2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Link XT – Plan raises energy prices
Nicolas Loris @NiconomistLoris Former Deputy Director, Thomas A. Roe Institute Green New Deal Would Barely Change Earth’s Temperature. Here Are the Facts.Feb 8, 2019 https://www.heritage.org/energy-economics/commentary/green-new-deal-would-barely-change-earths-temperature-here-are-the
Even more concerning, the direct impact from higher energy costs is just a small part of the story. Energy is a necessary input for nearly all of the goods and services consumers buy. Consequently, Americans will pay more for food, health care, education, clothes, and every other good or service that requires energy to make and transport. In fact, Heritage Foundation economists used the Heritage Energy Model, a derivative of the Energy Information Administration’s National Energy Modeling System, to model the economic impacts of a carbon tax, which Green New Deal advocates admit would only be one tiny fraction of the entire plan. Each and half the job losses coming in energy-intensive manufacturing industries. Over a 20-year period, the total income loss would be tens of thousands of dollars and the aggregate gross domestic product loss would be over $2.5 trillion. If policymakers spent, taxed, and regulated to achieve net-zero greenhouse gas emissions for America’s transportation, agricultural, and industrial sectors, the costs would be several orders of magnitude higher. Importantly, Americans have little appetite to pay such costs. In fact, to fight climate change. The protests in France are quite indicative of how people feel about costly climate policies.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Link XT – Plan raises energy prices
Marlo Lewis, Jr. • 02/26/2019 How Much Will the Green New Deal Cost Your Family? https://cei.org/blog/how-much-will-the-green-new-deal-cost-your-family/
The American Action Forum estimates that, between 2020 and 2029, the energy and environmental components of the Green New Deal would cost $8.3 trillion to $12.3 trillion, or $52,000 to $72,000 per household. The total GND program, including the jobs and “social justice” policies, would cost $51.1 trillion to $92.9 trillion, or $316,010 to $419,010 per household. Perhaps as significant as what the Green New Deal says is what it does not say. The word “cost” occurs only once—in a provision directing the U.S. government to “take into account the complete environmental and social costs of emissions.” Although emissions from infrastructure, transportation, manufacturing, and agriculture are to be reduced “as much as technologically feasible,” the text nowhere states or implies that emission reductions must be cost effective, commercially viable, or reasonably affordable. Although staggering, the costs in AAF’s chart above include only the direct expenditures needed to achieve the Green New Deal’s goals. A separate analysis would be required to estimate the GND’s impacts on the growth and performance of the U.S. economy. The AAF analysts conclude with a warning about the less quantifiable perils of centralized planning and World War II-style “mobilization” of the nation’s industries and resources: The Green New Deal is clearly very expensive. Its further expansion of the federal government’s role in some of the most basic decisions of daily life, however, would likely have a more lasting and damaging impact than its enormous price tag.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Link XT – Plan raises energy prices
Holtz-Eakin, et.al., Douglas Holtz-Eakin, Dan Bosch, Ben Gitis, Dan Goldbeck, Philip Rossetti February 25, 2019 THE GREEN NEW DEAL: SCOPE, SCALE, AND IMPLICATIONS Read more: https://www.americanactionforum.org/research/the-green-new-deal-scope-scale-and-implications/#ixzz85wHVJ331
We estimate that to transition to a power sector that has net zero emissions of greenhouse gases in 10 years would require a capital investment of $5.4 trillion by 2029. In addition, the annual operation, maintenance, and capital-recovery costs would be $387 billion.[1] We consider this estimate to be conservative in two respects. First, we assume that a low-carbon electricity grid is feasible with only 4 hours of storage available for renewable resources; academic estimates have said a reliable grid requires 12 hours.