Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: Accession Thumper

Turkey won’t change their mind

Hacaoglu, 22 – Bloomberg News

[Selcan Hacaoglu, and Natalia Drozdiak, "Turkey Says Position on NATO Won’t Change in Blow to June Summit," Bloomberg, 6-15-2022, https://www.yahoo.com/video/turkey-says-position-nato-won-134859990.html, accessed 6-19-2022]

Turkey Says Position on NATO Won’t Change in Blow to June Summit

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: Accession Thumper

Turkey collapsing NATO unity

Erlanger, 22 -- NY Times chief diplomatic correspondent in Europe

[Steven Erlanger and Matina Stevis-Gridneff, "Strongmen in Turkey and Hungary Stall Unity in NATO and the E.U.," NY Times, 5-18-2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/18/world/europe/sweden-finland-nato-turkey-oil.html, accessed 6-19-2022]

Strongmen in Turkey and Hungary Stall Unity in NATO and the E.U.

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: Accession Thumper

Turkey is disrupting NATO unity

Crowley, 22 -- NY Times Washington Bureau diplomatic correspondent

[Michael Crowley and Steven Erlanger, "For NATO, Turkey Is a Disruptive Ally," NY Times, 5-30-2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/30/us/politics/turkey-nato-russia.html, accessed 6-19-2022]

For NATO, Turkey Is a Disruptive Ally

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: No NATO Unity

NATO unity crumbling

Murray, 22 – The Telegraph

[Douglas Murray, "Nato’s united front is crumbling now that Putin has been humiliated in Ukraine," Telegraph, 5-23-2022, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/opinion/2022/05/23/natos-united-front-crumbling-now-putin-has-humiliated-ukraine/, accessed 6-19-2022]

Nato’s united front is crumbling now that Putin has been humiliated in Ukraine

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: No NATO Unity

Domestic backlash ensures fraying unity the longer the war goes on

Ellyatt, 22 -- CNBC international correspondent in London

[Holly Ellyatt, “The West’s unity over Ukraine could be starting to crack, just as Russia’s invasion gains ground,” CNBC, 6-16-2022, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/16/us-europe-unity-over-ukraine-is-starting-to-crack-amid-russia-onslaught.html, accessed 6-19-2022]

The West’s unity over Ukraine could be starting to crack, just as Russia’s invasion gains ground

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: No NATO Unity

Post-Ukraine unity is collapsing

Ramesh, 22 -- News9 Staff

[KV, "European unity starts fraying as Ukraine War stretches past 90 days," NewsNine, 5-27-2022, https://www.news9live.com/opinion-blogs/european-unity-starts-fraying-as-ukraine-war-stretches-past-90-days-172746, accessed 6-19-2022]

European unity starts fraying as Ukraine War stretches past 90 days

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 1AR › 1AR: ET Thumper

Emerging tech co-op high now

Harper, 22 -- Managing Editor of DefenseScoop

[Jon Harper, "Emerging tech to have prominent role in NATO's new strategic concept," FedScoop, 6-1-2022, https://www.fedscoop.com/emerging-tech-to-have-prominent-role-in-natos-new-strategic-concept%EF%BF%BC/, accessed 6-4-2022]

Emerging tech to have prominent role in NATO’s new strategic concept

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 2AC › 2AC: No Taiwan War

No China-Taiwan war

Scobell and Stevenson-Yang, 3-4

[BY: Andrew Scobell, Ph.D.; Lucy Stevenson-Yang, United States Institute of Peace, March 4, 2022, “China Is Not Russia. Taiwan Is Not Ukraine.” , accessed 4-2-2022]

