Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: alt causes/SSI insufficient

Social Security solves poverty in Puerto Rico.

Romig 23 – Kathleen Romig is Director of Social Security and Disability Policy at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. She works on Social Security, Supplemental Security Income, paid leave, and other budget issues. Romig previously worked at the Social Security Administration, Social Security Advisory Board, and Congressional Research Service, B.A. from Michigan State University’s James Madison College. ("Social Security Lifts More People Above the Poverty Line Than Any Other Program," Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, https://www.cbpp.org/research/social-security/social-security-lifts-more-people-above-the-poverty-line-than-any-other) //ox

Most people aged 65 and older receive the majority of their income from Social Security.[1] Without Social Security benefits, 37.7 percent of older adults would have incomes below the official poverty line, all else being equal; with Social Security benefits, only 10.3 percent do. (See Figure 1.) The benefits lift 15.4 million older adults above the poverty line, these estimates show. Comprehensive studies that match Census survey data to administrative records suggest that the official estimates overstate older adults’ reliance on Social Security but confirm that Social Security lifts millions of older adults above the poverty line and dramatically reduces the poverty rate among people aged 65 and older. Social Security Lifts 1 Million Children Above the Poverty Line Social Security is important for children and their families as well as for older adults. About 6.2 million children under age 18 (9 percent of all children in the U.S.) lived in families that received income from Social Security in 2021, according to Census data. This figure includes children who received their own benefits as dependents of retired, disabled, or deceased workers, as well as those who lived with parents or relatives who received Social Security. In all, Social Security lifts 1 million children above the poverty line.[2] Social Security records show that 2.7 million children under age 18 qualified for Social Security payments in December 2021. (See Appendix Table 2.) Of these, 1.2 million were the survivor of a deceased worker. Another 1.1 million received payments because their parent had a severe disability. And 327,000 children under 18 received payments because their parent was retired.[3] Social Security Protects Groups That Are Particularly Vulnerable to Poverty and Social Security is especially important for women and people of color. Women tend to earn less than men, take more time out of the paid workforce, live longer, accumulate less savings, and receive smaller pensions. Social Security brings 8.8 million older women above the poverty line, as Table 2 shows. Black and Latino workers benefit substantially from Social Security because they have higher disability rates and lower lifetime earnings than white workers, on average. In addition, Black workers have higher rates of premature death than white workers, and so their spouses and children are more likely to be eligible for Social Security survivor benefits. Latino workers have longer average life expectancies than white workers, which means they have more years to collect retirement benefits. Without Social Security, the poverty rate among older Latino adults would be 44.5 percent, and the poverty rate among older Black adults would be 50.2 percent.[4] Social Security Reduces Poverty in Every State Social Security reduces poverty dramatically among older adults in every state as well as Washington, D.C. and Puerto Rico, as Figure 2 and Appendix Table 1 show. Without Social Security, the poverty rate for those aged 65 and over would meet or exceed 40 percent in one-fourth of states; with Social Security, it is less than 10 percent in over two-thirds of states. Social Security lifts more than 1 million older adults above the poverty line in California, Florida, and Texas, and over half a million in Illinois, Michigan, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, and Pennsylvania.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: Puerto Ricans pay less taxes

SSI recipients barely pay federal taxes anyway – it is not a rational basis for excluding Puerto Rico

Harvard Law Review 22 (Harvard Law Review, Harvard Law Review Volume 136, Issue 1, November 2022, https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/#:~:text=Last%20Term%2C%20in%20United%20States,the%20territory%20as%20a%20whole.)//SW

But the picture is very different for the distinction between SSI can- didates in Puerto Rico and those on the mainland: the basis for this distinction is not rational at all, as Justice Sotomayor explained. The government gave only two purportedly rational bases for treating Puerto Rico residents differently for SSI purposes: federal taxation and cost. However, neither of these distinguishes would-be SSI recipients in Puerto Rico from SSI recipients in the states. The cost of the benefit is the same wherever the beneficiary lives, and, due to indigence, virtu- ally no SSI recipients pay federal income tax. Though these consider- ations differentiate Puerto Rico from the states, they do not differentiate between any individual SSI candidates. The only grounds asserted are thus “wholly irrelevant” to the unequal treatment of the individuals, so Justice Sotomayor correctly found no rational basis for this classification.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: Puerto Ricans don’t pay SSI taxes

The expressed purpose in the law was territorial exclusion

Pr51st 22, 11-28-2022, Puerto Rico 51st, "Why Doesn’t Puerto Rico Pay Federal Income Tax?,", https://www.pr51st.com/why-doesnt-puerto-rico-pay-federal-income-tax/, Accessed 7-19-2023,dedee

The law exempting income earned in Puerto Rico from federal income tax was passed with the idea that Puerto Rico would have more flexibility in local tax collection if the residents weren’t paying federal income tax.

One law office put it like this: “Section 933 was not designed as an incentive for U.S. citizens trying to enjoy the benefits of Acts 20 and 22 (which are generally not available to ordinary Puerto Rican residents), but rather a mechanism to effectively allow Puerto Rico to apply its [local] tax laws to raise revenue (and provide benefits from such revenue to its residents).”

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: Puerto Ricans don’t pay SSI taxes

Decision to exclude Puerto Rico from SSI benefits is rooted in racial stereotyping and oppression

Ford 22. Matt Ford is a staff writer at the New Republic. His work focuses on law, the courts, and democracy. Originally from Nevada, Matt previously wrote for The Atlantic. “Neil Gorsuch Has a Critical Race Theory About Puerto Rico,”. April 27, 2022. https://newrepublic.com/article/166219/gorsuch-puerto-rico-insular-cases//博洋

“[The ruling] makes it far easier for Congress, a body in which the territories are not represented, to treat residents of those territories differently with those who live in the states -- not just for Supplemental Security Income, but for all federal benefit programs,” said CNN Supreme Court analyst Steve Vladeck.

