2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Executive Action Shields
Sovocool 9, *Research Fellow in the Energy Governance Program at the Centre on Asia and Globalization. He is also an Assistant Professor at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at the National University of Singapore AND ** Senior Research Associate at the Lee Kuan Yew School of Public Policy at the National University of Singapore (Benjamin and Kelly, 34 Colum. J. Envtl. L. 333, “Preventing National Electricity-Water Crisis Areas in the United States,” Lexis)
Executive Orders also save time in a second sense. The President does not have to expend scarce political capital trying to persuade Congress to adopt [their] his or her proposal. Executive Orders thus save presidential attention for other topics. Executive Orders bypass congressional debate and opposition, along with all of the horse-trading and compromise such legislative activity entails. 292
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Sinema Loves
Jones 21 [Ja'han Jones is The ReidOut Blog writer for MSNBC, "Sinema, Manchin whined over infrastructure costs — but silent on UFO funds", MSNBC, https://www.msnbc.com/the-reidout/reidout-blog/sinema-manchin-defense-bill-rcna8359] GBS-HW
Conservative Democrats who have pushed back on what they saw as excessive spending in the bipartisan infrastructure bill and the Build Back Better plan had virtually nothing to say about the gargantuan defense spending bill the House passed this week. The National Defense Authorization Act, a bill introduced annually to fund military spending, breezed through the House in a 363-70 vote. It authorizes $770 billion for the military — some $25 billion more than President Joe Biden requested — and includes funding for naval ships and aircrafts, service member pay increases, nuclear weapons activities and the formation of a new office to study UFOs. And look, I enjoy extraterrestrial talk as much as the next person, but it doesn’t sit right with me that lawmakers who were up in arms about paying for things such as expanded health care access and child care costs seem to have no issue paying to investigate E.T. and ALF. Namely, I’m referring to conservative Democratic Sens. Joe Manchin of West Virginia and Kyrsten Sinema of Arizona, who chirped all throughout House Democrats’ deliberations over the size and scope of the bipartisan infrastructure bill signed into law last month. We heard Manchin kvetch over “entitlement” as the House considered whether to include paid family leave in the social spending package. And in public, Sinema was a rather aimless holdout throughout the negotiations, taking issue with the price of Biden's legislative agenda without declaring what she’d like to cut. We later learned she played a key role in watering down a plan to lower prescription drug costs. Neither Manchin nor Sinema has complained about the size of the NDAA. Government largess is apparently only real to conservative lawmakers, including these two Democrats, when the spending involves actual people living stateside. But when there are weapons of war and thirsty defense contractors involved, these lawmakers suddenly have no issue abandoning their conservatism. How convenient.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Manchin Loves
Cooper 21 [Ryan Cooper is a national correspondent at TheWeek.com, The Week, "Joe Manchin whines about $3.5 trillion — but he spent $9.1 trillion on defense", https://theweek.com/democrats/1005529/joe-manchin-whines-about-35-trillion-but-he-spent-91-trillion-on-defense] GBS-HW
Whether President Biden's agenda fails at this point depends on two people: Sens. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) and Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.). Earlier this week, Sinema appeared the more immovable obstacle. On Wednesday, Manchin made it clear he's still in the running for that infamous crown. "I can't support $3.5 trillion more in spending when we have already spent $5.4 trillion since last March," he wrote in a statement apparently ruling out any new programs whatsoever. "[S]pending trillions more on new and expanded government programs, when we can't even pay for the essential social programs, like Social Security and Medicare, is the definition of fiscal insanity," Manchin said. This is a complete crock, as Manchin's own actions prove: For years, he has been casually voting for bloated defense budgets many times the size of the Biden agenda. His squalling about overspending is dishonest nonsense, and he is utterly wrong about what America can afford. Traditionally, media coverage of government programs covers the estimated 10-year cost, because that's what the Congressional Budget Office typically publishes. Sometimes there are deviations from this rule — the genuinely enormous pandemic relief bills, for instance, were described by their one-year cost. Manchin is conveniently conflating the two metrics, as Eric Levitz explains at New York: The past year has witnessed the passage of three historically large stimulus bills, which were characterized in headlines as the "$2 trillion coronavirus relief bill," the "$900 billion COVID-19 relief bill," and the "$1.9 trillion relief bill," respectively. In each case, these headlines (roughly) described the legislation's immediate, single-year fiscal cost. By that metric, the Democrats' reconciliation package isn't a $3.5 trillion bill; it's a $350 billion one. [New York] The one institution that habitually gets the one-year treatment is the military, because troop worship is virtually mandatory in the American mainstream press, and 10-year budgets would risk public backlash. So let's redress that unfairness, and treat the Defense Department as the Biden agenda has been treated. Let's