2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Economy DAs
Schulz 2017 - Board of Directors of the United Nations Research Institute for Social Development [Patricia, Jan 31, Global Social Policy “Universal basic income in a feminist perspective and gender analysis” UP]
Feminist economists have for decades criticized mainstream economic theory for considering only remunerated work in the so-called production sector, and gross domestic product (GDP) still considers only this sector. Change occurs, there are now numerous publications and data in economic and social sciences addressing unpaid, care work and its relation to the various disadvantages women face. But even with this new approach and the almost general recognition that gender equality is key to economic development, care work remains mainly female. Even though satellite accounts give information on the value of reproductive work, it is still either not really considered as work if provided for free in the private sphere or, if it is provided against pay, in a work relationship, it is often poorly paid and considered. Reproductive work, mainly accomplished by women the world over, for free or very little money, thus remains steadfastly insufficiently addressed in practice in the labour market and legislation, as well as the homes of people.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Free Riding
Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, TA]
FREE-RIDING AND THE HOUSEHOLD The debates about basic income also center on the figure of a man in—or avoiding—paid employment. This is very clear in one of the major criticisms of, and apprehensions about, the idea of a basic income; that is, that it would encourage free-riding and idleness. Free-riders breach the principle of reciprocity by obtaining the fruits of the efforts of others and contributing nothing themselves in return; a basic income, it is charged, would “inspire a segment of the able population . . . to abjure work for a life of idle fun.”26 But who is being seen as so prone to idleness and fun? The assumption guiding the discussion of basic income is that the problem is about men and employment.27 A much greater problem about male free-riding to which a basic income is directly relevant, but a problem about the household, not employment, is therefore ignored. Van Parijs appears to be an exception to the prevailing view of free-riding. Unlike most other participants in discussions of basic income he has noticed that free-riding exists “on a massive scale” in household interactions.28 But who are the free-riders in the household? Barry notes that full-time housewives can be seen as free-riders.29 But they can only be seen in that way if “work” is taken to mean paid employment.30 As feminist scholars have emphasized for a very long time, housewives are working (unpaid) by undertaking the necessary caring work. Given the major contribution they already make for no monetary return at 98 POLITICS & SOCIETY all, wives (women) are hardly likely to be the target of the objection that a basic income would lead to idleness and fun. The majority of wives are now in some form of paid employment, but their labor force participation is usually different from that of men. This reflects the legacy of a wage-system that enshrined the belief that husbands (men) not wives (women) are “breadwinners.”31 Many more women than men work part-time, and women earn less than men. The private and public sexual division of labor, that is to say, continues to be structured so that men monopolize full-time, higher paying, and more prestigious paid employment, and wives do a disproportionate share of unpaid work in the home. Given the structure of institutions and social beliefs, this appears as a “rational” arrangement. The mutual reinforcement of marriage and employment explains why husbands can take advantage of the unpaid work of wives and avoid doing their fair share of the caring work. That is why there is massive free-riding in the household—by husbands. Neither free-riding by husbands nor its scale is usually acknowledged in discussions of basic income and stakeholding. This is because marriage and the household rarely enter the argument. The narrow parameters of discussion and the influence of the assumptions of neo-classical economics preclude attention to institutional structures and their interrelationships. Van Parijs is an exception in recognizing that a problem of free-riding exists in households, but his neoclassical theoretical apparatus leaves him unable to acknowledge that the problem is one of men (husbands) and the work of caring for household members. His argument is that free-riding arises merely because of differences in individual tastes or preferences. Free-riding, Van Parijs states, occurs when benefits enjoyed by both partners in a household are produced by only one of them, the partner who happens to care most about the particular benefit. His example is that the partner who most strongly prefers tidiness will make sure that the home is tidy.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Free Riding
Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, TA]