Puerto Rico is not a state of the US, it is a territory. This gives Congress the power to decide on its dealings with the island, despite the island having no representation in this process. These rulings and decisions are handed down to Puerto Rico, with no real recourse to stand up for itself.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: Puerto Ricans don’t pay SSI taxes

SSI recipients barely pay federal taxes anyway – it is not a rational basis for excluding Puerto Rico

Harvard Law Review 22 (Harvard Law Review, Harvard Law Review Volume 136, Issue 1, November 2022, https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/#:~:text=Last%20Term%2C%20in%20United%20States,the%20territory%20as%20a%20whole.)

But the picture is very different for the distinction between SSI can- didates in Puerto Rico and those on the mainland: the basis for this distinction is not rational at all, as Justice Sotomayor explained.75 The government gave only two purportedly rational bases for treating Puerto Rico residents differently for SSI purposes: federal taxation and cost. However, neither of these distinguishes would-be SSI recipients in Puerto Rico from SSI recipients in the states. The cost of the benefit is the same wherever the beneficiary lives, and, due to indigence, virtually no SSI recipients pay federal income tax. Though these considerations differentiate Puerto Rico from the states, they do not differentiate between any individual SSI candidates. The only grounds asserted are thus “wholly irrelevant” to the unequal treatment of the individuals, so Justice Sotomayor correctly found no rational basis for this classification.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: no legal basis for aff

Puerto Rico SSA ruling is not justified under rational basis

Harvard Law Review 22 (Harvard Law Review is a student-run journal of legal scholarship publishing articles by students, professors, judges, and practitioners. “United States v. Vaello Madero,” Issue 1, Volume 136, 11/01/22, https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/#:~:text=The%20package%20Congress%20designed%20for,a%20rational%20basis%20for%20Congress's)//sz

Equal protection under the Fifth Amendment guarantees that the federal government will not discriminate against individuals without a rational basis. Not in Puerto Rico. Last Term, in United States v. Vaello Madero, the Supreme Court decided that Congress can deny benefits to residents of Puerto Rico on the basis of the tax status of the territory as a whole. The Court rejected an equal protection claim for social security benefits without considering whether there was a rational basis for discriminating against the class of would-be beneficiaries. To do so, it conflated discrimination between political units with discrimination between individuals. Collapsing its equal protection analysis into its Territory Clause analysis, the Court rendered equal protection claims for discrimination on the basis of territorial residence all but nonjusticiable.

While living in New York, José Luis Vaello Madero started to receive Supplemental Security Income (SSI), a federal social security benefit available to any resident of the fifty states, the District of Columbia, or the Northern Mariana Islands whose income and assets fall below prescribed limits and who are blind, disabled, or sixty-five or older. In 2013, Vaello Madero moved to Puerto Rico. He continued to receive SSI payments until 2016, when he received notice that his residence in Puerto Rico disqualified him from receiving the benefit. A year later, the federal government sued him in the District of Puerto Rico to recoup the $28,081 that it had accidentally paid him between 2013 and 2016.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: no legal basis for aff

Fifth amendment requires Puerto Rican SSI benefits.

Harvard Law Review 22 ("United States v. Vaello Madero," Harvard Law Review, https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/#footnotes-container) //ox

Equal protection under the Fifth Amendment guarantees that the federal government will not discriminate against individuals without a rational basis. Not in Puerto Rico. Last Term, in United States v. Vaello Madero,1 the Supreme Court decided that Congress can deny benefits to residents of Puerto Rico on the basis of the tax status of the territory as a whole.2 The Court rejected an equal protection claim for social security benefits without considering whether there was a rational basis for discriminating against the class of would-be beneficiaries. To do so, it conflated discrimination between political units with discrimination between individuals. Collapsing its equal protection analysis into its Territory Clause analysis, the Court rendered equal protection claims for discrimination on the basis of territorial residence all but nonjusticiable. While living in New York, José Luis Vaello Madero started to receive Supplemental Security Income3 (SSI), a federal social security benefit available to any resident of the fifty states, the District of Columbia, or the Northern Mariana Islands4 whose income and assets fall below prescribed limits and who are blind, disabled, or sixty-five or older.5 In 2013, Vaello Madero moved to Puerto Rico.6 He continued to receive SSI payments until 2016, when he received notice that his residence in Puerto Rico disqualified him from receiving the benefit.7 A year later, the federal government sued him in the District of Puerto Rico to recoup the $28,081 that it had accidentally paid him between 2013 and 2016.8 The government and Vaello Madero issued a joint statement of fact, and each moved for summary judgment.9 Granting Vaello Madero’s motion,10 Judge Gelpí reasoned that fundamental constitutional rights — including Fifth Amendment due process rights and, through them, the equal protection guarantee11 — constrain the federal government’s actions in unincorporated territories such as Puerto Rico.12 Under equal protection, the government’s denial of Vaello Madero’s SSI benefits on the basis of his Puerto Rico residency could thus be sustained only if it survived rational basis review.13 Judge Gelpí found the classification by residence to be “by no means rational.”14 The government had justified the classification on the basis of the costs of extending the SSI program to Puerto Rico and the fact that Puerto Rico residents pay no federal income tax on Puerto Rico–derived income.15 However, these justifications were “belied” by the realities that almost no SSI recipients pay federal income tax due to their indigence, that Puerto Rico residents contribute to the federal treasury in other ways, and that residents of the Northern Mariana Islands as well as noncitizens on the mainland are eligible to receive SSI benefits.16 Instead, Judge Gelpí found that “[t]he principal purpose [of the classification] is to impose inequality” and that the classification thus could not survive rational basis review.17 Finally, Judge Gelpí rejected the government’s reliance on Califano v. Torres18 and Harris v. Rosario,19 two factually similar cases in which the Supreme Court found a rational basis for denying benefits to residents of Puerto Rico,20 finding that he could not “ignore important subsequent developments in the constitutional landscape.”21 The First Circuit affirmed.22 Writing for the panel, Judge Torruella23 analyzed the case assuming Califano and Harris remained good law24 but found them inapposite: Califano was about whether the denial of SSI to residents of Puerto Rico violated the right to travel, not equal protection;25 Harris was about block grants to states under a different program, not SSI’s individually distributed benefits.26 Because Califano and Harris were summary dispositions, they were binding only as to “the precise issues presented and necessarily decided” and so were not dispositive in this case.27 Moreover, the rational basis that Califano and Harris found was, in part, the “fact” that extending SSI benefits to Puerto Rico residents would disrupt Puerto Rico’s economy, a fact that had since become doubtful and was not argued in this case.28 Thus treating this case as one of first impression, Judge Torruella found that the justifications offered by the government — the cost of extending SSI to Puerto Rico and the fact that federal income tax is not extended to Puerto Rico — could not serve as a rational basis for the classification.29 Cost alone cannot be a rational basis for denying benefits to some individuals but not others because any benefit incurs costs.30 Further, the income tax argument was inapposite because virtually no SSI recipients pay federal income tax.31 Conceding that equal protection permits distinctions that lack “mathematical nicety,” Judge Torruella still found the classification in this case to be “wholly without any rational basis.”32 The Supreme Court reversed.33 Writing for the Court, Justice Kavanaugh34 held that the Territory Clause of Article IV “affords Congress broad authority to legislate with respect to the U.S. Territories,” including the authority to legislate “differently with respect to the Territories . . . than it does with respect to the States.”35 This authority lets Congress structure unique packages of taxes and benefits for the territories so long as there is a rational basis for doing so.36 The package Congress designed for Puerto Rico does not include the SSI benefit nor “most federal income, gift, estate, and excise taxes.”37 Though Califano and Harris were decided in different contexts, each held that Congress’s choice not to extend a tax to residents of Puerto Rico was a rational basis for Congress’s choice not to extend a welfare benefit to residents of Puerto Rico.38 Justice Kavanaugh found those results controlling.39 Regarding the objections to the income tax rationale, he found that “Congress need not conduct a dollar-to-dollar comparison of how its tax and benefits programs apply in the States as compared to the Territories, either at the individual or collective level.”40 Finally, he noted that if equal protection required equal benefits in the states and territories, state residents could challenge the lower taxation of territorial residents.41 Justice Thomas concurred, writing separately to propose that Fifth Amendment due process does not incorporate Fourteenth Amendment equal protection against the federal government.42 In his view, until Bolling v. Sharpe,43 Fifth Amendment due process required only a rational basis for legislation and imposed no equal protection limit on federal action.44 Bolling incorporated this requirement against the federal government using Lochner-era substantive due process,45 a theory that “strains credulity” because it sits uneasily with the constitutional text and pre–Civil War historical understandings46 and relies on an overbroad conception of liberty.47 Reading the Fifth Amendment Due Process Clause to include an equal protection guarantee also makes the Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause redundant in light of the Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause.48 Further, Bolling relied on a “debatable” and out-of-scope “moral judgment[]” that it would be “unthinkable” for the Constitution to hold the federal government to a lower standard than the states.49 Instead, according to Justice Thomas, Fifth Amendment due process is just “a separation-of-powers concept designed as a safeguard against unlicensed executive action.”50 He “tentative[ly]” concluded that the Fourteenth Amendment Citizenship Clause might “still prohibit the Federal Government from discriminating on the basis of race, at least with respect to civil rights.”51

