Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Current and older evidence is free during beta. Sign in for unlimited card access and full source downloads.

Matching cards
2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Internals › Base

Base turnout is key for Democrat Victory – without leftist turnout loss is inevitable

Milligan 6-3 (Susan Milligan. Senior political writer at U.S. News & World Report. She has covered domestic and foreign politics for 35 years, from New York City Hall to the Albany statehouse, and from Eastern Europe and the Middle East to Congress and the White House, “Midterm Math Works Against Democrats With Senate at Stake”, US News, 6-3-22, ) - aagg

Joe Biden can thank record voter turnout, women, Black and Latino Americans, young people and voters eager to get Donald Trump out of office for the Democratic president's 2020 victory. Unfortunately for Biden and his Democratic Party, the voters expected to turn out this fall will be fewer, older, more likely to be white – and eager to take out their frustrations on the party in charge. Those historical voting patterns are a big reason why Democrats face such daunting challenges this fall as they struggle to hang onto razor-thin majorities in Congress. And it has Democrats scrambling to find ways to tweak the turnout machine in key states, where even a shift of a single percentage point in a voter group could decide who controls the Senate next year. Not only are minority and young voters typically less likely to vote in midterm elections, but the people who are inclined to turn out are in a mood to punish – and that means voting out incumbents, says Matt Grossman, director of the Institute for Public Policy and Social Research at Michigan State University. "It's better to say that you've done something," if you are the party in power, "but you can't expect that to overwhelm the basic dynamic – and that is that people are more motivated by something that has happened that they didn't like than that they did like," Grossman says. Record high jobs creation? That's not resonating much with voters upset about inflation that is at a 40-year high, experts say. Record numbers of Black women being named to judicial posts by the Biden administration? The voters who are thrilled by that development can't match the motivation of parents convinced their K-12 children are being made to feel guilty in the classroom for America's history of slavery and racism. An anticipated Supreme Court opinion undoing guaranteed abortion rights could well propel disaffected Democratic voters to the polls in some areas of the country, making a pivotal difference in key races, analysts say. With the governor poised to be the one-person roadblock to abortion bans in several states, pro-abortion rights voters may be more motivated to turn out, casting votes for Democrats up and down the ballot. But Democrats still suffer from basic math that disadvantages the party in midterms. Voters 18-29 made up 17% of the 2020 electorate and voted heavily for Biden. In 2014, the last midterm where a Democrat was president, young voters made up just 13% of the electorate. In several states – notably Wisconsin, Georgia and Arizona – small shifts could decide whether Biden will have a Democratic or GOP-run Senate next year. But the peculiar natures of those states' electorates and candidates could make this fall far less predictable, analysts and political operatives say. In Georgia, slight upticks in turnout by women and Black voters helped Biden eke out a dramatic 2020 victory there and helped put Democrats Sen. Raphael Warnock and Sen. Jon Ossoff over the top in 2021 runoffs, flipping control of the Senate to Democrats. If typical midterm trends stayed the same, Warnock would likely lose to a Republican. But "there are a couple of wild cards in the mix here" that make the race far more competitive, says political science professor Alan Abramowitz, an expert on polling and elections at Emory University.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Internals › Youth Voters Key

Youth Voter Turnout is key for victory – Biden needs to find way for progress

Brownstein 3/22 (Ronald Brownstein, Senior Policy analyst at CNN, Atlantic Media’s editorial director, “Youth turnout could save, or sink, Democrats in 2022”, CNN, 3/22/22, ) – aagg

Soaring turnout and big margins among young voters were central to the Democratic victories in the 2018 congressional and 2020 presidential elections. But with many young people expressing disenchantment with President Joe Biden’s performance, preserving those advantages looms as one of the biggest challenges facing Democrats in the 2022 midterms. There’s widespread concern among Democrats that turnout for young people this November could fall back from its gains in 2018 toward the meager levels that contributed to the party’s crushing losses in the 2014 and 2010 midterm elections. “If you accept the status quo with young people, it’s not going to go great,” says Democratic pollster Ben Tulchin. “Turnout is not going to be good.” Most Republicans are expecting exactly that sort of decline, driven both by waning enthusiasm for Biden and diminishing concern about Donald Trump, whose visibility has dimmed since he left the White House. “We are seeing that younger voters who were voting in some of these elections because of Trump don’t seem to be inspired by Biden, and I think their turnout will fall back to traditional levels,” says GOP consultant John Brabender. Some structural dynamics may help to sustain youth turnout this fall. Many experts note that the large youth turnout of 2018 and 2020 creates momentum for continued participation, because people who register and vote in one election are more likely to vote in the next. Over the past two elections, Democrats and nonpartisan groups have built a significant organizational infrastructure to engage more young voters, and those efforts are continuing through 2022. “The elevated youth turnout and the elevated youth registration and participation that we saw from ’16 to ‘18 to ‘20 is not magic,” says Nsé Ufot, chief executive officer of the New Georgia Project, a non-profit voter registration and mobilization group founded by Stacey Abrams. “It is absolutely a direct result of our investment and our labor and targeting that particular group.” et many strategists focusing on the youth vote agree that these factors may not be enough to prevent a significant fall-off without changes in the political environment. One key for Democrats will be finding ways to raise the visibility of Trump, who was deeply unpopular with the youngest voters. Even more important may be Biden finding ways to generate more progress than he has so far on issues important to younger generations, particularly combating climate change and reducing the burden of student debt. “My stern warning to the Biden administration and Democrats is you have to take this seriously, because if we do go back to a 2010 or 2014 model where they really fall off it’s going to make it very difficult for us in November,” says Tulchin, who served as the pollster for Bernie Sanders during the 2020 primary campaign, when the senator from Vermont dominated Biden among younger voters.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Internals › Suburban Voters Key

Suburban women k2 midterms – Roe v. Wade proves

Beckwith and Korte 2022-- Ryan Teague Beckwith, Reporter in Bloomberg News' Washington, D.C., Gregory Korte, national political correspondent for Bloomberg News, “1 voting group holds key to midterms after abortion leak: Suburban women”, The Virginian-Pilot, , May 4, 2022, accessed 7-14-2022//Tata

