Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2023 GDI Disadvantage
Topshelf › Economy DA: Turns Climate—2NC

Turns warming – focus, rollback, and halts investment

Emilie 16 (Emilie Mazzacurati, Founder and CEO of Four Twenty Seven, a climate risk & resilience research firm, “What Brexit Means for Climate,” 6/29/16 )

Financial Implications: Impact on Efforts to Regulate and Price Climate Risk A very immediate impact from Brexit-induced financial volatility and risk of recession will be felt on efforts to better understand, regulate and price climate-related risks on financial markets. The very institutions and individuals that have been leading this effort globally – the Financial Stability Board and its Chair, Mark Carney, who is also the Chair of the Bank of England, as well as to some extent the Securities and Exchange Commission in the U.S., are going to be entirely focused on preventing a complete collapse of the British economy and a global recession. This will necessarily cause distraction away from the recent efforts to push climate change higher on the agenda of financial decision-makers. Assuming the world’s financial leaders are successful in preventing a global recession and the volatility of financial markets continues, we expect the discussion to resume and allow the recommendations from the Task Force on Financial Climate-Related Disclosure to garner the attention needed from global financial regulatory bodies. However, if Britain’s decision to leave the EU were to cause continued turmoil on financial markets around the world, leading to a major recession, the impacts on climate change policy could be extensive, and mostly negative. Recessions in general are bad for the environment because jobs and financial volatility typically take precedence on the political agenda over environmental regulations and climate policy, often perceived as putting added burden on the economy. A global recession could lead to budget cuts and increased contention over energy and climate budgets, and otherwise lead to a scale back of efforts to reduce emissions. Financial instability could also mean a setback for investments in clean energy, with financial flows likely to flock towards safe havens (U.S. bonds, gold) and away from riskier investments.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Topshelf › Economy DA: 1NC

Strong economy prevents global war existential terror, prolif, disease, and pollution

Haass ’20 [Dr. Richard Haass, Master’s and Doctorate of Philosophy Degrees from Oxford University, Former Director of Policy Planning for the Department of State, Veteran Diplomat Under 4 Presidential Administrations, Awarded the Presidential Citizens Medal, Rhodes Scholar, “International Relations In The COVID-19 Era: Richard Haass On What Comes After A Pandemic”, Interview with Meghna Chakrabarti and Jack Beatty on NPR’s On Point, 4/22/2020, [Transcribed by Otter.ai, Grammatical transcription edits by Casey Harrigan]

So suddenly, the world is being left on its own. And what we're seeing is the world is not on autopilot. It doesn't self-organize. And that's the most worrisome thing going forward that this pandemic is both a reflection, but also an accelerant of that because the United States has not rallied the world to meet the challenge posed by this pandemic. And instead, we've pulled back we become much more national, kind of an island power, the rest of the world, it's on its own, it's not doing very well. And this is this is the reason I'm so worried that a lot of the trends that were in place, including them on America, much less involved in the world, nationalism, populism, the breakdown of international collaboration, all those things were in train before this pandemic, and now we're seeing them double down.

MEGHNA: So is the you're saying the world is not self-organizing right now, perhaps, at this moment? And at the same time, it doesn't? Is it feeling the loss of the centrality of American leadership? Because, I think we could argue that the way that, for example, international leaders do talk about the United States right now, at times, they're not necessarily feeling the loss of American influence.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Topshelf › Economy DA: 1NC

A—The economy is going strong now—multiple indicators prove

Mena, CNN journalist, ‘23

[Bryan Mena, journalist, “The US Economy Grew Faster in the First Quarter than Previously Reported,” CNN, 5—25—23, , accessed 6-11-23]

US economic growth in the first three months of the year was faster than previously estimated, the Commerce Department reported on Thursday.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC Impact › No Impact – Food Prices

Food price increases won’t cause war – empirics

Bier 2011 (David Bier – immigration policy analyst at the Cato Institute. “Steven Pinker: Resource Scarcity Doesn’t Cause Wars,” GlobalWarming. November 28, 2011. )-TL

Once again it seems to me that the appropriate response is “maybe, but maybe not.” Though climate change can cause plenty of misery… it will not necessarily lead to armed conflict. The political scientists who track war and peace, such as Halvard Buhaug, Idean Salehyan, Ole Theisen, and Nils Gleditsch, are skeptical of the popular idea that people fight wars over scarce resources. Hunger and resource shortages are tragically common in sub-Saharan countries such as Malawi, Zambia, and Tanzania, but wars involving them are not. Hurricanes, floods, droughts, and tsunamis (such as the disastrous one in the Indian Ocean in 2004) do not generally lead to conflict. The American dust bowl in the 1930s, to take another example, caused plenty of deprivation but no civil war. And while temperatures have been rising steadily in Africa during the past fifteen years, civil wars and war deaths have been falling. Pressures on access to land and water can certainly cause local skirmishes, but a genuine war requires that hostile forces be organized and armed, and that depends more on the influence of bad governments, closed economies, and militant ideologies than on the sheer availability of land and water. Certainly any connection to terrorism is in the imagination of the terror warriors: terrorists tend to be underemployed lower-middle-class men, not subsistence farmers. As for genocide, the Sudanese government finds it convenient to blame violence in Darfur on desertification, distracting the world from its own role in tolerating or encouraging the ethnic cleansing. In a regression analysis on armed conflicts from 1980 to 1992, Theisen found that conflict was more likely if a country was poor, populous, politically unstable, and abundant in oil, but not if it had suffered from droughts, water shortages, or mild land degradation. (Severe land degradation did have a small effect.) Reviewing analyses that examined a large number (N) of countries rather than cherry-picking one or toe, he concluded, “Those who foresee doom, because of the relationship between resource scarcity and violent internal conflict, have very little support from the large-N literature.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC Impact › US Ag Not Key