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: no legal basis for aff

The court ruling is outdated---policy changes since then enable & warrant expanding SSI

Andrew Hammond 20, Professor Hammond joined Maurer faculty in 2023. He was an Assistant Professor of Law and an Associate Professor of Law at University of Florida Levin College of Law. Hammond also previously taught in the College and the Law School at the University of Chicago., 07/13/20, University of Florida Levin College of Law, “TERRITORIAL EXCEPTIONALISM AND THE AMERICAN WELFARE STATE”, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=188070086031106070068091005091110110004011091052061061010085126126027067086006099119037011125063116000098101017075085107030110020075007033072006092114093120067018103006065034067000088074067114070080089117108099125103008119017104093107071100115017073116&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE, DShah

Rationale #1: Federal Income Tax. The federal government has argued in both cases that the fact that Puerto Rican residents only pay federal income tax on certain sources of income provides a rational basis from excluding them from SSI, SNAP, and the Medicare subsidies.244 That’s true: residents of Puerto Rico do not pay federal income tax on most types of income.245 Unlike other Social Security benefits which are paid for through payroll taxes (taxes that Puerto Ricans pay), SSI is paid for by general tax revenue, including income tax receipts.246 Yet, while the Supreme Court in Rosario states that Puerto Ricans “do not contribute to the federal treasury,” recent tax receipts suggest otherwise.247 Puerto Rico contributes roughly $4 billion in annual tax revenue to the federal government, exceeding the contribution of several states.248

More importantly, this is a confused justification for excluding any group of Americans from SSI. As a means-tested program, SSI’s eligibility rules are not based on past or future federal tax payments. SSI is a program that only kicks in when an applicant has been shown to have insufficient work history to qualify for Social Security Disability Insurance and has little or no income.249 The idea that Congress could use a logic of contributory insurance to justify a noncontributory (i.e., means-tested) program is odd.250 The same is true for SNAP. No other group of Americans are excluded from SNAP because they do not pay income taxes. While it is difficult to find national data on tax receipts by these recipients, it is highly unlikely that many Americans who receive SNAP, SSI, or Medicare Part D have any federal income tax liability.251 As the First Circuit noted, an individual cannot have more than $8,796 in countable annual income to receive SSI, which is significantly less than the standard deduction of $12,400 for single tax filers, let alone for the blind and elderly.252 Perhaps that is why there is no other case where the federal government has defended its exclusion of a group of people from a welfare program on the basis of federal tax contributions.253

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: economic disruption theory

EDT doesn’t permit the exclusion of Puerto Ricans

Vélez 22 (Katerina Martínez Vélez, University of Missouri PhD Candidate, “Trouble in Paradise: Puerto Rico’s Routine Exclusion From Federal Benefit Programs as a Result of the Alien-Citizen Paradox,” The Business, Entrepreneurship and Tax Law Review Journal, Volume 6, Issue 2, Article 9, 2022, )//SW

The Economic Disruption theory hypothesizes that because of Puerto Rico’s high poverty and unemployment rates, extending benefit programs such as SSI, LSI, and SNAP to the island may have an especially adverse impact on labor incentives.147 However, as the Court in Peña Martinez notes, assuming that this theory is accurate, it makes little sense to wield it against certain groups of people, namely the aged, blind, and disabled, and other groups that, through no fault of their own, are generally not present in the workforce.148 The Court concedes that the Economic Disruption theory is not completely baseless, however, it may not be rationally used to explain the exclusion of Puerto Rican citizens from these benefit programs.149 These programs are meant to provide uniform benefits nationwide, regardless of the local poverty rate. 150 Moreover, the exclusion of Puerto Rican citizens encompasses a wide range of financially needy people, including the aged and disabled, for whom no “incentive” is suitable to place a job within their reach.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: califrano and harris

Califano and Harris cannot justify all unequal treatment and was not in the context of SSI

Harvard Law Review 22 (Harvard Law Review, Harvard Law Review Volume 136, Issue 1, November 2022, https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-136/vaello-madero/#:~:text=Last%20Term%2C%20in%20United%20States,the%20territory%20as%20a%20whole.)