see exactly how much "fiscal insanity" Manchin routinely supports. Estimates of the defense budget vary between the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) and the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), but for convenience's sake let me use the BEA figures. (We only need ballpark accuracy for the argument.) By this measure, total federal spending on defense consumption and investment in 2020 was $881 billion. Assuming that will be static over 10 years (and it won't be) gives us a 10-year figure of $8.8 trillion. That's almost certainly an underestimate, however, because Congress keeps compulsively stuffing more money into the Pentagon — the House just added $24 billion to the 2022 military budget though Biden didn't ask for it and we just ended a major war. Manchin voted for the one-year portion of that $8.8 trillion — and so much more. He was first elected to the Senate in 2010, giving us a full decade of defense budgets under his watch. If we take the figures for each year from 2011 to 2020, adjust them for inflation, and add them all together, we get a total of $7.6 trillion in 2012 dollars. Then if we adjust again to get 2021 dollars, we get a total of $9.1 trillion over a decade. Again, these are rough figures, but they are certainly in the right ballpark. Manchin voted for every single one of the military budgets over the last decade — in 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019, and 2020. He voted for all $9.1 trillion. While he occasionally complained about wasteful military programs and asked for an audit of the Pentagon, these quibbles were never enough to get him to vote differently. He helped inflate the already-bloated war budget and regularly boasted about thus "supporting" the troops. This year, he did it again. So on one level, all this operatic moaning about $3.5 trillion is ridiculous hypocrisy. Manchin has casually voted for nearly three times that for defense spending — money that killed hundreds of thousands of people and turned half the Middle East into a smoking crater. A modest fraction of that total to help parents pay their bills, give seniors dental coverage, fight climate change, and so forth is not some intolerable burden on the economy.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Public Loves
Krebs and Ralston 21 – Krebs is a Professor of Political Science University of Minnesota and Ralston is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Political Science and International Studies at the University of Birmingham (Ronald and Robert, “More Deferential But Also More Political: How Americans’ Views of the Military Have Changed Over 20 Years,” War on the Rocks, 11-17-21, ) //sg
Americans’ views on the relationship between civilian leaders and the military are disturbing. When it comes to decisions about the use of force, recent surveys demonstrate that Americans are inclined to disempower civilians and defer to the professional military’s judgment. Nor are Americans much troubled by active-duty, let alone retired, military leaders publicly intervening in policy debates. Moreover, Americans’ opinions on the subject are driven by their partisan political commitments. When Donald Trump was in the White House, this meant that Democrats were surprisingly deferential to the military, which they hoped would act as a check on this president whom they distrusted and often reviled. But is the public’s lack of commitment to democratic civil-military relations, and its politicized view of the military, a new problem? Or is it just the normal state of affairs, amplified into a crisis by the churn of the news cycle? It is hard to know because scholars and pollsters have not done regular, or even occasional, deep dives with identical questions that allow for direct comparisons. Over 20 years ago, in fall 1998 and spring 1999, the Triangle Institute for Security Studies conducted a comprehensive survey — more comprehensive than any before or since — of Americans’ views on civil-military relations. While occasional surveys have been fielded since, including by us, they have asked different questions. As a result, we do not know how Americans’ views on civil-military relations may have changed over the course of the last two decades. In June 2021, therefore, we fielded a survey, via the Lucid platform, to a representative United States-based sample of 913 respondents that replicated many of the questions asked by the Triangle Institute nearly a quarter-century ago. The Pull of Deference Americans across the political spectrum express considerably more deference to the military today than they have in the past. In 1998 and 1999, the Triangle Institute survey asked respondents whether they agreed or disagreed with the following statement: “In general, high ranking civilian officials rather than high ranking military officers should have the final say on whether or not to use military force.” A majority — 53 percent — of respondents agreed. This result, among others, suggested that Americans in the late 1990s had not fully grasped the principle of civilian control of the military. But even fewer of our 2021 respondents concur — just 43 percent. Deference to the military has increased among self-identified members of both major political parties: Around 30 percent of both Republicans and Democrats in the late 1990s strongly agreed with the statement that civilians should have the final say on the use of force, but just 15 percent of Republicans and 24 percent of Democrats similarly strongly agree in 2021.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Below Radar
