Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Too Small

Even a small basic income improves women’s psychological health through recognition

Robeyns, 2001 – Chair Ethics of Institutions at the Utrecht University, Netherlands [Ingrid. “Will a Basic Income Do Justice to Women?: A Contribution to the Symposium on P. Van Parijs ’s “Real Freedom for All” Analyse & Kritik, vol. 23, no. 1  AC]

2.5 Psychological Effects on Housewives One can expect that a basic income, even when it is small, will be positively valued by housewives (or househusbands). It gives those women a feeling of contributing to the incomes of the family, and to get more recognition for the care and household work they do. Pahl (1989) notices that for British housewives the child allowances they receive are psychologically very important, even when they are very small.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Too Small

Framework controls the size of the UBI - a gendered lens pushes a UBI to adequate levels rather than minimally sufficient ones because it recognizes that unpaid labor is necessary to make the minimal income sufficient.

Goldblatt, 2021 - Professor of Law, University of the Witwatersrand [Beth “Basic Income, Gender and Human Rights” Acc 1/28/23 TA]

Adequacy is an essential element of the right to social security. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural rights explained that: Benefits, whether in cash or in kind, must be adequate in amount and duration in order that everyone may realize his or her rights to family protection and assistance, an adequate standard of living and adequate access to health care … States parties must also pay full respect to the principle of human dignity contained in the preamble of the Covenant, and the principle of non-discrimination, so as to avoid any adverse effect on the levels of benefits and the form in which they are provided. 31 Adequate social protection that is attentive to gender must ensure that income support takes account of the position of women within households, women’s unpaid work and care obligations, women’s lower earnings and savings, and women’s position in the workforce which is often informal and precarious. What constitutes adequacy and whether there are minimum core levels of provision required by rights has been debated within the field of social and economic rights .32 In addition, valid concerns have been raised with a human rights emphasis on sufficiency leading to efforts to tackle poverty without also ensuring distributive equality.33 A substantive equality approach to social protection rights requires structural responses to systemic inequality via social, economic and political reconfigurations that lead to fundamental changes to gender, class and other relations.34 It thus requires policies aimed at overcoming inequality rather than just providing minimum levels of poverty relief. This idea of adequacy should be central to the human rights lens used to consider questions of the theory, design and politics of a basic income. In addition, adequacy must be understood as a global issue since affordability and economic choices facing states require international cooperation and assistance, as required by the ICESCR.35

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Reinforce Gender Roles

A basic income will not reinforce women’s domestic roles – that argument relies on classist and racist assumptions

Zelleke, 2019 - Prof of Practice in Political Science at NYU Shanghai [Almaz, May 16, Phenomenal World, “Feminist Theory, Gender Inequity, and Basic Income” Interview by Hana Beach, Acc 2/23/23 TA]

In the feminist literature there is a divide between those who think that a basic income is a good thing for women and those who think it will reinforce women’s disproportionate responsibility for care. They are worried that people will say that women should stay in the domestic sphere because now they are being compensated for doing so. What’s interesting to me about the welfare rights movements that originated in the 1960s and ’70s in the US and in Europe is how they inform this feminist debate. In those movements, the women who would have been the immediate beneficiaries of an unconditional guaranteed income were absolutely in favor of it. It was middle class and professional women in the 1970s who were against the idea of a basic income and who thought it would be something that would relegate women to the domestic sphere. This argument clearly doesn’t offer an intersectional understanding of feminism. When we think about what’s good for women, we have to think about what’s good for women of different classes and what’s good for women of different races and ethnicities. The outsourcing of childcare is one of the things that makes it possible for middle class and professional women to have careers. When women join the labor market, it’s not the case that care work is redistributed evenly among men and women. It’s being redistributed among women—specifically to poor women of color, to legal and undocumented immigrants, who now have to leave their own families in the care of someone else, who is typically unpaid, and earn a wage by caring for other people’s families. Redistributing care work in this way does not solve gender division of labor. We have to redistribute it to men as well. HB: In her famous essay “Welfare is a Women’s Issue,” former chairperson of the National Welfare Rights Organization [NWRO] Johnnie Tillmon made that connection about domestic service work and the division of labor—her analysis, gained from lived experience, was spot on, which I think says a lot about the importance of participatory policy design. AZ: It’s absolutely important to hear from the people who are going to be the biggest beneficiaries of a basic income or any other kind of policy of welfare reform. I’m drawn to the welfare rights movement because women were arguing for increased and unconditional welfare benefits. Those demands are clearly important to the discourse around basic income today.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Reinforce Gender Roles

