2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › I/L Defense – Won’t solve economy
David McGarry • June 17 2023 America shouldn’t import Europe’s carbon tariff Story https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/markets/america-shouldnt-import-europes-carbon-tariff/ar-AA1cxkpV
A CBAM, like any other tax or tariff, raises the price of covered goods. The economics are simple. When the seller’s costs increase, he or she relays some, or all, of that increase to the consumer. Moreover, protectionist policies such as this one warp industry’s economic incentives, encouraging firms to evade duties at the cost of operational efficiency. This inflates prices further. Tariffs also invite policy retributions from put-upon trading partners. America’s recent protectionist bungling serves as a case study. For example, one round of tariffs introduced against China in 2019 cost the typical American household $831 annually, according to by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. Another Fed , published in May 2020, suggested the recent U.S.-China trade war slashed the market capitalization of observed American firms by roughly $1.7 trillion. The Congressional Budget Office that Trump-era tariffs, imposed on several countries, would in 2020 reduce GDP by 0.5% and real household incomes by $1,277. The United States, unlike Europe, imposes no carbon tax. Nonetheless, environmental regulations impose substantial compliance costs on American manufacturers. Accordingly, the by Coons and Rep. Scott Peters (D-CA) “to account for the cost incurred by U.S. businesses to comply with laws and regulations limiting greenhouse gas emissions.” Lawmakers have been trying to pass some sort of CBAM for the past several years, with little to no regard for these negative effects. Coons and Sen. Bill Cassidy (R-LA) a pair of forthcoming CBAM proposals earlier this year. Another more environmentally minded , proposed in 2022 by Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI), to the exporting nation’s “carbon intensity.” Unlike his colleagues, Whitehouse seeks also to introduce carbon fees for domestic manufacturers as well as foreign ones. Any CBAM that includes no levy on domestic manufacturers would likely violate America’s international trade obligations and necessitate further harm at home. Article 3 of the , a enforced by the World Trade Organization, forbids signatories to favor domestically produced products over foreign competition. Imposing a national carbon tax to maintain WTO compliance would only further burden American consumers and industry.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › I/L Defense – Won’t solve warming
Kaufman, et.al., 2023 As US-EU trade tensions rise, conflicting carbon tariffs could undermine climate efforts Noah Kaufman is a research scholar at Columbia University's SIPA Center on Global Energy Policy. He was previously a senior economist at the Council of Economic Advisers. Chris Bataille is an Adjunct Research Fellow with the Center for Global Energy Policy (CGEP) of Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs (SIPA). Gautam Jain is a Senior Research Scholar at the Center on Global Energy Policy (CGEP) of Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs (SIPA) Sagatom Saha is an adjunct research scholar at Columbia University's SIPA Center on Global Energy Policy. He previously served in the International Trade Administration at the U.S. Commerce Department and the Office of the Special Presidential Envoy for Climate. Published: January 23, 2023 8.24am EST https://theconversation.com/as-us-eu-trade-tensions-rise-conflicting-carbon-tariffs-could-undermine-climate-efforts-198072
The U.S. and EU also now have competing carbon tariff proposals, and these could end up undermining each other. In December 2022, the EU reached a on a carbon border adjustment mechanism. It will put carbon-based on steel, aluminum and other industrial imports that aren’t regulated by comparable climate policies in their home countries. The Biden administration, meanwhile, proposed a “” of nations that would cooperate on reducing emissions by levying tariffs on relatively high-emission imports. At first glance, the two approaches might seem similar. But the EU and U.S. proposals reflect starkly different and arguably incompatible visions for the intersection of climate and trade policies. A failure to align approaches risks further stoking trade tensions and would likely have international repercussions. Without multinational coalitions, dirtier, lower-cost competition will undercut emerging low-carbon technologies. A strong transatlantic partnership is a prerequisite to greening the global economy. Without creative compromises and skillful diplomacy, the EU may find that its tariffs lead to reprisals rather than reciprocal action, and the U.S. quest to create climate clubs will not get off the ground.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › I/L Defense – Won’t solve warming
JUNE 9, 2023 What is in the Prove It Act introduced by Senator Coons and Senator Cramer? https://www.niskanencenter.org/what-is-in-the-prove-it-act-introduced-by-senator-coons-and-senator-cramer/
It will be problematic if lawmakers use the emissions study to implement stand-alone. It would risk violating the World Trade Organization’s non-discriminatory rules, causing retaliations from the U.S.’s trading partners, increasing costs for U.S. consumers, and creating an onerous administrative burden. Without a domestic U.S. carbon price, it would be difficult to determine and justify the magnitude of tariffs levied on carbon-intensive imports. Most of their production-related emissions are for domestic consumption. Using a punitive policy to address emissions in trade would have a very limited impact on these big polluters’ emissions trajectory. But it would lead to unintended consequences, as discussed above. Lawmakers should consider using the emissions study to inform the design and implementation of a . A carbon border adjustment consists of import taxes and export rebates paired with the domestic carbon tax at the same rate. A border-adjusted carbon tax would directly price the externalities of fossil fuel consumption, encourage the market to shift to clean energy sources, and level the playing field between U.S. and foreign producers in the U.S. market and foreign markets.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Political Capital Fails
