2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Solves Climate
DeGood and Walter 23
Kevin DeGood is the director of infrastructure policy at American Progress. Karla Walter is the senior director for employment policy at American Progress.; MAR 20, 2023; 5 Policy Priorities for the Federal Aviation Administration Reauthorization; ; //[TMS—GK]
The reauthorization of Federal Aviation Administration programs should provide dedicated funding for reducing greenhouse gas emissions from airplanes and airports, an increase in the Passenger Facility Charge, and decent wages and benefits for airport service workers. The scientific evidence is unequivocal: climate change is a threat to human wellbeing and the health of the planet. Any further delay in concerted global action will miss a brief and rapidly closing window to secure a livable future. The commercial aviation industry accounts for roughly 5 percent of U.S. gross domestic product (GDP), or $1.25 trillion, in 2022.1 This year, Congress is slated to reauthorize Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) funding and programs. The FAA bill presents an important opportunity to advance environmental sustainability; improve job quality for thousands of airport service workers; and ensure the efficiency and competitiveness of the U.S. aviation system. Unfortunately, current FAA funding levels and program structures are not designed to realize these environmental, labor, and economic goals. In fiscal year 2022, the FAA spent $6.4 billion on capital projects, grants to airports, and research.2 The overwhelming majority of these dollars supported basic capital work with only a small share directed to reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Federal law restricts the fees that airports may charge passengers, preventing capacity-constrained airports from raising the revenues necessary to finance their long-term capital needs. Finally, despite billions in federal support flowing to airports every year, many of the workers that make commercial air travel possible lack adequate pay and benefits. The FAA bill should increase funding for greenhouse gas reduction projects, ensuring the aviation sector can achieve net-zero carbon emissions by midcentury; extend federal pay and benefit standards to airport service workers to support an efficient, well-qualified workforce; and improve system efficiency by allowing airports to raise the revenue necessary to finance major capital projects. The reauthorization should include the following five policies. Provide not less than $1 billion annually for research, development, and deployment of sustainable aviation fuels (SAFs). In the 12-month period from December of 2021 to November of 2022, U.S. air carriers providing scheduled commercial service burned 11.4 billion gallons of aviation fuel on domestic flights.3 This is roughly equivalent to 17,273 Olympic swimming pools worth of fuel each year.4 The FAA estimates that, by 2042, domestic enplanements on U.S. commercial air carriers will increase from 645 million to 1.3 billion annually.5 In the absence of additional scientific breakthroughs, demonstration projects, and ultimately scaled production, aviation will contribute a larger and larger share of U.S. climate emissions by midcentury. Reform the Airport Improvement Program (AIP) to allow stand-alone climate mitigation, adaptation, and other sustainability projects. Federal grant support for civil airport development dates back to 1946 when President Harry Truman signed the Federal Airport Act. According to the AIP handbook, the program is designed to advance “airport planning, airport development, noise compatibility planning, and noise compatibility projects.”6 Additionally, the handbook states, “A project to improve a building’s energy efficiency is not eligible as a stand-alone project.”7 AIP’s narrow focus on capacity, system efficiency, and noise does not fit with the need to mitigate and adapt to the urgent threat of global climate change. The program should be reformed to not only allow stand-alone climate projects but to prioritize them when scoring projects for discretionary grant awards. Establish a performance management framework for airport Scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions and water use. Airports are responsible for a large amount of Scope 1 and 2 emissions. The Environmental Protection Agency defines Scope 1 emissions as “direct greenhouse (GHG) emissions that occur from sources that are controlled or owned by an organization (e.g., emissions associated with fuel combustion in boilers, furnaces, vehicles)” and Scope 2 emissions as “indirect GHG emissions associated with the purchase of electricity, steam, heat, or cooling.” 8 Under the framework, each airport receiving AIP funds with more than 100,000 average annual enplanements would be required to conduct an energy- and water-use audit to establish usage baseline. Each qualifying airport would then need to develop a plan for achieving net-zero Scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 along with water use reduction and recycling plans. Increase the maximum allowable passenger facility charge (PFC) from $4.50 to $8.00. Under federal law, commercial airports may charge each enplaning passenger a PFC of up to $4.50 with a maximum of two charges for a one-way flight and four charges on a round-trip. Airports may use PFC revenues on “FAA-approved projects that enhance safety, security, or capacity; reduce noise; or increase air carrier competition.”9 Congress last raised the maximum allowable PFC charge in 2000. Since that time inflation has substantially reduced the purchasing power of these dollars, hampering the ability of airports—especially large hub airports—from raising sufficient revenue for their long-term capital needs. The maximum PFC charge should be raised to $8 per flight segment. Additionally, the FAA bill should amend the program to allow PFC revenues to support stand-alone GHG reduction projects.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Impact › Solves Climate