[2] Second, we assume no new construction of transmission assets is required, even though efficiently siting new renewable assets will require significant transmission infrastructure. To reach this bottom line, we assume that states without nuclear moratoriums build approximately 50 percent of their needed capacity with nuclear power, and cover the remaining 50 percent with wind, solar, hydro, geothermal electricity, and battery storage. States with nuclear moratoriums are assumed to replace fossil fuels with wind, solar, and storage. This approach raises issues in dispatching electricity, because one needs to cover the difference between available nuclear and peak capacity with both solar and wind resources. Most renewable resources are non-dispatchable, and must be supplemented by storage and other available assets. (For example, if one has 500 megawatts (MW) of nuclear and needs 1000MW total, the solution is to use 500MW nuclear and 500MW solar for part of the day, 500MW nuclear and 500MW wind for a second part, and 500MW nuclear and 500MW storage for the remainder). The estimate incorporates full construction of all available hydro assets, and business-as-usual geothermal construction. The figure also assumes only 4 hours of storage would be available. To put these costs in perspective, total retail revenue in the electric power sector was $390 billion in 2017.[3] Generation costs were 59 percent of that, and would go from $230 billion to $387 billion each year in the above scenario, about a $157 billion difference, though if $70.5 billion of annual fuel costs are avoided by 2029 the net annual difference falls to $86.5 billion.[4] That increase (accounting for avoided fuel costs) would drive up total electricity costs by 22 percent. With an average monthly electric bill in 2017 of $111, the average household could expect around $295 of increased annual expenditures on electricity. This scenario is likely optimistic, as it assumes no increased costs for electricity generation and storage assets resulting from dramatically increased demand, nor does it consider any growth in transmission assets. Alternatively, the estimated costs could fall if storage assets could be deployed efficiently, but total costs would certainly be in the multiples of trillions of dollars range.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Link XT – Plan raises energy prices
Nicolas Loris @NiconomistLoris Former Deputy Director, Thomas A. Roe Institute Green New Deal Would Barely Change Earth’s Temperature. Here Are the Facts.Feb 8, 2019 https://www.heritage.org/energy-economics/commentary/green-new-deal-would-barely-change-earths-temperature-here-are-the
But not only would the Green New Deal be ineffective, it would also almost certainly impose steep costs on Americans, via increased energy bills. The 100 percent of America’s electricity from “clean, renewable, and zero-emission” energy sources—a steep increase from the 63 percent of electricity that came from carbon dioxide-emitting conventional fuels in 2017. Nuclear power was responsible for another 20 percent. But, according , “The Green New Deal makes new fossil fuel infrastructure or nuclear plants unnecessary. This is a massive mobilization of all our resources into renewable energies.” The proposal also calls for eliminating greenhouse gas emissions from transportation and other infrastructure as much as technologically feasible. Yet, as recently as 2017, petroleum accounted for 92 percent of America’s transportation fuel. To achieve these targets, the resolution proposes a massive government spending program in addition to carbon dioxide taxes, subsidies, and regulation. How are Americans going to pay for it? Don’t worry, the FAQ answers that one: “We will finance the investments for the Green New Deal the same way we paid for the original New Deal, World War II, the bank bailouts, tax cuts for the rich, and decades of war—with public money appropriated by Congress. Further, government can take an equity stake in Green New Deal projects so the public gets a return on its investment.” Credibly estimating the cost of the Green New Deal for American taxpayers, households, and businesses is exceedingly difficult. Even projecting the cost of switching to 100 percent renewable power for electricity relies on a set of largely unknowable assumptions. How companies would make large-scale investments to meet the mandate and how intermittent power sources would receive backup power is mostly a guessing game. Technological challenges aside, . Trillions of dollars of energy existing assets (coal, nuclear, natural gas plants, etc.) would be stranded and lost. In effect, the result would be households potentially paying in their electricity bill.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Uniqueness XT – Energy prices stable
Jon Reed, 2-20-2023, Jon Reed is an editor for CNET covering home energy, including solar panels and energy efficiency. Jon has spent more than a decade making a living by asking other people questions. He previously worked as an editor at NextAdvisor, focused on home loans and the housing market;"Your Utility Bills Might Be About to Drop. Here's Why," CNET, Some relief could be coming for your soaring energy costs.
