Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Cyber Link › No L – Cyber Security – Bipart

Cybersecurity programs are extremely bipartisan and popular

Patel 22 – Senior Manager at Signal Group (Pooja, “Cyber policy isn’t going away anytime soon,” Signal Group, 4-21-22, ) //sg

Throughout the 117th Congress, there continues to be strong bipartisan, bicameral momentum to coalesce around key cybersecurity initiatives. This has been all the more enhanced by the Biden Administration’s prioritization of this issue. Especially in an increasingly tense and partisan atmosphere, where policymakers will continue to diverge from bipartisan agreements with an election on the horizon, cybersecurity issues will continue to be a strong opportunity for lawmakers to facilitate real impact through efforts that cross party lines.

Thus far in the 117th Congress, cybersecurity policies and funding have garnered attention in nearly every major funding package. This includes large funding infusions within the 2021 American Rescue Plan, the 2021 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act, and the FY 2022 omnibus package. Beyond inclusion in these broader packages, there has also been significant traction to move smaller, less controversial bills that can quickly move through the legislative process, which has been supplemented by strong advocacy efforts from influential cybersecurity leaders on both sides of the aisle.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Cyber Link › No L – Cyber Security – Bipart

Link is thumped and false---information sharing bill indicates widespread collaboration

Roy Blunt 4-6-2022, Missouri Senator, writing a press release "Blunt, Klobuchar, Peters, Portman Introduce Bipartisan Legislation to Ensure Congressional Cybersecurity Defenders Receive Timely Cybersecurity Information," No Publication, https://www.blunt.senate.gov/news/press-releases/blunt-klobuchar-peters-portman-introduce-bipartisan-legislation-to-ensure-congressional-cybersecurity-defenders-receive-timely-cybersecurity-information//DG

Yesterday, U.S. Senators Roy Blunt (Mo.) and Amy Klobuchar (Minn.), Ranking Member and Chairwoman of the Committee on Rules and Administration, and Gary Peters (Mich.) and Rob Portman (Ohio), Chairman and Ranking Member of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee, introduced the bipartisan Intragovernmental Cybersecurity Information Sharing Act to ensure sharing of cybersecurity information between operational cybersecurity staff in the Executive Branch and the Senate and House of Representatives. This legislation will ensure that cybersecurity defenders in Congress are able to work collaboratively and directly with cybersecurity defenders in the Executive Branch and will require regular reporting to Congress on the status of implementation. The legislation would ensure the Sergeant at Arms and Doorkeeper of the Senate and the Chief Administrative Officer of the House of Representatives receive direct, timely, and actionable cybersecurity information from the Executive Branch. “The federal government faces more cyberattacks from more directions than ever before,” said Blunt. “This legislation will help ensure Congress’s cybersecurity professionals have access to the timely and sensitive information they need to better protect the House and Senate from the alarming rise in cyberattacks.” “Cybersecurity threats against our government require a timely, coordinated response. Yet too often a lack of communication between the Department of Homeland Security and Congress leaves us vulnerable to damaging cyberattacks,” said Klobuchar. “This bipartisan legislation will better protect us against cyberattacks by requiring the Department of Homeland Security to increase cybersecurity information sharing with Congress.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Cyber Link › No L – Cyber Bipart – Allies

Bipartisan consensus on new cybersecurity policy---attacks escalating unlocks a collaborative spirit

Daniel Kroese, 1-25-2022, Senior Cyber Team director at Palo Alto networks "Bipartisan Cybersecurity Legislation — Continuing the Progress in 2022," Palo Alto Networks Blog, https://www.paloaltonetworks.com/blog/2022/01/bipartisan-cybersecurity-policy//DG

Whether it’s government networks storing sensitive information or critical infrastructure systems, no entity is immune to cyber adversaries. Fortunately, the strong bipartisan consensus on cybersecurity threats has led to bipartisan interest in cybersecurity legislation. At Palo Alto Networks, we appreciate the collaborative spirit on Capitol Hill, working with a wide range of stakeholders to get policy right. With the 2022 legislative calendar now in full swing, we see cybersecurity policy activity coalescing around several worthwhile pillars of activity. Investing in Proactive Cyber Resilience The American people understand the value of filling potholes on the streets and have recognized that our “digital potholes” demand equal attention. While there’s no silver bullet, we can’t ignore the economics. Better cybersecurity outcomes demand more dedicated cybersecurity investment. History has taught us that investing in cyber resilience before something bad happens will almost always be cheaper in the long run. That’s why Palo Alto Networks was encouraged to see a State and Local Cybersecurity Grant Program included as a key provision in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act. The funds provided from this grant program will be cybersecurity game changers for jurisdictions all across the country. Similarly, the cybersecurity plans required to unlock those funds will promote a broad culture of cybersecurity vigilance that benefits us all. The multi-entity grant eligibility will promote innovative investments, such as security operations centers that span state lines. Properly resourcing the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) will act as a force multiplier to ensure that investment in cybersecurity resilience is met with technical assistance and services to help organizations with capacity building. Both the House and Senate continue showing eagerness to fund CISA’s necessary maturation. Investing in cybersecurity resilience will be foundational in gaining the upper hand on the ransomware epidemic. The White House has demonstrated strong leadership both domestically and internationally on this issue. That focus, coupled with dedicated funding, can meaningfully move the needle.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Cyber Link › No L – Cyber Bipart – Allies