McLauchin et al. 22 - Associate professor at the Department of Political Science of the University of Montreal and Director of the Centre for International Peace and Security Studies. PhD in Political Science at McGill University (Theodore, Tracking the Rise of United States Foreign Military Training: IMTAD-USA, a New Dataset and Research Agenda.” Journal of Peace Research, vol. 59, no. 2, Mar. 2022, ) //sg
The FMTR source data have several limitations. First, the reports do not systematically identify the use of military contractors. Second, FMTR includes total budgets and trainees for both classified and unclassified activities, but excludes additional details on classified activities and omits training by the Central Intelligence Agency. This creates biases. Considerable US assistance goes under the radar in order to provide plausible deniability for training the security forces of unsavory regimes, or to limit escalation in adversarial relationships (McManus & Yarhi-Milo, 2017). IMTAD-USA may therefore omit training activities in authoritarian states or in strategically sensitive areas. Analysts using these data may wish to introduce controls for regime type or for the type of strategic situation in which the United States has an interest in limiting escalation. These variables would then have to be interpreted as reflecting, in part at least, an interest in conducting training overtly or covertly.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Bipartisan Support
Jimmy Quinn, 6-16-2022, National security correspondant for the National Review"Congress to Rebuff Biden on Defense Spending for Second Year in a Row," National Review, https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/congress-to-rebuff-biden-on-defense-spending-for-second-year-in-a-row//DG
The Senate Armed Services Committee approved a version of the annual defense authorization bill that would result in an $847 billion defense budget, which is $45 billion more than what the White House requested. After the administration released its budget request earlier this year, lawmakers complained that the proposed budget would essentially fail to keep pace with exploding inflation and not match the 3–5 percent annual rise in defense spending recommended by a bipartisan panel in 2018. Politico reported that the House Armed Services Committee still needs to put forward its own version of the legislation but that it would likely also add money to the White House request. Congress also opted for a larger budget than what the president requested in last year’s defense bill, authorizing $749 billion in spending and enraging progressive defense-budget-cut advocates. The decision to approve a larger figure than what Biden proposed was supported by lawmakers from both parties, motivated in large part by rampant inflation. Senator Jack Reed, the committee’s chairman, called inflation “the first consideration” motivating the higher defense-budget figure, according to Politico. Another reason to support the larger proposal was the message that it would send about U.S. defense readiness. Senator Roger Wicker, the favorite to become the committee’s chairman if Republicans win a majority in the Senate next year, wrote on Twitter that the NDAA would “send a strong signal” to U.S. adversaries such as Russia and China.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Bipartisan Support
Edmondson 22 - reporter in the Washington bureau of The New York Times, covering Congress (Catie, “War in Ukraine Rallies Support in Congress for More Military Spending,” NY Times, 3-7-22, ) //sg
“I haven’t picked a number yet,” he said, “but without question, it’s going to have to be bigger than we thought.” He added: “The Russian invasion of Ukraine fundamentally altered what our national security posture and what our defense posture needs to be. It made it more complicated, and it made it more expensive.” His shift signals a stark new reality facing President Biden on Capitol Hill, where Democrats had already shown they had little appetite for controlling the defense budget, even as Mr. Biden declared an end to the era of ground wars and indicated he wanted to reimagine the use of American power abroad. Now, facing a military onslaught by President Vladimir V. Putin in Ukraine, and rising fears of a protracted war in Europe and an emboldened China, lawmakers in both parties — including some who had resisted in the past — are pressing for vast increases in military spending to address a changed security landscape. As images pour out of Ukraine of cities devastated by a relentless and indiscriminate volley of Russian missiles, Democrats and Republicans who have struggled to coalesce behind meaningful legislation to aid the Ukrainian cause are rallying around one of the few substantive tools available to them: sending money and weapons. The House this week is poised to approve $10 billion in emergency funds to Ukraine, including $4.8 billion to cover the costs of weapons already sent to Ukraine and eastern flank allies, as well as the deployment of American troops. But already on Monday, Senator Chuck Schumer, Democrat of New York and the majority leader, suggested lawmakers could approve a $12 billion package, in a sign of how eager lawmakers were to send more aid to Kyiv. The United States alone has deployed more than 15,000 troops to Europe, while committing an additional 12,000 to NATO’s response force if necessary. Beyond funding immediate needs, the consensus around more generous Pentagon spending previews a dynamic that is likely to drive negotiations around next year’s defense budget, potentially locking in the kind of large increases that Mr. Biden and many Democrats had hoped to end.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Defense Spending Link › No L – Bipartisan Support
Weisman 22 - congressional correspondent, veteran Washington journalist and author of the novel “No. 4 Imperial Lane” (Jonathan, “Ukraine War Shifts the Agenda in Congress, Empowering the Center,” NY Times, 3-15-22, ) //sg
