2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Cyber Security Links › L – Partisan Fights
Mariam Baksh, 4-6-2022, Cybersecurity Policy reporter for nextgov "Partisan Rift Stalls Efforts to Secure Critical Infrastructure from Cyberattack," Nextgov, https://www.nextgov.com/cybersecurity/2022/04/partisan-rift-stalls-efforts-secure-critical-infrastructure-cyberattack/364120//DG
Senior House Democrats and Republicans disagree on legislation Rep. John Katko, R-N.Y., has proposed that calls on the Department of Homeland Security to identify “systemically important critical infrastructure”—SICI—for prioritizing the government’s efforts to improve the nation’s cybersecurity. “It is not enough to simply identify these most critical entities, nor is it consistent with what the solarium Commission proposed,” Rep. Yvette Clarke, D-N.Y., chair of the House Homeland Security Committee’s panel on cybersecurity, infrastructure protection and innovation, said during a hearing Wednesday. “We need to be able to answer the question, ‘what do these companies need to do as a result of their designation?’ And ‘what does the federal government need to do for them?’” The Katko bill, and identical legislation proposed by Sen. Angus King, I-Maine, in the upper chamber, draws from a recommendation of the congressionally mandated Cyberspace Solarium Commission. The commission, which was composed of members of Congress from across the political spectrum, executive-branch officials and major private-sector representatives, proposed that entities designated systemically important critical infrastructure be allowed some protection from liability and access to information in exchange for implementing appropriate cybersecurity controls. Katko is ranking member of the House Homeland Security Committee. His legislation, which has –Rep. Abigail Spanberger, D-Va.—who has not been active on cybersecurity policy, covers the first part of the Solarium Commission’s bargain by calling on DHS to identify the entities and outlining benefits they would receive. But it does not approach a discussion of appropriate security controls companies should be required to implement. CISA, meanwhile, has made a point of noting the agency is taking on the work of identifying the entities in question, regardless of whether there is legislation instructing them to do so. “It's clear that CISA's Systemically Important Entities effort is engaged in a rigorous identification process, but the next steps of what to do with the list appear less clear to me than the Solarium Commission's vision of SICI, which calls for specific benefits and obligations to SICI entities,” Rep. Jim Langevin, D-R.I., said. Langevin chairs a key cybersecurity panel on the House Armed Services Committee and is co-chair of the House Cybersecurity Caucus. He and King were both members of the Solarium Commission. Agreement also broke down along partisan lines regarding the use of regulatory enforcement versus the voluntary approach that has been at the center of cybersecurity policy over the last decade.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – GMOs Backlash
Jesse Reynolds, 11-21-2020 Jesse Reynolds is an expert in international environmental policy. He researches and advises on how norms, rules, procedures, and institutions can help manage environmental opportunities and challenges, particularly those involving emerging technologies. “Engineering biological diversity: the international governance of synthetic biology, gene drives, and de-extinction for conservation," No Publication, https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877343520300890//DG
The emerging technologies of conservationist synthetic biology present high-stakes risk-risk tradeoffs, with sub-stantial potentials to further sustainability and to cause environmental harm. Governance is vital, but existing mechanisms, institutions, and processes have gaps. The further development of governance is a political process. Although critics often frame emerging technologies as being hyped by firms and boosters, this is not the case with conservationist synthetic biology. Those who advo-cate for its research and development seem to do so despondently [3,19] and emphasize caution over speed [12]. Furthermore, few to no business interests are pro- moting the endeavors. This is likely a consequence of these biotechnologies’ largely nonexcludable character, in which their effects cannot be limited to those who payfor the services [46]. Consequently, there is little poten- tial for profit in providing such public goods (in the economic meaning, not the normative one).