US food exports only feed wealthy countries – no internal link

Holobar 2016 (Krista Holobar, Agroecology and Food Policy Writer at Civil Eats—a food policy publication, 2016 (“Does Big Ag Really Feed the World? New Data Says Not So Much,” Civil Eats, October 5th, Available Online at )-TL

Ever since the U.N. announced that the world population is projected to exceed 9 billion by 2050 and global food production will have to more than double by that time, U.S. agricultural and agribusiness interests have been making the case that America’s farmers will have to double their production of grain and meat to “feed the world.” Those who make this argument maintain that industrial farming—which relies heavily on biotechnology and pesticides—is the only way U.S. farmers can double production, while organic and other agroecological methods will only put countless people at risk of hunger and malnutrition. But new data compiled by Environmental Working Group (EWG) makes it clear that we’re not really feeding the parts of the world that need it. In reality, most agricultural exports from the U.S. go to countries whose citizens can afford to pay for them. Our top five export destinations are Canada, China, Mexico, the European Union, and Japan—all countries with “high” or “very high” UN development scores and “very low” or “moderately low” Food and Agriculture Organization hunger scores. In 2015, less than one percent of America’s agricultural exports went to the 19 countries with the highest level of undernourishment, while exports to the top 20 destinations were 158 times greater. And over the last decade, the value of U.S. agricultural exports to the countries with very high or high undernourishment averaged only 0.7 [point seven] percent of the value of total agricultural exports.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC Impact › Bill -> T/Os

The Farm Bill will cause internal agricultural trade offs and does not increase government spending to stimulate the economy

Wiesemeyer and Hoffman 06-14-23 (JIM WIESEMEYER AND JENNA HOFFMAN, writing for Dairy Herd Management.com, How Does the Farm Bill Funding Process Work?, https://www.dairyherd.com/news/policy/how-does-farm-bill-funding-process-work)-TL

Q: What does the farm bill spending game plan look like? Thompson: "We need to find new dollars. And I think one of the allies that we haven't had is quite frankly Budget Chairman Jody Arrington (R-Texas). He's a great aggie himself. I think there are efficiencies that can bring us some new dollars, just as we look at incorporating some of the disaster relief that we normally spend in an emotional way. Anytime you do that you don't do it efficiently. The Senate usually puts in some additional legislation on must-pass pieces of legislation. It would spend a lot of money and not all that very smartly. By incorporating some of that disaster relief into crop insurance, we will enhance crop insurance, making it more attractive for more subscriptions. At the same time. I think we can do that by spending less money. We'll bring new dollars in and that's just one of a number of ideas we have when there's a recognition that in certain areas, certain titles of the farm bill, we need to find some new dollars.” Q: You can move around dollars even though Senate Ag Chair Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.) has said don't go into one area to get more funding elsewhere? Thompson: “The House will chair the farm bill this time around. But I think there's dollars to be had and common sense tells us especially when we've been going through such an emotional time of spending, look at the trillions of dollars just in the past two and a half years. We're talking trillions of dollars. You can't tell me some of that was not spent emotionally and was appropriated. The funding is sitting out there in different corners of the federal government. And I'm talking things specific to agriculture.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC Impact › AT: Food shortages

Countries that most susceptible to food insecurity are resilient and other institutional responses prevent escalation

Cliffe 16 (Sarah, Director of the Center on International Cooperation at New York University, 3/29/16, “Food Security, Nutrition, and Peace,” http://cic.nyu.edu/news_commentary/food-security-nutrition-and-peace)-TL

However, current research does not yet indicate a clear link between climate change, food insecurity and conflict, except perhaps where rapidly deteriorating water availability cuts across existing tensions and weak institutions. But a series of interlinked problems – changing global patterns of consumption of energy and scarce resources, increasing demands for food imports (which draw on land, water, and energy inputs) can create pressure on fragile situations. Food security – and food prices – are a highly political issue, being a very immediate and visible source of popular welfare or popular uncertainty. But their link to conflict (and the wider links between climate change and conflict) is indirect rather than direct. What makes some countries more resilient than others? Many countries face food price or natural resource shocks without falling into conflict. Essentially, the two important factors in determining their resilience are: First, whether food insecurity is combined with other stresses – issues such as unemployment, but most fundamentally issues such as political exclusion or human rights abuses. We sometimes read nowadays that the 2006-2009 drought was a factor in the Syrian conflict, by driving rural-urban migration that caused societal stresses. It may of course have been one factor amongst many but it would be too simplistic to suggest that it was the primary driver of the Syrian conflict. Second, whether countries have strong enough institutions to fulfill a social compact with their citizens, providing help quickly to citizens affected by food insecurity, with or without international assistance. During the 2007-2008 food crisis, developing countries with low institutional strength experienced more food price protests than those with higher institutional strengths, and more than half these protests turned violent. This for example, is the difference in the events in Haiti versus those in Mexico or the Philippines where far greater institutional strength existed to deal with the food price shocks and protests did not spur deteriorating national security or widespread violence.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC Impact › Generic Farm Bill Bad

The farm bill is badly written, turns its own impacts, and we’d be better off without it

Bookis and Rifkin 05-27-23(Alexandra Bookis is senior manager of U.S. government affairs at Farm Sanctuary. Mark Rifkin, a registered dietician, is senior food and agriculture policy specialist at the Center for Biological Diversity., This year’s Farm Bill needs big changes, https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/4019629-this-years-farm-bill-needs-big-changes/)-TL