The average American household is expected to see utility bills -- electric and gas -- hold steady or even drop in the next couple of years, according to the latest forecast by the . After a significant increase since 2020, electricity bills are expected to stay fairly flat in 2023 and 2024, with a drop in consumption offsetting a moderate rise in prices, a CNET analysis of EIA found. Natural gas bills are expected to drop after surging last year following Russia's invasion of Ukraine.So far this winter, energy savings can largely be attributed to lower heating costs due to the weather, according to , a director at Moody's Analytics who oversees the firm's climate risk initiative."This has been one of the most mild winters on record," Lafakis said. "That has really, really taken a toll on natural gas prices." While the balmy winter has been the biggest driver of household energy savings, global factors affecting the natural gas supply chain and the war in Ukraine also play a role. Energy costs soared in 2022, largely due to global factors. The showed electricity prices up 11.9% year over year in January, while utility gas service prices were up 26.7% year over year.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Uniqueness XT – Energy prices stable
LYLE NIEDENS Published March 08, 2023 https://www.investopedia.com/electricity-prices-may-fall-7229665
U.S. wholesale electricity prices should fall substantially this year, the U.S. Energy Information Administration's latest monthly report predicts, providing at least some relief for consumers who saw their electric bills surge in 2022. The EIA foresees the wholesale prices it tracks at 11 selected U.S. hubs averaging $51.36 per megawatthour (MWh) in 2023, down 37% from their collective 2022 averages. Electricity prices increased nationwide last year as prices for natural gas, accounting for about 40% of the fuel used for U.S. electric power generation, rose worldwide after Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Economic sanctions against Russia, a leading global natural gas supplier, fed the increase. Residential retail prices across the U.S. increased 9% last year,1 with consumption rising 2.6% even as rising costs to generate power strained utilities.1 However, the EIA projects natural gas prices delivered to U.S. electric generators will fall by about half this year. Moreover, it foresees U.S. electricity consumption receding by 1.2%, helping further alleviate the 2022's upward price pressure.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Uniqueness XT – Energy prices stable
·Senior Columnist June 14, 2023 ·4 min read https://finance.yahoo.com/news/its-not-just-gasoline-other-energy-prices-are-finally-falling-too-200442028.html
Some types of inflation are highly visible. Gasoline prices, in giant numbers at every filling station, are probably the most-seen inflation gauge. Other types of inflation are hidden, such as the indecipherable charges for electricity detailed in most people’s utility bills. Household energy has been a significant driver of inflation during the last two years, but there’s now a good chance power prices will drop for the foreseeable future. “Summer 2023 looks less painful for consumers and businesses,” Citi Research energy analysts wrote in a June 14 report. Most types of energy surged in price starting in 2021, with oil and gasoline prices peaking last June, when gas hit $5 per gallon. Pump prices are now down to about $3.60, close enough to the trendline of the last 10 years to call normal. Prices have fallen for a few reasons: Russia’s war in Ukraine hasn’t produced the oil shock some people expected. Supply has picked up. More refining capacity has come online. And demand from China, a huge energy customer, has been weak amid a sputtering economy there.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › Block Extension › Uniqueness XT – Energy prices stable
LAST UPDATED MAY 12, 2023 Kiplinger Energy Outlook: Gasoline Prices Holding Steady for Now https://www.kiplinger.com/economic-forecasts/energy
Mild winter weather led to a sharp drop in the price of natural gas, and for now, there are no signs of a recovery. The benchmark gas futures contract was recently trading at $2.22 per million British thermal units. At their peak last year, gas futures reached $9.50. Unseasonably mild weather in the United States and Europe this winter led to a big drop in normal heating demand, and now stockpiles of gas in storage are ample. Until demand picks up again, that glut of extra supply should keep prices fairly low, likely below $3 per MMBtu. A strong summer heat wave might be enough to spark a rally, since the United States relies heavily on gas to generate electricity, and hot weather leads to a lot of air conditioner use. But long-range weather forecasts aren’t pointing to that scenario for now.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › 1NC
Castellaw 17 (John – 36-year veteran of the U.S. Marine Corps and the Founder and CEO of Farmspace Systems LLC, “Opinion: Food Security Strategy Is Essential to Our National Security,” 5/1/17, https://www.agri-pulse.com/articles/9203-opinion-food-security-strategy-is-essential-to-our-national-security)