A UBI will not reinforce existing gendered roles in labor – it is the greatest step toward eliminating those roles based on caregiving.

Zelleke, 2011 - The New School for General Studies, New York [Almaz, Policy & Politics vol 39 no 1, “Feminist political theory and the argument for an unconditional basic income” TA]

Most importantly, basic income indirectly compensates care and society’s other unpaid work without reinforcing the existing gendered distribution of labour or the primacy of the public sphere by equating care with work. Although basic income is often characterised as allowing people not to work, its most radical feature in comparison to current forms of welfare state redistribution is that it allows people to work without losing benefits immediately at a punitively high effective rate of taxation, which they do in the ‘poverty trap’ effect of conditional or means-tested benefits. Because of its universality and its unconditionality, basic income preserves work incentives; at low levels of income it is not a substitute for earned income, but a complement, and operates as a wage subsidy (Van Parijs, 2001). This means that low-wage jobs, or the volunteer work that can provide some of the non-financial benefits of paid employment, for both the individual and society, can become feasible in a way they are not under conditional or means-tested forms of redistribution. Together with other strategies to increase the flexibility of paid employment, basic income promotes the ability of individuals to choose the mix of paid work, care and leisure that best meets their needs at any given time (Roebyns, 2000). Because no one – man or woman – has to choose between being a ‘worker’ or a ‘caregiver’ to receive income, basic income has the most potential of any redistributive scheme to transform over time the relation of both men and women to the provision of care and to the world of paid employment.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --AT Reinforce Gender Roles

The potential for reinforcement is not a reason to reject the Aff – it is a reason why our framework is essential to keep the state focused on gender to Prevent the turns.

Koslowski and Duvander, 2018 - prof of Social and Political Science, Univ of Edinburgh and prof of Sociology, Stockholm University [Alison and Ann-Zofie, Working Paper 2018:05 “Basic Income: The Potential for Gendered Empowerment?” Acc 1/28/23 TA]

5. Conclusions: Basic Income, a Radical or Conservative Policy with Regard to Gendered Empowerment? A basic income promises ‘real freedom’, or a freedom from dictate; what role then for state intervention? The interplay between social policies and norms is of key interest to social scientists and policy makers. This is particularly clear in the arena of public health, in which the interventionist state often plays a strong role in changing our behaviours, for e.g., with regard to smoking, alcohol consumption, vaccinations, sugar consumption. There are other examples around environmental behaviours too, e.g. recycling and reduced use of plastic bags and other plastics. Should the state not take action too with regard to gender equalities? Norms will develop: there is no such thing as total ‘real’ freedom. Legal frameworks however, such as parental leave policies can see changes to norms, even those as deeply embedded as parenting practices. In Sweden, such statements are hardly controversial, but choice and gender equality are sometimes contrasted, and the limits to state intervention are constantly renegotiated. Basic income would potentially change the boundaries for state intervention, which for many sounds intuitively positive, and may well bring many benefits. However, if the state does not intervene regarding gender-equality, gender norms will be determined by other less visible forces, such as the power dynamics within households. It is likely that a universal basic income has the potential for empowerment for all, but for this to be achieved, attention will need to be paid to its potential for gendered outcomes. The concerns raised here regarding the limitations of empowerment for women from a basic income—particularly with regard to whom remains holding the baby, doing the majority of domestic work and the majority of both formal and informal care work—are not in themselves arguments against the implementation of a basic income. However, there are certainly strong reasons to not let basic income replace other structures that have been shown to be relevant for gender equality, in particular the ones directed at supporting families, such as parental leave and childcare services.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Funding

A wealth tax is necessary to prevent a UBI from exacerbating the wealth gap further for low income families.