Tomer and George 23 (Adie Tomer is a Senior Fellow at Brookings Metro, and is an expert in infrastructure policy and urban economics, with a particular focus on transportation and digital technology issues, Caroline George is a Senior Research Assistant at Brookings Metro, “America’s airports aren’t ready for climate change,” Brookings, 3/1/2023, ) - MP
While the environmental threats to commercial airports have risen for decades, the federal government still does not compel airport authorities to harden their assets. There is no requirement that airport authorities draft resilience plans focused on adaptation, which limits their understanding of both individual climate risks and the potential costs to address those risks. The FAA’s Aviation Climate Action Plan recognizes this planning gap: “FAA is considering reinitiating [the Airport Sustainability Planning] program with an emphasis on resilience planning to address climate and extreme weather risks to airports in relation to sustainability.” Likewise, there is no significant FAA capital program exclusively dedicated to investing in resilient airport infrastructure. Instead, the federal government relies on disaster recovery efforts—if anything at all—after impacts occur. To promote interstate commerce, it’s in the federal government’s best interest to address this policy gap. The federal policy gap is matched by a general research gap. As Fiona Greer, Jasenka Rakas, and Arpad Horvath note in their analysis of 108 peer-reviewed journal articles, “The resilience of airports to climate change impacts is a significantly under-researched subject.” A lack of recent and overall publications by the National Academies’ aviation research division, the Airport Cooperative Research Program, affirms this finding. This research gap has practical implications too: We simply know too little about the range of needs and costs in the airport adaptation space. Fortunately, airport authorities and their federal partners have time to devise long-term strategies. We recommend two courses of action, both of which can inform more permanent solutions in the future. First, Congress should incentivize airport authorities to develop climate resilience plans that will guide how their facilities can adapt to emerging environmental conditions. Much like the resilience-focused planning requirements within the PROTECT and WaterSMART programs (or ongoing adaptation planning underway at the Department of Defense), this new planning program would help airports formally understand their climate threats, possible interventions, and the costs to implement them. The FAA can develop standard guidelines, and the program should be large enough to fund plans at multiple large, medium, and small hub airports. The guidelines should include a standard reporting feature that can inform an FAA database of typical project needs and costs. In the long term, lessons from the initial planning effort can inform a more permanent planning requirement and grant program for all airports who receive FAA Airport Improvement Program awards in the future. Second, Congress should launch a pilot program at the FAA to build resilient infrastructure at a small number of major commercial airports. With little resilience-focused construction underway at commercial airports, the FAA needs to experiment with different approaches to protecting these national economic assets. We recommend focusing on a mix of climate threats, such as flooding events at one airport and extreme heat at another, and their related interventions. Airports should be selected based on demonstrated climate need and preparedness to invest, including local fiscal resources. In designing the program, legislators and FAA staff can reference the Airport Environmental Mitigation Pilot Program. While many necessary adaptive interventions are likely to be costly (see San Francisco International Airport’s $590 million Shoreline Protection Program), early investment is our best chance to prevent even more expensive service disruptions and disaster recovery efforts in the future. In the long term, Congress and the FAA can use the lessons from the pilot to determine the best size for a more permanent program and the federal aviation taxes that could be secured to fund it. Combined, these two pilot programs represent a careful first step to hardening the country’s airports. They promise to expand on some of the environmental research efforts already underway across the federal government, such as within the FAA’s Airport Technology Research and Development branch and the Volpe Center. They also promise to create referenceable use cases for other airport authorities looking to protect their assets. There is a permanent tension between the need for Americans to fly and the threat our airports face from a changing climate. Federal airport resilience programs are critical for keeping the country safe and on the move for decades to come.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › AT: Winners Win
Daniel Drezner 21, Professor of international politics at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University, 3/30/2021, “Biden’s brand of bipartisanship,”
The paradox for Biden is that the more successful he is at addressing the pandemic and the economy, the more difficulty he could encounter in building bipartisan coalitions to address other problems. Political Science 101 would suggest that if Biden gets credit for ending the pandemic and restoring a strong economy, that popularity should translate into greater political capital for other problems in the queue.
Political Science 301 offers a cautionary warning: Solved problems fade from view. Biden is appropriately addressing the issues voters care about. But if the pandemic and the economy evolve as expected, voters will quickly bank those successes and focus on thornier problems — like immigration.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › AT: Winners Win
Courtney Subramanian 21, reporter, interviewing William Howell, a political scientist at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy; Joey Garrison, same, 3/7/2021, “‘Dinner table’ politics: Why Joe Biden ditched bipartisan dealmaking to pass his COVID-19 relief,”
Despite the relief plan's popularity outside the Beltway, it is unlikely that momentum from its passage will hurtle Biden into future legislative wins, Howell said.
