the most apparent and thus slightly less insidious form of boundaries imposed." 86 Ultimately, the third space allows groups to refuse to conform to the binaries of inside-outside, modernity-traditionalism, and assimilation-independence. People search for a more profound sense of what it means to exercise their right to self-determination and to have a political identity. In essence, the third space problematizes the boundaries of colonial U.S. rule.87 Using the lens of the third space allows us to understand the implications of and responses to colonialism in the context of Puerto Rico. It enriches our current understanding, while challenging the hegemonic notion of state sovereignty. This in turn allows us to broaden our analysis and learn from the ways in which social movements reimagine their existence in a colonized space, resist structural violence, and seek to redefine their reality. It enriches current legal scholarship by going beyond the question of Puerto Rico's political status. Furthermore, in light of the political impasse and the seeming absence of real alternatives to the island's existing political configuration, we must look beyond the obvious places to better understand how legal structures imposing second-class citizenship on Puerto Ricans are contested, particularly by women.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Legal/state focus bad

PR exists under the terms of the US, any attempts of sovereignty must be granted by its colonial power

Bustos 20 ( Camilla, law professor and expert in human/environmental rights. The Third Space of Puerto Rican Sovereignty: Reimagining Self-Determination Beyond State Sovereignty. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism. 2020. . DOA 7/23/23)//NPR

As a result of this historical development, Puerto Ricans are second-class citizens in the United States. Puerto Ricans operate both inside and outside the U.S. legal and political constitutional jurisdiction. They are bound by U.S. law but are also subject to their own constitution and government. They must obey U.S. courts and yet they have no federal representation in U.S. Congress and cannot vote in presidential elections while residing on the island.31 Even their efforts to hold referendums on Puerto Rico's status are merely symbolic and seen more as opinion polls. Any attempt to change the island's status necessitates congressional approval, evidencing the legacies of the conquest model and the existence of colonial rule.3 2 Judge Juan R. Torruella has said of this situation, "I cannot imagine a more egregious civil rights violation, particularly in a country that touts itself as the bastion of democracy throughout the world."33 Puerto Rico's second-class status is also evidenced by the fact that it cannot access international fora in the way that sovereign states do. Puerto Rico cannot enter the United Nations or be a party to any major treaty or international agreement; it can only be an observer in most international organizations.3 4 Even then, it requires U.S. approval since the island is subject to the plenary powers of Congress under the Territorial Clause. While it can petition before the InterAmerican Commission on Human Rights (IACHR, it is still not recognized as a state.3 5 More recently, in Puerto Rico v. Sanchez Valle, the Supreme Court reaffirmed the precedent established by the Insular Cases: the island lacks any sovereignty of its own, with U.S. Congress as the sole source of Puerto Rican sovereignty.36 Writing for the majority, Justice Kagan explained: If two entities derive their power to punish from wholly independent sources (imagine here a pair of parallel lines), then they may bring successive prosecutions. Conversely, if those entities draw their power from the same ultimate source (imagine now two lines emerging from a common point, even if later diverging), then they may not.3 7 Justice Kagan ruled that because the dual-sovereignty doctrine focuses not on the mere existence of self-rule but on its origins, the Court is forced to go to the "ultimate source" of power, which, in the case of Puerto Rico, is the U.S. Congress. This treatment of Puerto Ricans can be understood as the result of what Bruyneel called American colonial ambivalence, which refers to the inconsistencies in the application of colonial rule and the product of institutional and cultural dynamics. 3 9 Thus, it is colonial because the United States holds power in defining the terms of the Puerto Rico-United States relationship, but it is also ambivalent in that it changes. 40 Bill Asheroft explained that ambivalence is not only "the sign of the failure of colonial discourse to make the colonial subject conforn, it is the sign of the agency of the colonized." 41 Iarguethis relationship is also ambivalent in that it offers second-class citizenship to Puerto Ricans, where there are partial benefits, but not all the characteristics of full membership. In turn, Puerto Ricans' resistance to this arrangement contests the boundaries of colonial rule and thus contributes to the ambivalence of the island's relationship with the mainland.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Legal/state focus bad

Sovereignty exists beyond borders and statehood status, and PR’s transcends the power of the US

Bustos 20 ( Camilla, law professor and expert in human/environmental rights. The Third Space of Puerto Rican Sovereignty: Reimagining Self-Determination Beyond State Sovereignty. Yale Journal of Law and Feminism. 2020. . DOA 7/23/23)//NPR

The relationship between Puerto Rico and the United States has long been a story of empire and colonization. From the island's annexation to today, Puerto Ricans have struggled for their right to self-determination. The recently installed fiscal control board, housing crisis, austerity measures, Hurricane Maria, and the resignation of former governor Ricardo Rossell6 have revived social, economic, and political debates about Puerto Rico's political status. In light of the current challenges of attaining real independence and the failure of both the United States and the island's government to protect Puerto Ricans, several communities, activists, and lawyers continue to reimagine self-determination on their own terms. In particular, women across the island have created and led initiatives to assert control over their lives at a moment when neoliberal economic policies and colonial legacies continue to shape the future of Puerto Rico. Sovereignty in this context implies much more than the mainstream political science definition of state sovereignty. Traditionally, sovereignty has been used in post-colonial settings to describe a state's autonomy over its political, economic, and social life, independent from the former colonial power. Bruyneel describes state sovereignty as existing in a mutually constitutive relationship with the international state system. In tandem, this conceptual system reflects and imposes a hegemonic way of seeing and knowing the political world, and this is a world where marginalized groups . . . are presumptively unwelcome, where they seem mute politically when it comes to claims about people, power, and space.' In Puerto Rico, the discussion about sovereignty has been dominated by debates over the island's status vis-a-vis the United States. Now, in light of the island's history, recent crises have led to new forms of resistance to U.S. dominance, or what I call the third space of Puerto Rican sovereignty. I am inspired by Chief Justice Emeritus of the Navajo Nation Robert Yazzie's description of "sovereignty" as "the ability of a group of people to make their own decisions and control their own lives."2 Throughout this Note, I will use "sovereignty" not only to refer to Puerto Ricans' ability to make their own decisions regarding the future of the island, but also over their everyday lives. In this Note, I aim to illustrate how struggles for self-determination and sovereignty manifest themselves beyond the legal and political realms, inspiring local fights for a just recovery in the country.3 I analyze the ways in which Puerto Ricans assert their own visions of sovereignty as opposed to relying on traditional notions of sovereignty that focus on state sovereignty alone, which are often linked to the island's legal status. By studying how communities and groups have mobilized in response to different systems of oppression and a legacy of imperialism, I show how grassroots resistance can circumvent hegemonic notions of state sovereignty, claiming new definitions of individual and collective independence. I aim to center the voices and stories of marginalized groups in Puerto Rico and U.S. society: women, people of color, low-income communities. This is a deliberate effort to understand sovereignty through the eyes of those on the receiving end of state violence as opposed to through the dominant lens of state sovereignty. In particular, I focus on womenled organizations to highlight the ways in which women respond to and resist structural violence fueled by a neocolonial relationship with the United States and the imposition of neoliberal economic policies.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Legal/state focus bad

TAG

Rana 20 ( Aziz, is an American legal scholar and author who currently serves as Richard and Lois Cole Professor of Law at Cornell University specializing in American constitutional law. How We Study the Constitution: Rethinking the Insular Cases and Modern American Empire. The Yale Law Journal. 11/2/20. . DOA 7/23/23)//NPR

