2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › Biodiversity
Torres 2016 (Phil, the founder of the X-Risks Institute, an affiliate scholar at the Institute for Ethics and Emerging Technologies “Biodiversity Loss and the Doomsday Clock: An Invisible Disaster Almost No One is Talking About” http://www.commondreams.org/views/2016/02/10/biodiversity-loss-and-doomsday-clock-invisible-disaster-almost-no-one-talking-about)-TL
But there’s another global catastrophe that the Bulletin neglected to consider — a catastrophe that will almost certainly have conflict multiplying effects no less than climate change. I’m referring here to biodiversity loss — i.e., the reduction in the total number of species, or in their population sizes, over time. The fact is that in the past few centuries, the loss of biological diversity around the world has accelerated at an incredible pace. Consider the findings of a 2015 paper published in Science Advances. According to this study, we’ve only recently entered the early stages of the sixth mass extinction event in life’s entire 3.5 billion year history. The previous mass extinctions are known as the “Big Five,” and the last one wiped out the dinosaurs some 65 million years ago. Unlike these past tragedies, though, the current mass extinction — called the “Holocene extinction event” — is almost entirely the result of a one species in particular, namely Homo sapiens (which ironically means the “wise man”). But biodiversity loss isn’t limited to species extinctions. As the founder of the Long Now Institute, Stewart Brand, suggests in an article for Aeon, one could argue that a more pressing issue is the reduction in population sizes around the globe. For example, the 3rd Global Biodiversity Report (GBO-3), published in 2010, found that the total abundance of vertebrates — a category that includes mammals, birds, reptiles, sharks, rays, and amphibians — living in the tropics declined by a whopping 59% between 1970 and 2006. In other words, the population size of creatures with a spine more than halved in only 36 years. The study also found that farmland birds in Europe have declined by 50% since 1980, birds in North America have declined by 40% between 1968 and 2003, and nearly 25% of all plant species are currently “threatened with extinction.” The latter statistic is especially worth noting because many people suffer from what’s called “plant blindness,” according to which we fail “to recognize the importance of plants in the biosphere and in human affairs.” Indeed, plants form the very bottom of the food chains upon which human life ultimately depends. Even more disturbing is the claim that amphibians “face the greatest risk” of extinction, with “42% of all amphibian species … declining in population,” as the GBO-3 reports. Consistent with this, a more recent study from 2013 that focused on North America found that “frogs, toads and salamanders in the United States are disappearing from their habitats … at an alarming and rapid rate,” and are projected to “disappear from half of the habitats they currently occupy in about 20 years.” The decline of amphibian populations is ominous because amphibians are “ecological indicators” that are more sensitive to environmental changes than other organisms. As such they are the “canaries in the coal mine” that reflect the overall health of the ecosystems in which they reside. When they start to disappear, bigger problems are sure to follow. Yet another comprehensive survey of the biosphere comes from the Living Planet Report — and its results are no less dismal than those of the GBO-3. For example, it finds that the global population of vertebrates between 1970 and 2010 dropped by an unbelievable 52%. Although the authors refrain from making any predictions based on their data, the reader is welcome to extrapolate this trend into the near future, noting that as ecosystems weaken, the likelihood of further population losses increases. This study thus concludes that humanity would “need 1.5 Earths to meet the demands we currently make on nature,” meaning that we either need to reduce our collective consumption and adopt less myopic economic policies or hurry up and start colonizing the solar system. Other studies have found that 20% of all reptile species, 48% of all the world's primates, 50% of all freshwater turtles, and 68% of plant species are currently threatened with extinction. There’s also talk about the Cavendish banana going extinct as a result of a fungus, and research has confirmed that honey bees, which remain “the most important insect that transfers pollen between flowers and between plants,” are dying out around the world at an alarming rate due to what’s called “colony collapse disorder” — perhaps a good metaphor for our technologically advanced civilization and its self-destructive tendencies. Turning to the world’s oceans, one finds few reasons for optimism here as well. Consider the fact that atmospheric carbon dioxide — the byproduct of burning fossil fuels — is not only warming up the oceans, but it’s making them far more acidic. The resulting changes in ocean chemistry are inducing a process known as “coral bleaching,” whereby coral loses the algae (called “zooxanthellae”) that it needs to survive. Today, roughly 60% of coral reefs are in danger of becoming underwater ghost towns, and some 10% are already dead. This has direct consequences for humanity because coral reefs “provide us with food, construction materials (limestone) and new medicines,” and in fact “more than half of new cancer drug research is focused on marine organisms.” Similarly, yet another study found that ocean acidification is becoming so pronounced that the shells of “tiny marine snails that live along North America’s western coast” are literally dissolving in the water, resulting in “pitted textures” that give the shells a “cauliflower” or “sandpaper” appearance. Furthermore, human-created pollution that makes its way into the oceans is carving out vast regions in which the amount of dissolved oxygen is too low for marine life to survive. These regions are called “dead zones,” and the most recent count by Robert Diaz and his colleagues found more than 500 around the world. The biggest dead zone discovered so far is located in the Baltic Sea, and it’s been estimated to be about 27,000 square miles, or a little less than the size of New Hampshire, Vermont, and Maryland combined. Scientists have even discovered an “island” of trash in the middle of the Pacific called the “Great Pacific Garbage Patch” that could be up to “twice the size of the continental United States.” Similar “patches” of floating plastic debris can be found in the Atlantic and Indian oceans as well, although these are not quite as impressive. The point is that “Earth’s final frontier” — the oceans — are becoming vast watery graveyards for a huge diversity of marine lifeforms, and in fact a 2006 paper in Science predicts that there could be virtually no more wild-caught seafood by 2048. Everywhere one looks, the biosphere is wilting — and a single bipedal species with large brains and opposable thumbs is almost entirely responsible for this worsening plight. If humanity continues to prune back the Tree of Life with reckless abandon, we could be forced to confront a global disaster of truly unprecedented proportions. Along these lines, a 2012 article published in Nature and authored by over twenty scientists claims that humanity could be teetering on the brink of a catastrophic, irreversible collapse of the global ecosystem. According to the paper, there could be “tipping points” — also called “critical thresholds” — lurking in the environment that, once crossed, could initiate radical and sudden changes in the biosphere. Thus, an event of this sort could be preceded by little or no warning: everything might look more or less okay, until the ecosystem is suddenly in ruins. We must, moving forward, never forget that just as we’re minds embodied, so too are we bodies environed, meaning that if the environment implodes under the weight of civilization, then civilization itself is doomed. While the threat of nuclear weapons deserves serious attention from political leaders and academics, as the Bulletin correctly observes, it’s even more imperative that we focus on the broader “contextual problems” that could inflate the overall probability of wars and terrorism in the future. Climate change and biodiversity loss are both conflict multipliers of precisely this sort, and each is a contributing factor that’s exacerbating the other. If we fail to make these threats a top priority in 2016, the likelihood of nuclear weapons — or some other form of emerging technology, including biotechnology and artificial intelligence — being used in the future will only increase.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › Biodiversity
Argust 06-01-2023 (Marcia, How the Farm Bill can conserve wildlife and working landscapes, https://thehill.com/opinion/energy-environment/4028774-how-the-farm-bill-can-conserve-wildlife-and-working-landscapes/)-TL