This year’s Agriculture Improvement Act, commonly referred to as the “Farm Bill,” will invest a projected $700 billion over five years in U.S. food systems. If it replicates past failures, it will leave families and farmers insecure, excluding workers and farmed animals entirely while accelerating local and global environmental crises. In short, it will put the profits of Big Ag over the rest of us: people, farmed animals and the planet. Farm Bill investments and regulations should foster sustainable farmer opportunities and universal nutritional security, using plants and plant-based foods as essential means to accomplish shared ends. Instead, the Farm Bill will likely double down on the existing industrial agriculture investment model that supports millionaire landowners and billionaire investors at the expense of the rest of us. The bill, which will include funding for critical nutrition support nourishing over 40 million Americans, is a labyrinthine collection of titles covering credit, commodity insurance, research, conservation and other aspects of the U.S. food and farm system. These laws are so complex that even the most prominent food policy scholars describe breaking down the Farm Bill as insanity-inducing. One way to imagine these non-nutrition titles is through their goals: to provide the legal and financial framework for industrial agriculture. Credit, commodity support and insurance create a system of guaranteed profits for the largest landowners — so long as these landowners invest in feed, fuel or foreign exports rather than food for their communities. In fact, the Agricultural Research Service, which is funded by the Farm Bill, invests more in product commercialization than nutrition, conservation and sustainability combined. This industrial agriculture philosophy causes massive harms to land, water and climate. Though conservation programs claim to prevent the worst of these, soil erosion continues at unsustainable rates, most U.S. rivers are “too polluted for our health,” and the Environmental Protection Agency continues to systematically underrepresent food systems’ contributions to the climate crisis. Specific regulations, such as requiring that 50 percent of federal Environmental Quality Incentives Program funding support animal agriculture, result in government greenwashing and simplistic generalizations that government and industrial agricultural corporations’ policies automatically incorporate such values. The Farm Bill, passed only twice per decade, essentially allows Big Ag to be paid to pollute and to clean up its messes. Policymakers have long characterized the Farm Bill as a union between families and farmers. Without deliberate efforts to shift the bill’s underlying principles favoring industrial agriculture, this year’s Farm Bill will likely fail both families and farmers, despite any claims to the contrary. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, more than 9 in 10 adults in the United States have poor dietary habits, as measured by fruit and vegetable consumption. According to the Environmental Working Group, 6 in 10 direct-to-farmer subsidies go to the top 7 percent of recipients. Instead of prioritizing universal nutritional security and sustainable farmer opportunities, the Farm Bill invests in scarcity and consolidation across the supply chain. Shifting the Farm Bill requires a title-by-title approach. Oregon Rep. Earl Blumenauer’s Food and Farm Act takes a bold step in this direction. At his March 29 Capitol Hill legislative kickoff, our organizations joined advocates for farmers, the environment, human health, justice and farmed animals in a united call for reform. We need to make a commitment to food systems that nourish people today and ensure future generations can do the same. Now, we’re calling on Congress — for farmers, families and the rest of us — to put health and sustainability over Big Ag profits.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC AT: Link Core › 2AC PC Not Real

PC theory is outdated and doesn’t assume today’s hyper-polarization.

Roberts 2020 (David, writing for VOX 12-1-2020, "Joe Biden should do everything at once," Vox, https://www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/21724758/biden-transition-trump-polarized-climate-change-health-immigration)-TL

Obama’s efforts to collect and spend “political capital” were mostly for naught When Barack Obama took office in 2009 in a deepening recession, he expected to receive some Republican help bailing out the economy. It’s easy today to look back on that expectation as naive, but at the time it wasn’t unreasonable. The economy was on the brink of disaster, the need was clear, and the depth of conservative backlash was not yet as evident as it would become later. What happened instead was a wall of opposition from Republicans, built on bad-faith objections about deficit spending and government waste. With so little room to maneuver, Democrats were forced to negotiate with the tiny handful of moderate Republicans and the large handful of conservative Democrats in the Senate, holding the stimulus bill down to their arbitrary spending caps. In the end, the stimulus bill passed with zero Republican votes in the House and just three in the Senate. The result was an inadequate economic boost and a sluggish recovery that hobbled the rest of Obama’s presidency. Since it was widely agreed that “political capital” was limited and Democrats could only take on one fight at a time, the question then became what to tackle next. The answer proved to be health care reform, perceived as a policy better developed and more widely supported in the Democratic caucus. In July 2009, Democrats in the House introduced a health care plan based on a system that had been road-tested by Mitt Romney in his recent tenure as governor in Massachusetts. Many Democrats thought the process would take a few months, and then Congress could move on to climate change. Instead, again and again, Republicans lured Democrats into extended negotiations, only to withdraw support at the last minute over some new bad-faith objection (see: “death panels”). That left Democrats negotiating with their most conservative members, who did much the same thing (Joe Lieberman, may his name live in infamy). In the end, talks dragged on until March 2010, when Obama finally signed the Affordable Care Act. It got no Republican votes, in the Senate or the House. Then it was finally time for climate change, and the strategy there was yet more clever sequencing. Obama told Republicans that if they didn’t cooperate on climate change legislation, he would regulate greenhouse gases via the Environmental Protection Agency, which would offer less flexibility and less ability to compensate hard-hit communities. The idea was that the threat of EPA regulations — made inevitable by the Supreme Court’s 2007 Massachusetts v. EPA judgment that carbon dioxide is a pollutant subject to the Clean Air Act — would frighten Republicans to the legislative table, where they could better defend their interests. Instead, Republicans vowed implacable opposition to all of it. They would fight furiously against legislation when it was on the table and then fight regulations just as furiously when they came up. To a cool Vulcan mind like Obama’s, it seemed entirely irrational, against Republicans’ own best interests. At that point, he had not fully internalized the extent to which the conservative movement has become unleashed id, driven more by right-wing media than by Republican politicians, fueled by resentment and organized purely to defeat the libs. In June 2009, when the climate bill passed the House, it got eight Republican votes. By mid-2010, it was dead in the water, with no hope of any Republican votes in the Senate. Democrats no longer had their filibuster-proof 60 seats, and there was nothing like the same support in the caucus that health care reform generated, so it never came to a Senate vote. It ended with a whimper, not a bang. As promised, Obama’s EPA began slowly rolling out regulations, one at a time. It wasn’t until late in his first term that auto mileage standards were finalized and into his second term before EPA got to power plants. Republicans were able to keep Obama’s Clean Power Plan tied up in court through the end of his second term. Then Trump took power and began a simultaneous all-fronts assault on Obama’s regulations, unrolling them so fast it was difficult to even keep track. Two-party partisan politics really is a zero-sum game The theme of these stories is that Democrats relied on clever sequencing over and over again, imagining some amount of political capital (“credibility”) that they could husband and spend strategically to get assistance across the aisle, at every juncture underestimating the ferocity and unanimity of Republican opposition. They kept behaving as though they would find good-faith negotiating partners, as though they were still in the postwar American era of relatively low (or at least manageable) polarization. What too few of them realized was that they were already in a new era of near-total polarization, with the population sorted into like-minded enclaves, a bifurcated media ecosystem nurturing stacked (and diametrically opposed) “mega-identities,” and voters motivated primarily by “negative partisanship,” which is to say, hatred of the other side. A fully polarized two-party system really is a zero-sum game. Any victories or gains by one side come at the other side’s expense, even if the victory secures shared goals. The rational course for the party out of power is to fight with full intensity against everything, always, and that’s what Republicans did under Obama. With scarcely any exceptions, from 2010 through 2020, they pushed in every case for maximal partisan advantage, no matter the stakes or possible cost. The GOP has failed to repeal the Affordable Care Act, despite a few close calls, but otherwise, its unprincipled pursuit of raw power has paid off handsomely. The party captured state legislatures in 2010 and was able to gerrymander itself minority rule in several states. It practically shut down Congress as a legislative body for six years of Obama’s term. It blocked Merrick Garland’s nomination to the Supreme Court and for its efforts got Neil Gorsuch. It ignored Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s dying wishes and for its efforts got a 6-3 conservative Court majority that could last for generations. Republicans blocked so many Democratic judicial nominations that Senate leader Harry Reid had to get rid of the judicial filibuster to keep the courts staffed. Then, when the GOP took control of the presidency and Senate, it used the absence of the filibuster to pack the federal courts full of hyper-ideological, young, often woefully unqualified judges. Rather than paying any price for total partisan warfare, Republicans were rewarded in 2016 with the presidency and both houses of Congress. After carrying the country to the brink of authoritarian crisis, it has now lost the House and the presidency. But Joe Biden has been left to tackle a virtually uncontrolled pandemic and millions of people out of work and on the verge

