Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 SDI Disadvantage
1NC › Generic

Government spending and increased debt crashes business confidence and the economy

Panagiotis Konstantinou, Athanasios Tagkalakis, (Panagiotis Konstantinou, Lecturer at University of Macedonia, PhD in Economics from the European University Institute, and Athanasios Tagkalakis, Assistant Professor of Economics at the University of Patras, PhD in Economics from the European University Institute) Boosting confidence: Is there a role for fiscal policy?, Economic Modelling, Volume 28, Issue 4, 2011, Pages 1629-1641, ISSN 0264-9993, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2011.02.019. () SCade

An increase in government investment lowers consumer confidence. Whereas when the debt ratio is high it has negative effects on both consumer and business confidence. A higher government wage bill lowers both consumer and business confidence, with the effect on consumer confidence being stronger at times of high debt and on business confidence at times of low debt. The government wage bill and government investment exert a negative effect on confidence indices possibly because they entail a permanent increase in the size of the public sector, which would have to be financed by future taxes. In the case of public investment the standard Keynesian crowding out effect is also at play. On the contrary, an increase in the non-wage government consumption improves consumer confidence, whereas it improves both consumer and business confidence when the debt ratio is high. This could be linked to the fact that this type of spending is easily reversible if needed so.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
1NC › Generic

Small businesses confidence is overall still strong – but concerns are lingering

Anne Petrik, 23, (Anne Petrik, 5-4-2023, Vistage Research Center, Small Business Confidence Holds Despite Recession Concerns, https://www.vistage.com/research-center/business-financials/economic-trends/20230504-small-business-confidence-holds-wsj-survey, 6-20-2023) SCade

Despite positive — albeit slowing — growth in GDP and inflation rates easing, concerns about a recession are on the rise among small businesses. The proportion of small businesses that are moderately or extremely concerned about the impacts of a recession increased from 46% last month to 54% this month. It’s also interesting to note that while recession concerns are on the rise, overall confidence about the economy did not slip further. In fact, pessimism about the national economy eased compared to last month, which led to the WSJ/Vistage Small Business CEO Confidence Index remaining nearly flat at 79.0 compared to last monthly 79.8.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Disease defense

No disease impact

intervening actors check, resilience, burnout, and adaptation – this ev smokes them

Amesh 16 — (AMESH ADALJA is an infectious-disease physician at the University of Pittsburgh, 6-17-2016, "Why Hasn't Disease Wiped out the Human Race?," The Atlantic, http://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2016/06/infectious-diseases-extinction/487514/, Accessed 7-30-2016, HWilson) ***we do not endorse the problematic language in this evidence

“You’ll tell us when you’re worried, right?” That was the question posed to me countless times at the height of the 2014 West African Ebola outbreak. As an infectious disease physician, I was interviewed on outlets such as CNN, NPR, and Fox News about the dangers of the virus, and the answer I gave was always the same: “Ebola is a deadly, scary disease, but it is not that contagious. It will not find the U.S. or other industrialized nations hospitable.” In other words, no, I wasn’t worried—and not because I have a rosy outlook on infectious diseases. I’m well-aware of the damage these diseases are causing around the world: HIV, malaria, tuberculosis; the influenza pandemic that took the world by surprise in 2009; the anti-vaccine movement bumping cases of measles to an all-time post-vaccine-era high; antibiotic-resistant bacteria threatening to collapse the entire structure of modern medicine—all these, like Ebola, are continuously placing an enormous number of lives at risk. But when people ask me if I’m worried about infectious diseases, they’re often not asking about the threat to human lives; they’re asking about the threat to human life. With each outbreak of a headline-grabbing emerging infectious disease comes a fear of extinction itself. The fear envisions a large proportion of humans succumbing to infection, leaving no survivors or so few that the species can’t be sustained. I’m not afraid of this apocalyptic scenario, but I do understand the impulse. Worry about the end is a quintessentially human trait. Thankfully, so is our resilience. For most of mankind’s history, infectious diseases were the existential threat to humanity—and for good reason. They were quite successful at killing people: The 6th century’s Plague of Justinian knocked out an estimated 17 percent of the world’s population; the 14th century Black Death decimated a third of Europe; the 1918 influenza pandemic killed 5 percent of the world; malaria is estimated to have killed half of all humans who have ever lived. Any yet, of course, humanity continued to flourish. Our species’ recent explosion in lifespan is almost exclusively the result of the control of infectious diseases through sanitation, vaccination, and antimicrobial therapies. Only in the modern era, in which many infectious diseases have been tamed in the industrial world, do people have the luxury of death from cancer, heart disease, or stroke in the 8th decade of life. Childhoods are free from watching siblings and friends die from outbreaks of typhoid, scarlet fever, smallpox, measles, and the like. So what would it take for a disease to wipe out humanity now? In Michael Crichton’s The Andromeda Strain, the canonical book in the disease-outbreak genre, an alien microbe threatens the human race with extinction, and humanity’s best minds are marshaled to combat the enemy organism. Fortunately, outside of fiction, there’s no reason to expect alien pathogens to wage war on the human race any time soon, and my analysis suggests that any real-life domestic microbe reaching an extinction level of threat probably is just as unlikely. Any apocalyptic pathogen would need to possess a very special combination of two attributes. First, it would have to be so unfamiliar that no existing therapy or vaccine could be applied to it. Second, it would need to have a high and surreptitious transmissibility before symptoms occur. The first is essential because any microbe from a known class of pathogens would, by definition, have family members that could serve as models for containment and countermeasures. The second would allow the hypothetical disease to spread without being detected by even the most astute clinicians. The three infectious diseases most likely to be considered extinction-level threats in the world today—influenza, HIV, and Ebola—don’t meet these two requirements. Influenza, for instance, despite its well-established ability to kill on a large scale, its contagiousness, and its unrivaled ability to shift and drift away from our vaccines, is still what I would call a “known unknown.” While there are many mysteries about how new flu strains emerge, from at least the time of Hippocrates, humans have been attuned to its risk. And in the modern era, a full-fledged industry of influenza preparedness exists, with effective vaccine strategies and antiviral therapies. HIV, which has killed 39 million people over several decades, is similarly limited due to several factors. Most importantly, HIV’s dependency on blood and body fluid for transmission (similar to Ebola) requires intimate human-to-human contact, which limits contagion. Highly potent antiviral therapy allows most people to live normally with the disease, and a substantial group of the population has genetic mutations that render them impervious to infection in the first place. Lastly, simple prevention strategies such as needle exchange for injection drug users and barrier contraceptives—when available—can curtail transmission risk. Ebola, for many of the same reasons as HIV as well as several others, also falls short of the mark. This is especially due to the fact that it spreads almost exclusively through people with easily recognizable symptoms, plus the taming of its once unfathomable 90 percent mortality rate by simple supportive care. Beyond those three, every other known disease falls short of what seems required to wipe out humans—which is, of course, why we’re still here. And it’s not that diseases are ineffective. On the contrary, diseases’ failure to knock us out is a testament to just how resilient humans are. Part of our evolutionary heritage is our immune system, one of the most complex on the planet, even without the benefit of vaccines or the helping hand of antimicrobial drugs. This system, when viewed at a species level, can adapt to almost any enemy imaginable. Coupled to genetic variations amongst humans—which open up the possibility for a range of advantages, from imperviousness to infection to a tendency for mild symptoms—this adaptability ensures that almost any infectious disease onslaught will leave a large proportion of the population alive to rebuild, in contrast to the fictional Hollywood versions. While the immune system’s role can never be understated, an even more powerful protector is the faculty of consciousness. Humans are not the most prolific, quickly evolving, or strongest organisms on the planet, but as Aristotle identified, humans are the rational animals—and it is this fundamental distinguishing characteristic that allows humans to form abstractions, think in principles, and plan long-range. These capacities, in turn, allow humans to modify, alter, and improve themselves and their environments. Consciousness equips us, at an individual and a species level, to make nature safe for the species through such technological marvels as antibiotics, antivirals, vaccines, and sanitation. When humans began to focus their minds on the problems posed by infectious disease, human life ceased being nasty, brutish, and short. In many ways, human consciousness became infectious diseases’ worthiest adversary. None of this is meant to allay all fears of infectious diseases. To totally adopt a Panglossian viewpoint would be foolish—and dangerous. Humans do face countless threats from infectious diseases: witness Zika. And if not handled appropriately, severe calamity could, and will, ensue. The West African Ebola outbreak, for instance, festered for months before major efforts to bring it under control were initiated. When it comes to infectious diseases, I’m worried about the failure of institutions to understand the full impact of outbreaks. I’m worried about countries that don’t have the infrastructure or resources to combat these outbreaks when they come. But as long as we can keep adapting, I’m not worried about the future of the human race.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Disease defense

