2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Inflation
Politi 6/23 – Financial Times Washington Bureau Chief (James, “Biden’s blues: is the US president out of political capital?” Financial Times, 6-23-22,https://www.ft.com/content/3ed8d073-531e-480b-8ce7-44c848c03cfa) //sg
At the Beverly Hills home of media mogul Haim Saban earlier this month, Joe Biden painted a grim picture for a group of Democratic donors to illustrate the political battles that lie ahead for the party. The US president said it was essential to protect against a Republican party dominated by Donald Trump’s Make America Great Again movement, which is gearing up for a fight in November’s midterm elections — and to try to take back the White House in 2024. “Here’s the deal, guys: what you’re doing here really, really matters. We cannot afford to let this MAGA Republican party win. We can’t.” “The rest of the world is looking to us,” Biden continued. “There really is [a question of] ‘What happens if the US goes back to a Trumpian government?’ It is a gigantic, gigantic setback.” The warning was intended to mobilise donor support for Democrats up and down the ballot ahead of the midterms, when significant defeats are expected, including the probable loss of control of the House of Representatives and a possible move to minority status in the Senate. But it also reflected a more disturbing reality for the 79-year-old president: in the space of just 17 months, he has already burnt a lot of the political capital he had when he walked into the Oval Office in January last year. According to the Realclearpolitics.com polling average, just 39.6 per cent of voters approve of Biden’s performance in the White House so far, compared with 54.9 per cent who disapprove — a wide gap of 15 percentage points that will be hard to close. On its own, Biden’s ratings slump could bring a midterm loss big enough to cripple [undermine] his legislative agenda for the rest of his first term in office. But it will also raise doubts about his viability as a candidate for re-election in 2024. He says he intends to run for a second term, health permitting. Things could still get worse. Biden is facing not just political polarisation and rising prices but the risk of a recession that could hit around the time that his re-election campaign begins. Having initially moved cautiously to tackle inflation, Federal Reserve chair Jay Powell is now being more aggressive in pushing for higher rates, and said on Wednesday that a downturn was “certainly a possibility”.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Inflation
Politi 6/23 [James Politi, WASHINGTON BUREAU CHIEF, 06-23-2022, "Biden’s blues: is the US president out of political capital?", No Publication, https://www.ft.com/content/3ed8d073-531e-480b-8ce7-44c848c03cfa, DOA: 6-23-2022 //ArchanSen]
While both those presidents recovered to win second terms, it is far from clear whether Biden is able to engineer a similar comeback. He is now caught between his critics on the left, who believe he has failed to deliver on a promise of transformational economic and social change, and moderates within the party, who insist he has paid too much deference to progressives on both policy goals and personnel choices. Meanwhile, his key economic achievement of delivering a rapid recovery from the Covid-19 pandemic with a quick return to very low unemployment has been eclipsed by rising inflation. Consumer prices rose in May at an annual rate of 8.6 per cent, a 40-year high. Political analysts and pollsters say the unhappiness in the country is even broader than inflation. The gloom reflects disappointment that the US has failed to return to normal under Biden’s watch, they say, given the war in Ukraine, wave after wave of Covid and the arrival of supply chain disruptions redolent of a 1970s-style economy. The Federal Reserve now looks likely to increase interest rates much more aggressively than expected in the coming months to limit price gains. Such a heavy-handed tightening could lead to a slowdown in growth and in the labour market, with the odds of a recession over the next two years rising sharply. Unlike Trump, who repeatedly singled out Powell for criticism, Biden has pledged to respect the Fed’s independence as it decides the best way to tackle inflation. But that means he won’t be able to control or direct much of the country’s macroeconomic trajectory — and he will be aware of the list of presidents who failed to be re-elected due to economic malaise, from Jimmy Carter in 1980 to George HW Bush in 1992. “It’s a question of conditions and how people are feeling about their lives,” says Bob Shrum, a Democratic strategist and professor of politics at USC. “If you have a big recession next year, and we’re not out of it by 2024, [Biden] could find himself in the same position as Bush in 1992,” he adds. On top of all that, US politics remains starkly polarised, despite Biden’s goal of delivering more “unity” to a society torn apart in the wake of Trump’s four years in the Oval Office. Republicans have strenuously opposed much of Biden’s agenda, and there are bitter divisions over a number of issues ranging from abortion rights to the findings of the Congressional panel investigating the January 6 attacks on the US Capitol. “People are really, really down”, Biden conceded in an interview with the Associated Press last week.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC 2ac
Politi 6/23 [James Politi, WASHINGTON BUREAU CHIEF, 06-23-2022, "Biden’s blues: is the US president out of political capital?", No Publication, https://www.ft.com/content/3ed8d073-531e-480b-8ce7-44c848c03cfa, DOA: 6-23-2022 //ArchanSen]