“The idea that a legislative win begets a subsequent legislative win in this environment is probably asking for too much,” he said, noting the prospect of passing COVID-19 relief was higher than more hot-button issues like immigration or health care.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › AT: Winners Win
Smith 2021
Noah, Prof @Stony Brook University, “Biden Must Avoid Obama's Mistake When Setting His Agenda; Stick to the crisis at hand or risk spurring a backlash that could slow economic reforms and hurt Democrats in 2022,” January 13, 2021,
The universe of possibilities for the Biden administration radically expanded after the Democrats clinched the Senate majority, but the increase in political capital isn’t infinite. When deciding which problems to tackle first, President Joe Biden should prioritize initiatives that address the pandemic while moving the nation toward long-term goals for public health and green-energy stimulus. Biden can learn from the experience of Barack Obama, whose focus on health-insurance reform provoked a midterm backlash and probably forfeited a chance to boost the country out of the Great Recession sooner. He should heed the words of Winston Churchill who urged, “never let a good crisis go to waste.” Because crises are times when the public understands that change is necessary, it’s possible to make deep and lasting reforms. President Franklin D. Roosevelt understood this when he focused parts of his New Deal on long-term alterations to America’s economic structure, such as Social Security and the National Labor Relations Board. These policies not only contributed to the recovery from the Great Depression — the reason for Roosevelt's election — but created a more equal and stable economy in which workers had more bargaining power and old people didn’t have to live in penury. The U.S. was in the depths of the Great Recession when Obama took office in 2009. With the benefit of unified Democratic control of Congress, he passed a fairly substantial stimulus. But it was still too small to make more than a modest dent in the recession. It was too weighted toward tax cuts and it didn’t include much of a bailout for underwater homeowners. Instead, Obama spent much of his political capital on passing the Affordable Care Act, commonly known as Obamacare. Now, it’s true that health insurance was, and is, one of the country’s biggest problems. And it’s also true that Obamacare substantially reduced the ranks of the uninsured, which was a big, important victory. But the system Obama crafted was a compromise, which left the problem of ruinously high costs mostly unaddressed. The legislation failed to satisfy many on the left, with a few now even labeling it as mass murder for not making deeper reforms. Meanwhile, Obamacare remained unpopular throughout Obama’s term in office and may have substantially contributed to the Democrats’ catastrophic midterm election losses in 2010. Alternate histories are difficult to imagine, but it seems likely that had Obama spent his 2009 political capital on things more directly related to the recession — such as more infrastructure spending, a bigger bailout for underwater homeowners and a stronger welfare state — he'd have realized a higher return on that political capital. In other words, a crisis does present an opportunity for long-term reforms, but it’s best to use that opportunity for reforms that address the immediate crisis. The Democratic victories in the Georgia Senate runoffs have given Biden an unexpected opportunity to pass major legislation in the first year of his presidency, instead of relying on executive action and the faint hope of bipartisan compromise. The left will be clamoring for major action on health care and a variety of other momumental issues, but Biden needs to spend his political capital on reforms that are also tied to the COVID-19 pandemic and the resulting recession. The first priority is public health. COVID-19 exposed deep and catastrophic weaknesses in the U.S. public health institutions. Right now, vaccination is proceeding at a glacial pace due to an uncoordinated rollout that dumped vaccines in the lap of state public health agencies utterly unequipped to rapidly inoculate the entire populace. Biden needs to come right out of the gate with a coordinated, well-funded vaccination plan that reaches maximum vaccination rates as fast as possible. In doing so, he also needs to bolster public health agencies and revitalize and reform both the Centers for Disease Control and the Food and Drug Administration after years of neglect. This will be a bigger challenge than is popularly realized because of the possibility that vaccine-resistant virus strains will emerge. Biden will need to reorient much of the U.S. economy toward vaccine production and distribution until COVID-19 has been decisively beaten all around the world. It will take a lot of money and a lot of will. After the virus is beaten, the U.S. economy will still linger in recession unless the government acts decisively to boost demand. The best tool for doing this, as usual, is infrastructure investment. And the rapid progress in solar power and batteries means that Biden has a unique opportunity to address the climate crisis at the same time. A huge build-out of solar power and electric-car charging stations, including subsidies to rapidly replace fossil fuel plants and gasoline vehicles, will ensure that the U.S. economy comes roaring back while making huge steps toward decarbonization. Public health and green infrastructure should be the top priorities for Biden in 2021 and 2022. Yes, there are lots of other things in America that need reform, including health care. But the realities of the political system mean these will have to wait. Reforms must fit the crisis of the day; Biden can’t afford to get sidetracked on a quixotic quest to fix everything that’s wrong with the American economy.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC True
Greg Valliere 22, Chief U.S. Policy Strategist AGF Investments, 11/29/2022, “What Will Joe Biden Do With His Political Capital?,” https://perspectives.agf.com/what-will-joe-biden-do-with-his-political-capital/