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC AT: Link Core › 2AC Winners Win

The debt ceiling deal passing means the farm bill will pass

Bohl 06-02-23 (Eric, writer for NationalHogFarmer.com, Debt ceiling deal may clear way for farm bill, https://www.nationalhogfarmer.com/news/debt-ceiling-deal-may-clear-way-farm-bill)-TL

This week's bipartisan agreement to suspend the debt ceiling until 2025 in exchange for various spending reforms may directly impact the farm bill's chances this year. The bill, called the Fiscal Responsibility Act, made several eligibility changes to the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP. Disagreement over these changes had been a major point of contention standing in the way of a farm bill reauthorization. The agreement requires able-bodied SNAP beneficiaries without dependents up to age 54 to work or be in a work training program, an increase from the current maximum age of 49. It also added new exemptions to the work requirements for the homeless, veterans and people younger than 24 who were formerly in foster care. The changes are estimated to result in a net addition of about 78,000 new recipients. Senate Agriculture Committee Chairwoman Debbie Stabenow (D-MI) told reporters Tuesday that the bill "takes the issue of SNAP work requirements off the table. So, that's just one less issue we're going to have to negotiate" in the farm bill. House Agriculture Committee Chairman Glenn "GT" Thompson (R-PA) told Agri-Pulse, "I think it helps the farm bill process, absolutely." However, he suggested that the House may still consider changes to SNAP work requirements as it proceeds through the farm bill debate. The current farm bill, passed in 2018, expires September 30, 2023. Both Stabenow and Thompson have publicly expressed optimism that they can complete a reauthorization before the end of the year. The Fiscal Responsibility Act passed the House Wednesday by a 314-117 vote and cleared the Senate late Thursday by a 63-36 vote.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC AT: Link Core › GND Popular w/GOP

The GOP is moving towards their own Green New Deal—the plan gives them the excuse to go all in

Clift 2021 (Eleanor, writing for the Daily Beast, These Republicans Are Tiptoeing Toward a Green New Deal, 07-12-2021, https://www.thedailybeast.com/these-republicans-are-tiptoeing-toward-a-green-new-deal)-TL

