Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Considerably---2AC

“Substantially” means “considerably.”

O’Connor ’2 [Sandra Day; January 8; Justice on the Supreme Court; Westlaw, “Toyota Motor Mfg., Kentucky, Inc. v. Williams,” 534 U.S. 184]

Our consideration of this issue is guided first and foremost by the words of the disability definition itself. “[S]ubstantially” in the phrase “substantially limits” suggests “considerable” or “to a large degree.” See Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1976) (defining “substantially” as “in a substantial manner” and “substantial” as “considerable in amount, value, or worth” and “being that specified to a large degree or in the main”); see also 17 Oxford English Dictionary 66–67 (2d ed.1989) (“substantial”: “[r]elating to *197 or proceeding from the essence of a thing; essential”; “[o]f ample or considerable amount, quantity, or dimensions”). The word “substantial” thus clearly precludes impairments that interfere in only a minor way with the performance of manual tasks from qualifying as disabilities. Cf. Albertson's, Inc. v. Kirkingburg, 527 U.S., at 565, 119 S.Ct. 2162 (explaining that a “mere difference” does not amount to a “significant restric[tion]” and therefore does not satisfy the EEOC's interpretation of “substantially limits”).

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Certain---2NC

Same card mostly, but from a policy debate textbook.

Edwards ’8 [Richard; 2008; Professor of Communication Studies at Baylor University, Ph.D. in Communication Studies from the University of Iowa; Competitive Debate: The Official Guide, “Policy Debate Final Round,” p. 227]

And, “substantial” means the increase must be definite. Potential future increases are not topical. Words and Phrases, 1964, accessed online: “Substantial means not concealed, denoting that which not merely can be, but is supposed to be, potential, certain, absolute, real at the present time.”

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Certain---2NC

Same card, but from Words and Phrases.

Words and Phrases ’4 [Words and Phrases; 1904; Collected, Edited, and Compiled by the Members of the Editorial Staff of the National Reporter System; Judicial and Statutory Definitions of Words and Phrases, “Outward,” vol. 7, p. 5124]

The words “outward,” "open,” “actual,” “visible,” “substantial,” and “exclusive,” in connection with a change of possession, mean substantially the same thing. They mean not concealed, not hidden, exposed to view; free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve, or disguise; in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is opposed to potential, apparent, constructive, and imaginary; veritable, genuine, certain, absolute, real at present time, as a matter of fact not merely nominal, opposed to form, actually existing, true; not including, admitting, or pertaining to any others; undivided, sole, opposed to inclusive. Base v. Pease, 79 III App. 308, 318.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Certain---1NC

“Substantially” is certain.

Shepard ’98 [Justice Shepard on the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District; March 1, 1898; Westlaw, “Bass v. Pease,” 79 Ill. App. 308]

“Outward,” “open,” “actual,” “visible,” “substantial” and “exclusive” mean, in the connection that they are employed in the cases referred to, substantially the same thing. They mean “not concealed,” “not hidden, exposed to view,” “free from concealment, dissimulation, reserve or disguise;” “in full existence; denoting that which not merely can be, but is, opposed to potential, apparent, constructive and imaginary;” “veritable, genuine, certain, absolute;” “real, at present time, as a matter of fact;” “not merely nominal, opposed to form,” ““actually existing, true;” “not including, admitting or pertaining to any others; undivided, sole;” “opposed to inclusive.” Anderson's Law Dictionary and The Century Dictionary, under appropriate headings.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not All/AT: Subsets---1AR

“Substantially” does not mean wholly.

