Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › Compartmentalization

Lawmakers compartmentalize

Pergram 18 (Chad Pergram, Congressional reporter. “Amid Kavanaugh cacophony, Congress forges bipartisan agreements on key issues”. October 13, 2018. )

Step back from the Kavanaugh cacophony. Examine what lawmakers from both parties in both chambers accomplished in September and early October, with virtually zero fanfare. Amid the turmoil, Congress approved the first revamp of national aviation policy in years. The Senate approved the final version of the legislation 93-6. This came after a staggering six extensions due to bickering and disagreement. Then, Congress approved a sweeping, bipartisan measure to combat opioid abuse. The House okayed the package 393-8. The Senate adopted the measure 98-1. And, there was no government shutdown. The House and Senate came to terms on two bipartisan bills which funded five of the 12 annual spending bills which operate the government. The sides agreed to latch an additional measure to one of the spending plans to fund the remaining seven areas of federal spending through December 7. President Trump briefly threatened to force a government shutdown if lawmakers didn’t include money for his border wall in the plan. But the President ultimately punted that battle until December. Democrats praised Republicans for keeping conservative “poison pill” riders out of the appropriations bills. That decision drew Democratic support for the measures. The Senate approved a bipartisan water and infrastructure package. McConnell hailed the bipartisanship which descended upon the Senate – even as the senators fought over Kavanaugh. Nearly in the same breath, McConnell derided boisterous, anti-Kavanaugh protesters outside the Capitol as a “mob.” McConnell insisted this week he needed the Senate to clear a slate of 15 conservative judges to lower courts before he could cut senators loose for the midterm elections. McConnell and Schumer appeared at loggerheads. McConnell’s goal was clear: extract the confirmation of these nominees – or tether to Washington vulnerable Democratic senators from battleground states to keep them off the campaign trail. Schumer knew McConnell would ultimately prevail on the nominees after the midterms. So the New York Democrat accepted McConnell’s ransom, permitting the Senate vote on a slate of nominees on Thursday night. Schumer also extracted a concession from McConnell: send senators home until November 13th. One may wonder how lawmakers can find themselves in an imbroglio over a major issue like Kavanaugh – yet forge major bipartisan accords on other. Frankly, that’s just politics. Politics always elicits strange bedfellows. Successful lawmakers know they should compartmentalize their disputes. The enemy today may be your best ally tomorrow.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › Winners Win

Winner’s win---spending PC rebuilds it

Kane 7-24-2021, The Washington Post's senior congressional correspondent and columnist (Paul, “Day-to-day, Biden’s agenda looks rocky. But congressional Democrats say things are far rosier if you take the long view.,” Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/powerpost/biden-agenda-democrats-congress/2021/07/24/83b776be-ebc0-11eb-ba5d-55d3b5ffcaf1_story.html)

There is, so far at least, little fear that Democrats are spreading themselves too thin by eschewing the traditional practice of focusing on a handful of domestic policy issues in the first two years of an administration. “Political momentum and political capital is like a muscle. The more you exercise it, the more of it you have. It is not like a finite resource that you can run out of if you spend too much of it. What happens is that if we do a lot of positive things, then we’ve got more political clout to do even more positive things,” Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) said. But there is an undercurrent of fear that Democrats lost focus on battling the pandemic and that those gains might be forgotten if current trend lines prompt new shutdowns. “We’ve done a good job over the last several months. But we’re going to have to continue to do it with aggressiveness and precision because the other side has no interest in governing and is going to spend all their time trying to mischaracterize public policy wins,” Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.), who is in charge of messaging in Pelosi’s leadership team, said. Some worry that the Biden administration needs to stay focused on promoting the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan, fearful of mistakes similar to 12 years ago, when the Obama administration neglected to promote its roughly $800 billion economic recovery bill after it passed a month into office. “I don’t think they’ve gotten enough credit for the extraordinary logistical and managerial effort to manage the rollout of the vaccine. That was a big task. And I think it was managed effectively. And I think that’s maybe the most important thing and the least discussed,” Sen. Angus King (I-Maine) said. In late 2010, while he was still a college professor, King wrote an essay, “The Democrats Beat Themselves,” citing how poorly the Obama administration sold the economic recovery. “Basically, the President was subjected to a two-year, nonstop ‘Swift Boating’ and never really fought back,” King wrote after the 2010 political bloodbath for Democrats. So, yes, on Tuesday, federal health officials reported more than 62,000 new cases of the deadly virus as 314 Americans died of the virus. A day earlier, the stock market tumbled more than 700 points amid fears of the health crisis causing another economic shock. But exactly six months earlier — Jan. 20, the day Biden was sworn in under strict social distancing and masking guidelines outside the Capitol — there were more than 185,000 new virus cases and a rolling weekly average of almost 200,000, with 4,440 deaths caused by covid-19 that day. On Jan. 20, the Dow Jones industrial average stood at 31,188, far below the closing of 34,512 six months later. Labor Department reports this month showed strong wage growth amid steady job growth that suggests sometime next year, the economy will recover all the lost jobs from the pandemic. In June and most of July, Biden tried to move past the pandemic and focused his attention on the bipartisan infrastructure plan and the proposed $3.5 trillion budget plan that is favored by liberals. Those two packages are filled with campaign pledges to remake government support for the middle class, the most ambitious budgets since the Great Society proposals of the 1960s. Democrats will need to make Congress spend a lot more time in Washington if they want to get Biden’s agenda passed Democrats defend these proposals as worthy of the big moment the nation faces. “We are confronting a multitude of crises, including a once-in-a-century covid-19 pandemic, a democracy crisis, a racial justice crisis and a climate crisis all at the same time,” Jeffries said. Schatz views the old presidential model of focusing on a couple big things as outdated. “The model from the ’80s was if you do too many things, people are going to get freaked out. And I think the danger here is not doing enough rather than doing too much,” he said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › PC is Fake

PC is fake.

Waldman 12-2-2020, columnist @ Plum Line for WaPo (Paul, “Joe Biden has to move fast,” Washington Post, )//BB