200,000 years of existence disproves the impact

Halstead 20 – John, a Research Fellow at the Global Priorities Project, a collaboration between the Centre for Effective Altruism and the Future of Humanity Institute, where he specialised in global catastrophic risk. Before that, he was an academic philosopher, obtaining his D.Phil in Political Philosophy from the University of Oxford and working at Oxford's Blavatnik School of Government. “Safeguarding the Future Cause Area Report”, Founders Pledge, , 12-xx-2020

However, there are some reasons to think that naturally occurring pathogens are unlikely to cause human extinction. Firstly, Homo sapiens have been around for 200,000 years and the Homo genus for around six million years without being exterminated by an infectious disease, which is evidence that the base rate of extinction-risk natural pathogens is low.82 Indeed, past disease outbreaks have not come close to rendering humans extinct. Although bodies were piled high in the streets across Europe during the Black Death,83 human extinction was never a serious possibility, and some economists even argue that it was a boon for the European economy.84 Secondly, infectious disease has only contributed to the extinction of a small minority of animal species.85 The only confirmed case of a mammalian species extinction being caused by an infectious disease is a type of rat native only to Christmas Island. Having said that, the context may be importantly different for modern day humans, so it is unclear whether the risk is increasing or decreasing. On the one hand, due to globalisation, the world is more interconnected making it easier for pathogens to spread. On the other hand, interconnectedness could also increase immunity by increasing exposure to lower virulence strains between subpopulations.87 Moreover, advancements in medicine and sanitation limit the potential damage an outbreak might do.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Disease defense

Disease can’t cause extinction

Ord 20 – Dr. Toby, Senior Research Fellow in Philosophy at Oxford University, DPhil in Philosophy from the University of Oxford. “The Precipice: Existential Risk and the Future of Humanity,”, Hachette Books, pg. 124-126, 03-03-2020

Are we safe now from events like this? Or are we more vulnerable? Could a pandemic threaten humanity’s future?10

The Black Death was not the only biological disaster to scar human history. It was not even the only great bubonic plague. In 541 CE the Plague of Justinian struck the Byzantine Empire. Over three years it took the lives of roughly 3 percent of the world’s people.11

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Endocrine disruption defense

No impact to endocrine disruptors

Breithaupt ‘4 (Holger, PhD from U. Düsseldorf Institute of Enzyme Technology, EMBO Reports, “A cause without a disease”, 5:1, http://www.nature.com/embor/journal/v5/n1/full/7400063.html)

