2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves Energy Security
Green 22 (Mark Green spent 16 years as national editorial writer for The Oklahoman in the paper’s Washington bureau. Previously, Mark was a reporter, copy editor and sports editor at an assortment of newspapers. He earned his journalism degree from the University of Oklahoma and master’s in journalism and public affairs from American University, 2/17/22, accessed 7/14/22, API, “American Energy Leadership: Stability, Security, Positive Influence”
Conversely, when American energy isn’t leading, the U.S. and its allies may face severe challenges when you consider the essentiality of energy to economic growth, national security and environmental progress. This has been underscored as Europe faced a mid-winter cutoff of some or all of the natural gas it gets from by Russia – in the event Moscow decided to use energy as a weapon in the Ukraine crisis. This is in Russia’s . As things simmered in Europe, American liquefied natural gas (LNG) cargoes streamed across the Atlantic. For example, the U.S. Energy Department reports the U.S. exported 60.3 billion cubic feet of LNG to the United Kingdom in , roughly double the amount shipped in . According to , LNG exports to Europe in January supplied higher volumes (34% of Europe’s total supply) than Russian pipelined natural gas, which decreased from 30% to 40% of Europe’s supply to just 17%. The largest share of those LNG exports came from the United States, the report said. , API vice president for Natural Gas Markets, said last month that American energy was stepping up: “During this acute period of demand squeeze, the U.S. is not only exporting at record levels but has actually ramped up additional LNG capacity – responding to meet our allies’ demand when they need it the most.” This is significant – for Europe’s safety and global stability – and makes the case for policies that support and strengthen American energy leadership. In a letter to the editor of the Wall Street Journal, wrote that American energy can play a critical role with backing by the right policies in Washington:
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves Energy Security
Nyman 22 (Jonna Nyman, Department of Politics and International Relations, Lecturer at University of Leicester, University Road, 1/2022, accessed, 7/14/2022, Journal of International Relations and Development, “Rethinking energy, climate and security: a critical analysis of energy security in the US”
Understanding the complicated relationship between energy, climate and security is vital both to the study of international relations and to ensure the continued survival of a world increasingly threatened by environmental change. Climate change is largely caused by burning fossil fuels for energy, but while discussions on the climate consider the role of energy, energy security debates largely overlook climate concerns. This article traces the separation between energy and climate through an analysis of US energy security discourse and policy. It shows that energy security is continually constructed as national security, which enables very particular policy choices and prioritises it above climate concerns. Thus, in many cases, policies undertaken in the name of energy security contribute directly to climate insecurity. The article argues that the failure to consider securing the climate as inherently linked to energy security is not just problematic, but, given global warming, potentially harmful. Consequently, any approach to dealing with climate change has to begin by rethinking energy security and security more broadly, as national (energy) security politics no longer provides security in any meaningful sense.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves Energy Security
Ferguson 22 (Drew Ferguson is an American politician who is the U.S. representative for Georgia's 3rd congressional district, 3/7/22, accessed 7/11/22, Rep. A. Drew Ferguson (R-GA) News Release, “CONGRESSMAN FERGUSON: ENERGY SECURITY IS NATIONAL SECURITY”,
U.S. Congressman Drew Ferguson (R-Ga.), Chief Deputy Whip of the House Republican Conference and a member of the House Energy Action Team (HEAT), recently cosponsored H.R. 6886, the Powering America through Domestic Energy (PADE) Act. This bill would ban the importation of crude oil and petroleum products from the Russian Federation and bar President Biden from declaring and implementing a moratorium on the use of hydraulic fracturing or on oil and gas leasing on federal lands without Congressional approval. "As Vladimir Putin continues his brutal, unjust war against Ukraine, our nation's need for energy independence has never been greater," Ferguson said. "The U.S. currently imports 600,000 barrels of Russian oil a day, sending millions of dollars to Putin's tyrannical regime. Every gallon of Russian oil has Ukrainian blood on it. Instead of powering Putin, America and our allies should be fueled by American energy, and we must respond by replacing Russian oil and gas with clean American resources by increasing domestic production to regain our energy independence. It's clear that energy security is national security, and the PADE Act is a good first step toward ending dependency on Russian resources while increasing American energy independence."
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves Energy Security
Rodgers 22 (Cathy Anne McMorris Rodgers is an American politician who is the U.S. representative for Washington's 5th congressional district, 6/29/22, accessed 7/13/22, Targeted News Service, “McMorris Rodgers Warns of Global Socialist Price Controls On Energy” https://mcmorris.house.gov/posts/watch-mcmorris-rodgers-warns-of-global-socialist-price-controls-on-energy)SaadK
FLIP THE SWITCH ON AMERICAN ENERGY PRODUCTION "We're going to flip the switch on for American energy after the Republicans win the majority in November. "We're going to be very aggressive embracing, unleashing American energy. "I've introduced legislation with my colleague Bruce Westerman, who heads up the resources committee for the Republicans. It is the American Energy Independence from Russia Act. "It would immediately say yes to exporting LNG to our allies around the world. Europe is desperate for natural gas. We have lots of natural gas. "It would restart the oil and gas leasing on federal lands and waters here in the United States of America [and] immediately approve the Keystone XL pipeline. "It would require the President to submit an energy security plan because we know that energy security is the foundation for national security. "And it would restock our strategic petroleum reserves. "These are the policies that would unleash American energy, that would flip the switch. It would bring down gas prices here in the United States, help hard-working American families, and also help our allies around the world that are desperate for American leadership." SOCIALIST PRICE CONTROLS DON'T WORK "We know that price controls don't work." [...] "We know that it was tried in the 70's and it just resulted in long lines and more scarcity of supply. "We also know right now, when you think about doing this globally, that Russia is selling more oil to China and India. "[Russian President Vladimir] Putin is continuing to sell oil, funding his military, propping up his economy, while our President and G7 [leaders] are talking about some kind of price controls. They need to confront the reality of the situation and unleash American energy."