POLITICAL CAPITAL is crucial for any president. With it, he can win legislative victories; without it, opponents circle like sharks. For Joe Biden — after a solid second half — the issue is how he will spend his new political capital after the Democrats’ decent showing in the Nov. 8 elections. WITH POLITICAL CAPITAL, Biden can afford to alienate his allies in organized labor; yesterday he essentially told Congress to intervene and end the railroad strike threat. WITH POLITICAL CAPITAL, Biden can afford to anger human rights advocates by staying relatively quiet on the protests that are sweeping through China. Biden does not want to jeopardize chances of better relations with Xi Jinping. AND WITH POLITICAL CAPITAL, Biden can push for a spending package in December that may resurrect the child tax credit, raise the debt ceiling and provide $40 billion or more in new aid to Ukraine. THERE ARE SOME ISSUES — banning assault weapons, for example — that are unattainable. But Biden can demand action on guns. with public support. He also can speak out forcefully against the murderous ayatollahs in Iran, but that’s another issue where Biden’s capital is limited. BIDEN’S BIGGEST ASSET may be the looming GOP chaos in the House of Representatives, where Republicans will have a tiny majority. And the GOP is now consumed with a controversy over Donald Trump’s dinner with a Holocaust denier. BIDEN’S LEGISLATIVE SUCCESSES this year reportedly have made him more inclined to run for a second term. He’s known for extensive deliberations before making a decision, so it could be late winter before Biden decides on whether to run again. IF HE DECLARES THAT HE’S RUNNING, Biden probably won’t have to worry about a serious challenge from any Democrat, most of whom have declared that they won’t run if he does. This includes California Gov. Gavin Newsom, who said over the past weekend that he will not challenge Biden. WITH A SOLID RECORD of legislative wins and a Democratic Senate, Biden may be tempted to overlook the elephant in the room — his age. If he won re-election, Biden’s second term theoretically would end with him at 86 years old. An 86-year-old president is inconceivable to us; it’s a very stressful job, even with political capital.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC True
Maegan Vazquez 21, White House reporter for CNN Politics, 3/10/2021, “Negotiator-in-chief Biden notches his first win but a bipartisan governing loss,” https://www.cnn.com/2021/03/10/politics/joe-biden-negotiator/index.html
He was the top-ranking Democrat on the highly influential Senate Judiciary and Senate Foreign Relations committees for decades. Then, in 2008, Biden served as a sounding board for Obama on national security and foreign policy, according to The New Yorker. And in the Obama White House, Biden subsequently took on a foreign policy-centric portfolio and served as the White House proxy in Congress during contentious moments, like passing the 2009 economic stimulus package and avoiding the fiscal cliff. Biden’s reputation as a dealmaker throughout his time in the Senate and as vice president was forged by his unconventional partnerships across the aisle. Sometimes, that meant compromise in addressing the fiscal cliff directly with Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell. While the compromise was touted as a victory by the Obama administration, some progressives said the administration should have held the line. Democrats such as Colorado Sen. Michael Bennet have subsequently argued “that deal extended almost all those Bush tax cuts permanently.” In other instances, forging unconventional partnerships in order to get things done included policy debates with figures now considered to have values diametrically opposed to the ones Biden has said are at his core. That included co-sponsoring legislation with South Carolina Sen. Strom Thurmond, a segregationist, on several crime bills. It also included hashing out several differences in a chemical weapons treaty with North Carolina Republican Sen. Jesse Helms in the 1990s. Helms, who died in 2008, used racial signals in campaigns and fought against establishing a Martin Luther King Jr. Holiday because he felt the civil rights leader held radical political views. Biden’s return to 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue this year also undoubtedly marks a shift in the way the American president approaches lawmakers on the Hill compared to how things were done over the last four years. Now, there are fewer tweets from the commander in chief personally denigrating members of Congress. The new President in office is not just one who has brought Republicans in for meetings in the Oval Office early in his term, but one who has also congratulated Republican senators for winning their races. And so far, unlike what happened during the Trump years, there have been no known walkouts by the President during White House meetings with members of Congress. Despite four years of a President calling to drain the swamp, Biden’s many years in Washington, allies argue, is for the better. “(Biden’s past experience in) the executive branch is not only relevant experience, but I think it’s going to help them enormously as President. Whereas if went right from the Senate, there would certainly be a gap there,” Pennsylvania Democratic Sen. Bob Casey said. “The other thing is, I think he’s made it his business over the years to interact a lot with mayors and governors.” Biden in action It’s not clearly known what pushes Biden to pick up the phone or schedule a meeting with lawmakers these days to hash out a deal. But in his first months in office, it’s widely known that he’s making those calls and scheduling those meetings frequently. When White House press secretary Jen Psaki was asked about Biden’s relationship with West Virginia Sen. Joe Manchin – the moderate Democrat who has already proved to be a crucial and fickle vote for the President’s legislative proposals – Psaki said Biden is talking to Manchin and many other lawmakers often. Biden has a list of seasoned aides dedicated to legislative efforts, but the White House has suggested that he’s involved in a large portion of the direct negotiations with lawmakers himself. “He speaks with a range of senators and members of Congress and members of the House regularly as well. Obviously, they have meetings here, but he, perhaps because he served for 36 years, certainly doesn’t hesitate to pick up the phone and have a conversation, whether it’s something he agrees with, disagrees with,” Psaki said. “That’s something he’s prone to do, even when it’s not on his schedule for that day. Just when it comes up and it’s an ask somebody makes on the team.”