Bhattacharya 2019 - director of programs and strategy at the Insight Center for Community Economic Development [Jhumpa “Exploring Guaranteed Income through a Racial and Gendered Justice Lens” . . Accessed 23 June 2023 EO]

However, expecting that these families could use the benefit towards wealth accumulation is a stretch, as the most likely scenario is that the benefit will help people meet a basic standard of living that their current incomes do not allow them to do. Low-income families are battling low wages that do not allow them to meet the actual costs of living, are in jobs that do not pay benefits, and bear the brunt of criminal justice fines and fees. Without addressing these factors, a monthly cash benefit can only go as far as meeting the basic human needs that our government currently fails to guarantee, and it will not help lowincome families build wealth. In comparison, for families that are already able to meet their basic needs, an additional cash benefit affords them the choice to spend the benefit on things like vacations, healthier food, or to put some money towards savings. This allows them to either add to or start some wealth accumulation. Families in this income bracket may be able to breathe a little easier knowing that they have the supplemental income to fall back on in times of an unexpected emergency. For higher income families who already have established wealth, the benefit adds to their overall wealth, perhaps exacerbating current wealth inequities even further. Recent proposals to fix the lopsided tax system by taxing the super rich at a higher percentage could be one way to address this concern.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Funding

A UBI must be funded by progressive taxation in order to address poverty, racism, and gender inequality

Williams, 2021 -- Writer for Research and Data Section for UN Women. [Loui. April 21, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal basic income: Potential and limitations from a gender perspective” https://www.unwomen.org/sites/default/files/Headquarters/Attachments/Sections/Library/Publications/2021/Policy-brief-Universal-basic-income-en.pdf UP]

The design features necessary for a feminist universal basic income Debates remain largely hypothetical given that there are so few full-fledged UBI schemes, and because where they do exist they are usually not evaluated for gender impacts. It is clear that the extent to which UBI’s potential for reducing gender and other inequalities will be realized depends critically on its specific design features, including the level of benefit provided, its financing mechanism and its interaction with existing tax and social security systems. Without parallel investments in quality public services and strengthened support for workers’ rights, UBI could have detrimental effects for gender equality and social justice. However, well-designed UBI that is integrated into a comprehensive system of social protection, public services and labour market regulations could strengthen women’s and transgender and gender diverse people’s income security, lower poverty rates and go some way to redressing inequalities in wealth and income. This will be perceived by many as a high standard to live up to, and any UBI will have to be rolled out carefully and progressively. Extending the reach of existing social protection schemes aimed at particular groups—such as social pensions and child and disability benefits—and ensuring that these are unconditional and universally available could be an important steppingstone towards achieving universal income security for all. The main recommendations for States considering UBI are as follows: • Follow a rights-based approach to social protection when designing UBI schemes. This includes following the principles of progressive realization and non-retrogression to safeguard against the rollback of existing social security and labour protections. Like all other social protection schemes, UBI should be anchored in national legal frameworks. • Ensure that UBI is accompanied by parallel investments in quality public services, including care services, health care, education, housing and food security, and with attention to the rights of women and transgender and gender-diverse people working within these sectors. • Develop sustainable and redistributive financing mechanisms for UBI. The cost estimates for UBI at national poverty level are substantial, and fiscal trade-offs are likely to arise, especially for low-income and highly indebted countries, with implications for gender and other inequalities. These should be assessed and discussed in a transparent, participatory manner during the design phase. • Ensure that UBI schemes address the needs of groups facing multiple and intersecting forms of discrimination. UBI implementation should be inclusive of incarcerated, migrant, LGBTIQ+ and unhoused individuals, and should be embedded in a broader system of support that addresses the additional needs of people with disabilities, pregnant people and the elderly. • Design UBI through national dialogue involving government, civil society, social partners and community representatives to discuss potential benefits and trade-offs and build societal consensus on the form of the UBI and its integration into broader social protection systems. • Close current gaps in evidence by strengthening monitoring and evaluation of UBI and other cash transfer schemes from a gender perspective, including analysing their impact on groups of women and transgender and genderdiverse people experiencing different intersecting forms of discrimination.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Prostitution