Justice Sotomayor dissented, arguing that there was no rational basis for the denial of SSI benefits to residents of Puerto Rico.Conceding that Califano and Harris held that Puerto Rico’s tax status can justify unequal treatment, she maintained that they cannot justify “any and all unequal treatment “and argued that they are each distinguishable: Califano did not consider SSI under the equal protection framework, and Harris considered a block grant program, not a “uniform, federalized, direct-to-individual . . . program like SSI.”Further, Califano and Harris each relied on “the mistaken premise that residents of Puerto Rico do not contribute at all to the Federal Treasury,” whereas the government conceded here that they do. Treating the question as one of first impression, Justice Sotomayor contended that because SSI recipients on the mainland pay no federal income tax, it is irrational to ex- clude residents of Puerto Rico “on the basis that they do not pay enough taxes,” as that fact does not distinguish the two disparately treated classes Finally, she argued the majority’s holding allowed Congress to exclude beneficiaries from the states that contribute less to the federal treasury. 6 4

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---UQ---predictive

Elderly in Puerto Rico depend on social security

Fericelli 13 - Paul-Jesús Fericelli, LMSW, is an Instructor in the College of Arts & Humanities, Department of Social Work at The Pontifical Catholic University of Puerto Rico in Ponce, Puerto Rico. ("Family Assistance for Older Adults in Puerto Rico," Advances in Social Work, https://journals.iupui.edu/index.php/advancesinsocialwork/article/view/3809/13946) //ox

The United States provides Social Security benefits to assist older adults, and in 2005 research showed that almost 13 million U. S. senior citizens were lifted from the ranks of poverty because of Social Security (Sherman & Shapiro, 2005). Additionally, by 2010, this number increased to 36 million (Van de Water & Sherman, 2010). Other studies showed that about 9% of the population of the United States, age 65 years or older, is still living in poverty (DeNavas, Proctor, & Smith, 2010). Furthermore, for each 10% cut in public assistance, approximately 3% of America’s older adult households slip into poverty (Center for Strategic and International Studies, 2010). When considering income levels alone, at least 40% of people, age 65 years and older living in Puerto Rico are on the poverty borderline. (Ortiz, Abreu, Torres, & Vera, 2010b; Puerto Rico Community Survey, 2009). Puerto Rican older adults utilize Social Security, Medicare and public assistance as their main sources of income (Ortiz et al., 2010b). The United States Census Bureau (2009) has forecasted that Puerto Rican older adults will top 1 million in 10 years. The projection suggests that an additional one million Puerto Ricans will depend on public assistance, however, such support is questionable given cuts in federally funded programs.

Puerto Rico has a higher proportion of older adults in comparison with all of the U. S. territories (Administration on Aging, 2010; United Nations, 2009). By 2015, the population of older adults will be greater than that of children aged 15 years or under (Ortiz et al., 2010a; Tendencias Project, 2006). Sadly, a recent survey notes that 16.5% of Puerto Rican older adults have been victims of maltreatment or abuse, 40 % are living below poverty standards, and 50.3% are disabled living in their homes (Puerto Rico Community Survey, 2009). If these trends continue, they will clearly affect the cultural assets of the families and neighborhoods.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---UQ---poverty

Poverty increasing now – grids prove.

Bentley 6-28 - Chris has reported on climate change and the environment for public media outlets including PRI, WGBH and RIPR. He has a bachelor's degree in natural resources from Cornell University and a master's degree in journalism from Northwestern University. ("How Puerto Rico is preparing its electric grid for future hurricanes," WBUR, https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2023/06/28/puerto-rico-electric-grid-hurricanes ) //ox

In December, Congress greenlit $1 billion to "improve the resilience of Puerto Rico's electric grid,” on top of $11.4 billion already committed to the government-owned utility for recovery after Hurricane Fiona, which battered the island in September. Fiona knocked out electricity across the territory for days — weeks in some areas — exposing how brittle Puerto Rico's grid remains nearly six years after the unprecedented damage of Hurricane Maria in 2017. Many on the island want to break free from that cycle of destruction by building a decentralized grid powered largely by solar energy. But activists say the government isn’t doing enough to hasten that transition. 'Pueblo Solar' One vision for the future of Puerto Rico’s grid is in the small town of Adjuntas. Along Adjuntas’ central square, 14 businesses and two apartment buildings run on solar power, even as the sun sinks behind the mountains.

A ‘vicious cycle’ There are lots of communities in Puerto Rico who want what Adjuntas has. La Margarita is one of them. It's a neighborhood in the town of Salinas that experiences frequent flooding and power outages, especially after hurricanes. Many residents are elderly. Some live off a few hundred dollars a month from Social Security. And emergency preparedness is on everyone's mind here, says Wanda Ríos, president of the neighborhood association. “One of our missions was to have a resilient community,” Ríos says. “To have a resilient community, we have to have a resilient energy system.” Earlier this year, they installed solar panels on the community center, but Ríos wants the whole neighborhood to form a microgrid to better prepare for the next storm. “You can have a generator for maybe two or three hours and then you run out of gas. And when we have a hurricane, you don't have gas,” she says. “If we want to keep living, we want a clean environment, we have to move to solar.” The neighborhood association recently won a $30,000 grant from the federal Department of Energy to install more solar panels, but they need a lot more. And Ríos says the Puerto Rican government is too slow to certify groups like hers as energy cooperatives so they can access other types of financing.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---UQ---poverty

Puerto Rico poverty high now, plan key to solve.