But it also reflected a more disturbing reality for the 79-year-old president: in the space of just 17 months, he has already burnt a lot of the political capital he had when he walked into the Oval Office in January last year. According to the Realclearpolitics.com polling average, just 39.6 per cent of voters approve of Biden’s performance in the White House so far, compared with 54.9 per cent who disapprove — a wide gap of 15 percentage points that will be hard to close. On its own, Biden’s ratings slump could bring a midterm loss big enough to cripple his legislative agenda for the rest of his first term in office. But it will also raise doubts about his viability as a candidate for re-election in 2024. He says he intends to run for a second term, health permitting. Things could still get worse. Biden is facing not just political polarisation and rising prices but the risk of a recession that could hit around the time that his re-election campaign begins. Having initially moved cautiously to tackle inflation, Federal Reserve chair Jay Powell is now being more aggressive in pushing for higher rates, and said on Wednesday that a downturn was “certainly a possibility.” Although Biden has backed the central banker, a sharply slowing economy may inflict a new blow to his own political prospects and those of fellow Democrats. All things considered, Biden is facing the worst possible environment for an incumbent in need of a bounce back. “What’s most important for Biden and his party is just how bad things look right now, with just five months to go until the midterms,” said Cameron Easley, a senior editor at Morning Consult, the data and polling group. “At this point in his presidency, Donald Trump was a good bit more popular than Biden is right now.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Gas Tax Thumper
Olander 6-22 [Olivia Olander, 6-22-2022, "Biden blames Russia for gas prices as he presses Congress, states and oil companies", POLITICO, https://www.politico.com/news/2022/06/22/biden-russia-gas-prices-tax-00041486, DOA: 6-23-2022 //ArchanSen]
The White House on Wednesday again blamed Russia’s war in Ukraine for recent hikes in fuel prices, as President Joe Biden pushed for Congress to suspend the federal gas tax. Both Biden and Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm acknowledged on Wednesday that a gas tax holiday wouldn’t be enough on its own to counteract the forces raising gas prices, but framed it as an important step in a continuing process to help American consumers as oil supplies are constrained. “We could have turned a blind eye to Putin’s murderous ways,” Biden said in a short speech at the White House, referring to President Vladimir Putin of Russia. “The price of gas wouldn’t have spiked the way it has. I believe that would have been wrong.” The president contrasted the bipartisan support for Ukraine with criticism of his administration on rising gas prices. His administration has faced mounting disapproval for near-record levels of inflation. “Are you saying that we would rather have lower gas prices in America and Putin’s iron fist in Europe?” Biden said. “I don’t believe that.” Biden asked oil companies to increase refining capacity and pass “every penny” of their savings from the proposed gas tax holiday on to consumers. Earlier Wednesday he called for a three-month suspension of the 18-cent-per-gallon federal gas tax, but it seems unlikely to pass in Congress. The conversation between the administration and both Democrats and Republicans is ongoing, Granholm said. “I would hope that both sides of the aisle are listening to their constituents about getting relief,” she said at the daily White House press briefing.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › No PC – Gas Tax Thumper
Wagner 6-22 [John Wagner, 06-22-2022, "Post Politics Now: With new evidence coming in, Jan. 6 panel to continue hearings in July", Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/06/22/biden-gas-tax-jan6-committee/, DOA: 6-23-2022 //ArchanSen]
Meanwhile, President Biden called on Congress to suspend the federal gas tax for three months in a bid to provide some relief to drivers. But the plan faces head winds on Capitol Hill, where even some senior members of his own party have questioned the wisdom of a gas tax holiday, suggesting that the savings won’t be passed on to consumers. During remarks from the White House, Biden called on gas companies to pass along “every penny.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Affirmative › **N/U** › Won’t Pass
Becker 6-21-22 [Bernie Becker is a tax reporter for POLITICO Pro, "Another week, another BBB update", POLITICO, https://www.politico.com/newsletters/weekly-tax/2022/06/21/another-week-another-bbb-update-00040903] GBS-HW
It hasn’t been a fast-moving process. But Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer haven’t stopped talking about a slighter version of the Build Back Better agenda that Democrats were pushing last year. Manchin and Schumer met twice last week on a potential measure to raise taxes on the rich and corporations, and enact new climate and prescription drug provisions, as our Burgess Everett reported. Democrats also are sounding increasingly confident that a deal can be reached at some point before Congress breaks for the August recess. But as with everything BBB-related, it’s probably not wise to make any grand assumptions yet about whether Democrats will or won’t be able to work something out in the end. This much is clear, though — Democrats still have plenty of hurdles to clear before a slimmer BBB might make it to President Joe Biden’s desk. ABOUT THOSE HURDLES: The first obstacle for Democrats is pretty clear — finding a deal that Manchin will sign off on. But there’s a related issue there for Democrats, too: Sen. Kyrsten Sinema (D-Ariz.) hasn’t taken part in these Manchin-Schumer talks, by design — though she’s also quite busy with the gun control talks. Still, Sinema’s opposition to tax rate increases led Democrats to something of a grab bag of revenue raisers for the first BBB, so she’ll still have to bless whatever (if anything) might come out of the current discussions. And then there’s the calendar: Congress has a two-week recess after it completes its work for this week. Once lawmakers return, the House is only scheduled to be in session for three more weeks before it heads out for August recess. (The Senate has a fourth week on the books.) So Democrats don’t have a ton of time for this deal to come together, though Schumer and his team are already starting to bounce potential ideas off the Senate parliamentarian. To put that another way: Basically everyone acknowledges that the current talks between Schumer and Manchin are real. But some people closely watching the situation wonder if the discussions are moving quickly enough given that July is right around the corner. One final point: Everyone that Weekly Tax reached out to on Monday thought that a BBB-light bill wouldn’t die in the House, if it makes it through the Senate. There’s a variety of reasons for that. But perhaps first and foremost: People have a hard time imagining that a big bill like this would go down on Speaker Nancy Pelosi’s watch, especially as questions still swirl about how long she’ll stay as House Democratic leader. Actually, something else to consider: "Manchin resistance to clean energy provision could harm Biden’s climate goals," from our Josh Siegel and Kelsey Tamborrino.
Won’t pass – Manchin is a hater and legislative calendar leaves no room
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › AT Tariff XO Solves
Tan 6/20
Su-Lin, Senior Correspondent with CNBC, “Former U.S. ambassador says lifting China tariffs could slash inflation by 1% over time, help Biden in midterms” June 20, 2022 dmr
However, Robert Daly, director of the Wilson Center’s Kissinger Institute on China and the U.S. was skeptical about both Washington’s drive to lift tariffs and their contribution to inflation. He said the political pressure to stay tough on China would outweigh Biden’s desire to look after consumers and relieve them of the burden of bearing a higher cost of living. “If he simply unilaterally lifted those tariffs without getting anything from China, he would get a lot of pressure from Republicans, especially in the Senate, who would call him soft on China,” Daly said. Like Daly, Capital Economics’ Williams was also uncertain abolishing tariffs would do much to tame inflation. He said doing so would only reduce CPI by “a few tenths of a percent,” not 1% as others have predicted. “Putting the tariffs on didn’t cause inflation to rise much,” he told CNBC.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › AT Hikes Solve
Summers 21, a professor at and past president of Harvard University. He was treasury secretary from 1999 to 2001 and an economic adviser to President Barack Obama from 2009 through 2010. (Lawrence, 5-24-2021, "Opinion: The inflation risk is real", Washington Post, )
It is possible that the Fed could contain inflationary pressures by raising interest rates without damaging the economy. But in the current environment, where markets around the world have been primed to believe that rates will remain very low for the foreseeable future, that will be very difficult, especially given the Fed’s new commitment to wait until sustained inflation is apparent before acting. The history here is not encouraging. Every time the Fed has hit the brakes hard enough to slow growth meaningfully, the economy has gone into recession.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › AT Hikes Solve
Ip 7-21-2021 (Greg, “How Inflation Threatens the Recovery,” Wall Street Journal, )
Surveys suggest higher inflation is now consumers’ biggest concern. It is also politically risky for President Biden, who this week said the Federal Reserve should deal with it. But the Fed’s tools, namely higher interest rates, work by cooling demand. They are useless when the problem is restricted supply. In fact, raising rates in the face of a supply shock could aggravate the economic damage and perversely make future inflation too low, as the European Central Bank discovered when it did just that in 2008 because of higher oil prices.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/L Hikes Bad – Emerging Economies
Hoek 21, *Jasper, PhD, Chief of Emerging Markets @ the Federal Reserve, **Emre Yoldas, PhD, MA, Chief of the Global Monetary and Sovereign Markets Section @ the Federal Reserve, ***Steve Kamin, PhD, senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. (6-23-2021, "Are Rising U.S. Interest Rates Destabilizing for Emerging Market Economies?", Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, )
Rising U.S. interest rates are often thought to be bad news for emerging market economies (EMEs) as they increase debt burdens, trigger capital outflows, and generally cause a tightening of financial conditions that can lead to financial crises. Indeed, as shown in Figure 1 below, the rise in the federal funds rate (the black line) during the Volcker disinflation of the early 1980s was associated with a sharp rise in the incidence of financial crises in EMEs (the green bars). However, on other occasions, such as in the mid-2000s, EMEs weathered rising U.S. rates with few difficulties.
