Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Topicality
Basic Income › UBI = Sufficient To Live On, No Phase Out

UBI must be sufficient to live on without other earnings, does not phase out, and must be available to most of the population (as opposed to particular subsets).

Hoynes and Rothstein, UC Berkeley Public Policy and Economics Professors, 19

[Hilary W., Jesse, February 2019, NBER Working Paper, “Article Title,” Volume: 1, Number 1, page 3, https://eml.berkeley.edu/~jrothst/publications/w25538.pdf, accessed 6-27-23, S.A.M]

We take three features to define a UBI: a) it provides a sufficiently generous cash benefit to live on, without other earnings; b) it does not phase out or phases out only slowly as earnings rise; and c) it is available to a large proportion of the population, rather than being targeted to a particular subset (e.g., to single mothers).

2023 GDI Topicality
Basic Income › UBI - No Oversight or Conditions

Basic income must be universal and unconditional- no means-testing or work requirements.

Basic Income Earth Network, educational charity organization, No Date [BasicIncome.Org, “About Basic Income, , accessed 6-24-23, S.A.M]

A Basic Income is a periodic cash payment unconditionally delivered to all on an individual basis, without means-test or work requirement.

That is, Basic Income has the following five characeristics:

2023 GDI Topicality
Basic Income › Basic Income = Universal, Unconditional, Regular Cash

UBI, Basic Income, and Basic Income Grant all refer to similar proposals.

Harris, Oxford Brookes University Sociology Lecturer, 23 [Neal, 3-10-22, Critical Sociology, “Critical Theory and Universal Basic Income”, , page, SagePub: , S.A.M]

In this paper, I stick to the term Universal Basic Income (UBI); however, alternative formations such as Basic Income Grant (BIG) and simply ‘Basic Income’ have been used to refer to very similar proposals. For an analysis of the minor differences, see Standing (2017: 19).

2023 GDI Topicality
Basic Income › Basic Income = Universal, Unconditional, Regular Cash

Basic income = UBI

Congressional Research Service 19

[Congressional Research Service, “Universal Basic Income Proposals for the United States”, https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF10865, accessed 6-27-23, S.A.M.]

Overview

2023 GDI Topicality
Basic Income › Basic Income = Universal, Unconditional, Regular Cash

Basic Income is synonymous with universal basic income- it’s a regular sum paid to everyone by the government

Parker, Stanford News Service, 18 [Clifton, 8-8-2018, Stanford News Service, “Stanford scholar explores pros, cons of ‘basic income’,” https://news.stanford.edu/2018/08/08/stanford-scholar-explores-pros-cons-basic-income/, Accessed 6-25-23, S.A.M]

A basic income – also called basic income guarantee, universal basic income or basic living stipend – is a program in which citizens of a country receive a regular sum of money from the government. Tech leaders Elon Musk and Mark Zuckerberg have floated the idea, and the city of Chicago is considering such a proposal as a way to reduce the disruptions of automation in the workforce.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › Or – Means And

Or is the equivalent of and/or

Bryan A Garner, The Elements of Legal Style, 2d ed (New York: Oxford University Press, 2002) at 103:

and/or. Banish from your working vocabulary this "much condemned conjunctive-disjunctive crutch of sloppy thinkers" (citing Raine v Drasin, discussed below) . . . .

The word or usually includes the sense of and:

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › Or – Means And

“Or” means and

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 167)

C.A.2 (Conn.) 1958. Where words in will are placed in the disjunctive, and intent of testator is clear, word “or” is often construed as “and”.—Hight v. U.S., 256 F.2d 795.—Wills 466.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › Or

“Or” does not mean and

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 167)

Ct.Cl. 1878. The word “or” in a contract will not be construed to mean “and,” where it connects propositions reasonably in the alternative. Thus, the word in a contract which binds the contractor to supply so many pounds, more or less, as may be required for the wants of certain government stations between a certain time, cannot be construed to mean “and,” and does not entitle the constractor to furnish all the oats which may be needed at the station.—Merriam v. U.S., 14 Ct.Cl. 289, affirmed 2 S.Ct. 536, 107 U.S. 437, 17 Otto 437, 27 L.Ed. 531.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › Or

Exclusive evidence – ‘or’ means only one

Quirk 93 (Randolph, Professor of Linguistics – University of Durham, and Sidney Greenbaum, “A University Grammar of English”, http://grammar.ccc.commnet.edu/grammar/conjunctions.htm)

OR To suggest that only one possibility can be realized, excluding one or the other: "You can study hard for this exam or you can fail." To suggest the inclusive combination of alternatives: "We can broil chicken on the grill tonight, or we can just eat leftovers. To suggest a refinement of the first clause: "Smith College is the premier all-women's college in the country, or so it seems to most Smith College alumnae." To suggest a restatement or "correction" of the first part of the sentence: "There are no rattlesnakes in this canyon, or so our guide tells us." To suggest a negative condition: "The New Hampshire state motto is the rather grim "Live free or die." To suggest a negative alternative without the use of an imperative (see use of and ): "They must approve his political style or they wouldn't keep electing him mayor."