Zoss ’98 [Paul; November 16; Magistrate Judge on the United States District Court for the Northern District of Iowa; Lexis, “Bailey v. United States,” 39 F. Supp. 2d 1132, 1138]

To do this, the court will need a working definition of the terms "substantial" and "substantially." Courts have given these terms widely different meanings, depending on the context. See Victor v. Nebraska, 511 U.S. 1, 19, 114 S. Ct. 1239, 1250, 127 L. Ed. 2d 583 (1994) ("substantial" means either "not seeming or imaginary" or "that specified to a large degree" in the context of a reasonable doubt instruction, citing Webster's Third New International Dictionary 2280 (1981)); Kluener v. Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 154 F.3d 630, 637 (6th Cir. 1998) ("substantial" means something less than a preponderance, but more than a mere reasonable basis, citing 26 C.F.R. P1.6662-4(d)(3) (1997)); Id., at 639 ("substantial" means "considerable" or "ample"); Canyon Air Tour Coalition v. Federal Aviation Administration, 332 U.S. App. D.C. 133, 154 F.3d 455, 474 (D.C. Cir. 1998) ("substantial" may well be defined as meaning "more than half," "being that specified to a large degree or in the main," "not seeming or imaginary," "considerable in amount"); York Products, Inc. v. Central Tractor Farm & Family Center, 99 F.3d 1568, 1572-73 (Fed. Cir. 1996) ("substantially" means "considerable in . . . extent," citing American Heritage Dictionary Second College Edition 1213 (2d ed. 1982) or "largely but not wholly that which is specified," citing Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary 1176 (9th ed. 1983)); Koch v. United States, 47 F.3d 1015, 1021 (10th Cir. 1995) ("substantially" means "justified in substance or in the main -- that is, justified to a degree that could satisfy a reasonable person." (citations omitted)); Laitram Machinery, Inc. v. Carnitech, 884 F. Supp. 1074, 1085 (E.D.La. 1995) (definition of "substantially" in a patent case is a jury question); C.E. Equipment Co., Inc. v. United States, 17 Cl. Ct. 293, 299 (1989) ("substantially" means "less than totally"); Darlington v. Studebaker-Packard Corporation, 191 F. Supp. 438, 439 (N.D. Ind 1961) ("The word 'substantially' is a relative term and should be interpreted in accordance with context of claim in which it is used."). At trial, the court will expect the parties to propose appropriate definitions for these terms for the court to use in deciding this case.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not All/AT: Subsets---1AR

“Substantially” means greatly, NOT entirely.

Burke ’12 [Christopher; April 27; United States Magistrate Judge; Westlaw, “Virgin Atl. Airways Ltd. v. Delta Airlines, Inc.,” No. CIV.A. 11-61-LPS-CJB, WL 1636147]

The Court agrees, and finds that such a result would be at odds with the established law. See, e.g., Circle R, Inc. v. Trail King Indus., Inc., 21 F. App'x 894, 898 (Fed.Cir.2001) (reversing a district court decision that construed the phrase “substantially flat” to mean “entirely flat”); York Prods., Inc. v. Cent. Tractor Farm & Family Ctr., 99 F.3d 1568, 1572–73 (Fed.Cir.1996) (construing “substantially the entire height” as “nearly the entire height”). The adverb “substantially” is typically defined to mean “to a great or significant extent,” or “for the most part; essentially.”4 The adjective “flat” is typically defined to mean “smooth and even; without marked lumps to indentations” or “having a broad level surface.”5 These ordinary definitions are generally consistent with the patent specification discussed at length above, which depicts and describes seat-to-bed systems with constituent surfaces that are close to, though not entirely, flat. (See ′861 patent, col. 9–10; col. 13 (describing multiple embodiments with “substantially flat” passenger-bearing surfaces that are composed of “substantially coplanar[ ] and contiguous” surfaces)6 As such, although the patent specification and claims lead to the inescapable conclusion that the claimed “substantially flat bed” must consist of surfaces that are flat to a great extent, those surfaces need not be precisely so. (See, e.g., id., col. 33:12–17; 36:32–33; 43:7–8; 46:54–56).

Footnote 4 begins:

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially › Substantially---Not All/AT: Subsets---2AC

“Substantially” includes subsets and can be either quantitative or qualitative.