Broad support for cyber cohesion---bipartisan push to enhance cyber security cooperation with allies

Jacqueline Thomsen, 2-6-2019, Writer for the Hill "Lawmakers put Pentagon’s cyber in their sights," Hill, https://thehill.com/policy/cybersecurity/428576-lawmakers-put-pentagons-cyber-in-their-sights//DG

Congress has a new rising target when it comes to cyber: The Pentagon. The U.S. military last year was given the green light to start offensive cyber operations against foreign adversaries, an area that one new Democratic subcommittee chair says he will keep a close eye on in the coming months. But recent internal reports have pointed to a lack of basic cybersecurity measures within the Department of Defense (DOD) itself, with one DOD report last week finding that the military is “at risk from adversarial cyber operations.” And lawmakers have indicated that they will use this upcoming Congress to look at the Pentagon’s cyber preparedness, both in terms of carrying out and fending off cyberattacks. Rep. (D-R.I.), the chair of the House Armed Services Committee’s intelligence subcommittee, which oversees cybersecurity for the Pentagon, said he is particularly concerned about the offensive cyberattacks that the U.S. could carry out. He said that in the past, the U.S may have been too cautious in conducting cyber operations. But he warned against officials going too far and fast in exercising their newly found authorities and said that he plans to hold hearings on the topic. “Cyberspace, in some ways, it’s already a Wild West. We don’t want to make it worse,” Langevin said. “Wherever possible, we should working with our allies and friends in this space as we carry out the strategies — it’s important to have a whole of government approach.” The Democrat, who also co-founded the Congressional Cybersecurity Caucus, said that not all retaliation to a cyberattack has to actually take place in cyberspace. The U.S. will often deliver indictments or sanctions as a penalty for cyber acts, although that was largely before the military was given more power for offensive cyber actions. The Senate has wasted little time in questioning military leaders over their cybersecurity measures, grilling them about their preparedness at a hearing last week. Sen. (R-S.D.), the chairman of the Senate Armed Services Subcommittee on Cybersecurity, said last week’s hearing on Pentagon cybersecurity is one of several his panel will have in the coming months. “What we’re looking at is how do we get to whole of nation or whole of country when we talk about cybersecurity protections, and that means you have to have input from both the private and the government sector,” he said this week. “Each is separate, but they’re got to coordinate.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Biotech Link › L N/U – Biden Investments High

Link’s nonunique---Biden cut defense to invest in scientific research across the board

Science News Staff, 5-28-2021 Writers Representing Science.Org, , "Biden seeks big increases for science budgets," No Publication, https://www.science.org/content/article/biden-seeks-big-increases-science-budgets//DG

President Joe Biden today asked Congress to give big budget increases to most civilian science agencies. But military research would take a cut under his administration's first spending request to Congress, which lawmakers are certain to revise. The $6 trillion request calls for sweeping investments in infrastructure and social welfare programs in the 2022 fiscal year that begins 1 October. It also includes a 9% increase, or $13.5 billion, in total federal spending on R&D, bringing the total to $171 billion. Spending on basic research would rise by 10%, or $4.4 billion, to $47.4 billion, whereas applied research would get a 14% bump ($6.3 billion) to $51.1 billion. The budget "proposes historic increases in funding for foundational R&D across a range of scientific agencies," Biden said in a statement, including what he asserts is "the biggest increase in non-defense research and development spending on record." But not all agencies would see their research budgets rise under the plan. One big loser is the Department of Defense, which would see its basic research spending shrink by 11%, to $2.3 billion, and its applied science budget drop by 16%, to $5.6 billion. In contrast, Biden wants to more than double basic research spending at the Department of the Interior, to $171 million, and ramp up fundamental agricultural research by 26%, to $1.4 billion.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Biotech Link › No L – Sinema Loves Biotech

Sinema literally won an award because of how much she supports biotech!