Endocrine disruptors—or 'gender benders' as they are often referred to by the public—have become the focus of environmentalists and public health advocates who decry a slow poisoning of humans and the environment by the chemical and consumer goods industries. The term is a rather broad label for substances that are able to interfere with hormone receptors or hormonal pathways in the cell. Endocrine disruptors have caused serious public concern, because their interaction with the hormone system could potentially wreak havoc with prenatal and early development and affect a wide variety of organs. Theo Colborn, a researcher for the World Wildlife Fund, painted a bleak picture of their effects at a 2001 meeting of the US Department of the Interior: “... these chemicals can undermine the development of the brain, and intelligence and behaviour, and the endocrine, immune and reproductive systems. ... there is now a growing collection of studies revealing that some of these chemicals can affect our children's ability to learn, to socially integrate, to fend off disease and to reproduce” (Colborn, 2001).However, as public fear mounted, the evidence for a creeping epidemic caused by endocrine disruptors in the environment remained elusive In fact, early observations on wild and laboratory animals showed that some compounds that are able to interact with receptor molecules, in particular with the oestrogen receptor, exert effects on the reproductive system of these animals. These observations were accompanied by reports on the increasing incidence of breast and prostate cancer and declining male fertility, and it was only a matter of time before the press took up the issue and parents became concerned about this slow poisoning of their children. However, as public fear mounted, the evidence for a creeping epidemic caused by endocrine disruptors in the environment remained elusive. Although most scientists now acknowledge that many substances can have an effect on the human endocrine system, more recent analysis has shown that many of the claims about health effects were either exaggerated or based on flawed analysis of observations. As Stephen H. Safe, Professor of Veterinary Physiology and Pharmacology and of Biochemistry and Biophysics at Texas A&M University (College Station, TX, USA) put it: “The hypothesis is okay, but we don't even have a problem.”The scientific chapter of the endocrine disruptor story began in the early 1990s with a 'hypothesis' article in The Lancet in which Richard M. Sharpe from the MRC Reproductive Unit at the University of Edinburgh, UK, and Niels E. Skakkebaek from the Department of Growth and Reproduction at the University of Copenhagen, Denmark, wrote, “exposure to exogenous oestrogens, ... during foetal and neonatal life can lead to an increase in reproductive disorders” (Sharpe & Skakkebaek, 1993). On the basis of a meta-analysis of more than 60 studies published between 1940 and 1990, they suggested that abnormalities in the development of male sex organs and a 50% decline in sperm count could be attributed to exposure to oestrogens in utero. The finding that the prescription of an artificial oestrogen, diethylstilboestrol, for pregnant women from the 1940s to the 1970s had caused an increased rate of cervical cancer among the daughters of these women further supported Sharpe and Skakkebaek's hypothesis, and the fear that men could also be affected did not seem so far-fetched.Observation of wildlife also provided evidence for the effects of endocrine disruptors on reproductive health. Various publications described how chemicals suspected to have endocrine-disrupting effects, including DDT, dioxins, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), which are all banned, and various pesticides and fungicides, caused a wide range of reproductive disorders and deformities of sexual organs among wild animals in polluted areas. Nonylphenol, a degradation product from many detergents, herbicides, spermicides and cosmetics, has been shown to cause imposex in oysters, which is a pseudo-hermaphroditic condition in which females acquire male sex characteristics (Nice et al, 2003). Scientists in the UK found that oestrogenic compounds in human and agricultural wastewater triggered the feminization of male fish in British lakes and rivers. Else-where, US scientists found that female mosquito fish in Florida exposed to pulp-mill effluent developed a gonopodium, an organ normally found only in males. Similarly, male alligators in various contaminated lakes in Florida suffered from phallus deformations and an impaired immune system. Half of male carp caught in the Tama River in Japan were found to produce unusually large amounts of the yolk precursor protein vitellogenin, specific to female fish.In 1996, Colborn, together with science writers Dianne Dumanoski and John Peterson Myers, compiled these observations into the book Our Stolen Future and drew a straight line between the effects observed in wild animals and human health effects, including breast and prostate cancer and decreasing male fertility caused by decreasing sperm counts, cryptorchidism (where one or both testicles fail to descend from the body) and hypospadias (deformation of the phallus). Often compared to Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, Colborn's book had an enormous impact on public opinion and triggered intense media coverage about the suspected epidemic of cancers and male infertility. The media obtained further ammunition when Fred vom Saal and co-workers at the University of Missouri (Columbia, MO, USA) showed that bisphenol A (BPA), a commonly used compound found in many plastics, caused abnormal prostate growth and decreased sperm production in rats at doses far lower than those considered to be safe (Nagel et al, 1997; vom Saal et al, 1998). Patricia Hunt at Case Western Reserve University (Cleveland, OH, USA) observed that BPA caused severe aberrations of the meiotic cell division in mouse oocytes in up to 40% of all cases (Hunt et al, 2003). Although industrial and academic researchers have so far failed to reproduce vom Saal's findings, his work has become the main argument for public health advocates who seek to ban chemicals such as BPA because they can exert their toxic effects at extremely low doses.In fact, a series of studies that closely investigated the original publications claiming an increase in breast and prostate cancer and a decline in male fertility found that this is not so The political reaction to these reports was swift, particularly in the USA. The US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) convened two workshops in 1995 to make recommendations for research into the health threat of endocrine disruptors, including their effects on reproductive, neurological and immunological function and carcinogenic activity. In 1996, the US Congress amended the Food Quality Protection Act and the Safe Drinking Water Act to require the testing of food-use pesticides and drinking water contaminants for endocrine activity, which mandated the EPA to screen up to 70,000 chemicals regulated under the Toxic Substances Control Act for endocrine-disruptive effects. In 1999, the EPA launched the Endocrine Disruptor Screening Program (EDSP) and is now developing animal tests and other assays to screen for hormone activity. In Japan, the Ministry of the Environment decided to start risk assessment studies on more than 40 substances suspected to have endocrine-disrupting effects (Iguchi et al, 2002). On 29 October 2003, the European Commission proposed a new regulatory framework for all chemicals manufactured or imported in quantities of more than a tonne per year. Among the chemicals labelled as being of 'very high concern' that require authorization for particular use are substances that could cause reproductive damage or affect fetal development—in other words, endocrine disruptors.The only problem is that nobody actually knows whether the levels of endocrine disruptors in the environment are a threat to public health. “The so-called epidemic of endocrine diseases remains to be established,” said Raphael J. Witorsch, Professor of Physiology at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond, VA, USA. A working group, convened by the Royal Society of London, UK, that investigated the health threat of endocrine- disrupting chemicals (EDCs) came to the same conclusion: “whilst high levels of exposure to some EDCs could theoretically increase the risk of such disorders, no direct evidence is available at present” (The Royal Society, 2000). Richard Sharpe, one of the original authors of the endocrine disruptor hypothesis, also acknowledged that “the threat [to human health] is minimal.” In fact, a series of studies that closely investigated the original publications claiming an increase in breast and prostate cancer and a decline in male fertility found that this is not so. “We now know that this is absolutely not true,” Safe said about health advocates who warn that endocrine disruptors could cause a worldwide epidemic of disorders and diseases. According to Witorsch, many of the original epidemiological analyses were flawed and lacked confounding factors.In addition, large-scale studies among elderly women in the USA and the UK showed that the increase in breast and cervical cancer was caused mainly by hormone replacement therapy for post-menopausal women (Brower, 2003) rather than hormonally active compounds in the environment. In fact, many of the chemicals under suspicion bind only weakly to the oestrogen receptor and it is not clear whether they have an estrogenic, anti-estrogenic or anti-androgenic effect. Furthermore, critics maintain that EDCs have to compete with more effectively binding natural oestrogens that are abundant in the diet, in medicines and in contraceptives at much higher concentrations. “In terms of magnitude and extent, all such exposures to so-called endocrine disruptors are dwarfed by the extensive use of oral contraceptives and estrogens for the treatment of menopausal and post-menopausal disorders. Also, the exposure to hormonally active xenobiotics is virtually insignificant when compared with the intake of the phytoestrogens that are present in food and beverages,” commented Robert Nilsson, Professor of Toxicology at Stockholm University, Sweden (Nilsson, 2000). “So we've got all these [phytohormones] out there in the diet,” Safe concluded, but “my scepticism is how could small concentrations [of other chemicals] in the environment be a problem?”Equally, the low-dose effects that vom Saal observed in mice have come under criticism. “I remain completely unconvinced by the low-dose studies. ... How does BPA in Fred vom Saal's study induce an effect at concentrations at which we know that it doesn't bind to the oestrogen receptor?” Sharpe said. “I want to see that these effects can lead to disorders that are directly related to human health issues.” But Sharpe still sees a potential problem with compounds that act elsewhere in the signalling pathway and modify the internal balance of hormones. “If you alter the endogenous hormonal milieu, then you get a disease,” he said. “I have no problem with understanding that chemicals that have that ability can cause health problems.”... critics maintain that endocrine-disrupting chemicals have to compete with more effectively binding natural oestrogens that are abundant in the diet, in medicines and in contraceptives at much higher concentrations Indeed, the evidence of detrimental effects of endocrine disruptors in animals, particularly for aquatic organisms, is quite convincing, Sharpe maintained. He cited the example of TBT (tributyltin), widely used in ship paint. The chemical does not bind to a hormone receptor but modulates the endogenous hormonal milieu in mussels elsewhere to cause imposex. Consequently, as the human fetus is “kind of an aquatic organism,” as Sharpe put it, such chemicals could potentially impair prenatal development and cause effects later in life. But “humans are different from fish,” Safe countered, and he questioned the sense of extrapolating observations made in wild or laboratory animals to humans, who often have very different hormonal metabolisms. “There isn't a single chemical that doesn't have an effect,” he said, but “what are these animal studies telling us?” Witorsch agreed that making such assumptions is like “shooting from the hip”. “To judge in utero effects in rodents and try to extrapolate them to humans has to be done with caution,” he said. “An observation doesn't mean that you should ban a substance and a lack of observation doesn't necessarily mean that it is safe.”