The United States faces many threats to our National Security. These threats include continuing wars with extremist elements such as ISIS and potential wars with rogue state North Korea or regional nuclear power Iran. The heated economic and diplomatic competition with Russia and a surging China could spiral out of control. Concurrently, we face threats to our future security posed by growing civil strife, famine, and refugee and migration challenges which create incubators for extremist and anti-American government factions. Our response cannot be one dimensional but instead must be a nuanced and comprehensive National Security Strategy combining all elements of National Power including a Food Security Strategy. An American Food Security Strategy is an imperative factor in reducing the multiple threats impacting our National wellbeing. Recent history has shown that reliable food supplies and stable prices produce more stable and secure countries. Conversely, food insecurity, particularly in poorer countries, can lead to instability, unrest, and violence. Food insecurity drives mass migration around the world from the Middle East, to Africa, to Southeast Asia, destabilizing neighboring populations, generating conflicts, and threatening our own security by disrupting our economic, military, and diplomatic relationships. Food system shocks from extreme food-price volatility can be correlated with protests and riots. Food price related protests toppled governments in Haiti and Madagascar in 2007 and 2008. In 2010 and in 2011, food prices and grievances related to food policy were one of the major drivers of the Arab Spring uprisings. Repeatedly, history has taught us that a strong agricultural sector is an unquestionable requirement for inclusive and sustainable growth, broad-based development progress, and long-term stability. The impact can be remarkable and far reaching. Rising income, in addition to reducing the opportunities for an upsurge in extremism, leads to changes in diet, producing demand for more diverse and nutritious foods provided, in many cases, from American farmers and ranchers. Emerging markets currently purchase 20 percent of U.S. agriculture exports and that figure is expected to grow as populations boom. Moving early to ensure stability in strategically significant regions requires long term planning and a disciplined, thoughtful strategy. To combat current threats and work to prevent future ones, our national leadership must employ the entire spectrum of our power including diplomatic, economic, and cultural elements. The best means to prevent future chaos and the resulting instability is positive engagement addressing the causes of instability before it occurs. This is not rocket science. We know where the instability is most likely to occur. The world population will grow by 2.5 billion people by 2050. Unfortunately, this massive population boom is projected to occur primarily in the most fragile and food insecure countries. This alarming math is not just about total numbers. Projections show that the greatest increase is in the age groups most vulnerable to extremism. There are currently 200 million people in Africa between the ages of 15 and 24, with that number expected to double in the next 30 years. Already, 60% of the unemployed in Africa are young people. Too often these situations deteriorate into shooting wars requiring the deployment of our military forces. We should be continually mindful that the price we pay for committing military forces is measured in our most precious national resource, the blood of those who serve. For those who live in rural America, this has a disproportionate impact. Fully 40% of those who serve in our military come from the farms, ranches, and non-urban communities that make up only 16% of our population. Actions taken now to increase agricultural sector jobs can provide economic opportunity and stability for those unemployed youths while helping to feed people. A recent report by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs identifies agriculture development as the core essential for providing greater food security, economic growth, and population well-being. Our active support for food security, including agriculture development, has helped stabilize key regions over the past 60 years. A robust food security strategy, as a part of our overall security strategy, can mitigate the growth of terrorism, build important relationships, and support continued American economic and agricultural prosperity while materially contributing to our Nation’s and the world’s security.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › 1NC
AustTrade, 2022 Insight – Farm, food costs rise due to higher energy prices 4 March 2022 https://www.austrade.gov.au/news/insights/insight-farm-food-costs-rise-due-to-higher-energy-prices
Agricultural production needs energy. Energy is used directly by machinery and indirectly through inputs such as fertilisers, herbicides and pesticides. This means production costs and farm profits are sensitive to changes in energy prices. The impacts of high energy prices vary across commodities. Crop production is typically more energy-intensive than livestock production. This is because crops consume more fertiliser and need more mechanised operations. For crops like oats, wheat and barley, energy and fertiliser make up about half of total operating costs.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › 1NC