WASHINGTON — The escalating crisis in Ukraine is upending policy and political thinking on both the left and the right on Capitol Hill, as an immediate threat to the global order and soaring energy prices empower the political center at the expense of the two parties’ flanks. When lawmakers convene on Wednesday for a virtual speech by President Volodymyr Zelensky of Ukraine, Republicans and Democrats will be confronting a changed environment, for better and for worse. “It’s bringing Congress together in a way, frankly, I haven’t seen in my 12 years,” Senator Chris Coons, Democrat of Delaware and a confidant of President Biden, said on Tuesday of the consensus to support Ukraine. “You’d have to go back to 9/11 to see such a unified commitment.” That has meant a retreat by both parties from the policy proposals and political messages that most thrill their core supporters. On the left, Democrats are acquiescing to higher military spending and dropping a bid to pull back rapidly from fossil fuels. On the right, Trump-era isolationism and attacks on the trans-Atlantic alliance are being relegated to the fringe in Congress. Plans to make the president’s son Hunter Biden and Ukrainian corruption front and center in a Republican-controlled House now seem far-fetched. “It’s grounding,” said Representative Peter Meijer, Republican of Michigan, who was once an intelligence analyst in Afghanistan and now faces a challenger on his right endorsed by former President Donald J. Trump. “You can propose something that outstrips the bounds of reality, that’s fine. Then you look at what’s happening in Ukraine, and it’s like a car accident, a near-death experience that snaps you back to reality.” Mr. Zelensky is expected on Wednesday to reiterate his request for a complicated swap that would send MIG fighter jets to Ukraine from Poland, and U.S.-made F-16 fighters to Poland. That could prompt accusations from some Republicans that the Biden administration, which has opposed the swap as a dangerous escalation of the conflict with no real military purpose, is soft on Russia. He is also likely to ask the United States to help close the airspace over his country to Russian aircraft, as he did on Tuesday when he addressed Canada’s Parliament. Republicans and Democrats alike have questioned the MIG deal now that the Defense Department has raised specific concerns about whether Ukraine could even fly the planes. Speaking to reporters on Tuesday, Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the Republican leader, said Mr. Zelensky would not get congressional support for a so-called no-fly zone over Ukraine, and he signaled ambivalence on the fighter jet transfer. “Exactly how to make that happen is still under discussion,” he said. It is unclear whether the moment amounts to a hiatus in the partisan wars over national security. Republican leaders continue to strafe the president, accusing him of being weak toward Russia, coddling “petro-dictators” and betraying America’s energy security. “President Biden continues to have this attitude of, ‘Well, I don’t want to help Ukraine too much’ because he might offend Putin,” Representative Steve Scalise of Louisiana, the No. 2 Republican, said this week on Fox Business, referring to Russia’s president, Vladimir V. Putin. Democrats are incredulous that Republicans — a vast majority of whom did not criticize Mr. Trump for repeatedly standing by Mr. Putin, undermining NATO and then withholding military aid from Mr. Zelensky to pressure him to dig up political dirt on Mr. Biden — have the gall to question the current president’s willingness to confront Russia. “If you are a reporter, and there is a battle for the free world led by Zelensky and Biden, you don’t have to pretend not to remember that Republicans exonerated Trump for extorting Zelensky,” said Senator Brian Schatz, Democrat of Hawaii. But beyond partisan potshots, there are signs of the war’s very real impact. In December, when the House passed defense policy legislation authorizing $768 billion in military spending, 51 Democrats voted no, mainly because they saw that as far too much money. Last week, when the House funded the military and provided even more money — $782 billion and billions more for Ukraine — the number of Democrats voting in opposition dropped to 15. “Defense budgets should be driven by our needs, not some artificial target, but it’s pretty clear we are living in a dangerous time,” said Representative Tom Malinowski of New Jersey, a Democrat in a difficult re-election fight. Representative Pramila Jayapal, Democrat of Washington and the head of the Congressional Progressive Caucus, conceded that the current crisis had sapped momentum, at least for now, from efforts to slash military spending. “I do think Ukraine has just made it harder,” she said. “We had thought with the ending of the war in Afghanistan, we could push for a real reduction in the defense budget, and there will be another opportunity. But look, this is an epic battle.” Republicans are getting their own reality check. Under Mr. Trump, a growing faction of the party was pushing isolationism, questioning alliances and trade pacts, and pressing an “America First” agenda that would have fit well in the national mood leading up to World War II, Mr. Meijer said. In recent days, Representative Tom Cole of Oklahoma, a traditionalist Republican, sat down with the German ambassador to the United States to thank her for her country’s commitment to NATO’s defense and its aid to Ukraine. In an interview, Mr. Cole even suggested reviving the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a landmark trade pact negotiated by President Barack Obama that would have tied together economies in Asia, Australia, New Zealand, North America and South America to isolate China. In one of his first acts as president, Mr. Trump scuttled the agreement. “Ukraine has got a lot of Republicans rethinking the importance of international alliances,” Mr. Cole said. “Other countries are not always a burden. They’re quite often an asset.” Fealty to Mr. Trump’s foreign policy suddenly seems like a potential liability. Former Gov. Pat McCrory of North Carolina, who is running for the Senate seat held by Richard M. Burr, a Republican who is retiring, hit his Trump-endorsed primary opponent, Representative Ted Budd, as pro-Putin in a new advertisement this week. “Budd’s votes have been friendly toward Russia,” Mr. McCrory says in the ad. “He voted against sanctions on Russia. These are serious times, and we need serious senators.