Similarly, Van Parijs argues that while “a defensible long-term vision” of an unconditional basic income at the highest sustainable level is vital, nevertheless more limited and politically feasible proposals are also essential. He states that a household-based guaranteed minimum income “would definitely be a major change in the right direction”37—but the right direction according to which reasons? Household-based schemes disregard not only all the problems about the sexual division of labor, and the fact that women earn less than men, but also income distribution within households. Can it be confidently assumed that income would be distributed equally between husband and wife? A basic income is important for feminism and democratization precisely because it is paid not to households but individuals as citizens. A focus on individuals does not imply resort to the atomistic individualism of neo-classical economics. The problem of women’s self-government and full standing as citizens is visible only when individuals are conceptualized within the context of social relations and institutions. A household-based basic income allows the problem of marriage, employment, and citizenship to be avoided since wives (women) disappear into the category of “the family” or “household.” To treat a basic income as a payment to households rather than individuals ignores the question of who performs the work of caring for household members. That is, it is tacitly assumed that reciprocity exists and that free-riding is only a problem about men avoiding employment. This assumption is nicely illustrated by the picture of a male surfer on the cover of Real Freedom for All. In academic discussions the surfer is used to represent non-contributors. But in the popular political imagination and the media other symbols of free-riding are present, such as the African American “welfare queen” or, more recently, the “illegal immigrant” or the “asylum seeker.”38 The figure of the surfer not only obscures the problem for democratization of popular attitudes embodied in these other symbols but also obliterates the systematic avoidance of one form of contribution, the vital caring work, by men who are in employment. Nor do the numerous suggestions for conditions to be placed on payment of a basic income as a solution to free-riding—Atkinson’s “participation income” is a well-known example39—get to grips with free-riding by men in the household. While the notion of a “contribution” may be broadened to include, for example, the work of caring for others, as in Atkinson’s proposal, this is insufficient to focus attention on the structural problem of the connections between marriage, employment, and free-riding by husbands. While payment of a basic income to a husband for his “contribution” through employment and to his wife for her “contribution” in the home is to recognize that she does indeed make a socially valuable contribution, this does little to calm the fears of some feminists that a basic income will merely reinforce women’s lesser standing and the idleness of husbands in the household.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Women’s Movements
Whaley, 2016 - Senior director for Wisconsin Public Radio [KP Jan 12, “A Feminist Case For A Universal Basic Income” EV]
Judith Shulevitz believes it's time for the feminist movement to get behind an idea that's taking root in Northern European countries: the universal basic income. Also known as UBI, the idea is that the national government should pay a stipend to all residents of the country, no strings attached. In Finland, authorities a UBI that would involve paying $869 every month to every citizen, tax-free. The income would replace all other benefit payments and would be paid to all adults, regardless of any other income they might be earning. Shulevitz, who writes about feminism, culture and science for The New York Times, that a UBI is a way to reimburse caregivers who are mostly women for their unrecognized and largely unpaid work. She said there is a perception that stay-at-home moms are free-riders who live off their husbands, or businesses that offer paid maternity leave. That perception, she said, can make women feel secondary. "I argue it should be looked at it the other way — that society free-rides on women’s unpaid labor," said Shulevitz. "It essentially extracts this labor and turns it into value, called the next generation of workers." She said second-wave feminism was focused on getting women out of the home and into the workforce, something she believes was an incredibly noble and laudable goal. However, it didn’t take into consideration the problem of child care. "It’s one of the things universal basic income corrects. It’s an indirect correction, and I make some argument about why we need the indirect correction rather than the direct correction," Shulevitz said. According to her, the U.S. has some of the most backward policies on maternity leave in the world, and certainly the worst among developed countries. Many liberal northern European countries provide up to a year of paid maternity leave, as well as paternity leave. "We just overlook a lot of working women and their need to stay home with their infants, which every study shows is good for the infant and is good for their development for the rest of their lives," said Shulevitz. At the end of the day, she said, women and men should be able to make the choice to simply stay home and take care of their children and get not only respect, but also remuneration for doing so.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Single Mothers
Zelleke, 2011 - The New School for General Studies, New York [Almaz, Policy & Politics vol 39 no 1, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]