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – GMOs Backlash
Adam Chandler, 3-8-2016, Staff Writer at The Atlantic "How the GMO Debate Became a National Nightmare," Atlantic, https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2016/03/gmo-debate-congress/473664//DG
The battle over GMOs encompasses some of our worst political instincts. The public overwhelmingly fears GMOs and supports labeling. Owing to its partisan nature, the bill to be debated has been given two names: the Safe and Accurate Food Labeling Act (SAFE), by those against mandatory labeling, and Deny Americans the Right to Know Act (DARK), by those who support labeling. (Making matters worse, there is also a competing bill that would try to split the difference between supporting state-mandated labeling and attempting to limit label confusion on the national level.)An informal consortium of government organizations and science academies say that genetically modified foods pose no health threat to consumers and yet their interests are associated with pernicious-seeming big agricultural stalwarts like Monsanto and ConAgra. Meanwhile, the FDA isn’t so sure about the environmental impact of genetically engineered crops, which is a different issue altogether that is being lumped within the conversation.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – GMOs Backlash
Nathaniel Johnson 1-24-2014, Johnson is a senior staff writer at Grist"OK, GMOs matter," https://grist.org/food/ok-gmos-matter-but-the-noisy-fight-over-them-is-a-distraction//DG
I’ll confess to some sensationalism in claiming in the title of my last piece on the GMO controversy that “none of it matters.” Of course it does matter to some degree, and it matters very much to those who have dedicated their lives to the issue. It would have been more punctilious (and less fun) to instead title the piece: “The ferocity of the GMO debate makes it seem much more important than it really is.” It’s not that we should all resign ourselves to apathy. I’m simply suggesting that — whether your primary concern is the environment, or health, or poverty, or feeding the world — heavy expenditure of political capital on GMOs isn’t going to move you all that far toward your goal. Both Ramez Naam and Tom Philpott take me to task for underplaying the importance of GMOs, and I actually agree with almost all of what they’ve written here. I agree with Naam that we should be pursuing moonshot technologies like C4 and self-fertilization. But we shouldn’t be counting on those big breakthroughs to solve our problems: They may not ever come. I agree with Philpott that GMO crops have been overhyped and that discussion should stick to the facts on the ground.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – GMOs Backlash
Kojo Ahiakpa, 6-6-2018, Ahjakpa is an agribusiness advisor and a data analyst "THE POLITICS OF GMOs," No Publication, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/politics-gmos-kojo-ahiakpa?trk=portfolio_article-card_title//DG
Opposition to GMOs and science in general across the world has hitherto been a matter of political interests, usually led by corporate, religious and political actors. Journalist Marc Gunther has highlighted the conspiratorial narrative about GMO technology favoured by some corporate supported anti-GMO activists. Marc Gunther has recounted the extent to which corporate and political sponsorship for anti-GMO activism has driven most of the campaigns across the world. Nonetheless, the introduction of GMOs into any country has its own political and business implications. Those supplying fertilisers to governments, suppliers of pesticides, weedicides and insecticides will be taken out of business. Political actors who may be hunting for avenues to make some political capital, may take advantage of such issues and join the protest without necessarily pointing out cogent reasons for their oppositions.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – Industry Scandals
Jackson Moses, 10-19-2016, Moses is a venture capitalist and head of partnerships at MainStreet "Biotech Bashing: Pills, Politics, & Endless Potential," No Publication, https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/biotech-bashing-pills-politics-endless-potential-jackson-moses//DG
The Blame Game: How Tit-For-Tat Thinking Is Sinking Biotech Long the ire of Clinton, Warren, Sanders, and (now) Trump, Mylan's EpiPen pricing scandal provided politicians a prime excuse to attack the biotech sector for all healthcare-related problems. After news broke of Mylan's 500% EpiPen price hike, seasoned politicians (Democrat and Republican) took to , bashing the biotech industry for egregious price-gouging practices. As such, in an attempt to curb her impending PR nightmare, Mylan CEO Heather Bresch responded to media accusations by stating annual EpiPen price hikes were justified due to ongoing R&D costs (strike one), discounted public school rates (strike two), and Obamacare's failed incentive structure (strike three). Unsurprisingly, the aforementioned rationale didn't resonate with middle-class voters. The American public had quickly reached a populous conclusion, which also established a dangerous precedent: corporate greed is a punishable offense. The message was clear, if U.S. Representatives wanted to remain employed, Congress would hold "greedy" executives accountable for their private sector "crimes." Rightfully realizing the rare opportunity to acquire significant political capital, Hillary Clinton the following: "EpiPens can be the difference between life and death. There's no justification for these price hikes." She then released an official follow-up statement and demanded "Mylan immediately reduce the price of EpiPens." Market participants responded by dumping Mylan stock to the tune of 10%.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – Biotech Investment