If you had told climate activists a year ago that the country was on the cusp of $25 billion for electric transmission lines and a smart grid, $7.5 billion for charging stations and $3.5 billion to help weatherize the homes of low-income homeowners, they would have been ecstatic. These are the kind of big-bucks investments they’d been pleading for years without much success and now, defying the odds, a bipartisan group of senators working with the White House is positioned to deliver. The federal government should have been making climate investments on this scale for the last decade to reach the agreed-upon goal: a clean, carbon-free economy by 2050. Progressives will demand more than a political system rigged in favor of the status quo can deliver, but we’re closer to getting real action on climate than ever before. Too much time has been lost already but this year, 2021, marks the beginning of the end of climate denial as a winning political issue, and a new urgency about the health of the planet With extreme back-to-back weather events capturing headlines and the fossil fuel industry in retreat, fewer Republicans have the chutzpah to claim that climate change is a hoax invented by China, as Donald Trump did. Fifty-two Republicans, almost a quarter of the House caucus, joined a GOP-only Climate Caucus formed last month to get up to speed on the rapidly escalating challenge and help educate others on how addressing climate change can mesh with conservative principles. “Underneath all the partisan fervor, there is bipartisan agreement that clean energy and renewable energy are the future of energy. The question is whether it’s America’s future,” says Sean McElwee, 28, a self-described climate activist and founder of Data for Progress. “We’re being out-competed by China and Europe, and we need investments to make America competitive.” McElwee told the Daily Beast he approves of the policies in the bipartisan bill that’s being advanced on infrastructure “but I don’t approve the numbers.” He’s counting on the procedure known as reconciliation to allow Democrats to pass a second infrastructure bill without GOP support that will take the numbers up to where President Biden laid them out in his initial American Jobs Plan. The additional spending would include more climate initiatives plus “human” infrastructure for the caring economy Biden envisions. “I’m more of a pollster than a policy wonk,” McElwee said, explaining his optimism that Congress will act on climate. The millennials who were Obama’s generation of voters are in their mid-to-late thirties now and settling in with homes and mortgages. Republicans need to take climate change seriously if they want to reach this cohort, he says. “Reality has changed. Very few Republicans question the science of climate change. Solar and wind are competitive with fossil fuel. All that changes the political landscape.” Utah Rep. John Curtis, the founder and chair of the newly created GOP Climate Caucus, is emblematic of this changed thinking. Curtis asked his audience in an April speech at a conservative think tank, “Why does the climate question scare you? Are you really content with the label of not caring about the Earth?” If he even utters the word “climate,” he said that his wife gets panicked calls that he’s “gone off the deep end and I’m now in league with AOC.” Elected to Congress in 2017 in a special election to fill a Republican vacancy, Curtis had been serving as the Democratic mayor of Provo, Utah, where he was known for championing clean air and recreation initiatives, including a beach and a popular hiking trail. Congress hasn’t tried to pass meaningful legislation on climate since a measure to put a price on carbon pollution failed. “The world is an entirely different place now than it was in 2010,” said Elizabeth Gore, senior vice president for political affairs at the Environmental Defense Fund. That was the year West Virginia Governor Joe Manchin, running for the U.S. Senate, shot a bullet into “cap and trade” legislation in a campaign ad. The market-based solution that would have capped global pollution and allowed corporations to trade permits within that ceiling was derided by its critics as “cap and tax.” The legislation was the target of a massive lobbying campaign by the fossil fuel industry and its allies, and in the end, to try to win passage, was so full of loopholes and giveaways for corporations that White House Budget Director Peter Orzag called it the “largest corporate welfare program” in U.S. history. Even Campbell’s Soup was at the trough, angling for a deal for carbon-intensive making of soup. Democrats didn’t have the 60 votes needed for passage, and by the time Majority Leader Harry Reid pulled the bill in July, nobody much cared. And that’s where climate languished until 2018 when a blue wave of activism galvanized by a visceral opposition to President Trump put the House in Democratic hands and progressive priorities back in the spotlight. “Extreme weather patterns were more visible and became more of a motivating factor for everybody,” says Gore. “It’s not just an issue that voters support, it’s a top tier issue with much more engagement at the grassroots level. The debate is not whether it exists, it’s about ambition—how far to go in combating it.” Give credit where credit is due. “It was AOC ‘s first big issue,” says Ryan Fitzpatrick, director of the Climate and Energy Program at Third Way. He cites the outsized impact of the freshman lawmaker, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, on garnering public attention along with the rise of the Sunrise Movement, a climate-oriented activist group, launched in 2017, for bringing the issue front and center especially for young people. There are fights ahead. What are the “pay-fors?” How much more deficit spending is reasonable? Can Democrats find a sweet spot between Bernie Sanders’ $6 trillion wish list and Joe Manchin’s minimalism? “My party’s divided but my party’s also rational,” President Biden said. So far, the bipartisan deal on infrastructure is holding, driven by Manchin, who chairs the Energy and Natural Resources Committee, and Republican ranking member Lisa Murkowski. Beginning when the GOP controlled the senate and Murkowski was chair, they passed out of committee more than a dozen bills to clean up abandoned mines and oil wells and boost battery manufacturers. Now those bills are in the infrastructure deal. Manchin is Exhibit A in his changed attitude toward climate change and his recognition that a weakened coal industry cannot be resurrected and must be eased into a clean-up role. Progressives’ top demand on climate in a reconciliation bill passed by Democrats is a Clean Electricity Standard or CES. Twenty-nine states have such a standard, but they’re not binding. The rules governing the reconciliation process require legislation to have a direct budgetary impact. Policymakers are working on a performance program to set a target where utilities get a rebate if they meet it and would pay the government if they don’t. Collin O’Mara, president and CEO of the National Wildlife federation, calls the emerging legislation “a great down payment.” He would like more focus on resilience and mitigation because it’s going to take time for a clean energy economy to take hold. But he reflects the cautious optimism in the climate community. “No one is actually questioning the need to do this and to mitigate the climate horrors that we’re seeing,” he told the Daily Beast. “There’s something about the politics of actually bringing people together. I’m incredibly optimistic, and the reason is that I think the needs are so great and there are benefits to everybody.” He didn’t hesitate to venture a prediction that more than 10 Republicans in the Senate will vote for the bipartisan infrastructure deal and there will be some crossovers from the GOP for the Reconciliation package. Given our fractured politics, we’ve come a long way on climate when Republicans give up on denial and Democrats find a path moderates and progressives can support.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC AT: Link Core › FJG Popular w/GOP

Republicans need the plan to be able to pivot for future election victories—the plan gives them a template to approve larger spending bills like the farm bill in a way that they can sell to their voter base

Fershtman 2018 (Eric, writer for sinkhole.com, The Conservative Case for a Federal Jobs Guarantee, 05-13-18 https://sinkholemag.com/the-runoff/2018/5/13/the-conservative-case-for-a-federal-jobs-guarantee)-TL