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Impact – Readiness
Barnett 11, Former Senior Strategic Researcher and Professor in the Warfare Analysis & Research Department, Center for Naval Warfare Studies, U.S. Naval War College (Thomas P.M., The New Rules: Leadership Fatigue Puts U.S., and Globalization, at Crossroads, )
Events in Libya are a further reminder for Americans that we stand at a crossroads in our continuing evolution as the world's sole full-service superpower. Unfortunately, we are increasingly seeking change without cost, and shirking from risk because we are tired of the responsibility. We don't know who we are anymore, and our president is a big part of that problem. Instead of leading us, he explains to us. Barack Obama would have us believe that he is practicing strategic patience. But many experts and ordinary citizens alike have concluded that he is actually beset by strategic incoherence -- in effect, a man overmatched by the job. It is worth first examining the larger picture: We live in a time of arguably the greatest structural change in the global order yet endured, with this historical moment's most amazing feature being its relative and absolute lack of mass violence. That is something to consider when Americans contemplate military intervention in Libya, because if we do take the step to prevent larger-scale killing by engaging in some killing of our own, we will not be adding to some fantastically imagined global death count stemming from the ongoing "megalomania" and "evil" of American "empire." We'll be engaging in the same sort of system-administering activity that has marked our stunningly successful stewardship of global order since World War II. Let me be more blunt: As the guardian of globalization, the U.S. military has been the greatest force for peace the world has ever known. Had America been removed from the global dynamics that governed the 20th century, the mass murder never would have ended. Indeed, it's entirely conceivable there would now be no identifiable human civilization left, once nuclear weapons entered the killing equation. But the world did not keep sliding down that path of perpetual war. Instead, America stepped up and changed everything by ushering in our now-perpetual great-power peace. We introduced the international liberal trade order known as globalization and played loyal Leviathan over its spread. What resulted was the collapse of empires, an explosion of democracy, the persistent spread of human rights, the liberation of women, the doubling of life expectancy, a roughly 10-fold increase in adjusted global GDP and a profound and persistent reduction in battle deaths from state-based conflicts. That is what American "hubris" actually delivered. Please remember that the next time some TV pundit sells you the image of "unbridled" American military power as the cause of global disorder instead of its cure. With self-deprecation bordering on self-loathing, we now imagine a post-American world that is anything but. Just watch who scatters and who steps up as the Facebook revolutions erupt across the Arab world. While we might imagine ourselves the status quo power, we remain the world's most vigorously revisionist force. As for the sheer "evil" that is our military-industrial complex, again, let's examine what the world looked like before that establishment reared its ugly head. The last great period of global structural change was the first half of the 20th century, a period that saw a death toll of about 100 million across two world wars. That comes to an average of 2 million deaths a year in a world of approximately 2 billion souls. Today, with far more comprehensive worldwide reporting, researchers report an average of less than 100,000 battle deaths annually in a world fast approaching 7 billion people. Though admittedly crude, these calculations suggest a 90 percent absolute drop and a 99 percent relative drop in deaths due to war. We are clearly headed for a world order characterized by multipolarity, something the American-birthed system was designed to both encourage and accommodate. But given how things turned out the last time we collectively faced such a fluid structure, we would do well to keep U.S. power, in all of its forms, deeply embedded in the geometry to come. To continue the historical survey, after salvaging Western Europe from its half-century of civil war, the U.S. emerged as the progenitor of a new, far more just form of globalization -- one based on actual free trade rather than colonialism. America then successfully replicated globalization further in East Asia over the second half of the 20th century, setting the stage for the Pacific Century now unfolding.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Impact – Readiness
Pletka ‘22 [Danielle Pletka is a distinguished senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and co-host of the podcast What the Hell is Going On? 6-2-2022 “The Republicans Could Win the U.S. Midterms. Here’s What that Means for the World,” Foreign Policy, accessed 6-27-2022, https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/06/02/gop-congress-midterms-foreign-policy-ukraine-taiwan/]
Last month’s vote in the U.S. Congress to appropriate $40 billion in additional military and budgetary assistance for Ukraine laid bare fissures in the Republican congressional caucus: 11 of 50 Senate Republicans voted against the bill, as did 57 of 208 House Republicans. Was the Ukraine vote a harbinger of Republican national security squabbles to come? Was it a partisan vote against anything associated with President Joe Biden? Or was it a one-off reflecting a poorly drafted bill with too much extraneous baggage? More importantly, who will hold the foreign-policy reins in the likely Republican House (and possibly Senate) majority to come in 2023—the isolationists or the internationalists? Political pundits agree Republicans are likely to win back the House of Representatives and have a good shot at the Senate in the November 2022 midterm elections. That could—caucus permitting—propel House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy to the speakership and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell to the post of majority leader. Of the two, McConnell is the known quantity—an experienced legislator and parliamentarian and an old-school internationalist whose foreign-policy views were forged in the crucible of the Cold War. McCarthy, not so much. Indeed, it’s probably most accurate to say his foreign policy was forged in the crucible of former President Donald Trump. As previous Republican speakers have learned to their displeasure, the Republican Party in today’s House is less a caucus and more a raucous battle for primacy. Former Speaker John Boehner struggled against rebellious Tea Party upstarts, his successor Paul Ryan struggled against the self-named Freedom Caucus, and McCarthy is unlikely to have much fun either. In the minority, the Republican Party tends—emphasis intended—to stand together because the Democratic speaker and the executive in the White House are deemed public enemies No. 1 and No. 2. But with the majority comes the battle to control the agenda. Domestic policy will likely dominate the politicking in Congress: inflation, crime, education, the border. But Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, like so many conflicts before it, has proved that as much as politicians wish to focus on “nation building here at home,” global realities intrude. Ukraine is the tip of the iceberg, but Republicans have their eye on plenty of other issues as well, including relations with China, the question of defending Taiwan, the continued isolation of Russia, the Middle East (think energy, Iran, and Israel), and, more broadly, defense spending. But before the substance of the foreign-policy challenge hits the House and Senate floors, the ideological question merits examination. American Enterprise Institute scholar Colin Dueck divides the Republican Party’s foreign policy into three schools: foreign-policy activists, foreign-policy hard-liners, and foreign-policy noninterventionists. Looking back, it’s clear that so-called foreign-policy activists dominated Republican national security policymaking for much of the post-World War II era. These were the leaders who believed, as both Presidents Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush regularly underscored, that the United States is not simply one nation among many but that it is a beacon of freedom to the world, a “shining city on a hill.” Foreign-policy activists underwrote the Reagan Doctrine, the principle that the United States should lend a hand to all those hoping to halt the advance of communism wherever they were, including in Afghanistan, Nicaragua, Angola, El Salvador, and Grenada. Bush faced different challenges, but his underlying faith in U.S. power and values was similar. Rather than fighting communism, what Bush dubbed his “Freedom Agenda” took on the tyrannies that he believed fueled Salafi-jihadis. Yet his efforts were neither clearly thought through nor appropriately resourced. Worse yet, Bush could not convincingly argue that he was advancing U.S. national interests in every case. For the activist school, Bush’s Iraq War proved to be their swan song. Though the Iraq War offered an “I told you so” moment for the Republican Party’s isolationist wing, its immediate beneficiaries were President Barack Obama and the Democratic Party’s own “End the endless wars” crowd—or so it seemed at first. But the intervening years offered the Republican Party’s noninterventionists ample fodder: the disastrous war in Libya and the horrifying killing of a U.S. ambassador in Benghazi, the withdrawal from Iraq and the resulting rise of the Islamic State, the civil war in Syria and the ensuing cataclysmic refugee crisis. These crises were not the primary reason for Trump’s election, but they didn’t hurt his campaign. Rather, they—together with Obama’s self-labeled signature foreign-policy achievement, the Iran nuclear deal—offered an opportunity for Trump. “Donald Trump’s political achievement in 2016 was to sense the possibility for a new [Republican] coalition unseen since before World War II,” Dueck writes. “He did this not by reiterating libertarian foreign-policy preferences. Rather, he combined non-interventionist criticism of ‘endless wars’ with hardline stands on China, jihadist terrorism, anti-American dictatorships in Latin America, and US defense spending.” This is a sweet spot for Republican foreign policy, and understanding the reluctant internationalism of most of the party’s voters—a repudiation of the embarrassed anti-Americanism of the Democratic Party’s far left and the activist internationalism that has heretofore characterized the Republican Party leadership—will be key to geolocating a new Republican Congress’s preferred national security policy. A unifying theme for the Republican Party will be the challenge presented by China. It sells well with the base, and with trade liberalization off the table for the moment (for both parties), the question of China will likely come down to economic disengagement and Beijing’s threat to Taiwan. A case in point is a recent letter co-written by Joe Manchin and Shelley Moore Capito (respectively the Democratic and Republican senators from West Virginia) urging Biden to include Taiwan in his newly proposed Indo-Pacific Economic Framework. Republican signatories to the letter included James Risch, who is likely to be the chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee in a new Republican-held Senate; Roger Wicker, the likely chair of the Senate Armed Services Committee; Marco Rubio, the likely chair of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence; and most of the Republican members of the current Senate Appropriations Committee. Notably, several of the Senate’s more ardent Trump supporters, including Marsha Blackburn and Kevin Cramer, also joined the letter. (A similar House effort was also joined by likely future national security heavyweights, including probable House Foreign Affairs Committee Chair Michael McCaul.) Defense spending will be another key theme for the Republican Party. House and Senate Republicans have repeatedly slammed Biden’s defense spending as inadequate to address the country’s many national security challenges and have only escalated those charges since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. McConnell has called for a 5 percent increase in defense spending above inflation, and McCarthy has been equally energetic. Both understand—as Trump did—that investing in the military can be cast as a deterrent as well as a down payment on victory in any eventual conflict. And here again, the base is with them. Ditto for energy security: While there is a bipartisan constituency for pivoting away from the Middle East—and a growing bipartisan opposition to renewing the Iran nuclear deal—Republicans are less focused on climate change issues and more on basic pocketbook challenges. That will mean more enthusiasm for restoring American energy independence, avoiding unnecessary bickering with Saudi Arabia (still a major swing producer of oil), and easing regulations on U.S. oil and gas production. But what about Ukraine and cases like it? What about those 11 in the Senate and the 57 in the House? What about the conservative powerhouse think tank the Heritage Foundation and its political action committee drawing a line in the sand against the $40 billion Ukraine aid package? Like Heritage, Sen. Mike Braun finessed his opposition based not on the policy of aiding Ukraine but on the cost of doing so and the spiraling U.S. debt. Sen. Rand Paul, a perennial opponent of U.S. overseas engagement, pinned his “no” vote on the lack of an inspector general in the bill to oversee how the funds are spent. That’s fair enough, but it’s hard to picture every one of those “no” votes switching tack if presented with a better or cleaner bill—not when the Republican Party’s rising stars include the likes of Senate candidate J.D. Vance, who during his campaign said, “I gotta be honest with you, I don’t really care what happens to Ukraine one way or another.” It’s relatively easy to predict that a Republican majority will continue to support arming and aiding Ukraine, because the vote has already happened. And though a significant minority of the Republican caucus voted no, it was a minority. But there are harder cases (though not just for the Republicans): the looming Chinese threat to Taiwan, for one. Sure, there’s a majority in both houses for including Taiwan in trading arrangements, and there are vocal advocates in both chambers for ending the U.S. policy of “strategic ambiguity” toward Taipei. But where will the Republican Party be on defending Taiwan in the event of a Chinese attack? Will isolationists on both left and right actually have the power to steer a course? On its face, the answer appears to be no, but the devil is, proverbially, in the details. Sanctions on China would hit the Republican base hard, raising costs for basic goods even higher. As with all such crystal ball gazing, sorting the powerful from the merely loud will be a chore. Republican Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene is ever-so-vocal and enjoys a substantial Twitter following, but she has little clout in the House of Representatives. Paul is consistently isolationist, but few ask how he will vote as they decide their stance on major issues. More importantly, the majority of the Republican Party is not actually with them. Case in point: The TV host Tucker Carlson, pocket deity of Trump nostalgics, initially came out swinging against NATO’s condemnations of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s attack on Ukraine, but he soon tempered his position once it became clear that ranging himself on the side of the Russian dictator was a losing cause. Similarly, while all eyes focus on the Vances and Greenes, there actually remains a strong hawkish contingent in the Republican Party that is well represented on Capitol Hill, including by Sens. Tom Cotton, Rubio, and Ted Cruz, as well as Reps. Mike Gallagher, Elise Stefanik, and likely incoming House Armed Services Committee Chair Mike Turner, among others. Although these members may not be interventionists in the style of George W. Bush, there should be no question that they are national security hawks keen on defending both U.S. interests and U.S. allies. That will almost certainly mean efforts to increase the defense budget; pressure to increase the quality, consistency, and speed of arms deliveries to Ukraine; and an even harder line on China, potentially including additional sanctions on Beijing (notwithstanding grumbling from certain quarters).