In fact, American commentators often view aspects of national history to be uniquely homegrown, when in fact they are present to varying degrees in numerous other settler societies. Among others, these qualities include greater equality within the settler colony than in the imperial metropole or home country; a cultural sense of being “chosen” as a racial, ethnic, or religious community for a historical mission; a greater emphasis on militarism due to perceived threats from Indigenous and foreign populations; and, finally, a wariness of metropolitan social and political customs which are depicted at times as corrupt or decadent.14 But what made the American variation distinctively imperial—why I have referred to the United States as a “settler empire”15—concerns the essential role of continuous territorial conquest to internal economic and political development. Anglo-European settlers carried to North America a belief that the guiding ideological purpose of the national project was to make widely available to insiders a vision of freedom involving participatory political structures and broad access to land and property.16 All of this underscored the extent to which settlers took for granted that their legal and political institutions were meant to do two things simultaneously. First, they were supposed to provide racially-defined members with the emancipatory conditions of self-government and economic independence. And second, to support this overarching project, these institutions were designed to extract much-needed land and labor from Native and nonsettler groups, in the latter case particularly enslaved African persons and their descendants.17 This meant that European Americans long presumed that the basic engine of internal republican freedom and economic prosperity was territorial growth and, therefore, Indigenous conquest. Indeed, conquest was often embraced as the key social experience cohering disparate European migrants into a single people. For the famed early twentieth-century historian Frederick Jackson Turner, “[m]ovement” was nothing less than the “dominant fact”18 of the American experience, a point Teddy Roosevelt echoed even more pointedly when he declared, “The winning of the West was the great epic feat in the history of our race.”19Crucially, rather than undermining the settler imperial dynamics of collective life, the fact that all territory was supposed to be on a path to statehood highlighted them. The U.S. settler empire was systematically organized around efforts to claim Indigenous territory exclusively for insider communities, with territory repeatedly described as virgin or empty.20 Moreover, as historians Caroline Elkins and Susan Pedersen note, the primary approach to the local population was driven less by the desire “to govern [I]ndigenous peoples or to enlist them in their economic ventures than to seize their land and push them beyond an ever-expanding frontier of settlement.”21 This fact partly explains why Americans today rarely conceive of themselves as “settlers.”22 As scholar Patrick Wolfe notes, the basic logic of U.S. settler ideology was not the exploitation of Indigenous groups, but rather that of Native elimination.23 This elimination did not merely take the form of violence against local communities or the dissolution of Indigenous political and economic practices.24 It also meant that settlers sought to replace Native society as such and to “erect[] a new colonial society on the expropriated land base.”25 The vision of Indigenous territory as empty land was part and parcel of settler efforts to transform themselves into ‘Natives’ and to escape the very category of colonialism. Thus, the formal presumption that all territory should eventually become a state in the Union was constitutively joined to this effort to demographically transform the North American landmass. As new land was settled by Anglo-Europeans and fully incorporated—economically and culturally—into the broader society, it gained equal legal status. This process both ensured internal political equality and participation to those included as insiders, as well as the steady displacement of Native peoples. For our purposes, all of this also underscores the profound limits of the traditional way of reading the Insular Cases—namely as a legal debate between anti-annexationists who were anti-imperialists and pro-annexationists who were pro-imperialists. Under this reading, anti-annexationists were opponents of the American empire as such because they “rejected the notion of the United States as a country that could conquer territory and govern it indefinitely at the behest of Congress.”26 Yet, this scholarly interpretation obscures the extent to which the formal presumption of statehood was itself a central feature of how decentralized settler control over Indigenous land proceeded. In other words, as an anti-annexationist, it would be perfectly consistent to oppose overseas expansion through congressional discretion and nonetheless strongly back Native expropriation, ethno-racial hierarchy, and the established terms of the existing settler empire. Indeed, the extent to which formally equal territorial status was closely bound to a demographic and legal-political project of white-settler supremacy is highlighted by the fact that Chief Justice Roger Taney’s 1857 opinion in Dred Scott v. Sandford was perhaps the defining nineteenth-century judicial expression of the claim that the Constitution must follow the flag.27 Today, Dred Scott is remembered as the Supreme Court’s reviled defense of slavery and racial subordination. Chief Justice Taney infamously wrote of the legal status of Black people: “They had for more than a century before been regarded as beings of an inferior order, and altogether unfit to associate with the white race, either in social or political relations; and so far inferior, that they had no rights which the white man was bound to respect.”28 Thus, Taney declared that African Americans, whether or not enslaved, were entirely outside the state’s social compact and that the settler political community maintained an inherent and complete power to control them as a dependent population.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT: Aff makes things better

Self determination exists beyond statehood, a Western idea built on imposing ideas of governance and hierarchy

Saito 20 (Natsu Taylor, Natsu Taylor, is a Distinguished University Professor and Professor of Law at Georgia State University’s College of Law in Atlanta .Ch. 11: Decolonization and Self-Determination, in Settler Colonialism, Race, and the Law: Why Structural Racism Persists, New York: NYU, 2020. DOA 7/19/2023)//NPR

Thinking beyond States States are not inevitable forms of human social organization. The contemporary international legal order is composed of state actors, and we tend to presume that lands and peoples would, of course, come under the exclusive jurisdiction of a particular state. But history tells us otherwise. The current state-centric system is generally traced to 1648 and the Peace of Westphalia, but it took an additional three centuries before the world was divided up almost exclusively between state actors.69 Human societies were organized in many different ways for millennia before states were imposed upon them, and “sub-state” forms of governance continue to be as influential, in many respects, as state governments. “Possession of sovereignty is the result of force threatened and applied,” and “states are the results of wars fought and won, rather than of some sort of natural truth about the community,” Paul Kahn observes.70 State boundaries have always been, and continue to be, in flux, and the viability of the state system itself is increasingly being called into question.71 It is not clear that states have contributed in any significant way to human well- being. Instead, they have functioned to override alternative forms of so- cial organization, imposing in the process very Western, universalizing, hi- erarchical, and exclusive presumptions about governance. But we know that nations can be organized in multiple and overlapping ways, that territories may be shared between them, that individuals can identify themselves within networks of relationships rather than as subjects of a particular sovereignty. This means that self-determination can take many forms. As Rosa Ehrenreich Brooks suggests, “If we stop fetishizing the state, perhaps many phenomena that now often appear . . . as problems . . . would instead appear as virtues or opportunities.”72

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT: Aff makes things better

The distribution of resources and aid paves the way for dependency, a key part of maintaining PR’s colonial status

Fonseca 19(Melody, Department of Political Science, University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras Campus, Puerto Rico. BEYOND COLONIAL ENTRAPMENT: THE CHALLENGES OF PUERTO RICAN “NATIONAL CONSCIOUSNESS” IN TIMES OF PROMESA. Interventions. International Journal of Postcolonial Studies. 3/17/2019. . DOA 7/19/2023)//NPR