Dr. George C. Edwards 2016 III, Distinguished Professor of Political Science and Jordan Chair in Presidential Studies at Texas A&M, “The Potential of Presidential Leadership”, Study Done for the White House Transition Project https://www.whitehousetransitionproject.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/WHTP2021-08-Potential-of-Presidential-Leadership.pdf
The best evidence is that presidential persuasion is effective only at the margins of congressional decision making. Presidential legislative leadership operates in an environment largely beyond the president’s control and must compete with other, more stable factors that affect voting in Congress in addition to party. These include ideology, personal views and commitments on specific policies, and the interests of constituencies. By the time a president tries to exercise influence on a vote, most members of Congress have made up their minds on the basis of these other factors.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Political Capital Fails
ELI STOKOLS and LAUREN EGAN , 01-17-2023, (Eli Stokols is a White House correspondent and co-author of West Wing Playbook. He rejoined POLITICO in 2022 after nearly five years covering the White House for the Los Angeles Times. Prior to that, he covered the 2016 election at POLITICO. Lauren Egan is a White House reporter and co-author of West Wing Playbook. She previously worked as a White House reporter at NBC News, where she also covered the war in Ukraine and the 2020 presidential campaign.) "NH Dems put Biden on blast", https://www.politico.com/newsletters/west-wing-playbook/2023/01/17/nh-dems-put-biden-on-blast-00078179 lilw
The letter, like any missive between longtime friends, begins with pleasantries and a good amount of flattery. But the main message sent Tuesday afternoon by top New Hampshire Democrats to President JOE BIDEN is essentially, “what the hell are you thinking?” In 933 agonized words, some of Biden’s most steadfast supporters in the state plead with him to rethink his proposal to shuffle the 2024 primary calendar by putting South Carolina at the front of the line. Biden’s gambit could become a self-inflicted political wound, former New Hampshire Gov. JOHN LYNCH wrote in the email sent to chief of staff RON KLAIN and deputy chief of staff JEN O’MALLEY DILLON. “While we share your desire to elevate more diverse voices in the process, we believe that the proposed schedule could wreak havoc on Democrats up and down the ticket in New Hampshire and unnecessarily jeopardize four critical electoral votes in your re-election campaign,” reads the letter obtained by West Wing Playbook. Signed by more than 20 New Hampshire Democrats whose support of Biden stretches back in some cases to his first 1988 run for the White House — including JOHN BRODERICK JR., the former chief justice of the state’s supreme court, DNC member BILLY SHAHEEN and LOU D’ALLESANDRO, the dean of the state Senate – the communique lays out a number of issues with the proposed calendar change. Setting aside the fact it triggers an existential crisis in a state that wears its “First In The Nation” status like a toddler who won’t shed their Halloween costume until spring, the signatories also note that Biden’s plan requires the state legislature to allow Democrats to alter their primary calendar. That, they note, is highly unlikely given that the statehouse is controlled by Republicans who are “already capitalizing on” the notion Democrats don’t prize the state’s historic role on the nominating calendar. “We are especially concerned about how this will impact your re-election,” the letter states, noting that the state’s four electoral votes, as in the 2000 contest, could make the difference in a close election. “These four votes could be the deciding factor in 2024. Unfortunately, they could now be at risk.” Biden’s plan to reshuffle the primary order of states was announced after last November’s midterm election and quickly ratified by the DNC’s Rules and Bylaws Committee. Even with a consensus among Democrats to drop Iowa from its prized position as the first nominating contest after the debacle around the 2020 caucuses, many in the party were surprised when Biden proposed such dramatic changes. Beyond moving South Carolina up, the White House wants Georgia, another state with a GOP-controlled legislature, moved into the early window. Some Democratic operatives beyond the Granite State have wondered why Biden, who does not appear likely to face a serious primary, would spend serious political capital on the issue. Though Biden, with the move, signaled his appreciation to Black voters in South Carolina and his gratitude to Rep. JAMES CLYBURN (D-S.C.), whose endorsement helped him come from behind to capture the nomination in 2020, it’s not without cost. New Hampshire isn’t the only offended party. Labor leaders, likewise, have complained that South Carolina has one of the worst union records in the country.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Political Capital Fails
Ryan Telingator B.A. in Political Science and Government from Bowdoin University, May 20 2021, “When is Change Possible? Presidential Power as Shaped by Political Context, Constitutional Tools, and Legislative Skills”, https://digitalcommons.bowdoin.edu/honorsprojects/258/