Figure 1. Federal Funds Rate versus Incidence of Financial Crises in EMEs
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/ L Hikes Bad
Guida 11-2-2021, Economics Reporter @ Politico. (Victoria, "The Fed is ready to rein in its aid. Market tremors are already emerging.", POLITICO, )
For the Federal Reserve, this could be a year of living dangerously. The central bank is expected to announce this week plans to begin withdrawing its massive support for the economy, the first step in winding down the historic cash infusions it launched to save markets during the pandemic. What could come next — interest rate hikes — is causing angst among the Wall Street investors who finance the nation's debt and creating potential peril for Democrats on the 2022 campaign trail. Weaker-than-projected economic growth in the last quarter, a jobs slowdown and supply chain snags that are likely to continue deep into next year are all sending warning signs for President Joe Biden’s economy, despite an overall positive outlook that has sent the stock market soaring. At the same time, top Fed officials are increasingly voicing concern that inflation will stay higher for longer than they expected. As a result, some on Wall Street are worried that the Fed might raise borrowing costs as early as the middle of next year to fight price surges, a move that could jeopardize the recovery. Political progressives have similar concerns, but their focus is on ordinary Americans. “What problems would an interest rate hike solve and what problems would an interest rate hike create?” said Lindsay Owens, executive director of the Groundwork Collaborative, one of many progressive groups that have pressed the Fed to keep rates low until full employment is reached. “How did the American economy end up in a place where our supply chain is so shoddy that we can’t stock frozen pizza? When you think about that, the answer is not related to monetary policy.” The prospect of the central bank raising interest rates during an election year could cause tremors in the political world, with Democrats seeking to maintain their hair-thin majorities in Congress. Biden’s stewardship of the economy is a make-or-break issue for voters, and GOP lawmakers have hammered away at his big-spending policies as the driver of price surges. The White House and many economists point to production and shipping delays as the main culprit. The clearest sign of concern in the markets over the economy? Rates on long-term U.S. debt recently dipped below those on some shorter-term debt, a rare event known as a yield curve inversion that shows expectations of slower growth and has been the harbinger of recessions in the past. A slowing economy is not just an American concern: Yield curves in the Euro-zone flattened last week after the European Central Bank confirmed expectations for rate increases beginning next year. Markets aren’t predicting a downturn yet, said Roberto Perli, founding partner of research firm Cornerstone Macro and a former Fed economist. But they are saying: “By tightening [credit] prematurely, the Fed will compromise the long-term prospects for the U.S. economy.” In an interview Sunday with Bloomberg News, Treasury Secretary Janet Yellen said she wasn’t worried about the movement in Treasury yields: “No, not me. I think what we’re going to see is a good, solid recovery. The unemployment rate has gone down considerably, and this is nothing like the recovery from the 2008 financial crisis.” Fed policymakers begin two days of meetings today, after which they’re expected to announce plans to start pulling back the $120 billion in monthly bond purchases the central bank has carried out since the pandemic began, a move that was designed to depress interest rates. Fed officials have said that once that is completed, likely by mid-2022, they may begin a new cycle of raising rates That means the next year will be a delicate dance for the central bank, which hasn’t sent a definite signal yet whether rate hikes are likely, and the immediate challenge facing either Fed Chair Jerome Powell, if he is reappointed, or his successor. If the Fed moves too quickly to rein in consumer and business spending to cool inflation, it would be damaging to longer-term growth and job creation. If the central bank waits too long, it would have to act more aggressively to raise borrowing costs down the road, which could also trigger a recession. “It’s a no-win situation the Fed has been put in,” said Douglas Holtz-Eakin, president of the American Action Forum and the former head of the Congressional Budget Office.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/ L Hikes Bad
Bizouati-Kennedy 21, citing Jay Hatfield, founder and CEO of Infrastructure Capital and portfolio manager of PFFA AND Jonathan Wiley, vice president and head of investments at Arch Global Advisors (Yaёl, 7-1-2021, "Consequences of an Unnecessary Interest Rate Hike", Yahoo, )
Some observers are warning of the unnecessary consequences and issues an earlier rate hike could trigger, including slowing down the economic recovery and putting pressure on home prices. Jay Hatfield, founder and CEO of Infrastructure Capital and portfolio manager of PFFA, tells GOBankingRates that if the Fed surprises the market with faster than expected taper of quantitative easing, or even a rate hike, it could limit the economic recovery as the stock market would likely decline 10-20% with negative implications for financial conditions, consumer spending and business investment. “We do expect inflation to continue to surprise to the upside, but the Fed’s abandonment of its rigid 2% inflation target and newfound focus on its dual mandate, make a premature tightening unlikely,” Hatfield adds. The Fed indeed also significantly raised its inflation forecast, as according to meeting participants’ projections, the inflation forecast is up 3.4% from 2.4% in March, based on Fed data. Jonathan Wiley, vice president and head of investments at Arch Global Advisors, agrees, telling GOBankingRates that if the Fed decides to hike too quickly, there is a risk of them choking off the rebounding economy. “While there is clamoring for interest rates to rise soon to stem off inflationary pressures, we take the position that any price increases will only be transitory, as there are base effects. Falling yields on the 10-year of late would indicate as much. Further large, stimulative government expenditures could possibly change our opinion. However, progress remains slow in Washington. There is a delicate [Nik] Wallenda-like balancing act taking place, failing to signal properly can spook the markets as well,” he adds.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/ L Hikes Bad