Slow-walking will absolutely be the Republican strategy, on both appointments and legislation. They won’t come out and say they’re going to stonewall every appointee and refuse to allow any legislation to pass; instead they’ll say that they just want to make sure Biden doesn’t stock his administration with radical leftists and propose far-out socialist laws. Send us the nominees and the bills, and we’ll consider them. It’ll just take some time. Weeks will then stretch into months, and the Biden agenda will languish. They’ve done it before — Obama himself describes how they endlessly dragged out negotiations on the Affordable Care Act by claiming they might support it — and they’ll do it again. That’s the Republican plan. The first step to getting around it is to understand that the public won’t blame gridlock on the ones who are causing it. They’ll just see a bunch of bickering in Washington with nothing getting done, and Biden will be the one who takes the blame. Once you realize that the public is neither aware of nor particularly concerned about process questions, you can stop worrying about whether Republicans will squawk at this appointment or that executive order — because they’ll squawk no matter what you do. If it’s a good idea and you think the results will be good, then just do it. As quickly and comprehensively as possible. As David Roberts of Vox observes: In 2009, Obama and his aides made the mistake of thinking that their major initiatives had to be rolled out one at a time in sequence, because he had a finite store of “political capital” that had to be spent carefully. But political capital is not something that exists apart from any particular issue; it isn’t a special sauce that has to be poured on a policy in order to make it palatable. And with the parties as polarized and unified as they are, political capital has become all but meaningless. There may have been a time when a popular president possessed so much capital that a senator from the opposition party would feel compelled to support him on part of that president’s agenda, but that time is long gone. There is no account Biden can draw on to turn Republican “no” votes into “yes.” So setting up a series of high-profile policy battles may be the opposite of what Biden should do. The unfortunate fact is that he may not have the opportunity to do much in the way of big legislation on health care or climate change or anything else, and if he has only executive power to work with, it makes it all the more urgent to move quickly. Which means getting staff in place immediately and then unleashing them. The Revolving Door Project argues that Biden should give as much authority as possible to the agencies to let them dismantle their particular corners of the Trump legacy on their own, because the task “simply will not happen if approached sequentially or micromanaged” by a White House staff with limited bandwidth. That means moving on every policy area all at once. There’s nothing to be gained by putting off any part of Biden’s agenda. Whatever he can do given the limits of his power, he should do as soon as possible, in a flood of policymaking. Even if Democrats win both Georgia races and control the Senate, Biden should acknowledge that he likely has two years until the 2022 midterm elections to pass whatever legislation he can. Not only will Democrats probably lose one or both houses in the inevitable backlash (as happens to most presidents in their first midterm), the only possible chance at forestalling that result is to get results, as many as possible, that he can show the voters. Republicans will complain that Biden is being partisan, uncompromising, taking a “my way or the highway” approach. It will be a strategy to convince everyone of the lie that Biden and Democrats might be able to find some way of winning them over, when in fact they’ll be implementing a strategy of total opposition. If Biden follows them on that fruitless quest, he’ll be running in circles while crucial time passes and nothing gets done. The only option for him is to decide not to care about Republican whining and do what he got elected to do with all haste. The alternative is failure.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No I/L USICA Fails

“Buy American”

Ferrari 21 [John Ferrari is a nonresident senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI), where his work focuses on the defense budget, defense reform and acquisition, and the US military. He is concurrently the chief financial officer at QOMPLX, a data analytics and cybersecurity firm. Over his 32-year US Army career, Major General Ferrari, who is now retired, served as the director of program analysis and evaluation, the commanding general of the White Sands Missile Range, a deputy commander for programs at the NATO Training Mission in Afghanistan, and a strategic planner for the Combined Joint Task Force Seven in Iraq during Operation Iraqi Freedom. His Army service also includes working at the US Army Materiel Command, as a platoon leader and executive officer for the 2nd Cavalry Regiment in Germany, and as a company commander and plans officer for the 3rd Cavalry Regiment.https://breakingdefense.com/2021/11/why-buy-american-isnt-the-answer-to-safeguard-national-security-supply-chains/]//LP

With their determination to “onshore” production of the supply chain, Biden officials are following the same path as former President Donald Trump. To the credit of both administrations, from an economic and national security point of view, they are entirely correct in identifying the problem — namely that critical American supply chains are vulnerable to sabotage by its rivals. But both presidents got the solution wrong. The answer isn’t to “Buy American,” it’s to “Attract Allies” by supporting production in partner nations and buy from them. Don’t hide from the global national security economy, diversify it. Currently China, through its grip on especially the electronics industry and its menacing of Taiwan, has the ability to sabotage and potentially destroy our economy, weapon systems, and critical information technology infrastructure. This gives Chinese President Xi Jinping an enormous advantage over the United States, similar to the way Russian President Vladimir Putin is subverting the Europeans over energy. While COVID has underscored the fragility of America’s supply chains, it is nowhere near what could happen during heightened tensions or hostilities with China. Imagine a scenario of no chips from Taiwan and no ships crossing the Pacific. Given this threat, we need to reduce our dependency on China specifically and the Pacific Rim more generally. But the instinct to simply make everything stateside, borne out in Trump’s and Biden’s “Buy American” plans, is extremely flawed despite polling well and being electorally popular. To find a different answer, we need to recognize several facts: Our military today is a small player in the commercial marketplace, both domestically and globally. The Defense Department is simply not going to be able to dictate a solution by itself. Second, the direct military and economic support of our allies, while we fight off Chinese coercion, or even war, is critical. Therefore, we need to “pool” our defense buying power when procuring common parts, information technology, and weapon systems. This is not just for interoperability, but also for efficiency in scale. Additionally, we cannot and should not create protectionist barriers to keep China away if those barriers also erect a wall between us and our allies or potential allies. The worst thing we can do is send a signal that it’s “every country for itself.” The solution? The Biden administration should change its goals and messaging from “Buy American” to “Attract Allies” even if it could be politically toxic. A new Cold War is upon us, and we need to admit that COVID has demonstrated that we are already vulnerable to being held hostage. Take the semi-conductor market for example. Right now, all roads lead to China and Taiwan. The current plan is to subsidize the production of new plants in the US. What we actually need is to diversify the production of these critical chips away from the first island chain in East Asia, and anchor production in the US, Europe, Australia, and India. The US military, along with allied military forces could then set standards for hardening and securing the chips themselves, for improving cyber security, while also diversifying production facilities so that we do not present China with a single targeting challenge. Subsidies from western militaries could pay for the cyber security hardening of the chips, while national governments could subsidize the production of several plants across the globe, similar to the current plan in the US to allocate $50 billion for chip production facilities. With every nation piling on debt to pay for the COVID pandemic, our military allies, not to mention our own forces, are already constrained by a lack of resources. We need to set up purchasing cooperatives with our allies to achieve economies of scale in production, and through interdependencies with friendly nations, gain efficiency, effectiveness, and security. A recent conference of the Association of the United States Army had many small defense firms from other countries sharing the convention floor with global defense giants. It was a good reminder that the giants could afford the cost of selling their products to dozens of national bureaucracies, while smaller firms could not. Imagine the benefits of having only one global military purchasing standard and contracting process with no special “Follow This ‘Insert Country Name’ Rules.” By contrast, today, in America, the administration’s provisions in “Buy American” would force these smaller international firms to either move production or partner with local firms, both of which are extremely inefficient. Interoperability between allied forces during war is also crucial. An everyone “roll their own” approach to procurement is a detriment on the battlefield from a resupply perspective, and even more critical when it comes to data sharing among weapon systems. During the Cold War, NATO enforced its standards for resupply and munitions. Today that process is gone in Europe and lacking in the Pacific. “Buy American” will only make this problem worse. Protectionism is fraught with the danger of reciprocity, and it is likely that no nation will want to make the first move. President Biden’s agreement with like-minded nations over global corporate taxes offers hope that global cooperation is possible. Therefore, the administration should move quickly now to establish a defense and economic security alliance, drop the “Buy American” rhetoric, and promote an “Attract Allies” security policy.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No I/L USICA Fails

STEM education shortages

Schneider 21 [Mark Schneider is director of the Institute of Education Sciences within the U.S. Department of Education. https://www.yahoo.com/video/bill-doesnt-far-enough-investing-190100004.html]//LP