A UBI improves gender justice by helping those most insecure and vulnerable – it empowers women to leave abusive employers and avoid being pushed into sex work

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

A second comment has to do with heterogeneity among women. It is important for this debate to start from an assessment of the situation of the most vulnerable women and whether UBI would benefit them, rather than focusing the debate on whether UBI can further the more abstract goal of gender justice. For many women, lack of formal employment is actually not the main problem. The problem is rather the inability to perform the care work they want to perform without being stigmatized or condemned to a life of poverty or dependence. For some women, the problem is overwork—that they are combining several low-paying jobs to support their children and end up left with too little time to spend with them. Too often socially invisible, many domestic workers are bound to abusive employers by a lack of exit options. Lacking the economic security needed to have exit options also makes sex workers more vulnerable to abuse. The Sex Workers Open University (2017) in fact demands UBI on the basis that “[i]f every person in the UK was entitled to a universal basic income, no one would be pushed by absolute poverty into selling sex.” The conversation on whether UBI should be endorsed on grounds of gender justice should be dependent, at least to some extent, on what UBI would do to empower the women who are currently most economically insecure and most vulnerable to domination.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency - Prostitution

A basic income allows women to avoid abusive and dehumanizing jobs like prostitution

Pateman, 2018 – Prof of Political Science at UCLA [Carole, Aug 15, Feminist Current “Why feminists need to take up a basic income in their fight for women’s liberation: An interview with Carole Pateman” Interviewed by Jacqueline Gullion, https://www.feministcurrent.com/2018/08/15/feminists-need-take-basic-income-fight-womens-liberation-interview-carole-pateman/ Acc 3/23/23 TA]

JG: Yes, for women, we would have the liberty to escape dangerous situations, to avoid being stuck living with dangerous men, and to be able to care for our children. CP: Yes. I think these kinds of considerations are extremely important when we’re talking about basic income. It is a way for people to maintain their own standard of living, but it also enables them (if they have a particularly nasty, perhaps dangerous job, for example), to know that if they leave that job, they’re not going to starve. If there is a basic income available that enables them to live at least decently they can say “no” to those kinds of jobs. This is why a basic income is a major step forward. It’s not a panacea, but it is a necessary part of any policy for democratizing societies further than ours are now. JG: In the anti-violence movement in Canada, women are integrating Guaranteed Livable Income campaigns into women’s liberation campaigns, for example against male violence against women, which includes the campaign for the abolition of prostitution. CP: It’s very interesting and exciting that basic income is being taken up by feminist demands for equality. Because [basic income ensures] you have the means to escape from dangerous circumstances, like if you’re going into prostitution because it offers more money than other things you can do. Having a basic income available, I think, is crucial to enabling people to live as they would like to live and not as they have to because of the circumstances in which they find themselves.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Domestic Violence

A UBI empowers women to leave dominating spouses because it is individually based, not household based.

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

An Individual (Versus Household-Based) Benefit Most means-tested income support schemes establish eligibility based on household income. This means that dependents within households that have a higher income than the eligibility ceiling typically do not receive a welfare payment of their own. A wageless spouse depending on a rich enough partner, for instance, lacks eligibility for welfare support. Political theorists who have written on UBI take individuals to be the unit of concern for distributive purposes, and therefore the relevant beneficiaries of public assistance. Although families are often spaces of solidarity and support, they can also be spaces of contention and potentially domination. Nothing ensures that the distribution of resources from breadwinner to caregiver or unemployed spouse allows the dependent to lead a dignified life. UBI proponents contend that we should therefore make sure that individuals have exit options by getting an income of their own even if they dwell in a rich enough household. The move from household-based to individual benefits has thus been defended as an instrument of empowerment for women. Young adults are also invisible dependents who are often hardly eligible for income support, as is the case in France (Bidadanure 2012). Under most proposals, children are also covered by the UBI scheme—but they get a lower amount and the cash is allocated to their parents.2 The individual feature of UBI seeks to protect vulnerable individuals within family units and increase their freedom. The additional allowance for children ensures the family unit has enough to live free of economic insecurity.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Domestic Violence