Suburban women could now tip the balance in the midterm elections that will decide control of Congress after a leaked draft opinion indicated the Supreme Court was poised to overturn Roe v. Wade. Their votes helped determine the winner in the last two presidential contests. With Republicans in position to seize the House and Senate, the race is on to shock into action those with the most at stake on an issue that has become a fiercely contested partisan issue. The fight to win them over and get them to the ballot box will be most heated in the 24 states where bans would take immediate effect. But both Republican and Democratic strategists say that the country is in uncharted territory on an issue where public policy has been relatively stable since the landmark decision almost four decades ago. It remains to be seen if it’s a strong enough factor to influence key races and displace inflation as the biggest worry among a slice of the population struggling with the spiraling cost of living and ideologically slotted at the political center. Even though a large majority of women say abortion should be legal in all or most cases, Democrats will have to convince them that it is more pressing than every other issue boosting Republicans’ odds in November. President Joe Biden defeated Donald Trump in 2020 by winning over women outside urban centers and with strong support from them in places like Georgia. Republicans, who generally cheer the Supreme Court’s decision, had sought to make Biden’s poor approval rating and inflation the top issues for voters. The GOP has also tried to erode Democrats’ advantage among women with issues like school closures, curricula and mask mandates for schoolchildren. Melita Easters, executive director of Georgia WIN List, which seeks to elect Democratic women who favor abortion rights, said that the court’s decision would dramatically boost turnout among women in the November midterm elections. Democrats currently control both chambers by a razor-thin majority. “Suburban areas where women have been on the fence and voted either way based on the candidate, this is going to push them to Democrats,” she said. Biden won suburban women 59% to Trump’s 40%, according to AP VoteCast, a survey of more than 110,000 voters. Vicky Hausman, co-founder of Forward Majority, which seeks to win Democratic state legislative races, pointed to the Virginia governor’s race last year, where she said a strong focus on protecting abortion rights by Democratic candidate Terry McAuliffe boosted turnout but was not enough for him to beat Republican Glenn Youngkin, who focused on education issues. “In Virginia last year, it was a key issue for Democrats, but not a big enough wedge to win,” she said. Republicans were already reminding voters on Tuesday that other issues were driving their voters. “This is an important issue to many people,” said Florida Senator Rick Scott, chairman of the National Republican Senatorial Committee. “But so is inflation, so is crime, so is the border. People are going to be passionate about this and we ought to be passionate about what we believe in.” The draft Supreme Court decision overturning Roe was published by Politico Monday night, so it’s still too soon to show up in polling, and state laws would not change until the decision is issued, potentially in late June or early July. The high court’s final opinion could also be less dramatic than the draft by Justice Samuel Alito. But strategists say that the issue is most likely to be a major factor in four states with competitive governor’s races where bans would immediately go into effect this summer if Roe is overturned: Arizona, Georgia, Michigan and Wisconsin. That’s especially true in Georgia, where incumbent Republican Gov. Brian Kemp, currently leading in polls, signed the abortion ban into effect in 2019. An Atlanta Journal-Constitution poll in January showed more than two-thirds of Georgia voters wanted Roe v. Wade to remain in place. A higher turnout among abortion rights supporters in governor’s races could also boost Senate candidates in competitive races in Arizona, Georgia and Wisconsin. Women tend to hold more liberal positions on abortion than men, but are also more polarized on the issue. A third of all women say abortion should be legal in all cases, while 19% of men hold that position. At the other end, 18% of women say abortion should be illegal in all cases, compared to 13% of men. Opinions on the 1973 Supreme Court decision have remained largely consistent over the years. A 2021 Gallup poll found 58% opposed overturning Roe v. Wade, a nearly identical numbers to results on the same question in 1989. But the enthusiasm gap on the issue has grown over the past two decades, with 30% of self-described “pro-life” voters saying they would vote for a candidate only who shares their views on abortion, according to Gallup. Only 19% of voters who favor abortion rights similarly insist that candidates they support hold their views. In 2000, those numbers were roughly equal at 20% or so. That could change if Roe v. Wade is overturned.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Internals › Suburban Voters Key

Suburban Women are key for Democrat victory – 2020 proves

Balz and Sotomayor 5/16 (Don Balz, Chief Correspondent covering national politics since 1978, Master’s in communications from University of Illinois, Marianna Sotomayor, Congressional Reporter covering the house, Masters in Strategic Communication from George Washington University, "Key demographics for the 2022 midterm elections”, Washington Post, 5/16/22, ) – aagg

In almost every election, suburban voters play a critical role, and they will again in November. During the Trump years, many suburban voters, especially women, shifted toward the Democrats. A primary reason was the revulsion many of them felt toward President Donald Trump. Democrats hoped that shift signaled a more permanent alignment, and it’s true that some college-educated White women became a key part of the Democratic constituency. But what happened in the 2021 Virginia gubernatorial race raised doubts about their reliability as Democrats. Then-candidate and now-Gov. Glenn Youngkin was able to move the suburban vote back in the Republicans’ direction. “They weren’t flaming liberals,” GOP pollster Whit Ayres said of the suburban women who backed Democrats in 2018 and 2020. “There was a reaction against Trump.” Today, said GOP pollster Kristen Soltis Anderson, “They’re quite up for grabs.” Democratic pollster Celinda Lake agreed that her party’s candidates cannot take suburban women for granted in November. “Women elected Biden for stability and in reaction to Trump," she said. “They really rejected his style of leadership. But we had one woman say in a focus group, ‘I just want to get off this roller coaster.’ ” Under Biden so far, she added, "They’re getting no help in doing that.” Lake offered that assessment before the leak of a Supreme Court draft ruling that would overturn Roe v. Wade. That decision, if it comes early this summer, would give Democrats an issue to counter Republicans in the competition for the votes of suburban women. Republican strategists argue that unlike in 2020, they can now rely on suburban men turning out for their candidates after seeing many anti-Trump GOP voters swing back to the party this cycle. “Suburban women have moved so far the opposite direction, we’re not going to get all of them back right away. But if we can at least win back a good amount of the suburban men that we lost and some of the suburban women, that’s a formula for us to win in pretty much every state that we need to win in,” said a Senate GOP strategist, who spoke on the condition of anonymity so they could speak openly about the races they are working on. The bottom line is that any notable move by suburban voters in the direction of the Republicans this fall will prove costly to Democratic hopes of holding down their losses. But a Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade could counter GOP efforts to woo suburban women.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Internals › Suburban Voters Key

Suburban Voters are key to Democrat success – they turned the tides in 2018

Manchester 2/16 (Julia Manchester, Political Reporter at The Hill, Master's degree in political science from American University's School of Public Affairs, “Democrats seek midterm course-correct in suburbs”, The Hill, 2/16/22, ) – aagg