My research does not support Greenstein’s theory. Instead, my findings align more closely with those of George Edwards in At the Margins, where he argues that the “national preoccupation with the chief executive is misplaced,” and that presidential power is, in fact, limited in the Constitution’s “purposefully inefficient system in which the founding fathers’ handiwork in decentralizing power defeats even the most capable leaders.”50 Instead of focusing on legislative skills as a source of presidential influence, Edwards argues that party support and public support are more important. Legislative skills are only critical for “members of Congress who remain open to change after other influences have had their impact.”51 In a time as polarized as today, where very few members of Congress are “open to chang[ing]” their vote, these skills play a minor role in legislative negotiations. Similar assertions are made in another book by Edwards, Predicting the Presidency. He argues that exploiting existing opportunities (consolidating existing party and public support) is much more important for presidential success than creating opportunities (convincing legislators to change their vote vis a vis legislative skills).52 Both Lyndon Johnson and Ronald Reagan are remembered for their exemplary political skills. The Johnson Treatment, a legislating strategy in which Johnson used his imposing 6’4”, 240-pound figure – literally physically and verbally bullying, cajoling, lobbying, and threatening – to get what he wanted out of people,53 remains infamous in presidential political literature. Similarly, Ronald Reagan, “The Great Communicator,” is still revered for his oratorial prestige. Although these legislative skills were useful in passing the pieces of legislation outlined in the case studies – Johnson gaining support from southern Democrats on the EOA and Reagan compellingly speaking in favor of the ERTA – they proved impotent in political contexts not conducive to change. After Vietnam for Johnson and after the passage of the ERTA for Reagan (in conjunction with the recession in 1982), the presidents’ policy windows closed. Their renowned legislative skills could not overcome an inopportune political context. The case studies thus demonstrate the value of skills at the margins, but also exemplify their unsubstantial influence as the major factor driving policy. Again, the research suggests that political context is the most important factor in legislative change. 5.4 Applying Lessons to the Present: Predicting Biden’s Success With an understanding that the political context largely drives a president’s potential for change, with skills helping on the margins, it is important to assess the 2021 political climate in order make an informed prediction about Biden’s prospects. The COVID-19 pandemic opened a significant policy window for Biden. With a U.S. death toll nearing 580,000, massive unemployment, and a severe economic contraction, the pandemic was an all-encompassing problem that the entire country wanted addressed. Thus, the three streams of problem, policy, and politics converged to open the opportunity for the Biden administration to pass the American Rescue Plan. The Rescue Plan was signed into law in March and has received bipartisan support from the American public.54 President Biden claimed a mandate from his election, arguing that “millions of Americans” “voted for [his] vision,” giving “a clear victory” and tasking him to make his “vision real.”55 However, based on the extreme polarization in D.C., it is unlikely to become a quantifiable mandate that changes Congressional voting behavior.56 Polarization has made it impossible to win cross-party support, or, in Edwardsian terms, create new opportunities. There is deep political antagonism between parties, and even within parties,57 making any sort of bipartisanship near impossible.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Political Capital Fails
Josh Marshall editor and publisher of Talking Points Memo 2021, , “Youngkin Defeats McAuliffe,” TPM, 11-2-2021, https://talkingpointsmemo.com/edblog/youngkin-defeats-mcaullife
For months Democrats have been demanding that Biden get tough with the two Senate hold-outs or simply make them fall into line. I sympathize. I’ve wanted to as well. But it’s not clear what power he has to accomplish that. Try harder isn’t a good answer to that question. People have the idea that Presidents can simply overawe legislators by being President. But that’s not really the case. They can do that when they have some tangible leverage. For Biden it’s not clear what that leverage is.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Political Capital Fails
Steve Chapman staff at the Post and Courier, 2022, "Chapman: Biden faces the limits of his presidential power," Post and Courier, 1/2/2022, https://www.postandcourier.com/opinion/commentary/chapman-biden-faces-the-limits-of-his-presidential-power/article_7def57a6-68e8-11ec-afbb-2f103b684005.html
The president of the United States is often referred to as the most powerful person in the world. That description must come as some consolation to Joe Biden, who in moments of despair can reflect that the second most powerful person in the world, whoever that may be, must have it worse. Biden is in the position of someone who wins a lottery only to find out that half of the payout comes in Confederate dollars. His term so far illustrates how little control the president has over the things that matter most to him, his party and the American people. He came into office amid a virulent pandemic and a battered economy, crises that would be his to solve. But despite his largely successful push for COVID-19 vaccinations and economic stimulus, the headlines lately consist almost entirely of bad news. Eight hundred thousand Americans have died from the coronavirus, and each day brings more deaths. A new variant of the virus is on the rampage. The economic downturn that Biden inherited has turned into a boom, but one accompanied by the highest rate of inflation in nearly 40 years. The president is blamed by most people for these unwanted developments, judging from his 52% disapproval rating. But he has only a puny capacity to address them. His predicament is a classic source of job stress: responsibility without authority. There are no obvious policy changes he could make that would swiftly curtail either infections or inflation. Not