China Is Not Russia Russia under Putin has repeatedly dispatched its armed forces for combat missions overseas to a range of countries, including Georgia, Syria and Ukraine, as well as conducted major military interventions against other states, most recently Kazakhstan (albeit at the invitation of that country’s president). Moscow has also actively supported armed groups and militias in some of these same countries and others. Although China has also been active and assertive in the use of its armed forces beyond its borders in recent years, Beijing has eschewed large-scale combat operations. Around its periphery, China has engaged in provocations, confrontations and even violent clashes. But China, unlike Russia, has refrained from massive interventions, invasions or occupations of other countries since it invaded Vietnam in 1979. China’s largest deployments of troops overseas in the post-Cold War era have been on U.N. Peacekeeping missions. Whereas Russia has more than 20 military installations beyond its borders, to date, China has only one official military base on foreign soil — in Djibouti (established in 2017) — and a handful of other facilities it does not formally acknowledge. Of course, Beijing has a history of using its potent armed forces and muscular coercive apparatus within China’s borders to repress vigorously peaceful protesters, political dissidents and disaffected ethnic minority peoples. The locations of these operations include Beijing, Tibet and Xinjiang, as well as Hong Kong. China has also not hesitated to employ armed force and a wide array of coercive instruments around its periphery. This includes building roads and bunkers in remote frontier areas of the high Himalayas along its contested border with India and constructing artificial islands and military installations in disputed waters of the South China Sea. In recent years, China’s armed forces have also engaged in deadly clashes and violent confrontations with Indian army units along the disputed Line of Actual Control and harassed and rammed the fishing boats and coast guard vessels of Vietnam, the Philippines and other countries. Putin appears to relish projecting the image of a strongman who is routinely willing to thumb his nose at the rest of the world. By contrast, Xi — at least to date — has mainly sought to cultivate a statesmanlike image on the global stage. At times he has given speeches attempting to cast China as a more responsible, less meddlesome and values-free version of the United States. And Xi has invested a lot of time and resources in promoting a set of high-profile international efforts intended to demonstrate that China is a constructive and proactive great power. Employing positive rhetoric touting “win-win” solutions and aspirations to build a “community with a shared future for mankind,” China under Xi’s leadership has launched ambitious efforts such as the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank. Putin, by contrast, has made no real effort to offer an alternative to U.S. global leadership beyond delivering vague grandiose declarations (often in tandem with Xi) and has offered the world little in the way of economic stimulus beyond the prospect of more energy exports and hype about the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU). Despite consisting of only a handful of Soviet successor states, the EAEU is touted as Russia’s answer to China’s BRI. In terms of geostrategic activism, Russia’s major multilateralist initiatives have tended to involve China. These include the establishment of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization in 2001 and the formation of the BRICS grouping in 2010. The former is a security community with a Central Asian focus consisting of Russia, China and four Central and two South Asian states. The latter is a loose association of some of the world’s largest “emerging economies”: Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa. However, Moscow’s most significant geostrategic maneuver under Putin has been to strengthen Russia’s strategic partnership with China. Both Beijing and Moscow insist that their relationship is not an alliance and their 2001 treaty of friendship — which was renewed in 2021 — does not commit either signatory to come to the defense of the other in case of military conflict. Yet, the Sino-Russian relationship is a clearly consequential alignment that has grown closer in recent years, particularly as their respective relationships with the United States have deteriorated. Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has put China in a very uncomfortable position: Beijing does not want to antagonize Moscow but neither does it want to damage its relations with Washington and European capitals. Consequently, China has equivocated in its statements and actions. Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi has called for peace but has stopped short of condemning Russia or calling upon Moscow to withdraw its military. The lengthy joint statement of February 4, 2022, issued by Putin and Xi during the Russian leader’s visit to Beijing on the eve of the Winter Olympics, makes no mention at all of Ukraine — and China has pointedly abstained on all U.N. Security Council resolutions related to Russia’s invasion. Xi appears to have asked Putin to delay any military action against Ukraine until after the Olympics. Russia’s invasion poses other difficulties for China both in terms of running counter to Beijing’s long espoused principles in foreign affairs and its adverse impact on China’s national interests in Ukraine. Russia’s actions clearly contradict China’s cornerstone foreign policy principles of noninterference in other countries’ affairs and respecting territorial integrity. Moreover, China has sizable economic investments in Ukraine and is a good customer of Ukraine’s armaments industry. In 2020, Ukraine signed the BRI cooperation agreement, which further bolstered the economic relationship between the two countries and marked Ukraine as an important partner in Beijing’s signature foreign policy and economic initiative. Taiwan Is Not Ukraine The fact that Ukraine is not a member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was almost certainly a decisive factor in Putin’s calculus to invade Ukraine. Russia’s commander in chief knew that his invading forces would likely not have to contend with the militaries of any other countries. And if there were any lingering doubts in the Kremlin about the disposition of the most powerful member of NATO, U.S. President Joe Biden stated publicly that the United States would not send military forces to help defend Ukraine. Nevertheless, the Biden administration has taken strong steps to reinforce NATO allies in Eastern Europe and provide robust military assistance to Ukraine. By contrast, Xi and his Politburo colleagues have long been convinced that Taiwan has the resolute support of the world’s most capable military. The People’s Liberation Army — as all branches of China’s armed forces are known — continues to assume that if it launches an invasion of Taiwan, the U.S. military will swiftly and decisively intervene. The U.S.