For decades, development and road building throughout the U.S. progressed with little thought to how it might affect the movement of wildlife. But only recently have scientists had the technology and data to understand the importance of connecting ecosystems, which provides freedom of movement and adequate habitat for wildlife to feed, breed and evade predators. New research by The Pew Charitable Trusts, where I lead the U.S. public lands and rivers conservation project, shows that in addition to saving motorists’ lives, safeguarding habitat and centuries-old wildlife migratory routes provides myriad benefits. Those include sustaining healthy wildlife populations, promoting biodiverse ecosystems that are more resilient to increasing temperatures and supporting local economies that rely on hunting, fishing, wildlife viewing and other outdoor tourism. Fortunately, federal and state policymakers are putting this science into practice by enacting laws that provide species room to roam. These measures include funding for wildlife-friendly infrastructure, such as overpasses and underpasses that enable wildlife to follow migratory corridors across busy roads — and prevent human injuries and loss of life due to collisions between wildlife and vehicles. In the past two years, California, Colorado, New Mexico, Oregon, Utah, Wyoming, Montana, Idaho, Washington, Virginia and Florida have all taken bipartisan actions to improve ecosystem connectivity: directing collaboration among key agencies, calling for research to identify and prioritize wildlife crossing hotspots and investing in wildlife-friendly infrastructure projects. These solutions work. In Colorado, for example, a wildlife crossing over Colorado State Highway 9 reduced wildlife-vehicle collisions by 90 percent from 2016 to 2020. At the federal level, the bipartisan Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act of 2021 makes wildlife and aquatic connectivity programs eligible for billions of dollars in funding over five years, including $350 million in dedicated funding for states, tribes and other entities to use for wildlife crossing projects. These are worthy investments. And now Congress has another opportunity to mitigate habitat fragmentation and support communities and people. This year, lawmakers are taking up the Farm Bill, a multifaceted piece of legislation that comes up for reauthorization every five years. The bill includes provisions that incentivize the conservation of habitat and wildlife corridors on working lands such as farms and ranches.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › Enviro/CC Generic
McConville, Smith, and Lutz 05-23-23 (Drew, Jasia, and Mariel, report writing group for the Center for American Progress, Why the Farm Bill May Be the Highest-Stakes Climate Fight Flying Below the Radar,
The stakes are high as Congress begins serious discussions to reauthorize the farm bill, which expires at the end of September 2023. Among other things, this legislation represents a major opportunity to enable private landowners, farmers, ranchers, and rural communities to take action to address the crises of climate change and nature loss. Congress must have the back of farmers, ranchers, landowners, and communities who are stepping up to lead on conservation and climate change. In fact, in a divided Congress where House majority leadership has staked out an obstructionist position on most climate action, the must-pass farm bill may represent the only meaningful opportunity to make progress on these issues in the 118th Congress. Conversely, if extreme positions prevail and Congress strips away farm bill program investments made in the 2022 Inflation Reduction Act, America will take a massive step backward on climate, conservation, and rural prosperity. Scale of the climate and nature opportunity Farm bill conservation programs represent the largest source of federal funding for private landowners to preserve and steward their lands, waters, and wildlife for current and future generations; yet demand for these programs significantly outpaces supply, and competing pressures are growing.1 Meanwhile, as the climate crisis deepens, farm bill support can enable U.S. agriculture to lead the world in climate-smart innovation, help farmers and ranchers benefit from greenhouse gas-reducing practices, and build cleaner and more reliable energy solutions for rural America. Climate-smart agriculture represents a crucial front in the fight against climate change. With 10 percent of U.S. emissions coming from the agricultural sector and abundant opportunities to reduce emissions through improved practices and land use, the farm bill’s voluntary incentive programs hold tremendous potential to deliver meaningful gains for farmers and the climate.2 Additionally, a 2021 CAP analysis found that nature loss in the United States is driving the emissions of 140 million metric tons of carbon dioxide equivalent (MMT CO2e) each year.3 However, achieving President Joe Biden’s U.S. land conservation goal has the potential to reverse that trend and yield an additional 215 MMT CO2e stored by nature—as much savings as taking 47 million cars off the road. New farm bill program investments through the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) recognize the fundamental link between conservation and climate and direct resources toward practices that achieve conservation, resilience, and greenhouse gas reduction goals, all while supporting rural clean energy solutions that are building more resilient, reliable, and affordable energy systems. In recent years, America has lost roughly a football field’s worth of natural area every 30 seconds to development, and more than three-quarters of that loss is occurring on private lands, which is where farm bill programs focus.4 As a lifeline to farmers, forest owners, and others who are doing their part to conserve “America the Beautiful,” farm bill conservation and forest programs are critical to achieving the national conservation mission launched by President Biden and supported by community leaders across the country.5 The farm bill helps conserve tens of millions of acres of farmland, grassland, wetland, and forest on an ongoing basis; improve water quality; protect and restore valuable wildlife habitat; and support hunting, fishing, and other outdoor recreation.7 The federal government estimates that the Inflation Reduction Act’s new investments in these programs could support conservation on an additional 125 million acres of land—representing an area larger than the state of California—by reaching up to 280,000 farmers and ranchers over four years.8 Additionally, independent analyses have projected that IRA investments will create tens of thousands of agriculture-related jobs annually.9 Independent analyses have projected that IRA investments will create tens of thousands of agriculture-related jobs annually. Importantly, U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) implementation of new conservation and climate-smart investments can also ensure that historic inequities in farm bill funding distribution are actively addressed to guarantee that benefits flow to marginalized, underserved, and historically disadvantaged communities. These targeted investments are needed to achieve the Biden administration’s Justice40 Initiative and other equity commitments.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › Food Insecurity/War
Yarrow 05-25-23 (Grace, writing for the Hill, How the farm bill could alleviate food insecurity fueled by Ukraine war, https://thehill.com/policy/international/4021371-how-the-farm-bill-could-alleviate-food-insecurity-fueled-by-ukraine-war/)-TL
The war raging in Ukraine has exacerbated food insecurity across the world — and food aid experts are looking to the 2023 farm bill for solutions. Ukraine’s massive grain supplies typically feed 400 million people per year, but the war has “drastically cut supplies” and driven up food costs for consumers in rich and poor countries alike, according to the World Food Program (WFP). U.S. legislators are currently drafting the farm bill, an omnibus agriculture act passed every five years, which includes provisions for international food assistance. The farm bill authorizes a number of domestic and international food aid programs. The legislation doesn’t fully authorize funding for this aid, which must be decided in separate appropriations, but it outlines how each program runs and how it can use future funds. Lawmakers can use the must-pass farm bill draft to amend these programs as needed. Experts like Rebecca Middleton, chief advocacy and engagement officer for World Food Program USA, are hoping to see “robust authorization” for food aid support in the 2023 farm bill — especially the Bill Emerson Humanitarian Trust, Middleton said. The Bill Emerson Humanitarian Trust builds up over time and then can be cashed out at the authorization of the secretary of Agriculture. In April 2022, $282 million was withdrawn from the Emerson Trust to support countries in need after the start of the Russia-Ukraine conflict threatened food supplies in six major countries facing food insecurity: Ethiopia, Kenya, Somalia, Sudan, South Sudan and Yemen. The withdrawn money was used to obtain U.S. commodities and bolster existing aid in those countries, according to a U.S. Agency for International Development spokesperson. The Emerson Trust was renamed to honor former Mississippi Rep. Bill Emerson in 1998 but was originally established in 1980 as a wheat reserve. Because of rising food prices, in 2008, the Department of Agriculture converted the trust into a cash reserve that can be used to purchase U.S. commodities in times of need. The trust was most recently reauthorized in the 2018 farm bill, and Congress must reauthorize the Emerson Trust in the 2023 legislation. Congress also has the authority to replenish funds after they are withdrawn. “For all of those accounts [in the farm bill], the one that we’re really interested in is the Emerson Trust because it’s an account that’s not very well known, but is absolutely vital in situations like the one that we found ourselves in in 2022,” Middleton said. “It’s really absolutely vital assistance that the U.S. was able to provide because of that emergency account in this time of historic need.” The 2018 farm bill did not account for such crises like the COVID-19 pandemic or the Russia-Ukraine conflict, both which have had severe effects on supply and triggered more aid from the federal government, so the Emerson Trust was an essential resource in recent years. “I mean, the need was extraordinary and then just compounded with the shock to the global food supply chain with the Ukrainian crisis,” Middleton said. Rep. Jim McGovern (D-Mass.), the former ranking member of the House Agriculture Committee’s subcommittee on nutrition, said in a statement that he supports keeping international food aid well-funded in the new legislation. “The FY 2023 farm bill reauthorization needs to continue to build on the trajectory of the past two decades and ensure that the U.S., in partnership with American farmers and non-profits, can