Democrats are seeking a course correction in the suburbs ahead of November’s midterms as recent elections show the voting bloc beginning to trend Republican. Suburban voters helped boost Democrats during the 2018 midterms in what was seen as a rebuke of then-President Trump. That rebuke continued in 2020, as the group proved valuable to President Biden’s victory, as well as Democratic wins down the ballot. But last year’s elections in Virginia and New Jersey saw Republicans make gains with the demographic, thanks in part to mounting frustration with rising prices, coronavirus restrictions and education-related issues. Republicans are working to again pin the blame for those frustrations on Democrats ahead of November. Democrats, meanwhile, are working to persuade suburban voters they can be trusted with the issues voters care about most. Polling shows Democrats have their work cut out for them. A Harvard CAPS-Harris Poll survey released last month showed that 57 percent of suburban voters said they are more likely to vote for a Republican candidate in the midterms, while 43 percent said they would be more likely to vote for a Democratic candidate. Meanwhile, a Reuters-Ipsos poll released last month showed Biden losing ground with the suburban voters who helped elect him in 2020. Only 41 percent of suburban voters said they approved of the job the president was doing. “The reality of these midterms is they’re going to be difficult for Democrats as they sort of historically are for the party in power in Washington,” said Heather Williams, executive director at the Democratic Legislative Campaign Committee. New Jersey Gov. Phil Murphy (D), who also serves as the vide chair of the Democratic Governors Association and who won reelection in 2021 by a far narrower margin than expected, conducted a series of focus groups in the Garden State to further understand why constituents were exhibiting signs of discontent. The New York Times reported last week that the governor’s advisers found widespread frustrations pertaining to public health measures.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Disinformation

Disinformation will target US elections—red states are passing voting laws to try and minimize fraud

ARIANA FIGUEROA 6/22/22 (ARIANA FIGUEROA covers the nation's capital for States Newsroom. Her areas of coverage include politics and policy, lobbying, elections and campaign finance, “U.S. House members warned about disinformation in upcoming campaigns,” Missouri Independent, https://missouriindependent.com/briefs/u-s-house-members-warned-about-disinformation-in-upcoming-campaigns/)-AM//7-14-22

Rep. Teresa Leger Fernandez, D-N.M., said that this is not the first time targeted disinformation has been used in elections. She pointed to the 2016 election, where Black and Latino voters were targeted, receiving text messages that they could cast their vote for Democratic candidate Hillary Clinton on their phones instead of going to a voting location. “Electoral lies do have consequences,” Fernandez said. She asked Yosef Getachew, the Media & Democracy Program director at the government watchdog group Common Cause, how Congress can make sure that presidential electors are accurately certifying election results. The House panel looking at the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol is examining slates of pro-Trump  in seven states. Getachew said that Congress needs to tackle election reform, and pointed to Republican-led states that are enacting restrictive voting laws in response to the 2020 presidential election. Since 2021,18 states have passed 34 restrictive voting laws,  He added that states are also moving to pass election interference laws that could change how elections are conducted and how results are determined. Six state legislatures — Alabama, Arizona, Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, and Oklahoma — have passed nine election interference laws, The ranking Republican on the panel, Rep. Bryan Steil, R-Wis., said there were more pressing issues to hold a hearing on and that the federal government should not be determining what is true and what is false. “Americans are capable of forming their own opinions,” he said. Steil criticized the Biden administration for trying to put together a Disinformation Governance Board that aimed to combat disinformation.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Disinformation

Cybersecurity threats will undermine midterms (fix tag*)

Marks 22 - (Joseph Marks, Reporter for The Cybersecurity 202 newsletter focused on the politics of cyber, "Election officials want more funds to combat midterm election cyber threats," Washington Post, 2-17-2022, https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2022/02/17/election-officials-want-more-funds-combat-midterm-election-cyber-threats/, LASA-AS)

Election officials are facing a barrage of cybersecurity threats as the midterms approach. But chances are slim that Congress will pitch in any money to help out. Their wish list includes: More cyber testing for election office computer networks. Cyber training for election workers and volunteers. Better physical security to ensure outsiders and rogue staffers can’t monkey with election machines so they’re unsafe to use. That’s on top of money they need for a suite of non-cyber challenges, including replacing staff who’ve quit amid a wave of death threats against election workers, inspired by former president Donald Trump’s false claims of election fraud, as Mike DeBonis and Amy Gardner report. Recent challenges The money crunch is a common dilemma for election officials who’ve faced one crisis after another in recent years, including Russian interference in the 2016 contest, the coronavirus pandemic and disinformation campaigns about elections from foreign and domestic sources. Congress has kicked in to help — including about $800 million for election security between 2016 and 2020 along with another $400 million to run safe elections during the coronavirus pandemic. But that’s only a fraction of what officials have said is necessary to make elections as secure as possible. “When election officials don’t have sufficient funds to run elections, they have to make tough choices and the truth is those choices can adversely impact the accessibility and security of elections,” David Levine, an election integrity fellow at the German Marshall Fund’s Alliance for Securing Democracy, told me. The big ask Election funding proposals have ranged from $20 billion sought by Democratic election officials to a more modest request for $5 billion in the next budget cycle. The Bipartisan Policy Center has suggested spending about $400 million annually on elections and focusing on ideas favored by Republicans and Democrats. But bipartisan consensus is a long way off. Most Democratic proposals link election security efforts with measures to make voting easier — which Republicans oppose. Republicans, who’ve generally been skeptical of federal funding for elections, aren’t keen on pitching in more money regardless.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Disinformation

Midterms face cybersecurity challenges

Cassidy 7/7 - (Christina A. Cassidy, Reporter for AP's state government team with a focus on voting election administration and efforts to secure U.S. elections, "Election officials face security challenges before midterms," AP NEWS, 7-7-2022, https://apnews.com/article/2022-midterm-elections-russia-ukraine-voting-presidential-local-89f03587e105290deddc647d43dd6960, LASA-AS)

BATON ROUGE, La. (AP) — Election officials preparing for the upcoming midterms face a myriad of threats, both foreign and domestic, as they look to protect voting systems and run a smooth election while fighting a wave of misinformation that has been undermining public confidence in U.S. elections. The nation’s top state election officials gathered Thursday for the start of their annual summer conference, with a long list of challenges that begins with securing their voting systems. While a top concern heading into the 2020 presidential election was Russia or another hostile nation waging a disruptive cyberattack, the landscape has expanded to include ransomware, politically motivated hackers and insider threats. Over the last year, a small number of security breaches have been reported at local election offices in which authorities are investigating whether office staff improperly accessed or provided improper access to sensitive voting technology. Jen Easterly, who leads the nation’s cybersecurity agency, said Russia, China and North Korea remain “very dynamic and complex cyber threats” and that criminal gangs pushing ransomware were also a concern. But she noted election security officials could not afford to prioritize one over the other.“We can’t just worry about one thing because if we focus too intently on one set of threats, we’re very likely to miss them coming from another direction,” Easterly told reporters, after a series of private meetings with state election officials. The U.S. Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency has been conducting physical assessments for state and local election officials, which includes site visits and reviews of security procedures such as video surveillance and access controls. Physical security has always been a concern but an onslaught of threats since 2020 targeting election officials have added urgency to the effort. State and local election officials have reported being harassed in person and receiving death threats over social media and text message. “We’re seeing an exodus of people in the field. And some of it does relate to just the physical security threats that they’re facing,” said Kim Wyman, who leads election security efforts for the cybersecurity agency. “And what we’re trying to do with this is give them tools to be able to to deal with that.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Disinformation

The DHS suspects Russia of developing new campaigns to skew US elections through disinformation--- promises a Republican midterm victory.