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No NATO Link › No L – Public Support
Kull 22 [Steven Kull is director of the Program for Public Consultation (PPC), and Senior Research Scholar at the Center for International and Security Studies at Maryland (CISSM), University of Maryland, "Broad Bipartisan Support for US Engagement in European Security", WorldPublicOpinion.Org, https://worldpublicopinion.net/broad-bipartisan-support-for-us-engagement-in-european-security/] GBS-HW
In the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine the US government has responded by working closely with NATO allies, imposing a range of sanctions on the Russian government and its political elite, sending military aid to Ukraine, and sending troops to the neighboring countries of Poland and Romania. Americans are showing concern about the situation in Ukraine and support US actions. Two-thirds of Americans support sanctions on Russia in a recent ABC-Washington Post poll. A survey in February by Morning Consult found that 60% of voters agree, “the U.S. has a responsibility to protect and defend democracy in other countries,” including 70% of Democrats and 54% of Republicans. This is consistent with broader support for NATO and the principles of collective security. In the Program for Public Consultation’s 2019 survey on collective security and NATO, a robust 82% said it should, “be a high priority in U.S. foreign policy to uphold the principle of collective security, by contributing to collective military operations and/or using economic sanctions in response to international aggression” (Republicans 77%, Democrats 89%, independents 71%). An argument for collective security, that it is beneficial for countries to “join together to prevent any country from invading another,” was found convincing by an overwhelming bipartisan majority of 86% (Republicans 80%, Democrats 92%). An opposing argument that the US should just “do what makes sense in terms of our own interests at any particular moment and let other countries look out for themselves,” was found convincing by a much smaller number of 46%, including just 34% of Democrats and half of independents (49%), although a majority of Republicans did find it convincing (59%). This support translates to specific policies, such as the US continuing to be part of NATO and defending its members. An overwhelming bipartisan majority of eight in ten Americans favored the US continuing to be part of NATO (Republicans 77%, Democrats 90%, independents 78%). The arguments in favor of continued participation in NATO–based on the persistent threat from Russia, the common bond of promoting freedom and democracy, and the value of having integrated militaries–were found convincing by equally overwhelming majorities.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No NATO Link › No L – Manchin Loves
Manchin 22 [Joe Manchin is a U.S. Senator representing West Virginia, "Manchin Calls For Immediate Action To End Putin's Ability To Use Energy As A Weapon", Joe Manchin Press Release, https://www.manchin.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/manchin-calls-for-immediate-action-to-end-putins-ability-to-use-energy-as-a-weapon] GBS-HW
Washington, DC – Today, U.S. Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV) released the following statement calling for immediate actions to be taken to cut off Vladimir Putin’s ability to use energy resources as a weapon of war. “The brutal war that Vladimir Putin has inflicted on the sovereign democratic nation of Ukraine demands a fundamental rethinking of American national security and our national and international energy policy. The United States, our European allies and the rest of the world cannot be held hostage by the acts of one man. It is simply inexplicable that we and other Western nations continue to spend billions of dollars on energy from Russia. This funding directly supports Putin’s ability to stay in power and execute a war on the people of Ukraine. We cannot decry the atrocities of Putin while simultaneously funding his war. We as Americans must be willing to act now. More importantly, we must commit to leading the world in holding Putin and his oligarchs accountable, to strangle their financial lifelines and to hold all those who would support him equally accountable for the violence they have inflicted on Ukraine. “First, we must immediately ban the importation of all energy that is sourced from Russia. This ban must be enacted now. “Second, we must dramatically increase domestic production of energy to support the energy needs of American consumers without causing increased financial burden. “Third, we must compel every energy company – especially those in the U.S. and other Western nations – to immediately cease any and all investment, operations and production in Russia and in Russian allies. While some companies have already acted, there needs to be a complete commitment to destroying Putin’s economic weapons