respond swiftly and comprehensively to global humanitarian emergencies and invest in longer-term resilience and sustainability, especially for small farmers, so that they may more successfully withstand future economic and climate shocks,” McGovern said in a statement to The Hill. In addition to the Emerson Trust withdrawal, the Biden administration committed $2.76 billion toward global food security last summer, on top of Biden and other G7 leaders’ contributing $4.5 billion to the issue in 2022. High prices for fuel and fertilizer, theft of farm equipment, destruction of agricultural facilities, and the blockade of Black Sea ports all threatened to push millions of people internationally into poverty, hunger and malnutrition starting in 2022, according to the White House. The Horn of Africa faced a particularly acute crisis due to prolonged drought and famine. Dalton Henry, vice president of policy for U.S. Wheat Associates, is hoping to see solutions in the 2023 farm bill that prioritize using U.S. commodities as a “cornerstone” of donations to regions in need. “We have a tremendous priority placed on making sure that hungry people around the world get fed and the farm bill programs do such a good job at doing that with commodities,” Henry said. He added that it’s “hard to say” how much farm bill policies will change from past years, but that the Russia-Ukraine war has inflamed existing hunger and food insecurity due to global conflicts like those in Ethiopia and Yemen. Henry said the war in Ukraine has made the need for international food aid more prominent. “I think that, if anything, one of the big impacts is that the war has put global food security much more front of mind for a lot of folks,” Henry said, “and probably shone a little bit more of a light on some of these programs that normally kind of fly under the radar.”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › US Key
Coleman 2012 (Isobel, Senior Fellow and Director of the Civil Society, Markets, and Democracy Initiative at the Council on Foreign Relations, interviewed by Christophers Alessi, “U.S. Drought and Rising Global Food Prices,” 8/2/12, http://www.cfr.org/food-security/us-drought-rising-global-food-prices/p28777)-TL
This is the hottest summer on record in the United States since 1895, and people are beginning to wonder whether this type of drought that we're experiencing could become a new normal. The United States is a pivotal player in world food production and has the most sophisticated agricultural sector in terms of seeds, technology, irrigation, deep commodity markets, and future markets. If the United States crop is so devastated by drought, what is going to happen to the rest of the world? How do rising U.S. food prices affect global food prices down the world's food supply chain? Which areas of the globe are most at risk? There are many large food producers in the world. China is the largest wheat producer, but it is also the largest wheat consumer. What makes the United States unique is that we are the largest exporter, so we produce about 35 percent of the world's corn and soybean supply. Those two commodities are crucial in the food chain, because they are used for feed stock for animals. Around the world you have rising middle classes, a growing demand for meat and protein in the diet, and countries around the world are becoming increasingly dependent on relatively inexpensive food stocks from the United States. When you see a crop failure of the magnitude you have seen this summer, it flows through the whole food chain. Right now you have American livestock producers taking their pigs and cattle to the slaughter house because they simply don't have the food to be feeding them. So you're going to see meat prices in the short term in the United States go down, but over the longer term you're going to see rising meat prices; [experts] are predicting already 4 to 5 percent price increases in meat for the next year. That flows through the whole food chain, [to] big-population countries that import a lot of food, such as the Philippines, Afghanistan, Egypt. And when you see rapidly rising food prices, of course it leads to instability. We've seen [this] in the last five years across many of those countries, and you see rising food prices translate almost directly into street protests. You're going to see the continuation of [political] instability driven in part by rapidly rising food prices. In 2008, we had food protests across much of the Middle East, so governments are going to be very much on the alert for unrest and very sensitive to it. Egypt is already spending about one-third of its subsidies on food, and it is draining the Egyptian foreign exchange reserve to continue those subsidies. This combination of an already mobilized population out on the streets demanding lots of different changes [in Egypt], and rising food prices is going to create a very unstable atmosphere.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › US Key
Kahn 2016 (Laura H. Kahn, Researcher at Princeton University's Program on Science and Global Security, “Can We Remain Food Secure Amid Climate Change?”, Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 9-12-16, http://thebulletin.org/can-we-remain-food-secure-amid-climate-change9875)-TL
The United States plays a key role in global food security, according to the USDA report. With 16 percent of global agricultural exports, it is the world’s largest food exporter. It has 11 percent of the world’s arable land, and with advanced technologies including genetically modified crops, is able to maximize agricultural yields. It is the world’s largest producer of corn and soybeans and one of the world’s largest producers of wheat and rice. Global food prices are affected by US agricultural production, which is affected by the weather. In 2012, a severe drought affected 80 percent of US farmland resulting in corn and soybean shortages. The shortfall lead to international corn and soybean price increases of 25 and 17 percent, respectively. In the decades ahead, the entire United States is expected to warm considerably.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › Farm Bills Key
Johnson 2018 (Roger, president of NFU, former president of the National Association of State Departments of Agriculture, 4/18/18, "Future of American agriculture depends on 2018 farm bill", NOTE: The 2023 farm bill is an extension/renewal of the 2018 farm bill as of the writing of this file)-TL
There hasn’t been a more tumultuous time for the American family farmer in forty years. Escalating tensions between the U.S. and our trading partners are threatening to collapse domestic markets. Natural disasters as a result of climate change are ravaging entire agricultural regions across the country. And massive oversupply of most major commodities means farmers are earning less money than what it costs to grow and raise their crops and livestock. In fact, a majority of American farmers are projected to earn negative farm income this year, many for the second or third year in a row. While volatility is nothing new for the resilient American farmer, the current combination of unstable markets, extreme weather events, and economic despair in the farm economy is rare. If significant action isn’t taken immediately to address these issues, thousands of family farmers will be forced to give up their livelihoods, their ways of life, and for many of them, the places they call home. Farm families who dedicate their lives to providing food, fiber and fuel for the rest of the country, who sustain our rural, suburban and urban communities, and who steward more than half of our nation’s land will not have the opportunity to farm anymore. This significant action needs to start with the 2018 farm bill. Despite operating for decades under policies that favor fewer and larger farms, one saving grace for the American family farmer and her community has been the federal farm bill. The $800 billion piece of legislation serves as a tourniquet for the hemorrhaging of family farmers from the food system, and as the nutrition safety net for consumers who cannot afford to buy food. The current iteration of the farm bill expires in September. This will orphan programs that bolster both farmers’ and consumers’ safety nets. Until we fix the problems that ail our food system, the farm bill is the only legislation keeping many farmers and consumers afloat.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Impact Core › Impact Magnifier
Koren and Bagozzi 2016 (Ore Koren is an Assistant Professor of international relations and methodology in the Department of Political Science, Indiana University, Bloomington and Benjamin E. Bagozzi is Asociate Professor of Political Science & International Relations at the University of Delaware. “From Global to Local, Food Insecurity Is Associated with Contemporary Armed Conflicts.” Food Security, vol. 8, no. 5, Oct. 2016, pp. 999–1010)-TL