Muchacho 7-5 – (The News Journal, "Puerto Rico highly dependent of emergency federal funds, according to ETI Trends study," Weekly Journal, ) //ox

Puerto Rico’s economic development has become highly dependent of emergency federal funds from the United States government in the past six years, according to a study by Technical Studies Inc. (ETI Trends in Spanish). Following the devastation of hurricanes Irma and María, the Covid-19 pandemic, and more, federal funds have been the source of economic stability for the island, despite very low levels of growth. However, it has become clear that the dependency on emergency federal funds has grown exponentially. The study shows just how much the island has become dependent of federal funds. It showed that a spike in federal funds occurred in 2020, when the total rose from $26,968.8 million in 2019 to $33,881.0 million in 2020. In 2021, the total amount of federal funds went up to $42,846.6 million. “What remains are still the funds that will be disbursed in the coming years, including CDBG-DR, CDBG-MIT, and from FEMA, as well as the ones from programs that are not related to reconstruction. An example of these funds are the ones authorized by Congress for the Medicaid Program (destined to “Plan Vital”), to be distributed during the next five years,” said a press release from ETI Trends. The study also shows that most of the funds are destined to pay for people’s Social Security and Medicare, who represent 58% of the total. In the fiscal year 2022, a total of $39,750.4 million was received from federal funds. A total of $17,778.8 million went straight for the benefiting of Social Security and Medicare. This includes revenues from the Economic Stimulus Act of 2008, the Digital Television Transition and Public Safety Fund, the American Reinvestment Act of 2009, pandemic, disasters and federal recovery funds. “These are funds to whom there is an acquired right because people pay for them. They represent 45% of total federal funds received in fiscal year 2022,” the study said. While the study proves that there was an increase in federal funds from 2013 to 2021, it also shows that there was a decrease in the funds of about $3.100 million in 2022. Of those funds, $2.000 million were destined to go to the beneficiaries of Social Security and Medicare.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: congress solves aff

Congress won’t pass anything now BUT questioning the Insular Cases forces Congress to address it

Smith 23 (Elliot Smith, “Decolonozing the United States: The Case for Overturning the Insular Cases,” Brown Political Review, March 15, 2023, https://brownpoliticalreview.org/2023/03/decolonizing-the-united-states-the-case-for-overturning-the-insular-cases/)

Fitisemanu can also serve as an opportunity for the Court to admit that the racist logic used to justify perpetual US colonialism was wrong. As Neil Weare, the founder of the organization Equally American, explains, the Insular Cases  as Plessy v. Ferguson which created the “separate but equal” doctrine. While Plessy was , the Insular Cases, decided by many of the same justices, remain fully enforceable. A Supreme Court decision formally repudiating this decision would serve as a powerful recognition of the injustice imposed on Americans living in the territories. This acknowledgement would be largely symbolic. As Christina Ponsa-Kraus writes in the Yale Law Journal, overruling the Insular Cases  the current system—the territories would remain territories with no voting representation in Congress. The symbolic significance of overturning this shameful precedent could, however, spark greater attention to the issue. Just as overturning Plessy in Brown v. Board of Education sparked decades of legal and political challenges that advanced racial justice in the US, part of the importance of the Court’s ruling in Fitisemanu would be the subsequent political efforts that stem from it. 

Rejecting the framework of the Insular Cases would put significant pressure on Congress to address the territory problem, an opportunity they should use to promote the self-determination of those living in each territory. Since the notion of an “unincorporated territory” would no longer exist, all US territories would theoretically have to be . For some places like Puerto Rico, where in 2020  statehood in a referendum, statehood might be a desirable path, although there would likely be significant opposition from some lawmakers in Congress. Other territories, such as American Samoa, that have expressed reservations about further integration with the US might seek an alternate path. For example, American Samoa could seek independence as a , an option that would give them complete sovereignty including representation at the United Nations while maintaining some of the benefits provided by the US as part of an international agreement. Rather than repurposing the racist framework of the Insular Cases, this type of inclusive political debate that would move territories towards statehood or independence would best serve the need for self-determination in the territories. While the courts have no ability to compel congressional action on re-evaluating the status of the territories, the ruling in Fitisemanu could increase political pressure on lawmakers to address this long overdue issue. 

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: congress solves aff

Congress is not going to pass anything to help Puerto Ricans

Weare 21 (Neil Weare, raised in Guam and is the president and founder of Equally American, which advocates for equality and civil rights in U.S. territories. He is the co-author of the forthcoming casebook Law of U.S. Territories, which he has taught at Yale and Columbia, Slate, October 18, 2021 https://slate.com/news-and-politics/2021/10/biden-puerto-rico-vaello-madero-supreme-court.html)

Last year, during the heat of the presidential campaign, then-candidate Joe Biden  in response to a tweet announcing the Trump administration’s appeal of Vaello-Madero to the Supreme Court that “[t]his ends when I’m elected president.” But when  as president to stop defending these discriminatory laws in court, Biden blinked.

To the  of many, the Biden Justice Department continued defending the denial of SSI in Puerto Rico,  in its brief to the Supreme Court that “the Constitution vests Congress, not the courts, with responsibility for making appropriate changes.” The Justice Department did, however, concede there was “a strong policy case for increasing federal aid to needy residents of Puerto Rico.” Apparently, when Biden promised “this ends,” his eye was towards Congress, not the courts.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: court solves aff

Unfavorable signals from Court & program’s susceptibility makes Congress more receptive

Andrew Hammond 20, Professor Hammond joined Maurer faculty in 2023. He was an Assistant Professor of Law and an Associate Professor of Law at University of Florida Levin College of Law. Hammond also previously taught in the College and the Law School at the University of Chicago., 07/13/20, University of Florida Levin College of Law, “TERRITORIAL EXCEPTIONALISM AND THE AMERICAN WELFARE STATE”, https://deliverypdf.ssrn.com/delivery.php?ID=188070086031106070068091005091110110004011091052061061010085126126027067086006099119037011125063116000098101017075085107030110020075007033072006092114093120067018103006065034067000088074067114070080089117108099125103008119017104093107071100115017073116&EXT=pdf&INDEX=TRUE, DShah