AZBIO, 4-3-2019, Arizona Bioindustry association "Senator Sinema Honored as Innovator in Biotechnology," AZBio | AZBio is committed to building a top-ten life science industry in Arizona. We work with our member companies to do just that., https://www.azbio.org/senator-sinema-honored-as-innovator-in-biotechnology//DG

Senator Kyrsten Sinema was recognized today by the Biotechnology Innovation Organization (BIO) for her leadership as an Innovator in Biotechnology. Senator Sinema received the award in conjunction with today’s BIO Legislative Day Fly-In. BIO’s Innovator in Biotechnology award recognizes Members of Congress who have been collaborative partners, advocates, and champions of the biotechnology and life sciences industries. “The life sciences industry in Arizona provides jobs for over 25,000 people. Senator Sinema has been an invaluable advocate for the biotechnology community – both in Arizona and the nation at large,” said Joan Koerber-Walker, President & CEO of the Arizona BioIndustry Association. “On behalf of the Arizona life science industry, we thank her for outstanding leadership and dedication to supporting the innovative capacity and job-creating potential of American life science companies.” “Senator Sinema has been a stalwart advocate for sound public policies that advance the jobs creating potential of America’s biotechnology industry as we address the most pressing medical, agricultural, industrial and environmental challenges facing our nation and the world,” said BIO President and CEO Jim Greenwood. “Her commitment to support the needs of America’s innovative life science companies allows them to focus on what matters – delivering life-saving and life-enhancing products.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Biotech Link › No L – Manchin Loves Biotech

Manchin supports new R&D projects---DOE proves

AIP 4-20-2021, American Institute for Physics, institute dedicated to the advancement of the physical sciences in America"Manchin Seeks to Include DOE in Endless Frontier Push," No Publication, https://www.aip.org/fyi/2021/manchin-seeks-include-doe-endless-frontier-push//DG

Manchin said in his opening statement, “I would argue that efforts to strengthen our R&D foundation and technology development ought to start with the Department of Energy and the national labs,” repeating the line for emphasis. He urged lawmakers to “stand strong” in support of DOE’s role “as this conversation around domestic R&D and global competitiveness grows.” To make their case, Manchin and Barrasso solicited testimony from Los Alamos National Lab Director Thom Mason, former DOE Under Secretary for Science Paul Dabbar, and innovation policy experts Sarah Ladislaw and Lara Pierpoint, respectively representing RMI and Actuate, nonprofit organizations that seek to catalyze clean energy technology development.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Biotech Link › No L – Manchin Loves Biotech

Manchin loves biotech---he’s consistently advocating for expanding scientific research

U.S. Senate Committee on Energy and Natural Resources, 8-5-2021, "Manchin: Basic Scientific Research Is Critical To Addressing America’s Most Pressing Challenges, Strengthening Competitive Advantages," https://www.energy.senate.gov/2021/8/manchin-basic-scientific-research-is-critical-to-addressing-america-s-most-pressing-challenges-strengthening-competitive-advantages//DG

Washington, DC – Today, the U.S. Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee held a hearing on the U.S. Department of Energy’s Office of Science and its role in America’s research and development ecosystem. Senator Joe Manchin (D-WV), Chairman of the Committee, highlighted efforts the U.S. Senate has recently taken to drive scientific innovation and stressed the need to continually invest in and support scientific research. Chairman Manchin questioned the witnesses about the greatest need and opportunity for the Office of Science and how the $16.9 billion authorized in the U.S. Competition and Innovation Act for the research and development at National Labs would be used. “We’re looking at numerous areas where investments could be made and have the most impact in innovation and they would include areas like quantum information science and microelectronics and systems biology, essentially across the whole range of these, what we consider to be critical and emerging technologies. These technologies will open the door to new businesses and there are significant research opportunities in these areas as well. We also need to invest in the scientific infrastructure to support those activities,” said Dr. J. Stephen Binkley, Acting Director and Principal Deputy Director at the Department of Energy’s Office of Science.Chairman Manchin also highlighted the importance of investing in the infrastructure needs of the DOE and its laboratories in addition to research and development.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Biotech Link › No L – Bipartisan Support

DMIA both thumps perception of new investments and proves biotech is bipartisan

Mike Levin, 3-17-2022, U.S senator, writing a press release "Reps. Mike Levin and John Joyce Introduce Bipartisan Bill to Foster Innovation in Drug Manufacturing," No Publication, https://mikelevin.house.gov/media/press-releases/reps-mike-levin-and-john-joyce-introduce-bipartisan-bill-to-foster-innovation-in-drug-manufacturing//DG