Efforts are underway in Congress to enhance the scientific competitiveness of the nation. These efforts are laudable, but I fear they do not do enough to establish the necessary educational foundation in science, technology, engineering and math, especially for Black and Hispanic youth. The United States Innovation and Competition Act (USICA), recently passed by the Senate and now being considered in the House of Representatives, would expand the National Science Foundation to include a new Technology and Innovation Directorate. The goal is to advance research and development in key technology areas, including artificial intelligence, semiconductors, quantum computing, advanced communications, biotechnology and advanced energy. USICA contains provisions to support work within NSF to bolster STEM in both the nation’s K-12 schools and institutions of higher education. For example, it raises the ceiling on NSF investments in STEM and workforce development from less than $1 billion this year to more than $4 billion in 2026. Funds are also authorized to increase the availability of undergraduate research experiences, community college scholarships, apprenticeships, graduate fellowships and traineeships. As a major effort to boost the future of American technology, USICA is a good start — but it’s incomplete. Attention to applied education research is missing, meaning the very foundation for so much of the work that USICA will support is weak. As a nation, there is a great deal that we need to learn about how to improve instruction in math and science. The evidence of the weakness of the educational foundation for American STEM competitiveness is clear from the performance of our students on both national and international assessments. There is also evidence from a large-scale international assessment of adult competencies that America’s historical advantage, based on having a skilled adult workforce, is eroding relative to global competitors, particularly China. For example, the most recent math and science results from the 2019 National Assessment of Educational Progress show that around a third of American eighth-graders are below basic in math and science, a proportion that climbed to 40 percent by 12th grade. The proportion of Black and Hispanic students who perform below basic is far larger: around two-thirds for Black 12th-graders and well over half for Hispanic 12th-graders. Students perform somewhat better on the technology and engineering literacy assessment, though large racial disparities remain. Blacks and Hispanics together represent around one-third of the nation’s population — and an even larger share of the student population. It is going to be difficult to build a diverse STEM workforce with so many students from these groups underprepared in core STEM disciplines. If we continue to neglect the education of these students and the raw talent represented by so many Americans, the U.S. will be trying to compete with at least one hand tied behind our back. The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development administers two large-scale international assessments that give some additional insights into the ability of the U.S. to compete in the increasingly global economy — and the numbers are not good. The Programme for the International Assessment of Students (PISA) compares the literacy of 15-year-olds across the globe. In 2018, 77 nations and “education systems” participated in PISA. In mathematics, American 15-year-olds rank around the middle of the pack globally, whether looking at average scores or the scores of the top performers. Science performance is better, but still outside the global top 10. The organization also administers the Programme for the International Assessment of Adult Competencies. Most recently, the U.S. ranked 22 out of 33 on numeracy scores for young adults (24 or younger); but Americans ages 55 and above did far better, ranking 13th. The exam also tested for “Problem Solving in Tech Rich Environments.” The generational difference here is even starker: Americans aged 24 or younger ranked 20th, but those ages 55 and above ranked second among the 29 countries that participated in the problem-solving assessment. We seem to be replacing a relatively skilled cohort with a younger cohort that is far less internationally competitive. The key takeaway is that the U.S. education system is leaving too many students, especially Blacks and Hispanics, with less than a basic understanding of science, technology, engineering and math. And our young students and young adults are failing to keep up with their peers across the globe. Without improving foundational STEM skills, any edifice we build to enhance American competitiveness will be teetering on a weak foundation. And any hope of building a diverse STEM workforce will run into a supply constraint. Warnings abound. We must do better by the next generation of Americans as they face an increasingly competitive global environment in which STEM will play a key role. This challenge is clearly the motivation behind USICA, but considering the magnitude of the crisis facing the nation, it falls short, given the need for education R&D — especially for strong applied education sciences. This is why leaving the Institute of Education Sciences, the Department of Education’s science agency, out of USICA is a mistake.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No I/L USICA Fails

IPR shortfalls

Mills 2021

Anthony, Senior Fellow American Enterprise Institute, “Funding Isn’t Enough to Fix Science” May 28, 2021 //LP

There is an urgent need to shore up America’s research establishment. But inadequate funding is only the tip of the iceberg: More fundamental problems have dogged American science and innovation for years. Today, our breakthrough scientific discoveries appear less fundamental and less frequent than in decades past; scientists are spending increasing amounts of time on paperwork, administration, and bureaucratic compliance rather than on research itself; funding has become concentrated in a handful of well-established institutions; the average age of primary researchers continues to climb; and the so-called replication crisis has raised concerns about the reliability of many published findings. All of these point to deeper, structural problems in America’s R&D system. The goodwill provided by the current R&D push has created an ideal opportunity to implement much-needed reforms to U.S. science funding. Yet, as it stands, the U.S. Innovation and Competition Act (USICA) does little, if anything, to address these problems. Yet, the USICA does little to address the many other systematic issues that have bedeviled the American research establishment for years. Most conspicuous, perhaps, is the so-called replication crisis. Independent confirmation of experimental findings — whether by reproducing experiments or replicating experimental results — is generally held to be an important, even essential, part of the scientific process. Yet, in recent years, it has emerged that an alarming number of published scientific findings cannot be reproduced or replicated. The problem is particularly acute in psychology, biomedical research, ecology, economics, and the social sciences. The crisis is not, so to speak, merely academic. The types of research potentially implicated by it include areas of science that have direct bearing on medicine, public health, and government regulation. Lawmakers have taken note. In 2018, Congress directed NSF to commission the National Academies of Sciences (NAS) to study the crisis and provide a diagnosis as well as potential prescriptions. There is deep and ongoing disagreement within the scientific community about the nature and extent of the crisis — including whether it is a genuine problem and what, if anything, can be done about it. Nevertheless, the NAS report points to a growing consensus that the replication crisis is symptomatic of deeper flaws with the way scientific research is currently organized and conducted. These include obstacles to sharing scientific data, inadequate statistical training among researchers, problems with the peer-review system and grant culture, misaligned financial and professional incentives, and the corrosive effects of publish-or-perish. Yet, the Senate bill hardly acknowledges — much less addresses — any of these problems. The USICA does give a nod to the problem of geographic and institutional concentration. It is well known that government research dollars are highly localized in a few wealthy regions of the country and their prominent institutions. The bill addresses this through a $10 billion program of regional “tech hubs” across the country with special provisions for historically black and other minority-serving colleges. But the bill includes no serious attempts to modify or reform existing funding formulas within the NSF or other funding agencies, much less combat the various systematic problems in American R&D that inhibit such geographic and institutional diversity in the first place. The latest version of the bill does include provisions intended to protect American research from undue foreign influence or theft, including bolstering intellectual property, cybersecurity, and supply-chain resiliency. These, too, are important goals. Yet, insufficient attention has been paid to whether and how these measures may help or hinder the other problems facing American research, especially the compliance costs associated with byzantine federal grant requirements. To be sure, these problems cannot all be solved by a single funding bill. But some are easier to address than others. Principal researchers should not be spending 42 percent of their time on grant maintenance and compliance. Besides diverting scientific talent from research to paperwork, this creates barriers to entry for smaller institutions with fewer financial and personnel resources. Lawmakers could experiment with different ways to reduce the compliance burden, from streamlining the federal grant process to waiving unnecessary regulations and administrative requirements. Such simple reforms should be tied to funding increases, rather than left as vague guidance to agency staff. Other problems — such as the replication crisis — are much harder to tackle. But there are a number of things lawmakers could do in the scientific spirit of evidence-gathering and experimentation. For starters, new R&D spending should include allocations for research to study the replication crisis and attendant problems and solutions (as the NAS report on reproducibility recommends). Next, lawmakers could introduce more oversight and accountability into the federal R&D system to see what kinds of funding models work well for which purposes.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › Won’t Pass – McConnell