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Endocrine disruption defense

No impact – insufficient evidence about the impacts of endocrine disruption

The Lancet, March 2013, “endocrine-disrupting chemicals: how much of a health threat?”

Several headlines that appeared in the mainstream media last week might have left some people cowering behind their kitchen tables in fear of their Teflon-coated saucepans. “Everyday objects trying to kill you”, said one newspaper, “Poisoned by everyday life”, said another. The media were reporting the findings of a new report by WHO and the UN Environment Programme—State of the Science of Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals. The report warns that synthetic chemicals could have substantial health implications and it calls for more research to understand fully the associations between endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) and many household and industrial products. Around 800 chemicals are thought to be capable of interfering with hormone receptors, hormone synthesis, or hormone conversion. Some EDCs occur naturally, whereas synthetic varieties can be found in pesticides, electronics, and cosmetics. They can enter the environment through industrial, urban, or agricultural processes, and human exposure can occur via ingestion of food, dust, and water, inhalation of gases, or direct skin contact. The report makes several fair points—eg, many endocrine-related diseases and disorders are on the rise, the disease risk due to EDCs might be underestimated because human beings are exposed to a combination of EDCs, and the health risk of such mixtures is poorly studied. However, it goes too far in singling out associations with particular disorders when the evidence is largely or completely speculative. For example, the report discusses potential links between thyroid disruptors and increased thyroid cancer risk, but as it notes there is very limited evidence at present for associations between EDCs and thyroid cancer (the major evidence being a single fairly poor-quality study looking at pesticide exposure). A link with thyroid disruptors and autism is also mentioned but such a link is purely speculative. Perhaps the most important point the report makes is that there is currently no widely agreed system for assessing the strength of evidence of associations between exposures to chemicals (including EDCs) and adverse health outcomes. Clearly, such a system is badly needed.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Ag Prices / Food Security defense

Food shortage doesn’t cause war – best studies

Allouche 11, research Fellow – water supply and sanitation @ Institute for Development Studies, frmr professor – MIT, ’11 (Jeremy, “The sustainability and resilience of global water and food systems: Political analysis of the interplay between security, resource scarcity, political systems and global trade,” Food Policy, Vol. 36 Supplement 1, p. S3-S8, January)

The question of resource scarcity has led to many debates on whether scarcity (whether of food or water) will lead to conflict and war. The underlining reasoning behind most of these discourses over food and water wars comes from the Malthusian belief that there is an imbalance between the economic availability of natural resources and population growth since while food production grows linearly, population increases exponentially. Following this reasoning, neo-Malthusians claim that finite natural resources place a strict limit on the growth of human population and aggregate consumption; if these limits are exceeded, social breakdown, conflict and wars result. Nonetheless, it seems that most empirical studies do not support any of these neo-Malthusian arguments. Technological change and greater inputs of capital have dramatically increased labour productivity in agriculture. More generally, the neo-Malthusian view has suffered because during the last two centuries humankind has breached many resource barriers that seemed unchallengeable. Lessons from history: alarmist scenarios, resource wars and international relations In a so-called age of uncertainty, a number of alarmist scenarios have linked the increasing use of water resources and food insecurity with wars. The idea of water wars (perhaps more than food wars) is a dominant discourse in the media (see for example Smith, 2009), NGOs (International Alert, 2007) and within international organizations (UNEP, 2007). In 2007, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon declared that ‘water scarcity threatens economic and social gains and is a potent fuel for wars and conflict’ (Lewis, 2007). Of course, this type of discourse has an instrumental purpose; security and conflict are here used for raising water/food as key policy priorities at the international level. In the Middle East, presidents, prime ministers and foreign ministers have also used this bellicose rhetoric. Boutrous Boutros-Gali said; ‘the next war in the Middle East will be over water, not politics’ (Boutros Boutros-Gali in Butts, 1997, p. 65). The question is not whether the sharing of transboundary water sparks political tension and alarmist declaration, but rather to what extent water has been a principal factor in international conflicts. The evidence seems quite weak. Whether by president Sadat in Egypt or King Hussein in Jordan, none of these declarations have been followed up by military action. The governance of transboundary water has gained increased attention these last decades. This has a direct impact on the global food system as water allocation agreements determine the amount of water that can used for irrigated agriculture. The likelihood of conflicts over water is an important parameter to consider in assessing the stability, sustainability and resilience of global food systems. None of the various and extensive databases on the causes of war show water as a casus belli. Using the International Crisis Behavior (ICB) data set and supplementary data from the University of Alabama on water conflicts, Hewitt, Wolf and Hammer found only seven disputes where water seems to have been at least a partial cause for conflict (Wolf, 1998, p. 251). In fact, about 80% of the incidents relating to water were limited purely to governmental rhetoric intended for the electorate (Otchet, 2001, p. 18). As shown in The Basins At Risk (BAR) water event database, more than two-thirds of over 1800 water-related ‘events’ fall on the ‘cooperative’ scale (Yoffe et al., 2003). Indeed, if one takes into account a much longer period, the following figures clearly demonstrate this argument. According to studies by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO), organized political bodies signed between the year 805 and 1984 more than 3600 water-related treaties, and approximately 300 treaties dealing with water management or allocations in international basins have been negotiated since 1945 (FAO, 1978 and FAO, 1984). The fear around water wars have been driven by a Malthusian outlook which equates scarcity with violence, conflict and war. There is however no direct correlation between water scarcity and transboundary conflict. Most specialists now tend to agree that the major issue is not scarcity per se but rather the allocation of water resources between the different riparian states (see for example Allouche, 2005, Allouche, 2007 and [Rouyer, 2000] ). Water rich countries have been involved in a number of disputes with other relatively water rich countries (see for example India/Pakistan or Brazil/Argentina). The perception of each state’s estimated water needs really constitutes the core issue in transboundary water relations. Indeed, whether this scarcity exists or not in reality, perceptions of the amount of available water shapes people’s attitude towards the environment (Ohlsson, 1999). In fact, some water experts have argued that scarcity drives the process of co-operation among riparians (Dinar and Dinar, 2005 and Brochmann and Gleditsch, 2006). In terms of international relations, the threat of water wars due to increasing scarcity does not make much sense in the light of the recent historical record. Overall, the water war rationale expects conflict to occur over water, and appears to suggest that violence is a viable means of securing national water supplies, an argument which is highly contestable. The debates over the likely impacts of climate change have again popularised the idea of water wars. The argument runs that climate change will precipitate worsening ecological conditions contributing to resource scarcities, social breakdown, institutional failure, mass migrations and in turn cause greater political instability and conflict (Brauch, 2002 and Pervis and Busby, 2004). In a report for the US Department of Defense, Schwartz and Randall (2003) speculate about the consequences of a worst-case climate change scenario arguing that water shortages will lead to aggressive wars (Schwartz and Randall, 2003, p. 15). Despite growing concern that climate change will lead to instability and violent conflict, the evidence base to substantiate the connections is thin ( [Barnett and Adger, 2007] and Kevane and Gray, 2008).