for the pain and horror he has brought to Europe. “Fourth, as a nation we must commit to once again achieving complete energy independence by embracing an all-of-the-above energy policy to ensure that the American people have reliable, dependable and affordable power without disregarding our climate responsibilities. “Finally, we must dramatically increase our military support to our NATO allies and position the necessary forces to deter any escalation or threats to NATO members. “While we must do everything possible to end this conflict through diplomatic means, we can no longer place the free world’s national or energy security in the hands of Vladimir Putin. The time has come for America to once again lead the world in the fight for democracy and securing freedom. We are the greatest and most powerful nation in the world and we must seize this moment through our leadership.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No NATO Link › No L – Congress Loves
Richard Wike et al, 4-6-2022 , JANELL FETTEROLF, MOIRA FAGAN AND J.J. MONCUS, Researchers for the Pew global attitudes project"Seven-in-Ten Americans Now See Russia as an Enemy," Pew Research Center's Global Attitudes Project, https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2022/04/06/seven-in-ten-americans-now-see-russia-as-an-enemy//DG
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has led to a dramatic shift in American public opinion: 70% of Americans now consider Russia an enemy of the United States, up from 41% in January. And on this topic, Democrats and Republicans largely agree, with 72% of Democrats and 69% of Republicans describing Russia as an enemy. A new Pew Research Center survey, conducted March 21-27, finds that just 7% of U.S. adults have an overall favorable opinion of Russia. Only 6% in its leader, President Vladimir Putin. In contrast, 72% have confidence in Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. The ongoing war has brought renewed attention to NATO. Ukraine is not a NATO member, but it borders several member states, and NATO leaders have in recent weeks to coordinate their responses to the crisis. Attitudes toward the alliance have grown more positive since Russia’s invasion: 67% express a favorable opinion of the organization, up from 61% in 2021. Meanwhile, 69% say the U.S. benefits a great deal or a fair amount from being a NATO member. While both Democrats and Republicans (including those who lean to each party) hold largely positive views about NATO and U.S. membership in the organization, Democrats are consistently more positive, especially liberal Democrats. For instance, 85% of liberal Democrats think the U.S. benefits a great deal or a fair amount from NATO membership; among conservative Republicans, only 51% hold this view. Still, partisan differences over NATO have shrunk somewhat over the past year. The share of Democrats and Democratic leaners with a favorable overall opinion of NATO has held steady at nearly eight-in-ten, but among Republicans and GOP leaners, positive views have increased from 44% in spring 2021 to 55% today.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No NATO Link › No L – Congress Loves
Bruce Stokes, 5-23-2017, Fellow at PEW research center, "NATO’s Image Improves on Both Sides of Atlantic," Pew Research Center's Global Attitudes Project, https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2017/05/23/natos-image-improves-on-both-sides-of-atlantic//DG
Today, there are no partisan differences on living up to America’s Article 5 commitment. But in 2015, the last time Pew Research Center asked this question, Republicans (69%) were far more likely than Democrats (47%) to back aiding allies in a confrontation with Russia. Since then, such Republican sentiment, now at 65%, has not changed much. Democrats’ willingness to offer military support (63%) has increased 26 points. A separate Pew Research Center survey in January 2017 also found that for the first time since 2005, more Democrats than Republicans saw Russia’s power and influence as a major threat to the U.S. And Democrats’ concern about Russia rose 30 points from 2016 to 2017.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No NATO Link › No L – Congress Loves
Scott Wong, 5-23-2022, Senior Congressional Correspondant at NBC "Schumer, McConnell urge Biden to move quickly on NATO expansion ," NBC News, https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/schumer-mcconnell-urge-biden-move-quickly-nato-expansion-rcna30131//DG
Top Democratic and Republican leaders in the Senate have signed on to a resolution backing and urging President Joe Biden to expedite the process. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., and Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., said Monday they were co-sponsoring the symbolic resolution, which signals strong bipartisan support for the pair of European countries’ applications to join NATO. The Foreign Relations Committee will mark up the nonbinding resolution Thursday. The Senate isn't expected to take up legislation to approve NATO expansion until this summer. It requires support from two-thirds of senators and is expected to pass easily. The — by Sens. Bob Menendez, D-N.J., and Jim Risch, R-Idaho, the leaders of the Foreign Relations Committee — says that Russia’s invasion of Ukraine "has dramatically changed the security situation in Europe" and that NATO expansion is critical to ensure the security of the U.S. and its European allies. Finland shares an 800-mile border with Russia. The resolution also calls on the Biden administration to “move expeditiously” to complete all of the documents and reports needed for the Senate to sign off on NATO expansion, and it urges other NATO members to quickly complete their own ratification processes.