Long 21, economics correspondent. Before joining The Washington Post, she was a senior economics reporter at CNN and a columnist and deputy editor at the Patriot-News in Harrisburg, Pa. She also worked at an investment firm in London (Heather, “The economy isn’t going back to February 2020. Fundamental shifts have occurred.,” Washington Post, )
Then there is inflation, which hit a 13-year high in May, and is widely viewed as the biggest risk that could sink — or at least stall — the recovery’s progress. Although the Fed predicts this will be a short-lived phenomenon, businesses and consumers are already changing some behaviors. Many companies are shrinking the size of how many paper towels are in a package or how much cat food is in a can and still charging the same amount. Home builders are refusing to guarantee prices in fear that material costs will jump further, and investors are suddenly reviving interest in Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities. “Because there are now so many retirees, I think there will be more political pressure to tame any inflation,” said Lisa Cook, an economics professor at Michigan State University. “The general public has gotten used to low inflation.” All of this is coming at a time when workers are increasingly demanding more pay and better working conditions. They want more flexibility, more opportunities for workers of color and more understanding from employers of mental health and child care needs. Businesses are paying attention, largely because they are desperate for workers. There are an estimated 9.7 million job openings right now, according to job site Indeed. That’s a record, and several million more than the nation has seen before. It’s not a ‘labor shortage.’ It’s a great reassessment of work in America. How all of this will play out remains uncertain. In housing, prices in many markets are up 10 percent or more from a year ago, a very different dynamic than what the nation experienced coming out of the Great Recession. Many of the fastest growing prices are in smaller cities as Americans are relocating to places with more green space and sense of community. Advertisement A major concern is what happens now that so many first-time home buyers are being priced out because they can’t afford the hefty down payments. They will have to stay as renters. Susan Wachter, co-director of the University of Pennsylvania’s Penn Institute for Urban Research, predicts the nation is on the verge of a rental housing crisis. At the end of this month, the national eviction moratorium expires, and many landlords are eager to bump up rent and force out tenants who lost jobs in the crisis. At the same time, investors have scooped up cheap single-family homes in the hopes of renting them out for good profits. Single-family home rents were already up 5.3 percent a year as of April, according to research firm CoreLogic. “I see this coming year as a year where rents will increase by a surprisingly high amount,” Wachter said. “The affordability problem is going to extend out into more places, especially second and third-tier cities.” Advertisement In a worst-case scenario, it could lead to more homelessness, even in such a hot economy. It will almost certainly reinforce the divides between the haves and have nots. $1 million over asking: D.C. bidding wars escalate as U.S. housing crunch intensifies The same is true of the rise of automation during the pandemic. As companies looked for ways to reduce the number of people in an office, hotel or factory, they turned to robots and telework. They invested heavily in technology, which economists predict could result in one of the biggest boosts to worker productivity in years. This higher productivity forecast is one of the reasons the McKinsey Global Institute says the United States could see an economy that’s $3,500 per person bigger by 2024. But those gains are unlikely to be evenly distributed. Automation also has downsides, especially layoffs for workers without college degrees. “This is not a sure thing that we reap the benefits of faster growth without negative side effects. There are real worries about inequality,” said Susan Lund, head of the McKinsey Global Institute. “Are we able to create real opportunities for people who have been in low-wage, low skilled jobs?” Advertisement In addition to equality and housing questions, policymakers are also grappling with what will happen with inflation. The nation hasn’t seen sustained high inflation in 30 years. It’s unclear how Americans will react. There is perhaps no better illustration of the disruptive price and supply chain issues than lumber prices, which hit an eye-popping record of $1,670 per thousand board feet in May. There was a sigh of relief on Wall Street and in the White House as lumber prices on the commodities exchanges fell about $600 in the past two weeks. The price is still about three times higher than pre-pandemic norms, but it is trending down. But home builder Jerry Konter in Savannah, Ga., says