2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Add-Ons › NATO Add-On – Plan Bolsters NATO
Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)
One vital and unique contribution for NATO is facilitating legal interoperability among the Allies to resolve some of the most pressing legal barriers for AI implementation in future Allied operations. Legal interoperability, a subset of larger coalition interoperability, refers to the operational coordination around partner legal obligations and interpretations.75 It ensures “that within a military alliance, military operations can be conducted effectively consistent with the legal obligations of each nation.”76 Legal interoperability is a critical component of multilateral operations that has thus far been under-examined, despite its centrality to successful military operations. This is largely because “legal factors have a bearing on everything in alliances and coalition operations—from determining basic ‘troop-to-task’ considerations to decisions regarding the targets to be engaged—and the types of ordinances that may be used.”77
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Add-Ons › NATO Add-On – 2AC
Beauchamp ’18 (Zack Beauchamp, senior reporter at Vox, where he covers global politics and ideology, and a host of Worldly, Vox's podcast on covering foreign policy and international relations, “How Trump is killing America’s alliances”, Vox, , 2018)
How the weakening of American alliances could lead to a massive war. There has never, in human history, been an era as peaceful as our own. This is a hard truth to appreciate, given the horrible violence ongoing in places like Syria, Yemen, and Myanmar, yet the evidence is quite clear. Take a look at this chart from the University of Oxford’s Max Roser. It tracks the number of years in a given time period in which “great powers” — meaning the militarily and economically powerful countries at that time — were at war with each other over the course of the past 500 years. The decline is unmistakable: [[TABLE OMITTED]] This data should give you some appreciation for how unique, and potentially precarious, our historical moment is. For more than 200 years, from 1500 to about 1750, major European powers like Britain and France and Spain were warring constantly. The frequency of conflict declined in the 19th and 20th centuries, but the wars that did break out — the Napoleonic conflicts, both world wars — were particularly devastating. The past 70 years without great power war, a period scholars term “the Long Peace,” is one of history’s most wonderful anomalies. The question then becomes: Why did it happen? And could Trump mucking around with a pillar of the global order, American alliances, put it in jeopardy? The answer to the second question, ominously, appears to be yes. There is significant evidence that strong American alliances — most notably the NATO alliance and US agreements to defend Japan and South Korea — have been instrumental in putting an end to great power war. “As this alliance system spreads and expands, it correlates with this dramatic decline, this unprecedented drop, in warfare,” says Michael Beckley, a professor of international relations at Tufts University. “It’s a really, really strong correlation.” A 2010 study by Rice’s Leeds and the University of Kentucky’s Jesse C. Johnson surveyed a large data set on alliances between 1816 and 2000. They found that countries in defensive alliances were 20 percent less likely to be involved in a conflict, on average, than countries that weren’t. This holds true even after you control for other factors that would affect the likelihood of war, like whether a country is a democracy or whether it has an ongoing dispute with a powerful neighbor. In a follow-up paper, Leeds and Johnson looked at the same data set to see whether certain kinds of alliances were more effective at protecting its members than others. Their conclusion is that alliances deter war best when their members are militarily powerful and when enemies take seriously the allies’ promise to fight together in the event of an attack. The core US alliances — NATO, Japan, and South Korea — fit these descriptors neatly. A third study finds evidence that alliances allow allies to restrain each other from going to war. Let’s say Canada wants to get involved in a conflict somewhere. Typically, it would discuss its plans with the United States first — and if America thinks it’s a bad idea, Canada might well listen to them. There’s strong statistical evidence that countries don’t even try to start some conflicts out of fear that an ally would disapprove. These three findings all suggest that NATO and America’s East Asian alliances very likely are playing a major role in preserving the Long Peace — which is why Trump’s habit of messing around with alliances is so dangerous. According to many Russia experts, Vladimir Putin’s deepest geostrategic goal is “breaking” NATO. The member states where anyone would expect him to test NATO’s commitment would be the Baltics — Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania — small former Soviet republics that recently became NATO members. We can’t predict if and when a rival like Putin would conclude that America’s alliances seemed weak enough to