Jessica R. Towhey Posted to Energy February 28, 2020 New Report Says Green New Deal Would ‘Destroy’ Middle Class https://insidesources.com/new-report-says-green-new-deal-would-destroy-middle-class/
Bernie Sanders’ aggressive climate policy could bankrupt America’s middle class, according to a new study on the costs of the Green New Deal (GND). The Competitive Enterprise Institute, Power the Future, and the Wisconsin Institute for Law and Liberty analyzed implementation costs in 11 states and found that it would cost the average household more than $75,000 in the first year and more than $40,000 each year thereafter. In some states, like New Mexico, these costs would exceed the median household incomes. “The Green New Deal would effectively destroy America’s energy industry, and with it, our entire economy,” said Daniel Turner, executive director of Power the Future. The new study builds on one released by CEI and Power the Future last July analyzing electricity, vehicle, housing upgrade and shipping costs in five states: Alaska, Florida, New Hampshire New Mexico and Pennsylvania. The new study adds Colorado, Iowa, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio and Wisconsin to the analysis. The study also looked at how forcing a change to all-organic farming methods would rupture Wisconsin’s economy. The Green New Deal was introduced by U.S. Rep. Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) and Senator Ed Markey (D-Mass.) ostensibly to combat climate change. However, the proposal also includes progressive economic policy goals like guaranteeing a living wage and universal healthcare. What the sponsors did not include was a price tag, and determining its true cost has proven elusive. Various organizations from across the political spectrum have attempted to determine the total cost of the GND by breaking down its components. For example, expanding renewable energy to provide 100 percent of the country’s power grid would cost upwards of $200 billion a year for 10 years, according to physicist Christopher Clark. Upgrading every house and industrial building for energy efficiency would run about $10,000 per structure for a total of nearly $1.4 trillion, according to several estimates.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI – Energy Prices DA › 1NC
Robert Walton Senior Reporter Published March 14, 2023 Lower gas prices to drive 35%-45% ‘plunge’ in 2023 peak power prices across most of US: Moody’s https://www.utilitydive.com/news/lower-gas-prices-drive-35-45-plunge-in-2023-expected-peak-power-prices-a/644920/
, consumers could find some relief in 2023 as energy prices abate, Moody’s said. “Natural gas and power price expectations for 2023 have dropped steeply,” the firm said. The current winter season “has been unusually warm,” which moderated heating demand and left gas storage facilities with inventories about 21.5% above their historical five-year averages. “Expected 2023 natural gas prices are around 44% lower than forward market expectations in December,” Moody’s said. That has resulted in 2023 expected power prices more than 40% lower than 2022 in some regions, according to the research note which cited S&P Global Market Intelligence data.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › BioD Defense
Hough 14 [Rupert, Environmental Scientist with Expertise in Risk Modelling and Exposure Assessment and PhD from Nottingham University, February, “Biodiversity and human health: evidence for causality?” Biodiversity and Conservation, Vol. 23 No. 2, pg. 272-3/AKG]
Large country-level assessments (e.g. MEA 2005; Huynen et al. 2004; Sieswerda et al. 2001) must be interpreted with some caution. Data measured at country-level are likely to mask regional and local-level effects. Apart from the fact that there are limitations to regression analysis in providing any proof of causality, least squares regression models assume linear relationships between reductions in biodiversity and human health and thus imply a linear relationship between loss of biodiversity and the provision of relevant ecosystem goods and services. A number of authors, however, have suggested that ecosystems can lose a proportion of their biodiversity without adverse consequences to their functioning (e.g. Schwartz et al. 2000). Only when a threshold in the losses of biodiversity is reached does the provision of ecosystem goods and services become compromised. These models also tend to assume a positive relationship between socio-economic development and loss of biodiversity. One problem with this expectation is that the loss in biodiversity in one country is not per definition the result of socio-economic developments in that particular country, but could also be the result of socio-economic developments in other parts of the world (Wackernagel and Rees 1996). Furthermore, the use of existing data means researchers can only make use of available indicators. Unlike for human health and socio-economic development, there are no broadly accepted core-set of indicators for biodiversity (Soberon et al. 2000). The lack of correlation between biodiversity indicators (Huynen et al. 2004) shows that