Colonial violence against nationalist and pro-independence political movements has been partially successful in demobilizing society. So has been violence against protesters in times of PROMESA. However, current grassroots movements are putting into practice different strategies of struggle that attempt to move beyond the political parties paradigm constrained by the colonial entrapment and by the national liberation frame. This means exploring the possibility for a different approach that breaks with the hierarchical paradigm of power that has limited the anticolonial struggle to the primacy of national sovereignty towards a heterarchical understanding of colonialism, coloniality, and moreover, decolonization. For instance, Jornada employs a strategy of frequent protests and demonstrations against La Junta. They keep organizing demonstrations at every Junta meeting in Puerto Rico, as well as peaceful protests like the one that took place on May 2, 2018 in the main tourist area of El Condado with the purpose of denouncing police brutality during the International Workers’ Day National Strike. Jornada, and Colectiva Feminista en Construcción, puts into practice a political discourse that critically underlines the imbrication of race/gender/class/patriarchy within colonialism at their public manifestations. In this way, these colectivos are engaging with a decolonized national consciousness. Thinking of colonial Africa at the beginning of 1960, Fanon noted: National consciousness, which is not nationalism, is alone capable of giving us an international dimension. This question of national consciousness and national culture takes on a special dimension in Africa. The birth of national consciousness in Africa strictly correlates with an African consciousness. (Fanon 2004, 179) Therefore, political resistance in times of PROMESA calls for a kuschian formulation of the being – the estar siendo (Kusch 2010). In this sense, the question of what estar siendo Puerto Rican means and how a popular national response becomes necessary underpins the effort to weave “new” politics of liberation. Politics that aim to break with colonialism, while moving beyond coloniality and its affective and material entrapments. Specifically, it means maintaining the identity affirmation of “We are not Americans.”10 That is to say, we are not the colonial being, and moreover, we will not be the colonial non-being any longer. On the other hand, as different colectivos such as Comedor Social Universitario or Casa Pueblo in the rural town of Adjuntas are already doing – before, during and after Maria – it means dismantling the imaginary of dependency through community based and everyday practices. For instance, while Comedor Social Universitario has been feeding college students under economic precariousness,11 Casa Pueblo has provided solar panels to families in Adjuntas (Klein 2018). This organization has taken care of patients suffering from medical conditions which make them dependent on electricity; thus the lack of it may result in a life-threatening situation.12 Providing for the immediate necessities of the most vulnerable while building durable networks confirm the possibilities of politics within the colonial entrapment while moving beyond it. To come out of the kumbla, to redeem our past while moving beyond colonial entrapment, is a painful but healing process. Conclusion It is possible to argue that the current political debate in Puerto Rico regarding statehood, commonwealth or independence will lead to a single national response: decolonization. The present economic crisis and the terrible consequences of Hurricane Maria have forced many Puerto Ricans to emigrate to the United States. Contrary to the ideas and imaginaries that have defined the colonial being as more efficient in the execution of policies and resource distribution, the social catastrophe caused by Maria has shown its entrapment within the “colonial/modern gender system” (Lugones 2007). As current research is already demonstrating, the distribution of aid, as well as the articulation of government policies to provide for the most vulnerable, is based on racialized/genderized imaginaries (Martínez 2018), exposing how racialized and genderized the colonial entrapment is. As has been discussed in this essay, Puerto Ricans’ colonial citizenship does not only define a legal status, but also sustains the constant differentiation between the colonial being and the colonial non-being: from subjectivity, to its material consequences. The commonwealth did not turn this around, but rather maintained the subordination of any possible path towards decolonization while strengthening entrapment through economic dependency. Nevertheless, as has been discussed, current sociopolitical movements are paving the way for intersectional resistance to dependency and, therefore, to colonial entrapment. National consciousness is proposed beyond the national liberation frame by articulating the implications of racism, sexism, anthropocentrism, etc., within coloniality. While the sociopolitical scenario reflects how sociogeny constitutes the colonial non-being, the colectivos are knitting together the self and the collective – the individual experience and the collective experience – as a way to break with the kumbla. Whether organized mobilizations against La Junta, educational activities on racism, colonialism and decolonization from a feminist perspective, everyday practices, or community-based solidarity within the most vulnerable sectors as Comedor Social and other initiatives developed after María, the colectivos are breaking with colonial entrapment. They are demonstrating that the legitimate uses of anticolonial violence may not only be performed by physical violence, but must also be recognized in those roots of dependency that are unearthed every day, in the banishment of colonial entrapment through the overcoming of colonial subjects.xs

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT: Aff makes things better

TURN: The US is at fault when it comes to Puerto Ricos economic crisis- more intervention will only make things worse

Fonseca 19(Melody, Department of Political Science, University of Puerto Rico, Rio Piedras Campus, Puerto Rico. BEYOND COLONIAL ENTRAPMENT: THE CHALLENGES OF PUERTO RICAN “NATIONAL CONSCIOUSNESS” IN TIMES OF PROMESA. Interventions. International Journal of Postcolonial Studies. 3/17/2019. . DOA 7/19/2023)//NPR

As “underdeveloping countries” (Fernández Retamar 1993), colonial nations exercise quotidian exploitation and violence through the material and economic spheres. As stated by Fanon, the economic dependency of a recently independent country from its former oppressor was a reality that should be fought for through decolonization. This fight should take the form of national and popular action against colonial elites, beneficiaries of the colonial entrapment. The colonial elite pursue the benefit of their businesses and have no problems with transforming newly independent countries into tourist and investment destinations to improve profits (Fanon 2004, 100–102). This reality allows Fernández Retamar to affirm “only the Third World knows in its wholeness the horrors of capitalism” (2016a, 82); that finds in colonialism one of its most atrocious expressions. In Puerto Rico this economic dependency is also a strategy of colonial entrapment. A decade after the establishment of the commonwealth, official reports suggested “Puerto Rico’s capital yield overseas was 26.9 million dollars, while the foreign capital yield in Puerto Rico was 238.9 million dollars,” a net loss of 212 million dollars (Maldonado-Denis 1988, 160). At the same time, by 1965 foreign debt was 573 million dollars, and a year later Puerto Rico would be paying 3.3 per cent of its GDP in interest. However, by 1967 the total amount of dollars paid in interest was 25.5 per cent higher than a year before (Maldonado-Denis 1988, 160). In this same context, it is important to underline that 80 per cent of imports came from the United States and that 78 per cent of locally established industries were from foreign capital, mostly American (Maldonado-Denis 1988, 156–158). In general terms, this colonial economy included the institutionalization of massive emigration of Puerto Ricans to the United States (Duany 1999; Pol 2014) and the use of unincorporated status to avoid taxing US corporations on the island (Ayala and Bernabe 2016). Both policies paved the way for an economy dependent on the capitalist necessities of the “underdeveloping” nation. Nowadays, one could argue that Puerto Rico has been entrapped in a unilateral “free trade agreement” without having the chance even to discuss the clauses of such an “agreement.” An example of this is the socalled Leyes de Cabotaje that imply that any good imported to, or exported from, Puerto Rico has to go through the United States Merchant Marine. This means a US vessel, flag, and crew; plus, customs are registered at a continental port. In other words, to buy any goods from the neighbouring island of the Dominican Republic, those products should arrive first at any port of continental United States, switch to a US vessel for transport, and then arrive in Puerto Rico. These restrictions were first established by the Foraker Act of 1900, were extended by the Jones Act of 1917, and remained in place after the establishment of the commonwealth through the Federal Relations Act. Its terrible impact on Puerto Rico’s economy has been evident since the economic crisis in the early decades of the twentieth century (Scarano 1993; Curet-Cuevas 2003). It drastically raised the values of imported/exported goods, affected the production, consumption, and exportation of local products, and has since sustained the relation of dependency in two directions: Puerto Rico’s industry is highly dependent on the US market, as Puerto Ricans are dependent on US goods. In this way, colonial entrapment becomes visible: nothing enters or leaves the island without the authorization of the colonial being. Recently, the economist Gustavo Vélez pointed to the roots of Puerto Rico’s crisis being our colonial relationship with the United States. Since the establishment of the Foraker Act, Puerto Rico’s economy has been adversely affected and devalued on behalf of the US economy – firstly, with the conversion of the Spanish peso to the US dollar with an exchange rate of one peso per sixty cents. This facilitated US sugar corporations’ use of this devaluation to buy land at lower prices. Secondly, with the establishment of the US dollar as the official currency in Puerto Rico, devaluations have not occurred directly to money, but rather to property on the island. Thirdly, with significant tax cuts to US investment, as illustrated in Law 20 and Law 22 of 2012 (Vélez 2018), which paved the way for capital investment. And, finally, under the current imposition of PROMESA. Moreover, while the hegemonic discourse on Puerto Rico’s debt insists on local government corruption and mismanagement of federal funding, recent economic research is suggesting that the breaking point of the colonial crisis could be found in the process of “deindustrialization” of the Puerto Rican economy (Caraballo-Cueto and Lara 2018). This process, deepened by neoliberalism and austerity measures within a colonial scenario, has strengthened the colonial entrapment of Puerto Rico’s economy. While Puerto Rico has an external debt of around 70 billion US dollars, colonial status has also become a straitjacket for a possible resolution. In 1984 Puerto Rico was withdrawn from the protection of the US Bankruptcy Code. With this loophole, the local government established a local bankruptcy law (Ley de Quiebra Criolla) in 2014, later derogated as it was considered unconstitutional by the US Supreme Court. Under Title III of PROMESA, it has been established that La Junta has the power to decide everything about Puerto Rico’s debt: what will the government pay; to whom; and if they (La Junta) will call for bankruptcy protection in particular instances or not. None of these decisions will be made by the local government (Colón Colón and Jiménez 2016). Although a large number of Puerto Ricans support an audit of the debt, La Junta opposes this claim and insists on having the expertise to carry out the restructuration and payments to every creditor by imposing an agenda of severe austerity. In this sense, the local government and each of its public agencies has the task of designing a fiscal plan that meets the austerity agenda. This plan will be taken into consideration by La Junta that has the power to accept it, ask for a new plan, or impose a different one. As has been the case since the early stages of US colonialism in Puerto Rico, the colony is portrayed as a primary sector reservoir, holiday resort, the source of cheap labour, human resources for military service, and land to explore and practice military strategies, all within “domestic” territory. Under the control of an “underdeveloping” colonial power, Puerto Rico’s economy is entirely entrapped by the colonial relationship with the United States.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT: Aff makes things better