At first blush the political expediency of a federal jobs guarantee seems unlikely: it’s best known in its two New Deal-era iterations, the Works Progress Administration and Civilian Conservation Corps, which between 1935 and 1943 spent more than a billion dollars a year – during the Great Depression! – to employ more than eight million people. Republicans associate the New Deal, pretty firmly, with socialism, and with the rise of a massive, bloated welfare state that’s been existentially threatening to the twin American virtues of business and work; presidents like Ronald Reagan, George W. Bush, and now Donald Trump have sought, in various ways, to shrink the government’s reach, believing it’s necessary to allow business to flourish. Republican representatives and senators have sought – and now achieved – really, really deep tax cuts in the interest of the cherished theory of trickle-down economics, which has had, at best, mixed results (at worst: such thinking has led us to the greatest instance of income inequality in our nation’s history, on par, as Gwynn Guilford reports in Quartz, with Putin’s Russia). Politically, too, Republican support for the idea seems almost ludicrously far-fetched: it is, after all, an idea that’s picked up steam on the far left, first explored by academics like Darrick Hamilton, William Darity Jr., and Mark Paul in the social-democratic pages of Jacobin and Dissent, and now picked up by national progressive figureheads like Bernie Sanders and Cory Booker; Republicans essentially earmuff themselves and make faces when these guys say anything (and vice versa, to be fair). Not to mention the fact it would cost, as Annie Lowrey points out at the Atlantic, something like $400 to $700 billion a year. Against such an ideological backdrop, you might think a jobs guarantee is dead on arrival in a Republican government. But shrewd Republicans will understand that such a program is in fact both ideologically and politically aligned with their interests. With a few small phrasing tweaks, the essay that Paul, Darity Jr., and Hamilton published in Jacobin last February provides a solidly Republican rationale for a jobs guarantee program: they argue that an FJG would help lift millions of Americans out of poverty (or: help them lift themselves out of poverty), fill jobs for which we need workers but have a shortage (like child and elder care), drive private-sector wages up (by functioning as a “de facto wage floor”), provide training for workers with outdated skillsets, and, paired with infrastructure spending, help update our aging roads, bridges, parks, airports, and power grids – a central campaign promise of Donald Trump’s. An FJG would also do much to stabilize an increasingly volatile economy, by functioning as a kind of backup plan – the idea is that the FJG rolls would shrink during the economic good times, and expand in recessionary eras, when private industry is struggling. There are major challenges, as Lowrey details in that aforementioned Atlantic piece, but there are successful examples of cost-effective jobs guarantee programs on small scales. There is, as well, one really big example of a jobs guarantee program that Republicans universally, and rabidly, support and work tirelessly to expand every single year: the military.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC AT: Link Core › UBI Popular w/GOP

The GOP generally trends towards being open to universal basic income within some bounds like the plan outlines—prefer quantitative studies on the demographic

Constantino, Rao, and Cartledge 2021 (Sara M. Constantino 1 , Kapu Rao 2 , Marcella Cartledge 3 1School of Public and International Affairs, Princeton University, New Jersey 2Department of Government, Cornell University, New York 3Jain Family Institute & Department of Economics, University of Virginia, Virginia; Shades of Red: Assessing the Spectrum of Republican Preferences for Basic Income, Jane Family Institute July 2021 Issue, https://jainfamilyinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/pdf/republicansbasicincome_jfi_july2021.pdf p.15 )-TL

Holding the cost of a policy approximately constant, we observed different responses as to who should receive a basic income. We find general agreement across parties in preference for a basic income of $1,000 targeted at those under the federal poverty line (FPL), indicating preference for a means-tested policy, or one with an income phase out. However, preferences among Republicans are more evenly spread across the options, with the second highest preference for a universal policy of $150 for all. Findings for “UBI+” benefits (a normal UBI with specific target groups receiving an additional supplement) are consistent with these findings: Republicans prefer not to have a UBI+ for any distinct groups, followed by a preference for a UBI+ to those under the FPL. Democrats also prefer these two options with the reverse ordering, namely, they prefer the UBI+ for those under the FPL, followed by no UBI+. Notably, we included options for Native Americans, African Americans, and women to receive UBI+, but do not provide any ideological context (i.e., language of reparations). These options, however, are relatively unpopular. Moreover, Republicans have a strong preference for restricting eligibility to citizens, while Democrats are more or less evenly spread across different citizenship-based eligibility criteria. Citizenship-based eligibility requirements are separate from means-tested requirements, with slightly more endorsement for all legal residents. Conclusion Bipartisan coalitions for basic income are possible, though we do observe differences when we consider the nuanced details of the actual policy. We first note that while most Democrats strongly support UBI, we do not find the opposite result for Republicans or Independents. Indeed, these two groups maintain a sizable proportion of UBI supporters, or at least many who do not directly oppose UBI. This support is explained by two collections of factors: ideological views and socioeconomic characteristics. Despite the potential for Republican support of UBI policies in a general sense, policy details may create divisions among supporters. We find that a coalition-building effort should focus more on adroitly navigating policy specifics than make palatable the notion of unconditional cash-based assistance itself.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC AT: Link Core › SS Popular w/GOP

The GOP already is backing mainstream plans to increase social security financing and save the program

Davis 05-12-2023 (Susan, reporting for NPR, Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy wants to save Social Security. Will Washington let him?,