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves China
Murphy 22 (Rory Murphy is the vice president of government affairs at the U.S. China Business Council, “U.S. midterm elections and China policy”, SupChina, https://supchina.com/2022/07/14/u-s-midterm-elections-and-china-policy/. Accessed 7-14-22) – AC
Sure. Let’s assume Republicans take at least one chamber of Congress. They’ve made it quite clear that China is not going to go away as an issue. The House Republican Task Force on China put out a report, I believe, last September. Outlines a lot of their priorities, what they would like to pursue should they be in charge. I think I would encourage all of you to read through that. There’s a lot of ideas in there and I think all of them are on the table. Anchoring that effort in the House next year would be this assuming the outbound investment proposal we discussed earlier does not make it into a final China package this year. It’ll likely be the anchor of some legislative effort on China next year. That is our expectation. From a business perspective, there’s a constant political risk, reputational risk doing business. There’s an increase of interest, it seems, among lawmakers of both parties, but I’d say probably more so Republicans to call out companies, call out institutions on issues related to China. You have in the Senate, regardless of who seemingly every Senate Republican is positioning themselves to run for the White House in 2024, and that creates a dynamic where lawmakers are trying to position themselves as the toughest on China. And so, there’s arms race of policies that we’ll need to contend with. From a business perspective, that creates a lot of uncertainties. There’s a dynamic where it’s hard to push back on bad policies, even if you are a lawmaker who wants to get the policy right. The second that somebody puts out a policy that’s objectively bad, and there’s a lot of good policies, right policies that should be pursued, but some are, we would say objectively bad, it’s hard to question it, let alone oppose it because you’re at risk of being labeled as “weak on China.” From a political calculus, it just makes things really tricky. So, there’s a reputational risk for businesses that there could be an increase of them being called out outside of the legislative process. Then this constant uncertainty of what bills are going to be introduced, and how will they be enacted into law? It’s harder to forecast what will be approved, what won’t be than it was five, six years ago.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves China
Sibley 21 (Nate Sibley is a research fellow at the Hudson Institute’s Kleptocracy Initiative, “Republicans Can Embrace Much of Biden’s Anticorruption Plan”, Wall Street Journal, https://www.wsj.com/articles/republicans-can-embrace-much-of-biden-anticorruption-plan-kleptocracy-russia-china-corruption-11639339155, 12/12/21. Accessed 7-14-22) - AC
Even in the fractious current Congress, Republicans have been leaders in what must be one of the last bipartisan initiatives with any serious momentum, as evidenced by the launch of a bipartisan Caucus Against Foreign Corruption and Kleptocracy in June and of the U.S.-led Interparliamentary Alliance Against Kleptocracy in December. Rep. Maria Salazar (R., Fla.), whose family suffered at the hands of kleptocratic regimes in Cuba and Nicaragua, has become a powerful voice for adjusting U.S. anti-money-laundering regulations to end abuse of the American financial system. “These are not faraway problems for the United States; corrupt money also destroys American lives,” she said at a recent hearing. Republicans’ role has often been to restrain Democratic colleagues from measures that impose harsh regulation on U.S. businesses or violate reasonable privacy expectations. A recent bipartisan success: Included in the January defense authorization was a ban on anonymous shell companies. The bill mandated the creation of a U.S. corporate beneficial-ownership register accessible only to American law enforcement and banks, as opposed to the open public registers of Europe. Mr. Biden has done more than any previous president to highlight the threat of authoritarian kleptocracy. But he also needlessly surrendered Afghanistan to a theocratic narco-gang, green-lit Russia’s Nord Stream 2 pipeline, and nixed sanctions on the so-called Navalny 35 group of Vladimir Putin’s henchmen. He now appears poised to abandon Ukraine, which has persevered against Kremlin-backed oligarchy. The Treasury Department has yet to impose sanctions on anyone approaching the stature of Russian oligarch Oleg Deripaska. A future Republican administration and Congress could build on the Biden initiative. They could acknowledge that the biggest kleptocracy of all is run by the Chinese Communist Party. Egregious intellectual-property theft, economic blackmail of foreign countries and businesses, rampant bribery on the Belt and Road Initiative: China’s emergence as a global power shows what happens when thieves hold the reins of the world’s second-largest economy. Meanwhile, the Cuban-Venezuelan criminal enterprise continues to consume Latin America, and Tehran uses whatever cash it can get to spread terror across the Middle East. Buoyed by stronger anti-money-laundering defenses at home, Republicans could take a powerful offensive line against these regimes by reinstating the maximum pressure campaigns of the Trump administration—deploying the full force of U.S. sanctions and law enforcement against dictators who rob their own people and use the proceeds to threaten global security.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves China
Dawsey 22 (Josh, A political enterprise and investigations reporter for The Washington Post. He joined the paper in 2017 and previously covered the White Hous e. Before that, he covered the White House for Politico, and New York City Hall and New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie for the Wall Street Journal. He graduated from the University of South Carolina) “Many GOP candidates are bashing each other for ties to China.” Washington Post. 5-11-2022. //RK
The advertisement strikes an ominous tone from a familiar voice: Donald Trump inveighing against American companies sending their jobs to China. But the advertisement is from Trump foe and Georgia Gov. Brian Kemp, who is campaigning against David Perdue — the candidate the former president has picked to win in Georgia. The spot accuses Perdue of outsourcing jobs in the private sector as a CEO before becoming a candidate for the Senate in Georgia. “We tested a number of hits, and that was the best-polling one — the outsourcing to China,” said Cody Hall, Kemp’s communications director. In Georgia, a state more than 7,000 miles from China, it has been a centerpiece of Kemp’s campaign in paid advertising and messaging. Ties to China — even spurious, misleading or hyperbolic ones — have become an albatross for GOP candidates across the country in 2022 races and an animating presence in campaign stops and advertisements, with much of the Republican Party holding increasingly negative views of China after two years of the coronavirus and Trump’s rhetoric against the country. Campaign strategists and candidates in a number of states said that tying candidates to China has become a prime attack in a GOP primary — with candidates seeking to differentiate themselves as they largely hew to Trump’s political agenda. In Pennsylvania, Mehmet Oz has repeatedly slashed his foe David McCormick for conducting business deals with China as hedge fund CEO, while McCormick and his allies have attacked Oz for making money off Chinese state TV and using Chinese products for his companies. When Trump criticized McCormick last Friday night at a rainy rally, he lampooned him for being too kind to China in one of his most scorching attacks. The attacks have stretched from Texas to Ohio to Missouri, with candidates making aggressive and sometimes misleading claims about their opponents’ views on China. “There are China remnants in all these primaries,” said Tony Fabrizio, a prominent pollster who works for Trump and is working in many of this year’s contested primary states. “If you coddle China, or you are soft on China, that makes you not so much America first and not so tough,” Fabrizio said. “Being tagged as soft on China is not a good thing. Trump focused and catalyzed some of it. But China has been seen as the primary world foe for at least the last decade or more.” In a poll Fabrizio conducted earlier this year, he said, Republican voters overwhelmingly viewed China as more of a national security threat than Russia, even as Russia launched missiles into Ukraine and killed thousands of civilians in a brutal land war. A March by the Chicago Council on Global Affairs found that 75 percent of Republicans said China’s development as a world power represented a “critical threat” to U.S. interests, up from 67 percent in 2020 and 42 percent in 2018. It is a shift from decades past, when many Republicans took a more conciliatory tone toward China. Michael Pillsbury, one of Trump’s informal advisers who was slated to be his ambassador to the country if he had won a second term, said it once was different. “It is something quite new — Republicans used to be the party of business and free trade,” Pillsbury said. “And I remember during the early considerations of President Trump — putting heavy tariffs on