Alex Keown, 6-15-2022, Keown is a journalist for Biospace with 20 years of experience in the field of biotechnology "Biotech Industry Seeks Congressional Greenlight for NOL Sales," BioSpace, https://www.biospace.com/article/biotech-industry-seeks-congressional-greenlight-for-nol-sales-as-source-of-income//DG
The San Francisco Business Times reported that industry lobbyists are that will allow companies that are not yet generating revenue from the sales of their assets to be allowed to sell net operating loss carryforwards to larger companies. In other words, the biotech companies are looking to sell their losses to larger companies to provide them with a tax credit that would allow them to lower their tax burden. Currently, net operating loss (NOL) carryforwards allow businesses that have suffered financial losses within a fiscal year to deduct them from profits in future years. This will enable businesses to be taxed on average profitability. The plan floated by biotech leaders would certainly be appealing to some of the larger companies. As the Business Times explained, NOL carryforwards are attractive to merger and acquisition specialists because of their practical applications in decreasing tax burdens. But, those are NOLs that are gained through an acquisition. The current plan seeks to give small companies the ability to sell those losses on the open market without going through the M&A process. If a company gains a commercial revenue stream, it can take up to a decade and hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue that can offset those net operating losses. While the sale of NOLs is not an option across the country as a whole, there are places where the practice is already in place. For years, the state of New Jersey has allowed tech and life sciences companies to sell up to $20 million in state net operating losses or R&D tax credits to buyers, which the purchasers can use to reduce taxable income. California has also reinstated the sale of NOLs as the state faced a budget deficit of $34 billion. It appears to have been successful as the state is now projected to have a surplus. But, at the federal level, the idea of NOL sales has not seen much movement. This plan would allow early-stage companies with a new source of capital, mainly if they have been unsuccessful at finding significant funding from venture capitalists. The Business Times report comes the same day that Third Rock Ventures announced a new $1.1 billion fund aimed at supporting startup companies. The approach would provide a new source of funding for these early-stage companies. The supporters of the plan also noted that larger companies would benefit through a new tax-reduction tool. The Business Times speculated that these NOLs are worth hundreds of millions of dollars. If the carryforward sale is allowed, the biotech industry hopes this could also serve as a catalyst for investors to return to supporting these early-stage companies to drive the development of new therapies, diagnostics and medical devices. Investors have largely backed away from biotech and pharma over the past year due to market uncertainty caused by inflation, supply chain disruptions, the ongoing war in Ukraine and continuing talks about drug price controls. Since the start of the year, the Nasdaq Biotechnology Index has been down nearly 30%.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › Biotech Links › L – Biotech Investment
Servick 19 [Kelly Servick is a staff writer at Science, "Controversial U.S. bill would lift Supreme Court ban on patenting human genes", Science, https://www.science.org/content/article/controversial-us-bill-would-lift-supreme-court-ban-patenting-human-genes] GBS-HW
A congressional proposal that would overturn a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision that barred the patenting of human genes and ease other restrictions on patenting software and biomedical inventions is drawing fierce criticism from some scientific societies and patient advocates. Yesterday, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) in Washington, D.C., along with more than 100 other signatories from research institutes and advocacy groups, released a letter to lawmakers arguing the changes would stifle medical research and hinder patients' access to diagnostic tests.
The draft bill "would result in a quagmire of patent claims and legal impediments to the normal scientific exchange," said Harold Varmus, a cancer biologist at Weill Cornell Medicine in New York City and former director of the National Cancer Institute, in a press conference yesterday. "It's in the interest of virtually everyone to keep ideas and basic discoveries about the laws and products of nature in the public domain."