U.S. Representatives Mike Levin (D-CA) and John Joyce (R-PA) introduced the bipartisan  to foster innovation in drug manufacturing by building on the Food and Drug Administration’s (FDA)  (ETP). The program plays a critical role in supporting drug manufacturers’ efforts to develop new technologies and navigate the regulatory process, which can ultimately help address supply chain challenges and lower prices for consumers. The Subcommittee on Health of the Committee on Energy and Commerce is holding a  on the legislation and other related bills today. The bill directs the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) to build on the ETP by facilitating stronger public-private partnerships in pharmaceutical manufacturing, conducting research and testing on innovative manufacturing technologies, supporting education and training for regulatory staff, advancing regulatory science related to development and review, and awarding grants or contracts to advance research and development or adoption of innovative approaches. The bill authorizes $20 million per year from FY2023-2027 to carry out this effort. “As families face high drug costs and shortages of the medications they need, it’s critical that we invest in new manufacturing technologies that can help address supply chain challenges and bring down prices,” said Rep. Levin. “I’m proud to introduce the Drug Manufacturing Innovation Act with Rep. Joyce to ensure HHS is fostering the next generation of manufacturing technologies and improving the regulatory process so these innovations can come to fruition. Today’s Energy and Commerce hearing on our bipartisan bill is a positive step, and I’m hopeful we can advance the bill soon.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No Biotech Link › No L – Dems Love

Biotech is uniquely popular---democrats agreed to carve out exemptions in price control measures exclusively to support the industry

Brian Gormley, 12-2-2021, life science writer for the Wall Street Journal "Investors Say Drug-Pricing Measure May Shift Incentives for Biotech Venture Funding ," WSJ, https://www.wsj.com/articles/investors-say-drug-pricing-measure-may-shift-incentives-for-biotech-venture-funding-11638448200

Democratic drug-pricing measures passed by the House may steer more venture-capital funding to biological medicines, a field already drawing significant investor attention, some investors and analysts said. The roughly $2 trillion social-spending and climate bill, approved in November, enables Medicare to negotiate prices of certain older drugs it covers and introduces other measures to curb prescription-medication costs. Biological drugs, such as protein and antibody treatments, would be subject to Medicare negotiation 13 years after their market launch. Small-molecule drugs, chemical compounds typically taken as pills, would face Medicare negotiation after nine years. Companies refusing to negotiate would face a 95% excise tax on the sales of the drug. Medicare negotiations wouldn’t begin until 2025, and would be limited to 10 drugs initially, with the number increasing each year thereafter, rising to 100 by 2030. Negotiations would be restricted to the top-selling medicines in Medicare that have no generic competition. The bill also would cap annual drug-price increases at the rate of inflation. The Senate plans to consider the bill this month. The White House, which supports the drug-pricing measures, has billed them as making medications more affordable while preserving drugmakers’ ability to be rewarded for breakthroughs.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No AI Ethics Link › No Link – Dems Love LAWS Ban

Congress supports LAW regulation – Democrats united

McGovern 16 [Jim McGovern is a Congressman from Massachusetts, "McGovern, House Democrats Call for White House to Strengthen Safeguards on “Killer Robots”", Jim McGovern Press Release https://mcgovern.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=396941] GBS-HW

Today, U.S. Congressman Jim McGovern (D-MA) led a group of House Democrats in a letter to Secretary of State John Kerry and Defense Secretary Ash Carter to push for meaningful human control as a safeguard on lethal autonomous weapons systems, also known as fully autonomous weapons or so-called “killer robots – an emerging and concerning military technology. The letter comes ahead of the upcoming Fifth Review Conference of the Convention on Conventional Weapons (CCW) to be held at the United Nations in Geneva on December 12-16, 2016. The CCW is five-year Review Conference and will focus on lethal autonomous weapons systems. Click Here to View the Letter Online. In today’s letter to the Obama Administration, Congressman McGovern and House Democrats write that these weapons “would constitute a new method of warfare – and one that would not be for the betterment of humankind. Once activated, these weapons would be able to select and attack targets without any further human involvement. While these weapons do not yet exist, technology is racing ahead, and experts say that they could be procured within years, not decades." Joining Congressman McGovern on today’s letter to the White House were Representatives Barbara Lee (D-CA), Chris Van Hollen (D-MD), Alan Grayson (D-FL), Mark Pocan (D-WI), John Conyers (D-MI), John Lewis (D-GA), Raul Grijalva (D-AZ), and Maxine Waters (D-CA). The lawmakers expressed their support of “the call for a preemptive prohibition on the development, production, and use of fully autonomous weapons. This call has been endorsed by thousands of artificial intelligence and robotics experts, including many of the most respected people in those fields, as well as two dozen Nobel peace Laureates, more than 100 prominent faith leaders, numerous humanitarian organizations and many more. This prohibition, which should require meaningful human control over target selection and engagement for each individual attack, could be achieved as a new CCW protocol.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › No AI Ethics Link › No Link – Dems Love LAWS Ban