reality on the ground is a lot different than charts on a Wall Street trading terminal. Sky-high prices for lumber remain at stores and many suppliers because they still have to sell all the wood they bought at the top. Konter doesn’t expect retail prices to change until August or September. Advertisement For the first time in his 44-year career building homes, Konter altered his standard contract to no longer guarantee a firm date or price. He has to explain to buyers that the price could jump and items like cabinets that used to arrive in 10 days now take four months. While hopeful for improvement, he’s preparing for high prices and supply bottlenecks to last. His expectations — and behaviors — have shifted. “I personally believe we are about to kill the golden goose in the economy with these supply issues,” Konter said, adding, “There are so many people that are being left out of getting a home because of the additional input costs. It’s almost impossible to build an entry-level home.” While many economists and Wall Street traders believe the Fed’s prediction that inflation will subside later this year, they are quick to say their biggest fear is that the Fed is wrong. If a lot of people start believing inflation of 5 percent a year is here to stay, then they will demand higher pay and businesses will respond by raising consumer prices again, igniting a vicious cycle. The Fed would have to respond to that cycle by hiking interest rates quickly, a tactic that typically causes recessions.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Rate Hikes
Henricksen 17, emeritus senior fellow at the Hoover Institution (Thomas, “Post-American World Order,” Hoover Institution, )
The tensions stoked by the assertive regimes in the Kremlin or Tiananmen Square could spark a political or military incident that might set off a chain reaction leading to a large-scale war. Historically, powerful rivalries nearly always lead to at least skirmishes, if not a full-blown war. The anomalous Cold War era spared the United States and Soviet Russia a direct conflict, largely from concerns that one would trigger a nuclear exchange destroying both states and much of the world. Such a repetition might reoccur in the unfolding three-cornered geopolitical world. It seems safe to acknowledge that an ascendant China and a resurgent Russia will persist in their geo-strategic ambitions. What Is To Be Done? The first marching order is to dodge any kind of perpetual war of the sort that George Orwell outlined in “1984,” which engulfed the three super states of Eastasia, Eurasia, and Oceania, and made possible the totalitarian Big Brother regime. A long-running Cold War-type confrontation would almost certainly take another form than the one that ran from 1945 until the downfall of the Soviet Union. What prescriptions can be offered in the face of the escalating competition among the three global powers? First, by staying militarily and economically strong, the United States will have the resources to deter its peers’ hawkish behavior that might otherwise trigger a major conflict. Judging by the history of the Cold War, the coming strategic chess match with Russia and China will prove tense and demanding—since all the countries boast nuclear arms and long-range ballistic missiles. Next, the United States should widen and sustain willing coalitions of partners, something at which America excels, and at which China and Russia fail conspicuously. There can be little room for error in fraught crises among nuclear-weaponized and hostile powers. Short- and long-term standoffs are likely, as they were during the Cold War. Thus, the playbook, in part, involves a waiting game in which each power looks to its rivals to suffer grievous internal problems which could entail a collapse, as happened to the Soviet Union.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Rate Hikes
Kempe 20, best-selling author, prize-winning journalist and president & CEO of the Atlantic Council, one of the United States’ most influential think tanks on global affairs. He worked at The Wall Street Journal for more than 25 years as a foreign correspondent, assistant managing editor and as the longest-serving editor of the paper’s European edition. (Frederick, Updated: 4-21-2021, “Op-ed: How the US can win the post-coronavirus race for global dominance,” CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/18/op-ed-how-us-can-win-the-post-coronavirus-race-for-global-dominance.html)
Place your bets for the coming race to growth. It will be an epic contest among the world’s most significant economies, with generational and geopolitical consequences. For context, think back to what the United States accomplished after World War II, when it rose as an economic power to shape a better world. The post-COVID19 race could determine whether the U.S. rebounds in a manner that allows it to retain the mantle of global leadership. More likely for the moment, Beijing could leverage its first-mover advantage – alongside a faster economic recovery across Asian markets – accelerating the trend toward a Chinese-centric globalization. Elsewhere, as President Macron this week to the Financial Times, the coming months could determine whether the European Union collapses as a political and economic project. The days ahead also could trigger a dangerous widening of the economic gap between emerging markets and the developed world – with escalating conflict and surging migration. It may seem premature to reflect on which of the globe’s economies is likely to have the most robust and lasting economic comeback – and with what geopolitical impact. After all, this was a week in which the International Monetary Fund a 3% contraction in global GDP for 2020, the most dramatic drop since the Great Depression. Yet it is the details behind that dismal forecast that should raise