The Bill fails now - McConnell is withdrawing support

McPherson 6/30 [Lindsey McPherson is a Correspondent for Congress in the Roll Call with 15 videos in the C-SPAN Video Library; the first appearance was a 2015 Interview as a Staff Writer for Taxes in the CQ Now. The year with the most videos was 2018 with seven videos. The year with the highest average number of views per program was 2017 with an average of 428 views per program. Most appearances with Bill Scanlan (5), John McArdle (3), Stephanie Kaye (2). Most common tags: Immigration, Tax Policy, Federal Budget. https://rollcall.com/2022/06/30/mcconnell-threatens-support-for-china-bill-citing-budget-talks/]//LP

Republicans won’t back compromise legislation to boost domestic semiconductor manufacturing and U.S. competitiveness with China if Democrats continue to negotiate a partisan budget package that can pass without GOP support, Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell said Thursday. “Let me be perfectly clear: there will be no bipartisan USICA as long as Democrats are pursuing a partisan reconciliation bill,” the Kentucky Republican tweeted, using the acronym for the expansive competitiveness measure that passed both chambers in very different forms and is now in conference. McConnell’s pronouncement significantly complicates Democrats’ summer legislative agenda, which includes trying to pass both the competitiveness bill and the tax and spending package formerly known as “Build Back Better” before the August recess. McConnell made his statement shortly after Senate Democrats announced they reached agreement on a prescription drug pricing plan that’s a key piece of the budget reconciliation package they’ve been renegotiating to appease Sen. Joe Manchin III, D-W.Va. Manchin in December announced his opposition to the $2.2 trillion House-passed tax and spending bill, which was already scaled way back from Democrats’ earlier plans. “Sen. McConnell is holding American jobs in key US industries hostage to help China and protect his friends in big pharma allowing them to keep screwing over Americans with outrageously high Rx drug prices,” Justin Goodman, a spokesperson for Majority Leader Charles E. Schumer, said in an email. The White House took aim at the Republican leader as well, specifically calling out plans for chipmaking plant expansions in states like Ohio and Idaho that could be put on hold if the competitiveness bill stalls. Those two states are home to two of the Senate GOP negotiators on the bill: Rob Portman of Ohio, who’s retiring, and Michael D. Crapo of Idaho, the Finance Committee’s ranking Republican. “This takes loyalty to special interests over working Americans to a new and shocking height,” White House Press Secretary Karine Jean-Pierre said in a statement. “We are not going to back down in the face of this outrageous threat.” Intel Corp. last week put off a planned groundbreaking ceremony for its new $20 billion investment in Ohio, citing delays in getting the competitiveness bill passed. Boise, Idaho-based Micron Technology has been weighing an expansion in the southeast part of the state, in part prompted by state tax breaks; however, the state legislation is tied to enactment of federal incentives, according to local media. ‘Classic McConnell’ McConnell’s Thursday statement suggests a July vote is now out of reach unless Democrats abandon plans to resurrect their reconciliation package, which is unlikely. Schumer and Manchin have been holding private discussions on reconciliation for months, but the prescription drug pricing plan announcement is the first significant sign of progress to emerge from those negotiations. They’ve not yet reached agreement on climate or tax provisions, the other primary pieces of the downsized package they’re negotiating, and Schumer has said the legislation could be ready for floor action as soon as late July. Ways and Means member Donald S. Beyer Jr., D-Va., said in a Twitter thread that McConnell’s announcement that Republicans would block the competitiveness bill was just a public admission of a tactic he’s already deployed. “This isn’t new, Mitch McConnell has been stalling this bill for weeks; but now he’s admitting it,” Beyer said. “His obstruction is directly harming our economy, preventing job creation, and halting production of a key need to improve supply chains. Classic McConnell.” McConnell’s move has support within his conference. Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., who was among the 19 Republicans who voted for the Senate bill a year ago, retweeted McConnell, adding: “Couldn’t agree more.” McConnell also voted for the original Senate bill. Members of both parties have pointed to the competitiveness legislation as desperately needed to help fix crucial supply chain issues that have contributed to high inflation. Democrats think their reconciliation package will also help cool inflation in the long term, but Republicans argue those spending and tax increases will just exacerbate the current problem. While Republicans are likely to continue to blame President Joe Biden and congressional Democrats for inflation, their decision to block the competitiveness bill could blunt their midterm campaign argument that voters should elect Republicans to Congress if they want real solutions to rising prices. “This McConnell threat to kill a bipartisan bill to improve American competitiveness unless we keep prescription drug costs high strikes me as a miscalculation,” Sen. Brian Schatz, D-Hawaii, tweeted. The GOP tactic could also risk angering corporate donors. It’s not just the big chipmakers pushing the measure — it’s also companies across the manufacturing spectrum that rely on a steady supply of semiconductors. CEOs of major companies ranging from Microsoft and Google parent Alphabet to defense contractors like Lockheed Martin and Northrop Grumman banded together earlier this month to call on Congress to act urgently to pass a bicameral compromise. “The rest of the world is not waiting for the U.S. to act,” dozens of CEOs wrote in a June 15 letter to Schumer, McConnell, Pelosi and House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy. “Our global competitors are investing in their industry, their workers, and their economies, and it is imperative that Congress act to enhance U.S. competitiveness.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › Won’t Pass – PC

GOP won’t let Biden secure a victory on USICA

Ignatius 22 [https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2022/01/13/biden-is-failing-politically-not-just-because-republican-obstruction/]//LP

President Biden hit a political wall this week in his push for voting rights legislation, just as he did last year in trying to pass his Build Back Better spending package. It’s time for Biden to ask himself why he’s in this morass. Sign up for a weekly roundup of thought-provoking ideas and debates It sticks in my craw to quote Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), who has often been a wrecker in our national politics. But he had it right when he said Wednesday that Biden was elected with a mandate to “bridge a divided country, lower the temperature, dial down the perpetual air of crisis in our politics.” Biden is failing in that mission. Republican obstructionism is a big reason, but it’s not the only explanation. Biden has been losing his way politically. As he chases support from progressives in his own party, he has failed to craft versions of his social spending package and voting rights legislation that he could pass with fragile majorities. He’s been spinning his wheels. A prime (but rarely discussed) example of Biden’s loss of momentum is the failure to enact legislation to improve American competitiveness in chipmaking and other technologies. This bill, known as the U.S. Innovation and Competition Act (or USICA), passed the Senate back in June with a big majority, 68 to 32. Passage illustrated the strong bipartisan consensus that America must respond to China’s technology challenge. But USICA stalled in the House. Democrats there were miffed at what they saw as Senate attempts to dictate science policy. Some progressives didn’t want chipmaking to get in the way of battles for child-care credits and other Build Back Better programs. And House Republicans wanted to sabotage any potential success for Biden. So, the bill languished. Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) announced a House-Senate conference in November, but it never happened because the House hadn’t passed a bill. Rep. Bill Foster (Ill.), a leading Democrat on tech issues, told me the House should have gone to conference and approved the chipmaking portion of the bill, at least. But that didn’t occur, even though Biden’s national security team takes the China threat as seriously as Republicans do. Moderate Democrats are baffled. “It’s nuts that the House has been sitting on this good, important bill for months,” Sen. Mark R. Warner (D-Va.), one of its authors, told me in an email. A similar concern came from Thomas E. Donilon, President Barack Obama’s national security adviser. “It’s inexcusable that Congress hasn’t moved forward on this,” he told me. Pelosi’s aides say she wants to get a House version of the bill moving again soon. And one Senate staffer hoped a House bill could pass in a few weeks — clearing the way for a real conference to resolve differences. “We are working hard on trying to get USICA done in the House,” a White House official told me Thursday. But the official said it’s not clear if House Republicans will help. “To be blunt, it takes two to tango.” The larger question for Biden is whether there’s any space left for bipartisanship and conciliation. Political divisions have worsened over the past year, and Republicans, led by McConnell, have rebuffed nearly all of his overtures. He had bigger ambitions, on social and political revitalization. But with such fragile Democratic majorities in the House and Senate, Biden will struggle now to pass meaningful legislation. USICA would be a good test. So would a scaled-back version of Build Back Better that could win support from Sen. Joe Manchin III (D-W.Va.). But successful presidencies carry a sense of political momentum, going from success to success. Sadly, President Biden has lost much of that forward drive. It’s time for a restart, with less shouting and more of Biden’s trademark common sense.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---TURNS CASE › !---Turns Disease