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Logistics Links › L —AT Agency Shields
E.H. 1ac Christie 22, Senior Research Fellow, Finnish Institute of International Affairs, Arkadiankatu. Former liaison between the NATO Innovation Unit and the Commission’s staff. March 31. "Defence cooperation in artificial intelligence: Bridging the transatlantic gap for a stronger Europe" Wilfried Martens Centre for European Studies. European View, 1-9. //DG
Much has already been achieved in terms of new structures, new initiatives and new policy developments to support the collaborative adoption of AI among NATO Allies and EU member states. In addition to pre-existing structures and mechanisms at both the NATO and EU levels, which have ensured that nations are not starting from scratch, national defence institutions are already able to refer to common policy commitments and to options, whether through NATO or the EDA, for research or capability-development activ-ities. At the same time, ensuring a competitive edge in AI is a truly whole-of-government effort which requires considerable cross-over between the military and civilian realms. Large gaps remain between the US and the EU on certain key indicators. At the same time, the gaps pertaining to research are far smaller. To ensure greater European perfor- mance and relevance in AI in general, and its defence applications in particular, it seems desirable to focus on two strategic priorities: investment volumes, both public and pri- vate, which need to be significantly increased; and the full use of collaborative mecha- nisms involving the US.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Logistics Links › L – Cooperation Costs PC
Ulrike Esther 1ac Franke 21, senior policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR). She leads ECFR’s Technology and European Power initiative. Her areas of focus include German and European security and defence, the future of warfare, and the impact of new technologies such as drones and artificial intelligence on geopolitics and warfare. PhD in International Relations from the University of Oxford. Franke is a policy affiliate at the Governance of AI project at Oxford University’s Future of Humanity Institute. "Artificial divide: How Europe and America could clash over AI" – ECFR/367 2. January. //DG
This paper examines the reasons European states may want to work with the US on AI, and why the US may want to reach out to Europe on the issue. It also identifies the points of disagreement that may stop the allies from fully fleshing out transatlantic AI cooperation. The paper shows that, while both sides are interested in working together, their rationales for doing so differ. Furthermore, economic and political factors may stand in the way of cooperation, even though such cooperation could have a positive impact on the way AI develops. The paper also argues that transatlantic cooperation in the area of military AI could be a good first step – here, Europe and the US should build on existing collaboration within NATO. The paper concludes with a brief discussion of the different forums that have been created or proposed for transatlantic and broader Western cooperation on AI.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Logistics Links › L – Cooperation Costs PC
Ulrike Esther 1ac Franke 21, senior policy fellow at the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR). She leads ECFR’s Technology and European Power initiative. Her areas of focus include German and European security and defence, the future of warfare, and the impact of new technologies such as drones and artificial intelligence on geopolitics and warfare. PhD in International Relations from the University of Oxford. Franke is a policy affiliate at the Governance of AI project at Oxford University’s Future of Humanity Institute. "Artificial divide: How Europe and America could clash over AI" – ECFR/367 2. January. //DG
This paper has discussed the rationale for transatlantic cooperation on AI. It has shown that both Europe and the US have reasons for wanting to cooperate with each other. But substantial hurdles may prevent the transatlantic partners from cooperating in a significant way. However, they can still look to ramp up their cooperation. And non-combat military AI, in particular, may be low-hanging fruit for AI cooperation within NATO. Europeans should reach out to their American allies, so that a new, third phase of Europe’s policy efforts in this AI spring can indeed become a phase of international – and particularly transatlantic – cooperation.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Logistics Links › L – Cooperation Costs PC
Margarita 1ac Konaev & Husanjot Chahal 21, Research Fellow & Research Analyst, Center for Security and Emerging Technology, Georgetown University. "The Path of Least Resistance Multinational Collaboration on AI for Military Logistics and Sustainment" April. //DG
While there are notable technical, bureaucratic, and political barriers to multinational cooperation in AI, especially for military purposes, AI applications for logistics and sustainment represent both a promising and critical area for collaboration between the United States and its allies. There are many ways allies can work together in this space, including by developing joint standards for data sharing, investing in collaborative R&D programs, advancing multinational public-private partnerships, and integrating AI- enabled logistics and sustainment technologies into joint military exercises.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Logistics Links › L – Big Tech Backlash
Chung 21, big tech accountability advocate (Jane, “Big Tech, Big Cash: Washington’s New Power Players,” Citizen, )