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Ag Prices / Food Security defense

Worst case, fast government response stops collapse.

OECD ’21 [October 19; OECD, “Keep calm and carry on feeding: Agriculture and food policy responses to the COVID-19 crisis,” ;]

Despite significant disruption to the agriculture and food supply chains, particularly in the first half of 2020, most sector shocks were absorbed rapidly, with trade and markets recovering during the year. Average gross farm receipts for OECD and emerging economies actually increased in 2020, and the sector was the best performing or least affected economically in several countries. At the same time, restricting measures impacted the food security of many low income or unemployed consumers.

This relative economic resilience of the agriculture and food sector was largely due to sector specific policy measures undertaken by governments in response to the COVID-19 pandemic and associated restrictions. Many governments moved swiftly to keep agricultural supply chains functioning, including by designating agriculture and food as an essential sector and by ensuring international co-operation to limit trade disruptions.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Ag Prices / Food Security defense

Food industry is productive and resilient to collapse.

Johansson 21 – Robert, USDA Chief Economist. “America’s Farmers: Resilient Throughout the COVID Pandemic”, US Department of Agriculture, , 07-29-2021

Earlier this year, when we released the Department’s initial projections for 2020 at USDA’s Agricultural Outlook Forum, the immediate future looked to be improving (www.usda.gov/oce/ag-outlook-forum). We were expecting better weather, improved trading relationships, and global economic growth that would fuel demand for US agricultural exports. The COVID-19 outbreak has severely dampened expectations for 2020 and 2021. And while the timing and pace of the economic recovery remain uncertain, the fundamentals of U.S. agriculture are sufficiently strong to withstand the crisis.

The sector continues to chart productivity gains; and smart policies, technology, and innovation are helping farmers deal with the effects of adverse weather conditions. Although the early August derecho in the Midwest, the severe fires in the West, and the more recent Hurricane activity in the Gulf have caused localized losses, from a national perspective weather conditions have improved relative to 2018 and 2019, signaling a more bountiful harvest in the fall. Record levels of meat and dairy production are expected in 2020 and 2021.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Ag Prices / Food Security defense

No correlation between food shortages and conflict – other factors

Buhaug et al. 15 – Halvard, Peace Research Institute Oslo, PRIO, Norway and Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU, Norway. Tor A Benjaminsen, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, NMBU, Norway and Peace Research Institute Oslo, PRIO, Norway. Espen Sjaastad, Norwegian University of Life Sciences, NMBU, Norway. Ole Magnus Theisen, Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU, Norway and Peace Research Institute Oslo, PRIO, Norway. “Climate variability, food production shocks, and violent conflict in Sub-Saharan Africa”, Enviornmental Research Letters, Vol. 10, No. 12, , 12-22-2015

Across all models, we find relatively weak and insignificant effects for domestic food production and we also note that the sign of the coefficients shifts between outcome types. In this sense, table 1 implicitly contrasts both claims that political violence is more prevalent when basic needs are met (Salehyan and Hendrix 2014) and claims that agricultural income shocks increase civil conflict risk (von Uexkull 2014). The results are consistent with Koubi et al (2012) and van Weezel (2015), however, who conclude that rainfall—a significant determinant of yields in SSA—has little impact on conflict either directly or through economic performance.

The covariate that best and most consistently explains temporal variation in political violence is the time-lagged conflict incidence indicator. Models 1–2 show that a new civil conflict is unlikely to break out if another one is already ongoing in the same country whereas Models 3–6, which capture the occurrence of less organized conflict, demonstrate that violence begets violence. Coups d'état (Models 7–8) exhibit a comparatively weak temporal correlation pattern in our data and are generally regarded as a highly unpredictable phenomenon (Luttwak 1979).

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Ag Prices / Food Security defense

No food wars

Vestby et al. 18 – Jonas, Doctoral Researcher at the Peace Research Institute Oslo, Ida Rudolfsen, doctoral researcher at the Department of Peace and Conflict Research at Uppsala University and PRIO, and Halvard Buhaug, Research Professor at the Peace Research Institute Oslo (PRIO); Professor of Political Science at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU); and Associate Editor of the Journal of Peace Research and Political Geography. “Does hunger cause conflict?”, , 05-18-2018

It is perhaps surprising, then, that there is little scholarly merit in the notion that a short-term reduction in access to food increases the probability that conflict will break out. This is because to start or participate in violent conflict requires people to have both the means and the will. Most people on the brink of starvation are not in the position to resort to violence, whether against the government or other social groups. In fact, the urban middle classes tend to be the most likely to protest against rises in food prices, since they often have the best opportunities, the most energy, and the best skills to coordinate and participate in protests.