-Taiwan relationship, while technically “unofficial” due to the One China policy, has strengthened in recent years. On February 28, the Biden administration sent an unofficial delegation of former U.S. defense and national security officials to Taiwan as a signal to China of that commitment. It remains true that the greatest deterrence to a massive Chinese military attack on the island is Beijing’s assumption that war with Taiwan also means a war with the United States. However, there is no formal military alliance between the United States and Taiwan. The defense pact binding Washington to Taipei was formally abrogated in 1979. So why is Beijing convinced that Washington has an ironclad alliance-like relationship with Taiwan? There are at least two reasons. First, successive U.S. administrations have publicly committed themselves to support Taiwan against Chinese aggression and have regularly sold arms to the island’s armed forces. Second, although there is no language in the1979 Taiwan Relations Act (TRA) that explicitly commits the United States to come to Taiwan’s defense in the event of an attack on the island by China, many in Washington believe that such a commitment exists. While there are different interpretations as to what the TRA means, the most significant fact is that the vast majority of U.S. political and military leaders are fully convinced that this legislation binds the United States to a de facto alliance with Taiwan. China’s increased military assertiveness and greater level of armed provocations in the Taiwan Strait and elsewhere around China’s periphery in recent years have only served to strengthen the conviction in Washington that the island is a staunch democratic partner worthy of U.S. support as it tries to defend tiny Taiwan against efforts by Beijing to coerce the island into unwanted unification with China. However, Taiwan, unlike Ukraine, is not a member of the United Nation. While Ukraine has ambassador-level diplomatic relations with more than 180 countries, including China and the United States, Taiwan only has full diplomatic ties with approximately a dozen countries and none of these are major powers. Yet, thanks to the TRA, Taipei enjoys robust quasi-diplomatic relations with Washington, and thanks to Taiwan’s pragmatic ingenuity, the island possesses a vibrant worldwide network of de facto diplomatic missions. Although Ukraine’s diplomatic standing is far superior to Taiwan’s, the European country’s military alliance status is less impressive — Ukraine is not a member of NATO, although it is a very active member of NATO’s Partnership for Peace initiative. While Taiwan also has no formal military allies, the island has several close and consequential security partners, most notably the United States. China Is China and Taiwan Is Taiwan Taiwan continues to be the most contentious issue in U.S.-China relations. Moreover, the Taiwan Strait is routinely identified as the most plausible location of a military confrontation between the United States and China. For Xi and his Politburo colleagues, Taiwan looms large and is prominently identified as a “core” national interest of China’s, with Xi reiterating in 2021 that “resolving the Taiwan question and realizing China’s complete reunification is a historic mission and an unshakable commitment of the Communist Party of China” and that “no one should underestimate the resolve, the will, and the ability of the Chinese people to defend their national sovereignty and territorial integrity.” Moreover, most Chinese citizens consider Taiwan to be Chinese territory and view the island as something worth fighting for. Indeed, the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) has staked its political legitimacy on the ultimate goal of unifying Taiwan with China and in the meantime is working resolutely to prevent the island from becoming de jureindependent. Beijing’s preferred means of realizing unification or preventing independence is peaceful but the CCP has never renounced the use of armed force. Furthermore, the PLA’s central warfighting scenario is Taiwan and China’s military has been focused on planning and preparing for an operation against the island for decades. A Cautionary Tale? The above differences notwithstanding, Russia’s combat experience in Ukraine will have a spillover impact on how China thinks about Taiwan. If the Russian armed forces remain bogged down in a stalemate in Ukraine for an extended period and/or face a prolonged and widespread insurgency, this may give Xi and his fellow Politburo members pause. If Russia’s military experiences major setbacks and perhaps even embarrassing defeats, this may make China’s political leaders think twice about the advisability of an invasion of Taiwan. After all, an invasion of Ukraine is relatively straightforward — the country is geographically contiguous to Russia, sharing an extended land border with mostly gentle terrain. By contrast, an invasion of the island of Taiwan is a far more complex operation — a successful campaign requires careful planning and coordinated execution between air, naval and ground forces. It would also involve amphibious landings in addition to considerable urban warfare — on an even larger scale than in Ukraine — including operations on rugged mountainous terrain. Certainly, the PLA will carefully study Russia’s Ukrainian campaign and draw lessons from it, much as they have studied campaigns of other major powers. Such analyses are conducted with great seriousness because China’s armed forces themselves have not fought a major war since 1979 (when Chinese forces invaded Vietnam) and have not conducted a major island landing campaign since 1950 (against Hainan Island). One way that China’s leadership might be taking notes from Russia’s Ukraine invasion is by rethinking the risks associated with escalation. In addition to noting the potential military embarrassment that Russia is facing, China might be wary of the sweeping economic sanctions levied by the international community. If China were to receive similar backlash for an invasion of Taiwan, it would raise the possibility of truly crippling sanctions at a time when the Chinese economy is experiencing anemic growth and structural challenges. In particular, the weaponization of the SWIFT payments system might give China pause. Russia has been trying to popularize a cross-border financial information transmission system, and China is committed to developing the CIPS payment network, but neither has had significant success outside Russian or Chinese borders. Despite its flaws, SWIFT remains the most efficient system for international financial transactions for banks and being removed from SWIFT could potentially be devastating to the Chinese economy. Furthermore, the lessons of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine to date are that the costs of armed aggression are high in blood and treasure, as well as strong international censure of Moscow and a resolute collective response by NATO member countries.