Regulating LAWs is not politically controversial – the US is not developing LAWs and extending reforms to NATO wouldn’t change domestic policy

CRS 21 [Congressional Research Service, “Emerging Military Technologies: Background and Issues for Congress”, CRS Report, ] GBS-HW

The United States is not known to be developing LAWS, nor does it currently have LAWS in its inventory; however, there is no prohibition on the development, fielding, or employment of LAWS. DODD 3000.09 establishes DOD guidelines for the future development and fielding of LAWS to ensure that they comply with “the law of war, applicable treaties, weapon system safety rules, and applicable rules of engagement.” This directive includes a requirement that LAWS be designed to “allow commanders and operators to exercise appropriate levels of human judgment over the use of force.” “Human judgment over the use of force” does not require manual human “control” of the weapon system, as is often reported, but instead requires broader human involvement in decisions about how, when, where, and why the weapon will be employed. In addition, DODD 3000.09 requires that the software and hardware of all systems, including lethal autonomous weapons, be tested and evaluated to ensure they [f]unction as anticipated in realistic operational environments against adaptive adversaries; complete engagements in a timeframe consistent with commander and operator intentions and, if unable to do so, terminate engagements or seek additional human operator input before continuing the engagement; and are sufficiently robust to minimize failures that could lead to unintended engagements or to loss of control of the system to unauthorized parties. Any changes to a system’s operating state—for example, due to machine learning—would require the system to be retested and reevaluated to ensure that it has retained its safety features and ability to operate as intended. In addition to the standard weapons review process, LAWS must undergo a secondary senior-level review by the Under Secretary of Defense for Policy, the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, and either the Under Secretary of Defense for Acquisition and Sustainment or the Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering prior to both development and fielding. DOD is reportedly in the process of developing a handbook to guide senior leaders through this review.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **AT I/L** › Winners Win

Winner’s win---spending PC rebuilds it

Kane 7-24-2021, The Washington Post's senior congressional correspondent and columnist (Paul, “Day-to-day, Biden’s agenda looks rocky. But congressional Democrats say things are far rosier if you take the long view.,” Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/powerpost/biden-agenda-democrats-congress/2021/07/24/83b776be-ebc0-11eb-ba5d-55d3b5ffcaf1_story.html)

There is, so far at least, little fear that Democrats are spreading themselves too thin by eschewing the traditional practice of focusing on a handful of domestic policy issues in the first two years of an administration. “Political momentum and political capital is like a muscle. The more you exercise it, the more of it you have. It is not like a finite resource that you can run out of if you spend too much of it. What happens is that if we do a lot of positive things, then we’ve got more political clout to do even more positive things,” Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii) said. But there is an undercurrent of fear that Democrats lost focus on battling the pandemic and that those gains might be forgotten if current trend lines prompt new shutdowns. “We’ve done a good job over the last several months. But we’re going to have to continue to do it with aggressiveness and precision because the other side has no interest in governing and is going to spend all their time trying to mischaracterize public policy wins,” Rep. Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.), who is in charge of messaging in Pelosi’s leadership team, said. Some worry that the Biden administration needs to stay focused on promoting the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan, fearful of mistakes similar to 12 years ago, when the Obama administration neglected to promote its roughly $800 billion economic recovery bill after it passed a month into office. “I don’t think they’ve gotten enough credit for the extraordinary logistical and managerial effort to manage the rollout of the vaccine. That was a big task. And I think it was managed effectively. And I think that’s maybe the most important thing and the least discussed,” Sen. Angus King (I-Maine) said. In late 2010, while he was still a college professor, King wrote an essay, “The Democrats Beat Themselves,” citing how poorly the Obama administration sold the economic recovery. “Basically, the President was subjected to a two-year, nonstop ‘Swift Boating’ and never really fought back,” King wrote after the 2010 political bloodbath for Democrats. So, yes, on Tuesday, federal health officials reported more than 62,000 new cases of the deadly virus as 314 Americans died of the virus. A day earlier, the stock market tumbled more than 700 points amid fears of the health crisis causing another economic shock. But exactly six months earlier — Jan. 20, the day Biden was sworn in under strict social distancing and masking guidelines outside the Capitol — there were more than 185,000 new virus cases and a rolling weekly average of almost 200,000, with 4,440 deaths caused by covid-19 that day. On Jan. 20, the Dow Jones industrial average stood at 31,188, far below the closing of 34,512 six months later. Labor Department reports this month showed strong wage growth amid steady job growth that suggests sometime next year, the economy will recover all the lost jobs from the pandemic. In June and most of July, Biden tried to move past the pandemic and focused his attention on the bipartisan infrastructure plan and the proposed $3.5 trillion budget plan that is favored by liberals. Those two packages are filled with campaign pledges to remake government support for the middle class, the most ambitious budgets since the Great Society proposals of the 1960s. Democrats will need to make Congress spend a lot more time in Washington if they want to get Biden’s agenda passed Democrats defend these proposals as worthy of the big moment the nation faces. “We are confronting a multitude of crises, including a once-in-a-century covid-19 pandemic, a democracy crisis, a racial justice crisis and a climate crisis all at the same time,” Jeffries said. Schatz views the old presidential model of focusing on a couple big things as outdated. “The model from the ’80s was if you do too many things, people are going to get freaked out. And I think the danger here is not doing enough rather than doing too much,” he said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **AT I/L** › Compartmentalization