Turns disease

Bradley 21 Neil Bradley, is Executive Vice President, Chief Policy Officer and Head of Strategic Advocacy at the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, 5/27/21, U.S. Chamber Letter on S. 1260, “United States Innovation and Competition Act” https://www.uschamber.com/letters-congress/us-chamber-letter-s-1260-united-states-innovation-and-competition-act

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce supports the manager’s amendment to S. 1260, the, “United States Innovation and Competition Act,” and we appreciate the open, bipartisan regular order process by which this legislation was developed. For the United States to remain competitive internationally and tackle the challenges of future pandemics and jumpstart economic growth, the U.S. must maintain its leadership in technology. The United States Innovation and Competition Act represents a step toward achieving this goal by supporting research and development in key areas like autonomy, advanced communications, and artificial intelligence.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---TURNS CASE › !---Turns Democracy

Democracy collapse is an existential risk [Restoring domestic supply chains is key]

Basu 12/24 (Kaushik Basu, a former chief economist of the World Bank and chief economic adviser to the government of India, is professor of economics at Cornell University and a nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution. “An existential threat to humanity: Democracy’s decline” 12/24/21 )

With democratic norms fraying from Southeast Asia to Central Europe, Biden was right to warn of “the sustained and alarming challenges to democracy and universal human rights.” But too few acknowledge that rising authoritarianism around the world, like climate change and the evolution of lethal viruses, can pose an existential risk to humanity. Most people do not appreciate the extent to which civilizations depend on pillars of norms and conventions. Some of these have evolved organically over time, while others required deliberation and collective action. If one of the pillars buckles, a civilization could well collapse. Efforts to counter the current threats to democracy should start with the fact that every economy is embedded in culture and institutions. As Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and James Robinson have argued, long-run growth may depend more on institutions than on anything else. But institutions are not always exogenous. As the growing field of cultural evolution shows, human beings are adaptive learners who rely, often unwittingly, on social learning to entrench norms that are necessary for a society to flourish. Likewise, Avinash Dixit and Simon Levin argue that, in some contexts, we may need to take deliberate steps to instill pro-social preferences that can help us adapt to our changing world. We can do this through education, and by deliberating and deciding as citizens to promote certain kinds of collective behavior. That is what happened when delegates from American states convened in Philadelphia in 1787 to revise the existing Articles of Confederation and ended up drafting the U.S. Constitution, which became the cornerstone of the new country’s long-term growth and prosperity. We are in a similarly challenging situation today, as cross-border flows of goods, services, and capital flatten the world economically. The rapid advance of digital technology, accelerated over the last two years by the COVID-19 pandemic, is causing huge strains. Increased outsourcing of production has contributed to hypernationalism, which in turn is fueling the rise of anti-democratic leaders who exploit people’s desperation.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---TURNS CASE › !---Turns Democracy

Key to democracy

Palmer 6-25-2021, senior fellow on the National Security and International Policy team at the Center for American Progress, and was the attaché for the U.S. Department of Energy in Beijing (Nina, “The Innovation and Competition Act is progressive policy,” The Hill, )

Democrats and Republicans in Washington may have finally found an issue they can both support. Earlier in June, the U.S. Senate passed the U.S. Innovation and Competition Act (USICA) which proposes significant changes to science and technology policy with an eye to U.S. China policy. Approved by a surprisingly bipartisan 68-32 vote, the bill merges Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer’s (D-N.Y.) Endless Frontier Act and Sen. Robert Menendez’s (D-N.J.) Strategic Competition Act. President Joe Biden has urged speedy passage of the bill in the House, where it’s headed next.

Progressives in the House should support and advance this $250 billion bill, which contains strong provisions that will smartly make the U.S. more competitive, through investments in communities, innovation, improving racial and gender justice and income equality. The bill authorizes the most extensive investment in U.S. innovation infrastructure in a generation, building technology hubs in disadvantaged areas, increasing federal funding for both fundamental and applied research, increasing STEM scholarships and modernizing U.S. technology policymaking. The bill introduces measures to combat systemic sexism in the scientific community and targets minority-serving institutions (MSIs) for additional grants, scholarships and support. The bill also makes strides in recognizing and funding climate change mitigation measures, including clean energy development and conservation mechanisms. Most notably, it expands the definition of STEM to include energy and environmental studies, which will refocus a range of federal policies on these fields. The bill also prioritizes clean technologies for inclusion in the regional technology hub program.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---TURNS CASE › !---Turns Cyber

Successful reconciliation solves cybersecurity, global internet openness, and misinformation

Montgomery 3-14-2022, senior fellow at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (@FDD) and senior director of FDD's Center on Cyber and Technology Innovation (CCTI). He previously served as a senior adviser to the Cyberspace Solarium Commission. Annie Fixler is deputy director of CCTI. Follow the authors on Twitter @MarkCMontgomery and @AFixler. FDD is a Washington, D.C.-based, nonpartisan research institute focusing on national security and foreign policy. (Mark and Annie Fixler, “Reconciliation of China bills in Congress could produce big cybersecurity wins,” The Hill, )