the selected indicators do not measure the same thing, which hinders interpretation of results. Finally, there is likely to be some sort of latency period between ecosystem imbalance and any resulting health consequences. To date, this has not been investigated using regression approaches. Finally, it is thought that provisioning services are more crucial for human health and well-being that other ecosystem services (Raudsepp-Hearne et al. 2010). Trends in measures of human well-being are clearly correlated with food provisioning services, and especially with meat consumption (Smil 2002). While *60 % of the ecosystem services assessed by the MEA were found to be in decline, most of these were regulating and supporting services, whereas the majority of expanding services were provisioning services such as crops, livestock and aquaculture (MEA 2005). Raudsepp-Hearne et al. (2010) investigated the impacts on human well-being from decreases in non-food ecosystem services using national-scale data in order to reveal human well-being trends at the global scale. At the global scale, forest cover, biodiversity, and fish stocks are all decreasing; while water crowding (a measure of how many people shared the same flow unit of water placing a clear emphasis on the social demands of water rather than physical stress (Falkenmark and Rockstro¨m 2004)), soil degradation, natural disasters, global temperatures, and carbon dioxide levels are all on the rise, and land is becoming increasingly subject to salinization and desertification (Bennett and Balvanera 2007). However, across countries, Raudsepp-Hearne et al. (2010) found no correlation between measures of wellbeing and the available data for non-food ecosystem services, including forest cover and percentage of land under protected-area status (proxies for many cultural and regulating services), organic pollutants (a proxy for air and water quality), and water crowding index (a proxy for drinking water availability, Sieswerda et al. 2001; WRI 2009) This suggests there is no direct causal link between biodiversity decline and health, rather the relationship is a ‘knock-on’ effect. I.e. if biodiversity decline affects mankind’s ability to produce food, fuel and fibre, it will therefore impact on human health and well-being. As discussed in the introduction, the fact that humans need food, water and air to live is an obvious one. All these basic provisions can be produced in a diversity-poor environment. Therefore, to understand whether there is a potential causality relationship between biodiversity in its own right and human health, we need to move beyond the basic provisioning services.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › BioD Defense
WWF 20 --- “Freshwater species in freefall: why everyone should care”, Sept 10th 2020, https://wwf.medium.com/why-everyone-should-care-about-the-continuing-collapse-in-freshwater-species-b7fc9730ed69
WWF’s new Living Planet Report has confirmed our worst fears. Freshwater species populations are continuing to plummet — now down 84% on average in the past 50 years. While that shocking statistic tells the story of decades of decline in the overall abundance of freshwater life, it also includes tales of extinction, including this year’s biggest loss — the Yangtze Paddlefish. Sadly, too many other freshwater species are heading for the same fate. It’s no coincidence that confirmation of the ongoing collapse in freshwater species comes just a couple of months after the UN announced that the world was still way off track in terms of SDG6 — providing water for all. Few people connect the two, but the loss of freshwater biodiversity is the clearest sign that we are not on course to achieve that essential goal. Destroying the freshwater ecosystems that our societies and economies depend on is no pathway to sustainable development. Water sustainability has to incorporate the protection of ecosystems, and yet water planners, development agencies and governments continue to treat water as solely an economic input, nothing more. Rivers are regarded as little more than pipes and sewers, wetlands as wasted space to pave over or drain, floodplains as ready-made sites for housing developments. The result: the rivers, lakes and wetlands that literally sustain life are being wrecked by short-sighted policies and projects. How do we know? Because they now contain only 16% of the biodiversity that was in them in 1970.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › BioD Defense
Nichols 20 – John, American journalist and author. He is the National Affairs correspondent for The Nation and associate editor of The Capital Times. Books authored or co-authored by Nichols include The Genius of Impeachment and The Death and Life of American Journalism. "John Nichols: Russ Feingold is making an issue of biodiversity”, The Capital Times – Maidson, , 01-07-2020
When the United Nations welcomed heads of state to the 1992 Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro, a global consensus was reached to take vital steps to save the planet. To that end, more than 170 nations gave their support to the U.N. Framework Convention on Climate Change. But it was not the only treaty at the summit. There was also a Convention on Biological Diversity.