A basic income helps women by giving them financial security to leave abusive relationships

Hermann, 2021 - MA Candidate in International Affairs at Hertie School [Katrin, Sept 28, Path for Europe, “Reimagining Care: Feminist degrowth and UBI” Acc 1/16/23 TA]

One aspect that needs to be considered in the debate on basic income is its effect on the working habits of women and men. Feminist scholars have argued that basic income has the potential to help address the inequalities that persist between men and women within households and families. More often than not, social protection programs within countries reference households rather than individuals, not reflecting the inequalities that many women face – even if on paper the household is ‘well-off’.[5] Ailsa McKay, Carole Pateman and other feminist economists have pointed to UBI as a method of not only influencing the gendered division of labour within households, but also benefits such as providing economic independence for women. Given that women within the EU (and globally) are at a higher risk for poverty, a fixed income could alleviate not only economic concerns, but also improve the psychological health and well-being of women. This is due to the recognition of their work as a valuable part of the economy. The use of this income as a form of social protection is especially true for women in abusive relationships, as receiving an independent income would potentially enable them to have the financial security to leave (though this does not account for the myriad of other factors that may prevent women from leaving abusive partners).

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Domestic Violence

A basic income helps protect women from domestic violence by giving women the resources to leave.

Bidadanure, 2019 - prof of Philosophy, Stanford University [Juliana Uhuru, Mar 5, Annual Review of Political Science “The Political Theory of Universal Basic Income” TA]

Gender Inequality One way in which UBI can serve as a potential tool to correct gender inequalities is through its individual feature: It provides dependent spouses with exit options. In most systems of assistance, eligibility for welfare support is calculated per household. This makes it particularly difficult for those abused by spouses they economically depend on to free themselves. Conner (2014, p. 340) sums it up this way: “While a batterer is empowered by his partner's financial dependence, the autonomy of a woman who is victimized is diminished by her abuser's ability to control her through financial means. Moreover, financial instability is one of the greatest reasons why, after gaining freedom, a woman who experiences battering has limited choices and may ultimately acquiesce to her partner's attempts to reconcile.” This line of support for UBI is fairly uncontroversial and accepted by most in the literature. Note, however, that it does not necessarily constitute an argument for UBI as such; an individually means-tested and lightly conditional benefit would suffice to undermine the financial dependence of spouses. What makes a truly universal and unconditional basic income proposal more centrally connected to the goals of gender justice, I will now propose, is its capacity to contribute to the proper remuneration of care work.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Solvency – Domestic Violence

A UBI helps gender minorities avoid violence by giving them financial security to leave abusive households

Williams, 2021 - Research and Data Section, UN Women [Loui, Policy Brief No. 22 “Universal Basic Income: Potential And Limitations From A Gender Perspective” TA]

The feminist case for UBI Feminists supporters argue that an individual income such as UBI could help guarantee women’s economic autonomy in the face of ongoing discrimination in employment and increase their bargaining power in (and beyond) families and communities. UBI would remove the exclusionary pitfalls and stigma attached to means-tested schemes, as well as avoid the paternalistic and sometimes coercive implementation practices documented for some conditional cash transfers.14 It may also avoid the ‘unemployment traps’ sometimes experienced by welfare recipients who risk losing their benefits should they increase their labour force participation— with particular detriment to single parents and people with disabilities.15 A secure and reliable income on an individual rather than household level could be especially important for those seeking to leave violent partners or unhappy relationships, by cushioning the financial shocks of partnership dissolution that tend to leave women and transgender and gender-diverse people worse-off than men.16 Research on cash transfers also suggests that a regular inflow of cash can in some cases mitigate intimate partner violence, including by improving emotional and mental wellbeing through reduced economic stress.17 In the context of employment, UBI may provide the necessary safety net to exit exploitative working conditions or buffer income instability for those unable to access waged work. Employment discrimination can make it especially difficult for transgender and gender-diverse people to access safe and secure employment. For example, in the European Union alone at least nine member States do not protect against discrimination in employment on grounds of gender identity.18

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

Domestic violence hinders a woman’s ability to achieve financial stability because it denies transportation and child care.