Sotomayor ’17 [Sonya; February 22; Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States, J.D. from Yale University, A.B. in History from Princeton University; Justia, “Life Technologies Corp. v. Promega Corp., 580 U.S. ___ (2017),” ]

The threshold determination to be made is whether §271(f)(2)’s requirement of “a substantial portion” of the components of a patented invention refers to a quantitative or qualitative measurement. Life Technologies and the United States argue that the text of §271(f)(1) establishes a quantitative threshold, and that the threshold must be greater than one. Promega defends the Federal Circuit’s reading of the statute, arguing that a “substantial portion” of the components includes a single component if that component is sufficiently important to the invention.

We look first to the text of the statute. Sebelius v. Cloer, 569 U. S. ___, ___ (2013) (slip op., at 6). The Patent Act itself does not define the term “substantial,” and so we turn to its ordinary meaning. Ibid. Here we find little help. All agree the term is ambiguous and, taken in isolation, might refer to an important portion or to a large portion. Brief for Petitioners 16; Brief for Respondent 18; Brief for United States as Amicus Curiae 12. “Substantial,” as it is commonly understood, may refer either to qualitative importance or to quantitatively large size. See, e.g., Webster’s Third New International Dictionary 2280 (defs. 1c, 2c) (1981) (Webster’s Third) (“important, essential,” or “considerable in amount, value, or worth”); 17 Oxford English Dictionary 67 (defs. 5a, 9) (2d ed. 1989) (OED) (“That is, constitutes, or involves an essential part, point, or feature; essential, material,” or “Of ample or considerable amount, quantity, or dimensions”).

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially Increase › Substantially Increase---Considerably---1AR

“Substantially increase” means making considerably greater.

Beckering ’19 [Jane N; March 28; Court of Appeals Judge in the State of Michigan; Westlaw, “People v. Guthrie,” No. 341269, 2019 WL 1411111]

The Hardy Court addressed what is required to establish that a defendant engaged in conduct “designed to substantially increase the fear and anxiety a victim suffered during the offense,” reasoning as follows:

The phrase begins with the words “conduct designed.” “Designed” means “to intend for a definite purpose.” Thus, the word “designed” requires courts to evaluate the intent motivating the defendant's conduct. Next, we come to the words “substantially increase.” “Substantial” means “of ample or considerable amount, quantity, size, etc.” To “increase” means “to make greater, as in number, size, strength, or quality; augment.” Applying these definitions to the relevant text, we conclude that it is proper to assess points under OV 7 for conduct that was intended to make a victim's fear or anxiety greater by a considerable amount. [Hardy, 494 Mich. at 440-441, 835 N.W.2d 340.]

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Substantially Increase › Substantially Increase---Considerably---2AC

“Substantially increase” means make considerably greater.

Viviano ’13 [David; July 29; Justice for the Supreme Court of Michigan; Lexis, “People v. Hardy,” 494 Mich. 430]

The phrase begins with the words "conduct designed." HN8 "Designed" means "to intend for a definite purpose."25 Thus, the word "designed" requires courts to evaluate the intent motivating the defendant's conduct.26 Next, we come to the words "substantially increase." "Substantial" means "of ample or considerable amount, quantity, size, etc."27 To "increase" means "to make greater, as in number, size, strength, or quality; augment."28 Applying these definitions to the relevant text, we conclude that HN9 it is proper to assess points under OV 7 for conduct that was intended to make a victim's fear or anxiety greater by a considerable amount.29

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---AT: Immediate---2AC

“Should” refers to the future.

Brown ’8 [Mary Ann Brown; May 14; Judge on the Court of Appeals of Iowa; Westlaw, “In re Est. of Guthrie,” 752 N.W.2d 452]

Brock and Kaitlyn look to the word “should” in the phrase “in the event any of my children should predecease me” and claim the district court improperly found the word looked to the future. They claim the word should be interpreted as the past tense of “shall” to imply a duty or obligation. See Black's Law Dictionary 1379 (6th ed.1990). Looking at the phrase as a whole, however, rather than at a single word, we determine the phrase is considering possible future events. See In re Estate of Grulke, 546 N.W.2d 626, 627 (Iowa Ct.App.1996) (noting we must ascertain a testator's intent from the entire will).