“I can tell you [political spending] plays an important role. Not because the checks are big, but because the way the political process works. Politicians in the United States have events, they have weekend retreats, you have to write a check and then you’re invited and participate. “So if you work in the government affairs team in the United States, you spend your weekends going to these events; you spend your evenings going to these dinners, and the reason you go is because the PAC writes a check. “But out of that ongoing effort a relationship evolves and emerges and solidifies … I’m sometimes calling members and asking for their help on green cards, or on visa issues … Or the issues around national security, or privacy … “There are times when I call people who I don’t personally know, and somebody will say ‘you know, your folks have always shown up for me at my events. And we have a good relationship. Let me see what I can do to help you.’” – Brad Smith, President and Chief Legal Officer, Microsoft –––– “Microsoft’s quiet pursuit to buy TikTok suddenly appeared dead a month ago … so Brad Smith, the tech giant’s president, went to work. He called two dozen lawmakers, telling them that TikTok would be safe in Microsoft’s hands. Within 48 hours, he had what he needed.” – New York Times “We had a hierarchy in my office in Congress. If you’re a lobbyist who never gave us money, I didn’t talk to you. If you’re a lobbyist who gave us money, I might talk to you.” – Mick Mulvaney, former U.S. Representative Executive Summary In recent years, Amazon, Apple, Facebook, and Google have all come under increased scrutiny for threatening our privacy, democracy, small businesses, and workers. In the race to amass monopoly power in their respective markets, these corporations have developed predatory business practices that harvest user data for profit[1] and facilitated discrimination by race, religion, national origin,[2] age,[3] and gender.[4] Facebook and Google have wielded unprecedented influence over our democratic process.[5] Amazon has been accused of subjecting workers to unsafe working conditions during COVID-19,[6] while the plurality of its workforce is Black, brown, and/or non-white.[7] All of these companies have killed, rather than fostered innovation.[8] Increased investments in Washington have allowed these monopolists to harm consumers, workers, and other businesses alike, with relatively little accountability to date. A report Public Citizen released in 2019 (covering up to the 2018 election cycle) detailed how Big Tech corporations have blanketed Capitol Hill with lobbyists and lavished members of Congress with campaign contributions. This is an update of that report, based on data provided by the Center for Responsive Politics. Since the 2020 election cycle has ended, Public Citizen reevaluated Big Tech’s influence over the government by analyzing the tech companies’ lobbying spending and campaign contributions. Here are the key findings of this report: Facebook and Amazon are now the two biggest corporate lobbying spenders in the country.[9] Big Tech has eclipsed yesterday’s big lobbying spenders, Big Oil and Big Tobacco. In 2020, Amazon and Facebook spent nearly twice as much as Exxon and Philip Morris on lobbying. During the 2020 election cycle, Big Tech spent $124 million in lobbying and campaign contributions –– breaking its own records from past election cycles. Amazon and Facebook drove most of this growth. From the years of 2018-2020, Amazon increased spending by 30% while Facebook added an astounding 56% to its Washington investment. The four Big Tech companies recruited more lobbyists into their army, increasing its ranks by 40 new lobbyists, from 293 in 2018 to 333 in 2020.[10] Big Tech PACs, lobbyists, and employees contributed over 33% more in the 2020 election cycle than they did in the 2018 cycle, for an increase of over $4 million in funds, and a total of nearly $16.5 million in contributions to the election cycle. This marks the greatest cycle-over-cycle increase in campaign contributions from Big Tech in the ten-year span Public Citizen reviewed. Big Tech’s lobbyists are not just numerous, they are also among the most influential in Washington. Among the 10 lobbyists who were the biggest contributors to the 2020 election cycle, half lobby on behalf of at least one of the four Big Tech companies. Together, just these five lobbyists contributed over $2 million to the 2020 elections. Nearly all (94%) members of Congress with jurisdiction over privacy and antitrust issues have received money from a Big Tech corporate PAC or lobbyist. In total, just in 2020, Big Tech PACs and lobbyists have contributed about $3.2 million to lawmakers tasked with regulating them.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Logistics Links › L – Big Tech Backlash
Lin-Greenberg 20, postdoctoral fellow at the University of Pennsylvania’s Perry World House (Erik, “Allies and Artificial Intelligence: Obstacles to Operations and Decision-Making,” Vol 3, Issue 2)//BB
https://tnsr.org/2020/03/allies-and-artificial-intelligence-obstacles-to-operations-and-decision-making/
Tepid public support at home and abroad can stymie alliance military operations in two ways. First, public opposition to the use of AI among allied populations may lead policymakers to restrict the use of AI-enabled technologies for military operations. In the event of future hostilities, for example, the South Korean or German governments might oppose an ally’s use of AI-enabled lethal weapon systems on their territory.60 Indeed, advocacy from the public and activist groups has led a growing number of states — including U.S. allies like Pakistan and Jordan — to call for bans on the use of lethal autonomous weapon systems.61
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Ethics Links › L – Ban LAWS – DOD backlash