Accordingly, there is a widespread misapprehension that social unrest in periods of high food prices relates primarily to food shortages. In reality, the sources of discontent are considerably more complex – linked to political structures, land ownership, corruption, the desire for democratic reforms and general economic problems – where the price of food is seen in the context of general increases in the cost of living. Research has shown that while the international media have a tendency to seek simple resource-related explanations – such as drought or famine – for conflicts in the Global South, debates in the local media are permeated by more complex political relationships.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables help agriculture

Reducing reliance on fossil fuels is critical to future food security

Rishi Kant and Sammi Kumari — September 5, 2022 Shift to renewables will cut cost of farming, strengthen food security https://www.policycircle.org/economy/renewables-boost-food-security/

Food and fuel insecurity triggered by adverse weather phenomena and the Russia-Ukraine war cannot be ignored as an unfortunate coincidence or a once in the life-time event. There is enough evidence now to infer that these adverse consequences are the new normal associated with climate change. India is also increasingly getting impacted by the climate uncertainty. India recorded extremely high temperatures in March 2022. The associated heat waves affected the wheat crop adversely in many states and other crops such as chickpea, maize and mustard. Moreover, deficiency of monsoon rainfall in UP, West Bengal, Bihar and Jharkhand has impacted paddy sowing activities and there is apprehension that rice output in 2022-23 may also get affected. The extreme weather events in India pose a challenge for achieving sustainable agricultural growth, putting our food and livelihood security are risk. Reducing reliance on fossil fuels without compromising on energy security holds the key to food security. This calls for doubling our efforts towards tapping alternate sources of energy and incentivising its use in the agriculture. For instance, solar water pumps, solar dryers, and solar water heater can easily replace conventional machinery. Similarly, storing farm produce also requires energy which can be derived from solar energy. Highly subsidised power provided by many state governments in India to farmers disincentivise consumer to shift to alternate source of energy. High cost associated with alternative energy was one of the major inhibiting factors for shifting away from fossil fuel-based sources of energy. However, cost of renewables, especially solar, has been witnessing a consistent fall over the years. International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) has confirmed the critical role of cost-competitive renewable energy in addressing the objective of meeting growing energy demand. It has reported that almost two thirds or 163 gigawatts (GW) of newly installed renewable power in 2021 had lower costs than the world’s cheapest coal-fired operations in G20 countries. Besides, solar and wind energy have a short gestation period, making adoption much easier compared with nuclear projects. Such a shift will help reduce our energy cost and help climate change mitigation. But it will also go a long way to enhance food security by increasing productivity and yield. Countries like India with sufficient sun hours are poised to gain. Shifting to solar energy by agriculture sector will reduce the cost of farmers and enable them to increase investment in the farms. Renewable energy in agriculture is a win-win combination. A swift shift towards renewables will not only help meet our energy requirements in a cost-effective way, but also will help strengthen food and livelihood security across regions. The positive economies associated with the shift will boost demand and growth in other sectors as well. Once this process sets in, it will bring into force a virtuous cycle of economic growth and employment that will give a big boost to the economy. The shift away from carbon fuels will help India keep inflation under control and reduce our trade deficit.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Pursuing renewables increases energy costs-- It requires new infrastructure and operating costs that are extremely expensive

Philip Rossetti, 1-25-2019, Philip Rossetti was the Former Director of Energy Policy and is a Data Analyst. "What it Costs to Go 100 Percent Renewable," AAF, 

Combining the $285 billion of capital costs with the operation and maintenance costs results in an average annual expenditure of about $423.9 billion each year. For perspective, total revenue raised in the United States from electricity sales in 2017 . Even under the optimistic conditions of the above assessment, which assume very low electricity storage and discharge costs, and no increased transmission costs, merely building and operating the required number of renewable electric power plants would cost more than what Americans pay for electricity today.It should also be noted that the above estimate likely seriously underestimates the costs of electricity storage. Storage becomes more expensive if it must discharge quickly, and multiple times throughout the day. The above simply assumes that the type of battery storage being installed at a utility scale today would be sufficient for all purposes, but more nuanced analyses like those from  show an enormous cost difference between storing electricity and generating it. Lazard’s analysis estimates that the cost of wholesale, levelized cost of lithium-ion storage (the total lifetime cost relative to energy saved) would be  per megawatt hour. For perspective, the levelized cost of a natural gas power plant is , meaning using battery storage rather than a dispatchable natural gas power plant could cost consumers 4-6 times as much.The above estimates show that a 100 percent renewable target would require an extraordinary amount of investment, but determining exactly how much a typical consumer would be affected is not easy, since electricity costs encompass more than merely the capital and operating costs. An  produced for the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, however, estimated that a decarbonized 100 percent renewable electricity system would result in an  (2017’s average electricity cost is  per megawatt hour). Simply, a 100 percent renewable electricity grid would require Americans to pay between 43 and 286 percent more on their electric bills. In 2017, the average monthly , so a 43-286 percent increase would translate to an average of between $576 and $3,882 more spent on electricity per year per residence.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Switching to renewables is cheaper and more sustainable than 99% of coal plants

Michelle Solomon and Mike O’Boyle Michelle is a Senior Policy Analyst in the Electricity Program at Energy Innovation, working to accelerate the transition to a clean, affordable, and equitable electricity sector in the United States. Feb.9,2023 --- cut by ki h