The climate change treaty is well understood internationally — even if the Trump administration and its congressional allies continue to engage in dangerous denialism and obstruction.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › BioD Defense
Bruun and Ejrnæs 04-14’ – Hans Henrik, Researches and teaches ecology and biodiversity, with special focus on community assembly, with a preference for plants and their associated biota of insects and fungi, and on evidence-based nature conservation at the University of Copenhagen. Rasmus, Senior researcher in biology, Aarhus University. “Evidence against linking the biodiversity crisis to ecosystem collapse”, Techinical Note, , 04-14-2022
Brun et al. (2022) found that a few tall, high-SLA plant species had stronger effects on primary productivity than any measure of functional diversity. We add data on species rarity to show that ongoing biodiversity loss is unlikely to hamper ecosystem productivity, a core insight we feel the authors missed.
Main text
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › BioD Defense
Kareiva and Carranza 18 – Peter, Ph.D. in ecology and applied mathematics from Cornell University, director of the Institute of the Environment and Sustainability at UCLA.Valerie, Ph.D. Candidate at “Existential risk due to ecosystem collapse: Nature strikes back”, Futures, Vol. 102, Pg. 39-50, , 01-05-2018
The interesting question is whether any of the planetary thresholds other than CO2 could also portend existential risks. Here the answer is not clear. One boundary often mentioned as a concern for the fate of global civilization is biodiversity (Ehrlich & Ehrlich, 2012), with the proposed safety threshold being a loss of greater than 0.001% per year (Rockström et al., 2009). There is little evidence that this particular 0.001% annual loss is a threshold—and it is hard to imagine any data that would allow one to identify where the threshold was (Brook, Ellis, Perring, Mackay, & Blomqvist, 2013; Lenton & Williams, 2013). A better question is whether one can imagine any scenario by which the loss of too many species leads to the collapse of societies and environmental disasters, even though one cannot know the absolute number of extinctions that would be required to create this dystopia.