try testing them. Hopefully, it never happens. But the more Trump attacks the foundations of America’s allies, the more likely things are to change. The absolute risk of a Russian invasion of a NATO state or a North Korean attack on the South is relatively low, but the consequences are so potentially catastrophic — nuclear war! — that it’s worth taking anything that increases the odds of such a conflict seriously. The crack-up of the West? The world order is a little like a game of Jenga. In the game, there are lots of small blocks that interlock to form a stable tower. Each player has to remove a block without toppling the tower. But each time you take out a block, the whole thing gets a bit less stable. Take out enough blocks and it will collapse. The international order works in kind of the same way. There are lots of different interlocking parts — the spread of democracy, American alliances, nuclear deterrence, and the like — that work together to keep the global peace. But take out one block and the other ones might not be strong enough to keep things together on their own. At the end of the Cold War, British and French leaders worried that the passing of the old order might prove destabilizing. In a January 1990 meeting, French President François Mitterrand told British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher that he feared a united Germany could seize control of even more territory than Hitler. Some experts feared that in the absence of the external Soviet threat, Western European powers might go back to waging war with each other. Thankfully, those predictions turned out to be wrong. There are multiple reasons for that, but one big one — one that also helped keep relations between other historical enemies, like South Korea and Japan, peaceful — is a shared participation in US alliance networks. The US serves as the ultimate security blanket, preventing these countries from having to build up their own armaments and thus risk a replay of World War I. But if American alliance commitments become and remain less credible, it’s possible this order could crack up. America’s partners aren’t stupid. They understand that Trump is the product of deep forces in American politics, and that his victory might not be a one-off. If they think that this won’t be the last “America First” president in modern history, depending on America the way that they have in the past could quickly become a nightmare. The worst-case scenarios for a collapse in the US alliance system are terrible. Imagine full Japanese and German rearmament, alongside rapid-fire proliferation of nuclear weapons. Imagine a crack-up of NATO, with European powers at loggerheads while Russia gobbles up the Baltic states and the rest of Ukraine. Imagine South Korea’s historical tensions with Japan reigniting, and a war between those two countries or any combination of them and China. All of this seems impossible to imagine now, almost absurd. And indeed, in the short run, it is. There is no risk — zero — of American allies turning on each other in the foreseeable future. And it’s possible that the next president after Trump could reassure American allies that nothing like this could ever happen again. But the truth is that there’s just no way to know. When a fundamental force for world peace starts to weaken, no one can really be sure how well the system will hold up. Nothing like this — the leader of the world’s hegemon rounding on its most important allies — has ever happened before. What Donald Trump’s presidency has done, in effect, is start up another geopolitical Jenga game. Slowly but surely, he’s removing the blocks that undergird global security. It’s possible the global order survives Trump — but it’s just too early for us to say for sure. Given the stakes, it’s a game we’d rather not play.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Add-Ons › NATO Add-On – 2AC
Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)
New power distributions around AI and adjacent dual-use technologies are among the motivating factors causing the Alliance to reconsider whether its technological superiority may be threatened in the years ahead, as reflected in the 2019 Emerging and Disruptive Technologies (EDTs) Roadmap2 and, more recently, the NATO 2030 process.3 NATO navigates these changes and then approaches AI-accelerated changes to the international security environment in a highly political context. Notably, in 2019, French President Emmanuel Macron surprised many European counterparts by declaring NATO “brain-dead,” a warning wrapped in an even larger warning of trans-Atlantic security divisions.4 The critique that NATO is a “brain-dead” or “irrelevant” institution has existed in some form since the end of the Cold War.5 As NATO combats global perceptions of organizational irrelevance, there is a reason to push for bureaucratic adaptation to better manage technology-driven changes in the future. As such, despite some warnings to the contrary, Allies have an incentive to keep NATO a relevant military institution and ensure that it adapts to emerging threats and for future military contexts. The comment from President Macron helped prompt the NATO 2030 agenda, which is currently taking shape to increase the Alliance’s role as a political actor and as an organization with a greater focus on EDTs.6
