2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—Ext
Bhandari, Third Way researcher, ‘19
[Ryan Bhandari, Senior Policy Advisor, Economic Program, Third Way, “What Is the “Federal Jobs Guarantee” and What Are People Saying About It?” THIRD WAY, 3—25—19, , accessed 6-9-23]
#3: It could crowd out tens of millions of private sector jobs. There are currently 54 million people who earn $15 an hour or less. When they find out the federal government is offering $15 an hour plus benefits and permanent job security, many of those workers would quit their current job and join the federal workforce.3 Companies that could afford to would raise wages to keep some of these workers; other companies would simply go out of business. The labor markets would be controlled by the government in ways never seen before in America. And even if just half of low-wage private sector workers quit, the number of federal employees would rise by between 35 and 40 million.4 Costs to the government would then rise to anywhere from $1.6 trillion to $2.24 trillion per year, and the private sector would see massive repercussions.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—2NC
Paddison, award-winning journalist, ‘18
[Lauran Paddison, former CUNY Resilience Journalism Fellow and journalist, “What Is A Federal Jobs Guarantee?” HUFFINGTON POST, 7—6—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
Meanwhile, criticisms from the right tend to focus on cost. Brian Riedl of the Manhattan Institute, a right-leaning think tank, says he applauds the goal of encouraging good jobs at high wages, but calls the proposal of a guaranteed jobs program “fantasy land.” His criticisms are many and vociferous.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Crowd-Out—2NC
Gulker, AIER Senior Research Fellow, ‘18
[Max Gulker, PhD, Economics, Stanford University, Senior Research Fellow, American Institute for Economic Research, THE JOB GUARANTEE: A CRITICAL ANALYSIS, American Institute for Economic Research, 2018, p. 14-15]
6.1 Labor Market Disruptions
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Cost—2NC
Summers- Former United States Secretary of the Treasury- 2018
Lawrence H. Summers. Washington Post. Jobs for All- Take the idea seriously but not literally. . July 2, 2018/ DOA: 06/17/23. AR.
The impulse behind the latest “big” progressive idea of creating a federal job guarantee is entirely valid. Studies show that those without jobs are much more likely to be dissatisfied with their lives, to become addicted to alcohol or drugs and to be abusive within their families than even those working at low wages they find inadequate. On this point, the U.S. economy is falling short of its potential. The fraction of the adult population between ages 25 and 54 that is working or seeking work has declined over the past 20 years. Despite America’s vaunted labor-market flexibility, the chance that a 25- to 54-year-old man will be out of work is much greater than it is in France and not very different than what it is in Spain . And in sharp contrast to the rest of the world, the fraction of adult women working in the United States has been declining since 1999 . These trends are important causes of the increasingly bitter nature of U.S. politics and of resistance to technological change and overseas trade. President Trump received disproportionate support in parts of the country where joblessness increased most. If the United States could guarantee jobs in even a modestly efficient manner and in a way that significantly increased employment, it would be a very good thing. I want to be enthusiastic about job-guarantee proposals. But at a time when cynicism about government runs strong, it is important for progressives to avoid making promises that they cannot keep. We must rigorously examine the practicality of a job guarantee. A first question is how much to pay. A program of last-resort employment could likely provide the minimum wage and low benefits. But that will not help those laid off from highly paid manufacturing jobs or those who expect to earn wages well above the poverty line. While such a proposal could help many young people, it is far from clear that it would connect with the principal concerns of Rust Belt adults. On the other hand, if the guaranteed jobs paid premium wages, say double the $7.25 per hour national minimum wage, they would be an attractive alternative for a quarter or more of the workforce, raising questions of cost and economic disruption. Suppose a $15 per hour guaranteed job drew 4 million additional people into the workforce and also attracted 10 million existing employees, just one quarter of those for whom it would represent a wage increase. The cost, once benefits, materials and supervisory needs are included, would, conservatively, be $60,000 per worker. That would increase government spending by $840 billion — one-fifth of the current federal total. If wages for the 30 million lower-wage workers who remained in the private sector went up by just $4 per hour, private-sector costs would rise by $240 billion. The burden would largely fall on small businesses and disproportionately hurt restaurants and other major employers of low-wage labor. A second question job guarantees raise is what all these new workers would do. The current federal government civilian workforce comprises 2 million people . Meaningfully increasing employment or offsetting adverse trends even if all hired came off the sidelines of the workforce through a jobs program would require boosting the federal workforce by at least 50 percent. The United States has large needs, for example in infrastructure and care of the aged. At the federal level, these are met through contracting, not direct hiring. Using an employment guarantee to address these national problems would require significant restructuring of the way services are provided, likely with an efficiency cost. A final question concerns the macroeconomics of a jobs guarantee. If the Federal Reserve saw the budget deficit expanding substantially, a tightening of the labor market or upward pressure on wages, it would probably respond by raising interest rates significantly. This would discourage spending and offset the employment gains from a guarantee scheme. If, on the other hand, the program was financed with new taxes, demand from those who paid the taxes would go down. That would reduce private-sector employment and offset the gains from an employment guarantee.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Cost—2NC
Stain, American Enterprise Institute researcher, ‘18
[Michael R. Stain, Director, Economic Policy Studies and Resident Scholar, American Enterprise Institute, “Private Sector, Not Government, Is Key to Job Creation,” BLOOMBERG, 5—1—18, , accessed 5-1-23]
It’s hard to overstate the silliness of this proposal, as many pointed out last week.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: Cost—2NC
Haskins, Heartland Institute research, ‘20
[Justin Haskins, Heartland Institute researcher, “Rep. Ilhan Omar’s Government Jobs Program Would Be Economic Disaster,” FOX NEWS, 8—1—20, , accessed 6-9-23]
Creating a jobs guarantee program that would bankrupt our country, create unsustainable deficits, slow economic growth, and increase the government’s control over the labor market is one of the worst ideas radical Democrats have proposed — and that’s saying a lot.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Links › Economy L: 2NC
Gulker, AIER researcher ‘18
[Max Gulker, Senior Research Fellow, American Insitute for Economic Research, “Proposed Federal Jobs Guarantee Is Too Big to Exist,” American Institute for Economic Research, 5—4—18, , accessed 6-8-23]
The second concern is the the program’s impact on the economy. I’m not talking about stimulus models and tax projections here. What would happen if anyone, whether in the private or public sector, prescribed from the top down what 10 percent of our workforce was going to do? If everyone just dug holes, as the old saying goes, the shovel industry would be revolutionized overnight.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Productivity—2NC
Tyson, senior reporter at CFO, 23
Jim Tyson- Senior Reporter at CFO. CFO. AI boosts productivity 14%: NBER case study. . May 1, 2023. DOA: 06/20/23. AR.
Dive Brief: Generative artificial intelligence boosted worker productivity 13.8% at a Fortune 500 company while reducing employee turnover and increasing customer satisfaction, according to a case study published by the National Bureau of Economic Research. AI is especially helpful in upgrading performance among less-skilled and less-experienced workers, researchers at the MIT Sloan School of Management and Stanford University found in what they said is the first empirical study of generative AI’s impact on the workplace. “Access to AI-generated recommendations increases worker productivity, improves customer sentiment and is associated with reductions in employee turnover,” the researchers found using data from 5,179 customer support agents at an unidentified company that provides business process software. Dive Insight: Generative AI has seized the attention of CFOs and their C-suite colleagues since the introduction in November of OpenAI’s ChatGPT, prompting forecasts that businesses will rapidly adopt the technology. In the next few years the market for generative AI will probably balloon at a 32.2% compound annual growth rate — from $42.6 billion in 2023 to $98.1 billion in 2026, according PitchBook. “AI is a fast-evolving technology with great potential to make workers more productive, to make firms more efficient and to spur innovations in new products and services,” according to a White House report released in December.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Productivity—2NC
Liu 4—25
Jennifer Liu- lead work reporter for CNBC. CNBC. Stanford and MIT study: A.I. boosted worker productivity by 14%—those who use it ‘will replace those who don’t’. . Apr 25 2023. DOA: 06/20/23. AR.