Festus, Missouri. Sheboygan, Wisconsin. Omaha, Nebraska. Millsboro, Delaware. These communities all have something in common — a coal plant slated for retirement. From to required upgrades to limit pollution to greenhouse gas reduction policies, the operators decided running the plants no longer made sense. Those communities, and hundreds more across the country, face an existential question. What comes after coal? Even considering recent supply chain hiccups, new wind and solar have gotten remarkably cheap as coal costs continue increasing. New Inflation Reduction Act clean energy and financing and potential mean the economic risks for existing coal — and the communities that depend upon them economically — will only get worse. To better understand these risks and the economic upside of a coal-to-clean transition, Energy Innovation Policy & Technology the cost of new renewable energy and battery resources compared to coal generation. We found 99% of coal plants are more expensive to run than the all-in cost of new wind or solar resources in the same region. And 97% of plants are more expensive than wind or solar within a 30-mile radius.The margins are not even close. For 80% of coal plants, renewable generation costs are at least 30% lower than the marginal cost of continuing to operate the plant, excluding capital costs of the coal plants. Even though renewables and coal play different roles in the power system, this stark “coal cost crossover” means billions in savings can shore up reliability and transmission needs. Investment in lower cost wind and solar resources is an economic opportunity worth up to $589 billion, providing jobs and tax base to coal communities. New projects can be even cheaper if utilities access the Department of Energy Loan Program Office’s new government-backed loan authority to reinvest in clean energy projects, available through 2026. Any utility integrated resource plan finalized before August 2022 is now outdated. Regulators and utilities must act quickly to secure potential savings and investments by reevaluating any resource plans made prior to the IRA’s passage and enabling competitive procurement practices. Aligning least cost with a community transition Communities have faced barriers to a just, affordable transition away from coal. Consider a joint proposal by Native American Tribes and Arizona Public Service to reinvest in communities affected by the 2019 closure of Navajo Generating station, which along with the Kayenta Coal Mine, employed nearly 1,000 workers. Although hailed as a potential model for other communities, last September the Arizona Corporation Commission staff putting this proposal into rates, and one commissioner the regulators’ authority to charge ratepayers for community investment funding. The case, still in , embodies how traditional ratemaking principles of placing only costs of service into utility rates can restrict utility investments in rural communities that have provided low-cost energy to city dwellers for decades. The IRA changes this dynamic by providing a 10% bonus on top of extended investment and production tax credits for projects sited within “” — regions that have depended on the extraction, processing and concentrated use — for example, at power plants — of coal, oil and natural gas. Least-cost resource planning is now aligned with what the reinvestment communities need. For about half the coal capacity in the U.S., our analysis finds the cheapest replacement renewable resource would be local solar within 30 miles of the power plant, which could leverage the energy community bonus credit. Local replacement could also qualify for financing and funding available through two IRA programs. are now available through the U.S. Department of Energy to “retool, repower, repurpose or replace energy infrastructure that has ceased operations, or enable operating energy infrastructure to avoid, reduce, utilize, or sequester air pollutants or . . . greenhouse gases.” In our current high-interest rate environment, utilities can access this low-cost capital to make a down payment on and save consumers even more. The IRA also allocated to replace fossil generation with clean energy through the U.S. Department of Agriculture. The 18 gigawatts of coal primarily owned by cooperatives are excellent candidates for this funding, generating a huge reinvestment opportunity in rural communities that have economically depended on coal plants but borne the brunt of their pollution. New clean energy projects can diversify economies and anchor re-industrialization of the site’s infrastructure, even as coal generation declines.Read More in Generation What about grid reliability? Coal still plays an important role in system reliability today. Wind and solar will not replicate this role alone, but reliability can improve as coal phases down if planners that includes existing dispatchable resources, new clean energy resources, storage, expanded transmission, and demand-side management. Our reliability paradigm will change, but electrical engineers are . Building new wind and solar resources fast enough will be key to addressing resource adequacy challenges and meeting consumer demand for renewable energy. As coal gets more expensive and riskier, market opportunities for cheap renewables abound — but we’re not building sufficient new clean energy to keep up with market potential. The North American Electric Reliability Corporation’s show much of the electric grid faces risk of resource shortfall through 2027, with 7 of 13 U.S. assessment regions at elevated or high risk of shortfall. Even with great need, transmission bottlenecks and interconnection queues can take five years or more to get new projects online. This means coal plants that would otherwise retire are being kept around. The Rush Island Generating Station in Missouri and Indian River Generating Station in Delaware were both required to upgrade transmission to ensure grid stability near each plants’ location before they could retire. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission is now granting cost recovery to keep these plants online until those upgrades can be completed. Meanwhile, interconnection delays for new resources have kept Wisconsin’s Edgewater Power Station and Nebraska’s North Omaha Power Station running. Siting cheaper renewables close to retiring coal plants can reduce interconnection approval time by using the plant’s existing interconnection rights. With interconnection delays getting longer and costs increasing, local replacement could overcome one of the main hurdles to adding new, clean capacity and transitioning plants like Edgewater and North Omaha. Our analysis finds the savings of switching to local clean energy would be enough to pay for 137 GW of four-hour battery storage across the U.S., equal to 62% of the coal fleet capacity we studied. The potential to add not only energy, but capacity, at plant sites could bolster reliability value and reduce the need for transmission upgrades, such as those identified for Rush Island and Indian River. Priorities for utilities and their regulators For a variety of reasons including utility ratemaking, outdated and non-transparent cost assumptions, lack of political will, transmission availability and reliability concerns, many utilities operating coal are not taking advantage of lower-cost renewable energy. Policymakers and utilities should act now to ensure customers are not saddled with higher prices by accounting for all the IRA has to offer. First, regulators and system operators should reform methods to assess reliability and resource adequacy, so they fairly reflect the reliability value of new resources. from the Energy Systems Integration Group recommends how to credit the resource adequacy value of all resources without discriminating, including newer resources like wind, solar and storage. ISO/RTOs also need to assess opportunities to streamline the process for new resources to leverage coal plant interconnection rights and avoid high costs and long delays. Second, utilities must update any integrated resource plan or investment strategy enacted before IRA passage to reflect the new costs of renewable energy. In addition to requiring re-evaluation of potential investments, regulators should encourage utilities to use IRA loan programs to pay for clean resources, and, as has done, so renewable resources can fairly compete against fossil fuels. Finally, state energy offices and legislatures should follow Colorado’s example by , including establishing a centralized body to engage communities and disburse funds. The economic case for replacing highly polluting and expensive coal-fired generation with clean energy is stronger than ever. Utilities have a generational opportunity to accelerate the transition. Moving slowly risks leaving consumer savings, improved public health and climate benefits on the table.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Net zero is cheaper and greener than continued fossil fuel use

James Ashworth, 9-13-2022, "Net zero is cheaper and greener than continuing the use of fossil fuels", No Publication, https://www.nhm.ac.uk/discover/news/2022/september/net-zero-cheaper-and-greener-than-continuing-use-fossil-fuels.html, 7-2-2023, //ms