What do these findings imply about the effect of food insecurity and conflict? Naturally, even the most detailed and elaborate models are simplistic, especially when containing as diverse a range of observations as those examined above. Nevertheless, in terms of conditional probabilities, all models show a statistically significant first difference change of approximately +92 % in the probability of conflict when a high risk scenario is simulated for an average cell.4 The conditional probabilities discussed above highlight the inherent complexity of social systems, as a phenomenon as notable as violent conflict ultimately arises due to a variety of stressors. Therefore, it should be emphasized that the above findings should not be interpreted as explaining conflict onset. Conflict can erupt due to various political (Buhaug 2010; Fearon and Laitin 2003) or economic (Hegre and Sambanis 2006; Collier and Hoeffler 2005) reasons – which may or may not be related to food insecurity – that are beyond the scope of this paper. Rather, the present study more simply suggests that political violence will have a higher likelihood of concentrating in regions that (i) offer more access to food resources and (ii) face low levels of food availability within areas that offer some access to food resources. This study adopts an economic perspective on food security to explain this variation in the concentration of social conflict. From the demand side, violent conflict is most likely to revolve primarily around access to food sources. When food insecurity produces higher demands for food, these demands will directly compel groups and individuals to seek out and fight over existing food resources, rather than leading these actors to pursue and fight over geographic areas that lack any (or have very little) agricultural resources. Thus, access to croplands and food is a necessary condition for food insecurity-induced conflict, which is confirmed in the cropland analyses presented here. From the supply side, and within those areas that do already offer access to agriculture and/or food, conflict is most likely to occur in regions that offer lower levels of food availability, or insufficient food supplies. This is because lower food availability (or supplies) in these contexts directly implies higher levels of resource scarcity, which can engender social grievances, and ultimately, social and political conflict (Brinkman and Hendrix 2011; Hendrix and Brinkman 2013). More broadly, several causal mechanisms could plausibly link food security and social conflict. For one, conflict in regions with higher food access and lower availability might arise as a principal outcome of food insecurity. This approach is most directly in tune with the body of research concerned with the resource scarcity-based security implications of climate change (e.g. Miguel et al. 2004; Burke et al. 2009; O’Loughlin et al. 2012), as well as with broader studies of conflict dynamics and food security in both rural and urban contexts (Brinkman and Hendrix 2011; Hendrix and Brinkman 2013; Messer and Cohen 2006). From this perspective, individuals and groups actively fight with one another due to food insecurity-induced grievances, which may manifest in groups’ attempts to overthrow existing political structures, or in these actors’ efforts to more directly seize and control available (but scarce) agricultural resources in an effort to better guarantee long-term food security for their constituents. If future global projections for population growth, consumption, and climate change hold true, then these dynamics suggest that incidences of violent conflict over food scarcity and food insecurity may increase as individuals and groups fight over a continuously shrinking pool of resources, including food. A second mechanism involves the existence of logistic support in conflict-prone regions, or lack thereof. Throughout history and well into the nineteenth century, armies living off the land have been a regular characteristic of warfare. The utilization of motorized transport vehicles and airlifts has significantly reduced the need of modern militaries to rely on local populations for support, at least among modernized, highly technological militaries (Kress 2002, 12–13). However, given the bureaucratic and economic capabilities required to maintain such systems, the majority of state and non-state armed groups in the developing world are still unlikely to be supported by well-developed logistic supply chains (Henk and Rupiya 2001). Taking into account the consistent relationship between economic welfare and conflict (Hegre and Sambanis 2006; Fearon and Laitin 2003), unsupported warring groups on all sides of a conflict may move into regions that offer more access to cropland in order to forage and pillage to support themselves, which in turn produces higher incidences of hostilities, especially if there is not much food per person available within these fertile regions. Hence, violent conflict in this case is not the direct result of food insecurity, but rather is shaped by food insecurity concerns.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Internals › Joe Biden Key
Heavican 05-12-23 (Kellan, writer for BrownfieldAgNews.com, BOOZMAN: PRESIDENT BIDEN BACKS AN ON-TIME FARM BILL, https://brownfieldagnews.com/news/boozman-president-biden-backs-an-on-time-farm-bill/)-TL
The Ranking Member of the Senate Ag Committee says President Biden is committed to supporting and passing the 2023 Farm Bill on time. Speaking with reporters after a meeting with the President, Ag Secretary Tom Vilsack, and other leaders of the ag committees, John Boozman says the President “gets it” and his message was clear. “The importance for him as President to get this done for all of us, for all of our states, for our farm community.” He tells Brownfield no specifics were discussed but, “I’m really excited about the prospect of going forward coming up with a farm bill that our farmers can be excited about.” Boozman says the Senate Ag Committee will begin establishing the baseline cost. “We need to kind of figure out our top lines to spend and things like that. I think we’re going to get that figured out in the next couple of months.” And, he says, he expects to meet President Biden again to discuss progress on the legislation. Boozman made his remarks during a press conference at a farm bill roundtable hosted by the University of Nebraska-Lincoln Friday.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Internals › XO Action Key
Davis 05-12-2023 (Susan, reporting for NPR, Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy wants to save Social Security. Will Washington let him?,
It's also still amorphous. While it is no secret to what Cassidy is working on, there's also no official legislative text, and no plans to have any hearings. "Until a president chooses to show leadership, there's no reason to have a hearing," he said. "It will become fodder for somebody running for reelection who would rather be irresponsible with the future of the United States, as opposed to being honest with the American people and coming up with an innovative solution." There was a short window where Cassidy thought Biden might engage on Social Security after the 2022 midterms because Cassidy believes divided government is the only way to advance bipartisan legislation that affects entitlement programs. "Ultimately, [the White House] decided that the president is going to run for reelection accusing Republicans of wanting to destroy Social Security. He made that clear in his State of the Union speech," Cassidy said. While he says he will vote Republican in 2024, he's already made it clear he will not vote for Trump if he is the party's nominee. Cassidy was one of seven Senate Republicans who voted to convict Trump in the Senate impeachment trial for his role in inciting the Jan. 6 attack on the U.S. Capitol. Whether or not being an opponent of the most popular man in the Republican Party will make it difficult to advance policy ideas within that same party, Cassidy shrugs. "Scripture says that today's own troubles be sufficient for the day. I can worry all I want to about tomorrow. My goal is today." For now, Cassidy and his allies are waiting for their moment, which will come sometime after the 2024 election and sometime before Social Security hits insolvency in about a decade. He said he intends to spend the rest of his time in Congress trying to solve it. He faces reelection in 2026. "I'm here to do something, not to be something," he said. "And if we can do something — wow. On my epitaph, it'll be several things listed, but one of them will be: Worked with others to fix Social Security."
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Internals › PC Finite
Siewert 17 (Markus B. Siewert “"It’s Never Easy for the President to Get Exactly What He Wants.” : Presidential Activism and Success in the Legislative Arena During the Presidencies of Clinton, Bush, and Obama” Inaugural dissertation to obtain the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Faculty of Social Sciences of the Johann Wolfgang Goethe University to Frankfurt am Main, Submitted: April 2017, Released: June 2018, )
One of the most important presidential strategies in the legislative arena is (trying) to set the agenda of Congress (see Wood 2009 for an extensive overview; Cohen 2012; Edwards and Wood 1999; Light 1999). The reasoning behind this is straightforward: Since presidents have only few tools at hand to sway lawmakers on how they cast their ballot, the focus of the White House is set at an earlier stage: by already influencing what is considered in the first place. Compared with the legislative prevalence of executives in parliamentarian democracies, presidents in the United States are clearly less able to dominate the agenda space. Yet based on his constitutional right to recommend legislation deemed necessary and appropriate (Art. II, Sec 3, U.S. Constitution), it is primarily the resources of the executive branch - i.e., the departmental bureaucracies, and the Executive Office of the President - which put the president into the position to exert policy leadership via drafting legislative proposals. Unmatched by any other single legislators or even Congress as a whole, John W. Kingdon is right to argue that “[…] no other single actor in the political system has quite the capability of the president to set agendas.