concerns within the U.S. and Europe. Their steeper economic decline and slower recovery could lay the seeds for a long-lasting shift of global tectonic plates to China’s advantage. The IMF projected a U.S. economic decline of about 6% in 2020 and a contraction of the eurozone of 7.5%. That compares to projected Chinese economic growth for 2020 of 1.2% after a first quarter real decline of 6.7% – far less than the 10%-plus dip many experts had expected. The only group of countries in the world projected to be in positive territory are East Asian, at roughly 1%. Even if one accepts that Chinese coronavirus fatalities likely are greater than their public figures and that the growth decline is likely larger, that doesn’t change the potential for a scenario that Deloitte and Salesforce this week as “Sunrise in the East.” Describing this scenario, as one of four possibilities they list, they write, “The global center of power shifts decisively east as China and other East Asian nations take the reigns as primary powers on the world stage and lead global coordination of the health system and other multilateral institutions.” That comes with the broader acceptance of greater surveillance mechanisms as part of the public good, a faster recovery of East Asian countries with less economic impact from COVID19, and a significant ramping up of Chinese foreign direct investment to burnish its global reputation. Still, the U.S. has a host of incumbent advantages that could serve it well if it uses its economic recovery to also strengthen its infrastructure, if it reverses runaway unemployment quickly, if it can tame political polarization and, most significantly, if it rediscovers its taste for collaborative global leadership. In the economic race, no advantage is greater than the dollar. China may be the world’s second largest economy, but the Chinese yuan only 2% of global payments and reserves while the dollar for roughly two thirds of foreign exchange reserves. The dollar four-fifths of global supply chains. The Economist China could chip away at U.S. economic advantages through three underestimated strengths of its own: as a trusted debtor, an attractive creditor, and increasingly as a tech partner. As a debtor, China’s $13 trillion bond market is the world’s second largest and . Chinese debt 1.3% in the first quarter, vastly better than the 15.5% for other emerging market bonds. Over the same period, the Chinese market added $8.5 billion (60 billion yuan) in net inflows. As a creditor, China has remained willing and generous, an approach that served the U.S. well after World War II. For example, it its willingness to back a G20 deal to suspend bilateral loan repayments by poorer countries, a sizable benefit also at its own cost. On the tech front, few countries were as ready as China for money and people to go entirely online. Tencent and Ant Financial have more than a billion users each for their digital wallets, and they are expanding rapidly throughout Asia. OneConnect, an offshoot of China’s largest insurer, provides financial institutions in sixteen Asian countries with cloud-based services. So, what other advantages can the United States leverage in this race? Never underestimate the brittleness of an authoritarian country under stress. Its broad censorship, it’s opaque legal system, and the nature of its surveillance state are hardly models to emulate. Beyond that, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe is not alone that his country relocate high-value supply chains from China. If many countries do the same, the manufacturing foundation of China’s economy could erode. The Financial Times’ Gideon Rachman that the global trust in the dollar is just one of two built-in U.S. advantages that are difficult to dislodge. The other? “Where, outside your home country, would you most like your children to go to university or to work?” he writes. Most significant in this race would be if the United States regained its appetite for political and economic leadership as the world’s premier “convening power.” That need not be done at the cost of China – or anyone else. The race still can be won if U.S. leaders see it as a marathon and recall that much of the world long embraced their global leadership because partners learned they were more likely to win as American partners. This economic rebound from COVID19 will be patchy and uneven. Being first out the gate will be significant, and that is likely to be China. Yet history has taught the United States that it’s victory will be longest lasting if it can achieved alongside partners and allies.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Rate Hikes
Kiersz 11-2-2021, Andy, Ben Winck: both reporters @ Business Insider ("3 ways the economic recovery could suddenly turn into a recession as red flags mount", Business Insider, )
The Fed could tighten too hard and fast in response to inflation
Pent-up demand from last year's lockdowns and ongoing supply chain difficulties have led to inflation hitting its highest level in over a decade. While price increases are in one way a sign of the recovery's strength - American consumers are desperate to buy things - moves to fight heightened inflation could crush that heightened demand.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Populism
Russell 19, citing T.V. Paul, James McGill professor of political science. (Nina, 11/5/19, "Experts discuss threats to the international nuclear order", McGill Tribune, http://www.mcgilltribune.com/news/6474654-110519/)
Experts convened to discuss threats to the global nuclear order on Nov. 1 at Thomson House. Hosted by McGill’s Centre for Peace and International Security Studies and moderated by Jennifer Welsh, Canada 150 Research Chair in Global Governance and Security at McGill, panellists discussed the shift in global power after the end of the Cold War.