Carvin 7/11/2022- (Stephanie Carvin teaches international relations at Carleton University and is a contributing author to the Centre for International Governance Innovation.“ U.S. Authorities Brace for Russian Interference in Midterms” Accessed 7/11/22 -kg-

While millions have been captivated by the dramatic testimony in the congressional hearings into the Jan. 6, 2021, insurrection in Washington, D.C., Western officials are looking ahead to how threats to democratic processes, particularly elections, may unfold in advance of the 2022 midterm elections. In particular, officials from the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) have issued warnings that Russia is seeking to exploit real or perceived election irregularities to sow doubts about the legitimacy of democratic systems. According to media reports, such efforts may include small-scale hacks of local election authorities, designed to draw notice, and then the exploitation of the discovery of those cyber intrusions to raise doubts about the legitimacy of election results. Such tactics will complement and amplify conspiracy theories, promoted by former President Donald Trump and his followers, that "the system is rigged" and unfair. For Russia to engage in these tactics would represent another evolution in its overall strategy to undermine confidence in Western democratic systems—a strategy that has come a long way since 2016. At that time, Russia sent human sources to gather information about the U.S. political system—to find ways to support Trump's presidential campaign using social media. This activity was bolstered through a "hack and dump" effort, where Russian-backed actors broke into the accounts of Democratic Party officials in order to "leak" their data in ways that amplified conspiracies around the party and Hillary Clinton. These "malinformation" campaigns (whereby malicious actors use "information that stems from the truth but is often exaggerated in a way that misleads and causes potential harm") have evolved. In 2017, Russian-backed hackers obtained access to 9 gigabytes of then-presidential candidate Emmanuel Macron's documents and published them on the internet. However, this time the hackers were more ambitious in their approach, seeking to plant fake information within the stolen messages. That "information" included fraudulent claims that Macron held offshore accounts in the Cayman Islands to evade taxes. Other countries have also raised concerns that Russia (and other authoritarian states) no longer seek to sway elections for particular candidates but are instead engaged in a long-term strategy of discrediting democratic institutions. By doing so, they likely aim to increase dysfunction and division within Western countries and lessen the appeal of democracy worldwide.However, the recent DHS warning is so far the most specific, and may reflect an effort to "prebunk" the threat—that is, to call out malicious behavior before it occurs to disrupt it or mitigate its impact. In addition, it's important not to overplay the "Russian bot" narrative. Humans have agency and are more likely to be swayed by domestic actors and influencers than by anonymous social media accounts. However, online disinformation networks have developed over the last decade, many fed by Russian-amplified antisemitic, anti-LGBTQ+, anti-immigrant and anti-globalist conspiracy theories. As a growing far-right media ecosystem and political actors have adopted these narratives, they have become more potent. Given Trump's continuing loud championing of the idea that the 2020 election was stolen, we can expect domestic actors in Western countries to adopt these narratives should a Russian hack (deliberately or not) be discovered. Accordingly, election officials will have to be prepared to be as transparent as possible with the public and to issue warnings in advance of and possibly during elections. Governments need to do their best to secure election systems and the networks behind them to try to prevent hacks in the first place. Social media companies, many of which have a very mixed track record in dealing with misinformation, disinformation and malinformation on their platforms, will need to look for coordinated inauthentic activity promoting false narratives. Finally, and most concerning, governments will need to prepare for increasing attacks, some violent, on democratic and other societal institutions. In recent weeks there has been media reporting documenting the abuse of election workers in the United States who are seen as part of a great conspiracy to steal elections. A Reuters investigation found more than 100 examples of threats of death or violence to election workers by Trump supporters, resulting in only four arrests. While this abuse is disturbing on its face, it has a wider impact: These threats may make it hard to recruit the election volunteers and front-line workers on whom Western democratic systems rely. Moreover, when election results are disputed, individuals who are convinced their votes have been stolen may attack the very institutions that play a role in solving disputes and settling matters. Already there have been numerous threats against judges involved in hearings of individuals accused of participating in the Jan. 6 attack on Capitol Hill. Similarly, in Canada, judges presiding over trials involving so-called freedom convoy supporters have received threats to their physical safety. The existence of networks of individuals primed to receive and believe conspiracy-driven narratives, and of adversarial states willing to exploit them for their own ends, presents a real challenge for Western countries. As Russia seeks to distract North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) democracies from their efforts in Ukraine, we can expect further efforts to amplify and encourage domestic extremists who seek to remedy their grievances through the threat of violence.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Disinformation

Plan solves disinformation, which hurts Republicans

Panetta & Haltiwanger 6/9 - (Grace Panetta and John Haltiwanger, Senior politics reporters at Business Insider with a focus on elections and security, "Top Senate Democrats sound the alarm about Russian interference in the 2022 midterms," Business Insider, 6-9-2022, https://www.businessinsider.com/senate-dems-sound-the-alarm-about-russian-interference-in-2022-2022-6, LASA-AS)

Prominent right wing figures in the US, including Fox News host Tucker Carlson, have echoed Russia's propaganda and disinformation on Ukraine. Russian state TV has recycled and applauded Carlson's commentary, which reaches millions of Americans — he hosts the most-watched show on cable news in the US. As Russia gathered tens of thousands of troops on Ukraine's border in the lead-up to the invasion in late 2021, Carlson parroted Moscow by blaming NATO for Putin's aggression toward Kyiv. Carlson said NATO only existed to "torment" Putin, claiming that the authoritarian leader "just wants to keep his western borders secure." Russia's invasion of Ukraine was ultimately an unprovoked assault on a sovereign nation, which is why much of the world has rallied behind Kyiv and against Moscow. After the invasion, Carlson also pushed a discredited Russian conspiracy theory that the US was funding bio-weapons development at labs in Ukraine. The false bio-labs story also found an audience on far right social media channels in the US, among other platforms and forums, highlighting the myriad ways disinformation can spread in today's world. "People are asking if the far right in the US is influencing Russia or if Russia is influencing the far right, but the truth is they are influencing each other," Thomas Rid, a professor at Johns Hopkins University and expert on Russian disinformation, told the New York Times in March, adding, "They are pushing the same narratives." There are no signs that the Ukraine war will end at any point in the near future. As the conflict continues and the economic consequences of it are felt more acutely by Americans, the circumstances could provide an ideal avenue for the proliferation of Russian disinformation in the US — sowing further discord across the country amid a period of historic political divisions.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L - Distraction