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---Immediate---1NC

“Should” is immediate.

Summers ’94 [Edward; November 8; Justice of the Oklahoma Supreme Court; Oklahoma State Courts Network, “Kelsey v. Dollarsaver Food Warehouse of Durant,” ]

4 The legal question to be resolved by the court is whether the word "should" in the May 18 order connotes futurity or may be deemed a ruling in praesenti.14 The answer to this query is not to be divined from rules of grammar;15 it must be governed by the age-old practice culture of legal professionals and its immemorial language usage. To determine if the omission (from the critical May 18 entry) of the turgid phrase, "and the same hereby is", 1 -- makes it an in futuro ruling - i.e., an expression of what the judge will or would do at a later stage - or 2 -- constitutes an in in praesenti resolution of a disputed law issue, the trial judge's intent must be garnered from the four corners of the entire record.16

Footnote 13:

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---AT: Certain---1AR

“Should” is not certain.

White ’26 [Warren L; January 8; Judge on the Springfield Court of Appeals of Missouri; Westlaw, “Hubbard v. Turner Department Store Co.,” 220 Mo.App. 95]

3 The verb “should” has various shades of meaning. In its ordinary meaning it does not express certainty as the word “will” sometimes does. In the telegram under consideration it seems to be used in the sense that, from the anticipated profits, plaintiff might receive a bonus of $25 to $50 per month. It is nothing more than an expression of opinion, with no definite assurance that such would be the result. The expression, “twenty–five to fifty dollars per month extra,” adds nothing to the certainty or definiteness of the proposal but is merely suggestive. The whole expression, “a part of profits that should mean from twenty–five to fifty dollars per month extra, to our minds cannot possibly be construed as guaranty or an unconditional promise to pay a minimum of $25 per month or a maximum of $50 per month out of the profits, in addition to the agreed salary. It is merely suggestive. Moreover, no method is provided for determining what the share of plaintiff in the profits might be; no per cent. is named. Whether net or gross profits or whether profits from the whole store or only the furniture department, were to be the basis of settlement, is all left to conjecture. There is no stipulation as to when settlements were to be made, which, obviously, might be either weekly, monthly, annually, or whenever the employment should cease. The expression in the telegram, “if you want to come and work hard, we will take care of you in good shape,” avails plaintiff nothing from the standpoint of law. The whole telegram is one well calculated to mislead, whether deliberate or not. Morally, defendant was under some obligation to increase plaintiff's salary in the event the concern prospered and plaintiff worked hard; but, legally, we are confronted with an insurmountable obstacle in so far as affording relief to plaintiff is concerned. It is an elemental and fundamental rule of law that a contract, to be valid, “must be certain and unequivocal in its essential terms, either within itself or by reference to some other agreement or matter.” 6 R. C. L. 644; 9 Cyc. 245; 18 R. C. L. 494; Burks v. Stam, 65 Mo. App. 455; Blaine v. Knapp & Co., 140 Mo. 241, 41 S. W. 787; United Press v. New York Press Co., 164 N. Y. 406, 58 N. E. 527, 53 L. R. A. 288; Varney v. Ditmars, 217 N. Y. 223, 111 N. E. 822, Ann. Cas. 1916B, 758.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---AT: Certain---2AC

“Should” is advisory, not certain. It also equals “ought.”