China — there were voices within the White House and within the party that this goes against Republican traditions.” The current mood toward China, Pillsbury said, is darker than it has been in decades in the United States. Pillsbury and others note that many of the candidates launching the attacks have not delivered succinct policy positions on what they would do differently, and that some of the attacks seem to be fearmongering. There is a confluence of reasons Republicans have escalated their anti-China rhetoric, according to strategists and candidates. The party’s supporters listened to Trump bad-mouth China throughout his term, even as he struck a more conciliatory tone behind the scenes. There is deep frustration among some Rust Belt states that Chinese imports have cost American jobs and deflated towns. And there is palpable and widespread blame on China for the coronavirus, which was first detected in the Chinese city of Wuhan. “The part of commonality across the MAGA base is being tough on China,” said Jason Miller, a longtime Trump adviser. “It is interwoven in the trade message, but it’s more that Republicans see China as an existential threat to all of Western civilization.” Trump’s team polled last year on various messages for his rallies, and learned that attacking China was among the most popular with his supporters. Trump started calling for reparations from China over the coronavirus, receiving raucous cheers at his rallies — with no enforcement mechanism provided. In addition to Trump, who is weighing a reelection bid, other potential 2024 presidential candidates have focused on China, with former secretary of state Mike Pompeo and others offering harsh rhetoric against the country. It has been much less of an issue in Democratic primaries. In Pennsylvania, McCormick’s work at the hedge fund Bridgewater — and its extensive business dealings with China — have been a key part of Oz’s message. Before running for the Senate, McCormick’s Bridgewater “raised the equivalent of $1.25 billion for its third investment fund in China,” according to the Wall Street Journal.Let’s go China!” two men paid by the Oz campaign, dressed in vests and calling themselves “finance bros,” cheered in one ad. They called him the “Wolf of Westport,” a reference to the affluent Connecticut town near New York City where Bridgewater is headquartered.McCormick has been criticized frequently by Oz’s campaign for his 2007 remarks on China while serving as a top Treasury Department official in the George W. Bush administration. “When China succeeds, the United States succeeds,” McCormick said, speaking in Beijing.Some McCormick allies said they viewed his Chinese business ties as his greatest disadvantage when he started the campaign; his first move was to write an op-ed for Fox Business defending himself and promising to be more aggressive on China.“That’s why I believe it is past time for America’s leaders to confront head-on the Chinese Communist Party (CCP), which poses the greatest economic and national security threat to the United States,” McCormick wrote.McCormick campaign spokesperson Jess Szymanski said in a statement: “Dave’s battle-tested experience will make him one of the strongest Senators in Washington in holding China accountable and restoring pro-growth, America First policies.”For their part, McCormick and his team have put together an extensive book of research attacking Oz for some for his investments in China. For example, Oz made money when his television show was syndicated in the country and acquiesced to Chinese state TV rules in order for the show to be broadcast. “The Dr. Oz show has aired in over 100 countries for over 13 years to provide life-changing health information to millions of people across the globe,” said Brittany Yanick, a spokesperson for Oz. “Dr. Oz’s stance on China is unequivocal — the Chinese Communist Party’s malign actions both within their own country and on the world stage are reprehensible.” And when Oz launched a bedding company, he contracted with a firm in China to make many of its products. Pillows, mattresses and mattress toppers, among other things, were all made in the country through a partnership with the company Malouf. That allowed Oz to make between $1 million and $5 million, according to a financial disclosure he filed. Oz’s campaign defended the items being made in China, saying it was difficult to find materials to make such products in the United States.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves China
Magnier 22 (Mark Magnier is a US correspondent based in Washington. Before joining the Post, he worked for the Wall Street Journal in China and for the Los Angeles Times in India, China and Japan. He’s covered the Chinese economy, China and India’s explosive rise and conflicts in Iraq, Pakistan and Afghanistan.) “Republican lawmakers in US focus more on China in online posts, study says.” South China Morning Post. 7-15-2021 https://www.scmp.com/news/china/article/3141153/republican-members-us-congress-focus-more-china-social-media-posts-study //RK
There may be a bipartisan consensus on tougher US policy toward China, but Republican lawmakers tend to focus on China’s negative behaviour and attributes, employing terms like “propaganda”, “spy” and “lie” on social media, according to a Pew Research Centre analysis. The report released on Wednesday also found that a relatively small number of Republicans accounted for the majority of postings, often hammering away repeatedly at the same themes. Meanwhile, Democratic counterparts focused more on attacks on Asian-Americans. “It’s not a coincidence that Republicans showed a lot of interest since 2019 in China and Democrats on Asian-American issues,” said Federico de Jesus, founder of FDJ Solutions, a political and communications consultancy. “Republican members of Congress not only want to cater to Trump. They also want to persuade their people that they’re not being a wuss [on China] even as they end up spreading conspiracy theories.” According to the Pew study, just 56 lawmakers out of 535 in Congress generated 16,060 posts mentioning China or the Chinese people from January 2020 through April 2021. Of those 56, 54 were Republican. The offices of Republican senators Marco Rubio of Florida, Ted Cruz of Texas and Tom Cotton of Arkansas, among the moctive Republican communicators on China, did not respond to a request for comment. In cases where lawmakers from both parties referred to China – as with Covid-19, for instance – the language employed was often very different, Pew found. Republicans tended to use terms such as “Communist Party”, “[hold] accountable”, “investigation” and “lie”, while Democrats tended to use “Chinese virus” – often in the context of decrying its use and the prejudice it generated.Former president Donald Trump and members of his administration often referred to the pandemic as the “Chinese virus”, “Wuhan virus” or “kung flu”, a framing that analysts said deflected attention from Trump’s policy missteps and fuelled attacks on Asian-Americans.“For Republicans in particular, China serves as a convenient target for political attacks, often without regard for the impact those words may have on Chinese-Americans and others,” said Brett Bruen, president of Global Situation Room, a crisis management firm. “We should talk about policy differences and security concerns,” added Bruen, formerly White House head of global engagement. “Our leaders need to be much more responsible in such a combustible environment.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Impact – Inflation
Rubin 6/14 – Richard Rubin, reporter focusing on the intersection of taxes, politics and economics at The Wall Street Journal, “Republicans Aim to Combat Inflation With Tax, Trade Policies”, The Wall Street Journal, https://www.wsj.com/articles/gop-offers-tax-trade-policies-aimed-at-combating-inflation-11655222400, June 14, 2022, accessed 7-13-2022//Tata
WASHINGTON—Congressional Republicans are beginning to detail their plans to combat inflation and soften its impact on households, indicating some tax, trade and regulatory policies they might pursue if they take control of the House and Senate in this fall’s midterm elections. Sen. Chuck Grassley (R., Iowa) on Tuesday is proposing to adjust a tax-code provision for inflation and reduce some taxes on investments. Meanwhile, Republicans on the House Ways and Means Committee are outlining their anti-inflation agenda, calling for rescinding unused federal spending, reducing regulation and negotiating new trade agreements. The policies offer a preview of the fall midterm election campaign, where inflation is likely to be one of the core issues on voters’ minds as Republicans try to regain control of the House and Senate. But in the closely divided Congress, it is difficult to design politically viable legislative proposals that remove money from the economy or significantly reduce costs for businesses and households. “The Biden administration has offered no real solutions—just more Washington spending and higher taxes on Main Street businesses that will fuel higher prices in the future,” said Rep. Kevin Brady (R., Texas), the top Republican on the Ways and Means Committee. Republicans have focused on inflation, which hit 8.6% in May for its highest level since 1981, as Democrats’ greatest vulnerability this fall. They have argued that the Biden administration’s policies, including its push