Biden is losing on the economy - passing policies can shift the midterm narrative away from inflation

Robillard 4/12 (Kevin Robillard is a is a senior political reporter for HuffPost "Inflation Is The Only Political Issue. Democrats Need An Answer.," HuffPost, 4-12-2022, https://www.huffpost.com/entry/inflation-only-political-issue-democrats-need-an-answer_n_6254bebae4b0e97a3515908e) -AT

Inflation is a global problem, but the rate of inflation has been higher in the United States than in Europe. Economists generally point to skyrocketing demand since the introduction of coronavirus vaccines, coupled with supply chain issues. Conservatives, and some liberals, also argue the administration’s American Rescue Plan added to the problem. Voters are not pleased with how either party is handling the inflation debate, but Democrats, who hold the presidency and narrow control of both chambers of Congress, are set to pay more of a political price unless Biden and party leadership can rapidly squelch inflation or change the dominant narratives about the economy. A major problem? Democrats aren’t sure what they can do. Biden plans to travel to Iowa on Tuesday to announce a new EPA rule allowing gas stations to sell 15% ethanol-blend gasoline this summer ― normally they are allowed to sell up to 10% because of pollution concerns ― which should help ease demand and lower prices for gasoline. He has also worked to uncork supply chains at ports and in the trucking industry. Biden has already announced plans to release 180 million barrels of oil from the Strategic Petroleum Reserve and has worked to battle consolidation in the agriculture industry to bring down food prices. The White House has also repeatedly pointed to policies included in the Build Back Better package that Sen. Joe Manchin (D-W.Va.) killed late last year ― giving Medicare the power to negotiate prescription drug costs, providing subsidies for child care ― as possible solutions. But the chances of resurrecting portions of the package remain somewhere between nonexistent and murky.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L - Distraction

Any of Biden’s accomplishments can distract voters from inflation crisis – Biden looking to use plan as pivot

Cook and Litvan 5/10 (Nancy Cook Laura Litvan, Nancy Cook is a White House reporter at Bloomberg News and Laura Litvan is a reporter and editor at Bloomberg, "Inflation Is So Bad Democrats Want Biden to ‘Do More’ for Midterms," Bloomberg, 5-10-2022, https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-05-10/inflation-rate-haunts-biden-democrats-ahead-of-2022-midterms) -AT

Inside the administration, there’s a sense of frustration, doom, and some say magical thinking about inflation, but no clear path on the best way for the White House to grapple with an economic phenomenon that’s been more severe and lasted longer than officials expected. Unfortunately for Biden and Democrats, the lesson from the 1970s and ’80s is that US presidents are quite limited in what they can do on their own to tamp down price pressures. In the approach to November’s midterm elections, Ron Klain, Biden’s chief of staff, has argued that the president and his allies should talk more about the president’s accomplishments, especially the remarkable , along with laws he signed to provide families with  and . Klain also advocates that Biden contrast his policies with Republican proposals on taxes and the deficit.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L - Distraction

Plan helps dems—distracts voters from GOP favoring trends and inflation

Bunch 22—Senior writer for the Philadelphia Daily News focusing on social injustice and inequality (Will Bunch, Tribune Content Agency, “OPINION: Here’s the message that wins the midterms for Democrats, if they’re not afraid.,” 03-04-22, EBSCO Host Database)// SBM

Mar. 4--It hasn't aired yet, but I want to share with you the political ad that could win the 2022 midterm for the Democrats -- even with all the doom and gloom about President Biden's approval rating and all the historical trends that favor the GOP. For reasons that will be clear in a minute, I'm not using the candidate's name. The TV spot starts with one of the most dramatic and best-known soundbites in American history: the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. at the Lincoln Memorial in 1963, proclaiming, "I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character." The ad then switches to the candidate, dressed smartly but casually -- not in a fleece vest, though! -- and sitting in front of a blackboard in a school classroom. He looks into the camera. "I want an America where every child learns those words and what they mean," the candidate says. "That's why I was shocked when my opponent and other Republicans in our state voted for a bill that would keep American heroes like Martin Luther King [picture of King on the Selma-to-Montgomery march] and Rosa Parks [shot of Parks, sitting on a city bus] out of our schoolhouses. I'm sick and tired of the trying to ban books from our and gag our teachers in their classrooms. That's not just wrong -- it's straight-up un-American." Then, a tone shift as images from the war in Ukraine, including everyday citizens defending their homeland against Russian invaders, fill the screen. "We are all inspired by people around the globe, fighting for their freedom. It's time we fight for here in the . I want to make it easier for you to vote, not harder. Let's make our schools about learning, not censorship." The music begins to swell, with emotional frames of voters, kids in classrooms. "I'm running for Congress to fight to protect the American way." There's a reason you haven't seen this TV spot yet, even if you're a political obsessive like me. It hasn't been filmed, and -- given the tortured history of political thinking and strategy over the last 40 years -- it might never be. I made it up, because I think the political party that -- for all its well-documented flaws -- wants to take the United States forward instead of backward into some Stone Age of white supremacy is missing a golden opportunity to push a message that connects with a majority of Americans. We all know the conventional wisdom about what is certain to happen when the nation votes in November. The historical precedent is that the party holding the White House gets clobbered, as happened to Donald Trump in 2018 and Barack Obama in 2010 -- a notion now cemented by President Biden's low approval rating and voter unease over high levels of inflation. Yet often the lofty conventional wisdom fails to notice changes at ground level. The post-2020 Census reapportionment process that was supposed to give an added edge to Republicans didn't actually do that. More important, the current political zeitgeist is radically different than it was during 2021 s off-year elections in Virginia, Florida, and other states. For one thing, the news is dominated by shock and outrage over Vladimir Putin's barbaric invasion of Ukraine -- a constant reminder of Donald Trump and other top Republicans who spent years as Putin apologists, or worse, as well as the risks of authoritarianism over democracy. But perhaps more important, Republicans who saw some gains last year running against that addresses racism or LGBTQ rights now seem guilty of a major overreach. The extent of that GOP overreach can be seen both in the sheer number of bills that Republicans are introducing in statehouses across America -- so-called gag orders about what teachers can say in their classrooms -- at a rate of roughly three a day, according to PEN America, as well as outrageous local examples, like the Tennessee school board that pulled the anti-Holocaust graphic novel Maus out of the curriculum. Now, there is polling evidence that most Americans don't like what they are seeing. Last month, a CBS News poll found resounding majorities of voters oppose any kind of book bans -- for example, 83% say that books should never be banned for criticizing U.S. history -- and also support classroom teaching about racism or other historical topics, even those with the potential to make some students uncomfortable. Basically, the CBS News respondents acknowledged that America has made some progress on racial issues but also believe that racism persists and that these issues should be discussed in classrooms. That's very much the opposite of what TV pundits are saying, as well as the trend of GOP governing in the nation's red states. There is a tendency, or course, to write off polling data on sensitive topics around race. Aren't there some voters who say one thing to a pollster and behave differently in the booth? But let's look at the politician who in 2021 became the avatar of the fight over antiracism education, Virginia's new Republican governor, Glenn Youngkin. Taking office in January, Youngkin surprised voters with some of his extreme actions, which including a Day One executive order aimed at eliminating "divisive concepts" from classrooms, and even a tip line for parents to report on their kids' teachers. The result? After little more than a month in office, Youngkin is already under water, with just 41% of Virginians approving of his performance and 43% disapproving. War in Ukraine demands that all of us pick a side: democracy or decadence -- Will Bunch Clearly, there's an opportunity here for Democrats. The party's inclination in recent times is to go after voters with a rational appeal rather than an emotional one. In 2022, Democrats' conundrum is that despite a slew of positive data around job creation and the broad economy, most voters say they aren't feeling it, and they're concerned about inflation and high gas prices. In today's climate, the best pitch for Democrats is an emotional one -- that the Republicans are the party of banning books and gagging teachers. Could anything be more against American values, the ones our grandfathers fought for in World War II?