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC True
Steven E. Schier 11, Professor of Political Science at Carleton; Presidential Studies Quarterly, December 2011, “The Contemporary Presidency: The Presidential Authority Problem and the Political Power Trap,” Presidential Studies Quarterly 41(4)
The concept of political capital captures many of the aspects of a president's political authority. Paul Light defines several components of political capital: party support of the president in Congress, public approval of the president's conduct of his job, the president's electoral margin, and patronage appointments (Light 1999, 15). Light derived this list from the observations of 126 White House staff members he interviewed (1999, 14). His indicators have two central uses. First, Light's research reveals that they are central to the “players' perspective” in Washington. That is, those “in the game” view these items as crucial for presidential effectiveness. Second, they relate to many central aspects of political authority as defined by Skowronek. So on both theoretical and practical levels, the components of political capital are central to the fate of presidencies. The data here will reveal that presidents over the last 70 years have suffered from a trend of declining levels of political capital, a trend that is at the heart of their political authority problem.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC True
Markus Siewert 18, Assistant Professorship of Policy Analysis Hochschule für Politik München an der Technischen Universität München and Former Chair for Policy Analysis at the Bavarian School for Public Policy, June 2018, “It’s Never Easy for the President to Get Exactly What He Wants,” https://d-nb.info/1164077325/34
Third, agenda-setting offers the White House the opportunity to highlight its priorities, how they are distributed across various policy issues, and in which way policies should be packaged (Rudalevige 2005, 437ff; Wayne 2009b, 317ff). Because the resources of any administration to lobby Congress are not infinite and the multiple political arenas are usually heavily crowded with myriad policy items and problems striving to be solved, the White House needs to prioritize its policy agenda. This involves, among other things, to select some issues over others, decide about their sequencing, how to pursue them, and how much political capital it wants or needs to spend on any given item. Therefore, the administration will focus on certain policies with more attention, on others with less, depending on the prioritization by the president but also upon other considerations, such as the overall density of the policy agenda or imminent pressures of the time. The trick is to not overwhelm Congress with the president’s initiatives. As Lyndon B. Johnson famously quipped, “Congress is like a Whiskey drinker. You can put an awful lot of whiskey into a man if you just let him sip it. But if you try to force the whole bottle down his throat at one time, he’ll throw it up.” (cited in Rudalevige 2002, 113). Thus, the failure to prioritize easily leads to overload of Pennsylvania Avenue with Congress at the one end, and to excessive demands and exhaustion for the White House at the other end. The rocky start of the Clinton administration underlines this argument: since the White House did not pursue a ‘rifle-approach’ to define clear policy priorities for its initial months and then execute them, it got lost in numerous legislative battles and mine-fields early on in its first year. Instead it followed a ‘shotgun-approach’ by addressing as many issues as possible at once leading to an overkill and chaos (Rockman 1996; `Sinclair 2000b).
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC Key
Rachel Frazin 23, reporter at the Hill, 3/20/2023, “Climate-incentivizing policies a contention point in farm bill,” https://thehill.com/policy/future-of-farming/3903959-climate-incentivizing-policies-a-contention-point-in-farm-bill/
The farm bill, officially titled the Agriculture Improvement Act, is a major agriculture policy bill that is passed every five years and subject to the influence of both parties. This year it will go before a GOP-led House and Democratic-led Senate — where it needs 60 votes to pass — with both chambers very narrowly divided.