Lawmakers compartmentalize

Pergram 18 (Chad Pergram, Congressional reporter. “Amid Kavanaugh cacophony, Congress forges bipartisan agreements on key issues”. October 13, 2018. )

Step back from the Kavanaugh cacophony. Examine what lawmakers from both parties in both chambers accomplished in September and early October, with virtually zero fanfare. Amid the turmoil, Congress approved the first revamp of national aviation policy in years. The Senate approved the final version of the legislation 93-6. This came after a staggering six extensions due to bickering and disagreement. Then, Congress approved a sweeping, bipartisan measure to combat opioid abuse. The House okayed the package 393-8. The Senate adopted the measure 98-1. And, there was no government shutdown. The House and Senate came to terms on two bipartisan bills which funded five of the 12 annual spending bills which operate the government. The sides agreed to latch an additional measure to one of the spending plans to fund the remaining seven areas of federal spending through December 7. President Trump briefly threatened to force a government shutdown if lawmakers didn’t include money for his border wall in the plan. But the President ultimately punted that battle until December. Democrats praised Republicans for keeping conservative “poison pill” riders out of the appropriations bills. That decision drew Democratic support for the measures. The Senate approved a bipartisan water and infrastructure package. McConnell hailed the bipartisanship which descended upon the Senate – even as the senators fought over Kavanaugh. Nearly in the same breath, McConnell derided boisterous, anti-Kavanaugh protesters outside the Capitol as a “mob.” McConnell insisted this week he needed the Senate to clear a slate of 15 conservative judges to lower courts before he could cut senators loose for the midterm elections. McConnell and Schumer appeared at loggerheads. McConnell’s goal was clear: extract the confirmation of these nominees – or tether to Washington vulnerable Democratic senators from battleground states to keep them off the campaign trail. Schumer knew McConnell would ultimately prevail on the nominees after the midterms. So the New York Democrat accepted McConnell’s ransom, permitting the Senate vote on a slate of nominees on Thursday night. Schumer also extracted a concession from McConnell: send senators home until November 13th. One may wonder how lawmakers can find themselves in an imbroglio over a major issue like Kavanaugh – yet forge major bipartisan accords on other. Frankly, that’s just politics. Politics always elicits strange bedfellows. Successful lawmakers know they should compartmentalize their disputes. The enemy today may be your best ally tomorrow.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **AT I/L** › Biden Not K/

Schumer is pushing, not Biden.

Czuczka 6/19 [Tony Czuczka, 6-19-2022, "Biden Aide Says Inflation Fight Can Advance If Congress Helps", Time, <span class="skimlinks-unlinked">https://time.com/6189130/biden-inflation</span>/, DOA: 6-23-2022 //ArchanSen]

“We’re working very closely with congressional leadership, with Senate leadership on that,” and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer is working with his caucus on, Deese said. “And we’re hopeful that we will see progress on that in the coming weeks.” “The single most impactful thing that we could do right now is to work with Congress to pass legislation that would lower the costs of things that families are facing right now,” he said.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **AT I/L** › PC is Fake

PC is fake.