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 2AC › 2AC: Accession Thumper

Turkey blocking new members sabotages NATO unity

McFall, 22 -- Fox News

[Caitlin McFall, "Erdogan disrupts NATO unity amid Putin’s threat to European security," Fox News, 5-26-2022, https://www.foxnews.com/world/erdogan-disrupts-nato-unity-putins-threat-european-security, accessed 6-19-2022]

Erdogan disrupts NATO unity amid Putin’s threat to European security

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 2AC › 2AC: No NATO Unity

Post-Ukraine unity is collapsing

Lucas, 22 -- Center for European Policy Analysis nonresident fellow

[Edward Lucas, "NATO Is Out of Shape and Out of Date," Foreign Policy, 6-7-2022, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/06/07/nato-ukraine-russia-war-alliance-reform-geopolitics-military/, accessed 6-19-2022]

NATO Is Out of Shape and Out of Date

2022 SDI Disadvantage
AFF › 2AC › 2AC: ET Thumper

NATO emerging tech co-op high now

Hudson, 22 -- former managing editor of the Wall Street Journal's European edition

[Richard L., and Florin Zubascu, "Science goes to war: western allies step up collaboration in military research," Science|Business, 4-7-2022, https://sciencebusiness.net/news/science-goes-war-western-allies-step-collaboration-military-research, accessed 6-5-2022]

Science goes to war: western allies step up collaboration in military research

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Private Sector Counterplan

Private sector AI can’t lead to AI leadership—the government is critical.