Congressional Research Service 21 – (“Defense Primer: U.S. Policy on Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems,” Congressional Research Service Reports, 11-17-21, https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11150) //sg
Lethal autonomous weapon systems (LAWS) are a special class of weapon systems that use sensor suites and computer algorithms to independently identify a target and employ an onboard weapon system to engage and destroy the target without manual human control of the system. Although these systems are not yet in widespread development, it is believed they would enable military operations in communications-degraded or -denied environments in which traditional systems may not be able to operate. Contrary to a number of news reports, U.S. policy does not prohibit the development or employment of LAWS. Although the United States does not currently have LAWS in its inventory, some senior military and defense leaders have stated that the United States may be compelled to develop LAWS in the future if U.S. competitors choose to do so. At the same time, a growing number of states and nongovernmental organizations are appealing to the international community for regulation of or a ban on LAWS due to ethical concerns.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Ethics Links › L – Ban LAWS – Congress Backlash
The Guardian 21 [The Guardian, "US rejects calls for regulating or banning ‘killer robots’", https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/02/us-rejects-calls-regulating-banning-killer-robots] GBS-HW
The US has rejected calls for a binding agreement regulating or banning the use of “killer robots”, instead proposing a “code of conduct” at the United Nations. Speaking at a meeting in Geneva focused on finding common ground on the use of such so-called lethal autonomous weapons, a US official balked at the idea of regulating their use through a “legally-binding instrument”. The meeting saw government experts preparing for high-level talks at a review conference on the Convention of Certain Conventional Weapons from 13 to 17 December. “In our view, the best way to make progress ... would be through the development of a non-binding code of conduct,” US official Josh Dorosin told the meeting. The United Nations has been hosting diplomatic talks in Geneva since 2017 aimed at reaching an agreement on how to address the use of killer robots. Activists and a number of countries have called for an all-out ban on any weapons that could use lethal force without a human overseeing the process and making the final kill order. In November 2018, the UN chief, António Guterres, joined the call for a ban, but so far countries do not even agree on whether there is a need to regulate the weapons. During Thursday’s debate, a number of countries, including India and the United States, criticised the idea of a legally binding agreement. Dorosin insisted a code of conduct “would help states promote responsible behaviour and compliance with international law”.Campaigners disagreed.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Ethics Links › L – Ban LAWS – Congress Backlash
De Vynck 21 [Gerrit De Vynck is a tech reporter for The Washington Post. He writes about Google and the algorithms that increasingly shape society, "The U.S. says humans will always be in control of AI weapons. But the age of autonomous war is already here,” Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2021/07/07/ai-weapons-us-military/] GBS-HW
Drones have been a key part of warfare for years, but they’ve generally been remotely controlled by humans. Now, by cobbling together readily available image-recognition and autopilot software, autonomous drones can be mass-produced on the cheap. Today, efforts to enact a total ban on lethal autonomous weapons, long demanded by human rights activists, are now being supported by 30 countries. But the world’s leading military powers insist that isn’t necessary. The U.S. military says concerns are overblown, and humans can effectively control autonomous weapons, while Russia’s government says true AI weapons can’t be banned because they don’t exist yet. But the facts on the ground show that technological advancements, coupled with complex conflicts like the Syrian and Libyan civil wars, have created a reality where weapons that make their own decisions are already killing people. “The debate is very much still oriented towards the future,” said Ingvild Bode, an autonomous weapons researcher at the University of Southern Denmark. “We should take a much closer look at what is already going on.” Libya wasn’t the only place drones that can kill autonomously were used last year. Turkey has used the same quadcopters to patrol its border with Syria. When Azerbaijan invaded Armenian-occupied territory in September, it sent in both Turkish- and Israeli-made “loitering munitions” — drones that can autonomously patrol an area and automatically divebomb enemy radar signals. These weapons look like smaller versions of the remote-controlled drones that have been used extensively by the U.S. military in Iraq, Afghanistan and other conflicts. Instead of launching missiles through remote control, though, loitering munitions have a built-in explosive and destroy themselves on impact with their target. Since they have both remote-control and autonomous capability, it’s impossible to know from the outside whether humans made the final call to bomb individual targets. Either way, the drones devastated Armenia’s army, and the war ended two months later with Azerbaijan gaining huge swaths of territory. These kinds of weapons are moving firmly into the mainstream. Today, there are dozens of projects by multiple governments to develop loitering munitions. Even as countries like