to enact a $1.9 trillion pandemic aid package in early 2021, have helped fuel price increases. President Biden has contended his policies spurred job growth and have helped fight the pandemic. He has also been calling out Republicans for lacking clear policies to fight inflation. He has emphasized the importance of the Federal Reserve but has also called for Congress to pass a law to subsidize household costs such as prescription drugs and child care as prices rise. “My plan is to make concrete—concrete, common-sense steps to bring down the biggest expenses that families are facing,” Mr. Biden said in a speech last month. The president has been trying to link Republicans to an idea from Sen. Rick Scott (R., Fla.) to impose minimum income taxes on all Americans. Mr. Scott last week reframed that proposal as a work requirement. The newest fiscal proposals from Republicans fit more squarely into conservative economic ideology, though all would be difficult to get through a divided Congress and past Mr. Biden, who would be able to veto any legislation passed by a Republican-controlled Congress. Mr. Grassley said his plans would encourage savings and cool demand as a way to combat inflation. He would change the income threshold for the 3.8% investment-income tax created in Obamacare. It currently starts once income reaches $200,000 for an individual and $250,000 for a married couple and doesn’t rise each year like other tax code provisions. He would raise the latter threshold to $400,000 and index both to inflation. Mr. Grassley would also exempt interest income from taxation—up to $300 for individuals and $600 for married couples. He would expand a tax credit for middle-income households to save for retirement and more than double the income levels at which capital gains and dividend income starts being taxed so that the 0% tax bracket for that investment income would end when income reaches $89,075 for individuals and $178,150 for married couples. “When people are encouraged to save, the more you save, it reduces demand. That helps inflation,” he said. “Hopefully the November elections make a big change and we’re able to move on these things in the next Congress.” Mr. Grassley would pay for those changes by extending—without indexing for inflation—the $10,000 cap on the state and local tax deduction. The House outline includes policies that Republicans have advocated before, including rescinding unused federal spending, extending expiring tax cuts, increasing energy production and removing some regulations. Extending tax cuts set to lapse after 2025 could put more money into the economy and be inflationary, but Republicans will advocate that as a way to spur growth.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Impact – Econ
Stein Tønnesson 15, Research Professor, Peace Research Institute Oslo; Leader of East Asia Peace program, Uppsala University, 2015, “Deterrence, interdependence and Sino–US peace,” International Area Studies Review, Vol. 18, No. 3, p. 297-311
Several recent works on China and Sino–US relations have made substantial contributions to the current understanding of how and under what circumstances a combination of nuclear deterrence and economic interdependence may reduce the risk of war between major powers. At least four conclusions can be drawn from the review above: first, those who say that interdependence may both inhibit and drive conflict are right. Interdependence raises the cost of conflict for all sides but asymmetrical or unbalanced dependencies and negative trade expectations may generate tensions leading to trade wars among inter-dependent states that in turn increase the risk of military conflict (Copeland, 2015: 1, 14, 437; Roach, 2014). The risk may increase if one of the interdependent countries is governed by an inward-looking socio-economic coalition (Solingen, 2015); second, the risk of war between China and the US should not just be analysed bilaterally but include their allies and partners. Third party countries could drag China or the US into confrontation; third, in this context it is of some comfort that the three main economic powers in Northeast Asia (China, Japan and South Korea) are all deeply integrated economically through production networks within a global system of trade and finance (Ravenhill, 2014; Yoshimatsu, 2014: 576); and fourth, decisions for war and peace are taken by very few people, who act on the basis of their future expectations. International relations theory must be supplemented by foreign policy analysis in order to assess the value attributed by national decision-makers to economic development and their assessments of risks and opportunities. If leaders on either side of the Atlantic begin to seriously fear or anticipate their own nation’s decline then they may blame this on external dependence, appeal to anti-foreign sentiments, contemplate the use of force to gain respect or credibility, adopt protectionist policies, and ultimately refuse to be deterred by either nuclear arms or prospects of socioeconomic calamities. Such a dangerous shift could happen abruptly, i.e. under the instigation of actions by a third party – or against a third party. Yet as long as there is both nuclear deterrence and interdependence, the tensions in East Asia are unlikely to escalate to war. As Chan (2013) says, all states in the region are aware that they cannot count on support from either China or the US if they make provocative moves. The greatest risk is not that a territorial dispute leads to war under present circumstances but that changes in the world economy alter those circumstances in ways that render inter-state peace more precarious. If China and the US fail to rebalance their financial and trading relations (Roach, 2014) then a trade war could result, interrupting transnational production networks, provoking social distress, and exacerbating nationalist emotions. This could have unforeseen consequences in the field of security, with nuclear deterrence remaining the only factor to protect the world from Armageddon, and unreliably so. Deterrence could lose its credibility: one of the two great powers might gamble that the other yield in a cyber-war or conventional limited war, or third party countries might engage in conflict with each other, with a view to obliging Washington or Beijing to intervene.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Impact – Econ
Tkacik, 20 --- PhD from the University of Maryland and a JD from Duke, professor of government at Stephen F Austin State University (4/21/2020, Michael, “Ingredients in place for new great power war; The Covid-19 pandemic may be the final toxin in a deadly political mix,” , accessed on 11/16/2020, JMP)
World War II The events leading to war in 1939 included a sharp division between the wealthy and everyone else, economic catastrophe in the Great Depression, sharp reductions in global trade, a breakdown in international cooperation, and the end of liberal governance in much of the world. Once again, these variables are present. Even before the Covid-19 pandemic, trade was decreasing and beggar-thy-neighbor economic policies had become the norm. It might be tempting to place this blame on Trump, but he was elected by people in his country who have suffered 40 years of criminal economic competition from China. It is no wonder they elected Trump and it is no wonder he undermined a global trade system that has failed America’s working class. Similarly, evidence of the breakdown of international cooperation and liberalism are everywhere. The world is unable to deal with the existential threat of climate change. Authoritarian regimes have seats on the UN Human Rights Council. There is a great and increasing gap between the wealthy and everyone else, a new Gilded Age. Liberalism, unable to cope, is in retreat everywhere, from the US and the UK to fledgling democracies in Eastern Europe and Latin America. Our world is gravely ill. Pandemic Into this morass we stir a global pandemic, with its origin in a corrupt, authoritarian state that is hostile to openness, human dignity and truth. That China denied and then exported the pandemic was as predictable as it is lamentable. The pandemic will bring a global economic depression, the only variable from World War II not present today. We should expect more governments to fall, we should expect liberalism to retreat further, and we should expect increased nationalism and violence upon our own species. In short, we are in for dark days. Dictators attempt to divert the attention of their people from corruption and injustice by seeking external enemies. Wars will therefore increase, and status quo powers such as the United States may attempt to defend a crumbling system. The chance of war between China and the United States has increased dramatically because almost all of the structural variables today point toward war. Both World War I and II were avoidable because different variables were present. Consequently, had skilled leadership been present, each war might have been avoided by correctly diagnosing the causes of the impending crises. That the wars were not avoided does not mean they could not have been; it simply means leadership was not up to the task. But today the causes of both of those wars have been combined in a single cauldron. So it is reasonable to ask, even with good leadership (of which there is no doubt we are lacking), can great-power war be avoided?