that Biden has much power to make policy changes, as Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., has reminded him. Manchin was potentially the decisive vote to pass the president’s huge Build Back Better package. But two weeks ago, he said he would oppose it, at least in its current form. With that, a large chunk of Biden’s domestic agenda appears to be sitting on a pile of tinder that is soaked in gasoline, ready to go up in smoke. His promises on climate change, family support, health care and affordable housing may amount to a litany of inaction. President Harry Truman could empathize. “I sit here all day trying to persuade people to do the things they ought to have sense enough to do without my persuading them,” he lamented. “That’s all the powers of the president amount to.” The plight he lamented is particularly pronounced for Biden, whose party has a slim majority in the House and the slimmest possible majority in the Senate — giving any Democratic senator a veto over almost any major legislation. The White House and progressives in Congress can denounce Manchin all they want, but he has no reason to fear them. The condemnations will only bolster his standing in a state where Biden got less than 30% of the vote. Much has been made of the bully pulpit enjoyed by the president. Biden is finding that to be overrated. He recently went on national TV and implored Americans to get vaccinated for their own health and as “a patriotic duty.” But a lot of people heed his pleas only as a guide to what not to do. When Truman won the 1948 election, he didn’t have to contend with an opponent who refused to accept the outcome and incited an attack on the U.S. Capitol. Biden has a burden unlike any of his predecessors: being seen as illegitimate by a significant share of the citizenry. A November poll by the Public Religion Research Institute found that 68% of Republicans suffer from the preposterous delusion that the 2020 election was stolen. Biden’s victory fostered a different delusion among Democrats: that they had the opportunity to take bold action to address serious problems. In fact, the 2020 election was a dismal showing for Democrats, who lost seats in the House of Representatives and lost ground in state legislatures. It was not a resounding mandate for change. It was an expression of Trump fatigue. There was the surprise of Democrats gaining control of the Senate thanks to victories in two Senate runoff races in Georgia last January. But with just 50 seats and a solid wall of Republican opposition, their control is flimsier than a cardboard canoe. So Biden and his party are doomed to spend the next year being stymied. He should enjoy it while he can. After that, his job could get really hard.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Winners win
Paul Kane 2021, Senior Congressional Correspondent and Columnist at the Washington Post, “Day-to-day, Biden’s Agenda Looks Rocky. But Congressional Democrats Say Things Are Far Rosier If You Take The Long View.”, Washington Post, 7/24/2021, https://www.washingtonpost.com/powerpost/biden-agenda-democrats-congress/2021/07/24/83b776be-ebc0-11eb-ba5d-55d3b5ffcaf1_story.html
There is, so far at least, little fear that Democrats are spreading themselves too thin by eschewing the traditional practice of focusing on a handful of domestic policy issues in the first two years of an administration. “Political momentum and political capital is like a muscle. The more you exercise it, the more of it you have. It is not like a finite resource that you can run out of if you spend too much of it. What happens is that if we do a lot of positive things, then we’ve got more political clout to do even more positive things,” Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) said.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Winners win
Phil Mattingly 2021, “Biden wanted to remind Democrats what it was like to win. Now he's aiming to capitalize on that momentum.,” CNN, 11-9-2021, https://www.cnn.com/2021/11/09/politics/joe-biden-infrastructure-bill-momentum/index.html
When President Joe Biden worked the phones for hours late into Friday night to push through his massive infrastructure bill, what he really wanted was to show Democrats what it felt like to win. After months of missed deadlines, simmering distrust and political fallout, White House officials now hope success can breed success. The victory came at a critical moment for a party and a President mired in months of internecine legislative warfare that had largely overshadowed the actual policies in question. Getting the $1.2 trillion package over the line is viewed by the White House and its Democratic allies as a moment where some trust -- however fragile -- has been established between the party's different factions, giving Democrats the chance to finally turn the corner. "It helps when you succeed on something and everybody sees and figures out what it feels like to win and get something done," a senior administration official said. "It creates momentum." "Momentum" is hardly a scientific concept, and there aren't any misconceptions inside the West Wing about the complicated high-wire act required in the weeks ahead to clinch the $2 trillion economic and climate package that makes up the second piece of Biden's domestic agenda, officials say. But the hours of frenzied Friday night negotiations, in close coordination with House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, led to something that has been missing throughout weeks of fits and starts, missed deadlines and delicate balancing act between moderates and progressives: An outcome. Biden is planning to capitalize on that victory by inviting scores of lawmakers to the White House for a formal signing ceremony next week, officials say. It's the type of event where eager members of Congress angle for a photo-op or signing pen -- something that has remained out of reach on Biden's central agenda items until now. In isolation, it doesn't resolve the existing policy divides facing Democrats on both sides of