the United States, China and Russia participate in discussions about a treaty limiting autonomous weapons, they’re racing ahead to develop them. “The advanced militaries are pushing the envelope of these technologies,” said Peter Asaro, a professor at the New School in New York and a co-founder of the International Committee for Robot Arms Control, which advocates for stricter rules around lethal autonomous weapons. “They will proliferate rapidly.” Over the past decade, cheaper access to computers that can crunch massive data sets in a short time has allowed researchers to make huge breakthroughs in designing computer programs that pull insights from large amounts of information. AI advances have led to machines that can write poetry, accurately translate languages and potentially help scientists develop new medicines. But debates about the dangers of relying more on computers to make decisions are raging. AI algorithms are only as good as the data sets they were trained on, and studies have shown facial recognition AI programs are better at identifying White faces than Black and Brown ones. European lawmakers recently proposed strict new rules regulating the use of AI. Companies including Google, Amazon, Apple and Tesla have poured billions of dollars into developing the technology, and critics say AI programs are sometimes being deployed without full knowledge of how they work and what the consequences of widespread use could be. Some countries, such as Austria, have joined the call for a global ban on autonomous weapons, but U.S. tech and political leaders are pushing back. In March, a panel of tech luminaries including former Google chief executive Eric Schmidt, then-chief of Web services, now chief executive of Amazon Andy Jassy and Microsoft chief scientist Eric Horvitz released a study on the impact of AI on national security. The 756-page final report, commissioned by Congress, argued that Washington should oppose a ban on autonomous weapons because it would be difficult to enforce, and could stop the United States from using weapons it already has in its arsenal. In a first, Air Force uses AI on military jet “It may be impossible to define the category of systems to be restricted in such a way that provides adequate clarity while not overly constraining existing U.S. military capabilities,” the report said.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Ethics Links › L – Restrictions Cost PC
1ac Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ /DG
While jumping straight to implementation can mean a more pragmatic focus on tools, tracking how different AI stakeholders use those tools may be more difficult. In this way, principles can be seen as a helpful organizing force, as is the case for DOD. This said, the scale of the U.S. military bureaucracy and national security innovation base may require higher visibility relative to allied counterparts. Still, another key difference is precisely this visibility. The analysis here is based on information in the public domain, which may also partially explain its transatlantic tilt. The U.S. approach to responsible and ethical AI for defense also differs from other Center for Security and Emerging Technology | 52 countries in that the consultation and process that led to its principles is far more transparent than is true for most allies. A possible Catch-22 could be at play here, with allies reticent to publicize approaches to such controversial issues, despite the fact that offering such inroads can build trust and confidence that governments are handling these high-stakes questions responsibly.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › AI Ethics Links › L – Restrictions Cost PC
Kang 22 – NYT tech policy reporter (Cecilia, “As Europe Approves New Tech Laws, the U.S. Falls Further Behind,” New York Times, 4-22-22, ) //sg
In the United States, Congress has not passed a single piece of comprehensive regulation to protect internet consumers and to rein in the power of its technology giants. It’s not for lack of trying. Over 25 years, dozens of federal privacy bills have been proposed and then ultimately dropped without bipartisan support. With every major hack of a bank or retailer, lawmakers have introduced data breach and security bills, all of which have withered on the vine. A flurry of speech bills have sunk into the quicksand of partisan disagreements over freedoms of expression. And antitrust bills to curtail the power of Apple, Amazon, Google and Meta, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, have sat in limbo amid fierce lobbying opposition. Only two narrow federal tech laws have been enacted — one for children’s privacy and the other for ridding sites of sex-trafficking content — in the past 25 years. “Inertia is too kind of a word to describe what’s happened in the United States; there’s been a lack of will, courage and understanding of the problem and technologies,” said Jeffrey Chester, the executive director of the Center for Digital Democracy, a public interest group. “And consumers are left with no protections here and lots of confusion.” The prospects that any legislation will pass imminently are dim, though regulations at some point are almost inevitable because of the way tech touches so many aspects of life. Of all the proposals currently in front of Congress, an antitrust bill that would bar Apple, Alphabet and Amazon from boosting their own products on their marketplaces and app stores over those of their rivals has the best shot. A co-author of the bill, Senator Amy Klobuchar, Democrat of Minnesota, said Democratic leaders had promised it would go to a vote by this summer. But even that bill, with bipartisan support, faces an uphill climb amid so many other priorities in Congress and a fierce tech lobbying effort