Artificial intelligence tools like chatbots helped boost worker productivity at one tech company by 14%, according to new research from Stanford and MIT that was first reported by Bloomberg. The study is thought to be the first major real-world application of generative AI in the workplace. Researchers measured productivity of more than 5,000 customer support agents, based primarily in the Philippines, at a Fortune 500 enterprise software firm over the course of a year. Tech support agents who used AI tools that created conversational scripts boosted their productivity, measured as issues resolved per hour, by 14% on average, but the improvement was even more pronounced for “novice and low-skilled workers” who were able to get their work done 35% faster. In some cases, using AI trumped having real-life work experience: Customer service agents with two months of experience who used AI support performed as well or better than agents with over six months of experience working without AI. Meanwhile, the use of AI tools showed a minimal impact on “experienced or highly skilled workers,” the authors note, and at times served as a distraction. AI support can be especially helpful to entry-level or early-career workers, says Lindsey Raymond, an MIT Ph.D. candidate and co-author of the paper. Less experienced workers benefit from AI by taking its recommendations to get up to speed and learn skillsets that usually come with experience. With that said, AI tools benefit from the best and brightest workers training the AI itself by providing examples of best practices, which the technology then turns into recommendations for others workers to apply.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Productivity—2NC
Shalal, reporter for Reuters, 23
Andrea Shalal- reports on the White House, global trade and economics, the IMF and the World Bank, for Reuters for 34 years. Reuters. Shifts in US employment may drive gains in labor productivity -Treasury. https://www.reuters.com/markets/us/shifts-us-employment-may-drive-gains-labor-productivity-treasury-2023-03-10/. March 10, 2023. DOA: 06/20/23. AR.
WASHINGTON, March 10 (Reuters) - Shifts in U.S. employment over the past two years toward sectors with higher wages and productivity, and higher average hours worked, may drive further gains in labor productivity going forward, two top Treasury Department economists said on Friday. The U.S. recovery from the COVID-19 pandemic has seen employment recovering "much faster" than after recent recessions, Ben Harris, assistant secretary for economic policy, and Tara Sinclair, deputy assistant secretary for macroeconomics, said in an analysis. Assessing U.S. economic developments two years after President Joe Biden's COVID relief package, the American Rescue Plan, Harris and Sinclair said the labor market recovery had been "exceptionally strong," the economy was now over 5% bigger than before the pandemic began and core inflation was lower than in many major advanced economies. "Acknowledging that other advanced economies faced different economic shocks — notably, our European partners were more adversely affected by Russia’s war against Ukraine — the evidence shows that the U.S. economic recovery has been quite strong," they wrote. "Data suggests that the actions taken by the Biden administration meaningfully contributed to the pace of recovery and strength of the labor market." The posting coincided with a release of new Labor Department data showing a slight increase in the U.S. unemployment rate to 3.6% in February and higher-than-expected payroll gains, with hiring concentrated in a narrower range of industries. Harris and Sinclair did not address the fresh data, but noted significant differences in employment statistics among Group of Seven economies in the early phase of the pandemic, largely due to differences in how those economies supported workers and businesses during the shutdowns. In the United States and Canada, unemployment insurance was most suited to rapid, large-scale support. Meanwhile many European economies leveraged social safety nets, often in a way that led to continued employment in official statistics. Despite differences in the initial response, employment rates were now low across the G7 nations, they said. But labor productivity growth in the United States had outpaced that of Europe and Japan, possibly because the U.S. unemployment insurance system allowed greater movement of labor relative to systems that preserved employer attachment. "In general, U.S. employment has reallocated from lower wage industries to high-wage and higher productivity industries. U.S. employment has also shifted to industries with higher average hours worked, implying a stronger recovery in hours relative to employment. This reallocation of labor may drive further gains in labor productivity going forward," they said.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Labor Market Strong—A2 “Wages”
Tanzi, Bloomberg journalist, ‘23
[Alexandre Tanzi, journalist, “Wage Growth Is Slowing Sharply in US Job Postings, Indeed Says,” BLOOMBERG, 6—7—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
Wage growth in US job postings has been softening for more than a year now, and at the current rate it could return to pre-pandemic levels by early 2024, according to Indeed Hiring Lab.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Labor Market Strong—General
U.S. Bank ‘23
[staff, “The Effect of the Job Market on the Economy,” US Bank, 6—5—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
The trends of recent jobs reports, while still showing a reasonable level of new job creation, appeared to signal the effects of the Fed’s efforts to slow the job market. The Fed is focused, in part, on rising labor costs, which can influence broader inflation measures. “Wage growth pressures appear to be easing,” says Rob Haworth, senior investment strategy director for U.S. Bank. “We’re seeing more people starting to re-enter the workforce. If these trends continue, that has the potential to help push wage growth down in the months to come – a positive trend for inflation.”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Labor Market Strong—General
Baccardax, journalist, ‘23
[Martin Baccardax, journalist “Jobs Report Lifts Hope for Soft Landing as Hiring Up, Wages Slow; Stocks Surge,” THE STREET, 6—2—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
The U.S. economy added far more new jobs than expected last month, but slowing wage growth and a bump higher in the headline unemployment rate suggest that gains won't likely alter market projections for Federal Reserve rate hikes.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Inflation—2NC
Caldwell- senior U.S. economist for Morningstar Research, 23
Preston Caldwell- senior U.S. economist for Morningstar Research. Morningstar. Why We Expect Inflation to Fall in 2023. . May 26, 2023. DOA: 06/19/23. AR.