Michael C. Horowitz, 2018 (Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Retrieved 6/11/2022 from )

Some might argue that it is necessary for the United States to develop and announce a formal AI strategy similar to China’s.122 While there are plenty of private-sector incentives for the development of AI technology, only the government can coordinate AI investments and ensure the development of particular implementations that it considers critical for AI leadership.123

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Non-NATO Counterplan

NATO has a unique role to play as an AI leader.

Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)

At the core, this chapter argues that NATO is well positioned to steward the development of military AI and institute governance mechanisms towards coalition inclusion of responsible AI while simultaneously maintaining incentives for comparative advantage. Using the three pillars—ethics and values, legal norms, and safety and security—as issue areas which present AI governance challenges, we show that NATO has space to emerge as a leader in AI governance and contribute to responsible adoption of EDTs in the international security environment. This builds on foundations that derive NATO’s responsibilities to govern AI according to its values, legal obligations, and institutional interests. These foundations from both STS and military innovation studies offer ways that the Alliance can activate its existing governance mechanisms to exert influence in new ways. Not only is this influence important for the Alliance to bolster its institutional relevance in an evolving international security architecture, but it also dovetails with its capacity to shore up military effectiveness and interoperability as Allies modernize their arsenals and associated concepts into the frontier of AI.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Non-NATO Counterplan

NATO is key to multinational alignment on AI policy—three reasons:

Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)

To begin to fill this gap, the analysis in this chapter centers on two AI governance mechanisms that NATO has at its disposal, and subsequently explores the Alliance’s capacity to use these mechanisms to exert its influence in key pillars of AI governance. Of the many possible AI governance mechanisms for NATO, this chapter offers a deeper assessment of two: (1) strategic and policy planning and (2) standards and certification. We fashion these mechanisms as primary components that connect NATO technology governance measures and responsible AI use.12 To illustrate NATO’s capacity to govern AI, we then examine three pillars, or foundational issue areas, which we believe represent critical elements of technology governance. We argue that, within each pillar, NATO is uniquely situated to facilitate cooperation via its governance mechanisms, with a view to shaping the future of AI for the Alliance and maintaining a competitive edge. Each pillar—(1) ethics and values, (2) legal norms, and (3) security and safety—is an area where researchers and analysts have acknowledged significant governance challenges, both at a national level and for international organizations like NATO. Each pillar, discussed in depth below, illustrates NATO’s potential as a governance stakeholder that can encourage multinational alignment on policy and standards for safer and better outcomes in future operations.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Non-NATO Counterplan

NATO standards on AI will help develop world standards on AI technology.

Amanda Miller, 12/13/2021 (staff writer, AIR FORCE MAGAZINE, “NATO’s Plan to Grow Trust in Military AI,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)