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Add-Ons › Democracy Add-On – Solves War
Kosuke Imai 20, PhD in Political Science @ Harvard, Professor in the Department of Government and the Department of Statistics at Harvard University, “Robustness of Empirical Evidence for the Democratic Peace: A Nonparametric Sensitivity Analysis”, https://imai.fas.harvard.edu/research/files/dempeace.pdf
Abstract The democratic peace—the idea that democracies rarely fight one another— has been called “the closest thing we have to an empirical law in the study of international relations.” Yet, some contend that this relationship is spurious and suggest alternative explanations. Unfortunately, in the absence of randomized experiments, we can never rule out the possible existence of such confounding biases. Rather than commonly used regression-based approaches, we apply a nonparametric sensitivity analysis. We show that overturning the negative association between democracy and conflict would require a confounder that is forty-seven times more prevalent in democratic dyads than in other dyads. To put this number in context, the relationship between democracy and peace is at least five times as robust as that between smoking and lung cancer. To explain away the democratic peace, therefore, scholars would have to find far more powerful confounders than those already identified in the literature.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Add-Ons › Democracy Add-On – 2AC
Noam Chomsky, 5/27/2019 (American linguist, philosopher, cognitive scientist, historian, social critic, and political activist. Sometimes called "the father of modern linguistics", Chomsky is also a major figure in analytic philosophy and one of the founders of the field of cognitive science, “Chomsky: Nuclear Weapons, Climate Change & the Undermining of Democracy Threaten Future of Planet,” , Retrieved 8/4/2021)
NOAM CHOMSKY: I want to make a couple of remarks below about the severe difficulty of maintaining and instituting democracy, the powerful forces that have always opposed it, the achievements of somehow salvaging and enhancing it, and the significance of that for the future. But first, a couple of words about the challenges that we face, which you heard enough about already and you all know about. I don’t have to go into them in detail. To describe these challenges as “extremely severe” would be an error. The phrase does not capture the enormity of the kinds of challenges that lie ahead. And any serious discussion of the future of humanity must begin by recognizing a critical fact, that the human species is now facing a question that has never before arisen in human history, question that has to be answered quickly: Will human society survive for long? Well, as you all know, for 70 years we’ve been living under the shadow of nuclear war. Those who have looked at the record can only be amazed that we’ve survived this far. Time after time it’s come extremely close to terminal disaster, even minutes away. It’s kind of a miracle that we’ve survived. Miracles don’t go on forever. This has to be terminated, and quickly. The recent Nuclear Posture Review of the Trump administration dramatically increases the threat of conflagration, which would in fact be terminal for the species. We may remember that this Nuclear Posture Review was sponsored by Jim Mattis, who was regarded as too civilized to be retained in the administration—gives you a sense of what can be tolerated in the Trump-Pompeo-Bolton world. Well, there were three major arms treaties: the ABM Treaty, Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty; the INF Treaty, Intermediate Nuclear Forces; the New START treaty. The U.S. pulled out of the ABM Treaty in 2002. And anyone who believes that anti-ballistic missiles are defensive weapons is deluded about the nature of these systems. The U.S. has just pulled out of the INF Treaty, established by Gorbachev and Reagan in 1987, which sharply reduced the threat of war in Europe, which would very quickly spread. The background of that signing of that treaty was the demonstrations that you just saw depicted on the film. Massive public demonstrations were the background for leading to a treaty that made a very significant difference. It’s worth remembering that and many other cases where significant popular activism has made a huge difference. The lessons are too obvious to enumerate. Well, the Trump administration has just withdrawn from the INF Treaty; the Russians withdrew right afterwards. If you take a close look, you find that each side has a kind of a credible case saying that the opponent has not lived up to the treaty. For those who want a picture of how the Russians might look at it, the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists, the major journal on arms control issues, had a lead article a couple weeks ago by Theodore Postol pointing out how dangerous the U.S. installations of anti-ballistic missiles on the Russian border—how dangerous they are and can be perceived to be by the Russians. Notice, on the Russian border. Tensions are mounting on the Russian border. Both sides are carrying out provocative actions. We should—in a rational world, what would