Congress deserves mixed grades for its recent efforts to strengthen the nation’s cybersecurity and improve the resilience of its critical infrastructure. If Republicans and Democrats can find a path forward to integrate the Senate’s U.S. Innovation and Competition Act (USICA) with the House’s America COMPETES Act, Congress could make substantial, long-term investments in America’s technology future. The two bills would build upon important but insufficient cybersecurity provisions in recent legislation. The Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, which President Biden signed into law in November, contained $1 billion to enhance the cybersecurity of state and local governments and established a Response and Recovery Fund for major cyber incidents. Yet that law’s support to specific critical infrastructure sectors was inconsistent and missed some glaring weaknesses, such as those of the water sector. Similarly, the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) for Fiscal Year 2022, which the president signed into law in December, had 40 cybersecurity-specific authorizations. But during conference, Congress dropped some of the most significant provisions, such as mandatory incident reporting. Now, lawmakers get another bite at the cybersecurity apple as Congress sets up its conference committee to adjudicate USICA (which passed on a bipartisan basis last June) and the COMPETES Act (which passed last week on a nearly partly-line vote). House and Senate lawmakers have a $52 billion starting point: Both bills contain $52 billion in funding for the CHIPS Act, which establishes a grant program to support domestic semiconductor production. Congress passed the CHIPS Act on a bipartisan basis as part of the FY2021 NDAA. CHIPS funding is the most headline grabbing (and expensive) single issue in the two bills, but it is by no means the only important cybersecurity and critical infrastructure provision. The USICA and COMPETES bills have similar cybersecurity provisions in three arenas that House and Senate members can easily reconcile and embrace. First, both bills seek to rectify dramatic shortages in the federal cyber workforce. They invest in STEM education and create rotational cybersecurity positions giving federal employees the flexibility to gain experience and skills. The House bill also expands “CyberCorps: Scholarship for Service,” a critical, ROTC-like program for the federal cybersecurity workforce, from its current $60 million annual budget to $90 million by fiscal year 2026. This will increase both the number of students (future federal employees) and the number of universities and community colleges involved. Such a provision would likely receive bipartisan support in the Senate. Second, both bills invest in U.S. leadership in international technical standards-setting bodies like the International Telecommunication Union. This arena has become a crucial battlefront in the contest between Western values of a free and open internet and the authoritarian push for ever-greater state control and censorship. Beijing has aggressively sought to gain leadership positions and promote technically flawed proposals in these forums in order to distort and weaponize the bodies against the interests of America and its partners. Both bills thus strive to improve America’s response to Chinese maneuvering. Third, both bills increase funding for the State Department’s Global Engagement Center, an important agency for battling foreign disinformation campaigns. Next, the conference members should work to reach agreement in several other areas tackled only in one chamber’s bill. The House bill, importantly, requires the executive branch to develop a strategy for “information and communication technology critical to the economic competitiveness of the United States.” Such a strategy would ensure that America is not dependent on untrusted vendors beholden to foreign powers or who otherwise have lax security. Three other provisions of note: the House bill 1) designates “Critical Technology Security Centers to evaluate and test the security of technologies essential to national critical functions,” 2) creates international capacity-building programs to improve the cybersecurity of U.S. allies and partners, and 3) supports the software security and digital privacy work of the National Institute of Standards and Technology. Meanwhile, the most significant provision unique to the Senate bill creates a National Risk Management Cycle to “identify, assess, and prioritize cyber and physical risks to critical infrastructure.” Understanding these risks is the foundational step to properly resourcing U.S. government efforts to defend against, mitigate, and deter these threats. In its comprehensive March 2020 report on U.S. cyber strategy, the Cyberspace Solarium Commission noted that the U.S. government “lacks a rigorous, codified, and routinely exercised process” for identifying risk. Even where the government has identified critical infrastructure risks, a lack of sustained funding has limited the mitigation and management of the risks over time. A National Risk Management Cycle would begin to rectify this problem. A chance to improve research The Senate version also includes provisions to create regional technology hubs built on partnerships among industry, academia, and workforce groups to support domestic high-tech job growth in areas of the country that have not been historic innovation centers. A successful bipartisan conference should result in numerous meaningful cybersecurity provisions enacted into law. While not as flashy as CHIPS, they collectively lead to more effective cybersecurity and more resilient critical infrastructure.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---TURNS CASE › !---Turns Economy

Key to US economic leadership

FYI: The ‘Endless Frontier Act’ was renamed the The United States Innovation and Competition Act. You can tell they are the same by content and by Schumer’s sponsorship

Sidney 21 Arthur D. Sidney Vice President of Public Policy for the Computer and Communication Industry Association, April 29, 2021, Multi-Association Letter Endless Frontier Act

The undersigned trade associations and private sector organizations write to express our strong support for the Endless Frontier Act, sponsored by Senate Majority Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Senator Todd Young (R-IN), which would provide much needed, and long overdue, investment in technology, entrepreneurship, science, research and development, and will promote the long-term, global economic competitiveness of the United States. We are encouraged by this bold and visionary bipartisan effort to ensure the U.S. can outcompete our foreign competitors, especially China. We encourage Congress to make passage of this bill a top priority as we move into a period of economic recovery and job growth post-COVID. Since the end of World War II, the United States has been the unequivocal global leader in scientific and technological ingenuity and innovation, and as a result, the American people have benefited through good-paying jobs, economic prosperity, and a higher quality of life. Today, however, America’s leadership of innovative technologies is being compromised by the aggressive and distortive practices of our foreign competitors. While the U.S. has been underinvesting in the very ingredients that made the country a global leader, namely our superior research and manufacturing capabilities, favorable regulatory regime and economic system, and skilled workforce, our competitors are deploying significant, and at times, distortive resources, engaging in anti-competitive practices such as intellectual property theft, and are exerting influence beyond their borders attempting to dominate the key technology fields of today and of the future. Without a comprehensive, national investment strategy in critical and emerging technologies, our country will continue falling behind in the race to create cutting-edge solutions to the world’s problems. It is crucial that the U.S. bolster its own approach to ensure that our values remain infused in the technologies of the future, especially as China and other nations significantly increase their investments in emerging technologies. Many regions and cities across the country are well-suited to foster innovation and others have tremendous innovation potential. But as a nation, we lack the comprehensive, wide-spread investment needed to build nationwide strength in new and emerging technologies. In order to remain the global leader in technology, the Endless Frontier Act instills within the U.S. government a commitment to prioritize science and technology advancements by creating a Directorate for Technology and Innovation at the National Science Foundation, and charges the foundation with creating and implementing a geostrategic investment plan focusing on 10 key technology focus areas. Additionally, this Act provides $100 billion to reinvigorate American leadership in the discovery and application of new technologies, as well as $10 billion to designate a minimum of 10 regional technology hubs, which will be the global centers for R&D, and to help regions throughout the nation develop strategies to build their tech economies. These efforts will provide a lifeline to the future of the American economy, prepare the U.S. workforce to compete globally, encourage new company formation, and create high skilled, good-paying American jobs. We are also pleased to see a strategic focus on manufacturing innovation through the enhancement and expansion of Manufacturing USA and by strengthening America’s critical supply chains, such as semiconductor supply chains.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › IL---GCF

Solves climate change

CMIA 2021

Climate Markets and Investment Association, “GCF and Climate Finance,” Feb 19, 2021 https://www.cmia.net/gcf-and-climate-finance/

"We can't solve climate change without private finance. The GCF and other climate funds are pivotal to leverage private sector capital and CMIA channels the private sector voice to provide solutions that are workable, bankable and scalable." Margaret-Ann Splawn, Working Group Co-Chair GCF and Climate Finance The Green Climate Fund (GCF) is the world’s largest climate fund. The Green Climate Fund was conceptualised at the Cancun COP in 2009 and fully operational since 2015, is the largest climate finance fund in the world – targeting the commitment of funding flows of US$100 billion per year with all pools of finance. Its specific mandate is to encourage and facilitate private investment in climate related activities. GCF aims to go much further than other public climate finance institutions in leveraging private capital for mitigation and adaptation, and using its own risk bearing capacity to enable innovation and funding at scale. The GCF has already gone some way towards integrating the private sector into its activities. Several of the institutions which have been approved to receive funding directly from the GCF are commercial entities. However, more private sector national and regional entities have become accredited over the last few years too. But the GCF needs to take more action to reach out to the business and investment communities. The GCF 27th Board meeting adopted the Updated Strategic Plan for the GCF 2020-2023 which includes a strategic priority of ‘catalysing private sector finance at scale’. CMIA holds one of two Active Private Sector Observer seats on the board of the GCF. Through its observer, CMIA has a unique ability to give the board direct feedback from its membership on key issues that will impact how successfully the GCF interacts with private actors.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › IL---GCF

Key to Green Climate Fund support

Lillis and Marcos 1/26

Mike and Cristina, The Hill, “House Republicans bash Democrats' China competition bill” January 26, 2022 https://thehill.com/homenews/house/591530-house-republicans-bash-democrats-china-competition-bill