Looking forward, the Supreme Court’s recent decisions, including unanimously upholding Puerto Rico’s oversight board, suggests that the Court will be less solicitous of equal protection challenges.266 And some programs may be more vulnerable to constitutional attack than others. Programs like SSI and SNAP that have benefit levels for the entire nation except certain territories seem particularly vulnerable, but Medicaid may be less amenable to litigation by Americans in the territories. Medicaid involves a mix of federal and state funding, and the Supreme Court undid the Affordable Care Act’s attempt to create a national standard of eligibility. The unfavorable signals from the Supreme Court and the difference in programs’ susceptibility to court challenges suggest that Congress may be a more receptive forum to change the status quo of placing territorial Americans outside the welfare state. Despite being a national legislature that denies meaningful participation to some Americans, including those who are the focus of this Article, Congress could eliminate the territorial exceptionalism in the American welfare state. The next Section explains how it could do so.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: status quo solves

Disabled and elderly people in Puerto Rico currently receive no funding, at most they get $58 a month

[Nick Buffie, 11-12-21, Center for American Progress, Nick Buffie is a Senior Policy Analyst at PPI's Center for Funding America's Future, where he focuses on tax reform, income security programs, pro-growth public investments, and fiscal sustainability, "Massive Safety Net Loopholes Hurt Poor Puerto Rican Residents,", https://www.americanprogress.org/article/massive-safety-net-loopholes-hurt-poor-puerto-rican-residents/, Accessed 7-15-2023, LASA-LR]

Residents of Puerto Rico are not denied all benefits. Rather, federal law often contains odd carveouts for people on the island. For example, until earlier this year, Puerto Rican families were only eligible for the child tax credit (CTC) if they had three or more children. Before 2021, a poor mainland family with two children could receive up to $2,800 of CTC benefits, while  received nothing.

In other instances, Puerto Rico is given  that substitute for normal safety net programs. For example, in place of SSI, Puerto Rico receives the . And in place of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), Puerto Rico receives the . While in theory these block grants could provide Puerto Rico with the same funding as under normal guidelines, in practice, they have resulted in  to programs for the poor.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
case › advantage/solvency › 2ac---at: status quo solves

Rights are being denied, not granted

Povey ’22. Oliver Povey is a journalist and writer for AS USA newspaper. “Social security disabilities: why did the Supreme Court deny benefits for residents in Puerto Rico?”, May 14, 2022. https://en.as.com/latest_news/social-security-disabilities-why-did-the-supreme-court-deny-benefits-for-residents-in-puerto-rico-n//博洋

In the latest set back to equality in the US, Puerto Rico has once again been denied the same rights as other parts of the US. The Supreme Court has ruled that, as a territory and not a state, the same rules and rights need not be passed on to the island that exist in other parts of the US. One of the points made by Justice Kavanaugh, who penned the 8-1 opinion, was that “just as not every federal tax extends to residents of Puerto Rico, so too not every federal benefits program extends to residents of Puerto Rico.” This argument was criticized by Justice Sotomayor, herself of Puerto Rican descent and the only dissenting voice. She said this ruling could be used to target citizens living in states which pay much less federal taxes, like Vermont, Wyoming, South Dakota, North Dakota, Montana and Alaska.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---framing

No nuclear extinction – no scientific backing

Ladish 20(Jeffrey Ladish, Executive Director at Palisade Research Oakland, California, United States. Ladish, Jeffrey. “Nuclear War Is Unlikely to Cause Human Extinction.” Lesswrong.com, 7 Nov. 2020, www.lesswrong.com/posts/sT6NxFxso6Z9xjS7o/nuclear-war-is-unlikely-to-cause-human-extinction. Accessed 19 July 2023.)//rhftw