happen would be negotiations between the two sides, with independent experts to evaluate the charges that each is making against the other, to lead to a resolution of these charges, restore the treaty. That’s a rational world. But it’s unfortunately not the world we’re living in. No efforts at all have been made in this direction. And they won’t be, unless there is significant pressure. Well, that leaves the New START treaty. The New START treaty has already been designated by the figure in charge, who has modestly described himself as the greatest president in American history—he gave it the usual designation of anything that was done by his predecessors: the worst treaty that ever happened in human history; we’ve got to get rid of it. If in fact—this comes up for renewal right after the next election, and a lot is at stake. A lot is at stake in whether that treaty will be renewed. It has succeeded in very significantly reducing the number of nuclear weapons, to a level way above what they ought to be but way below what they were before. And it could go on. Well, meanwhile, global warming proceeds on its inexorable course. During this millennium, every single year, with one exception, has been hotter than the last one. There are recent scientific papers, James Hansen and others, which indicate that the pace of global warming, which has been increasing since about 1980, may be sharply escalating and may be moving from linear growth to exponential growth, which means doubling every couple of decades. We’re already approaching the conditions of 125,000 years ago, when the sea level was about roughly 25 feet higher than it is today, with the melting, the rapid melting, of the Antarctic, huge ice fields. We might—that point might be reached. The consequences of that are almost unimaginable. I mean, I won’t even try to depict them, but you can figure out quickly what that means. Well, meanwhile, while this is going on, you regularly read in the press euphoric accounts of how the United States is advancing in fossil fuel production. It’s now surpassed Saudi Arabia. We’re in the lead of fossil fuel production. The big banks, JPMorgan Chase and others, are pouring money into new investments in fossil fuels, including the most dangerous, like Canadian tar sands. And this is all presented with great euphoria, excitement. We’re now reaching energy independence. We can control the world, determine the use of fossil fuels in the world. Barely a word on what the meaning of this is, which is quite obvious. It’s not that the reporters, commentators don’t know about it, that the CEO of the banks don’t know about it. Of course they do. But these are kind of institutional pressures that just are extremely hard to extricate themselves from. You can put yourself in the—try to put yourself in the position of, say, the CEO of JPMorgan Chase, the biggest bank, which is spending large sums in investment in fossil fuels. He certainly knows everything that you all know about global warming. It’s no secret. But what are the choices? Basically he has two choices. One choice is to do exactly what he’s doing. The other choice is to resign and be replaced by somebody else who will do exactly what he’s doing. It’s not an individual problem. It’s an institutional problem, which can be met, but only under tremendous public pressure. And we’ve recently seen, very dramatically, how it can—how the solution can be reached. A group of young people, Sunrise Movement, organized, got to the point of sitting in in congressional offices, aroused some interest from the new progressive figures who were able to make it to Congress. Under a lot of popular pressure, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, joined by Ed Markey, actually placed the Green New Deal on the agenda. That’s a remarkable achievement. Of course, it gets hostile attacks from everywhere: It doesn’t matter. A couple of years ago it was unimaginable that it would be discussed. As the result of the activism of this group of young people, it’s now right in the center of the agenda. It’s got to be implemented in one form or another. It’s essential for survival, maybe not in exactly that form, but some modification of it. Tremendous change achieved by the commitment of a small group of young people. That tells you the kind of thing that can be done. Meanwhile, the Doomsday Clock of the Bulletin of Atomic Scientists last January was set at two minutes to midnight. That’s the closest it’s been to terminal disaster since 1947. The announcement of the settlement—of the setting mentioned the two major familiar threats: the threat of nuclear war, which is increasing, threat of global warming, which is increasing further. And it added a third for the first time: the undermining of democracy. That’s the third threat, along with global warming and nuclear war. And that was quite appropriate, because functioning democracy offers the only hope of overcoming these threats. They are not going to be dealt with by major institutions, state or private, acting without massive public pressure, which means that the means of democratic functioning have to be kept alive, used the way the Sunshine Movement did it, the way the great mass demonstration in the early ’80s did it, and the way we continue today.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Add-Ons › Democracy Add-On – 2AC