Plan fails: Even well meaning assistance reinforces the existing hierarchies that subject Indigenous people to colonial rule

Saito 14 (Natsu Taylor, is a Distinguished University Professor and Professor of Law at Georgia State University’s College of Law in Atlanta. Tales of Color and Colonialism: Racial Realism and Settler Colonial Theory. Fall 2014. Florida A & M University Law Review. . DOA 7/19/2023)//NPR

Lorenzo Veracini observes that settler colonial narratives "move forward along a story line that cannot be turned back."5 65 The settlers' vision of establishing a new, superior, and more civilized society undergirds their claims to legitimacy and justifies their assertion of sovereign prerogative. This is reflected in the construct of American exceptionalism, whose central thesis is that the United States represents the pinnacle of Western civilization and, therefore, the highest stage of human progress to date.5 66 There is no endpoint to this vision; settler colonialism ultimately succeeds when it has "ceased being settler colonial" by virtue of permanently normalizing settler hegemony.5 67 Within this worldview, "the discontinuation of a settler colonial circumstance remains unthinkable.'5' 6 Theory is crucial because it renders decolonization "thinkable." In attempting to theorize strategically, it seems particularly useful to identify the processes through which colonial structures of domination and subordination are constructed and maintained. By understanding settler strategies of elimination, subjugation, subordination and manipulation-the ways in which colonization is effectuated-we can begin to develop, envision, and implement strategies to counter those processes. 569 If settler colonization's foundational requirement is the occupation of other peoples' lands, a key precept of any theory of decolonization will be the primacy of Indigenous struggles. As Patrick Wolfe notes, "[n]o amount of good intentions or improved racial theorizing" will alter the underlying colonial reality unless "accompanied by territorial (re-)cession."570 While this may be a point that "many will wish to deny, but none can refute,' 5 7 1 any end run around this premise leaves us engaged in "an exercise in settler nation building. '57 2 Within this framework, as Veracini points out, "even well meaning processes of indigenous and national reconciliation, or the incorporation of indigenous governance structures within the settler polity, ultimately contribute to the erasure of variously defined indigenous sovereignties and therefore to the reproduction of settler colonizing practices. 5 7 3 In other words, if the structures that maintain the subordination, not only of Indigenous peoples, but also peoples of African descent and immigrants of color, are an integral part of the settler colonial enterprise, if they are maintained to ensure the continued profitability of the occupation of Indigenous lands, it is illogical to believe that they can or will be dismantled until the legitimacy of that occupation is effectively challenged. From my perspective, this is why movements for equal rights within the settler polity have not eliminated racial subordination, and why it is in the interest of all peoples who wish to dismantle racial hierarchy to embrace Indigenous decolonization as an integral part of our own struggles for liberation. This is the point at which we often encounter what I think of as the "fear factor." In my experience, it is difficult to have rational discussions about decolonizing American society with anyone who is not Indigenous because the very idea triggers a defensive reaction that generally manifests as "but then we'd have to leave," quickly followed by "and I don't have anywhere to go. '57 4 As this reaction demonstrates, it is useful for settler culture to project sovereignty and identity as all or-nothing propositions, leaving non-Indigenous peoples to imagine that their disappearance is the only alternative to the status quo. Because this is not a thinkable alternative, it allows them to dismiss the foundational issue of colonial occupation without even addressing it. In fact, however, as Dean Saranillio observes, "[i]magined violence on the part of Indigenous movements is a common trope that allows Native savagery to stand in for settler self-critique."575 It was Anglo-American settlers, not American Indian nations, who imposed their presumption of exclusivity, who arrived with a firm conviction that they could live on this land only if Indigenous peoples were eliminated. What decolonization entails is a relinquishment of the settlers' claimed prerogative to encompass everything and everyone within their state; in other words, the conviction that only they are self-determining.57 6 Indigenous nations are not calling for the departure of all settlers or other migrants, "but rather accountability for their discourses and practices that ultimately come at Native expense."577 The presumption that relinquishing exclusive settler sovereignty equates to a wholesale evacuation of the territory by non-Indigenous peoples does not reflect any material reality but simply an inability to conceive of living with, or within, others' polities. What imagining decolonization does require is the capacity to envision forms of social and political organization outside the settler colonial paradigm. Paradigm shifts are, of course, disconcerting, but they can also be immensely liberating.5 78 In supporting the ability of Indigenous peoples to be self-determining, we open up the possibility for all peoples on this continent to be self-determining. If we recognize that the institutions that perpetuate racism and other variants of social, political, and economic exploitation are maintained by the ongoing colonization of this land, we can see that it is in our collective self interest to participate in its decolonization. In other words, challenging the legitimacy of the occupation of this continent, consistently and straightforwardly, is a necessary part of our own liberation. This means not only supporting Indigenous efforts to gain particular land rights within the strictures of settler society, but also supporting Indigenous peoples' struggles for self determination more generally.57 9 Non-Indigenous peoples cannot prescribe what Indigenous self-determination should look like, any more than the U.S. government can dictate the terms upon which Indigenous peoples are "allowed" to be self-determining.58 0 To the extent we impose our own value judgments on other peoples' exercise of their right to self-determination, we are, in essence, invoking a variant of Justice Brown's uncontrovertibly colonial assertion that we can rely on Congress to protect U.S. "dependencies" in accordance with the "principles of natural justice inherent in the Anglo-Saxon character."5 ' The struggle for the liberation of all peoples thus requires, I believe, understanding-and acting upon-the principle that colonialism cannot be dismantled so long as Indigenous peoples remain colonized. While I see this as a necessary step, understanding and addressing the subjugation of other peoples, including but not limited to peoples of color, within settler society will also entail identifying and confronting the strategies of elimination, subjugation, subordination, and manipulation employed to maintain racial hierarchy and protect settler privilege. This is a strikingly under-theorized dimension of settler colonial studies and my purpose here is simply to point out that this framework can be of great utility. The complex dynamics of racialization and institutionalized racism have been explored in law and in virtually all social science disciplines. Building upon this work, if we consider the ways in which any given example-say, racial profiling in traffic stops-serves as a strategy of subjugation or subordination, we can begin to build a conceptual framework that connects seemingly disparate manifestations of racism. By understanding the purposes served by such policies and practices in the context of the settler colonial state, we can more creatively envision remedial measures and assess their ability to empower our communities rather than reinforcing the status quo.5 12 Thus, for example, Andrea Smith proposes that, rather than engaging in what amount to moral appeals to a legal system that has facilitated genocide, slavery, and racism, we should divest the current legal system of its moral authority and think strategically about how it can be used to further a decolonizing agenda. She goes on to propose an approach to gender violence in Native communities that incorporates traditional means of fostering justice and accountability to the community-rather than criminalization and incarceration -within a context that recognizes decolonization as the ultimate goal.58 4 Similar approaches could, of course, be undertaken within any given community and in response to a wide range of problems. Andrea Smith's example illustrates not only the possibility of exercising some degree of self-determination with respect to a particular issue, but the potential for envisioning entirely different bodies of substantive law and systems of enforcement. Robert Cover's oft-cited observation that "[n]o set of legal institutions or prescriptions exists apart from the narratives that locate it and give it meaning" was referenced earlier.58 5 Moving beyond this descriptive statement, he noted that "[t]he position that only the state creates law . . . confuses the status of interpretation with the status of political domination. 58 6 In other words, we can actively and collectively engage in the construction of the law. The same, of course, could be said for developing political, economic, and cultural institutions. In this effort, we can look to international law. International law does not provide us with any quick fixes, but its emphasis on human dignity affirms that we cannot be free within social structures that accord "rights" while crushing the human spirit, and it articulates clearly that all peoples have the right to self-determination. Exercising the right to self-determination can take an infinite variety of forms, from a community's demand for a stop sign at a dangerous intersection; to local control of policing, education, and/or healthcare services; to the reorganizing of economically self-sufficient and politically independent nations. The litmus test, as I see it, is whether any given action empowers communities and promotes decolonization, or further entrenches extant relationships of domination and subordination.