Adams, 2016 – Michigan State Department of Psychology [Adrienne. “Measuring the Effects of Domestic Violence on Women’s Financial Well- Being.” University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Financial Security, 25 Feb. 2016, cfs.wisc.edu/2011/05/01/adams2011/. AC]

Researchers have identified several indicators of transportation problems confronted by DV survivors, including unreliable access to a vehicle, not owning a car, not having a driver’s license, the cost of gasoline and repairs, and the accessibility of public transportation (i.e., availability, reliability, and cost). The child care problems women confront are similar; studies have examined indicators of the accessibility, reliability, and prohibitive cost of child care as barriers to employment for DV survivors. Research Brief 3 Financial Stability While economic self-sufficiency reflects an individual’s or a family’s ability to meet their needs without outside help or support, achieving financial stability requires having not only income to cover daily living expenses, but also assets available to leverage in times of hardship, meet financial goals, and build long-term security. As previously discussed, generating enough income to cover the costs of living can be a significant challenge for DV survivors. Additionally, many women with abusive partners are asset poor. For some women, the lack of assets is directly related to the abuser’s behavior. Batterers may restrict women’s access to assets by refusing to include their name on property such as a home, vehicle, or business; they may deny access to cash, savings, and investments; and they may control access to health insurance (Adams, et. al., 2008; Brewster, 2003; Sanders & Schnabel 2007).

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

Domestic abuse heightens the difficulty of building wealth – abused women rarely have control of household assets.

Adams, 2016 – Michigan State Department of Psychology [Adrienne. “Measuring the Effects of Domestic Violence on Women’s Financial Well- Being.” University of Wisconsin-Madison Center for Financial Security, 25 Feb. 2016, cfs.wisc.edu/2011/05/01/adams2011/. AC]

For other women, asset building may be restricted by a history of surviving paycheck-to-paycheck, mounting debt, and a steady chain of hardships, conditions that are often exacerbated by an abusive partner (Goodman, et al., 2009). With insufficient income and assets and an abusive partner engaging in economically destructive behavior, financial instability tends to manifest itself in DV survivors’ lives in the form of significant financial and material hardship (Adams, et al., 2008; Adams, et al., in press; Brush, 2004; Goodman, et al., 2009; Tolman, et al., 2001). Measures used in DV research to capture financial and material hardship include deprivation, consumer issues, and hardship-mediating activities. For example, instruments such as the Women’s Employment Study (WES) material hardship measures, (Tolman, et al., 2001), the Economic Health Index (EHI; Adams, et al., 2008), and the financial hardship subscale of the DV-FI, (Weaver, et al., 2009) assess a range of financial hardships. Difficulty finding and maintaining affordable housing is one of the most common measures and has been assessed using indicators that document survivors’ experiences of eviction and home foreclosure, doubling-up in homes with friends or relatives, and homelessness. Food insufficiency is also frequently included as an indicator of hardship among DV survivors, as are credit and debt problems. Measurement instruments typically capture problems such as not having enough money to buy food or other necessities and having to cope with debt from rent and utility bills, credit cards, student loans, and medical bills that may have accumulated (with or without the woman’s consent) during the abusive relationship or may have resulted from starting over after leaving the abuser. Further, because accumulated debt and the inability to meet daily living expenses often result in having one’s telephone, electricity, or other utilities turned off, these types of hardships are also captured. People employ a variety of coping strategies when faced with financial hardship. Thus, a second approach to measuring the financial hardship experienced by DV survivors involves assessing strategies used to manage hardship. To this end, Tolman et al. (2001) developed a measure for the WES that includes strategies such as pawning or selling possessions; selling things from home, such as cosmetics or crafts; engaging in illegal activities; and earning extra money through babysitting, cleaning houses, or styling hair. While not yet used in a study with DV survivors, Shim et al. (2009) modified an instrument from the Michigan Study of Life Transitions (Eccles, Barber, & Jozefowicz, 1998) to capture “economizing” and “extreme” coping in the context of financial hardship. This instrument could serve as a tool for assessing DV survivors’ use of strategies ranging from moderate financial adjustments such as cutting back on expenses to potentially financially damaging behavior such as using payday loans or credit cards to pay bills. These instruments allow researchers to assess not only the extent of financial hardship in a woman’s life, but also the types of strategies they use to cope with that hardship. 4 Center for Financial Security Subjective Financial Well-being In addition to compromised economic selfsufficiency and financial stability, DV has a detrimental impact on women’s subjective financial well-being (Adams, et al., in press). Subjective appraisal of financial well-being is important because what people think and how they feel influences their decisions and actions.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