Sen. Bill Cassidy, a gastroenterologist by trade, is comfortable doing uncomfortable things, so it's no surprise he's trying to lead an effort in Congress to protect Social Security, commonly referred to as the "third rail" of American politics. In other words: Anyone who tries to touch it, gets burned. "The third rail should be that you're going to sit passively while the program goes insolvent, at which points benefits are cut," the Louisiana Republican, 66, told NPR in an interview in his Senate office. "I'm trying to stop those cuts. Allowing the cuts should be the third rail." Cassidy is an equal opportunity critic of President Joe Biden and former President Donald Trump — currently the frontrunner for the GOP nomination — because both men are campaigning to protect Social Security but not offering much of anything on how they plan to do it. "If I sound aggravated as heck, we've got a program that's going insolvent in eight to nine years," Cassidy said, noting the resulting cut could see poverty among the elderly nearly double. "And we have the leading presidential candidates acting like there's not a problem." The problem with Social Security If Washington does nothing, in about a decade, Social Security will start to run out of money. It's funded by workers' taxes and any surpluses or interest earnings in its trust fund. The program cannot borrow money on its behalf, so the only option once existing funds are exhausted would be an estimated 24% benefits cut for recipients. Nearly everyone over the age of 65 in the U.S. receives some form of Social Security benefit. It's unlikely Washington will let it get to that point — Social Security is wildly popular and economically crucial for most Americans — but few in positions of power are actually trying to come up with a fix to actually prevent it from happening. About two years ago, Cassidy decided to start working on it. "It suddenly occurred to me that we could address this by creating an investment fund," he said "And if we did that, it would be a way to address the shortfall and to limit or to prevent this 24% decrease [in benefits]." He linked up with independent Sen. Angus King of Maine, who caucuses with Democrats, and who Cassidy praised as a "tremendous partner." They began to approach senators one-by-one to pitch them on their "big idea," as Cassidy calls it. The pitch goes like this: Invest $1.5 trillion over five years in an independent investment fund separate from Social Security. "Now, you let it sit there for 70 years and you allow it to grow," Cassidy said. "It blossoms and eventually becomes adequate to pay for 75% of the liabilities of the Social Security trust fund." The government would have to borrow money to pay for scheduled benefits. "But you're borrowing money against the money which is in the fund, so it decreases the risk of our debt and deficit," Cassidy explained. The fund would be managed independently of Congress with the explicit intention of preventing future political interference. Cassidy concedes his plan only partially solves the solvency problem — it does not address the tougher questions about raising taxes or the retirement age, but he said at a minimum it will not raise taxes on seniors or affect anyone close to retirement. "Then you need political consensus," he admitted. His message to skeptics? "I just tell people, 'You may not like our plan. Come up with a better option.' " Seeking political consensus Cassidy and his staff have been working Washington channels through lobbying shops, think tanks and economic gurus to get feedback and make changes as they go, all in the name of building that consensus. "I could give you a list of probably 50 different entities on the right and the left that we went to speak to to either build support or to learn from them," he said. "And the final product is robust." It's also still amorphous. While it is no secret to what Cassidy is working on, there's also no official legislative text, and no plans to have any hearings. "Until a president chooses to show leadership, there's no reason to have a hearing," he said. "It will become fodder for somebody running for reelection who would rather be irresponsible with the future of the United States, as opposed to being honest with the American people and coming up with an innovative solution."

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC UQ › No Farm Bill Written

They haven’t even finished the first draft of the bill yet

Clark 06-16-23 (Carol, writing for Los Alamos Daily Post, Rep. Stansbury On Farm Bill Submissions,

From the Office of U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury: WASHINGTON, D.C. — U.S. Rep. Melanie Stansbury (N.M.-01) submitted requests today for the Farm Bill to the House Committee on Agriculture. The submissions include her Water Data Act, increasing funding for food assistance, and improving our agricultural infrastructure. “I am thrilled to submit lifechanging requests to reshape the Farm Bill to fill the gaps to help our communities in New Mexico thrive,” Rep. Stansbury said. “New Mexico is a farming and ranching powerhouse, which is why my office worked diligently to ensure the voices of New Mexicans were centered in all our submissions. From addressing unprecedented drought, to improving our food systems and food security for our communities—these submissions will greatly help improve our rural communities. I cannot wait to see the results we deliver.”

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC UQ › Immigration Thumper

The Dignity Act is going to use up all of the bipartisanship that the farm bill needs to pass

Garcia 06-12-2023 (Marcela, columnist for the Boston Globe, Back to the future with an unlikely bipartisan immigration bill,

How times — and the Republican Party — have changed. Perhaps a crucial factor for the bill’s success was the support it garnered from the business community, “which lobbied for the bill to ensure a flow of low-wage workers into the country,” according to an analysis written by Elaine Kamarck and Christine Stenglein from the Brookings Institute. Included in the legislation was an expansion of guest worker visa programs. Charles Kamasaki, an immigration scholar who wrote “Immigration Reform: The Corpse that Will Not Die” about the law’s passage, offers a lesson for today’s lawmakers. Kamasaki told Vox that “these kinds of bills are really hard to pass. Before they pass, they almost invariably die. … You have to be in a constant search for where you can get the votes. And that inevitably involves trade-offs and compromises that aren’t necessarily fully satisfactory to either side.” That brings me to the Dignity Act and why we should pay attention to it. Representative Maria Elvira Salazar is a Republican from Florida who likely doesn’t agree on many issues with fellow Representative Veronica Escobar, a Democrat from El Paso, who is the cochair of President Biden’s reelection campaign. Salazar, a former Spanish-language broadcast journalist, was elected in 2020 to represent parts of Miami in Congress, with support from former president Donald Trump and deeply conservative Latino voters. Yet Escobar and Salazar came together to author a bill that represents the most sweeping effort presented in Congress to overhaul immigration in a decade. The 500-page Dignity Act would allocate significant resources to strengthen border security; create a 12-year pathway to citizenship at a $10,000 cost for undocumented residents; revise and modernize the asylum process; address longstanding visa backlogs; and expand work visas, among other provisions. Their bill faces steep odds, of course. “Getting this on the floor is some ways away, because the first step has to be talking to members of the Republican conference and the Democratic caucus, and so Maria and I are engaging in those conversations right now, explaining the bill, listening to folks’ concerns, talking about the possibilities, talking about the opportunity,” Escobar said in an interview with The Washington Post last week. The Dignity Act is a bona fide, bipartisan effort to solve the great immigration challenge from two Latina lawmakers. The economic climate makes it an even more urgent issue. With labor shortages in nearly every industry — there were 10.1 million job openings as of the end of April — Escobar and Salazar’s bill is a no-brainer for the business community to support.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC UQ › NDAA Thumper

Congress is too busy with the complex and controversial NDAA to spend time working on the farm bill—they’ll kick the can down the road with a 2 year extension

Shane 06-18-23 (Leo, covers Congress, Veterans Affairs and the White House for Military Times, Defense bill work ramps up, but Senate keeps debate out of public view, https://www.militarytimes.com/news/pentagon-congress/2023/06/19/defense-bill-work-ramps-up-but-senate-keeps-debate-out-of-public-view/)-TL