“ (Kingdon 2003, 24). Previous research has shown that defining the agenda is a promising strategy for the White House. Presidential initiatives, both major and minor ones, almost always find their way into the legislative hopper (Cameron and Park 2008, 51f; Cohen 2012, 24ff; Edwards and Barrett 2000, 116ff). Accordingly, legislation proposed by the administration makes up between 30% and 50% of the congressional calendar, while the remaining proportion is initiated by members of Congress, is based on recurring pieces of legislation, and are reaction to external events or imminent crises (Edwards and Barrett 2000, 112ff; Taylor 1998, 377ff; Theriault 2002). While this indeed makes the president the single most important agenda-setter, it also demonstrates that he does not dominate the legislative agenda of Congress (Sinclair 2006, 255–63). We can mainly identify three mechanisms how presidential agenda-setting affects the lawmaking process in Congress. First, it enables the president to define the boundaries of policies under consideration, and in this way to structure the following deliberation. In this sense, agenda setting is first and foremost about obtaining the Deutungshoheit - i.e., the prerogative of interpretation - over the policy debate through setting the terms of the debate, moving first on certain policy aspects, and via framing and priming of core arguments (Edwards and Wood 1999; Eshbaugh-Soha and Peake 2005). George W. Bush, for instance, during his 2000 presidential campaign advertised his plans for massive across the board tax breaks which, at that time, were perceived as a mere “pipe dream” on both sides of the political spectrum (Milbank 2001). Cutting taxes, and especially to this extent, did not rank high among the priorities of lawmakers nor the American public. The arrival of Bush in the White House, however, completely changed the dynamics of debate. It put the tax cut proposal upfront of the legislative agenda during his first half year as president, and Democrats in the end had to accept an amount of tax breaks which came up to more than double of what they called reasonable six months before during the election campaign. Bill Clinton, on the other hand, was largely rolled by the issue dynamics in the debates regarding the overhaul of the Internal Revenue Service in 1997. Favoring only minor reforms, he had to concede early on to pressures from the public and Congress who, fueled by several major scandals, thirsted for a largescale reorganization of the IRS instead of a fine-tuning approach preferred by Clinton (Broder 1997). Of course, these are only two illustrations highlighting how presidents can succeed but also fail in setting the tone of the debate from early stages and through this pre-structure the outcome of the lawmaking process. Second, presidential leadership at the agenda-setting stage helps to overcome collective action problems within Congress and among its 535 legislators by providing a focal point around which other political actors’ policy positions can crystalize (Cameron and Park 2008; Cohen 2012; Neustadt 1991, 8f). The USA PATRIOT Act can serve as a prime example in this regard, on which the New York Times stressed that “[b]y and large, the House and Senate bills both use as a starting point a proposal sent to Capitol Hill nearly two weeks ago by the White House.” (Lewis and Pear 2001). Since lawmakers in Congress today only have scarce resources to draft their own bills, presidential input from the beginning is often highly appreciated. Yet, a proposal from the White House furthermore fulfills the role of first mover draft upon which the subsequent debate can be structured. In this sense, it both offers a distinct policy outline upfront and provides guiding posts for the further deliberation process. Third, agenda-setting offers the White House the opportunity to highlight its priorities, how they are distributed across various policy issues, and in which way policies should be packaged (Rudalevige 2005, 437ff; Wayne 2009b, 317ff). Because the resources of any administration to lobby Congress are not infinite and the multiple political arenas are usually heavily crowded with myriad policy items and problems striving to be solved, the White House needs to prioritize its policy agenda. This involves, among other things, to select some issues over others, decide about their sequencing, how to pursue them, and how much political capital it wants or needs to spend on any given item. Therefore, the administration will focus on certain policies with more attention, on others with less, depending on the prioritization by the president but also upon other considerations, such as the overall density of the policy agenda or imminent pressures of the time. The trick is to not overwhelm Congress with the president’s initiatives. As Lyndon B. Johnson famously quipped, “Congress is like a Whiskey drinker. You can put an awful lot of whiskey into a man if you just let him sip it. But if you try to force the whole bottle down his throat at one time, he’ll throw it up.” (cited in Rudalevige 2002, 113). Thus, the failure to prioritize easily leads to overload of Pennsylvania Avenue with Congress at the one end, and to excessive demands and exhaustion for the White House at the other end. The rocky start of the Clinton administration underlines this argument: since the White House did not pursue a ‘rifle-approach’ to define clear policy priorities for its initial months and then execute them, it got lost in numerous legislative battles and mine-fields early on in its first year. Instead it followed a ‘shotgun-approach’ by addressing as many issues as possible at once leading to an overkill and chaos (Rockman 1996; Sinclair 2000b).
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Internals › PC Finite
Hayward 12 (John is a writer at Human Events. “DON’T BE GLAD THE BUFFETT RULE IS DEAD, BE ANGRY IT EVER EXISTED,” 4/17, http://www.humanevents.com/2012/04/17/dont-be-glad-the-buffett-rule-is-dead-be-angry-it-ever-existed/)
Toomey makes the excellent point that Obama’s class-warfare sideshow act is worse than useless, because it’s wasting America’s valuable time, even as the last fiscal sand runs through our hourglass. Politicians speak of “political capital” in selfish terms, as a pile of chips each party hoards on its side of the poker table, but in truth America has only a finite amount of political capital in total. When time and energy is wasted on pointless distractions, the capital expended---in the form of the public’s attention, and the debates they hold among themselves---cannot easily be regained. ¶ There is an “opportunity cost” associated with the debates we aren’t having, and the valid ideas we’re not considering, when our time is wasted upon nonsense that is useful only to political re-election campaigns. Health care reform is the paramount example of our time, as countless real, workable market-based reforms were obscured by the flaccid bulk of ObamaCare. The Buffett Rule, like all talk of tax increases in the shadow of outrageous government spending, likewise distracts us from the real issues.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Internals › Generic PC k2 Farm Bill
Brooks and Schnell 06-07-23 (EMILY BROOKS AND MYCHAEL SCHNELL writing for TheHill, Conservative rebels throw House into limbo, https://thehill.com/homenews/house/4038648-conservative-rebels-throw-house-into-limbo/)-TL
Conservatives are still incensed at the debt limit compromise deal McCarthy struck with President Biden that got more votes from Democrats than Republicans, though two-thirds of the GOP conference voted for the bill. A group of 20 “concerned” conservatives met among themselves Wednesday morning to discuss their issues with leadership, Rep. Ralph Norman (R-S.C.) told The Hill. But the major hurdle to reaching some agreement appears to be a big one: The conservatives haven’t named any demands and are still deciding what they should be. “I don’t know,” Rep. Andy Biggs (R-Ariz.) said when asked what he is looking for in order to break the impasse and move legislation on the floor again. “The Speaker formed a coalition with Democrats to get us a $4 trillion national debt. And I continued to be concerned because he hasn’t repudiated that coalition. And my guess is he’s prepared to do that again on the next three must-pass bills: Farm Bill, NDAA, and the budget.” “We’re looking for concrete things that are going to be done,” Norman said. When asked to elaborate, he responded, “well, that’s in process now.”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › AT: Winners Win
Khari 2021 (Williams, Khari. “The Choices Joe Biden Makes Now Will Set His Legacy in Motion.” Roll Call, Roll Call, 23 Jan. 2021, www.rollcall.com/2021/01/25/the-choices-joe-biden-makes-now-will-set-his-legacy-in-motion/ )-TL
ANALYSIS — President Joe Biden laid out a sweeping mission on Inauguration Day, declaring his goal to tackle the “cascading crises” afflicting America. He cited eroding faith in democracy and even in truth, growing inequity, systemic racism and the climate crisis. “Any one of these would be enough to challenge us in profound ways. But the fact is, we face them all at once,” he said. Biden pledged then to “rise to the occasion” and “to master this rare and difficult hour.” The implication was that he would offer solutions, or at least progress, to all of these crises. In reality, he’ll have to pick his battles, and the choices he makes in the coming weeks will begin to set the terms of his legacy. The modern president faces constraints built into the framers’ system of checks and balances. The job is all the harder given the party polarization that today makes even plausible compromises hard to reach. So Biden will have to decide: Which crises deserve the bulk of his attention and political capital and which will have to wait? Presidents have to make these choices early, when their terms are fresh and their party is in control of Congress because that’s when making far-reaching law is possible. There’s no doubt that Biden will focus on the pandemic. He will try to use COVID-19 relief to address other Democratic priorities around inequity, racial injustice and environmental protection. But with a Senate evenly divided at 50-50 and a 10-seat Democratic House majority, any overreach could plunge his agenda into quicksand. Biden is seasoned enough in the ways of Washington that he knows this. So of the sweeping pledges in his inaugural address, some will rise to the top of his legislative agenda and he’ll settle in other cases for rhetorical nods, executive actions and regulatory maneuvers. Some pledges will prove just lip service to constituencies in the Democratic Party’s base. Biden’s agenda is already circumscribed by a pandemic that has taken 400,000 American lives and, despite the rollout of vaccines, shows only halting signs of abating. With his announcement of a $1.9 trillion plan to fight the virus