It’s a debate likely to be magnified by the Democrats’ new America Competes Act, which is already sparking partisan battles over those same thorny issues. Indeed, McCaul is focusing on one element of the package, sponsored by House Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Greg Meeks (D-N.Y.), which contains climate provisions designed to hold China accountable for its greenhouse gas emissions. That includes contributions of $8 billion over two years to the Green Climate Fund established by the United Nations to help developing countries respond to climate change.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › IL---Technological Innovation

Mitigates warming

Jeffrey Mervis, 2/4/2022 (Jeff reports on science policy in the United States and around the world in an effort to explain to scientists how government works, “House passes sweeping U.S. innovation bill, teeing up talks with Senate,” , Retrieved 3/3/2022)

The effort, designed to maintain the country’s technological edge over China, took a major step forward today when the U.S. House of Representatives passed the America COMPETES Act. The 2900-page bill must now be reconciled with a similar, comparably massive bill called the U.S. Innovation and Competition Act (USICA) that the Senate passed in June 2021. But ironing out the differences will test the Democrats’ razor-thin majorities in each body. Although USICA (S.1260) was approved by a vote of 68 to 32, including 19 Republican senators, COMPETES (H.R. 4521) was supported by just one Republican and passed the House on a 220 to 210 vote. (One Democrat said nay.) Although key House Republicans have said they support many of the research-related elements in the bill, they strongly objected to other provisions, including language on trade and labor policy. Negotiating a compromise bill acceptable to enough lawmakers–and President Joe Biden–to make it into law will be a complex task touching on a wide range of issues. They include how to allocate new research funds, how to protect U.S. research from foreign interference while also reshaping immigration rules to make it easier for the United States to attract foreign-born technical talent, and whether to take a more aggressive stance to combat climate change. Both bills come with hefty price tags: $250 billion for USICA and $350 billion for COMPETES. And both include provisions that authorize the government to spend tens of billions of dollars on research across several federal agencies. The numbers are mostly aspirational; Congress would still have to approve most of the spending through its annual budget process. Higher education lobbyists hope legislators won’t repeat what happened in 2007 and 2010, when Congress failed to deliver promised big hikes in research spending that it had authorized. The increased investments include adding an NSF technology directorate and doubling the agency’s overall budget over 5 years. The Department of Energy’s Office of Science and its national laboratories would get a similarly large boost. And the Department of Commerce would get $7 billion to establish a network of new regional innovation hubs. The nation’s semiconductor industry would receive $52 billion, with the bulk of the money used to increase manufacturing capacity but some also going to microelectronics research facilities. Both bills call for tightening oversight of research collaborations with China and a handful of other countries deemed to exert a “malign foreign influence” on federally funded research. For example, both bills would prohibit scientists with federal grants from participating in Chinese talent recruitment programs and require universities to provide more information about any foreign gifts they receive. The two bills also seek to stamp out sexual harassment on college campuses, calling for a uniform policy on reporting allegations and findings to federal funding agencies. But there are also important differences between the two bills on research policy. For example, the Senate wants NSF’s new technology directorate to focus on 10 key disciplines, such as artificial intelligence and quantum computing. In contrast, the House bill asks NSF to combat climate change, reduce economic and social inequality, and build a robust scientific workforce along with advancing strategically important fields. “The Senate bill implies a trade-off between supporting key technologies to maintain our competitive edge and improving the quality of life for all Americans,” says a Democratic staffer on the House science committee, which crafted many of the research provisions in the COMPETES bill. “But we think that technology is simply a means to an end, and that you can do both things.” The House and Senate also have competing visions of how to spread federal research dollars more equitably across the country, including to institutions that enroll large numbers of students from groups traditionally underrepresented in science. The Senate bill requires that 20% of the money slated for NSF and DOE be spent in the roughly two dozen states that receive the fewest federal research dollars. In contrast, the House bill avoids any mandatory set-asides, instead creating new programs that target institutions in those have-not states. The COMPETES Act would also change immigration policy to allow more foreign students to stay after they earn advanced degrees in science and engineering at U.S. universities. One provision would exempt them from the existing cap on the number of applications for permanent residency status. The bill would also create a new visa category for budding high-tech entrepreneurs. Those measures are likely to be opposed by lawmakers who want to shut off the flow of immigration, especially from China and other countries seen as economic and military foes, and the Senate bill contains no such changes. The House bill includes a raft of provisions on climate change. For example, it would authorize a 2-year, $8 billion U.S. contribution to the United Nations’s Green Climate Fund, aimed at helping emerging economies respond to the climate crisis. It calls for spending $600 million annually through 2026 to help U.S. solar energy companies become “less reliant on solar components made in China.” And it would give the Department of State additional funds for climate-related foreign aid, and for developing a new 10-year strategy to mitigate global climate change impacts. The House bill’s sweeping scope is its strength, says Representative Eddie Bernice Johnson (D–TX), chair of the House science committee. “With this legislation, we are making investments to build clean energy solutions, address the climate crisis, reinforce our national security, enhance our semiconductor manufacturing capabilities, and so much more,” Johnson said in kicking off debate on the House floor that ended this morning. “In short, we are acting to address the critical needs identified by the scientific community, industry, academia, and other stakeholders as what they need most to succeed in the 21st century.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › IL---Technological Innovation

Bolsters all tech necessary to solve climate change

MICHELLE BURRIS, 3/1/2022 (a fellow at The Century Foundation, focusing on racial and gender equity in workforce development, “The America COMPETES Act Provides an Inclusive Vision for Technology and Manufacturing Competitiveness,” , Retrieved 3/3/2022)

Manufacturing is the lifeblood for many communities, providing middle-class jobs and robust economic activity. Furthermore, manufacturing has special value to smaller cities and towns, particularly in the Midwest and Southeast, as well as for urban communities of color where deindustrialization has had lasting negative impacts. And, manufacturing has gained fresh attention over the past two years, starting with the nation’s need for medical goods during the COVID-19 pandemic, continuing now as snarled supply chains have driven up prices for cars and other critical goods, and looking ahead to electric vehicles, alternative energy generation, and other innovative technologies needed to addresses the existential challenge of climate change. A centerpiece of the America COMPETES Act is the CHIPS for America Fund, which allocates $52 billion to initiatives established by the CHIPS for America Act and paves the way for America to fabricate computer chips as well as reduce semiconductor supply chain disruptions. This fund could have an outsized impact on the entire manufacturing sector in America. As Mark Muro, Robert Maxim, and Stephen Ezell at Brookings argue, semiconductor devices are essential to today’s digital economy, as they operate most cars and all computers. The manufacturing and sale of these devices are dependent on a robust semiconductor supply chain, and the funding allocated by the act not only will ensure that the digital economy operates without disruption, but also will strengthen the nation’s capacity for technology and innovation. Historically, this fund has been particularly important, as the U.S. semiconductor industry for years has lagged behind those of competitor countries. Researchers, including those at the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation, found that only ten years after creating the semiconductor industry, the United States lost its global leadership, and the nation’s lack of attention to this critical industry meant U.S. competitiveness continued to erode. The $52 billion commitment to American computer chip production in the America COMPETES Act will once again put America in a winning place.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › IL---International Signal + GCF

It's a key international signal

Alejandro Pérez, 2/4/2022 (senior vice president of policy and government affairs @ World Wildlife Fund, “WWF Statement on the America COMPETES Act,” , Retrieved 3/3/2022)