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves Growth
Abott 5/9/22 (Andrew Abott. Writer and Public affairs consultant. “Can a November Red Wave Save the U.S Economy Like Gingrich’s 94 Win?” Amac. May 9, 2022. https://amac.us/can-a-november-red-wave-save-u-s-economy-like-gingrichs-94-win/)
Today, Republican leaders should explicitly remind Americans of this history, and point out to voters that they have a similar opportunity before them. Just as George H.W. Bush handed his predecessor an economy that was rapidly recovering from recession only to have it wrecked by a Democrat president tacking left, Donald Trump gave Biden the strongest economic recovery in history. As we know, Biden proceeded to quickly squander it. Just as in 1994, however, the election of large Republican majorities in the House and Senate would produce an immediate change in the national morale and economic culture. Biden’s weak economy would begin turning around the day after the election. The results would be seen instantly. Coupled with a legislative agenda of strong pro-growth policies, a Republican Congress could go a long way toward saving the U.S. economy, creating jobs, and producing a rapid return to prosperity. And who knows—perhaps Biden would even have the sense to take a page out of Bill Clinton’s book, and race back to the political center to save his presidency, and the economy along with it.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › GOP Solves Growth
Rainey 21—Senior employment and immigration reporter for POLITCO (Rebecca Rainey, POLITICO, "Red states lead economic recovery, giving GOP ammo against Biden’s spending plans,” 6-24-2021, )// SBM
States with Republican governors are leading the recovery from the Covid-19 economic shock, complicating President Joe Biden’s push for a new sweeping infusion of federal aid. Of the 15 states that have returned to pre-pandemic levels of economic activity, 12 are led by Republican governors, shows. Of the 10 states reporting the lowest levels of activity since January 2020, seven — including New York, Pennsylvania and Illinois — are run by Democratic governors. Businesses, economists and policymakers are divided over whether conservative governors’ policies on jobless benefits and Covid-19 restrictions — many of them chose not to issue stay-at-home orders at all — are actually helping their economies or if their states’ industries simply didn’t fall as far behind during the pandemic. Red states are also reporting lower unemployment numbers. Still, the uneven recovery and the lackluster job growth reported in both April and May have given Republicans ammunition to repudiate Biden’s expensive aid plans. They’ve also ignited concerns among conservatives that the federal assistance — especially the $1.9 trillion American Rescue Plan that passed without GOP support in March — should have focused more on who needed help the most. “Across the board, there could have been a lot better use of the funds being more targeted,” Rachel Greszler, an economist at the Heritage Foundation, said. Congress should have linked unemployment insurance to workers’ earnings or allowed states to use federal aid to dole out their own benefits based on what the labor market required “in the ways that they thought would work best for them,” she said. The seven states that chose to not issue a stay-at-home order last year — Arkansas, Iowa, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Dakota, Wyoming and Utah — were all led by GOP governors. Republican-led states were also early to ease pandemic business restrictions and mask mandates: Missouri, Montana, Iowa and Alaska were some of the first states to peel back their business requirements in January and February. Texas, Arizona, Arkansas, New Hampshire and Wyoming followed in March. Of those states, Montana, New Hampshire, Arkansas, South Dakota, Utah, Missouri and Nebraska returned to pre-pandemic levels of economic activity in April and reported lower unemployment than the national 5.8 percent rate in May. By comparison, states that still have some coronavirus restrictions in place, including California, Connecticut and Hawaii, saw the highest rates of unemployment in the country in May and were still producing less in April than they did pre-pandemic. Washington lawmakers sent direct checks to millions of middle- and lower-income Americans and supplemented state unemployment benefits with extra weekly payments and coverage for workers traditionally ineligible for jobless aid. They also doled out $1 trillion in forgivable government-backed loans to small businesses under the Paycheck Protection Program, initially on a first-come, first-served basis. Other economists question whether Congress could have maneuvered as precisely as Greszler suggested to rescue the economy in the beginning, facing a flood of business closures and tens of millions of layoffs caused by the pandemic health restrictions. “There isn’t a lot of nuance that you can use in policy when you’re trying to get money out the door as quickly as possible and adjust for the local situations for every worker in the state,” said Daniel Zhao, senior economist at Glassdoor. “It’s very difficult to get aid out to everybody who needs it at the same time, and in a way that was actually targeted through individual situations.” The uneven nature of the recovery partly reflects the diversity of state economies. States like New York, California, Hawaii and Nevada that rely heavily on tourism, as well as food and accommodations, are some of the deepest in the economic hole and have the longest way to go, according to the Federal Reserve’s April State Coincident Index, which estimates economic conditions based on local employment and wage data matched to states’ GDP trends. As of April, Hawaii’s economic activity is 13 percent below where it was in January 2020, according to the index. Activity in Nevada and New York is also still down near 10 percent compared to before the pandemic. Florida, down just 1 percent, is doing better. But states including Utah, Idaho, South Dakota and Nebraska that rely largely on food processing and manufacturing — industries deemed essential and required to stay open during the pandemic — are getting back to normal much more quickly. “What we’re seeing is the states that were down the most at the beginning are still down the most, and those were basically the states that rely most on travel,” said Michael Ettlinger, founding director of the Carsey School of Public Policy at the University of New Hampshire. “There’s just more destruction, if you will, in those states, and it’s just going to take longer to come back.” The edge that GOP-led states such as Georgia, Mississippi, Arizona, and Missouri enjoy in rebounding from the pandemic has fueled Republican attacks against Biden’s policies. More than two dozen GOP governors have moved to end supplemental unemployment benefits funded by the federal government, citing labor shortages they say are triggered by the generosity. In Congress, Republican lawmakers are using a similar argument against Biden’s plans to spend $4 trillion shoring up the nation’s infrastructure and expanding social programs. “Our focus should be rebuilding the economy as quickly as possible, not subsidizing it,” said Sen. Mike Rounds (R-S.D.), who cited the extension of unemployment benefits an aid package pushed through by Democrats in March. Some economists say it’s unclear if generous unemployment benefits are a factor keeping jobs from being filled. from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce itself found the ratio of available workers to job openings is about what it was pre-pandemic. Before Covid, “businesses were struggling to fill openings because the available workers lacked the skills businesses needed,” senior economist Curtis Dubay wrote. “That issue persists now.” from the hiring website Indeed’s chief economist, Jed Kolko, found that job search activity in states ending the federal benefits saw a short, temporary jump on the platform shortly after governors announced they would do so. Economists, as well as the Biden administration, also say issues such as continuing day care struggles for parents, lingering fear of contracting the virus, and an economy that seems like it has gone from zero to 60 in a matter of weeks are probably having the strongest effect. “We’ve got this kind of race to the bottom, state-after-state, with Republican governors … ending benefits, and frankly, misleading people,” Senate Finance Chair Ron Wyden (D-Ore.) said. “They tried to make a big deal out of saying we’re cutting the $300 extra. That’s just not true. They’re cutting extra a week, they’re cutting the gig workers out, if someone has exhausted the state benefits.” With — disproportionately workers of color and women — facing “an income practically of zero … that makes the need for federal reform much more serious,” he said. “This crazy quilt of state systems that offer differing levels of data, unemployment benefits and approaches on reopening to me highlight the need, the urgency of fundamental reform,” Wyden said. He’s advocating for that would unite all states under one benefits infrastructure and create automatic triggers linking benefits to economic conditions, among other things. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and Wyden last year proposed extending the jobless benefit program until a state’s unemployment rate fell below 6 percent, but Republicans were hesitant to support a long-term extension of taxpayer-funded unemployment aid. If Congress had enacted that proposal last July, 27 states would currently have a low enough unemployment rate to phase out the extra $300 in extra benefits under the program. “Hopefully what this drives is a conversation after the pandemic is over on how to improve our safety net,” Zhao said, “not just in terms of expanding it but also making sure that it’s actually reaching the people it needs to and reaching them quickly when help is needed.”