We’re projecting large deflation in prices for durable goods, food, and energy over 2023-27. For durable goods, resolution of the semiconductor shortage should play a large role in expanding supply. A normalization of consumer spending mix will also shift demand away from durables (and other goods) and back into services. For food and energy, prices should subside as these industries adjust to disruption from the Russia-Ukraine conflict and other factors. We don’t expect the price spikes in energy and durables to be replaced by new problems elsewhere in the economy. We expect moderate wage growth and the absence of any long-lasting supply disruptions to keep general inflation at restrained levels. Inflation expectations (which can fuel high inflation in a self-fulfilling prophecy) also look restrained. Fed tightening will cool off the overall economy substantially in 2023 and 2024, extinguishing the inflationary fire before it gets out of control. Supply Chains Are Healing as Demand Normalizes and Capacity Expands A broad array of production and logistical disruptions have contributed to inflation in durables and other parts of the economy. But supply chains are healing as demand normalizes and capacity catches up. The New York Fed’s Global Supply Chain Pressure Index (which captures ocean shipping costs and delivery times, among other indicators) is now, stunningly, showing looser supply chain conditions than before the pandemic. There’s more help on the way. As one indicator on the logistics side, there are enough container ships set to be delivered over the next several years to expand the current fleet by 30%. On the manufacturing side, capacity is also expanding in the U.S. and other major economies (most notably China). Beyond these broad supply-chain disruptions, perhaps one half of the runup in durable goods prices looks to be a result of the semiconductor shortage alone. Semiconductor manufacturing capacity is frantically expanding, with 2022 capital expenditures having soared 90% above prepandemic levels. It takes a while to ramp up capacity, but it is now a question of when—not if—the semiconductor shortage will be cleared. Inflation in 2023: This Is Not the 1970s’ Oil-Price Shock With inflation in 2022 reaching its highest since 1981, many have drawn an analogy to the “Great Inflation” of the 1970s, suggesting inflation will remain stubbornly high for the next decade. But not all bouts of high inflation were as long-lasting as in the 1970s. One critical difference between today’s episode and the 1970s is the nature of the supply shocks, particularly regarding energy prices. Morningstar’s energy team forecasts oil prices to fall to $55 per barrel in 2026 (West Texas Intermediate) from an average of $92 per barrel in 2022. This would make it about where prices were in 2019 before the pandemic. Oil prices have jumped owing to sanctions on Russia, and globally suppliers have been caught off-guard by the strength of the postpandemic recovery. But we expect producers to steadily ramp up production until prices fall back to the marginal cost of production, which we assess at $55. Additionally, the recent plunge in natural gas prices will steadily roll over into lower household utility bills over the next year or so. The contrast with the 1970s’ oil-price shock could not be greater. Oil prices first tripled in 1973 and ended the decade up 11 times versus 1970 levels. There were short-run disruptions that contributed to that surge, but the long-term story was the awakening of OPEC’s market power, which never returned to the rapid production growth exhibited in the 1960s. Also, other cheap sources of crude had been tapped out by this time, necessitating a shift to offshore drilling and other, more-expensive sources. These kinds of secular forces driving higher prices explain why the 1970s’ oil shock never fully receded—but secular forces aren’t the main drivers in today’s oil price surge.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Inflation—2NC
Duggan 6/13
Wayne Duggan- Forbes Advisor contributor. He is also a staff writer at Benzinga and author of the book "Beating Wall Street With Common Sense" and has contributed news and analysis to U.S. News & World Report, Seeking Alpha, InvestorPlace.com and The Motley Fool. and Benjamin Curry- the Retirement and Investing Editor for Forbes Advisor. With two decades of business and finance journalism experience, Ben has covered breaking market news, written on equity markets for Investopedia, and edited personal finance content for Bankrate and LendingTree.. Forbes Advisor. The Price Is Right: U.S. Inflation Hits Two-Year Lows In May. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/current-inflation-rate/#:~:text=CPI%20by%20the%20Numbers,declined%20for%2011%20months%20straight. Jun 13, 2023. DOA: 06/19/23. AR