None of these changes would guarantee on their own that men would scale back time spent in paid employment, or that if they did they would increase their time spent in care work. But they would decrease the costs to men of doing so, and would increase their opportunities to break out of the gendered distribution that confines men to paid employment-centric models of contributory citizenship just as women are constrained in other ways (Roebyns, 2000, 2001). An unconditional basic income and the reduction of the dependency of the caregiving partner on the employed partner for income, benefits and status should encourage both men and women to combine both roles either simultaneously or in turn. Finally, while an unconditional basic income and the associated institutional changes a feminist theory of distributive justice implies would increase the bargaining power of women vis-à-vis men over determining the distribution of labour within any particular family, the gains for women in traditional male–female partnerships are not accomplished at the expense of the exclusion of single parents from any benefits or the exploitation of the low-income women who carry the burden of care work when more affluent women work in paid employment.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Foreign Examples
Kangas et al, 2023- a Research Director at the Department of Social Research at the University of Turku in Finland [Olli, with Minna Ylikännö "Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 20, no. 3, ProQuest, https://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/basic-income-status-women-established-gender/docview/2774904198/se-2, doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20031733. EO/EP]
Each welfare state is a unique institutional entity with its own historical and political background and, consequently, its own institutional context. Thus, we can assume that expected beneficial or detrimental gendered outcomes are different between a country with low gender equality and an established gender-equal welfare state, such as Finland. The institutional context is important, and institutions travel badly. Therefore, the results of the experiments are not directly transferable to other countries. However, we, too, end up with a few universalising comments or, if you like, lessons from the Finnish UBI experiment. In all societies, minimum income protection, either UBI or Finnish residence-based universal basic security, is a necessary condition for fulfilling the grand goals advocated by the protagonists of the basic income concept. However, this is not a sufficient condition to achieve these goals. In addition, we need an amplitude of family policy measures, such as available and affordable childcare, and we need well-functioning healthcare, education, and employment services to support people and societies in their path towards gender equality. Hence, gender equality cannot be achieved by a single social policy measure. The achievement of more equal societies requires several measures that consistently seek to promote that value. A decent level of money is a necessary but insufficient condition for empowering people. As Koslowski and Duvander [39] outline, ‘Money, a floor to stand on, surely helps [to procure freedom], but it will not alone be likely to challenge norms, for example, around parenting practices’. When we want people to change their behaviour to meet shared societal norms, we need different policies that are sufficiently effective to change the practices that produce gender inequality. 4.2. Limitations of the Study and Future Research The strength of the Finnish UBI experiment was that it was a large-scale, randomised and obligatory field experiment with a treatment and a control group. At the beginning of the experiment, those two groups were identical. There are limitations, too. The experiment lasted only two years which is too short of a period for people to make long-term decisions. There are obvious strengths in randomised field experiments. The flip side of such experimental designs is that we cannot analyse possible saturation/community effects, i.e., what would happen if everybody in the community received basic income [3,20,51,52]. The target group in the Finnish experiment was unemployed. Therefore, we cannot estimate substitution effects, that is, the extent to which men and women would decrease their labour supply if they received UBI. However, the results on the impact of childcare allowance on employment indicate that UBI would possibly produce gender-biased substitution effects. The utilisation of cash-for-care schemes in childcare provides arguments against UBI’s potential to enhance gender equality in the labour market. There is strong evidence that the cash-for-care home care allowance typically used in Finnish families with small children reduces female employment in both the short and long term ([41,42], see also [53]). Whereas on the basis of our data, we can only draw indicative conclusions about the positive impacts that UBI may have on empowerment and capability formation in an ‘established gender-equal welfare state’, we cannot estimate possible negative impacts upon labour supply or any other substitution effects UBI might cause. The Finnish UBI experiment produced results that apply to the Finnish context or contexts similar to the Finnish one. It is important to carry out basic income experiments in different surroundings: In developing economies (e.g., the Kenya experiment), where any social benefit introduced will eventually lead to better income, higher social security and well-being, and in more prosperous economies with developed and more comprehensive social security systems (e.g., in the U.S., Germany, Catalonia). Comparison of results from different experiments and experimental designs would yield more reliable knowledge on the possible positive and negative effects of UBI.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Foreign Examples