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Gridlock Good
Conerly ’18 (Dr. Bill Conerly is a business-focused economist, Forbes contributor, and Duke Ph.D. He connects the dots between the economy and business decisions, “Post-Election Economic Forecast: Political Gridlock Will Be Good For Business”, 11/7/18, ) SM
The economy will do well with government control divided between Democrats and Republicans. I didn’t always believe this, but a decade ago I was persuaded by the late economist William A. Niskanen. "Our federal government may work better (well, less badly) when at least one house of Congress is controlled by the opposing party," he wrote. "Divided government is, curiously, less divisive. It’s also cheaper. The basic reason for this is simple: When one party proposes drastic or foolish measures, the other party can obstruct them. The United States prospers most when excesses are curbed, and, if the numbers from the past 50 years are any indication, divided government is what curbs them." Excesses have been evident since the election of Donald Trump, not only from the president’s Twitter account but also from his opponents. We’ve seen huge deficits from the party that used to be tight-fisted. We’ve seen draconian immigration actions. Global trade relations are in turmoil. Maybe some gridlock will be good for us. Niskanen, writing in 2006, found only two eras of fiscal restraint since World War II: the last six years of Eisenhower’s administration, and the last six years of the Clinton administration. In both eras, the opposition party controlled Congress. War also seems to be absent from periods of divided government. Niskanen also wrote: "In 200 years of U.S. history, every one of our conflicts involving more than a week of ground combat has been initiated by a unified government. Each of the four major American wars during the 20th century, for example—World War I, World War II, the Korean War, and the Vietnam War—was initiated by a Democratic president with the support of a Democratic Congress. The current war in Iraq, initiated by a Republican president and backed by a Republican Congress, is consistent with this pattern." Major government changes are likely to be stable when they are developed by divided government, Niskanen also argued. He cited Reagan tax cuts, approved by a Democrat-controlled House of Representatives. A more modern example is Obamacare, passed during one-party control, which the other party vowed to repeal as soon as possible. Although that repeal didn’t happen, the country continues to suffer from uncertainty about health care policy. The economy is not managed by the government, but by millions of individuals and companies trying to make the best choices for themselves. When the government does take action in the economic sphere, it’s not entirely for the public interest. We learned this from Niskanen’s most lasting contributions to economics, his theory of bureaucracy, part of public choice economics. He said that people in government are human, and their decisions will at least partially reflect their own ambitions. Bureaucrats want larger budgets and influence. Looking forward to 2019 and 2020, expect less extravagant federal spending growth—at least a little bit. Don’t expect major tax cuts again. Look for deregulation to continue in those areas where Congressional approval is not needed. This direction will be good for the economy. A president can do a good bit of mischief all by himself. Barack Obama campaigned in 2008 against too much presidential power accorded to George W. Bush, but changed his tune after he held power. A Democrat-controlled House of Representatives will not grant additional discretionary authority to the president, though they will be unable to roll back power granted by existing laws. Foreign trade is an area where past Congresses granted the president wide latitude—much to the regret of many existing members. Look for continued controversy here. Immigration is an area ripe for compromise, and maybe the odds are a little better now. But just a little. Nobody thinks current law is ideal, and nobody thinks current law is being enforced. But this may be too thorny an issue for Congress to resolve. That means immigration will continue to be low, exacerbating the tight labor market that has been caused by economic growth and demographic change. I recently wrote that the economy would probably not go into recession in 2019, but that we should all be prepared for the possibility. I stand by that statement even after the election results.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Gridlock Good
Fisher Investments 4/22 (Fisher Investments Canada uses historical information to analyze current market activity, uncovering the difference between potential and possible outcomes, writes for the Financial Post, “Why markets like political gridlock, according to Fisher Investments Canada”, 4/7/22, ) SM
How do elections influence equities? Many commentators we follow seem to have preconceived notions of which candidate or party is best for markets. But in Fisher Investments Canada’s view, equities don’t prefer any party or politician. We suggest investors set this view of party and personality aside. Instead, we think it is most helpful to assess political developments the way our research shows markets do: Will elections likely result in gridlock or not? Whilst it may seem counterintuitive, political gridlock is often a positive development for equities, in our view. Fisher Investments Canada defines gridlock as political conditions that make it difficult for a government to pass legislation. In our experience, many investors hate gridlock since it means governments don’t do much. We think most voters understandably want elected officials to get things they like done. But in our view, that preference for action can also make it harder to see political activity the way equities do—as we will explain. Gridlock can take various forms. One common version is a multiparty coalition with little ideological alignment. For example, Germany’s recently elected coalition combines left-leaning and right-leaning parties. They may command a majority on a combined basis, but our research shows the scope of action they agree on is narrow and centrist—not radical and sweeping—with little likely to get done. But we have seen ideologically aligned multiparty coalitions at loggerheads, too—when a far-left or far-right party differs from their more moderate counterparts in policy emphasis and implementation, as with the leftist and centre-left parties in Spain’s and Portugal’s governments. Similarly, we find minority governments are by definition gridlocked, as they must get dissenting parties’ support or agreement to abstain from voting to pass legislation—as is the case in Canada currently. Even in one-party majority governments, gridlock can stymie leadership’s agenda. Fisher Investments Canada has observed intraparty gridlock—divisions within the majority party—can also block government action. We saw this often in former U.S. President Donald Trump’s first two years, when his Republican Party had a majority in America’s Congress. We are seeing it again now under President Joe Biden’s Democratic Party, which also has majorities in both chambers of Congress. A leader with weak political capital may not be able to push bills through, either—even with a majority, a leader’s flagging popularity may result in a leadership struggle that often means legislative activity grinds to a halt, like in the UK now. Whatever gridlock’s form, it typically does two things. One, it can block big proposed legislation. Two, it can water down major proposals by forcing politicians to compromise—resulting in something less extreme versus initial expectations. Our research shows equities in competitive developed nations generally favour gridlock. Big legislative change (from any party) creates uncertainty, which we think can upset equities. Gridlock, in our view, reduces this likelihood. It prevents lawmakers from radically altering property rights or creating winners and losers through legislation, regulations and other government levers. This can reduce uncertainty over future tax rates, government interference, labour laws and other factors potentially affecting corporate profits. In our experience, all major change—no matter how well-intentioned—risks creating winners and losers. Behavioural finance research shows people hate losses more than they enjoy equivalent gains—a phenomenon psychologists term myopic loss aversion or prospect theory.[i] This can generate net negative sentiment when legislation creates winners and losers. Investors—and voters—aren’t always rational, according to prospect theory. Big change may benefit a party or parties’ constituents, but myopic loss aversion shows those who don’t benefit tend to take it much harder, which can outweigh any feeling of gain. For markets, this cognitive bias means any sweeping legislation—regardless of party—risks being a headwind. Additionally, big shifts in laws and rules governing commerce can complicate businesses’ ability to plan and invest. We think gridlock—for equities—lowers political uncertainty overall. So, how does a typical election cycle affect equities? We find elections often drive big emotions, as politicians cater to constituents’ biases, sowing uncertainty—who will and won’t benefit? This weighs on risk taking. When everything is up in the air, subject to change, it is difficult to see through the fog. In our experience, the prospect of political change can weigh on investors’ moods—e.g. uncertainty can make it harder for businesses to plan longer term. Not knowing what the political environment will be—and how it may affect businesses—can hamper their ability to make investment decisions, committing capital and resources. This could weigh on growth until the air clears and firms have more certainty to pursue big, strategic projects. But if the vote results in gridlock, lawmakers likely won’t be able to accomplish as much as they promised on the campaign trail. The election outcome plus gridlock lowers political uncertainty, giving businesses more clarity to proceed with long-term expansion and allowing them to take more risk than they otherwise might. This may be disappointing to some—and encouraging to others—but for markets, we think gridlock establishes a political environment in which little will likely change. That allows forward-looking markets to see further ahead, knowing the business framework firms are operating under probably won’t be toppled anytime soon. Our long read of history suggests politicians’ and government actions can be unpredictable. Gridlock cuts down on the uncertainty, leaving one less risk for equities to ponder—and an underappreciated market tailwind, in our view. Investing in equity markets involves the risk of loss and there is no guarantee that all or any capital invested will be repaid. Past performance is no guarantee of future returns. International currency fluctuations may result in a higher or lower investment return. This document constitutes the general views of Fisher Investments Canada and should not be regarded as personalised investment or tax advice or as a representation of its performance or that of its clients. No assurances are made that Fisher Investments Canada will continue to hold these views, which may change at any time based on new information, analysis or reconsideration. In addition, no assurances are made regarding the accuracy of any forecast made herein. Not all past forecasts have been, nor future forecasts will be, as accurate as any contained herein.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › Gridlock Good