Waldman 12-2-2020, columnist @ Plum Line for WaPo (Paul, “Joe Biden has to move fast,” Washington Post, )//BB

Slow-walking will absolutely be the Republican strategy, on both appointments and legislation. They won’t come out and say they’re going to stonewall every appointee and refuse to allow any legislation to pass; instead they’ll say that they just want to make sure Biden doesn’t stock his administration with radical leftists and propose far-out socialist laws. Send us the nominees and the bills, and we’ll consider them. It’ll just take some time. Weeks will then stretch into months, and the Biden agenda will languish. They’ve done it before — Obama himself describes how they endlessly dragged out negotiations on the Affordable Care Act by claiming they might support it — and they’ll do it again. That’s the Republican plan. The first step to getting around it is to understand that the public won’t blame gridlock on the ones who are causing it. They’ll just see a bunch of bickering in Washington with nothing getting done, and Biden will be the one who takes the blame. Once you realize that the public is neither aware of nor particularly concerned about process questions, you can stop worrying about whether Republicans will squawk at this appointment or that executive order — because they’ll squawk no matter what you do. If it’s a good idea and you think the results will be good, then just do it. As quickly and comprehensively as possible. As David Roberts of Vox observes: In 2009, Obama and his aides made the mistake of thinking that their major initiatives had to be rolled out one at a time in sequence, because he had a finite store of “political capital” that had to be spent carefully. But political capital is not something that exists apart from any particular issue; it isn’t a special sauce that has to be poured on a policy in order to make it palatable. And with the parties as polarized and unified as they are, political capital has become all but meaningless. There may have been a time when a popular president possessed so much capital that a senator from the opposition party would feel compelled to support him on part of that president’s agenda, but that time is long gone. There is no account Biden can draw on to turn Republican “no” votes into “yes.” So setting up a series of high-profile policy battles may be the opposite of what Biden should do. The unfortunate fact is that he may not have the opportunity to do much in the way of big legislation on health care or climate change or anything else, and if he has only executive power to work with, it makes it all the more urgent to move quickly. Which means getting staff in place immediately and then unleashing them. The Revolving Door Project argues that Biden should give as much authority as possible to the agencies to let them dismantle their particular corners of the Trump legacy on their own, because the task “simply will not happen if approached sequentially or micromanaged” by a White House staff with limited bandwidth. That means moving on every policy area all at once. There’s nothing to be gained by putting off any part of Biden’s agenda. Whatever he can do given the limits of his power, he should do as soon as possible, in a flood of policymaking. Even if Democrats win both Georgia races and control the Senate, Biden should acknowledge that he likely has two years until the 2022 midterm elections to pass whatever legislation he can. Not only will Democrats probably lose one or both houses in the inevitable backlash (as happens to most presidents in their first midterm), the only possible chance at forestalling that result is to get results, as many as possible, that he can show the voters. Republicans will complain that Biden is being partisan, uncompromising, taking a “my way or the highway” approach. It will be a strategy to convince everyone of the lie that Biden and Democrats might be able to find some way of winning them over, when in fact they’ll be implementing a strategy of total opposition. If Biden follows them on that fruitless quest, he’ll be running in circles while crucial time passes and nothing gets done. The only option for him is to decide not to care about Republican whining and do what he got elected to do with all haste. The alternative is failure.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Saudi Visit

PC link thumped---he went all in on Saudi

Laura Kelly and Rachel Frazin, 6-12-2022, "Biden political gamble on Saudi trip unlikely to drive down gas prices," Hill, https://thehill.com/policy/3519473-biden-political-gamble-on-saudi-trip-unlikely-to-drive-down-gas-prices//DG

President is using key political capital on a risky gamble – that meeting with condemned Saudi Crown Prince will convince the Kingdom to stabilize global oil markets and ease prices for Americans at the gas pump.   But experts say it’s not guaranteed that the trip will produce lower gasoline prices and the political cost may be far greater for the president.  “I don’t believe there’s an amount of oil the Saudis could provide that would substantially reduce U.S. gas prices. It will be difficult for Biden to come away with something he can call a win,” Samantha Gross, fellow and director of the Energy Security and Climate Initiative at the Brookings Institution, told The Hill.  