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › Or

‘Or’ can be one – does not have to be both

Webster’s 96 (Revised Unabridged Dictionary, “Or”, http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/or)

1. One of two; the one or the other; -- properly used of two things, but sometimes of a larger number, for any one

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And

Not “or”

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 167)

C.A.5 (Tex.) 1988. The word “and” is to be accepted for its conjunctive connotation rather than as a word interchangeable with “or” except where strict grammatical construction would frustrate clear legislative intent.—Bruce v. First Federal Sav. And Loan Ass’n of Conroe, Inc., 837 F.2d 712—Statut 197.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And

Requires both

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 166)

C.A.Fed. 2001. Inclusion of conjunctive “and” in regulation indicated that all three of the enumerated criteria had to be demonstrated.—Watson v. Department of Navy, 262 F. 3d 1292, certiorari denied 122 S.Ct. 817, 534 U.S. 1083, 151 L.Ed.2d 700.—Admin Law 412.1.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And

In addition

Ansell 00 (Mary, “Chapter 28: Conjunctions”, English Grammar: Explanations and Exercises, http://www.fortunecity.com/bally/durrus/153/gramch28.html)

Coordinate conjunctions are used to join two similar grammatical constructions; for instance, two words, two phrases or two clauses. e.g. My friend and I will attend the meeting. Austria is famous for the of its landscape and the hospitality of its people. The sun rose and the birds began to sing. In these examples, the coordinate conjunction and is used to join the two words friend and I, the two phrases the beauty of its landscape and the hospitality of its people, and the two clauses the sun rose and the birds began to sing. The most commonly used coordinate conjunctions are and, but and or. In addition, the words nor and yet may be used as coordinate conjunctions. In the following table, each coordinate conjunction is followed by its meaning and an example of its use. Note the use of inverted word order in the clause beginning with nor. Coordinate Conjunctions and:  in addition She tried and succeeded.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And/Or

“And/or” means or

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 224)

Or. 1942. As used in the constitutional amendment and statue relating to the creation of public utility districts, the hybrid phrase “and/or” may be construed as meaning “or”.—Ollilo v. Clatskanie People’s Utility Dist., 132 P.2d 416, 170 Or. 173.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And/Or

And/or is now grammatically acceptable

Brians 13 , Paul Brians, Emeritus Professor of English, Washington State University Pullman Common Errors in English Usage: The Book (3rd Edition, November, 2013), http://public.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/andor.html)

The legal phrase “and/or,” indicating that you can either choose between two alternatives or choose both of them, has proved irresistible in other contexts and is now widely acceptable though it irritates some readers as jargon. However, you can logically use it only when you are discussing choices which may or may not both be done: “Bring chips and/or beer.” It’s very much overused where simple “or” would do, and it would be wrong to say, “you can get to the campus for this morning’s meeting on a bike and/or in a car.” Choosing one eliminates the possibility of the other, so this isn’t an and/or situation.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And/Or

“And/or” can mean either – defer to general community practice

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 224)

N.D. 1964. “And/or” as used in contract may mean either “and” or “or”, and interpretation should be one which will best effect purpose of parties as determined in light of equities of the case.—Hummel v. Kranz, 126 N.W.2d 786—Contracts 159.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And/Or

X or Y or both

Wood 1 (Diane P., Circuit Judge – United States Court of Appeals, “Susan E. Hess, Plaintiff-Appellee, v. Hartford Life & Accident Insurance Company”, 12-13, http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/cgi-bin/getcase.pl?court=7th&navby=case&no=002043)

Having determined that Hess's 1996 employment contract is properly a part of the administrative record the district court was entitled to consider, we must next decide whether Hartford could reasonably have determined that Hess's benefits as of April 19, 1996, should have been based only on her 1995 draw amount. Like the district court, we cannot read the contract that way. Hess's 1996 contract clearly states that the draw system was to be phased out as of April 5. The contract also specifies that her benefits, including long-term disability benefits, would be calculated based on her "base salary and/or draw." (We note in passing that the phrase "and/or" has its critics. Bryan A. Garner reports in A Dictionary of Modern Legal Usage 56 (2d ed. 1995), that "and/or has been vilified for most of its life-- and rightly so." He goes on to say, however, that the expression, while "undeniably clumsy, does have a specific meaning (x and/or y = x or y or both)." Id.) Here, this would mean that Hess could have her benefits calculated on the basis of her base salary, or her draw, or both. In the context of Fleet's transition away from a draw system, the only reasonable interpretation of this provision was that the benefits would be based on the draw while it was in effect and on the base salary thereafter. As of April 5, Hess was thus contractually entitled to a benefits package based on her base salary--that is, based on the average of her previous two years' commissions. The fact that Fleet may have breached the contract (or been slow in implementing its details) by failing to move from the draw system to the base salary system until June 1 does not change the package of compensation and benefits to which Hess was contractually entitled. Nor could the fact that Fleet failed to inform Hartford about the date the change-over was to have occurred affect Hess's benefit amount. The Hartford policy states that "[i]f [Fleet] gives The Hartford any incorrect information, the relevant facts will be determined" to establish the correct benefit amount. Once informed by Hess's attorney that Hess believed the information Fleet provided Hartford was incorrect, it was incumbent on the examiner to refer to Hess's employment contract to determine her actual regular monthly pay. Had he done so, he would have seen that Hess became entitled to the higher level of benefits on April 5, two weeks before her disability. The district court therefore did not err when it concluded that Hartford's failure to consider the contract was arbitrary and capricious.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And/Or