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Democracy

Democracy initiatives are a winner – it helps Biden rejuvenate image.

Herndon & Cohn 7/13 (Astead & Nate, The New York Times, “Could the Midterms Be Tighter Than Expected?” The Daily, July 13th, 2022, https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/13/podcasts/the-daily/midterms.html?showTranscript=1)

So we have a poll that shows, on the one hand, better overall polling for Democrats in this moment than we might expect. But they also have these very serious political challenges that they’re facing, including an unpopular president and a voter coalition that shows real signs of erosion. What is the path forward here for Democrats? Are candidates supposed to go to voters and say, hey, you don’t like the president, but you should like me instead? Nate Cohn Well, in the short term, they don’t have too many other cards to play. Joe Biden is unpopular. The economy is not in a great place. Unless the president can figure out a way to rejuvenate his political standing, get costs under control, help the economy, and so on, it’s hard to see them getting out of that fundamental problem. So in the meantime, they happen to have three solid issues that appeal to a really important part of their base in democracy, abortion, and gun control. And it’s worth noting that, in a midterm environment, that can get you pretty far. The midterm elections are lower turnout. The electorate tends to be better educated. More ideologically consistent voters are likelier to show up in that sort of election.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L - Emerging Tech

They also want to hammer Biden for lack of action on emerging tech

Gould 21 [Joe Gould. "23 Republicans urge Biden to work with allies on tech to combat China". 1-28-2021. Defense News. https://www.defensenews.com/congress/2021/01/28/23-republicans-urge-biden-to-work-with-allies-on-tech-to-combat-china. 6-23-2022.] - AL

WASHINGTON ― Nearly two dozen Republican lawmakers are calling on President Joe Biden to engage with allies on emerging technologies like 5G networking and artificial intelligence in the face of China’s advancements. House Armed Services Committee ranking member Mike Rogers, House Foreign Affairs Committee ranking member Mike McCaul, and House Science, Space and Technology Committee ranking member Frank Lucas signed a letter to Biden urging him to maximize alliances to counter “China’s vision for tech authoritarianism and protect our own economic and national security interests.” The message to Biden signals an avenue for bipartisan cooperation, just days after Secretary of State Antony Blinken appeared supportive of U.K. Prime Minister Boris Johnson’s efforts to forge a D-10 group of democracies ― South Korea, India and Australia, plus the G-7 nations ― to cooperate on 5G and vulnerable supply chains. In his confirmation hearing last week, Blinken said: “Bringing concerned countries together, the digital democracies together in an appropriate forum, is the place to start.” “I don’t want to minimize the challenge. We obviously have disagreements among democracies about a lot of profound questions about how technology is used, so we’ve got some work to do just to get our own collective house in order,” he said. Western allies, under pressure from President Donald Trump, agreed to exclude Chinese tech giant Huawei from their 5G networks, claiming an espionage risk, something the company has denied. Since then, the European Union signed a long-promised investment deal with China last month despite the public concerns from the incoming Biden administration. The Republican lawmakers, referencing Johnson in their letter, recommended raising the issue of China’s tech authoritarianism through the G-7 and NATO ― but also expanding engagements with allied democracies, and creating and hosting new international groups dedicated to democratic cooperation on technology. They also called for the development of an allied network to encourage cooperation among companies in allied states to scale emerging technologies, and for the U.S. to help allies establish governmental bodies like the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States to review foreign investments and prevent the transfer of allied technologies. McCaul, who chaired the House’s Republican-only China Task Force, called on Biden to prioritize investments in domestic manufacturing of next-generation semiconductor chips in his expected infrastructure plan. McCaul has sponsored legislation to boost funding for basic research. “We must work with our allies to ensure that our supply chain is secure and the future of technology is safely out of the hands of the [Chinese Communist Party],” McCaul said in a statement. Democratic lawmakers have also raised alarms over China’s development of emerging technologies. After a report last month that Huawei tested AI software that could recognize Uighur minorities and alert police, Democratic Sen. Bob Menendez, the incoming Senate Foreign Relations Committee chairman, tweeted the following: “A shocking reminder that #China continues to flout the ethical development of emerging technologies. The US must lead an effort with our allies to ensure the proper use of the digital domain predicated on the values of openness, stability, security, & protection of human rights.”