Blue is potential cosmo stuff- overlap idk why it would be useful but imma mark it anyway

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Links

Legislation serves as a vehicle for colonialist action

Córdova 08(Nathaniel I., Willamette University American Ethnic Studies Program, Latin American Studies Program, and the Center for Religion, Law, and Democracy. Expert in Philosophy, Rhetoric, and Theory. The Incomplete subject of Colonial Memory: Puerto Rico and The Post/Colonial Biopolitics of Congressional Recollection. The Communication Review. 2008. . DOA 7/18/2023)//NPR

Although studies of memory in our field have analyzed such memorial vehicles as monuments, epideictic addresses, museums, settlements, and scrapbooks, legislation and plebiscites as sites of remembrance have not been much studied (Browne, 1993; Katriel & Farrell, 1991; Dionisopoulos & Goldzwig, 1992; Katriel, 1994). As technologies of governance, the Young Act and its proposed referendum, and the Report by the President’s Task Force are institutional forms—cultural vehicles that construct and invoke the frames of remembrance through which we view not only Puerto Rico’s colonial past, but also its present and future. In fact, public memory is marked less by any historical accuracy of temporal beginnings than by the way in which frames of remembrance weave the interests of the present into representations of the past. Legislation, especially that which selects as subject matter a people’s “stories of their origins and of their authority as a political order,” is a particularly profitable site for the investigation of just such constructions and negotiation of frames of remembrance (Cox, 1987). The use of legislation as grounding text is significant especially since legislation as constitutive of a state’s social ideology seems so far to have escaped the notice of those rhetoricians who study public memory (Mertz, 1995, p. 361).7 In the case of Puerto Rico, rhetorical analysis is crucial to understanding how legislation and status plebiscites have served as vehicles for the invocation of a memorial narrative that has kept the island in a colonial status. Furthermore, such analysis continues what Marouf Hasian has called “the process of accessing the historical memories of some of these discursive contests over imperial responsibility and colonial morality” (Hasian, 2002, p. 231). Embodying the epistemologies and ritual invocations that constitute and manage Puerto Ricans as colonial subjects, self-determination legislation and political status referendums are part of what Lauren Berlant refers to as the National Symbolic: [T]he order of discursive practices whose reign within a national space produces, and also refers to, the ‘law’ in which the accident of birth within a geographic/political boundary transforms individuals into subjects of a collectively held history. Its traditional icons, its metaphors, its heroes, its rituals, and its narratives provide an alphabet for a collective consciousness or national subjectivity; through the National Symbolic the historical nation aspires to achieve the inevitability of the status of natural law, a birthright. (Berlant, 1991, p. 20) Since Puerto Rico cannot achieve self-determination unless via a congressionally authorized process, the invocation of memories through the Act, its proposed referendum, and the historical narrative commonly shared with the Report by the President’s Task Force constitute a subject of U.S. sovereignty, an incomplete subject of colonial memory, politically immature and unable to achieve self-determination on its own (Miller, 1993, p. xii).8 This subject is geopolitically bounded in two ways: through its location in a territorial possession of the U.S., and through its recollection as spatially located within a collectively held and narrowly defined U.S. history. Consequently, this remembrance through a congressional legislative process for self-determination is ultimately a colonial lieux de memoire, a symbolic loci or topoi used to support the U.S.’s memorial heritage and sovereignty (Nora & Kritzman, 1996). In other words, as a memorial narrative, sovereignty is a partial articulation or configuration of power designed to project and extend political authority. In this case it is expressed as a memoro-politics, what Ian Hacking defines as “above all a politics of the secret, of the forgotten event that can be turned, if only by strange flashbacks, into something monumental” (Hacking, 1995, p. 214). This point is made trenchantly clear by Thomas Blom Hansen and Finn Stepputat in the introduction to Sovereign Bodies: Citizens, Migrants, and States in the Postcolonial World (2005): We suggest that sovereignty of the state is an aspiration that seeks to create itself in the face of internally fragmented, unevenly distributed and unpredictable configurations of political authority that exercise more or less legitimate violence in a territory. Sovereign power . . . is always a tentative and unstable project whose efficacy and legitimacy depend on repeated performances of violence and a ‘will to rule.’ These performances can be spectacular and public, secret and menacing, and also can appear as scientific/technical rationalities of management and punishment of bodies. (p. 3) These texts then, constituting a sovereignty narrative, become a kind of mnemonic socialization, reinscribing the tutelary power of the state over its immature subjects. The relationship of a memoro-politics and sovereignty points to the state’s management of particular populations through the disciplinary “cluster of relations” that Foucault referred to collectively as bio-power. This notion of bio-power designates a calculus, “technologies of power” under which human life is subsumed, operating less as coercive power and more as a production of disciplinary domains of truth/knowledge that facilitate the management of individual bodies and populations (Foucault 1990, p. 140). Congressional memoro-politics, and the knowledge it proclaims, is thus a vehicle for the transformation and management of the colonial subject population. Foucault’s claim about “an explosion of numerous and diverse techniques for achieving the subjugation of bodies and the control of populations, marking the beginning of an era of ‘bio-power,” commends us to examine the ways in which a memoropolitics shape official histories, nationalisms, the remembrance of our colonial past, and forms of subjectivity. More recently, Giorgio Agamben (1998) building on Foucault and political philosopher Carl Schmitt (1975), has extended this notion of biopolitics by highlighting a “politics of sovereign exception” whereby the state exempts itself from its own laws or standards of justice, fostering the development of zones to which particular subjects are relegated. Such an exception exacts a distinction between subjects and the sovereign, whereby the sovereign is exempt from rules of life, while this subject obtains a “bare life” status (zoe), both included and excluded at the same time by virtue of being both part of, but marginalized from, the political community. These “inclusively excluded” people form a category of those mistreated, killed, disappeared, marginalized, or otherwise abused by the state in circumstances that, precisely as a result of such states of exception, fall outside the usual space of the political community. These subjects, described by Agamben through the figure of the homo sacer, occupy the margins of the political order indistinctly and indefinitely—or perhaps, as in the case of Puerto Ricans, until such a time as they are redeemed and allowed to re-enter it. For Agamben then, this distinction between bare life and the sovereign exception is constitutive of political community, as “the production of the biopolitical body is the original activity of sovereign power” (p. 6). As a performance of sovereign power over particular colonial bodies, exercised not only in the name of the nation but in the name of the colonized population, congressional recollection of the U.S.-Puerto Rico political status dilemma is the expression of colonialist biopolitics. This point ought not be surprising since colonialism was always, and in its post/colonial incarnation continues to be, a biopolitical project. The relationship of the United States with the island has from its inception being about the managing and controlling of bodies, from the creation of a special status as “unincorporated territory,” to the discourses of imperial science that sought to catalog its new possessions early after the Spanish-American War, to current efforts at “oxymoronically” granting self-determination to Puerto Ricans, the U.S. colonial project retains the sovereign exception. Consequently, questions of the political status of Puerto Rico become a problem of sovereign power articulated through a nostalgic lens of concern for the lives of Puerto Ricans still depicted as immature or incomplete colonial subjects.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Links