A rapid transition to net zero could save $12 trillion in the coming decades. With renewable technologies likely to become cheaper than fossil fuels within a decade, switching now will allow the world to have a greener and cheaper future. is no longer just the smart decision – it's also the most profitable one. A team of researchers from Oxford University predict that a rapid transition to green energy sources such as could save anywhere between $5 to $15 trillion compared to taking no action. This forecast held true in 80% of scenarios modelled by the team and could save even more money if green technology continues to improve. , who co-authored a paper detailing the findings, says, 'There is a pervasive misconception that switching to clean, green energy will be painful, costly and mean sacrifices for us all - but that's just wrong.' 'Renewable costs have been trending down for decades and are already cheaper than in many situations. Our research shows they will become cheaper than fossil fuels across almost all applications in the years to come and if we accelerate the transition, they will become cheaper faster.' 'Completely replacing fossil fuels with clean energy by 2050 will save us trillions.' The findings of the study were . Trends in renewables and fossil fuels The researchers analysed decades, and in some cases centuries, of data on the cost and output of a range of different energy sources, including coal, oil, gas, solar and wind to predict future trends to 2050. They also investigated developing technologies such as and which can make use of power from renewable sources. They found that the prices of fossil fuels, when adjusted for inflation, are relatively similar to their cost 140 years ago but with spikes in the past 40 years associated with geopolitical events. This pattern has been attributed to a 'running-to-stand-still' dynamic. This describes how fossil fuels were much easier to find and extract over a century ago but are now increasingly scarce. While technology has improved extraction processes over this time, the increased cost to target less accessible ensures that prices remain similar to their historic values. In the meantime, the price of solar and wind power has dropped at an almost exponential rate. In the 1950s, solar power was as much as 10,000 times more expensive than coal and gas but is now cheaper than electricity from fossil fuels and is rapidly approaching parity with their primary costs, especially in light of the war in Ukraine. As a result, renewable energy is now providing significantly more of the world's power . The production of solar energy has increased by an average of 44% a year for the past three decades, while wind power has increased by 23% a year. While fossil fuels still produce more energy than renewables today, the researchers predict that they are likely to be overtaken within the next 10 years if current trends continue. Are fossil fuels cheaper than renewable energy? Not for much longer. Renewable energy is already cheaper than fossil fuels in a number of industries, and the researchers forecast that by 2050, almost all applications will be cheaper with renewables. In this scenario, most buildings and vehicles will be powered by renewable energy, with the most energy intense forms of industry and travel making use of fuels produced using renewable power. This prediction follows historic trends that reveal that the cost of solar power, for instance, has fallen by 15% per year on average - over 10 percentage points ahead of projections by the . , the study's lead author, says this difference is a result of unrealistic costs used in other models. 'Past models, for transitioning to zero carbon energy have deterred companies from investing and made governments nervous about setting policies that will accelerate the energy transition and cut reliance on fossil fuels,' Rupert says. 'But clean energy costs have fallen sharply over the last decade, much faster than those models expected.' 'Our latest research shows scaling up key green technologies will continue to drive their costs down - and the faster we go, the more we will save. Accelerating the transition to renewable energy is now the best bet not just for the planet, but for energy costs too.' The scientists examined how costs would change in the next 50 years using three different models, which looked at a fast transition to net zero, a slow transition, and no transition. They found that at any reasonably expected - which is used to estimate how much something in the future would be worth in today's money - the fast transition is significantly cheaper than no transition in 80% of cases, with a most likely saving of $12 trillion. Under the fast transition scenario, a Megawatt hour of solar energy is forecast to cost anywhere from $2 to $40 by 2050 while a barrel of oil will be anywhere from $20 to $110.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Renewables are cheapest option and lock in low costs

Nathaniel Bullard, 7-14-2022, Nat Bullard is a senior contributor to BloombergNEF and Bloomberg Green. He is a venture partner at Voyager, an early stage climate technology investor. "Renewable Energy Provides Relief From Rising Power Prices", Bloomberg, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-14/renewable-energy-provides-relief-from-rising-power-prices, 7-2-2023, //ms

But at the same time, renewable power could provide some relief from rising power prices. Absolute cost figures are important, but perhaps more important are the details of the power markets in which new wind and solar projects operate. Onshore wind and solar costs have risen year on year At the same time, the cost of power from coal and gas have risen even more. The result is that the gap in between wind and solar (generally the lowest-cost options in most developed grids) and coal and gas has widened, not closed. The gaps between wind and solar, and coal-fired power, are greater than a year ago but still not as big as in 2020. The gaps between wind and solar, and gas-fired power, have never been greater.

While onshore wind and solar levelized costs have risen, the cost of offshore wind has fallen. In 2014, the benchmark cost of offshore wind power was more than double the cost of gas-fired power. Today, it is just 7% higher. Electricity system planners and power utility executives, if they expect fuel prices to be high in the future, may look at this narrow differential and plan in favor of the technology without any fuel costs (more on that in a bit).

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Renewables decrease energy prices

International Renewable Energy Agency, 7-13-2022, "Renewable Power Remains Cost-Competitive amid Fossil Fuel Crisis", No Publication, https://www.irena.org/news/pressreleases/2022/Jul/Renewable-Power-Remains-Cost-Competitive-amid-Fossil-Fuel-Crisis, 7-2-2023, //ms

Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates, 13 July 2022 – Costs for renewables continued to fall in 2021 as supply chain challenges and rising commodity prices have yet to show their full impact on project costs. The cost of electricity from onshore wind fell by 15%, offshore wind by 13% and solar PV by 13% compared to 2020.

, published by the International Renewable Energy Agency (IRENA) today, shows that almost two-thirds or 163 gigawatts (GW) of newly installed renewable power in 2021 had lower costs than the world’s cheapest coal-fired option in the G20. IRENA estimates that, given the current high fossil fuel prices, the renewable power added in 2021 saves around USD 55 billion from global energy generation costs in 2022.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Plan is necessary to avoid the risk of inevitable future energy price spikes.

Mike Jacobs is leading the Union of Concerned Scientists’s work on electricity markets and regulatory reform. More Fossil Natural Gas Won’t Lower High Energy Bills December 5, 2022 | 3:53 pm https://blog.ucsusa.org/mike-jacobs/more-fossil-natural-gas-wont-lower-high-energy-bills/

For US consumers, gas and electricity this year are costing billions more because utilities are moving too slowly to adopt gas replacements, namely renewable energy, energy efficiency, as well as building electrification. Utilities, regulators and consumers need to make that transition to manage risks to energy security and cost spikes.

2023 SDI Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Affirmative Answers › Turn – Renewables solve prices

Current use of fossil fuels is driving rising electricity prices

Ivy Main JULY 19, 2022 12:03 AM Your electric bills are skyrocketing. Blame our failure to invest in renewable energy. https://www.virginiamercury.com/2022/07/19/your-electric-bills-are-skyrocketing-blame-our-failure-to-invest-in-renewable-energy/

Fossil fuel prices are higher everywhere, and the effect is hitting electric bills as well as prices at the gas pump. Utilities that generate power from and face fuel costs two or three times as high as they were just a couple of years ago —and those costs are passed on to customers. Some utilities employ hedging strategies and long-term contracts to reduce the impact of price spikes. But as a general matter, how painful your bill increase will be is a function of how much electricity your utility generates from fossil fuels.