Kangas and Ylikanno 2023 - Research Director, Department of Social Research, University of Turku and senior specialist at the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment [Olli and Minna, January 23, 2023, “Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9914593/ UP}
On the basis of our findings, we argue that the previous academic discussion revolving around UBI is too universalising and does not pay sufficient attention to national contexts. Theoretical reasoning has been universalised in two ways. First, it has often been based on philosophical argumentation without links to any specific social context or welfare state. Second, if it has some links to existing welfare state models, it most often has been Anglo-American, that is, the liberal welfare state [50], which has formed an institutional context wherein the would-be UBI is submersed (however, see [9,21,22,43]). Nevertheless, the results have been, almost without exception, interpreted to apply universally to all welfare states. Each welfare state is a unique institutional entity with its own historical and political background and, consequently, its own institutional context. Thus, we can assume that expected beneficial or detrimental gendered outcomes are different between a country with low gender equality and an established gender-equal welfare state, such as Finland. The institutional context is important, and institutions travel badly. Therefore, the results of the experiments are not directly transferable to other countries.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Excludes Immigrants or Felons
Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]
The design features necessary for a feminist universal basic income Debates remain largely hypothetical given that there are so few full-fledged UBI schemes, and because where they do exist they are usually not evaluated for gender impacts. It is clear that the extent to which UBI’s potential for reducing gender and other inequalities will be realized depends critically on its specific design features, including the level of benefit provided, its financing mechanism and its interaction with existing tax and social security systems. Without parallel investments in quality public services and strengthened support for workers’ rights, UBI could have detrimental effects for gender equality and social justice. However, well-designed UBI that is integrated into a comprehensive system of social protection, public services and labour market regulations could strengthen women’s and transgender and gender diverse people’s income security, lower poverty rates and go some way to redressing inequalities in wealth and income. This will be perceived by many as a high standard to live up to, and any UBI will have to be rolled out carefully and progressively. Extending the reach of existing social protection schemes aimed at particular groups—such as social pensions and child and disability benefits—and ensuring that these are unconditional and universally available could be an important steppingstone towards achieving universal income security for all. The main recommendations for States considering UBI are as follows: • Follow a rights-based approach to social protection when designing UBI schemes. This includes following the principles of progressive realization and non-retrogression to safeguard against the rollback of existing social security and labour protections. Like all other social protection schemes, UBI should be anchored in national legal frameworks. • Ensure that UBI is accompanied by parallel investments in quality public services, including care services, health care, education, housing and food security, and with attention to the rights of women and transgender and gender-diverse people working within these sectors. • Develop sustainable and redistributive financing mechanisms for UBI. The cost estimates for UBI at national poverty level are substantial, and fiscal trade-offs are likely to arise, especially for low-income and highly indebted countries, with implications for gender and other inequalities. These should be assessed and discussed in a transparent, participatory manner during the design phase. • Ensure that UBI schemes address the needs of groups facing multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination. UBI implementation should be inclusive of incarcerated, migrant, LGBTIQ+ and unhoused individuals, and should be embedded in a broader system of support that addresses the additional needs of people with disabilities, pregnant people and the elderly. • Design UBI through national dialogue involving government, civil society, social partners and community representatives to discuss potential benefits and trade-offs and build societal consensus on the form of the UBI and its integration into broader social protection systems. • Close current gaps in evidence by strengthening monitoring and evaluation of UBI and other cash transfer schemes from a gender perspective, including analysing their impact on groups of women and transgender and genderdiverse people experiencing different intersecting forms of discrimination.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT UBI doesn’t increase Job Opportunities for Women