Pennsylvania Avenue on the second piece of Biden's agenda. But it does give lawmakers, who for months have clashed over the direction of the bills, something to celebrate -- and sell back home. "Now comes the hard part," one House Democrat told CNN early Saturday morning. It was a sentiment largely echoed by more than a dozen participants in the process throughout the weekend. But if the need to reconcile a series of policy thickets remains, there is a sense that the party dynamics may have, in fact, shifted in the frenzied final late-night hours that cleared the way to pass Biden's $1.2 trillion infrastructure proposal. "You see that whatever the things that are dividing you or separating you, it helps to clarify that actually we agree on a hell of a lot more," the official said. That process, arduous and painful as it may have been -- both politically and in terms of the caucus dynamics -- finally led to a breakthrough. Now that breakthrough needs to translate into action on the broader and more transformational economic and climate package. That's exactly what White House officials are banking on. "It ain't over yet as they say the old expression goes, but I feel good," Biden told reporters on Monday after an event celebrating the defending NBA Champion Milwaukee Bucks. "I think people have realized, are beginning to realize it's important to get it done." Biden draws a line in the sand The agreement drove the players leading those clashes together to reach a deal, culminating in a massive piece of legislation passing the House. In a party driven -- in the words of one House Democrat -- "not by mistrust, but by no trust," it was an important development. It also came at a critical moment for Biden, with his poll numbers sitting at their lowest point of his first year in office and just days after Democrats emerged from an election night that saw their nominee for governor in Virginia -- a state Biden won by 10 points just one year ago -- lose. "I think the one message that came across was: Get something done," Biden told reporters of the role in the Virginia governor's race in the outcome. "It's time to get something done. " Biden, who for weeks took quiet criticism from House Democrats for not publicly drawing a harder line on what he wanted, pivoted hard to do exactly that during those final hours -- something Pelosi explicitly called for, people involved told CNN. But reaching that point was a progression, officials said, developed over months of negotiations, private conversations, blown deadlines, intraparty recriminations and -- in some cases -- what many Democrats viewed as missed opportunities. It was, for better or worse, all part of the process for a new administration and congressional Democrats adjusting to full control in Washington for the first time in decade. "It's getting to know a lot of these people, to build trust," Biden told reporters the day after the bill passed. "Because everything I say I'm going to try to do, I will try to do. And I think that's also part of the process." A Senate veteran learns more about the House Biden's point is a window into the last several months, where a 36-year veteran of the Senate -- who often makes clear in private settings his view that he has an innate sense for Capitol Hill -- faced his own learning curve, particularly in the House. The party dynamics have shifted, with progressives carrying not just a voice, but the votes to dictate what will or won't advance. Many came to office in the four years after Biden left Washington. Even more had never served in the majority with a Democratic president. Exacerbating it all were the barest of majorities in the House and Senate, making Biden's ambitious policy agenda -- which progressives overwhelmingly supported -- even more complicated to advance. Biden has sought to reintroduce himself to the dynamics by hosting scores of lawmakers in the Oval Office, crowding lawmakers onto couches and hearing them out over the course of dozens of meetings since taking office. While each meeting usually has an officially stated purpose, they have served more generally as get-to-know-you sessions, during which Biden is able to gain greater insight into each member's particular needs. For many, it is their first visit to the White House; Biden's predecessor Donald Trump did not habitually invite Democrats to meet with him. They often leave with White House-baked chocolate chip cookies or, more recently, specially commissioned ice cream bars bearing Biden's presidential seal. A lightning-fast, at least by congressional standards, win on Biden's $1.9 trillion Covid-19 relief proposal in his first few months in office was -- to a degree -- misleading. The urgency mattered, with the country still mired in the worst of the pandemic. Democrats were exceedingly careful not to undercut their new president -- or their new Senate majority. The path on his $3 trillion, dual-pronged domestic agenda has been significantly less seamless. Even for the self-professed "congenital optimist" in the Oval Office, navigating the divides has proved frustrating in recent weeks as his negotiators and Democratic leaders sought to thread the needle through compromises and self-imposed deadlines, to no avail. "We have to develop the will, and develop the will means putting aside personal agenda," Rep. Jim Clyburn, the House Democratic whip form South Carolina and a close Biden ally, said on "Fox News Sunday." "That to me has been a problem for us." It also takes a recognition that any single member can create a new problem to resolve. Those problems appeared to perpetually win the day -- until late Friday night. "This, in terms of degree of difficulty is very, very high," the official said. "Which makes succeeding all the more satisfying and fulfilling." Working the phones Still, the plans for that victory were quickly thrown off track Friday morning by a small group of House moderates who refused to move forward without a full Congressional Budget Office accounting of whether the second package would be financed. With that off the