FW-ish link- Congressional legislature is shrouded in colonialist themes, by demanding governmental actions the AFF re-entrenches Puerto Rico in the same cycle of colonial violence

Córdova 08(Nathaniel I., Willamette University American Ethnic Studies Program, Latin American Studies Program, and the Center for Religion, Law, and Democracy. Expert in Philosophy, Rhetoric, and Theory. The Incomplete subject of Colonial Memory: Puerto Rico and The Post/Colonial Biopolitics of Congressional Recollection. The Communication Review. 2008. . DOA 7/18/2023)//NPR

The Mnemonic Power of the Law: Establishment of Congressional Memorial Superiority Over That of the Colonial Subject Congress further extended the legitimacy of its recollection by asserting its memorial superiority and establishing an incomplete colonial subject just arriving at the gates of political maturity. Puerto Ricans were (and are) deemed incomplete subjects by virtue of their political immaturity, their inability to resolve their problem of political status. Such incompleteness, combined with the already established congressional authority, marks the subject’s absence of memory and thus “world,” creating an ever-expanding master’s universe in which the subject can participate. This master’s universe is deployed in the registers of congressional memory. Moreover, congressional memory excludes the U.S.’s role in forging a fragmented colonial situation in the first place, but takes the fragmentary nature of the subject’s recollection and pits it against Congress’ own unified “whole and coherent” recall based on access to a legal archive that can re-member selves through officially sanctioned mechanisms like the referendum. The preponderance of institutional and judicial evidence that the Young Act, and the Task Force Report marshall in support of official recollection invests them with a mantle of moral superiority by virtue of their capacious memory, and the sovereign exception to dictate the space of the nation occupied by their unincorporated possession.21 The imprimatur of congressional authority even legitimates its claims to memory over those of its colonial subjects by countering the viability of Puerto Ricans using such documents as the Puerto Rico Federal Relations Act (48 U.S.C. 731 et seq.), which some Puerto Rican leaders had rightfully claimed described the relationship between the United States and the island as being “in the nature of a compact, based on the principle of consent,” as memorial touchstone in support of their own recollection (48 U.S.C. 731b): Based upon the present status of Puerto Rico under Public Law 81–600, the Federal courts have ruled that for purposes of U.S. law this arrangement for local territorial government has not changed Puerto Rico’s status as an unincorporated territory subject to the plenary authority of Congress under the Territorial Clause; that the right to due process and equal protection of the law applies to Puerto Rico, but this does not include equal enfranchisement in the political process or equal rights and benefits under Federal law as available to citizens residing in the States; that the authority of the Government of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico is limited to purely local affairs not governed by provisions of the Federal Constitution and Federal laws applicable to Puerto Rico; and that the establishment of local constitutional self-government with the consent of the people was authorized through an exercise of Congressional discretion under the Territorial Clause which is not binding on a future Congress. Harris v. Rosario, 446 U.S. 651 (1980); Examining Board v. Flores de Otero, 426 U.S. 572, 81–600 (1976); Rodriguez v. Popular Democratic Party, 457 U.S. 1 (1982); U.S. v. Sanchez, 992 F.2d 1143 (1993). (H.R. 105–131, p. 13) The tone of the Young Act is one of correcting and disciplining the recollection of its colonial subjects, an approach also clearly seen in H.R. 105–131’s section titled “Puerto Rico’s International Legal Status,” especially in the paragraph noting that, “those who suggest that U.S. diplomats overstated the degree of self-government achieved under the Constitution to get the U.N. to go along may be partially right, but that is why countries submit written statements to clarify ambiguities and set the record straight” (p. 15). Once again, we are reminded of the legal archive upon which congressional memorial superiority is grounded, setting the record straight as to the intent of the United States, and disciplining any counter-memorializing. Official congressional recollection declares not only that Puerto Rico has been a colonial backwater since 1898, but remembers Puerto Ricans as “statutory citizens,” a colonial limbo with no guarantee of protection under the U.S. Constitution unless one of the options provided by Congress is adopted. The language of statutory citizenship emerges as a citizenship class that embodies the “included excluded” status that firmly locates the subject at the margins of the political order, with less than equal rights: While the U.S. citizenship of persons born in Puerto Rico is expressly recognized in the local constitution, the current citizenship of persons born in the territory is not created, defined or guaranteed by the local constitution or the commonwealth structure of local self-government. Rather, the current U.S. citizenship of persons born in Puerto Rico is created and defined by Congress in the exercise of its Territorial Clause power and in implementation of Article IX of the Treaty of Paris. (H.R. 105–131, p. 13) Through this “exclusionary inclusion” Puerto Ricans are thus ambivalently inscribed into the political order arriving at self-determination if and when they choose the course of action provided by the United States. To this end, the Young Act included a provision proposed by Representative Dan Burton (R-Indiana) which stipulated that in the event the initial referendum was deemed inconclusive and Puerto Ricans chose to continue commonwealth status, another referendum would take place no less than once every 10 years or until such a time when a viable status was selected. Thus, although 1998 conceivably marked the moment at which Puerto Ricans as colonial subjects had finally arrived at the gates of political maturity, it did not guarantee self-determination. The colonial subject remains an incomplete subject until such a time when it remembers to choose properly from a menu provided by the colonial master and Congress deems the choice appropriate. Congressional memory relies on legal doctrine as universalizing discourse, displacing contingency and replacing it with the mnemonic power of the law. Ensconced within the mantle of legal discourse, Congress masks an attempt at “departicularizing” the U.S.-Puerto Rico relationship, that is, erasing any semblance of localized or concretely situated meaning, by using a barrage of legal detail and technical reference (Alonso, 1988).22 Paradoxically, the law’s mnemonic power also grants congressional memory the appearance of particularity. Not only does the minute level of recollection establish institutional authority, but it numbs us by the sheer weight of its rhetorical prowess. This departicularization or universalization is achieved by diverting our attention to a set of legal specificities, such as Supreme Court decisions and constitutional clauses to which Congress holds privileged access and thus special institutional recollection. Its reliance on the mnemonic power of law grants Congress the semblance of a detached observer, an objective institution through which knowledge of the past flows. As a result, Congress appears as speaking with a unified voice, one that bestows upon congressional memory a sense of normalcy and correctness, what sociologist Ana Maria Alonso refers to as “transparent objectivity” (Alonso, 1988, p. 36). As Alonso also tells us, the “voice” of the “I” who “sees” is that of the observer, an observer who claims to hear the colonial subject’s voice while remaining eyewitness to the past, and thus its sole legitimator (p. 45). As sole legitimator of the past, Congress retains the power to define Puerto Rico’s present and future, prohibiting Puerto Ricans living in the U.S. from voting in the referendum, and demanding compliance with language admonitions for entrance into the union as a state. These demands once again reveal the logic of sovereign exception that suffuses congressional claims to a process of self-determination, reasserting a biopolitical practice that required the locals to subject their bodies and lives to the various demands of the colonial master. The weight of legal precedent displayed in these artifacts, and the exclusion of the U.S.’s responsibility in forging the colonial impasse, coupled with the newly remembered moral responsibility of Congress, and the declarative style in which the Young Act reasserts the U.S.’s national interest, do not countenance any opposition to the U.S.’s authority to act as it sees fit with the island. As Congressman Burton, a member of the House Committee on Resources that initiated H.R. 856, oxymoronically noted during the first hearings on the Act, “If the Puerto Rican people choose to maintain Commonwealth status, turning away from self-rule, we as a Congress will maintain the supreme administrative control of the island” (Young Act Hearings Report: #105–16, 1997, p. 4). In essence, Rep. Burton’s comment was an invocation of traditional authority which sought to establish itself, as Hannah Arendt’s dictum in the introduction to Walter Benjamin’s Illuminations reminded us, as sovereign: “Insofar as the past has been transmitted as tradition, it possesses authority; insofar as authority presents itself historically, it becomes tradition” (Arendt, 1969, p. 38). Hence, Congress’s memorial superiority, buttressed by the mnemonic power of the law, and by the vision of the incomplete memory of the colonial subject now finally arriving at the gates of political maturity, grants Congress, the Young Act, and the proposed referendum as sites of remembrance, an unapologetic aura of tradition, authority, and full sovereignty over the incomplete subject of colonial memory that it constitutes, and which inhabits an indistinct zone of exception in a U.S. post-colonial imaginary. Congress takes great pains to make sure its authority is firmly established by asserting their right and authority under the territorial clause of the U.S. Constitution to determine federal policy and resolve issues of self-determination for the island. Of foundational value among the historical claims is the recognition of congressional authority over Puerto Rico as stipulated in article IX of the Treaty of Paris and thus in U.S. Constitutional law: “under the Territorial Clause of the Constitution, Congress has the authority and responsibility to determine Federal policy and clarify status issues in order to advance the self-determination process in Puerto Rico” (H.R. 856, Part 2, 12). Although claims to authority do not culminate with this next passage in the Young Act, titled Authority of Congress to Determine Status, it is perhaps the most telling of them all: Since current unincorporated territory status of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico is not a permanent, unalterable, or guaranteed status under the Constitution of the United States, Congress retains plenary authority and responsibility to determine a permanent status for Puerto Rico consistent with the national interest. (H.R. 856, Part 6, 3)