and help Americans crushed by its economic effects, Biden demonstrated that he’d like to use it as a vehicle for his broader goals. That’s why it includes an increase in the minimum wage to $15 per hour and a refundable tax credit for children. Both would redistribute more of the country’s wealth to those at the bottom end. In proposing draft legislation to offer a path to citizenship to immigrants living in the country illegally, Biden indicated it was also at the top of his list, and that he’s willing to gamble that 10 Republican senators will want to put the issue that animated Donald Trump’s presidency aside. In 2013, 14 Republican senators voted for a similar proposal, but all but five of them are gone.What will Biden allow to slip? His incoming Treasury secretary, Janet Yellen, said that tax hikes on corporations and the wealthy would not be an immediate priority. And Biden has not yet pressed Democratic priorities of years past to overhaul policing to combat racial injustice, to bolster the ability of workers to organize unions, and to restrict gun ownership. His climate actions and plans, halting the Keystone XL pipeline and pledging aid for green job creation, look more like a middle ground than the more far-reaching assault on fossil fuels that climate activists want.These decisions have consequences. The president Biden served for eight years, Barack Obama, let immigration slip off his priority list in 2009 and 2010 in favor of an economic stimulus, an overhaul of American health insurance and a financial regulatory law. The comprehensive immigration bill he said he wanted never got done. Obama settled for executive actions to combat biased policing and to keep guns away from criminals and unstable people. He put little capital behind congressional Democrats’ efforts to pass laws creating a cap and trade system for carbon emissions and to expand labor organizing via a card check system. Obama moved only late in his presidency to regulate greenhouse gas emissions, and his most far-reaching proposal to combat power plant pollution died with Trump. The same was true of Obama’s plan to dramatically expand overtime pay to help the working class. As a result, some crises grew more severe in Obama’s time, while the ones he prioritized — unemployment, the uninsured and financial malfeasance — abated.Republicans are already dismissing Biden’s virus relief proposal as too expensive and overbroad and his executive actions as sops to progressives. “On the Biden administration’s very first day, it took several big steps in the wrong direction,” Senate Minority Leader said Thursday. He pressed Democrats to commit to preserving the filibuster rule that most Senate legislation win 60 votes in order to “check and balance one another respectfully.” But Democratic constituency groups, such as advocates for immigrants and teachers’ unions concerned about school safety during the pandemic, were thrilled to be atop Biden’s priority list, while those further down are holding their fire for now.Biden could move his proposals with bipartisan support — like $1,400 checks for most Americans and new funding for vaccine distribution and schools — through regular order if 10 GOP senators will vote to break a filibuster. And he could save aid to states and expanded unemployment benefits for a budget reconciliation process that will allow Democrats to pass one bill per year without any GOP support.Biden could use a second reconciliation process, in 2022, to expand access to health care, rebuild American infrastructure or tackle climate change. But Republicans hope he tacks to the center.President George W. Bush faced a Congress much like the one with which Biden must deal, split nearly evenly between Democrats and Republicans. He won his biggest legislative successes, tax cuts, through budget reconciliation, then co-opted issues popular with his opposition.Bush succeeded on territory comfortable for Democrats, increasing education funding and accountability measures in his No Child Left Behind education law, and offering seniors a Medicare drug benefit. The partisan items he let slip, such as partial privatization of Social Security, didn’t get done.Bill Clinton, chastened by his failure to overhaul health care, also moved to the center to work with Republicans on a welfare law and expanded free trade. Even Trump, after his success using reconciliation to enact 2017’s tax overhaul, worked with Democrats on 2018’s law to offer more leniency to nonviolent criminals and to improve prison programs aimed at reducing recidivism.For Biden, that might be a path to success with Congress, although it’s bound to disappoint his party’s progressive base.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › AT: Winners Win
Shepard 05-31-23 (Alex, writing for The New Republic, Joe Biden Won the Debt Ceiling Negotiation but Lost the War, https://newrepublic.com/article/173083/joe-biden-won-debt-ceiling-negotiation-lost-war
The good news about the agreement on the debt ceiling President Joe Biden and House Speaker Kevin McCarthy struck is that it’s probably the best deal Democrats could have gotten. Biden can sell his party on the fact that the deal falls far short of the draconian demands made by the GOP’s right flank—who had previously been running the show and are now incensed at being left behind. Democrats had spent much of the debt negotiations on their back foot; now Republicans are in disarray. Similarly, Biden can once again sell voters on the fact that he’s a sober dealmaker committed to keeping the government functioning, not the fire-breathing ideologue or doddering vegetable that Republicans typically portray him as. There’s not much to celebrate in this deal, but Biden can pitch it to both skeptical members of his party and the public as a necessary compromise: Once negotiations with McCarthy began, this was probably the best deal he could have struck. The bad news is that he made a deal at all. Everything that’s good about this deal, provided it passes, occurs in the short term: The government doesn’t default; the United States only suffers minor reputational harm. Generally speaking, avoiding apocalypse—and default could have caused something close to that—is a good thing. But by negotiating with McCarthy, Biden legitimized what were effectively terrorist tactics and dramatically increased the likelihood of an apocalyptic event in the near future. Republicans can and will continue to hold the debt ceiling hostage; the expectation, thanks to Biden’s willingness to engage, is that concessions will follow—or else the U.S. defaults. This is a clear deviation from recent Democratic strategy, and it is a potentially devastating one. In 2011, Barack Obama got played by Republicans: He thought they were negotiating about raising the debt ceiling in good faith; they weren’t. Realizing this too late, he submitted to steep, multitrillion-dollar cuts—ones that were devastating to a still-anemic postrecession economy—in order to avoid default. Having realized that Republicans had no interest in legitimate bargaining, however, Obama set what should have been the ongoing precedent: Don’t negotiate over the debt ceiling. It worked—subsequent fights over raising the debt ceiling avoided concessions. The lesson has been clear: If you want to win, don’t play the game. Biden paid lip service to this strategy, repeatedly making public statements to the effect that raising the debt ceiling was nonnegotiable. This is a reasonable stance. For one thing, Republicans have always voted to raise the debt ceiling when they are in power. For another, it is existential: It must be done so the U.S. government can continue to function. Failing to raise it, moreover, would catastrophically damage America’s reputation abroad and potentially blow up the economy. Republicans were putting a gun to the head of the American—and perhaps global—economy, and they were doing it for base, political reasons. The only responsible thing to do was to ignore them. This was also good politics for Biden. He was betting against Kevin McCarthy, something few have gone broke doing. McCarthy’s caucus is unruly; getting his seat as speaker of the House required major concessions to his most unhinged members. Biden made a calculated bet that McCarthy couldn’t put together a package that could serve as a starting point for negotiations, a bet he ultimately lost. McCarthy did produce one—an unworkable, ridiculous budget and one that showed the Republican Party’s eagerness to slash necessary social programs relating to health care and education—by the skin of his teeth last month. But McCarthy and Republicans had also made a bet about Biden: that he would cave. Biden likes negotiating too much; his statements about not negotiating were resolute, but there was a hint of squishiness—Biden kept leaving openings for possible negotiations. After McCarthy and House Republicans passed their budget, that’s exactly what happened. Biden played ball. And while, yes, he won the negotiating battle, he lost the debt ceiling war. That’s largely because Republicans can come back to the table the next time the debt ceiling is up for raising in a divided government and ask for, well, anything. As New York’s Jonathan Chait writes in a perceptive piece about the implications of this deal, “given that Republicans have probably cut domestic discretionary spending as low as they can tolerate if not lower, the next round of demands will likely cut deeper into anti-poverty programs that were spared this time. Or possibly, Republicans will creatively demand concessions on immigration, abortion, or any other social issue that has seized their imagination at the moment.” There’s simply no telling where this will lead, but none of it is reassuring. Now opened, this Pandora’s box is going to be almost impossible to close.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › Green New Deal
Teirstein 2019 (Zoya, staff writer for Grist, How are Republicans dealing with Green New Deal enthusiasm? As well as you’d expect., 02-11-2019 https://grist.org/article/how-are-republicans-dealing-with-green-new-deal-enthusiasm-as-well-as-youd-expect/)-TL