And/or means one or the other or both

Pullum 8 (Geoffrey K., Professor of General Linguistics – University of Edinburgh, “”, Language Log, 4-14, http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=35)

Does and/or mean "and and or", or "and or or"? That is, if I say I am interested in A and/or B, do I mean I'm interested in A and B and I'm interested in A or B, or do I mean that I'm interested in A and B or I'm interested in A or B? (You may want to say that it means I'm interested in A and B and/or I'm interested in A or B; but in that case I repeat my question.) Having reflected on it for a little while, I am convinced that the answer has to be that A and/or B must mean "A and B or A or B". That is, if an entity A is claimed to have the property of being F and/or G, the claim amounts to saying that either (i) A has the property of being both F and G or (ii) A has the property of being either F or G. And to claim that F is a property of entities A and/or B is to claim that either (i) F holds for A and B or (ii) F holds for A or B. However, in that case and/or is effectively identical in meaning with or, so it is at first rather hard to see why and/or exists at all. But I do have a guess. The right theory of what or means in English is that it is in general inclusive but that sometimes the exclusive special case is conveyed as a conversational implicature. I'm going to study linguistics at either York or Edinburgh would often be taken to have the exclusive sense: since you typically go to a single university to take a single degree, and during the degree course you have no time to study elsewhere, a decision to choose York would normally exclude choosing Edinburgh as well. The exclusive sense is thus conveyed: one or the other of York and Edinburgh will be chosen, and if it is York it will not be Edinburgh, and if it is Edinburgh it will not be York. But of course if you think about it, someone who says she is choosing between those two universities does not commit herself for life to never studying at the other. When the two alternatives exclude each other, then the exclusive meaning is the only one that makes sense. If you are asked whether you want to sit in the stalls or in the balcony, it's one or the other but not both, because you can only be in one place at one time. When they don't exclude each other, it's always understood that or allows for both: obviously someone whose ambition is to win either an Oscar or an Olympic medal wouldn't feel a failure if they won both. Winning both would satisfy the ambition in spades. So my guess would be that and/or is a way of underlining the point that the or is to be understood in its inclusive sense rather than its exclusive sense. Sometimes you want to explicitly indicate "or more than one of the above", and and/or does that. Take the first example of and/or in the Wall Street Journal corpus of 1987-1989 (a 44-million-word collection of random articles that linguists often use as a source for real-life examples because the Linguistic Data Consortium — the host for the giant Language Log servers — made it available in 1993 nice and cheap). The example (which actually happens to be a quotation from the Washington Post) is this: Too many of his attitudes, claims and complaints are careless, conflicting, dubious, inaccurate, mean, petty, simplistic, superficial, uninformed and/or pointlessly biased. I take it as obvious that if one hundred percent of the hapless man's attitudes, claims and complaints had all ten properties — every single one was careless and conflicting and dubious and inaccurate and mean and petty and simplistic and superficial and uninformed and pointlessly biased — then the quoted claim would be regarded as true, not false. An or would have done the job here, but the and/or injects a (logically redundant) reminder that it may well be the case that more than one of the list of ten properties applies to the miserable individual in question.

2023 GDI Topicality
And/Or › And/Or

One or the other or both

Words and Phrases 7 (3A W&P, p. 220)

C.A.1 (Mass.) 1981. Words “and/or,” for contract purposes, commonly mean the one or the other or both.—Local Division 589, Amalgameted Transit Union, AFL-CIO, CLC v. Com. Of Mass., 666 F.2d 618, certiorari denied Local Div. 589, Amalgamated Transit Union AFL-CIO v. Massachusetts, 102 S.Ct. 2928, 457 U.S. 1117, 73 L.Ed.2d 1329.—Contracts 159.

2023 GDI Topicality
Social Security › SS Includes Medicare

Medicare is a part of the Social Security Act

Brain Injury Association of America, No Date [Brain Injury Association of America, “Medicare (Title XVIII of the Social Security Act)​”, ., accessed 6/26/2023,ero]

Medicare was established in 1965 under Title XVIII of the Social Security Act as a federal health insurance program for individuals age 65 and older, regardless of income or health status. Individuals pay taxes throughout their working lives and generally become eligible for Medicare when they reach age 65. More than 55 million people rely on Medicare for their health insurance. About 17 percent of these individuals are under age 65. The program is administered by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), an agency of the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.