A number of people have claimed that a full-scale nuclear war is likely to cause human extinction. I have investigated this issue in depth and concluded that even a full scale nuclear exchange is unlikely (<1%) to cause human extinction. By a full-scale war, I mean a nuclear exchange between major world powers, such as the US, Russia, and China, using the complete arsenals of each country. The total number of warheads today (14,000) is significantly smaller than during the height of the cold war (70,000). While extinction from nuclear war is unlikely today, it may become more likely if significantly more warheads are deployed or if designs of weapons change significantly. There are three potential mechanisms of human extinction from nuclear war: 1) Kinetic destruction 2) Radiation 3) Climate alteration Only 3) is remotely plausible with existing weapons, but let's go through them all. 1) Kinetic destruction There simply aren't enough nuclear warheads to kill everyone directly with kinetic force, and there likely never will be. There are ~14,000 nuclear weapons in the world, and let’s suppose they have an average yield of something like 1 megaton. This is a conservative guess, the actual average is probably closer to 100 kilotons. With a 1 megaton warhead, you can create a fireball covering 3 km², and a moderate pressure wave that knocks down most residential houses covering 155 km². The former kills nearly everyone and the latter kills a decent percentage of people but not everyone. Let's be conservative and assume the pressure wave kills everyone in its radius. 14,000 * 155 = 2.17 million km². The New York Metro area is 8,683 km². So all the nuclear weapons in the world could destroy about 250 New York Metro areas. This is a lot! But not near enough, even if someone intentionally tried to hit all the populations at once. Total land surface of earth is: 510.1 million km². Urban area, by one estimate, is about 2%, or 10.2 million km.² Since the total possible area destroyed from nuclear weapons is ~2.17 million km² is considerably less than a lower bound on the area of human habitation, 10.2 million km², there should be basically no risk of human extinction from kinetic destruction. The circle with the white border indicates the zone of moderate blast damage radius (5 psi): 7.03 km (155 km²) from a 1,000 kiloton warhead, If you want to check my work there, I was using . The even more obvious reason why kinetic damage wouldn't lead to human extinction is that nuclear states only threaten one or several countries at a time, and never the population centers of the entire world. Even if NATO countries and Russia and China all went to war at the same time, Africa, South America, and other neutral regions would be spared any kinetic damage. 2) Radiation Radiation won't kill everyone because there aren't enough weapons, and radiation from them would be concentrated in some areas and wholly absent from other areas. Even in the worst affected areas, lethal radiation from fallout would drop to survivable levels within weeks. Here it's worth noting that there is an inherent tradeoff between length of halflife and energy released by radionuclides. The shorter the half life the more energy will be released, and the longer the half life the less energy. The fallout products from modern nuclear weapons are very lethal, but only for days to several weeks. From , 1987 edition Let's try the same calculation we used with kinetic damage, and see if an attack aimed at optimizing fallout for killing everyone could succeed. Using again, I'll go with the fallout contour for 100 rads per hour. 400 rads is thought too be enough to kill 50% of people, so 100 rads per hour is likely to kill most all people not in some kind of shelter. We need to switch to using a groundburst detonation rather than an airburst detonation, because groundbursts create far more fallout. A 1mt ground burst would create an area of about 8,000 km² of >100 rads per hour. Okay, multiple that by 14,000 warheads, and we get 112 million km². That's a lot! It's still less than the 510.1 million km² of earth's land mass, but it's a lot more than the ~10.2 million km² of urban space. Presumably this is enough to cover every human habitation, so in principle, it might be possible to kill everyone with radiation from existing nuclear weapons. The bright red and slightly less bright red indicate fallout contour for 1,000 rads and 100 rads per hour, covering 1,140 km² and 7,080 km² respectively, from a 1,000 kiloton ground burst. In practice, it would be almost impossible to kill every human via radiation with the existing nuclear arsenals, even if they were targeted explicitly for this purpose. The first reason is that fallout patterns are very uneven. After a ground burst, fallout is carried by the wind. Some areas will be hit bad and some areas will be hardly affected by fallout. Even if most human population centers were covered, a few areas would almost certainly escape. Two other things make extinction by radiation unlikely. Many countries, especially in the southern hemisphere, are unlikely to be affected by fallout much at all. Since most of these countries are likely to be neutral in a conflict, and not near combatant countries, they should be relatively safe from fallout. While fallout might travel hundreds of kms, it still won't reach places separated by greater distances. Fallout that reaches the upper atmosphere will eventually fall back down, but usually after the period of lethal radioactivity. The other mitigating factor is that in typical nuclear war plans, ground bursts are usually restricted to hardened targets, and air bursts are favored for population and industry centers. This is because air bursts maximize the size of the destructive pressure wave. Air burst detonations result in little lethal fallout reaching the ground, so populations not downwind of military targets would likely be safe from the worst of the radiological effects in a war scenario. The final protection from extinction by radiation is simply large amounts of mass between people and the radiation source, in other words, fallout shelters. After several weeks, the radionuclides in fallout from ground burst detonations will have decayed to the point where humans can survive outside of shelters. Many fallout shelters exist in the world, and many more could be made easily in a day or two with a shovel, some ground, and some boards. Even if lethally radioactive fallout from ground bursts covered all population centers, many humans would still survive in shelters. The risks of extinction from nuclear-weapon-induced-radiation wouldn't be complete without discussing two factors: nuclear power plants and radiological weapons. I'm only going to cover these briefly, but they both don't change the conclusions much. Nuclear power plants could be targeted by nuclear weapons to create large amounts of fallout with a longer half-life but less energy per unit time. The main concern here is that nuclear power plants and spent fuel sites contain a much greater *mass* of radioactive material than nuclear missiles can carry. The danger comes primarily from spreading the already very radiative spent or unspent nuclear fuel. The risk this poses requires a longer analysis, but the short version is that while nuking a nuclear power plant or stored fuel site would indeed create some pretty long-lived fallout it would still be concentrated in a relatively small area. Fortunately, even a nuclear detonation wouldn't spread the nuclear fuel more than several hundred km at most. Having regions of countries covered in spent nuclear fuel would be awful, but it doesn't much raise the risk of extinction. are nuclear weapons designed to maximize the spread of lethal fallout rather than destructive yield. The particular concern from the extinction perspective is that they can be designed to create fallout that continues to emit levels of radiation that can make an area uninhabitable for months to years. These kind of radiological weapons kill more slowly, but they still kill. In principle, radiological weapons could be used to kill everyone on earth. However, in practice, the same constraints that apply to standard nuclear weapons apply to weapons optimized for long-lasting fallout, as well as some additional constraints. Radiological weapons wouldn't produce more fallout than standard warheads, they would just produce fallout with different characteristics. As a result the amount of radiological weapons required to cover every part of earth's surface would be massively expensive (likely as expensive as the largest existing nuclear arsenals), and serve no military purpose. Their inefficiency in destruction and death compared to standard nuclear weapons is probably why radiological weapons have never been developed or deployed in large numbers. This makes them an ongoing theoretical concern, but not an existential risk in the immediate future. A is Russia's claim to have developed a large-yield (100mt) submersible nuclear weapon with the suggestion that it could be used as a radiological weapon, but even if this is true, it's unlikely to be deployed in large numbers. 3) Climate alteration The bulk of the risk of human extinction from nuclear weapons come from risks of catastrophic climate change, nuclear winter, due to secondary effects from nuclear detonations. However, even in most full-scale nuclear exchange scenarios, the resulting climate effects are unlikely to cause human extinction. Reasons for this: a) Under scenarios where a severe nuclear winter occurs as described by Robock et al, some human populations would likely survive. b) The Robock group’s models are probably overestimating the risk c) Nuclear war planners are aware of nuclear winter risks and can incorporate these risks into their targeting plans Before diving into each subject, it’s worth understanding the background of nuclear winter research. In the 1980s a group of atmospheric scientists proposed the hypothesis that a nuclear war would result in massive firestorms in burning cities, which would loft particles high into the atmosphere and cause catastrophic cooling that would last for years. Many found it alarming that such an effect could be possible and go unnoticed for decades while the risk existed. Some scientists also thought the proposed effect was too strong, or unlikely to occur at all. Until a few years ago, if you looked only at peer reviewed literature you would only find papers forecasting severe nuclear winter effects in the event of a nuclear war. Understandably, many people assumed that this was the scientific consensus. Unfortunately, this misrepresented the scientific community’s state of uncertainty about the risks of nuclear war. There have only ever been a small numbers of papers published about this topic (<15 probably), mostly from one group of researchers, despite the topic being one of existential importance. I’m very glad Robock, Toon, and others have spent much of their careers studying nuclear winter effects, and their models are useful in estimating potential climate change caused by nuclear war. However, I’ve become less convinced over time the Robock model is largely correct. See section B below for why I’ve changed my mind. However, I’m quite uncertain about the probability of strong cooling effects from nuclear war, and am still quite concerned about the potential for severe cooling, even if the risk of extinction from such events is small. A: Under scenarios where a severe nuclear winter occurs as described by Robock et al, some human populations would likely survive. The latest and most detailed model of potential cooling effects from a fullscale nuclear exchange comes from, Robock et al., “Nuclear winter revisited with a modern climate model and current nuclear arsenals: Still catastrophic consequences” found . The effects from this model are severe. In the 150Tg case, after a year, summer temperatures in the Northern hemisphere are 10-30 degrees C cooler. The effects are less severe at the equator (5 degrees C), but basically all places in the world are affected. The most likely outcome is that most people starve to death. Many would freeze too, but starvation is likely the greatest risk. Even in this model, it appears that in equatorial regions, some farming would still be possible, enough for some populations to survive. After a 10-15 years, agriculture in most of the world would be possible at reduced capacity. Surface air temperature changes for the 150 Tg case averaged for June, July, and August of the year of smoke injection and the next year. Carl Shulman asked one of the authors of this paper, Luke Oman, his probability that the 150Tg nuclear winter scenario discussed in the paper would result in human extinction, was “in the range of 1 in 10,000 to 1 in 100,000.” This strikes me as quite plausible, though one expert opinion is no substitute for a deep analysis. The contains his reasoning for this assessment. Two different analyses are required to calculate the chances of human extinction from nuclear winter. The first is the analysis of the climate change that could result from a nuclear war, and the second is the adaptive capacity of human groups to these climate changes. I have not seen an in depth analysis of the latter, but I believe such an assessment would be worthwhile. My own guess is that humans are capable of surviving far more severe climate shifts than those projected in nuclear winter scenarios. Humans are more robust than most any other mammal to drastic changes in temperature, as evidenced by our global range, even in pre-historic times. While a loss of most agriculture would likely kill most people on earth, modern technology would enable some populations to survive. Great stores of food currently exist in the world, and it is l likely that some of these would be seized and protected by small groups, providing enough food to last for years. While even such populations with food stores wouldn’t have enough to survive for 10-15 years, such food stores would give groups time to adapt to new food sources. The organization has explored a number of alternative food sources that could keep populations alive in the event of a nuclear war or other large solar disruption, and I expect great necessity to drive the discovery of even more in the event of such a disaster. B: The Robock group’s models are probably overestimating the risk The nuclear winter model at its simplest: Nuclear detonations → Fires in cities → Firestorms in cities → Lofted black carbon into the upper atmosphere → black carbon persists in upper atmosphere, reflecting sunlight and causes massive cooling Each step is required in order for the effect to occur. If nuclear war causes massive fires in cities but does not lead to firestorms that loft particles, then no long term cooling is going to occur. Some of these steps are easier to model than others. Based on my reading of the literature, the greatest uncertainties involve the dynamics of cities burning after a nuclear attack, and whether the conditions would produce firestorms sufficient to loft large numbers of particles high enough in the atmosphere to persist for years. We’re finally beginning to see some healthy debate about some of these questions in the scientific literature. Alan Robock’s group published a paper in 2007 that found significant cooling effects even from a relatively limited regional war. A group from Los Alamos, Reisner et al, in 2018 that reexamined some of the assumptions that went into ’s model, and concluded that global cooling was unlikely in such a scenario. Robock et al. , and Reisner et al responded to the . Both authors bring up good points, but I find Reisner’s position more compelling. This back and forth is worth reading for those who want to investigate deeper. Unfortunately Reisner’s group has not published an analysis on potential cooling effects from a modern full scale nuclear exchange, rather than a limited regional exchange. Even so, it’s not hard to extrapolate that Reisner’s model would result in far less cooling than Robock’s model in the equivalent situation.