Richman ’16 [James; August 17; Judge on the Second Circuit, California’s Court of Appeals; Westlaw, “Marin Assn. of Pub. Emps. v. Marin Cty. Employees' Ret. Assn.,” 2 Cal. App. 5th 674]

There is, of course, no bar to the Supreme Court adopting a Court of Appeal's reasoning as its own. Yet there is legitimate reason to question whether that was what the Supreme Court intended in 1983. First, as just shown, only the least authoritative of the three sources cited **385 actually supports the word “must,” while the two Supreme Court decisions employ “should.” Second, barely a month later, the Supreme Court—speaking though the same justice—filed another decision which used the “should” formulation from the 1955 Allen decision as quoted in Abbott.20 Third, the 1983 Allen decision involved retirees (and Flournoy the widow of a retiree), who historically receive a heightened degree of judicial protection. (See fn. 19, ante.) Fourth, and most significantly, the “must” formulation has never been reiterated by the Supreme Court, which has instead uniformly employed the “should” *699 language from the 1955 Allen decision. (Olson v. Cory, supra, 27 Cal.3d 532, 541, 178 Cal.Rptr. 568, 636 P.2d 532 [“Although an employee does not obtain any ‘absolute right to fixed or specific benefits ... there [are] strict limitation[s] on the conditions which may modify the pension system in effect during employment.’ [Citation.] Such modifications must be reasonable and any ‘ “changes in a pension plan which result in disadvantage to employees should be accompanied by comparable new advantages” ’ ”]; Legislature v. Eu (1991) 54 Cal.3d 492, 529–530, 286 Cal.Rptr. 283, 816 P.2d 1309 [quoting Olson]; City of Huntington Beach v. Board of Administration (1992) 4 Cal.4th 462, 472, 14 Cal.Rptr.2d 514, 841 P.2d 1034 [“changes in a pension plan which result in disadvantage to employees should be accompanied by comparable new advantages,” citing Allen v. City of Long Beach, supra, 45 Cal.2d 128, 131, 287 P.2d 765].)

It thus appears unlikely that the Supreme Court's use of “must” in the 1983 Allen decision was intended to herald a fundamental doctrinal shift. “Should,” not “must,” remains the court's preferred expression. And “should” does not convey imperative obligation, no more compulsion than “ought.” (Lashley v. Koerber (1945) 26 Cal.2d 83, 90, 156 P.2d 441; see People v. Webb (1986) 186 Cal.App.3d 401, 409, fn. 2, 230 Cal.Rptr. 755 [“the word ‘should’ is advisory only and not mandatory”].) In plain effect, “should” is “a recommendation, not ... a mandate.” (Cuevas v. Superior Court (1976) 58 Cal.App.3d 406, 409, 130 Cal.Rptr. 238.)

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---Certain---2NC

“Should” means “must.”

Stroud ’2k [John F Jr; July 7; Judge on the Court of Appeals of Arkansas; Westlaw, “Guest v. San Pedro,” 70 Ark. App. 389]

The interpretation of this section, which appears to be a question of first impression, turns upon the meaning of the word “should” in the phrase “[a]ny partial abatement or reduction of child support should not exceed 50% of the child-support obligation during the extended visitation period.” In Little v. State, 261 Ark. 859, 554 S.W.2d 312 (1977), the supreme court ruled that the trial court, giving an instruction on circumstantial evidence, had not misled the jury by using the word “should” instead of “must” in stating that circumstances should point to and be consistent with guilt but should be inconsistent with any other reasonable hypothesis. The Little court opined that use of the word “must” would have been preferable to the use of “should,” but the court noted that the *396 words are often synonymous. 261 Ark. at 884, 554 S.W.2d at 324, citing Rodale, The Synonym Finder 780 (Special Deluxe Ed.).

Similarly, we hold that the word “should” is equivalent to the word “must” as used in the phrase “any partial abatement or reduction of child support should not exceed 50% of the child-support obligation during the extended visitation period.” We hold that the 50% limitation in Administrative Order No. 10 is mandatory: abatement or reduction of child support during an extended visitation period cannot exceed 50% of the child-support obligation during the extended visitation period.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---Certain---2NC

“Should” is obligatory, NOT advisory.