While there are data that relate local reductions in species richness to altered ecosystem function, these results do not point to substantial existential risks. The data are small-scale experiments in which plant productivity, or nutrient retention is reduced as species numbers decline locally (Vellend, 2017), or are local observations of increased variability in fisheries yield when stock diversity is lost (Schindler et al., 2010). Those are not existential risks. To make the link even more tenuous, there is little evidence that biodiversity is even declining at local scales (Vellend et al., 2013, Vellend et al., 2017). Total planetary biodiversity may be in decline, but local and regional biodiversity is often staying the same because species from elsewhere replace local losses, albeit homogenizing the world in the process. Although the majority of conservation scientists are likely to flinch at this conclusion, there is growing skepticism regarding the strength of evidence linking trends in biodiversity loss to an existential risk for humans (Maier, 2012; Vellend, 2014). Obviously if all biodiversity disappeared civilization would end—but no one is forecasting the loss of all species. It seems plausible that the loss of 90% of the world’s species could also be apocalyptic, but not one is predicting that degree of biodiversity loss either. Tragic, but plausible is the possibility of our planet suffering a loss of as many as half of its species. If global biodiversity were halved, but at the same time locally the number of species stayed relatively stable, what would be the mechanism for an end-of-civilization or even end of human prosperity scenario? Extinctions and biodiversity loss are ethical and spiritual losses, but perhaps not an existential risk.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › Syn Bio Defense
Lentzos et al. 14 – Flippa, a Senior Lecturer in Science & International Security at the Department of War Studies and Co-Director of the Centre for Science and Security Studies (CSSS) at King’s College London. Catherine Jefferson, researcher in the Department of Social Science, Health, and Medicine at King’s College London. Claire Morris, a senior research fellow in the Department of Social Science, Health, and Medicine at King’s College London. “The myths (and realities) of synthetic bioweapons”, Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, , 09-18-2014
Even experts have a hard time enhancing disease pathogens. Some observers have also expressed concerns that synthetic biology could be used to enhance the virulence or increase the transmissibility of known pathogens, creating novel threat agents.
Mousepox and bird flu (H5N1) experiments are frequently cited to demonstrate how dangerous new pathogens could be designed. But assessments of this threat tend to overlook a salient fact: In both these experiments, the researchers did not actually design the pathogens. With respect to H5N1, researchers had indeed been trying to design an air-transmissible virus variant for some time, without success. The ferret experiment was set up as an alternative approach, to see whether natural mutations could generate an air-transmissible variant. The researchers had no influence on the specific mutations induced. In the mousepox experiment, researchers inserted the gene for interleukin-4 into the mousepox virus to induce infertility in mice and serve as an infectious contraceptive for pest control. The result—that the altered virus was lethal to mice—was unanticipated by the researchers. In other words, it was not planned.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › Syn Bio Defense
Revill 17 – Dr. James, Research Fellow with the Harvard Sussex Program at SPRU. “Past as Prologue? The Risk of Adoption of Chemical and Biological Weapons by Non-State Actors in the EU”, Cambridge, pg. 626-642, , 09-29-2017
The second factor is “the perceived complexity of the innovation in terms of adoption and use”.40 This is important in the innovation literature, as Rogers remarked, “[t]he complexity of an innovation, as perceived by members of a social system, is negatively related to its rate of adoption”.41 Several scholars of terrorist innovation have also highlighted the issue of complexity;42 or, as Cragin et al have stated, “[h]ow simple or complex a technology appears affects perceptions of how risky it will be to adopt.”43
In most cases terrorist groups appear to have largely opted for the simplest pathway towards the achievement of their goals and the weapons used tend to be vernacular, functional devices drawing on local and readily-available materials, rather than sophisticated, “baroque” technologies. This is certainly the case with IEDs, the history of which is characterised largely by incremental innovations – although nevertheless frequently effective ones – with many means of delivery recycled from the past.44 Complexity can therefore be seen as important in the adoption of technology by terrorists generally, but is perhaps particularly acute in the case of CBW technology.
2023
SDI
Affirmative
MSDI – Medicare for All Affirmative › 2AC --- Innovation DA › Syn Bio Defense
Wimmer 18 – Eckard, Professor at Stony Brook University. “Synthetic Biology, Dual Use Research, and Possibilities for Control”, Defence against Bioterrorism, pg. 7-11, , 03-23-2018
Listed below are some constraints that show how in the US the development of dangerous infectious agents, referred to as “select agents”, is controlled – perhaps misuse even prevented – through technical and administrative hurdles:
I. Re-creating an already existing dangerous virus for malicious intent is a complex scientific endeavor. (i) It requires considerable scientific knowledge and experience and, more importantly, considerable financial support. That support usually comes from government and private agencies (NIH, NAF, etc.), organizations that carefully screen at multiple levels all applications for funding of ALL biological research. (ii) It requires an environment suitable for experimenting with dangerous infectious agents (containment facilities). Any work in containment facilities is also carefully regulated.