In response to the House of Representatives’ passage of the America COMPETES Act, World Wildlife Fund (WWF) released the following statement from Alejandro Pérez, senior vice president of policy and government affairs: “As part of the America COMPETES Act, the House has passed a number of key legislative initiatives to protect the global environment, recognizing the critical role that nature and the ecological integrity of our planet play in our future security, stability, and prosperity. “Provisions in the bill renew programs to protect tropical forests and coral reefs and prevent wildlife trafficking. They advance new measures to curb illegal fishing, halt deforestation, and stop the spillover of zoonotic diseases like COVID-19. And they direct the U.S. to take stronger steps to confront the grave and growing threat posed by climate change, including authorizing major new investments in the Green Climate Fund. “Taken collectively, these elements of the bill are an impressive move by Congress to tackle some of our most urgent global challenges. They also send a strong signal to other countries that international cooperation is paramount to making headway on these problems, and that the United States intends to help lead the way. “As the House and Senate work towards agreement on a final version of the bill, we urge Congress to ensure these environmental provisions remain in the legislation that is ultimately sent to the President’s desk.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › 1NC

Climate change causes extinction

Alexander-Sears 21, PhD Candidate in Political Science at The University of Toronto, former Professor of International Relations at the Universidad de Las Américas (Nathan, “Great Powers, Polarity, and Existential Threats to Humanity: An Analysis of the Distribution of the Forces of Total Destruction in International Security,” Conference Paper: International Studies Association, 2021 Annual Conference, Research Gate)

Humanity faces existential risks from the large-scale destruction of Earth’s natural environment making the planet less hospitable for humankind (Wallace-Wells 2019). The decline of some of Earth’s natural systems may already exceed the “planetary boundaries” that represent a “safe operating space for humanity” (Rockstrom et al. 2009). Humanity has become one of the driving forces behind Earth’s climate system (Crutzen 2002). The major anthropogenic drivers of climate change are the burning of fossil fuels (e.g., coal, oil, and gas), combined with the degradation of Earth’s natural systems for absorbing carbon dioxide, such as deforestation for agriculture (e.g., livestock and monocultures) and resource extraction (e.g., mining and oil), and the warming of the oceans (Kump et al. 2003). While humanity has influenced Earth’s climate since at least the Industrial Revolution, the dramatic increase in greenhouse gas emissions since the mid-twentieth century—the “Great Acceleration” (Steffen et al. 2007; 2015; McNeill & Engelke 2016)— is responsible for contemporary climate change, which has reached approximately 1°C above preindustrial levels (IPCC 2018). Climate change could become an existential threat to humanity if the planet’s climate reaches a “Hothouse Earth” state (Ripple et al. 2020). What are the dangers? There are two mechanisms of climate change that threaten humankind. The direct threat is extreme heat. While human societies possesses some capacity for adaptation and resilience to climate change, the physiological response of humans to heat stress imposes physical limits—with a hard limit at roughly 35°C wet-bulb temperature (Sherwood et al. 2010). A rise in global average temperatures by 3–4°C would increase the risk of heat stress, while 7°C could render some regions uninhabitable, and 11–12°C would leave much of the planet too hot for human habitation (Sherwood et al. 2010). The indirect effects of climate change could include, inter alia, rising sea levels affecting coastal regions (e.g., Miami and Shanghai), or even swallowing entire countries (e.g., Bangladesh and the Maldives); extreme and unpredictable weather and natural disasters (e.g., hurricanes and forest fires); environmental pressures on water and food scarcity (e.g., droughts from less-dispersed rainfall, and lower wheat-yields at higher temperatures); the possible inception of new bacteria and viruses; and, of course, large-scale human migration (World Bank 2012; Wallace-Well 2019; Richards, Lupton & Allywood 2001). While it is difficult to determine the existential implications of extreme environmental conditions, there are historic precedents for the collapse of human societies under environmental pressures (Diamond 2005). Earth’s “big five” mass extinction events have been linked to dramatic shifts in Earth’s climate (Ward 2008; Payne & Clapham 2012; Kolbert 2014; Brannen 2017), and a Hothouse Earth climate would represent terra incognita for humanity. Thus, the assumption here is that a Hothouse Earth climate could pose an existential threat to the habitability of the planet for humanity (Steffen et al. 2018., 5). At what point could climate change cross the threshold of an existential threat to humankind? The complexity of Earth’s natural systems makes it extremely difficult to give a precise figure (Rockstrom et al. 2009; ). However, much of the concern about climate change is over the danger of crossing “tipping points,” whereby positive feedback loops in Earth’s climate system could lead to potentially irreversible and self-reinforcing “runaway” climate change. For example, the melting of Arctic “permafrost” could produce additional warming, as glacial retreat reduces the refractory effect of the ice and releases huge quantities of methane currently trapped beneath it. A recent study suggests that a “planetary threshold” could exist at global average temperature of 2°C above preindustrial levels (Steffen et al. 2018; also IPCC 2018). Therefore, the analysis here takes the 2°C rise in global average temperatures as representing the lower-boundary of an existential threat to humanity, with higher temperatures increasing the risk of runaway climate change leading to a Hothouse Earth. The Paris Agreement on Climate Change set the goal of limiting the increase in global average temperatures to “well below” 2°C and to pursue efforts to limit the increase to 1.5°C. If the Paris Agreement goals are met, then nations would likely keep climate change below the threshold of an existential threat to humanity. According to Climate Action Tracker (2020), however, current policies of states are expected to produce global average temperatures of 2.9°C above preindustrial levels by 2100 (range between +2.1 and +3.9°C), while if states succeed in meeting their pledges and targets, global average temperatures are still projected to increase by 2.6°C (range between +2.1 and +3.3°C). Thus, while the Paris Agreements sets a goal that would reduce the exis 6 - tential risk of climate change, the actual policies of states could easily cross the threshold that would constitute an existential threat to humanity (CAT 2020)

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Negative › !---CLIMATE › 1NC

USICA is key to disruptive innovations that solve climate change

Walker 21 Senior Vice President for Global Affairs and Chief Legal Officer at Google, Seizing the moment - A framework for American innovation,

Decades of government investment in R&D led to scientific breakthroughs that gave us the tools we use every day, and public-private partnerships have sparked innovations from the microchip to the internet. Government R&D investment has led to economic growth, jobs and new startups. As just one example, some of Google’s earliest work was made possible, in part, by the Digital Library Initiative, funded by the National Science Foundation. But if you fast forward to today, the U.S. government investment in tech has moved to the slow lane. Government-funded research in the U.S. has fallen by 60% as a percentage of GDP — from 1.9% of GDP in 1964 to just 0.7% today. Many countries around the world are investing significantly in research and development. For example, China has said that it will be increasing government R&D funding by 7% annually and recently announced a five-year plan to invest an additional $1.4 trillion in developing next-generation technologies. As a nation we now have a historic opportunity to put aside partisanship and come together on an issue that will determine our future competitiveness. The United States must seize the moment to cultivate science and technology by setting out a national innovation strategy, and we commit to doing our part. Senators Schumer and Young have introduced the bipartisan Endless Frontier Act — an important step in putting to work America’s strengths in science and technology to tackle some of the biggest issues of our time, from climate change to global health. Legislative proposals to increase funding for the National Science Foundation will accelerate innovation in the technologies of the future — including quantum computing, AI, biotech and genomics, advanced wireless networks, and robotics — and strengthen the U.S. innovation ecosystem through regional hubs spread throughout the country.