Riddle ’14 [Finis E; December 22; Justice on the Supreme Court of Oklahoma; Westlaw, “St. Louis & S. F. R. Co. v. Brown,” 45 Okla. 143]

The specific grounds of objection are that the court should have used the word “shall” instead of “should,” that the word “should” is merely advisory, and that the jury was left at its discretion in the matter of reduction of the damages. It has been said that the word “should” is the past tense of the word “shall,” and we think, in the connection in which it was used, the jury understood that it meant more than simply advisory.

In the case of Smith v. State, 142 Ind. 288, 41 N. E. 595, the Supreme Court of Indiana held that it was more imperative than the word “may.”

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › Should › Should---Certain---1NC

“Should” is mandatory.

Keller ’32 [W.H.; July 14; Judge on the Superior Court of Pennsylvania; Westlaw, “Foresi v. Hudson Coal Co.,” 106 Pa.Super. 307]

As regards the mandatory character of the rule, the word “should” is not only an auxiliary verb, it is also the preterite of the verb, “shall,” and has for one of its meanings, as defined in the Century Dictionary: “Obliged or compelled (to); would have (to); must; ought (to); used with an infinitive (without to) to express obligation, necessity or duty in connection with some act yet to be carried out.” We think it clear that it is in that sense that the word “should” is used in this rule, not merely advisory. When the judge in charging a jury tells them that, unless they find from all the evidence, beyond a reasonable doubt, that the defendant is guilty of the offense charged, they should acquit, the word “should” is not used in an advisory sense, but has the force or meaning of “must,” or “ought to,” and carries with it the sense of *313 obligation and duty equivalent to compulsion. A natural sense of sympathy for a few unfortunate claimants who have been injured while doing something in direct violation of law must not be so indulged as to fritter away, or nullify, provisions which have been enacted to safeguard and protect the welfare of thousands who are engaged in the hazardous occupation of mining.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › The United States Federal Government › USFG---the Three Branches/Not States---2NC

“Federal government” is national.

Thompson ’21 [Thompson School District; 2021; Public school district for Loveland, Colorado and surrounding area; Thompson Schools, “Structures of Government,” ]

Australia, Switzerland, Canada, Mexico, Germany, India, and some 20 other stats also have federal forms of government today. In the United States, the term ‘Federal Government’ is often used to refer to the National Government, but note that the 50 state governments are unitary in structure, not federal.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › The United States Federal Government › USFG---the Three Branches/Not States---1NC

The “United States federal government” precludes the states.

U.S. Legal ’16 [U.S. Legal; 2016; Organization offering legal assistance and attorney access; U.S. Legal, “United States Federal Government Law and Legal Definition,” ]

The United States Federal Government is established by the US Constitution. The Federal Government shares sovereignty over the United Sates with the individual governments of the States of US. The Federal government has three branches: i) the legislature, which is the US Congress, ii) Executive, comprised of the President and Vice president of the US and iii) Judiciary. The US Constitution prescribes a system of separation of powers and ‘checks and balances’ for the smooth functioning of all the three branches of the Federal Government. The US Constitution limits the powers of the Federal Government to the powers assigned to it; all powers not expressly assigned to the Federal Government are reserved to the States or to the people.

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › The United States Federal Government › USFG---Not Singular Whole---1AR

“The” means a member of its class.

Webster ’7 [Merriam Webster online dictionary; carbon dated 2007; “the,”

b—used as a function word to indicate that a following noun or noun equivalent is a unique or a particular member of its class

2022 Michigan Topicality
Topicality---Starter Pack 2022 › The United States Federal Government › USFG---Not Singular Whole---2AC

“The United States federal government” does not necessitate whole-of-government action.

Chicago ’13 [Chicago Manual of Style; carbon dated June 23, 2013; Questions and Answers, “Headlines and Titles of Works?” https://www.chicagomanualofstyle.org/qanda/data/faq/topics/CapitalizationTitles/faq0015.html]

A. The government of the United States is not a single official entity. Nor is it when it is referred to as the federal government or the U.S. government or the U.S. federal government. It’s just a government, which, like those in all countries, has some official bodies that act and operate in the name of government: the Congress, the Senate, the Department of State, etc.