table for at least a week and maybe longer, Pelosi shifted course. The decision to move the infrastructure bill without the second proposal, pitched by members of the Congressional Black Caucus and moved on by Pelosi, initially ran into the same progressive roadblock that had sidetracked the prior two deadlines. But unlike those moments -- when Biden was regularly on the phone with members but cautious not to corner or jam any member -- the President went all in to find a path forward, according to people familiar with the calls. He and his team worked in close coordination with Pelosi on who to call and what to float as potential options to reconcile the differences. The two spoke by phone four times, with Pelosi giving Biden names of lawmakers to call and working closely with his top negotiators as they worked through the process of laying the groundwork to move forward. Biden made calls to moderate members. He made calls to progressive members. He talked to most of Pelosi's leadership team over the course of the day. It wasn't immediately effective. Biden was explicitly told "no" in a call with at least one progressive -- Rep. Pramila Jayapl, the chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus -- sources said. Jayapal initially rejected the effort publicly as well. In a conference call with dozens of progressives, there was palpable frustration on Biden's part when the reticence to move forward on infrastructure without the second proposal was made clear, according to participants. An official acknowledged that some of the conversations "were a little bumpy" and not everyone was on board at the beginning. But the decision was made to continue to press forward. The result -- after hours of calls, negotiations, an official statement from Biden -- was progressive and moderate leaders coming together to craft statements committing to move forward on the economic and climate package once the CBO score was in hand.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Link Turn – UBI Popular
Gaby Galvin Published Sept. 8, 2022 Basic income pilots gain momentum across US cities https://www.smartcitiesdive.com/news/basic-income-pilots-cities-direct-cash-payments/631426/
At least a dozen U.S. cities have launched basic income pilot programs in recent months, representing a major jump over the past year. To date, that offer residents direct cash payments with no strings attached have launched in North America, according to the Stanford Basic Income Lab, which tracks such pilots. That number will soon grow as researchers say more cities are set to launch their own programs. The pilots span the United States: , Texas; , Illinois; Michigan; ; , Kentucky; and , among others. Advocates and researchers said drivers of the increased local momentum this year include federal funding for cities through the American Rescue Plan Act, pandemic-era cash support such as stimulus checks (which may represent a tipping point in favor of such programs in the ) and a growing focus on racial and wealth inequities since 2020.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Link Turn – UBI Popular
Hilary Hoynes and Jesse Rothstein Goldman School of Public Policy, University of California,Berkeley,California94720,USA; email:hoynes@berkeley.edu,rothstein@berkeley.edu Annual Review of Economics Universal Basic Income in the United States and Advanced Countries 2019 https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-economics080218-030237
Universal basic income (UBI) proposals are getting a lot of attention in high-income countries. A wide range of proponents, from Charles Murray, a political scientist and scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, to Andy Stern, former president of the Service Employees International Union, have backed the idea. We count six recent, high-profile trade books—including those by Murray and Stern—arguing for various forms of UBI as solutions to the problems faced by first-world economies (Murray2016,Stern2016,VanParijs&Vanderborght2017,Hughes2018, Lowrey2018,Yang2018). Using a metric of mentions in New York Times articles, “universal basic income” appears 30 times in 2017 and nearly as many in the first six months of2018.The term never appeared before 2014; even the more expansive search term of “basic income” averaged only two uses per year from 1945 to 2014(Figure1).
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Link Turn – UBI Popular
Former Contributor August 31 2017 Top Economists Endorse Universal Basic Income https://www.forbes.com/sites/francescoppola/2017/08/31/top-economists-endorse-universal-basic-income/?sh=24b2bffc15ae
The idea of a universal basic income is becoming increasingly popular. Five years ago, it was definitely confined to the weird fringe. But now, it is attracting interest across the political spectrum. Silicon Valley entrepreneurs, concerned about the impact of technology on traditional models of employment, are and . Governments its potential to replace part of their increasingly complex, expensive and inefficient welfare systems. And now it has been endorsed by winners of the Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel, commonly referred to as the “economics Nobel prize”. The economists were participating in the 6th Lindau meeting on economic sciences, which ran from 22nd to 26th of June this year in the picturesque town of Lindau, Germany. Speaking in a on the garden island of Mainau, Sir Chris Pissarides advocated universal basic income as a solution to the inequality that arises from both globalisation and the rise of robots and AI. We should not try to deal with inequality by stopping these global processes, because these have the capacity to bring more prosperity to the world,” he said. “We should welcome expansion of trade and the opening up of India and Africa, and improve R&D to bring robotics into production. After all, if there aren’t enough jobs for us all to do, we can take more leisure. We are ageing, so we can feel comfortable that machines will do more of the work that human beings currently do.”