Sears ’21 (Steven M. Sears is the president and COO of , a specialized, asset-management firm that was created to help high-net-worth investors add conservative options trading strategies to their portfolios. He also is a contributing columnist at Barron’s where he writes the Striking Price, “Wall Street Likes Gridlock in D.C. Here’s How to Play It”, 11/5/21, ) SM
The greatest investment opportunity in the world might be America’s political dysfunction and division. The outcome of various state elections on Tuesday suggests that the November 2022 midterm Congressional elections might lead to even more gridlock in Congress. If that happens, the stock and options market should flourish as investors position for the end of legislation that targets businesses and the wealthy. The inability of Democrats to win the governor’s office in Virginia—a state handily won by President Joe Biden—and the closeness of other state races, suggests that whatever the Federal Reserve does to interest rates may be overshadowed by Congressional gridlock. The next few months will be critical in seeing how this nascent thesis evolves, but Washington’s wish to regulate Wall Street and raise taxes suddenly seems less certain to come true. The 2022 midterm elections are a long way off for investors, but politicians and their campaign operatives likely feel extraordinary urgency and risk. The midterms will contest 34 of 100 Senate seats, and the entire House of Representatives. If the Republicans gain control of even one house of Congress, Biden will become powerless to accomplish much of anything, and many investment-risk factors will fade. “Wall Street loves gridlock in Washington because it tends to preserve the status quo,” Michael Schwartz, Oppenheimer & Co.’s chief options strategist, told Barron’s. Schwartz noted that political developments are a potential antidote to the normalization of the Fed’s easy-money policies. Until someone invents a way to make targeted investments on political dysfunction, the financial sector remains one of the top ways to position. Finance is heavily regulated and the inability of Congress to pass restrictive laws generally means banks and brokerage firms thrive. We have previously recommended financial stocks as a way to, and brokers, such as (ticker: IBKR) as from volatility and trading volumes. Those approaches still make sense, as does private equity, but for a slightly different reason. Investing in private equity companies expresses confidence in the ability of those firms to proactively deal with whatever develops. Consider (KKR), a company we when the stock was around $56.71. Since then, the stock has surged, and the company continues to seem well positioned. , while distributable earnings, or cash that could be returned to shareholders, spiked. For the third quarter, distributable earnings totaled $925.1 million, or $1.05 a share, up from $452.8 million, or 53 cents a share in the same year-ago period. Investors who like the looks of those earnings can consider harnessing the stock in the options market. With KKR at $83.31, investors can sell the March $80 put for about $4.50 and buy the March $85 call for about $5.20. The risk reversal—that is selling a put and buying a call with a higher strike price but same expiration—positions investors to buy the stock at a lower price, while enabling them to participate in any gains. Should KKR be below $80 at expiration, investors are obligated to buy the stock or adjust the position in the options market to avoid assignment. If the stock is at $100, for instance, the call is worth $15. During the past 52 weeks, the stock has ranged from $35.32 to $83.44. Shares are up 106% this year. Without doubt, the trade expresses great confidence in KKR, but faith in the company has been well rewarded since the company was first mentioned here in August 2016 as a stock that was reversing years of mixed performance. Steven M. Sears is the president and chief operating officer of Options Solutions, a specialized asset-management firm. Neither he nor the firm has a position in the options or underlying securities mentioned in this column. Email:
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › 2nc – Impact
Mann ’14 [Eric; 2014; special agent with a United States federal agency, a special assistant for a U.S. Senator and served as a presidential appointee for the U.S. Congress, Graduate Degree in Homeland Security at Georgetown; “Austerity, Economic Decline, and Financial Weapons of War: A New Paradigm for Global Security,” https://jscholarship.library.jhu.edu/bitstream/handle/1774.2/37262/MANN-THESIS-2014.pdf]
The conclusions reached in this thesis demonstrate how economic considerations within states can figure prominently into the calculus for future conflicts. The findings also suggest that security issues with economic or financial underpinnings will transcend classical determinants of war and conflict, and change the manner by which rival states engage in hostile acts toward one another. The research shows that security concerns emanating from economic uncertainty and the inherent vulnerabilities within global financial markets will present new challenges for national security, and provide developing states new asymmetric options for balancing against stronger states. The security areas, identified in the proceeding chapters, are likely to mature into global security threats in the immediate future. As the case study on South Korea suggest, the overlapping security issues associated with economic decline and reduced military spending by the United States will affect allied confidence in America’s security guarantees. The study shows that this outcome could cause regional instability or realignments of strategic partnerships in the Asia-pacific region with ramifications for U.S. national security. Rival states and non-state groups may also become emboldened to challenge America’s status in the unipolar international system. The potential risks associated with stolen or loose WMD, resulting from poor security, can also pose a threat to U.S. national security. The case study on Pakistan, Syria and North Korea show how financial constraints affect weapons security making weapons vulnerable to theft, and how financial factors can influence WMD proliferation by contributing to the motivating factors behind a trusted insider’s decision to sell weapons technology. The inherent vulnerabilities within the global financial markets will provide terrorists’ organizations and other non-state groups, who object to the current international system or distribution of power, with opportunities to disrupt global finance and perhaps weaken America’s status. A more ominous threat originates from states intent on increasing diversification of foreign currency holdings, establishing alternatives to the dollar for international trade, or engaging financial warfare against the United States.
2022
Michigan
Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Impacts › 2nc – Impact
Crowley 22 (Monica Crowley is Assistant Secretary for Public Affairs for the U.S. Department of the Treasury from 2019 – 2021, “Red States Lead Economically, Despite Biden”, Newsweek, , 4/4/22, accessed 7-13-2022) AC
President Joe Biden's disastrous economic policies—higher taxes, uncontrolled spending, oppressive regulations, suffocation of our energy sector—are sending the U.S. economy into a slowdown. His assault on economic freedom is giving us skyrocketing inflation, an ongoing labor crunch and continuing disruptions to the supply chain—all of which are crippling an already fragile recovery. Despite these darkening economic clouds, however, there is a bright spot: red states. Since pandemic restrictions began to recede in mid-2020, states led by Republican governors and state legislatures have been engines of economic dynamism. Month after month, red states have outperformed the national economic recovery and continue to outshine their blue state counterparts. Consider the most recent state jobs report for February. Once again, states with Republican governors took 15 of the top 20 spots for jobs recovered since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, and 17 of the top 20 have GOP-led legislatures. In fact, nine Republican states have emerged from the pandemic with more jobs than when the pandemic hit: Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Montana, Tennessee, Texas and Utah. And 12 states with Republican-controlled legislatures are now seeing record-low unemployment rates. It's a prime example of why policy matters. Biden might try to take credit for this economic comeback, but any progress made is despite—not because of—his destructive policies. Democrats insisted on keeping our country locked down without justification in order to amass ever-greater power and control. They ran mom-and-pop shops into the ground, sinking life's savings, destroying livelihoods and shattering dreams. Long after the acute crisis had ended, Democrats disincentivized work by actively paying Americans to stay home. Many blue states continued to offer an additional $300 per week on top of normal state unemployment payments. This additional cash didn't expire until September 6, 2021—a year and a half after the start of the pandemic. It's no wonder that as many as 1.8 million Americans turned down jobs, with an estimated 37% of workers making more money from unemployment and other state benefits than they would from actually working a job.In fact, unfilled job openings are still at a near-record high and employers are struggling to fill open positions. A recent survey found that 48% of small businesses were hiring or trying to hire, and 93% said there were "few or no qualified job applicants." The latest data still show a staggering 11.3 million job openings, even though there are 6.2 million unemployed Americans trying to find a job. Employees aren't the only resource businesses are struggling to find. Thanks in large part to Biden's out-of-control spending, inflation has hit its highest mark in 40 years. More than 25% of small businesses say inflation is the number one problem they face. Everything from gas to groceries now costs dramatically more, making it pricier for businesses to get the supplies they need—if they can get them at all. The supply chain crisis has caused delays and shortages, making it difficult for businesses to get certain goods and often resulting in higher prices for those of us trying to buy things. All of this has created a hostile business environment that has killed jobs and unnecessarily slowed our economic recovery. To make matters worse, the Federal Reserve is going to try—belatedly—to rein in galloping inflation by tightening the money supply. That is likely to create a perfect economic storm of little-to-no growth accompanied by high inflation, resulting in a painful recession. But thanks to pro-growth policies—lower taxes, fewer regulatory burdens, no mandates and greater individual liberty—the recovery in states with Republican leadership has been noticeably faster and more significant. Not only have red states returned to, or exceeded, their pre-pandemic employment numbers, but residents are also seeing higher incomes. Nine of the top 10 states with the greatest personal income growth in 2021 are led by Republican governors.