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Covid/Gas Prices

PC’s burnt out---Covid, Gas, Ukraine, nosediving approval all tank influence

Barnini Chakraborty, Senior Investigation Reporter at the Washington Examiner, 6-25-2022, "At-risk Democrats distance themselves from Biden ahead of midterm elections ," Washington Examiner, https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/campaigns/at-risk-democrats-distance-themselves-from-biden-ahead-of-midterm-elections//DG

Biden has burned through almost all of the political capital he had when he was sworn into office last year. His popularity has taken a nosedive amid his struggles to contain the COVID-19 pandemic, soaring gas prices, and multiple foreign crises. His public approval rating fell for a fourth straight week to 36%, matching its lowest level seen in May, according to a Reuters/Ipsos opinion poll released Thursday. His overall approval rating has stayed below 50% since August. Sen. Rick Scott (R-FL), who leads the National Republican Senatorial Committee, told the Washington Post his organization is spending big to "make sure voters know that Senate Democrats have supported Joe Biden and his inflation-inducing, gas price-raising, border crisis-creating agenda almost 100% of the time." Biden's popularity problems are threatening to overturn gains in state legislatures.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – AR

Record low approval ratings prove his agenda is stalled

Patteson 6/23 – NY Post politics reporter (Callie, “Biden’s job approval rating slips to lowest level in months, NY Post, 6-23-22, ) //sg

President Biden’s approval rating has continued to slip this month, hitting 36% — one of the lowest levels seen in the past few months, according to a new survey. A recent Reuters/Ipsos opinion poll finished Wednesday found that the president’s job approval rating dropped three percentage points in just one week and six percentage points from the start of June. Wednesday’s findings are just shy of the president’s average approval rating, which sits at approximately 39.8%, according to data collected by RealClearPolitics. The average rating hit a record low of 38.9% on June 13. Biden’s approval rating hit a record low of 33% earlier this month, a Quinnipiac University survey found, and the president has struggled to regain Americans’ confidence as inflation continues to soar. Even members of his own party have lost trust in Biden, with only 73% approving of the job he is doing as president — down one percentage point from the week before while also down a whopping 12 percentage points from a similar survey done in August.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Ukraine

Ukraine war is sapping his pc

Wong 22 - senior congressional reporter for NBC News (Scott, “Russia's war in Ukraine upends Democrats' gathering — and election-year agenda,” NBC News, 3-6-2022, ) //sg

The stark reality, however, is that Russia’s war, now in its third week, is sapping a lot of time, energy and political capital from Biden and congressional lawmakers, and further jeopardizing the party’s already slim chances to repackage pieces of its stalled Build Back Better plan and pass it through Congress. Not only did they work furiously over the past several weeks to assemble and pass a bipartisan $13.6 billion emergency military and humanitarian aid package for Ukraine; Biden and lawmakers also have been working on a series of economic sanctions targeting Vladimir Putin, his oligarchs and Russian financial institutions. Next week, the House and Senate, with backing from Biden, are expected to vote to revoke Russia’s “most favored nation” trade status — the latest escalation in what has become an all-out economic war with Putin. “The idea that we’re going to send in offensive equipment and have planes and tanks and trains going in with American pilots and American crews — just understand, don’t kid yourself. No matter what y’all say, that’s called World War III, OK?” Biden said. “Let’s get it straight here guys.” The Biden administration this week killed a plan to transfer Poland's MiG 29 fighter jets to Ukraine, leaving some lawmakers surprised, frustrated and vowing to take matters into their own hands. “I think there’s a broad agreement in the Democratic Caucus … that we should provide MiGs and provide support,” Rep. Jason Crow, D-Colo., a combat veteran, said in an interview. “I just think that is a reflection of where the American people are and the pressure that we’re getting in our districts and in the country. The American people want us to help Ukraine survive and to do what’s necessary, short of going to war with Russia.” “The idea that we’re going to send in offensive equipment and have planes and tanks and trains going in with American pilots and American crews — just understand, don’t kid yourself. No matter what y’all say, that’s called World War III, OK?” Biden said. “Let’s get it straight here guys.” The Biden administration this week killed a plan to transfer Poland's MiG 29 fighter jets to Ukraine, leaving some lawmakers surprised, frustrated and vowing to take matters into their own hands. “I think there’s a broad agreement in the Democratic Caucus … that we should provide MiGs and provide support,” Rep. Jason Crow, D-Colo., a combat veteran, said in an interview. “I just think that is a reflection of where the American people are and the pressure that we’re getting in our districts and in the country. The American people want us to help Ukraine survive and to do what’s necessary, short of going to war with Russia.” So far, voters support Biden’s response to the Russian invasion of Ukraine. But Biden’s handling of the war has not given a bounce to his sagging favorability numbers. A Wall Street Journal survey out Friday showed that 57 percent of voters disapprove of Biden’s performance, while only 42 percent approve. Those numbers are likely driven by rising inflation and gas prices, which are hitting the pocketbooks of Americans even as the economy heats up and the unemployment rate falls.