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Link Turn – UBI Popular
CLIFTON B. PARKER AUGUST 8, 2018 Stanford scholar explores pros, cons of ‘basic income’ https://news.stanford.edu/2018/08/08/stanford-scholar-explores-pros-cons-basic-income/
Given the flux of American politics right now, an idea like “universal basic income” could gain political traction, a Stanford historian says. Stanford scholar , a research fellow at the and an associate professor of history in the Stanford School of Humanities and Sciences, says such a program could help protect workers who hit rock bottom in an age of technological disruption. A basic income – also called basic income guarantee, universal basic income or basic living stipend – is a program in which citizens of a country receive a regular sum of money from the government. Tech leaders Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg have floated the idea, and the city of Chicago is considering such a proposal as a way to reduce the disruptions of automation in the workforce. Burns researches and writes about 20th-century American intellectual, political, and cultural history and is currently writing a book about the economist , who supported the idea of a universal income. What would be the benefits of a universal basic income if it were to become a reality? The most attractive aspect of universal basic income, or UBI, is that it can serve to underwrite market participation, in contrast to other welfare programs that essentially require people to not be employed to receive the benefit. Some programs even require participants to have essentially zero assets in order to qualify. In effect, the programs kick in when people have hit rock bottom, rather than trying to prevent them from getting there in the first place.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Won’t Pass
Emma Dumain | 03/08/2023 06:33 AM EST Senate chatter grows louder on carbon tariff https://www.eenews.net/articles/senate-chatter-grows-louder-on-carbon-tariff/
Sen. Mitt Romney (R-Utah), at a recent committee hearing, noted, “We do a lot of things that make us feel good about ourselves but will have almost no impact on global emissions. If we want to do something serious about global emissions, we need to put a price on carbon.” For many years, climate hawks were preoccupied with the government setting a price for greenhouse gas emissions to encourage emitters to pursue alternative, more environmentally friendly means of energy production. Democrats at one point discussed putting a carbon tax in the Inflation Reduction Act as a revenue-raiser but dropped it amid concerns it could disproportionately affect lower-income households. Many Republicans, however, are inclined to balk at any new tax, period. Now, lawmakers are more focused on getting agreement on a carbon border adjustment mechanism, or CBAM, which is tantamount to environmental trade policy that would slap a fee — or tariff — on imported goods based on their carbon content as a means of incentivizing decarbonization broadly. It’s far from certain the current chatter will lead to a bill that can actually become law in the 118th Congress, where partisan divisions in a presidential election cycle will make legislating exceedingly difficult. But lawmakers and advocates say there’s an opportunity at the very least to build momentum now around an issue that has been the subject of debate for years, thanks not just to a growing recognition of mounting climate challenges but increased anxiety about China’s rising power and influence.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Won’t Pass
---sidebar – Import tariffs are distinct from border taxes. Tariffs
Import taxes are “any fiscal measures which put into effect, in whole or in part, the destination principle (i.e. which enable exported products to be relieved of some or all of the tax charged in the exporting country in respect of similar domestic products sold to consumers on the home market and which enable imported products sold to consumers to be charged with some or all of the tax charged in the importing country in respect of similar domestic products).”
Contributor March 16 2023 Don’t Be Fooled: The Carbon-Import Tax Is Just A Tariff //AshAN
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Won’t Pass
Emma Dumain | 05/10/2023 06:09 AM EDT Senators eye ‘CHIPS 2.0’ as vehicle for carbon tariff https://www.eenews.net/articles/senators-eye-chips-2-0-as-vehicle-for-carbon-tariff/
Lawmakers would also have to resolve significant disagreement over whether putting a domestic price on carbon is necessary for achieving a CBAM that deals with international behavior surrounding emissions. Some advocates say a domestic carbon fee is a necessary step to ensure a CBAM’s enforceability by the World Trade Organization. Others, including Coons, are currently willing to risk running afoul of the WTO by leaving that component out of their proposals to make their ideas more politically palatable. Getting consensus on CBAM legislation, meanwhile, would also have to happen on an entirely separate track as getting consensus on the broader “CHIPS 2.0” package. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) only threw support behind the idea last week alongside the chairs of several relevant committees and subcommittees. Hearings and markups in several Senate committees are likely. In a sign of just how much work lawmakers have to do to write this bill and get it ready for primetime, many Senate Republicans the day of the press conference said they had not yet been alerted to their Democratic counterparts’ plans. On Tuesday evening, Cramer told E&E News he was still unfamiliar with the burgeoning effort, though he was open to the idea. “A CBAM is obviously a trade tool designed to unite allies and freeze out adversaries — or in this case polluters who happen to be adversaries, so it’s certainly a plausible vehicle that can carry it.” There’s also no guarantee Republicans, once brought into the process, will actually back the finished product. Cramer, for instance, was among the 33 Republicans who didn’t vote for the first CHIPS and Science Act last year.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › Affirmative Answers › Won’t Pass
Emma Dumain | 03/08/2023 06:33 AM EST Senate chatter grows louder on carbon tariff https://www.eenews.net/articles/senate-chatter-grows-louder-on-carbon-tariff/
Conservative climate adviser George David Banks agreed that lawmakers are well positioned now to set up a bill this Congress that would “help the U.S. come up with its own math” for how much embodied carbon is in any given product on which a tariff would be levied. “I don’t think we can allow the Europeans to do that for us,” Banks — a former climate official for President Donald Trump and a chief strategist for Republicans on the now-disbanded House Select Committee on the Climate Crisis — said of the reason he sees an opening for action. There remains, however, significant disagreement over whether putting a domestic price on carbon is necessary for achieving a CBAM that deals with international behavior surrounding emissions and would ensure its enforceability by the World Trade Organization. Whitehouse’s previous proposal would slap a fee on U.S. industrial facilities for emissions that exceed the average for their industry. The Coons proposal would not address a domestic price. Cassidy’s framework is not likely to touch it, and Cramer late last year penned an for The Wall Street Journal where he said that “establishing a carbon price isn’t necessary for reducing emissions, and it isn’t feasible on this side of the Atlantic.” A failure to reach a consensus on this question alone could sink progress in this Congress.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › A2 PC Not Key
Katherine Tully-Mcmanus, 23, (Katherine Tully-Mcmanus, Katherine Tully-McManus is the author of the Huddle newsletter and a congressional reporter.