Kangas et al, 2023- a Research Director at the Department of Social Research at the University of Turku in Finland [Olli, with Minna Ylikännö "Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 20, no. 3, ProQuest, https://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/basic-income-status-women-established-gender/docview/2774904198/se-2, doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20031733. EO]
To summarise our results thus far, UBI did not have a significant effect on employment in the Finnish UBI experiment, but it significantly increased confidence in re-employment and, in that sense, empowered the receivers of UBI. Gender and the interaction between gender and treatment do not appear to be statistically significant explanatory factors in either Model 1 or 2. Thus, according to our results, UBI does not have different effects on women and men in an established gender-equal welfare state such as in Finland. 3.2. Self-Confidence as a Proxy for Empowerment As shown in Table 2, the differences in opinions on all three aspects of confidence between the treatment and control groups are statistically significant. For all the respondents, the highest level of confidence is found in coping with difficult life situations: 67% of the respondents in the treatment group and 58% in the control group answered that they had high, that is, good or very good, confidence in coping with difficult life situations. The lowest level of confidence was found in economic situations. In the treatment group, 44% had high or very high confidence, whereas the corresponding proportion in the control group was lower (33%). The low shares in both groups indicate that the level of the Finnish flat-rate unemployment benefits is too low, and hence, the level of UBI in the Finnish experiment, being set to the level of basic-level unemployment benefits, was too low to satisfy everyday financial needs. However, the higher level of confidence in one’s economic situation in the treatment group indicates that an unconditionally paid social benefit reduces the financial stress caused by low household income [49]. On the one hand, comparing the opinions of women in the treatment and control groups, we find that in all three confidence-based aspects, those in the treatment group reported significantly higher levels of confidence (χ2 Sig. = 0.003 for economy; 0.002 for future; and 0.005 for coping) than those in the control group. For men, the corresponding significances were 0.000, 0.042, and 0.207. On the other hand, when we compared men and women in the treatment group, we did not observe significant gender differences (see Table 2). UBI possibly increases confidence and furthers empowerment, although its effects are gender-neutral.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Statistical Discrimination
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
One could argue that if statistical discrimination increases efficiency, this efficiency gain can be used for the worse off, for example women. If one follows this argument, statistical discrimination should not per definition be morally condemned However, I strongly oppose to this argument. First, the little empirical re-search on discrimination that contains detailed and direct information on produc-tivity (e.g. Wenneras/Wold 1997) shows that even when a woman is two times as productive as a man, employers might prefer to offer a job to him instead of her. I would therefore argue that the best assumption to start from is that sta-tistical discrimination lowers aggregate productivity and efficiency. Nevertheless, this efficiency suboptimality can sustain because of three elements. First, it is rational for employers who have no information on individual productivity to use groups-based proxies. Second, perception biases (which can be formed by sexist, racist or other believes) can lead to a misfit between the observed proxies and real productivity. And finally, I see no reason why other considerations next to produc-tivity (like a preference for employee homogeneity or preferences for certain types of people) would not interfere with the profit maximising strategies of employers hiring people. Furthermore, even if statistical discrimination would lead to efficiency gains, it should still be condemned on moral grounds. It violates the basic principle of equal concern and respect for all individuals. Therefore, I think it is a real challenge for theorists of justice, including basic income proposers, to find strategies to end statistical discrimination and integrate them in their theories.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Women will Exit the Workforce
Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1 AC]
3.3 The Importance of the Individual Character of a Basic Income The second wave women's movement in Europe argues for the individualisation of the social security entitlements since derived entitlements would increase the dependence of women on their husbands. It has also been argued that an independent benefit entitlement for women in the social security system is necessary for a full exercise of her social and political rights as a citizen (Lister 1990). A basic income is an individual right par excellence. However, it is not at all obvious that individual social security rights will work at the financial advantage of women. If these rights are implemented in a society with persistent earnings differences between men and women, a complete individualisation of the pension rights will in any case work at the disadvantage of women (Joshi/Davies 1994). It has been argued that the individualisation of the entitlements may be part of a long-term strategy for gender equality, but in the short run it can worsen the social security position of women (MacDonald 1998). If a basic income would be introduced, it might better be implemented together with a credit split system, where individual entitlements are determined based on the entitlements partners build up together during the period of marriage or cohabitation (Okin 1989).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Women will Exit the Workforce