Markets Believe Inflation Is on the Mend David Bahnsen, chief investment officer at The Bahnsen Group, says Tuesday’s CPI report is a clear sign the Fed has won its battle against inflation. “Tuesday’s CPI suggests that inflation has been defeated,” Bahnsen says. “:Most of the inflation we are seeing is coming from housing, but it takes time for home price declines to show up in the CPI data, so today’s 4% inflation rate is actually much closer to the 2% Fed target.” The central bank is attempting to navigate a balancing act of aggressively raising interest rates to bring down inflation without tipping the U.S. economy into recession. Higher interest rates increase borrowing costs for companies and consumers, slowing economic activity. Up to this point, the U.S. labor market and stock market have mostly shrugged off inflation and rising interest rates. The S&P 500 is up 12.6% year-to-date as investors seemingly anticipate a soft landing for the U.S. economy. In fact, the S&P 500 officially entered bull market territory in early June, surpassing a 20% gain from its October 2022 lows.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Inflation—2NC
Duggan 6/13
Wayne Duggan- Forbes Advisor contributor. He is also a staff writer at Benzinga and author of the book "Beating Wall Street With Common Sense" and has contributed news and analysis to U.S. News & World Report, Seeking Alpha, InvestorPlace.com and The Motley Fool. and Benjamin Curry- the Retirement and Investing Editor for Forbes Advisor. With two decades of business and finance journalism experience, Ben has covered breaking market news, written on equity markets for Investopedia, and edited personal finance content for Bankrate and LendingTree.. Forbes Advisor. The Price Is Right: U.S. Inflation Hits Two-Year Lows In May. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/investing/current-inflation-rate/#:~:text=CPI%20by%20the%20Numbers,declined%20for%2011%20months%20straight. Jun 13, 2023. DOA: 06/19/23. AR
CPI by the Numbers A combination of higher interest rates, easing supply chain constraints and tighter credit has helped tame inflation in 2023. As of May, the annualized rate of CPI inflation has declined for 11 months straight.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Inflation—2NC
Reuters ‘23
[Susan Heavey and David Lawder, journalists, “Yellen Says U.S. Inflation Easing as Some Sectors Slow, Labor Market Strong,” REUTERS, 6—7—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
The U.S. economy is strong amid robust consumer spending but some areas are slowing down, U.S. Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said on Wednesday, adding that she expects continued progress in bringing inflation down over the next two years with a strong labor market.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Economy Strong Now / No Recession
Schafer, Yahoo journalist, ‘23
[Josh Schafer, journalist, “US Economy Beats Back ‘Dubious’ Recession Fears After GDP, Jobs Data Top Expectations,” YAHOO FINANCE, 5—25—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
On Thursday, revisions to first quarter economic data showed the economy grew faster than initially expected despite inflation coming in higher than first noted.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Uniqueness › Economy U: Economy Strong Now / No Recession
Pound, CNBC journalist, ‘23
[Jesse Pound, journalist, “Consumers Are Keeping the U.S. Out of a Recession. It’s Getting Harder,” CNBC, 6—8—23, , accessed 6-10-23]
The widely predicted U.S. recession remains out of sight as the first half of 2023 winds down, but the consumer sector that has fueled a remarkable recovery from the pandemic shutdowns may finally be showing signs of fraying.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
Topshelf › Economy DA: Turns Democracy—2NC
Glaser 9 – Prof Econ @ Harvard, Edward, Building walls with US trading partners, The Boston Globe, 3-6,
Few findings in social science are more robust than the fact that democracies almost never fight one another. If the current downturn causes democracies to become dictatorships, then the probability of conflict between those places and our own democracy will increase. Since dictators are far more likely to slaughter their own people, America may be faced with the awful choice of military intervention or standing by and watching the deaths mount. Democracy is bolstered by prosperity and damaged by downturns. Since the pioneering work of Martin Lipset 50 years ago, social scientists have tried to understand why democracies and wealth go together. My colleague Robert Barro found that this link exists not because democracies increase prosperity, but because prosperity supports democracy. The appeal of democracy's enemies increases when democracies, like the Weimar Republic, are unable to deliver economic success.