Christie Lawrence & Sean Cordey, 2020, (Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence,” , Retrieved 6/12/2022)
The Case for Transatlantic Cooperation There are three critical, interconnected arguments for transatlantic cooperation to ensure AI innovation protects the security, values, and economic interests of the United States and the European Union. 1.Global Good: Transatlantic AI partnerships and cooperation encourages innovation and applications that enhance human welfare, strengthen the economies of the US and the EU, and advance global security. 2.Great Power Competition: US-EU leadership of like-minded nations is needed in this age of great power competition to tip the scales against efforts by authoritarian governments—particularly, China and Russia—to undermine democracies. 3.Shared Values: The US and the EU share fundamental values and would benefit from joint efforts to establish AI norms that would more effectively advance their common vision of AI and ripple throughout the global AI ecosystem. Although the US consistently sounds the alarm bells around China’s AI aspirations and the EU urges international efforts against AI that violates fundamental rights, increasingly noting China’s actions with concern,8 little concrete international action has taken place. The United States and the European Union’s ongoing reassessment of their respective AI strategies and legislation9 provides a window of opportunity to align and collaborate. Transatlantic AI cooperation is at a critical juncture and the United States and the European Union should seize this opportunity to take concrete actions.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Conflict Resolution Advantage › Solvency – AI Integration Solves Nuclear Stability
Michael C. Horowitz, 2018 (Professor at the University of Pennsylvania, “Artificial Intelligence, International Competition, and the Balance of Power,” Retrieved 6/11/2022 from )
From a research perspective, one limitation of this article is its focus on the balance of power and international competition, as opposed to specific uses of AI. Future research could investigate particular implementations of AI for military purposes or other critical questions. Specific implementations could include the use of autonomous weapon systems able to select and engage targets on their own. These systems could raise ethical and moral questions about human control,116 as well as practical issues surrounding war that is fought at “machine speed.”117 The integration of AI into early-warning systems and its ability to aid in rapid targeting could also affect crisis stability and nuclear weapons.118 In the broader security realm, AI will affect human security missions.119 By laying out an initial framework for how military applications of narrow AI could structure international competition and the balance of power, this article lays the groundwork for thinking through these questions in the future.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Conflict Resolution Advantage › Solvency – AI Integration Solves Nuclear Stability
Matthew Kroenig, 2021 (Professor in the Department of Government and the Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, “Will Emerging Technology Cause Nuclear War?: Bringing Geopolitics Back In,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)
The next section provides a novel framework, grounded in the prevail¬ing geopolitical context, for understanding how new technology might affect nuclear strategic stability. Namely, the spread of new technology to the United States and its Allies and partners—status quo powers at the core of the existing international system—will tend to shore up sources of strategic stability. Conversely, the spread of new technology to revisionist powers China and Russia presents the greatest risk of conventional con¬flict that might escalate and threaten nuclear strategic stability.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Conflict Resolution Advantage › Solvency – AI Solves Conflict Resolution
Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)
Mitigating these types of risks is typically done in testing, evaluation, validation and verification (TEVV) and in experimentation activities.92 Yet AI cannot be validated and verified the way traditional software systems are because there is no guarantee that an AI system will perform in the real world as it does in a testing environment, and because lifelong-learning systems will perform differently over their lifecycle. Having robust assurance and TEVV processes in place are also important for operators to build trust in the systems they are meant to use, as well as for citizenries and coalition partners at large to see that accountability procedures still apply. As such, building institutional procedures to govern AI safety and security is necessary to build trust in the use of the technology—as well as to develop countermeasures and defensive systems that protect against adversarial threats.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › Solvency – A2: China/Russia Say No