Congressional Republicans don’t have a plan to tackle climate change — an issue voters across the political spectrum now agree needs to be addressed — but it only took a weekend for the GOP to come up with a response to the Green New Deal proposed by Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Senator Ed Markey. Surprise! The right is not a fan of the proposal, which calls for rapid decarbonization of the economy alongside other agenda items like universal healthcare, housing, and a federal jobs guarantee. Already, more than 15 percent of the House — 68 members — have signed on as sponsors of the deal. Supporters include five high-profile presidential contenders, Cory Booker, Kamala Harris, Elizabeth Warren, Kirsten Gillibrand, and, most recently, Amy Klobuchar. Republicans, banking on the hope that backing such an ambitious proposal will come back to bite Democrats during the presidential election next year, unleashed a torrent of backhanded encouragement. “It would be great for the so-called ‘Carbon Footprint’ to permanently eliminate all Planes, Cars, Cows, Oil, Gas & the Military – even if no other country would do the same. Brilliant!,” President Trump tweeted on Saturday. Eliminating airplanes and oil and gas would be great for our carbon footprint, but the resolution doesn’t actually call for an end to fossil fuels. “I would like them to push it as far as they can. I’d like to see it on the floor. I’d like to see them actually have to vote on it,” Idaho Republican Representative Mike Simpson told Politico, adding, “It’s crazy. It’s loony.” South Carolina’s Lindsey Graham tweeted on Friday, “Let’s vote on the Green New Deal!” Other Republicans took a more straightforward approach. Wyoming Republican and Environment Chair John Barrasso called the deal a “socialist manifesto.” “I think everyone on our side would say that the Green New Deal is a little bit much,” Michigan Representative Fred Upton told journalists. Clearly, Republicans are a bit skeptical of the goals outlined in AOC and Markey’s resolution. But I think the Democrats pushing the deal would agree with Senator Graham: “Let’s vote on the Green New Deal!”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › Medicaid
Olstein 03-08-23 (Alice, writing for Politico, Republicans take aim at Medicaid as budget talks heat up, https://www.politico.com/news/2023/03/08/house-democrats-republicans-medicaid-00086136)-TL
Senior Republicans in the House and Senate are proposing deep cuts to Medicaid as talks around reducing the deficit intensify ahead of a budget showdown between President Joe Biden and House leaders. As outside conservative groups make a case for cuts in closed-door briefings and calls, members point to pledges from party leaders on both sides not to touch Social Security or Medicare as a key reason the health insurance program for low-income Americans is on the chopping block. Lawmakers, however, remain divided on how they want to bring down the cost of the $700 billion program, with proposals to add work requirements, cap spending and repeal Obamacare’s Medicaid expansion all under consideration. “No one’s interested in doing anything other than saving it to make it more solvent for those that might need it down the road,” Sen. Mike Braun (R-Ind.) told POLITICO. “If you want to save [Medicaid] for future generations, it’s never too early to look at how to do that.” Biden, who is expected to release his budget on Thursday, has spent much of the year castigating Republicans for proposals to cut Medicare, Social Security, Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act part of a broader effort to paint the GOP as a threat to popular health programs. Though Democrats, who control the Senate, will almost certainly reject big cuts to Medicaid, Republicans’ desire to rein in federal spending portends a drawn out political fight over a program that now insures more than one-in-four Americans. Republican House and Senate leadership have been adamant that they will not cut those two entitlement programs, but have said less about Medicaid, which insures more than 90 million Americans. That number swelled during the Covid-19 pandemic, when states were barred from removing people who were no longer eligible. Asked if assurances by GOP leaders that Medicare and Social Security are off the table have put more pressure on lawmakers to find savings in Medicaid, Rep. Michael Burgess (R-Texas) quipped: “It doesn’t take much imagination to figure that out.” Some Republicans want to revive a 2017 plan to phase out the enhanced federal match for Medicaid and cap spending for the program — an approach the Congressional Budget Office estimated would save $880 billion over 10 years and increase the number of uninsured people by 21 million. “If you remember back to the American Health Care Act, we proposed that we make some significant changes to Medicaid. I think you’re gonna find that some of those same ideas are going to be revisited,” said Rep. Buddy Carter (R-Ga.), a member of the House Budget Committee and the conservative Republican Study Committee, a group now working on its own budget proposal to pitch to GOP leadership. Carter added that there is also interest in the caucus in abolishing Obamacare’s Medicaid expansion, arguing that the majority of states that have opted to expand the program over the last decade might have “buyer’s remorse.” “Medicaid was always intended for the aged, blind and disabled — for the least in our society, who need help the most,” he said. “Trying to get back to that would probably be beneficial.” Carter and many other Republicans are also pushing for Medicaid work requirements, though the one state that implemented them saw thousands of people who should have qualified lose coverage. “For the people who are on traditional Medicaid — the pregnant, children and disabled — there’s no sense in talking about work requirements,” Burgess said. “But for the expansion population, able-bodied adults who were wrapped in under the Affordable Care Act, yeah, that has to be part of the discussion.” Other Republicans want to make narrower reforms. Rep. Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.), who chairs the Energy and Commerce Committee’s Health Subcommittee, is looking at changes to value-based payments in Medicaid so that states aren’t “on the hook for treatments that don’t work.” Still others are weighing potential changes to areas within Medicaid, including provider taxes and how to handle coverage for people who are eligible for both Medicare and Medicaid. The GOP members are spurred on by outside conservative groups like the Paragon Institute, which has been holding monthly briefings for Capitol Hill aides and backchanneling with members. “If you look at what’s driving the debt, it’s federal health programs,” Brian Blase, the president of Paragon, who worked at the White House’s National Economic Council under the Trump administration, told POLITICO. “Either Congress will reform federal health programs or there will be a massive tax increase on the middle class.” Democrats, for their part, are working to make any proposal to cut Medicaid as politically risky for Republicans as threats to Medicare. “I worry that my Republican colleagues have, I guess, heard from the public about their desire to cut Social Security and Medicare [and] are looking elsewhere, and obviously poor people have very little representation in Congress, so that’s an easy target,” said Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), who chairs the Health, Education, Labor and Pensions committee. Democrats hoping to shield Medicaid in the upcoming budget negotiations are emphasizing how many red states have voted to expand the program since Republicans last took a run at it in 2017. They’re also stressing that the people covered by Medicaid aren’t solely low-income parents and children. “Right now at least 50 percent of Medicaid goes to seniors, and a lot of that is for nursing home care,” Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.), the top Democrat on the Energy and Commerce Committee, told reporters. “People don’t realize that Medicaid is the ultimate payer for nursing home care once you run out of money or once your Medicare runs out.” In a speech in late February, President Joe Biden excoriated Republicans for pushing deep cuts to Medicaid, arguing that doing so would threaten the finances of rural hospitals that are barely able to keep their doors open today. “Many places throughout the Midwest, you have to drive 30, 40 miles to get to a hospital. By that time, you’re dead,” he said. “Entire communities depend on these hospitals. Not getting Medicaid would shut many of them down.” Two people familiar with White House plans tell POLITICO that Biden is expected to include a federal expansion of Medicaid in the remaining holdout states in the budget he will submit to Congress later this week.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › Increase Taxes
Catennaci and Alic 2022 (Thomas and Haris, writing for Fox Buisness, Republicans slam Dems' plans to increase taxes again in 2023: 'The left's Holy Grail is tax hikes', 08-12-22 https://www.foxbusiness.com/politics/republicans-slam-dems-plans-increase-taxes-2023-lefts-holy-grail-tax-hikes)-TL