2023 Michigan Affirmative
1ac › 1ac---v1 › 1ac---framing

Nuclear war not existential

Scuras 19 (Scouras, James. James Scouras is a senior scholar at the Johns Hopkins University Applied Physics Laboratory and the former chief scientist of the Defense Threat Reduction Agency’s Advanced Systems and Concepts Office. His research focuses on assessment and management of global catastrophic risks, with emphasis on nuclear war and the evaluation of policies intended to reduce the risk of its occurrence. “Nuclear War as a Global Catastrophic Risk.” Journal of Benefit-Cost Analysis, vol. 10, no. 2, 2019, pp. 274–295, www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/EC726528F3A71ED5ED26307677960962/S2194588819000162a.pdf/nuclear_war_as_a_global_catastrophic_risk.pdf, https://doi.org/10.1017/bca.2019.16.)//rhftw

Nuclear war is clearly a global catastrophic risk, but it is not an existential risk as is sometimes carelessly claimed. Unfortunately, the consequence and likelihood components of the risk of nuclear war are both highly uncertain. In particular, for nuclear wars that include targeting of multiple cities, nuclear winter may result in more fatalities across the globe than the better-understood effects of blast, prompt radiation, and fallout. Electromagnetic pulse effects, which could range from minor electrical disturbances to the complete collapse of the electric grid, are similarly highly uncertain. Nuclear war likelihood assessments are largely based on intuition, and they span the spectrum from zero to certainty. Notwithstanding these profound uncertainties, we must manage the risk of nuclear war with the knowledge we have. Benefit-cost analysis and other structured analytic methods applied to evaluate risk mitigation measures must acknowledge that we often do not even know whether many proposed approaches (e.g., reducing nuclear arsenals) will have a net positive or negative effect. Multidisciplinary studies are needed to better understand the consequences and likelihood of nuclear war and the complex relationship between these two components of risk, and to predict both the direction and magnitude of risk mitigation approaches.