Some of the most contentious areas in the climate arena pertain to whether Congress should be incentivizing climate-smart farming practices.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC Key
Luke Goldstein 23, writing fellow at The American Project, 5/24/2023, “How Washington Bargained Away Rural America,” https://prospect.org/power/2023-05-24-how-washington-bargained-away-rural-america/
Food stamp legislation all but certainly had enough support to pass on a floor vote if the Ag Committee would have allowed it; President Johnson was even able to get a pilot “surplus commodities” program instituted administratively in 1962. Finally, to save the farm bill, the Southerners struck an agreement to build on the surplus commodities demonstration and include food stamps in the package. This arrangement was permanently enshrined in the 1977 farm bill.
“That historical contingency forever changed the politics of the farm and thus the direction of our country’s ag policy,” said Jonathan Coppess, the author of The Fault Lines of Farm Policy and the former administrator of the Farm Service Agency at the Department of Agriculture under President Barack Obama.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › I/L › PC Key
Jim Wiesemeyer 5-11. Washington analyst for Pro Farmer, previously a Washington editor with Doane’s Agricultural Report and Washington editor and managing editor of the Washington Farmletter. "Lawmakers Meet with Biden to Discuss Farm Bill 2023". Drovers. 5-11-2023. https://www.drovers.com/news/ag-policy/lawmakers-meet-biden-discuss-farm-bill-2023
President Biden invited a bipartisan group of lawmakers to the White House this afternoon to discuss the upcoming farm bill reauthorization. Invitees include Rep. G.T. Thompson (R-Pa.), Sen. John Boozman (R-Ark.), Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.), Rep. David Scott (D-Ga.), and USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack.
Stabenow labeled the session as a chance to “have a broader discussion about the farm bill and all the implications for it,” and that it will show “we are working together in a bipartisan way.” She also noted it was a chance for both sides to share their priorities for the bill.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L-Healthcare
Oberlander ’20 (Jonathan Oberlander (oberland@med.unc.edu) is a professor in and chair of the Department of Social Medicine in the School of Medicine and a professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management in the Gillings School of Global Public Health, both at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.) ) – simon.says
President Barack Obama called the 2010 midterm elections a “shellacking.” He was right. Democrats lost 64 seats in the House of Representatives, relinquishing a majority they had won just 4 years before. And although the results reflected a variety of factors, they had a lot to do with anger over the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Republicans had spent the campaign attacking “Obamacare” as a boondoggle that would make private insurance more expensive, undermine Medicare for seniors, and generally wreck everything that was good about the US health care system. With the messy, year-long effort to pass the law still a fresh memory, voters seemed inclined to agree. Public opinion tilted toward disapproval of the law by anywhere from a few percentage points to more than 10, depending on the survey. One study by a group of prominent political scientists concluded that the health care law had cost the Democrats about 25 seats.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L-Healthcare
Oberlander ’20 (Jonathan Oberlander (oberland@med.unc.edu) is a professor in and chair of the Department of Social Medicine in the School of Medicine and a professor in the Department of Health Policy and Management in the Gillings School of Global Public Health, both at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.) ) – simon.says
Additionally, electoral incentives may be increasing partisanship. American elections in recent decades have been highly competitive by historical standards.25 Competitive elections can exacerbate partisanship because if the minority party believes it has a realistic chance to win the next election, then it has incentives to pursue obstructionist strategies to deny the majority party legislative victories.15,25 The result is more delays and brinksmanship, and less ability for lawmakers to form cross-party coalitions to address policy problems.23 The ACA was born into a fiercely polarized and partisan crucible that it has been mostly unable to escape. Large Republican gains in federal and state elections in 2010, which partly reflected a backlash against the ACA, provided the GOP with institutional platforms to undermine the law and its institutionalization.12 In contrast, Medicare did not face Republican majority control of the House and Senate until thirty years into its operation. Partisanship has infused every aspect of the ACA’s political life, from enactment to state implementation, federal administration, and litigation.15 The extraordinary levels of polarization and partisanship in US politics help explain many things: why Republicans have abandoned health policy ideas they once favored, why not a single Republican voted for the ACA, why many states have rejected Medicaid expansion, why the ACA has been subject to so many legal challenges and why the courts have become another venue of political conflict, why public opinion has been divided over the law, why there has been no successful bipartisan effort to remedy the law’s shortcomings, why ACA politics persist as existential rather than incremental, and why the ACA has engendered so much controversy over the past decade despite its moderate roots and considerable achievements. The political fight over the ACA is a front in a broader partisan and ideological struggle that defines contemporary American politics.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L-Healthcare