Cantillon and McLean, 2016 - Glasgow Caledonian University and UC Berkeley [Sara and Caitlin, Sept 3, The Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare, Basic Income Guarantee: The Gender Impact within Households," Available at: TA]
At the same time, predictions of a drop in women's labor force participation may also be overstated. Sociological and heterodox economic perspectives have emphasized broader motivations other than income regarding labor force participation, such as status, satisfaction, and other less tangible benefits. The incentive for unemployed persons to take up employment is most often measured using the "replacement rate" (RR)—the ratio between net income out of work and net income when in work, and research in this area reinforces the idea of work or employment being more than just income. Empirical data shows that there are many who choose to work, despite facing replacement ratios of close to or over 100 percent (Callan et al., 2011). That is, they choose to be working, even if they could be close to or even better off financially by remaining unemployed. BIG advocates (Fitzpatrick, 1999; Van Parijs, 1995) further point out that existing systems of social security have substantial disincentives to work embodied in unemployment and poverty traps where low-income households face severe reductions in benefits for every dollar they earn. Combined with logistical problems, financial costs of entering work, and uncertainty regarding stability of employment, there is a huge incentive to forgo work in favor of benefits, if choosing one reduces income from the other. BIG reduces such disincentives, thus potentially making the most vulnerable women better off, with greater rather than lesser incentive to engage in paid labor. This issue highlights the role of women's diversity in creating ambiguous effects of BIG, with some women likely to be gainers and some losers under any reform (see also Robeyns, 2001).
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Women will Exit the Workforce
Kangas and Ylikanno 2023 - Research Director, Department of Social Research, University of Turku and senior specialist at the Ministry of Economic Affairs and Employment [Olli and Minna, January 23, 2023, “Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9914593/ UP/EP]
To summarise our results thus far, UBI did not have a significant effect on employment in the Finnish UBI experiment, but it significantly increased confidence in re-employment and, in that sense, empowered the receivers of UBI. Gender and the interaction between gender and treatment do not appear to be statistically significant explanatory factors in either Model 1 or 2. Thus, according to our results, UBI does not have different effects on women and men in an established gender-equal welfare state such as in Finland. 3.2. Self-Confidence as a Proxy for Empowerment As shown in Table 2, the differences in opinions on all three aspects of confidence between the treatment and control groups are statistically significant. For all the respondents, the highest level of confidence is found in coping with difficult life situations: 67% of the respondents in the treatment group and 58% in the control group answered that they had high, that is, good or very good, confidence in coping with difficult life situations. The lowest level of confidence was found in economic situations. In the treatment group, 44% had high or very high confidence, whereas the corresponding proportion in the control group was lower (33%). The low shares in both groups indicate that the level of the Finnish flat-rate unemployment benefits is too low, and hence, the level of UBI in the Finnish experiment, being set to the level of basic-level unemployment benefits, was too low to satisfy everyday financial needs. However, the higher level of confidence in one’s economic situation in the treatment group indicates that an unconditionally paid social benefit reduces the financial stress caused by low household income [49]. On the one hand, comparing the opinions of women in the treatment and control groups, we find that in all three confidence-based aspects, those in the treatment group reported significantly higher levels of confidence (χ2 Sig. = 0.003 for economy; 0.002 for future; and 0.005 for coping) than those in the control group. For men, the corresponding significances were 0.000, 0.042, and 0.207. On the other hand, when we compared men and women in the treatment group, we did not observe significant gender differences (see Table 2). UBI possibly increases confidence and furthers empowerment, although its effects are gender-neutral.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Alternate Causes
Zelleke 2011 - prof of political science at The New School [Almaz, January Policy and Politics, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” http://www.ingentaconnect.com/content/tpp/pap/2011/00000039/00000001/art00004 TA]