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT Aff Solve Self-Determination

The alt is self-determination,

Alfonso 07 (Ricardo, Human Righst specialist, DOA 7/20/2023)//NPR

Self-determination is a social and political status that may also be expressed as a legal right in international law."l The peoples' right to self-determination is so widely recognized in international conventions that it has acquired a status beyond "convention and is now considered a general principle of international law."' 6 Besides recognition in international covenants, the right to selfdetermination has also been recognized by other international legal documents, and by jurisprudence of the International Court of Justice.17 As such, it is of paramount importance for courts, when examining the application of federal laws that highlight the dilemma of the current political status, to acknowledge that the issue of self-determination is unresolved in Puerto Rico. Assuming that a compact in fact was made between the people of Puerto Rico and the United States, it is arguable that, when in conflict, the Constitution of Puerto Rico should trump federal law if the two were incompatible. As reflected by our previous discussion of case law, the federal courts have rejected this theory, repeatedly stating that the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution applies to Puerto Rico, and thus federal law is in fact hierarchically superior to the Constitution of the Commonwealth. However, considering Puerto Rico's lack of political representation in the Federal Government it is not in the same situation as the states, so, it follows that no such compact existed and that Puerto Rico is still under territorial, or colonial, control. Therefore, the application of the FDPA, as should be the case with any other federal law violating the will of the people of Puerto Rico, is in itself a violation of the right to selfdetermination and a demonstration of the true nature of the current political status. C. The application of the FDPA as a violation of the right to internal selfdetermination The ambit of application of the right to self-determination and its denotation has expanded over the years. Today, self-determination connotes not only a right to political independence, or decolonization, but also the people's right to shape their own political, social, economic, and cultural development. This corollary of the right to self-determination entitles a people to have internal autonomy and democratic rule. The definition encompassing the internal dimension of the right is supported by the language of international Covenants, and in the Declaration of Principles of International Law Concerning Friendly Relations and Co-operation among States in Accordance with the Charter of the United Nations.us Under this legal scheme, the imposition of the FDPA against the will of the people of Puerto Rico is a violation of the right to internal selfdetermination. Some commentators have argued that the right to self-determination cannot be considered fully exercised merely by procedural mechanisms, usually popular referendums, rather attention must also be paid to the outcome and results. 9 Thus, when a relation like the one between Puerto Rico and the United States exists, a procedural event, such as the referendum approving the PRFRA and the Constitution, cannot be deemed as sufficient for the full exercise of the right. This would impair the people from enjoying their right to continuously exercise self-determination. The ongoing nature of self-determination is crucial under political status were "democratic deficits", such as the automatic application of federal laws, infringe the development of self-government, or "internal" selfdetermination. That is to say, "If law -including the international legal order- is to come out on the side of liberation, it must transcend the formalistic perspective. It must take cognizance of results and conditions.' 3 ' This is especially the case with the death penalty in Puerto Rico, since its application violates the right to determine a specific human rights policy within the territory and breaches a political decision taken by the people of the Island to eliminate the death penalty.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT Aff Solve Self-Determination

Alt Solves -- The United States only will consider options that hold its colonial control over Puerto Rico

Pedro Cabán, 21, Pedro Cabán is Professor of Latin American, Caribbean and U.S. Latino Studies at the University at Albany. "The End of the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico", Dissent Magazine, 4-30-2021, https://www.dissentmagazine.org/online_articles/the-end-of-the-commonwealth-of-puerto-rico/, Wooster FG

But if ELA is dead, how long will it lay in state? Will it ever be interred?

Senators on both sides of the aisle have already expressed their opposition to statehood, including Senator Chuck Schumer, who said that he is “not going to support their statehood bill.” Even if Congress agreed to accept the results of a referendum, it is doubtful it would commit to admitting Puerto Rico into the union on the basis of a simple majority vote, as H.R. 1522 provides. In the absence of overwhelming popular support for statehood, Congress will not act.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › AT Aff Solve Self-Determination

The project of incorporation into statehood is not anti-imperial - making Puerto Rico a state is constitutive of settler colonial logic

Aziz Rana, 20, Aziz Rana is the Richard and Lois Cole Professor of Law at Cornell Law School. Many thanks to Ayoub Ouederni and the editors of the Yale Law Journal for the invitation to join this Collection and for their excellent editorial assistance. "How We Study the Constitution: Rethinking the <i>Insular Cases</i> and Modern American Empire", No Publication, 11-2-2020, https://www.yalelawjournal.org/forum/how-we-study-the-constitution, Wooster FG

Crucially, rather than undermining the settler imperial dynamics of collective life, the fact that all territory was supposed to be on a path to statehood highlighted them. The U.S. settler empire was systematically organized around efforts to claim Indigenous territory exclusively for insider communities, with territory repeatedly described as virgin or empty.20 Moreover, as historians Caroline Elkins and Susan Pedersen note, the primary approach to the local population was driven less by the desire “to govern [I]ndigenous peoples or to enlist them in their economic ventures than to seize their land and push them beyond an ever-expanding frontier of settlement.”21 This fact partly explains why Americans today rarely conceive of themselves as “settlers.”22 As scholar Patrick Wolfe notes, the basic logic of U.S. settler ideology was not the exploitation of Indigenous groups, but rather that of Native elimination.23 This elimination did not merely take the form of violence against local communities or the dissolution of Indigenous political and economic practices.24 It also meant that settlers sought to replace Native society as such and to “erect[] a new colonial society on the expropriated land base.”25 The vision of Indigenous territory as empty land was part and parcel of settler efforts to transform themselves into ‘Natives’ and to escape the very category of colonialism.