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – China

Republicans resilient on China – basis of midterm GOP ads

Mccormick 22 (John a national political reporter who has covered every presidential campaign since 2000. He joined The Wall Street Journal in May 2019 after working for Bloomberg News, the Chicago Tribune, the Des Moines Register and the Rochester Post-Bulletin.) “China Is Frequent Topic, Especially for GOP, in Midterm Campaign Ads .” WSJ. 5-2-2022. https://www.wsj.com/articles/china-is-frequent-topic-especially-for-gop-in-midterm-campaign-ads-11651489201 //RK

Criticism of China is emerging as a popular topic in this year’s midterm congressional campaign ads, especially in Rust Belt states where the loss of manufacturing jobs to Asia and elsewhere have placed economic stress on voters. Television ads mentioning China—some of which have drawn criticism from Asian-American groups—are running most heavily in Pennsylvania, Ohio, West Virginia and Wisconsin. Some of that can be attributed to the timing of primaries: Ohio’s is Tuesday, followed by Pennsylvania and West Virginia later in May, while Wisconsin’s is Aug. 9. Roughly one in nine ads aired so far this year in all House and Senate races have mentioned China, a Wall Street Journal analysis of broadcast-television and national cable data from the ad-tracking firm AdImpact shows. That isn’t far behind , another topic Republicans are especially eager to talk about.Of the almost 34,000 airings that have touched on China, more than 80% were sponsored by Republicans or conservative-leaning groups. The U.S. wants to counter China’s influence around the world by providing everything from infrastructure to vaccines and green energy. WSJ’s Stu Woo explains how the plan, dubbed Build Back Better World, aims to compete with China’s Belt and Road Initiative. Photo composite: Daniel Orton“China is a symbol of how a lot of people perceive Ohio economically, especially the manufacturing sector,” said former Ohio Democratic Gov. Ted Strickland, who used China in his own 2016 ads for an unsuccessful U.S. Senate bid. “I do think it has a lot of power.” of former President ’s failed 2020 re-election campaign, with frequent mentions of trade actions he had taken as well as the “China virus” expression that he used to refer to Covid-19 as he sought to blame the country for the pandemic and the . There are incentives for criticism of the Asian giant: Nearly three-quarters of voters in  in March said China was the nation’s largest economic threat, while a 52% majority said it presented the biggest security threat. Ohio and Pennsylvania, where China-related ads have run most frequently so far, are hosting two of the most contentious U.S. Senate primaries on the GOP side. The two states have also easily recorded the most spending so far this year on political ads. The top campaign sponsor so far this year of TV ads mentioning China is celebrity surgeon Mehmet Oz. As part of his effort to win  for U.S. Senate, he has aired more than 8,300 spots that have mentioned China. Scoops, analysis and insights driving Washington from the WSJ's D.C. bureau. In one that has been running in five Pennsylvania media markets, the Oz campaign calls his leading opponent, David McCormick, the former chief executive of hedge-fund giant Bridgewater Associates, “pro-China” and cites that as a reason Mr. Trump endorsed Mr. Oz. Asked last week in a debate to respond to attack ads claiming he has profited from China, Mr. McCormick sought to minimize his dealings there and said he had “done business around the world in 20 countries, including 2% of our b. Mr. Oz’s campaign-ad mentions of China are more than double the number of airings for the next closest candidate, Democratic Rep. Tim Ryan of Ohio. Mr. Ryan, now seeking his party’s endorsement for Senate, has cast the U.S. relationship with China in stark terms. “It is us versus China,” Mr. Ryan says in . “America can never be dependent on communist China.” Mr. Ryan’s ad drew criticism from the AAPI Victory Fund, a super political-action committee that aims to mobilize Asian-American and Pacific Islander voters. In , the group described the spot as “rife with sinophobic rhetoric” and called for an end to such language at a time when hate crimes against Asian-Americans are on the rise.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – China

Republicans can only counter China sufficiently – Dems weak, GOP holding China accountable

Brennan 21 (David is currently Newsweek's Diplomatic Correspondent covering world politics and current affairs from London. Prior to joining Newsweek in early 2018, he reported on British politics and global current affairs as a staff writer at International Business Times. Originally from London, David graduated from the University of Cambridge in 2012.) “On China, Republicans split between engaging with Joe Biden or eviscerating him.” Newsweek. 2-17-2021. https://www.newsweek.com/china-republicans-split-between-engaging-joe-biden-eviscerating-him-1569850 //RK

A group of Republican lawmakers has issued a damning assessment of President 's early China strategy, as the party considers how to push the new administration toward a tougher line on Beijing and punish it if it fails. The 120-member Republican Study Committee released a briefing document on Tuesday summarizing Biden's approach to China as: "Bad policies, bad personnel." The group, chaired by Indiana Rep. Jim Banks, is the largest conservative caucus in the House. Banks has said he plans to use its clout to influence China policy. The committee lauded Biden's predecessor  as "the first president to take on Communist China in a generation," holding Beijing to account "for stealing U.S. intellectual property, infiltrating the U.S. education system, hijacking international organizations and spreading disinformation about the COVID-19 pandemic." Long-term concerns about Chinese behaviour converged under Trump, prompting bipartisan agreement that Beijing represents a problem to be addressed. Previous administrations had hoped that engaging with the Chinese Communist Party would encourage a more liberal regime while swelling U.S. coffers. But Beijing used its new-found wealth and influence to entrench its authoritarianism at home and push for new territory and power abroad. The CCP is unapologetic about its  and . Its attempts to dodge blame for the coronavirus pandemic have also rankled with democracies worldwide. On the campaign trail, Biden vowed to be tough on China, seeking to dodge allegations from Trump and other critics that he would return to a softer, more cooperative relationship with Beijing. "The Biden administration has already taken a number of disastrous steps to undo President Trump's success in countering China," the Republican Study Committee claimed in its memo. "The Biden team so far has exhibited a pattern of weakness and a return to Obama's failed approach of engaging rather than holding China accountable for its bad behavior. "The Biden administration's foreign policy team is overwhelmingly made up of a number of individuals who either have had links to the CCP, or have a record of weak statements and actions on confronting it." "Despite tough talk on China, such as Secretary Blinken saying that Trump was right to take a tougher approach to China, the Biden administration's actions have shown they will do the opposite," the committee said. Not all  are taking such a combative stance. In the , some GOP members are looking to build bridges with the Biden White House to create a bipartisan Beijing strategy. Anger at Chinese trade practices, human rights abuses, territorial expansion and propaganda output were one of the few things that united the two parties during Trump's term. With Washington, D.C. still divided, this may be one of the few flags around which both parties can rally in the coming years. After Biden's first call with President , Senator Jim Risch of Idaho—the ranking Republican on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee—told Newsweek he was encouraged by the president's mention of human rights abuses and other American grievances. "I am glad to see that President Biden increasingly views China as a serious competitor to the United States, and that he raised Taiwan, coercive economic practices and human rights," Risch said. "I'm also encouraged by the China policy review currently underway at the Department of Defense. COVID-19 has taught us that the Chinese Communist Party is willing to undermine global health to preserve its standing, and that fact demands a cautious approach towards pursuing cooperative initiatives with China, whether on climate change or other issues." Whether their approach is combative or cooperative, Republicans are set to keep the pressure on Biden and his team. The party saw China as  in last year's election. The economic impact of the pandemic, concerns over globalization and the decline of U.S. manufacturing, plus traditional worries about military hegemony, are a potent combination. Add to this the increasingly well-publicized human rights  and Hong Kong. "China must be our top foreign policy priority," Risch said, adding that he had introduced the STRATEGIC Act, which calls for a clear strategy for competing with Beijing and coordinating with allies in Europe. "I plan to conduct congressional oversight of the Biden administration's China policy and strategy for the entire Indo-Pacific region," Risch said. "The challenges China poses are an American issue and I expect the Biden administration and Congressional  to work across the aisle on effective, concrete and politically sustainable policies that have the support of the American people."