Basic income is by no means enough on its own to achieve true gender equality, but the feminist justification of a basic income, unlike justifications based on the traditional androcentric subject of justice and citizenship, implies other institutional and policy changes as well to make sharing caregiving responsibilities easier and more attractive for women and men. Some steps along the path to gender equality follow directly from the universal caregiver model of citizenship, and include: • the wider availability of part-time work and job sharing; • job security during periodic leaves for full-time caregiving; • the decoupling of access to benefits such as health insurance and pensions from paid employment (a continuing problem in the US); • the widespread availability of care centres, both publicly supported and privately run, for children, older people and adults unable to care for themselves; • the reconfiguring of children’s schooling away from an anachronistic schedule designed to conform to the requirements of an agricultural society and a schedule that recognises the realities of paid employment demands on many parents.6 Other steps require extending the norm of gender neutrality now prevalent in higher education and professional workplaces, for example to the still androcentric institutions of vocational education and skilled blue-collar workplaces (Bergmann, 2005; Estévez-Abe, 2006). Still other steps require a more radical restructuring of the employment sector including, for example, reductions in rewards for seniority or continuity of service in promotions or advancement to protected status in both blue-collar and professional jobs.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Alternate Causes
Pateman, 2004 – prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Democratizing Citizenship: Some Advantages of a Basic Income. Politics and Society on March 1, 2004. ]
Second, let me emphasize that a basic income is not a panacea. In itself, a basic income would not, for instance, provide an adequate stock of affordable housing, sufficient good quality education, adequate health care, an end to racism, or violence-free neighborhoods. Yet if a genuinely democratic society in which the freedom of women is as important as that of men remains an aspiration, it is hard to see that there is a substitute for an unconditional basic income.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Necessary but Insufficient
Zelleke, 2011 - The New School for General Studies, New York [Almaz, Policy & Politics vol 39 no 1, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]
The feminist version of the liberal egalitarian tradition that has as its foundation a universal, unconditional basic income at a level to meet basic needs, on the other hand prioritises the emerging norm of combined care work and paid employment throughout adulthood. The latter attempts not so much to mould individual behaviour to a socially dominant norm, but to allow for the emergence of alternative norms of behaviour beyond the dominant universal breadwinner norm. By socialising the cost of supporting care – not only among fathers, but also among all those whose high earnings suggest protection from the burdens of care – a basic income promotes reciprocity not only within families but also between those with care responsibilities and those without. Finally, by providing an unconditional floor of income to low-skilled workers, basic income provides bargaining power for those who might prefer to stay home and take care of their own children or parents over working as low-paid caregivers for higher-paid women and men, or for women and men of all classes to demand workplaces more accommodating of universal care responsibilities. A universal, unconditional basic income does not promise a gender-symmetrical society – an unreachable goal anyway, until men can bear and breastfeed babies. But it may lead to a society in which remaining, and perhaps essential gender differences do not penalise women (or men) who choose not to pursue androcentric ideals of citizenship by relegating them to poverty, dependence on their spouses or employers, and second-class citizenship.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Necessary but Insufficient
Zelleke, 2011 - The New School for General Studies, New York [Almaz, Policy & Politics vol 39 no 1, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]
Basic income is by no means enough on its own to achieve true gender equality, but the feminist justification of a basic income, unlike justifications based on the traditional androcentric subject of justice and citizenship, implies other institutional and policy changes as well to make sharing caregiving responsibilities easier and more attractive for women and men. Some steps along the path to gender equality follow directly from the universal caregiver model of citizenship, and include: • the wider availability of part-time work and job sharing; • job security during periodic leaves for full-time caregiving; • the decoupling of access to benefits such as health insurance and pensions from paid employment (a continuing problem in the US); • the widespread availability of care centres, both publicly supported and privately run, for children, older people and adults unable to care for themselves; • the reconfiguring of children’s schooling away from an anachronistic schedule designed to conform to the requirements of an agricultural society and towards a schedule that recognises the realities of paid employment demands on many parents.6 Other steps require extending the norm of gender neutrality now prevalent in higher education and professional workplaces, for example to the still androcentric institutions of vocational education and skilled blue-collar workplaces (Bergmann, 2005; Estévez-Abe, 2006). Still other steps require a more radical restructuring of the employment sector including, for example, reductions in rewards for seniority or continuity of service in promotions or advancement to protected status in both blue-collar and professional jobs.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Necessary but Insufficient