Before joining POLITICO in July 2021, Katherine spent close to a decade covering Congress at CQ Roll Call, starting as an intern covering committee markups. She got hooked on finding often-overlooked stories about Congress as an institution, operations and life in the Capitol complex. Katherine brought her obsessions with how Congress funds itself, the congressional workplace, Capitol security and oddities of the Legislative Branch to the Huddle newsletter., 1-13-2023, POLITICO, Shutdown stress simmers early, https://www.politico.com/newsletters/huddle/2023/01/13/shutdown-stress-simmers-early-00077839, 1-28-2023) SCade
With a divided government on Capitol Hill – and Republicans’ narrow majority in the House – there have been practical doubts about what Congress could actually accomplish this session beyond the very basics of governing. But even the most fundamental constitutional task for Congress, funding the government, is in peril. And it’s in the laps of Sens. Patty Murray (D-Wash.) and Susan Collins (R-Maine) in the Senate and ranking member Rosa DeLauro (D-Conn.) and new House Appropriations Chair Kay Granger (R-Texas) in the House. The White House and Democratic-controlled Senate will never accept the $130 billion in spending cuts House Republicans are pledging. The backup plan will also make lawmakers balk: a short term continuing resolution that includes a trigger for spending cuts as incentive for finishing comprehensive spending bills. Current government funding doesn’t run out until the end of September, but lawmakers are already sweating the rough road ahead. McCarthy’s promises: Speaker Kevin McCarthy (R-Calif.) has made big promises on spending, including capping the next fiscal year at the spending levels from before the $1.7 trillion government funding package that passed in December. Republican appropriators are singing a different tune. GOP Rep. Steve Womack of Arkansas called the closed door handshake deal on slashing funding “simply a non-swimmer.” Put on your life jackets, folks. “I think we’ll come to the realization that the ‘22 number was rolled off the tongue pretty well, but it’s a lift that we’re not going to be able to make,” Womack told Caitlin and Connor O’Brien this week. Compounding challenges include the House Republican commitment to move each of the 12 spending bills separately and to open each to an unlimited number and scope of amendments. (Open rules and unlimited amendments have been around in recent history, but it has been decades since the spending bills moved one-by-one.) Blast from the past: Former Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) weighed in last night on CNN, saying he thought he had too much power as speaker. “Look, the thing that bothered me the most were these omnibuses…a bill that thick, that four people ultimately decide on,” Ryan said Thursday. The top Democrat on the House spending panel, DeLauro, says they are “up to the job,” and that she is “optimistic” for avoiding any kind of government shutdown. “You know what they say, women need a seat at the table. We are the table,” DeLauro said. The dang debt limit: Before the government funding showdown really comes to a head, there’s a bigger fight that could siphon a lot of time, energy and political capital away from spending. That’s the debt limit, which is expected to top out this summer. Republicans say they want spending cuts to reign in the debt before they back a debt limit hike, but that’s not the order the challenges will come to the Hill. If you’re already having sequestration stress dreams, you are not alone.
2023
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Carbon Border Tax DA › 1NC › A2: Winners Win
Daniel Drezner 2021 professor of international politics at the Fletcher March 30, 2021. “Biden’s brand of bipartisanship”. Washington Post.
The paradox for Biden is that the more successful he is at addressing the pandemic and the economy, the more difficulty he could encounter in building bipartisan coalitions to address other problems. Political Science 101 would suggest that if Biden gets credit for ending the pandemic and restoring a strong economy, that popularity should translate into greater political capital for other problems in the queue. Political Science 301 offers a cautionary warning: Solved problems fade from view. Biden is appropriately addressing the issues voters care about. But if the pandemic and the economy evolve as expected, voters will quickly bank those successes and focus on thornier problems — like immigration.