Today, there are no partisan differences on living up to America’s Article 5 commitment. But in 2015, the last time Pew Research Center asked this question, Republicans (69%) were far more likely than Democrats (47%) to back aiding allies in a confrontation with Russia. Since then, such Republican sentiment, now at 65%, has not changed much. Democrats’ willingness to offer military support (63%) has increased 26 points. A separate Pew Research Center survey in January 2017 also found that for the first time since 2005, more Democrats than Republicans saw Russia’s power and influence as a major threat to the U.S. And Democrats’ concern about Russia rose 30 points from 2016 to 2017.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No NATO Link › No L – Congress Loves
Shaheen 22 [Jeanne Shaheen is a U.S. Senator representing New Hampshire, "Manchin Calls For Immediate Action To End Putin's Ability To Use Energy As A Weapon", Joe Manchin Press Release, https://www.manchin.senate.gov/newsroom/press-releases/manchin-calls-for-immediate-action-to-end-putins-ability-to-use-energy-as-a-weapon] GBS-HW
(Washington, DC) – U.S. Senator Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH), Chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Subcommittee on Europe and Regional Security Cooperation and co-chair of the Senate NATO Observer Group, introduced a resolution with SFRC Ranking Member Jim Risch (R-ID) and Chairman Bob Menendez (D-NJ), as well as Majority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-NY), Republican Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) and U.S. Senators Ron Johnson (R-WI), Ben Cardin (D-MD) and Chris Coons (D-DE) last Thursday in support of Finland and Sweden’s accession to NATO.
“As the Ukrainian people fight for their lives and freedom, Finland and Sweden’s commitment to join the transatlantic alliance at this pivotal time matters not just for Ukraine, but for Europe, global stability and the future of liberal democracies around the world. As co-chair of the Senate NATO Observer Group, I’m proud of the continued bipartisan efforts in Congress to ensure that Senate support for NATO remains strong, especially amid Putin’s unprovoked, bloody invasion of Ukraine,” said Senator Shaheen. “This new bipartisan resolution builds on that progress and I look forward to working with my Senate colleagues to ratify Sweden and Finland’s accession into NATO as soon as possible, and I encourage other NATO allies to do the same.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Humanitarian Aid Link › No L – Bipartisan Support
Erin Collinson, 12-20-2019, Director of Policy Outreach GCD "Amid Partisan Rancor, Congress Reaches Bipartisan Agreement on Foreign Aid Spending," Center for Global Development | Ideas to Action, <a class="vglnk" href=//DG
What else? Appropriators provided a modest increase in global health program funding, owing largely to a record contribution to the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, Tuberculosis, and Malaria. MCC received level funding for the third year in a row. With a presidential election year on the horizon, lawmakers seized a unique opportunity for bipartisan action, attaching several development-related authorizing bills to the large spending package (Division J), including the , as well as legislation to support Venezuelans in crisis, step up efforts to fight neglected tropical diseases, prevent child marriage among displaced populations, and combat wildlife trafficking. While retaining a number of conditions on assistance to the Northern Triangle, the bill will help ensure certain forms of assistance are shielded from future cuts. On a wonkier note, the bill appears likely to force an agreement on the online publication of foreign assistance data—resolving an issue members of the development community refer to as “.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Humanitarian Aid Link › No L – Bipartisan Support
TCH, Texas Childrens Hospital press release 4-26-2022, "Texas Scientists Urge White House To Commit To Global Funding Of Non-Patented COVID-19 Vaccine," No Publication, https://www.texaschildrens.org/about-us/news/releases/texas-scientists-urge-white-house-commit-global-funding-non-patented-covid-19-vaccine//DG
“Given that worldwide cases of COVID-19 are once again on the rise, federal support for the worldwide vaccination effort has never been more crucial,” said Dr. Peter Hotez, professor and dean of the National School of Tropical Medicine at Baylor College of Medicine and co-director, Texas Children’s Hospital Center for Vaccine Development. “Public health, both in the United States and abroad, hinges on our government’s willingness to engage in meaningful vaccine diplomacy. This requires Congressional funding to support worldwide distribution of CORBEVAX, the only safe, effective, low-cost, easily scalable vaccine currently available in the world. Bi-partisan support exists for this effort and represents the only path to eradication of the COVID-19 virus.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Humanitarian Aid Link › No L – Bipartisan Support
WHBR 4-28-2022, White house briefing room, press releases "FACT SHEET: White House Calls on Congress to Provide Additional Support for Ukraine," https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/statements-releases/2022/04/28/fact-sheet-white-house-calls-on-congress-to-provide-additional-support-for-ukraine//DG