Economic Anxiety Increases intimate partner violence Rates – Empirics Prove

Stanley, 2020 - Special Advisor to the Harvard Law School Gender Violence Program [Maclen "Why the Increase in Domestic Violence During COVID-19?" Psychology Today, 9 May, EO]

One specific type of stressor has been given significant attention in the context of IPV: economic anxiety. Indeed, plentiful research has shown that IPV is more likely (and more severe) in households that are economically distressed. For example, studies from the 2008 recession found that increases in unemployment claims correlated with a greater number of reported cases of IPV. Today, the COVID-19 pandemic has caused unprecedented job loss at levels comparable to the Great Depression. US Bureau Labor Statistics Unemployment RatesSource: US Bureau Labor Statistics Many researchers believe that a perceived threat to the masculine identity undergirds the relationship between economic anxiety and IPV (e.g., Dutton & Browning, 1988; Totten, 2003). One qualitative study interviewed 33 men attending a domestic violence program and found that threats to masculine identities played a significant role in the occurrence of IPV (Anderson & Umberson, 2001). When masculinity is threatened (for example, by job loss and the perceived failure to “provide”), abusers respond with violence in order to regain a sense of power and control in their relationships.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

Isolation makes intimate partner violence difficult to escape – stress empirically increases violent control.

Stanley, 2020 - Special Advisor to the Harvard Law School Gender Violence Program [Maclen "Why the Increase in Domestic Violence During COVID-19?" Psychology Today, 9 May, EO]

With workplaces closed, visits to family and friends discouraged, and even public parks off-limits, social isolation has become government-sanctioned. Unfortunately, social isolation is one of the most common tactics employed by perpetrators of IPV. By isolating victims from friends, family, and any outside contact, abusers are able to assert control over the victim’s entire environment. Social isolation can lead to the normalization of abuse and allow abusers to more easily engage in gaslighting techniques. Severe and persistent isolation can cause victims to rely solely on their abusers to define a sense of reality, which feeds into a cycle of abuse that is very difficult to escape. Stress Another factor commonly associated with IPV is stress. Natural disasters and crises catalyze immense stress responses that often correlate with increases in IPV. As mentioned above, one study examining interpersonal violence in the wake of Hurricane Harvey found that stress associated with the disaster was related to higher rates of IPV both during and after the hurricane. A similar report following the 1989 Exxon Valdez oil spill in Alaska found that disaster-related stress was associated with a nearly threefold increase in IPV. With regard to the COVID-19 pandemic, stressors abound. In many ways, disease outbreaks can foster a type of stress more insidious than that of other disasters. Namely, pandemics ignite the unknown. During most disasters such as hurricanes or earthquakes, we know whether or not we’ve been personally impacted. Although these events can be extraordinarily stressful, there is at least an established time boundary from which we can begin to assess damage and eventually move forward. But with viral pandemics, we are often left in an ongoing state of risk and worry, triggering an overexposure of the stress hormone cortisol. Elevations in stress hormones have long been associated with increased aggression.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