Thus, the formal presumption that all territory should eventually become a state in the Union was constitutively joined to this effort to demographically transform the North American landmass. As new land was settled by Anglo-Europeans and fully incorporated—economically and culturally—into the broader society, it gained equal legal status. This process both ensured internal political equality and participation to those included as insiders, as well as the steady displacement of Native peoples. For our purposes, all of this also underscores the profound limits of the traditional way of reading the Insular Cases—namely as a legal debate between anti-annexationists who were anti-imperialists and pro-annexationists who were pro-imperialists. Under this reading, anti-annexationists were opponents of the American empire as such because they “rejected the notion of the United States as a country that could conquer territory and govern it indefinitely at the behest of Congress.”26 Yet, this scholarly interpretation obscures the extent to which the formal presumption of statehood was itself a central feature of how decentralized settler control over Indigenous land proceeded. In other words, as an anti-annexationist, it would be perfectly consistent to oppose overseas expansion through congressional discretion and nonetheless strongly back Native expropriation, ethno-racial hierarchy, and the established terms of the existing settler empire.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Alt Solvency Ext

The Alternative must be immediate change – any path that leaves the decision of Puerto Rican governance to the United States locks in a mindset within the Puerto Rican population that makes Self-Determination Impossible.

Scott Bordow, 23, "ASU professor testifies before UN on Puerto Rican self-determination", ASU News, 6-30-2023, https://news.asu.edu/20230629-global-engagement-asu-professor-testifies-un-puerto-rican-selfdetermination, Wooster FG

Q: How did your work studying these disparities influence your testimony and what was the gist of your testimony?

A: I went as a psychologist. There were a lot of attorneys who were talking more about the sort of legal ramifications of colonialism in Puerto Rico. I had a different take, which is this disparity in mental health. What we know from other populations who also have experienced colonization is that, beyond the political and beyond the economic ramifications, there’s also a toll that happens at the health and psychological level. It’s not only about the economy and politics, but the narratives and what we end up internalizing about ourselves as a people who have been colonized. You create a narrative and logic where the colonized community is inherently racially, culturally and linguistically inferior. That then sets up why we cannot govern ourselves or we can’t be self-determined. That ends up affecting our self-esteem, which in turn affects depression, anxiety and intergroup dynamics.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › Alt Solvency Ext

The Alternative must be immediate change – any path that leaves the decision of Puerto Rican governance to the United States locks in a mindset within the Puerto Rican population that makes Self-Determination Impossible.

Scott Bordow, 23, "ASU professor testifies before UN on Puerto Rican self-determination", ASU News, 6-30-2023, https://news.asu.edu/20230629-global-engagement-asu-professor-testifies-un-puerto-rican-selfdetermination, Wooster FG

Q: How did your work studying these disparities influence your testimony and what was the gist of your testimony?

A: I went as a psychologist. There were a lot of attorneys who were talking more about the sort of legal ramifications of colonialism in Puerto Rico. I had a different take, which is this disparity in mental health. What we know from other populations who also have experienced colonization is that, beyond the political and beyond the economic ramifications, there’s also a toll that happens at the health and psychological level. It’s not only about the economy and politics, but the narratives and what we end up internalizing about ourselves as a people who have been colonized. You create a narrative and logic where the colonized community is inherently racially, culturally and linguistically inferior. That then sets up why we cannot govern ourselves or we can’t be self-determined. That ends up affecting our self-esteem, which in turn affects depression, anxiety and intergroup dynamics.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Colonial Necropolitics

Necropolitics north america bad for colonized

Pérezts ‘21 –Eemlyon business school

[Mar Pérezts, Department of Social Sciences & Humanities, Emlyon Business School & OCE Research Centre, Ecully, France, “Necropower in North America: Getting Away with Murder: Unpacking Epistemic Mechanisms of Necropower and Disposability in North America,” Palgrave Macmillan, Cham., 2021, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-73659-0_6//IC]

In this chapter, I have argued that the production of disposability and necropower operate first and foremost at the epistemic level before trans- lating into violent materializations, and that the latter is in fact the shame- ful result of a complex epistemic process. To sum up, necropower in North America, understood as the institutionalized organization of profitable violence and death, operates epistemically within a specific order through four intertwined mechanisms: the normalization of violence and death, masculinization, marketization, and derision. All constitute key modi ope- randi, each allowing power over a specific order (respectively, power over a representational order, over a gendered order, over an economic order, and over a subjectification order) and warranting further study. This com- plex death-space appears as a case of organizing beyond organizations, that is, as a multilevel phenomenon of necropolitics taken to new propor- tions and effects. Epistemologically speaking, this organizes, legitimizes, and perpetuates disposability both as an empirical and conceptual trait of how necropower unfolds not above or beneath the law, but through it, sustained and legitimized by a necroempowered order.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Colonial Necropolitics

Normalization of Violence and Death

Pérezts ‘21 –Eemlyon business school

[Mar Pérezts, Department of Social Sciences & Humanities, Emlyon Business School & OCE Research Centre, Ecully, France, “Necropower in North America: Getting Away with Murder: Unpacking Epistemic Mechanisms of Necropower and Disposability in North America,” Palgrave Macmillan, Cham., 2021, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-73659-0_6//IC]

Growing up in Mexico, I’ve experienced first hand how getting accus- tomed to everyday street and narco violence is sadly a fact of life, part of our embodied habitus. We learn from a very early age that violence is not a matter of if, but when. We are taught to look behind us, to see whether we’re being followed. We erect barbed wire around our homes, however humble they may be. We are sadly no longer surprised when we hear of a kidnapping, of when we are threatened at gunpoint to give up money or jewelry at a random street corner in broad daylight. Violence, death, and the accompanying fear continue to benefit from impunity, are part of everyday life, particularly as women, to the extent that they become nor- mal, and we learn to live with them.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Colonial Necropolitics

Unpacking the epistemological Dimension of necropower and Disposability in north America

Pérezts ‘21 –Eemlyon business school

[Mar Pérezts, Department of Social Sciences & Humanities, Emlyon Business School & OCE Research Centre, Ecully, France, “Necropower in North America: Getting Away with Murder: Unpacking Epistemic Mechanisms of Necropower and Disposability in North America,” Palgrave Macmillan, Cham., 2021, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-73659-0_6//IC]

Getting away with murder depends on constituting a sufficiently robust logic behind necropower that frames it as conceptually acceptable, and even inescapable; as an order of things that cannot be reasonably challenged. Fear of ending up in pieces in a plastic bag is the emotional mechanism that makes sure of this, but even before fear, the order of necropower is epistemically constructed as a ‘system that works’, a ‘cosmos’ of tragedy but of incredible efficacy.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Extinction

Decolonizing Lands best response to Mass Extinction

Bendik-Keymer ‘21 – Professor at Case Western Reserve

[Jeremy Bendik-Keymer, Professor (Philosophy) Case Western Reserve University: Cleveland, OH, US, “Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws: a philosophical essay on respecting jurisdiction,” Griffith Law Review, DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595, 4/13/21, https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595//IC]

I believe that I have made a plainly reasonable case for decolonising lands and laws as a moral response to the threat of mass extinction. My argument is philosophical and ‘big- picture’, as we say from where I’m from. It leaves the details up to those more qualified than I to discuss the law – whether Indigenous or nation-state based.

2023 DDI Negative
NEG---KM vs TT Puerto Rico › Colonialism K › ! - Extinction

Land abstraction

Bendik-Keymer ‘21 – Professor at Case Western Reserve

[Jeremy Bendik-Keymer, Professor (Philosophy) Case Western Reserve University: Cleveland, OH, US, “Facing mass extinction, it is prudent to decolonise lands & laws: a philosophical essay on respecting jurisdiction,” Griffith Law Review, DOI: 10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595, 4/13/21, https://doi.org/10.1080/10383441.2020.1878595//IC]

The moral problem in the legacy of European imperialism isn’t just the afterlife of plunder with its unresolved historical crimes.48 The problem goes deeper than that. At the centre of the drivers of mass extinction is land abstraction. Land abstraction is the instrumentalisation of land for the purposes of economic value shorn free of moral considerability. Land abstraction leaves us open to – and in that sense makes possible – mass extinction as an anthropogenic phenomenon. Land abstraction, we might say, opens the way to destruction at the scale of the planet.49