Western militaries—already “late to the party” in the creation of artificial intelligence—risk unforeseen consequences by adopting AI made for the commercial sector, said NATO’s David van Weel. That’s why the alliance is publicizing a new plan by which it hopes its governments will get involved in AI development from the start, both for security reasons and to “bridge a gap of distrust” in the technology. Though he acknowledged that sharing the plan is a bit out of character for NATO, all 30 nations, including the U.S., have signed on. “We are not known, at NATO, for publishing a lot,” said van Weel, assistant secretary general for emerging security challenges. “We try to keep secrets a lot.” Van Weel introduced NATO’s AI strategy, published in October, during an American Enterprise Institute webinar Dec. 7. The webinar “Artificial Intelligence: Can We Go From Chaos to Cooperation?” accompanied the release of AEI’s paper, “Artificial Intelligence: The Risks Posed by the Current Lack of Standards.” As a “pervasive technology,” AI will “have an impact on everything we do,” said van Weel. Setting aside “the killer robot discussion,” van Weel dismissed the notion of excluding AI from all military uses: “The idea that AI would not be used for defense purposes is like saying that the steam engine, when it was invented, could only be used for commercial purposes, or electricity would not be supplied to the military.” But being behind the private sector in AI development has left governments “in a situation where regulation comes after the broad use and misuse of technology,” van Weel said. “So we need to be early to the party and make sure that we understand new technologies, not to militarize them—no, but to understand the security and defense implications.” Van Weel said military uses of AI should be regulated, but “you don’t want to over-regulate if you don’t know that you can defend yourself within the regulations that you’re proposing.” He provided the example of drone swarms “that collectively, powered by AI, are able to follow an intrinsic pattern—for example, our water supply or one of our cities. So how do we defend against them? Well, we can’t, frankly, because you need AI in that case in order to be able to counter AI.” But even among peers, he describes skepticism. “I’ve been on panels quite a lot where people say, ‘Well, please, I don’t trust the defense use of artificial intelligence,’ and that’s something we need to address,” van Weel said. “We are a trusted user. We—NATO, all the 30 allies—we all subscribe to the democratic values. We all subscribe to the values our societies are built upon, and we’re there to protect them.” NATO’s strategy proposes six principles of responsible use of AI similar to the Defense Department’s Ethical Principles for Artificial Intelligence adopted in 2020—but with a plan to verify that the principles are followed. According to NATO’s list of attributes, military AI should be lawful; responsible and accountable; explainable and traceable; reliable; governable; and having bias mitigation. To engender confidence in the principles, NATO has also proposed a new initiative. “Principles are nice, but they need to be verifiable as well, and they need to be baked in from the moment of the first conception of an idea up until the delivery,” van Weel said. To that end, to verify new AI, NATO wants to create test centers, co-located with universities throughout the alliance. This includes “existing test centers with knowledge, where allies that are thinking about co-developing AI for use in the defense sector can come in and verify, with protocols, with certain standards that we’re setting, that this AI is actually verified,” van Weel said. “It’s not a world standard yet, but if the 30 nations, Western democracies, start out by shaping industry to adhere by these standards, then I feel that we are making an impact, at least in the development of AI and hopefully also in the larger world setting standards.”

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Non-NATO Counterplan

NATO is key to transatlantic alignment on AI issues:

CENTER FOR EUROPEAN POLICY ANALYSIS, 2/17/2021 (“NATO Leadership on Ethical AI is Key to Future Interoperability,” ., Retrieved 6/15/2022)

The transatlantic partnership must focus on coordinating these core principles and systematic governance to ensure AI systems development aligns with the rule of law and democracy. In particular, this must ensure answering questions about human dignity, human control, and accountability. NATO is the ideal defense and security forum for this alignment. Given the US lead on adopting ethical principles for the entire DoD and the EU’s drive to assert checks and balances for private-sector tech companies, NATO remains the organization that can bring these two together and establishes the ethical bottom line. These will then ensure the diverging legal and ethical stances towards Big Tech do not lead to an interoperability barrier in the future. If developments surrounding the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the challenges it brought for U.S.-based, data-driven companies are any indication, a strong transatlantic led initiative is needed in order to ensure the same challenges do not hinder NATO.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Non-NATO Counterplan

NATO is uniquely situated to create AI norms and promote standards that shape AI development in the future.

Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)