At the same time, the Administration is delivering humanitarian, economic, food, and other security assistance to Ukraine and the region. This includes roughly $1.7 billion to ensure continuity of Ukraine’s democratic operations and provide other macroeconomic assistance to the region. It also includes $650 million in military assistance to Ukraine, eastern flank countries, and other partners in the region, as well as hundreds of millions of dollars in food, shelter, and other humanitarian aid to help Ukrainians who have been displaced by Russia’s war. Supplemental resources are also supporting efforts to hold Putin and his cronies accountable for their war of choice, helping the United States seize billions in assets and holdings. Continued bipartisan support in Congress is vital to ensuring that the Ukrainian people have the resources they need to win this war, and this Administration is committed to working with lawmakers and our global allies and partners to keep aid flowing to Ukraine uninterrupted and to support those devastated by the food crisis that Putin’s war has exacerbated.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Disinformation Link › No L – Bipartisan
Maggie Miller, 11-15-2021, Cybersecurity reporter for Politico "Bipartisan commission urges US take immediate steps to curb online misinformation," Hill, https://thehill.com/policy/cybersecurity/581634-report-urges-us-government-to-take-immediate-steps-to-curb-online//DG
A report from a bipartisan commission published Monday recommends that U.S. government and social media platform leaders take a series of immediate steps to curb the “crisis of trust and truth” stemming from online disinformation and misinformation. , puts forward recommendations that can be taken to address issues including election security and COVID-19 disinformation and misinformation online, painting a picture of an urgent moment to take action. “This crisis demands urgent attention and a dedicated response from all parts of society,” the commissioners wrote in the report. “Every type and level of leader must think seriously about this crisis and their role in it. Each can and should enter this conversation, genuinely listening to the problems and taking real ownership of solutions.” The report outlines dozens of recommendations to address the crisis, including creating a “national response strategy” to establish roles and responsibilities for fighting misinformation across the executive branch, investing in local journalism, diversifying social media platform workforces and investing in civic education. “At the time of this writing, the Federal Government lacks any clear leadership and strategy to the disinformation problem, despite its own acknowledgment of the impact on public health, elections, businesses, technology, and continued campaigns on communities of color, including immigrants and refugees,” the report reads. “This lack of leadership, ownership, or strategy is hampering efforts, slowing response times, and duplicating efforts.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Disinformation Link › No L – Bipartisan
Tanner Stening, 9-16-2021, Reporter at Northeastern University "Liberals and conservatives agree on need for social media ‘labeling’ to counter misinformation, problematic speech, study finds," News @ Northeastern, https://news.northeastern.edu/2021/09/16/bipartisan-support-for-countering-misinformation//DG
The study comes as governments try to exert control over the tech giants’ moderation policies. Just this week, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, a Republican, requiring that social media companies disclose their content moderation policies and create an appeals process for banned users. Under the new law, users could sue companies to get their accounts reinstated. Florida approved earlier this year. Democrats have also tried to influence the companies’ policies. Over the summer, President Joe Biden Facebook to take swifter action against posts that spread COVID-19 misinformation, saying the bad information circulating on the platform about the safety and efficacy of the vaccines was “killing people.” “There is a huge need to try to figure out what tools and methods we need to use to combat disinformation and misinformation,” Wihbey says, summarizing the survey sentiment. “At the same time, I think people don’t believe that shutting down accounts and disabling share buttons is the [only] way to go.” Wihbey says the study may indicate that the public is coming to some sort of middle ground. “We find that people want labels to link them to credible sources for checking, prepare them for thinking critically about misinformation, and slow the spread of misinformation by warning people about the content they may be trying to share,” its authors state.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Cyber Link › No L – OCO Bipart
O’Donnell 19 – Multi-Branch veteran and military writer (Wes, “The US Enters a New Era of Offensive Cyber Operations,” American Military University Edge, 6-26-19, ) //sg
That has changed. In August 2018, President Trump rescinded PPD-20 and enacted a new policy that allows agencies to make the determination on which cyber operations to pursue and the authority to pursue them.
Offensive Cyber Operations Have Bipartisan Support