A lack of income security causes a cycle of domestic violence because women are forced to return to their abusers

Niess-May, 2019 - Executive Director of SafeHouse Center [Barbara, October 22nd, The Intersection of Domestic Violence and Poverty, https://www.safehousecenter.org/the-intersection-of-domestic-violence-and-poverty/#:~:text=Poverty%20is%20a%20primary%20driver,a%20survivor%20of%20domestic%20violence. EP]

Mary, and many other survivors, have very, very few choices at this point. For many, they wish their partner would just stop abusing. Without significant intervention focused on accountability, it is not likely the behavior will change. In fact, studies show that the abuse will worsen and the survivor’s life will be at great risk. Mary, and thousands of other survivors find themselves with their children, homeless, without resources or a prospect for income, estranged from friends or family and often from a distance still “managing the abuse” of the former partner. Because of this often underappreciated predicament, many survivors return to the abusive partner saying they need to care for their children. The reality is, poverty has entrapped the survivor in the abuse. One of the primary reasons women are homeless is because of domestic violence. And, ironically, many return to the abusive home because they have nowhere else to go—overwhelmingly because of economic reasons. Poverty, among other things, is a primary reason why an abuser is able to continue to control the survivor. Also, there are too few intervention programs with mixed efficacy. And, the legal and social system actors continue to enable the assailants through lack of knowledge and believing that the survivor has a responsibility in holding the assailant accountable.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

Income inequality increases domestic violence by preventing escape from abuse.

Niess-May, 2019 - Executive Director of SafeHouse Center [Barbara, October 22nd, The Intersection of Domestic Violence and Poverty, https://www.safehousecenter.org/the-intersection-of-domestic-violence-and-poverty/#:~:text=Poverty%20is%20a%20primary%20driver,a%20survivor%20of%20domestic%20violence. EP]

Poverty is a primary driver in the continuation of an assailant having power and control over a survivor of domestic violence. Studies and practice show that if survivors of domestic violence have resources to safely leave a relationship, and land in safe, affordable housing with a means to care for themselves and their children they are more likely to escape further abuse. Low to no income individuals in a domestic violence situation, particularly with children, rarely have the resources they need to break free from the violence.

2023 MNDI Affirmative
AFF › --Extend Harms – Domestic Violence

Domestic violence is soaring now due to COVID and crises – empirics prove.

Stanley, 2020 - Special Advisor to the Harvard Law School Gender Violence Program [Maclen "Why the Increase in Domestic Violence During COVID-19?" Psychology Today, 9 May, EO]

Among all of the horrors that COVID-19 has wrought, domestic violence is a growing scourge that lurks in the shadows. Indeed, a stark uptick in reports of domestic violence and abuse (more commonly referred to in clinical settings as “intimate partner violence” or “IPV”) has recently received national (and even global) attention. New estimates from the United Nations Population Fund suggest that three months of quarantine will result in a 20 percent rise in IPV throughout the world. In total, the report predicts at least 15 million additional cases of IPV will occur as a result of COVID-19 lockdowns. For some, the correlation between sheltering-in-place and increased IPV seems to have elicited surprise. New York Governor Andrew Cuomo, for example, expressed alarm upon learning of the increased reports of domestic violence within his state. But for anyone experienced with IPV, the increase in its occurrence arrived with the predictability of the tides. IPV surges in times of natural disasters and crises. We previously witnessed this ugly social phenomenon during Hurricane Harvey in 2017, and we will see it again during whatever form of Armageddon brings the nation to its knees on the next go-around. Harris County District Attorney’s Office-Domestic Violence Caseload Statistics, 2018 Domestic Violence Rates Post-Hurricane HarveySource: Harris County District Attorney’s Office-Domestic Violence Caseload Statistics, 2018 The question still remains, though: why? Plentiful research exists demonstrating several key factors associated with IPV, including during times of natural disaster and crisis. By examining this literature, we can better understand why today’s lockdown measures appear to be fueling increased instances of IPV.