John R. Allen, 3/24/2021 (President of the Brookings Institution, “It is time to negotiate global treaties on artificial intelligence,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)
That said, there are increasingly calls for the technologically advanced democracies to come together to aggregate their capacities, as well as leveraging their accumulated moral strength, to create the norms and ethical behaviors essential to governing the applications of AI and other technologies. Creating a reservoir of humanitarian commitment among the democracies will be vital to negotiating from a position of moral strength with the Chinese, Russians, and other authoritarian states whose views on the future of AI vary dramatically from ours.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › Solvency – AI Leadership Solves
Zoe Stanley-Lockman, 2022 (Defense and Strategic Studies, Nanyang Technological University, “NATO’s Role in Responsible AI Governance in Military Affairs,” , Retrieved 6/11/2022)
We explore how NATO can operationalize the debate around ethics and values of military AI to garner coordination and continue progress of EDT harmonization among partners. Building on the theoretical discussion from STS and military innovation literature above, the adoption of technologies that reinforce values serves the strategic interest of NATO to shape technological innovation against current waves of illiberalism.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › Solvency – AI Leadership Solves
Rob Murray, 9/1/2020 (head of the Innovation Unit in NATO’s Emerging Security Challenges Division, “Building a resilient innovation pipeline for the Alliance,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from )
The Alliance’s transatlantic nature places it in a unique position within the international order to provide both demand-side policies and supply-side resources that can genuinely build such a pipeline, creating not only innovations but entirely new markets – as Eisenhower noted: the foundation of military strength is economic strength. Recent history would suggest, the model of democracy and Allied governments’ willingness to make big bets on mission-oriented technology does indeed create new markets and it is this model, underpinned by shared values, which will be key to NATO’s longer term success.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › IL – AI Co-op Solves ILO
Christie Lawrence & Sean Cordey, 2020, (Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School, “The Case for Increased Transatlantic Cooperation on Artificial Intelligence,” , Retrieved 6/12/2022)
Health-related joint R&D is already a top priority within existing EU-US S&T collaboration and benefits from a reciprocal funding agreement between the US NIH and the EU.42 Covid-19 and prioritization by both the US and the EU to develop AI applications for healthcare further the potential for stronger US-EU AI collaboration in this sector. The environmental sciences sector similarly benefits from preexisting strong transatlantic collaboration and increased focus for AI-related research. The EU’s focus on developing a “European Green New Deal” will only raise the importance and quantity of European R&D in this field.43 Greater defense-related AI cooperation is increasingly viewed as an imperative by the US, with the DOD Artificial Intelligence Strategy highlighting the need for international AI cooperation to “safeguard a free and open international order.”44 Recent positive visits and collaboration between the JAIC, NATO, and European allies indicate AI collaboration in the defense sector will grow.45
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › IL – Tech Key to US Heg
Matthew Kroenig, 2021 (Professor in the Department of Government and the Edmund A. Walsh School of Foreign Service at Georgetown University, “Will Emerging Technology Cause Nuclear War?: Bringing Geopolitics Back In,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)
In emphasizing the divergent positions of the United States of America and its nuclear- armed rivals in the international system, this article also contributes to a growing body of literature that takes seriously hierarchy in international relations theory.9 The United States, the international sys¬tem’s leader for the past several decades, is likely to use new technology to reinforce its advantageous position within the existing international order. China and Russia will most likely employ new technology in bids to erode America’s privileged position. Analyses not grounded in an understanding of these states’ different positions in the prevailing international order risk overlooking this important source of variation in conflict behavior and nuclear-escalation dynamics. This framing of the problem leads to a different set of policy implica-tions. The United States and its Allies and partners must retain second- strike capabilities, preserve current power distributions, maintain an in-novation edge, and prevent the proliferation of destabilizing military technologies to revisionist powers.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › IL – Competitors in AI Undermine LIO
DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE, 2/12/2019 (“SUMMARY OF THE 2018 DEPARTMENT OF DEFENSE ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE STRATEGY,” Retrieved 6/12/2022 from .)