Several House Republicans condemned Democrats' apparent plans to increase taxes in 2023 if they were to keep majority control in Congress. Rep. Richard Neal, D-Mass., the chairman of the powerful House Ways and Means Committee, said Democrats would seek to boost both corporate and individual tax rates if they kept control of the House following the upcoming midterm elections in November, according to Bloomberg reporter Erik Wasson. Neal added that Democrats could seek to revive previously proposed overhauls of the tax code to raise federal revenue and pay for major spending programs. "For anybody that was even debating whether or not we should remove Speaker Nancy Pelosi from the speakership, now, they have further evidence." Rep. Bryan Steil, R-Wis., the top GOP member of the Select Committee on the Economy, told FOX Business in an interview. "The last thing we should be doing in a recession is raising taxes." "The Democrats are showing their cards that their plan is to continue to raise taxes and recklessly spend, which is a recipe for the disaster that we're already experiencing with runaway inflation," Steil continued. Steil was one of many Republican lawmakers who quickly responded in force to Neal's comments. "This has been their problem from day one," Rep. Tom Emmer, R-Minn., the chairman of the National Republican Congressional Committee (NRCC), told FOX Business. "They don't have an answer for the double-digit inflation that they caused. They don't have an answer for gas prices except destroying our economy so people buy less. "Remember, every consumer ends up paying those taxes," he continued. "They can tax corporations and make these statements all they want, but it all gets passed through to the consumer on the street." In response to the report Friday, the NRCC tweeted that Americans should "Vote. Them. Out." "Congressional Democrats are one trick ponies. Their solution to every problem is to tax more and spend more of other people’s money," Rep. Andy Barr, R-Ky., a senior member of the House Financial Services Committee, told FOX Business. "Today’s historic tax increase during a recession is just another example. Republicans will put an end to this failed economic agenda in the next Congress." Rep. Kevin Hern, R-Okla., a member of the House Ways and Means Committee and the chairman of the Republican Study Committee's budget and spending task force, said additional taxes on business will only lead to more companies moving operations overseas. "When you make it more difficult by increasing the tax rates, our businesses will go someplace where they can create a better environment for their workers," Hern told FOX Business. Hern added that Democrats want to tax Americans more and make Washington an "even bigger place than it is right now." "The left's Holy Grail is tax hikes and more government control of our lives," Rep. David Schweikert, R-Ariz., another House Ways and Means Committee member, told FOX Business. "At least the left is being honest about the dystopian future they intend to bring us." Schweikert said people who believe Democrats aren't in favor of new tax hikes "haven't been listening." "They're about to raise taxes by over $300 billion, which will ultimately be paid by American consumers," Rep. Blaine Luetkemeyer, R-Mo., the ranking member of the House Small Business Committee, tweeted. "Now Democrats are proudly saying this is only the beginning." "Democrats aren’t hiding they want to keep raising taxes," Rep. Mike Waltz, R-Fla., added. "Remember when you go to vote." However, Rep. Bill Pascrell, D-N.J., responded in support of Neal's comments. He said Democrats' top priority is to ensure the wealthy pay "their fair share," while the GOP is committed to allowing billionaires to cheat on their taxes. Meanwhile, the House is set to vote on the Inflation Reduction Act, a spending package that includes a series of tax hikes. The bill, which passed the Senate on Sunday, includes a corporate minimum tax projected to raise federal revenue by $313 billion, boosts tax enforcement which would increase revenue by about $124 billion and imposes a stock buyback tax on corporations, raising another $74 billion.
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › FJG
Bonn 2019 (Tess, reporting for The Hill, Yang rips Sanders’s federal jobs guarantee, says it poses ‘whole set of problems’,09-19-19
Presidential candidate Andrew Yang ripped Democratic rival Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) over his proposed federal jobs guarantee, saying implementation would ignore “a whole set of problems” for parents and caregivers. “The spirit of it is fantastic,” Yang told Hill.TV during an interview that aired Thursday. “But the implementation would have a whole set of problems.” “The biggest issue I have with this idea of federal jobs guarantee is it ignores the sort of work that my wife does every day who’s at home with our two boys, one of whom is autistic,” he added. “The federal jobs guarantee does nothing for parents, nurturers and caregivers.” Sanders’s campaign didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment. Sanders’s proposed federal jobs guarantee is based on the notion that all Americans should be entitled to a well-paying job that pays at least $15 an hour and comes with health care and child care. Yang also doubled down on defense of his universal basic income proposal, which has drawn criticism from Sanders. “If you put this money into our hands, it creates hundreds of thousands of jobs right in our communities where we live and work,” Yang told Hill.TV. “Work that we’d be excited about doing.” Yang has warned that automation is one of the biggest threats to the labor force, and that his solution is a universal basic income program that would give every American $1,000 a month. The former entrepreneur used the third Democratic primary debate to announce a pilot program of his proposal. During his opening statement at the debate last week, Yang announced that he would randomly pick 10 families to receive $1,000 a month for a year. He told Hill.TV that 500,000 people have already signed up for the Freedom Dividend pilot program. In an interview with Hill.TV in August, Sanders said there’s “no question” that automation and artificial intelligence would have a fundamental impact on working families, as Yang has argued. But Sanders said “people want to work,” and to “be a productive member of society.”
2023
GDI
Disadvantage
2NC › 2NC Link Core › UBI
Brufke 2020 (Juilegrace, writing for the Hill, GOP lawmakers slam proposals for guaranteed income amid pandemic, 04-29-2020,
House Republicans are pushing back on the idea of providing a minimum guaranteed income to Americans amid the financial fallout of the coronavirus pandemic. Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) expressed an openness to the concept on Monday during an interview with MSNBC while discussing the financial aid recently approved by Congress to help bolster the economy. “Let’s see what works, what is operational and what needs attention,” she said. “Others have suggested a minimum income, a guaranteed income for people. Is that worthy of attention now? Perhaps so,” Pelosi continued. “Because there are many more people than just in small business and hired by small business … that may need some assistance as well.” While Congress previously passed coronavirus relief measures that included provisions to provide up to $1,200 to individuals and forgivable loans to small businesses, proponents of a universal basic income have argued that Congress needs to do more to help Americans stay afloat. However, top GOP lawmakers are accusing Democrats of attempting to use the pandemic to move policy to the left, blasting the proposal as fiscally irresponsible and opportunistic. “It’s incredibly tone-deaf of Speaker Pelosi to continue using this crisis to push these radical socialist ideas that have been consistently rejected,” House Minority Whip Steve Scalise (R-La.) said. “What we should be focused on is responsibly implementing the relief packages we passed to get trillions of dollars directly into the hands of families and businesses so the American people have jobs and an economy to come back to when we finally reopen.” Rep. Jim Banks (R-Ind.) echoed Scalise’s sentiments, arguing that Congress should be working on a plan to get the economy back on track after the pandemic. “Congressional Democrats already told us they’re taking advantage of a crisis to turn America into a socialist country. They admitted this pandemic is a ‘tremendous opportunity to restructure things to fit [their] vision,’ ” Banks said, referring to a comment made by House Majority Whip James Clyburn (D-S.C.). “Republicans, on the other hand, are trying to provide temporary relief to preserve the strong Trump economy we had before the pandemic.” Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.) also blasted Democrats for considering the idea. “The Speaker’s comments reaffirm that Republicans are the party of working Americans while Democrats prefer diminished productivity, hundreds of millions for illegal aliens, upgrades to the Kennedy Center and bailouts for states that made bad decisions before COVID-19 ever escaped the Wuhan Institute of Virology,” Gaetz told The Hill. There has been no evidence that the coronavirus outbreak originated from a research lab in Wuhan. Meanwhile, others have argued that they don’t believe creating another safety net is necessary, pointing out that there are already programs in place that can be utilized to help those struggling financially. “We already have a universal basic income — it’s called work. We also have [Social Security Disability Insurance] SSDI for people who are unable to work physically or due to disabilities. We have security if you’re older, they’ve earned it,” Rep. Paul Mitchell (R-Mich.) told The Hill. “We have a variety of forms of support for people like unemployment compensation and public assistance for purely short-term assistance,” Mitchell continued, “so I’m trying to understand exactly what [Pelosi] wants to do besides throw more money at people.” While the idea of a standard income has faced strong opposition from the GOP, members of both parties have floated proposals for additional federal assistance to be provided to individuals and businesses amid the pandemic. Sen. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) has proposed for the federal government to pay 80 percent of workers’ wages through the end of the pandemic. And Reps. Tim Ryan (D-Ohio) and Ro Khanna (D-Calif.) have proposed for those making less than $130,000 a year to receive a monthly payment of at least $2,000. Rep. Pramila Jayapal (D-Wash.), a co-chair of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, introduced a measure that would create a program to provide a federal guarantee for 100 percent of workers’ salaries up to $100,000 for up to three months.