NATO’s increasing interest in EDTs introduces the need to consider how governance priorities can help reinforce the Alliance’s influence. The STS and military innovation literature provide the theoretical foundations for NATO’s stewardship of AI as they place attention on “the role that institutions play in shaping technological trajectories.”45 As AI development continues, the actions that NATO and its members take will have important implications for their capacity to adopt, respond to, and shape their future operating environment. Particularly for democracies, this confers to military stakeholders a dual responsibility to prevent and manage risks, as well as to proactively shape their approach to technological development anchored in democratic values and security. As a multinational alliance with an incentive to drive cooperation and alignment, NATO is situated to define and operationalize norms, as well as promote standards that help shape the contours of future military effectiveness and technological competition. In a RRI framework, not only is this an institutional role, but it also becomes an institutional responsibility. To apply this responsibility to NATO’s stewardship of AI, the institutional interplay between technology, structure, and concepts is a form of socio-technical system with important implications for AI governance because they link the ways that an institution uses its power to adopt and shape AI trajectory to its respective ends. Already, several mechanisms are built into military bureaucracies to ensure that technology is adopted in alignment with responsible engineering practices and responsible state behavior.46 The Alliance is organized to harmonize between Allies so that their contributions enhance military effectiveness and political cohesion between like-minded democracies. We argue that these effectiveness-centric mechanisms likewise empower NATO to exert its influence in technology governance. More specifically, this entails the Alliance helping steward technological development for a more predictable strategic environment and enhanced democratic clout around the exploitation of technology reinforcing rule of law. For NATO, we focus on strategic and policy planning, as well as standards and certification because they reflect the Alliance’s particular strengths and interests in S&T. These practices are relevant to governance insofar as they exemplify an institution’s power to shape the trajectory of technological development—but this selection is by no means exhaustive.47

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › Counterplan Answers › A2: Domestic Counterplan

Domestic counterplan can’t solve for AI—international cooperation is necessary:

DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE, 2/12/2019 (“SUMMARY OF THE 2018 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE STRATEGY,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from .)

We cannot succeed alone; this undertaking requires the skill and commitment of those in government, close collaboration with academia and non-traditional centers of innovation in the commercial sector, and strong cohesion among international allies and partners. We must learn from others to help us achieve the fullest understanding of the potential of AI, and we must lead in responsibly developing and using these powerful technologies, in accordance with the law and our values.

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › A2: Other DAs › Politics – Plan Popular – 2AC

There is growing political support for transatlantic cooperation on AI with NATO.

Christie Lawrence & Sean Cordey, 2020, (Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence,” , Retrieved 6/12/2022)

Transatlantic Cooperation: Despite over 40 years of scientific relationships and projects between the United States and the European Union, AI-specific collaboration has been fraught with varying degrees of political and academic skepticism on both side of the Atlantic, notably within the European Commission and the governments of some Member States (e.g., France and Germany).31 Such a dynamic is aggravated, in part, by the ever-deteriorating transatlantic relationship spurred by policy and trade disagreements, public spats, and increasing American isolationism. Despite such explicit omissions and stand-offs at the highest levels, transatlantic collaboration for AI does happen, most notably in various multilateral forums working on standards (e.g., ISO, IEC, IEEE, G7, G20) or on ethics and norms (e.g., OECD, GPAI32).33 In recent months, however, interests and political support for greater transatlantic coordination on AI seems to be increasing. This trend was notably demonstrated by a visit from Lt. Gen. Jack Shanahan—then Director of the US Department of Defense’s Joint Artificial Intelligence Center (JAIC)—to Brussels in January 2020 and a visit by the European Parliament’s delegation to Washington D.C in February 2020. Both visits included discussions on AI with a variety of key stakeholders, such as NATO, representatives from the US Congress, State Department, Federal Transit Administration (FTA), Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board (PCLOB).34

2022 SDI Affirmative
Offcase Answers › A2: Other DAs › Readiness DA/Ethics Bad DA – 2AC

Developing safe and secure AI is necessary for NATO to maintain AI technological superiority.

Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)

In any discussion of AI as an emerging military technology, it is necessary to strike a balance between acknowledging the transformative potential of AI in the security environment, while simultaneously recognizing the “hype” that may, thus far, be unfounded. But some conclusions are clear. The risks and opportunities of military AI can pose significant challenges for future military operations, and this necessarily means there are many stakeholders with a vested interest in developing, promoting, and implementing responsible military AI. As multinational coalitions and military operations are a foundational security policy for much of the world, this means NATO is also a stakeholder with a vital interest in promoting safe and secure technology among its partners, both traditional and non-traditional. As the international security environment continues to shift, there is space for NATO to pursue its agenda to maintain technological superiority not just to protect and defend its way of life, but also to build on its pillars of AI governance to steward military innovation on a responsible trajectory.