to defeat it. If history is a guide, the path toward U.S. tech regulation will be long. It took decades of public anger to regulate the railroads through the creation of the Interstate Commerce Commission in 1887. It took nearly 50 years from the first medical reports on the dangers of cigarettes to the regulation of tobacco. There’s no single reason for the sludge of progress in Congress. Proposals have been caught in the age-old partisan divide over how to protect consumers while also encouraging the growth of business. Then there are the hundreds of tech lobbyists who block legislation that could dampen their profits. Lawmakers have also at times failed to grasp the technologies they are trying to regulate, turning their public foibles over tech into internet memes. Tech companies have taken advantage of that knowledge blind spot, said Tom Wheeler, a former chairman of the Federal Communications Commission. “It’s what I call the ‘big con,’ where the tech companies spin a story that they are doing magic and that if Washington touches their companies with regulations they’ll be responsible for breaking that magic,” he said. In the vacuum of federal regulations, states have created a patchwork of tech rules instead. California, Virginia, Utah and Colorado have adopted their own privacy laws. Florida and Texas have passed social media laws aimed at punishing internet platforms for censoring conservative views. Amazon, Alphabet, Apple, Meta and Microsoft said they supported federal regulations. But when pressed, some of them have fought for the most permissive versions of the laws that have been under consideration. Meta, for instance, has pushed for weaker federal privacy legislation that would override stronger laws in the states. In response, many of the tech companies mobilized an extensive lobbying and marketing campaign to defeat the bill. Through a trade group, Amazon claimed in television and newspaper ads that the bill would effectively end its Prime membership program. Kent Walker, Google’s chief legal officer, wrote in a blog post that the legislation would “break” popular products and prevent the company from displaying Google maps in search results. Ms. Klobuchar said the companies’ claims were hyperbole. She warned that by fighting the proposal, tech companies might be choosing the worse of two difficult options. “They are letting Europe set the agenda on internet regulation,” Ms. Klobuchar said. “At least we listened to everyone’s concerns and modified our bill.” The inaction may appear surprising given that Republicans and Democrats are ostensibly in lock step over how tech companies have morphed into global powerhouses. “Consumers need confidence that their data is being protected, and businesses need to know they can keep innovating while complying with a strong, workable national privacy standard,” said Senator Roger Wicker, Republican of Mississippi. “The U.S. cannot afford to cede leadership on this issue.” Lawmakers have also forced many tech chief executives — including Jeff Bezos of Amazon, Tim Cook of Apple, Sundar Pichai of Google and Mark Zuckerberg of Meta — to testify multiple times before Congress in recent years. In some of those televised hearings, lawmakers of both parties have told the executives that their companies — with a combined $6.4 trillion in market value — aren’t above government or public accountability. “Some of these companies are countries, not companies,” Senator John Kennedy, Republican of Louisiana, said in a January antitrust hearing, adding that they are “killing fields for the truth.” But so far, the talk has not translated into new laws. The path to privacy regulations provides the clearest case study on that record of inaction. Since 1995, Senator Edward J. Markey, Democrat of Massachusetts, has introduced a dozen privacy bills for internet service providers, drones and third-party data brokers. In 2018, the year Europe’s General Data Protection Regulation took effect, he proposed a bill to require a consumer’s permission to share or sell data. Mr. Markey also tried twice to update and strengthen privacy legislation for youths following his 1998 law, the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act. With every effort, industry lobbying groups have denounced the bills as harmful to innovation. Many Republican lawmakers have opposed the proposals, saying they don’t balance the needs of businesses. “Big Tech sees data as dollar signs, so for decades they’ve bankrolled industry lobbyists to help them evade accountability,” Mr. Markey said. “We’ve reached a breaking point.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Negative › **I/L** › AT Winners Win: PC Finite – Time to Regenerate
Silber 07 [PhD Political Science & Communication – focus on the Rhetoric of Presidential Policy-Making – Prof of Poli Sci – Samford, [Marissa, What Makes a President Quack? Prepared for delivery at the 2007 Annual Meeting of the American Political Science Association, August 30th-September 2nd, 2007, Understanding Lame Duck Status Through the Eyes of the Media and Politicians]
Important to the discussion of political capital is whether or not it can be replenished over a term. If a President expends political capital on his agenda, can it be replaced? Light suggests that “capital declines over time – public approval consistently falls: midterm losses occur” (31). Capital can be rebuilt, but only to a limited extent. The decline of capital makes it difficult to access information, recruit more expertise and maintain energy. If a lame duck President can be defined by a loss of political capital, this paper helps determine if such capital can be replenished or if a lame duck can accomplish little. Before determining this, a definition of a lame duck President must be developed.