Kangas et al, 2023- a Research Director at the Department of Social Research at the University of Turku in Finland [Olli, with Minna Ylikännö "Basic Income and the Status of Women in an Established Gender-Equal Welfare State: Results from the Finnish Basic Income Experiment." International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 20, no. 3, ProQuest, https://proxy.lib.umich.edu/login?url=https://www.proquest.com/scholarly-journals/basic-income-status-women-established-gender/docview/2774904198/se-2, doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph20031733. EO]
However, we, too, end up with a few universalising comments or, if you like, lessons from the Finnish UBI experiment. In all societies, minimum income protection, either UBI or Finnish residence-based universal basic security, is a necessary condition for fulfilling the grand goals advocated by the protagonists of the basic income concept. However, this is not a sufficient condition to achieve these goals. In addition, we need an amplitude of family policy measures, such as available and affordable childcare, and we need well-functioning healthcare, education, and employment services to support people and societies in their path towards gender equality. Hence, gender equality cannot be achieved by a single social policy measure. The achievement of more equal societies requires several measures that consistently seek to promote that value. A decent level of money is a necessary but insufficient condition for empowering people.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Necessary but Insufficient
Webster, 2019 - Head of research at Royal Society of Arts [Hannah March 8th Why Basic Income is a women’s issue, Royal Society of Arts, , EP]
However, we need to stay mindful of the fact that a Basic Income is for everyone. Whilst it could be an important step for women on low income, it will not actively lessen inequalities without careful attention. Basic Income payments are blind to their context, and so don’t alone incentive for a greater contribution to the home for men. Left unattended, there is a risk that current attempts to rebalance these roles could lose momentum as some may consider Basic Income payments as remuneration for women’s work in the home. Therefore, a more holistic approach to gender inequalities, of which a Basic Income offers one strand, is essential. Conversations about women’s progression in the workplace, stereotypes about male and female types of employment, the distribution of family leave and power dynamics in the home, amongst others, need to be had to help inform any large-scale implementation of a Basic Income. Making sure basic income supports feminism With the concept in its infancy in the UK, we still have the opportunity to make sure the policy supports the feminist cause. An important step we can already take is to ensure we stay mindful of the narrative around the legislation, and a sensitivity to the myriad of contexts which a Basic Income will be paid into. The RSA’s argument for a Basic Income is built around new opportunities for individual change, such as trying a new job, training or creative activity, and in ensuring that there is wider, and more tailored, support to ensure everyone benefits from the changes they need. Our Public Services and Communities team have been running workshops in Fife to understand the feasibility of a Basic Income trial in the area, and what this would look like for a range of residents, including women in the current welfare system. Making a concerted effort to explore how this may play out for women and mothers, and to provide additional support where needed, will create an inclusive conversation around the policy.
2023
MNDI
Affirmative
AFF › --AT Too Small
Lawhon and McCreary, 2020 - profs of Geography at Universities of Oklahoma and Florida State [Mary and Tyler, March, Antipode – A Radical Journal of Geography “Beyond Jobs vs Environment: On the Potential of Universal Basic Income to Reconfigure Environmental Politics” TA]
Equally importantly, a UBI provides support for those undertaking work that is poorly remunerated in existing economies. Indeed, as feminists such as Federici (2012) and James (2012) have long argued, the reproduction of capitalist workforces relies upon the exploitation of women’s unpaid work in the home. Those working as migrants and in the service industry are equally central to ongoing production and reproduction, but undervalued in existing political economies. A UBI is normatively different than arguments in favour of payment for specific services; as an unconditional grant, it is received whether one works or labours. In practice, however, it enables participation in and greater valuation of reproductive activities. While it is difficult to conceive of a UBI that would replace the standard of living of traditionally unionised, white, male industrial labour force, a moderate UBI could effectively increase incomes and reduce the dependency of more highly exploited populations doing socially reproductive work.