T.V. Paul, James McGill professor of political science, emphasized the connection between global rising populism and the increasing acceptance of nuclear weapon use.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Populism
O’Sullivan 21, Senior Contributor at Forbes (Mike, July 17th, “Is Inflation A Boon for Populists?” Forbes, , Accessed 11-06-2021)
My hunch is that inflation is about to become the latest populist focus. Recent data show that in the US and increasingly in Europe, inflation is awakening after a long slumber. Indeed, many professional economists and investors have never experienced high inflation. In the USA, some inflation measures and price components are the highest that they have been since the 1980’s. The consensus and official view on rising inflation is that it is ‘transitory’ – driven by a burst of coronavirus recovery spending. The risk, across many fronts is that it proves more enduring and thus can cause financial, economic and political pain.
Inflation is transitory?
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › I/L – Inflation Recession
Tully 11-3-2021, citing William Luther, an economics professor at Florida Atlantic University (Shawn, "The Fed has two options on inflation—and neither are pretty", Fortune, )
Or, the Fed could take the low road and skirt the agony of a hard times. But embracing inflation of 3%-or-higher creates its own set of problems. Suppliers would avoid long-term contracts that provide their clients certainty on their future input costs. "Those suppliers would stand to lose money if they committed to multi-year contracts, and inflation raised their costs a lot more than they anticipated," says Luther. The bigger worry: America would become a far riskier place to do business, chiefly because consumers, companies and investors could no longer rely on the Fed to keep purchasing power steady, a pillar of our economic might. More uncertainty raises the "equity risk premium," the extra investors are willing to pay for stocks over super-safe Treasuries. A rising ERP means lower multiples, and lower equity prices. "If the Fed permits higher inflation to avoid recession, we know that it conducts policy not the way it promised, but the way it sees fit at the moment," says Luther. If the Fed's gone this far, market participants will fret, who knows if it will allow inflation to race even faster?
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **Impact** › ! Economy
Henricksen 17, emeritus senior fellow at the Hoover Institution (Thomas, “Post-American World Order,” Hoover Institution, )
The tensions stoked by the assertive regimes in the Kremlin or Tiananmen Square could spark a political or military incident that might set off a chain reaction leading to a large-scale war. Historically, powerful rivalries nearly always lead to at least skirmishes, if not a full-blown war. The anomalous Cold War era spared the United States and Soviet Russia a direct conflict, largely from concerns that one would trigger a nuclear exchange destroying both states and much of the world. Such a repetition might reoccur in the unfolding three-cornered geopolitical world. It seems safe to acknowledge that an ascendant China and a resurgent Russia will persist in their geo-strategic ambitions. What Is To Be Done? The first marching order is to dodge any kind of perpetual war of the sort that George Orwell outlined in “1984,” which engulfed the three super states of Eastasia, Eurasia, and Oceania, and made possible the totalitarian Big Brother regime. A long-running Cold War-type confrontation would almost certainly take another form than the one that ran from 1945 until the downfall of the Soviet Union. What prescriptions can be offered in the face of the escalating competition among the three global powers? First, by staying militarily and economically strong, the United States will have the resources to deter its peers’ hawkish behavior that might otherwise trigger a major conflict. Judging by the history of the Cold War, the coming strategic chess match with Russia and China will prove tense and demanding—since all the countries boast nuclear arms and long-range ballistic missiles. Next, the United States should widen and sustain willing coalitions of partners, something at which America excels, and at which China and Russia fail conspicuously. There can be little room for error in fraught crises among nuclear-weaponized and hostile powers. Short- and long-term standoffs are likely, as they were during the Cold War. Thus, the playbook, in part, involves a waiting game in which each power looks to its rivals to suffer grievous internal problems which could entail a collapse, as happened to the Soviet Union.