Thoughtful, responsible, and human-centered adoption of AI in the Department of Defense has the potential to strengthen our national security and transform the speed and agility of our operations. Our adversaries and competitors are aggressively working to define the future of these powerful technologies according to their interests, values, and societal models. Their investments threaten to erode U.S. military advantage, destabilize the free and open international order, and challenge our values and traditions with respect to human rights and individual liberties.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › UQ – NATO Faces Global AI Tech Race
Edward Hunter Christie, 11/24/2020 (Deputy Head of the Innovation Unit, Emerging Security Challenges Division @ NATO, “Artificial Intelligence at NATO: dynamic adoption, responsible use,” Retrieved June 12, 2022 from )
As noted in the first article in this series on innovation at NATO, the Alliance faces a global technology adoption race. Rival powers are leveraging new technologies to pursue the dual goal of greater economic competitiveness alongside greater military capabilities. The Allies face a range of challenges as they seek to exploit emerging and disruptive technologies. These challenges are based on two interrelated pillars of work: ensuring a dynamic adoption of new technologies and governing them responsibly. Artificial Intelligence (AI) is at the heart of these considerations.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › UQ – NATO Faces Global AI Tech Race
Rod Thornton, 6/17/2019 (Senior Lecturer in the Centre for Defence Education Research and Analysis, UK Defence Academy/Defence Studies Department, King’s College London, “One to ponder: the UK’s ethical stance on the use of Artificial Intelligence in weapons systems,” , Retrieved 6/12/2022)
Among the world’s major states an AI arms race is underway. The US and China, with their huge spending on AI and with their ability to draw on the expertise of indigenous high-tech firms (such as Google, Amazon, Huawei, Tencent, etc), are way ahead of other states in the development of AI systems for their militaries. They understand that to be left behind in such development risks facing not just battlefield disadvantage but also actual strategic defeat. Weapons based on AI have the potential to become even more powerful than nuclear weapons. One Russian source, for instance, sees a future ‘Third Word War’ being won ‘within seconds’ by using AI-enabled cyber warfare. As Vladimir Putin has said on several occasions, ‘whoever becomes the leader in this [AI] sphere will become ruler of the world’.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › UQ – US is losing AI Arms Race to China
John R. Allen, 3/24/2021 (President of the Brookings Institution, “It is time to negotiate global treaties on artificial intelligence,” , Retrieved 6/15/2022)
The U.S. National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence recently made the news when its members warned that America faces a national security crisis due to insufficient investment in artificial intelligence and emerging technologies. Commission Vice Chair Robert Work argued “we don’t feel this is the time for incremental budgets … This will be expensive and requires significant change in the mindset at the national, and agency, and Cabinet levels.” Commission Chair Eric Schmidt extended those worries by saying “China is catching the US” and “competition with China will increase.”
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – AI Leadership Advantage › UQ – US is losing AI Arms Race to China
Benjamin Boudreaux, 1/11/2019 (professor at the Pardee RAND Graduate School, “Does the U.S. Face an AI Ethics Gap?” , Retrieved 6/12/2022)
Members of Congress, the U.S. military, and prominent technologists have raised the alarm that the U.S. is at risk of losing an Artificial Intelligence (AI) arms race. China already has leveraged strategic investment and planning, access to massive data, and suspect business practices to surpass the U.S. in some aspects of AI implementation. There are worries that this competition could extend to the military sphere with serious consequences for U.S. national security.
2022
SDI
Affirmative
*****AI Interoperability Affirmative***** › Case – Top Level › Solvency – China/Russia Counterweight
Lena Trabucco, 10/5/2020 (Research Assistant at the Centre for Military Studies at the University of Copenhagen, “AI Partnership for Defense is a Step in the Right Direction – But Will Face Challenges,” , Retrieved 6/14/2022)
Few solutions have been offered to the US for maneuvering Europe’s competing visions for military AI, and how to effectively court hesitant European nations. And the current absence of Germany from the AI partnership suggests the US still hasn’t figured it out. If the goal is to expand the partnership as a counter-weight to Chinese and Russian AI military innovation, then the US will have to address the foundational differences that some European allies have regarding the role of military AI in order to bring the partnership under a unifying strategy.