Krugman 23 Paul Krugman joined The New York Times in 2000 as an Op-Ed columnist. He is distinguished professor in the Graduate Center Economics Ph.D. program and distinguished scholar at the Luxembourg Income Study Center at the City University of New York; “The G.O.P.’s Long War Against Medicare and Social Security;” The New York Times; 2/13/2023; ]
Politically, the most crucial moment in President Biden’s State of the Union address was his declaration that “some Republicans want Medicare and Social Security to sunset every five years.” Why did he say that? Maybe because Senator Rick Scott, when he was the chairman of the National Republican Senatorial Committee, released a fiscal plan last year with the bullet point “All federal legislation sunsets in five years.” Seems straightforward, doesn’t it, despite cries of “lies” from the floor? But right-wing news media — well aware that Biden hit a nerve — has gone into overdrive insisting that his claim was false. Even some mainstream media figures have claimed that Biden was “over the top.” The basis for these denunciations, as far as I can tell, is the idea that calling a plan to sunset legislation a plan to sunset legislation is somehow misleading, because voters don’t know what “sunset” means. Indeed, just because the legislation authorizing a program comes to an end needn’t mean that the program will die; Congress can always vote to reinstate it. The basis for these denunciations, as far as I can tell, is the idea that calling a plan to sunset legislation a plan to sunset legislation is somehow misleading, because voters don’t know what “sunset” means. Indeed, just because the legislation authorizing a program comes to an end needn’t mean that the program will die; Congress can always vote to reinstate it. But, of course, many Republicans do to eviscerate these programs. To believe otherwise requires both willful naïveté and amnesia about 40 years of political history. First of all, if Republicans had absolutely no desire to make major cuts to America’s main social insurance programs, why would they sunset them — and thus create the risk that they wouldn’t be renewed? As Biden might say, c’mon, man. And then there’s that historical record. Two things have been true ever since 1980. First, Republicans have tried to make deep cuts to Social Security and Medicare every time they thought there might be a political window of opportunity. Second, on each occasion they’ve done exactly what they’re doing now: claiming that Democrats are engaged in smear tactics when they describe G.O.P. plans using exactly the same words Republicans themselves used. So, about that history. It has been widely forgotten, but soon after taking office Ronald Reagan proposed . But he backed down in the face of a political backlash, leading analysts at the Cato Institute to call for a “” strategy — their word — creating a coalition ready to exploit a future crisis if and when one arrived. To that end, Cato created the , calling for replacing Social Security with individual accounts — which George W. Bush tried to do in 2005. By then, however, Cato had quietly ; “privatization” polled badly, and Bush insisted that it was a “” used to “scare people.” So there’s a history here, and there’s a similar history for Medicare. Many people probably recall that Newt Gingrich shut down the federal government in 1995. I don’t know how many people realize that Gingrich’s key demand was that President Bill Clinton agree to large and Medicaid. After Republicans gained control of the House in 2010, Paul Ryan began pushing for major cuts in spending. One key element was converting Medicare from a system that pays medical bills to a system offering people to be applied to the purchase of private insurance — that is, vouchers. But many though not all supporters of the Ryan plan insisted that calling vouchers “vouchers” was a left-wing smear. So are people who claim that Biden was over the top unaware of this track record? Do they really not know that Republicans have spent more than four decades trying to find ways to undermine Medicare and Social Security? Are they unaware that there’s a long history of Republicans whining that Democrats are engaged in smear tactics when they describe Republican policies using exactly the same words Republicans used themselves until political consultants urged them to find euphemisms? Well, I don’t think Biden is going to let up. He knows (as do his hysterical opponents) that his attacks are effective, and he has the facts on his side. Oh, and one Republican who might be especially vulnerable to Democratic attacks over social insurance programs is Ron DeSantis. Before becoming Florida’s governor, DeSantis enthusiastically Ryan’s Medicare voucher proposal and declared that allowing seniors to retire in their late 60s was “unsustainable.” As governor, DeSantis has made headlines with culture-war attacks on education and his opposition to public-health measures. But in some ways his biggest achievement, if you might call it that, has been blocking the expansion of Medicaid in his state under the Affordable Care Act; in so doing he’s leaving of Floridians with no realistic way to get health insurance and is leaving billions in federal funds on the table. True, Medicaid, unlike Medicare and Social Security, is means-tested. But it’s also ; DeSantis’s actions suggest that he’s an ideologue who hates social programs on principle. So to go back to our original premise, when Biden suggests that “some Republicans” want to eviscerate key programs, he’s right; and Ron DeSantis is almost surely one of the Republicans he’s right about.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L-UBI
Talton 22 Jon Talton writes about business and the Pacific Northwest economy in the Sunday Seattle Times, “Universal basic income: An argument without end,” The Seattle Times, 4/1/20203, [TMS-GK]