Both the House and Senate Armed Service committees will mark up their annual defense authorization bill drafts this week, but the public will only get to see one of them do their work. That’s because Senate lawmakers have opted to continue their tradition of conducting the high-stakes defense policy work behind closed doors. All of the subcommittee work — except for the personnel subcommittee, which will hold a public hearing on Wednesday — and the full committee debate is closed to the public, shutting off insight into where senators stand on the debates that will shape the Defense Department for years to come. In contrast, the House Armed Services Committee will hold an open markup of its draft bill on Wednesday. The work is expected to last more than 14 hours. In the last 11 years, the marathon event has only finished before midnight twice. The public debate includes hours of discussion over spending priorities, personnel requirements and policy changes. Senate lawmakers have said the open debate prompts posturing and inhibits frank discussions. House lawmakers insist the work should be done in a matter where all Americans can observe and learn about the issues. By the end of the week, both committees are expected to have their separate versions of the legislation ready to head to their respective chamber floors for votes. After that, House and Senate leaders will spend the next few months negotiating a compromise bill, with the goal of sending the measure to the White House sometime this fall.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC UQ › Extension Most Likely

No impact to the bill failing and will just lead to an extension after the 2024 elections

Heider 05-30-23 (Alex, writer for RFDTV.com, Former Ag Committee chair says the current Farm Bill could possibly be extended, https://www.rfdtv.com/former-ag-committee-chair-says-the-current-farm-bill-could-possibly-be-extended)-TL

The Farm Bill deadline is just four months away, and there are growing concerns the important piece of legislation will not be done on time. However, Collin Peterson, the former House Ag Committee chair says that wouldn’t necessarily be a deal breaker. “They could. I’d be surprised, but September 30th is not a drop-dead date. Nothing actually happens that day that’s going to cause any significant problems. I think they probably have till the end of the year to try to get something done. If it doesn’t get done by the end of the year, I think it’ll probably get extended. They’ll do a one-year extension, and then it’s an election year. I wouldn’t be surprised if you do a one-year extension, then you’ll end up with a two-year extension,” Peterson said. Speaking at the U.S. Meat Export Federation Spring Conference in Minneapolis, Peterson explained to the crowd what a one or two-year extension of the current Farm Bill could mean. “Depends on where you’re from. One of the things people are focused on is these reference prices. Well, the 10 percent reference price increase is $20 billion. I think corn goes to $4 or something, and soybeans go to $9 and something, so they’re not going to trigger. If we spend $20 billion, for us in the Midwest, we get nothing out of it for the first two or three years, according to the projections. In the South, that’s different. So, rice has got a significant problem. We raised their reference price last time to $14.50, and now they say they need $16 to break even. Rice is a small crop, so we can do that. Peanuts are a small crop. We can do that. Cotton, they don’t have as big a problem, but they want in on the deal. They’re expensive. So that whole reference price issue, I think in terms of the overall situation, there’s a lot of money for not that much good. In the Midwest, that money would be better spent on crop insurance,” Peterson said. The former legislator from Minnesota says there are a lot of lawmakers in Washington right now who have never had a hand in the Farm Bill before and need education on U.S. and world agriculture. “Maybe that’s a good thing. They haven’t voted against it. There’s just a lot of education that needs to be done. I mean, we have in the House on the Democratic side, you got 11 Freshmen that are on the committee. Obviously, they’ve never been involved in this. Half of them don’t have a whole lot of agriculture in their district, so there’s just a lot of education that needs to be done. And frankly, on the Republican side, back in the old days, they had very strong ties to agriculture on the Republican side. That’s not the case so much. Even on their side, they don’t have solid of an ag background as they used to, so it’s a different world,” Peterson said.

2023 GDI Disadvantage
Aff Answers › 2AC UQ › No Pass

Farmers know that the bill will fail—this isn’t their first rodeo

Food & Environment Reporting Network Ag Insider 06-07-23 (FARMERS ARE BECOMING MORE DOUBTFUL OF A FARM BILL IN 2023, https://www.agriculture.com/news/business/farmers-are-becoming-more-doubtful-of-a-farm-bill-in-2023)-TL

Two out of three crop and livestock producers say they are uncertain or believe Congress is unlikely to enact a new farm bill this year, said a Purdue University survey on Tuesday. Neither the Senate nor House Agriculture committees has unveiled a preliminary version of the bill or scheduled a bill-drafting session, an unusually slow start. Doubt has increased this spring, said the Ag Economy Barometer, which surveys large-scale producers each month to gauge the health of the farm economy. Some 67 percent of respondents to the latest survey that they believed a farm bill was unlikely this year or were uncertain if passage would occur — an increase of 7 percentage points in one month. In the latest survey, 32 percent of farmers said a farm bill was “very unlikely” or “somewhat unlikely” this year and 35 percent were “uncertain.” Some 33 percent said a farm bill in 2023 was “somewhat likely” or “very likely.” A month earlier, 29 percent said a farm bill was unlikely, 31 percent were uncertain and 40 percent said it was likely. Nearly half of corn and soybean farmers said crop insurance was the most important section of the farm bill; 25 percent chose commodity subsidies. Ten percent selected agricultural research and nine percent each chose land stewardship and renewable energy. Producers were equally divided on whether the farm bill would increase reference prices for corn and soybeans or leave them unchanged; 13 percent said reference prices, an important factor in calculating subsidy payments, would be cut. The Ag Economy Barometer fell to a reading of 104, its lowest reading since last July, due to weaker commodity prices during May, said Purdue agricultural economists Jim Mintert and Michael Langemeier, who oversee the barometer. Producers were surveyed from May 15-19 for the new report. Purdue interviews operators with production worth at least $500,000 a year for the barometer. USDA data say the largest 7.4 percent of U.S. farms top $500,000 in annual sales. The survey has a margin of error of plus or minus 5 percent.