“A program that was designed for poor widows will not be supported in a world where mothers are poor because they are unsupported by their divorced husbands or because they are unwed,” he told The New York Times in 1987. ”A program that was designed to pay mothers to stay at home with their children cannot succeed when we now observe most mothers going out to work.” Others countered that AFDC was too stingy to lift people out of poverty. This program was a big target when Bill Clinton campaigned for the White House to “end welfare as we know it.” Clinton and the Republican Congress did so in 1996. Unfortunately, the much smaller, often temporary, programs that replaced it reduced the income of the poor, especially those in so-called deep poverty (a household with cash income 50% the poverty level). Hence, for supporters of a universal basic income, even more ammunition. But if Republicans gain control of Congress next year, as appears likely, and the White House in 2024, the idea would be dead or corrupted. Most conservatives are convinced aid to the poor discourages work, although the evidence is lacking. Robert Greenstein at the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities think tank argued against universal basic income in 2019, writing that providing all Americans with a basic $10,000 a year would cost $3 trillion a year. That would be three-quarters of the federal budget. Paying for it, along with Social Security, Medicare, defense and infrastructure, would require higher taxes than any point in American history. He added, “And if we want to create more opportunity and reduce racial and other barriers and inequities, we’ll also need to raise new revenues to invest more in areas like preschool education, child care, college affordability, and revitalizing segregated inner-city communities.” This outcome is particularly possible under Republican governance. Then, the “opportunity” of a universal basic income might come at the cost of eliminating or reducing the existing safety net, leaving the poor even worse off. No net and not enough floor.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L-UBI
Gilberstadt ’20 (Hannah Gilberstadt is a former research assistant) . – simon.says
A narrow majority of U.S. adults (54%) say they would oppose the federal government providing a guaranteed income – sometimes called a universal basic income (UBI) – of about $1,000 per month for all adult citizens, whether or not they work; 45% favor the proposal. Young people favor a universal basic income by about two-to-one; much less support among older adults The idea of the government providing a universal basic income for all adult citizens draws broad and intense opposition among Republicans, but is generally supported by Democrats, according to a new Pew Research Center survey. Nearly eight-in-ten Republicans and Republican-leaning independents (78%) oppose the federal government providing a universal basic income of about $1,000 per person, with 62% strongly opposed. A smaller share of Democrats and Democratic leaners (66%) favor a UBI, with just a third supporting the proposal strongly.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L – Green Jobs
Umair Irfan 2019, Correspondent at Vox. Former reporter for ClimateWire at E&E Newss in DC. June 2019, “The Green New Deal is fracturing a critical base for Democrats: unions”, https://www.vox.com/2019/5/22/18628299/green-new-deal-labor-union-2020-democrats
Some unions don’t think that the Green New Deal can pull off its pro-union agenda. But others are optimistic.
The UMWA and other energy unions are skeptical that the Green New Deal builds a bridge sturdy enough to carry workers over to a future with cleaner energy. While there’s language about a jobs guarantee, there is no mechanism in the resolution to fund those jobs nor any specifics about how much they will pay, where they will be, and what benefits will be provided. The average starting salary for a coal mine worker is $60,000, while the average salary for a solar installer is $53,000, so for some workers, a straight switch would be a downgrade.
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L – Green Jobs
Gardner 19 Timothy Gardner, Timothy reports on energy and environment policy and is based in Washington, D.C., March 26th, 2019, “Republicans defeat Green New Deal in U.S. Senate vote Democrats call a stunt”, Reuters, , liam.
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. Senate Republicans on Tuesday defeated the “Green New Deal” resolution that called for tackling climate change by moving the United States off fossil fuels, while Democrats said the vote was a political stunt on an issue that will not die.
FILE PHOTO: Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell speaks with reporters following a policy luncheon in Washington, U.S. March 12, 2019. REUTERS/Erin Scott
2023
CNDI
Disadvantage
2NC › Link › L – FJG
Thomas Palley 9-14-2018; independent economist living in Washington DC; Job Guarantee Programs: Careful What You Wish For; Social Europe; https://www.socialeurope.eu/job-guarantee-programs-careful-what-you-wish-for; DL
A third political economy concern is the productivity of guaranteed employment jobs. A JGP will be sold politically to the public on grounds that JGP workers are productive. However, delivering productivity requires organisational and managerial capacity that the public sector may not have. In that case, there is a risk that such jobs become perceived as “make work”. That would play into the political economy of animus to government, and it could boomerang back in the form of politics opposed to government provision of public goods and services and opposed to macroeconomic stabilisation policy. Careful what you wish for In sum, the debate over JGPs is fraught. Even those who support the aims of a JGP, and are favourably inclined to activist public policy, may still be wary of a JGP for economic and political economy reasons. Implementing a JGP will require political capital and the right political conditions. It might be better to use that favorable moment to introduce new policies (e.g. a UBI) and upgrade a collection of existing different policy modalities that together deliver the same or more benefits without the political economy risks.