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Ukraine

Working with Ukraine is top priority

Christina Wilkie 22, Bachelor earner and white house reporter, 3-21-2022, “Biden’s leadership on Russia will be a bright spot in a gloomy State of the Union,” CNBC, https://www.cnbc.com/2022/03/01/bidens-leadership-on-russia-is-a-bright-spot-in-a-gloomy-state-of-the-union.html-RayS

On Ukraine, Biden and his foreign policy team are leading the rest of the world, revitalizing the NATO alliance and stepping up to the challenge that Russian President Vladimir Putin poses to the rules-based international order — one that has maintained relative peace in Europe for nearly 80 years. On Tuesday morning, tens of thousands of Russian troops were surrounding the Ukrainian capital, Kyiv. Farther to the east, Russian forces shelled a public square in Kharkiv, Ukraine’s second-largest city, killing hundreds. In response to the invasion, a loose coalition of large and small democracies around the world has banded together to impose severe restrictions on Russia’s central bank and sanctioned its richest citizens, its airlines and its state-run media. The goal of the effort is to isolate Moscow and force the Kremlin to pay a high price economically for launching a war of choice. Biden and the United States have been at the forefront of this coalition, which includes G-7 members, NATO allies, rich countries such as Japan and developing countries such as Ghana and even traditionally neutral countries such as Switzerland and Monaco. White House press secretary Jen Psaki said Biden will “talk about the steps we’ve taken to not only support the Ukrainian people with military and economic assistance, but also the steps he’s taken to build a global coalition imposing crippling financial sanctions on President Putin, his inner circle and the Russian economy.” Biden will also address “the importance of the United States as a leader in the world — standing up for values and standing up for global norms,” she told reporters Monday. In just the past week, Biden has held scores of leader-to-leader calls with U.S. and NATO allies to coordinate both U.S. support for Ukraine and sanctions on Russia. He has also deployed thousands of U.S. troops to help shore up the defenses of NATO member states to whom Russia poses the most immediate threat. At the same time, Biden’s secretaries of state and defense have requested and distributed hundreds of millions of dollars worth of additional weapons to Ukrainian troops and humanitarian aid to refugees fleeing the front lines. This combined U.S. military, diplomatic, economic and humanitarian response has earned praise for Biden from both Democrats and Republicans. “President Biden’s leadership in the Ukraine crisis has been truly impressive,” conservative intellectual Bill Kristol tweeted Monday. Even more importantly, early polls show that average Americans of all parties are coalescing around support for Ukraine and opposition to Russia’s invasion.

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Ukraine

Americans support work in Ukraine, this boosts dems if plan passes

Shibley Telhami 22, 3-31-2022, "What do Americans think of the Russia-Ukraine war and of the US response?," Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/blog/order-from-chaos/2022/03/31/what-do-americans-think-of-the-russia-ukraine-war-and-of-the-us-response/ -RayS

It turns out that large majorities of Americans are indeed following the Russian invasion closely, according to our University of Maryland Critical Issues Poll. The poll was carried out online between March 16 to 28, 2022 by Nielsen Scarborough, who used a nationally representative sample of 1,320 adults with a margin of error of +/- 2.7%. It found that 40% of respondents say they are following the crisis “very closely,” and another 45% say they are following somewhat closely. Here are twelve takeaways: 1 Americans clearly view Ukraine as being far more friendly than Russia, even if most Americans don’t simply consider Russia to be an enemy or Ukraine to be a full ally. Thirty-four percent of respondents say Russia is an enemy, including 30% of Republicans and 40% of Democrats, while 38% say Russia is an “unfriendly country,” and 24% say it is neither friendly nor unfriendly. Nineteen percent consider Ukraine an ally, while a slight majority of 54% consider Ukraine a “friendly country,” and 25% consider it neither friendly nor unfriendly. 2 Large bipartisan majorities remain opposed to sending U.S. troops to Ukraine, even if the conflict persists. Sixty-five percent oppose sending troops, including 68% of Republicans and 62% of Democrats. At the same time, a large majority, 83%, supports supplying the Ukrainian army with military equipment, including 82% of Republicans and 86% of Democrats. Similarly, 89% of those polled support continuing to impose tough sanctions on Russia, including 85% of Republicans and 95% of Democrats. 3 If the Russian invasion persists, small bipartisan majorities will support a no-fly zone over Ukraine, even as large majorities of Americans express concern about the possibility of fighting Russians and of nuclear conflict. Fifty-six percent of respondents say they support enforcing a no-fly zone over Ukraine, including 52% of Republicans and 61% of Democrats. Despite this view, most respondents also expressed overwhelming concern about potential U.S. military confrontation with Russia (61% were “very” concerned and another 28% were “somewhat concerned”). Nuclear fears also weighed heavily: 58% were also “very concerned” and another 24% “somewhat concerned” about potential nuclear confrontation with Russia. 4 Americans view the U.S. response to the Ukraine crisis more favorably than unfavorably but are divided in their attitude along party lines. Forty-nine percent say their opinion of the U.S. reaction has been favorable, including 31% of Republicans and 69% of Democrats, compared to 31% who express unfavorable opinions, including 49% of Republicans and 13% of Democrats. A further 20% express neither favorable nor unfavorable opinions. Most Americans, 51%, say the U.S. reacted at the “appropriate level,” but a majority of Republicans, 56%, say the U.S. has “underreacted.” Two-thirds of Americans support U.S. President Joe Biden’s decision to end importing Russian energy, including 56% of Republicans and 80% of Democrats. 5 Most Americans, including majorities of Democrats and Republicans, say they are prepared to pay some price in energy costs and inflation for supporting Ukraine, but not in American lives. Seventy-three percent say they are at least somewhat prepared to pay higher energy costs, including 88% of Democrats and 58% of Republicans, while 65% are at least somewhat prepared to see increased inflation, including 78% of Democrats and 51% of Republicans. At the same time, 68% of Americans are “not at all” (41%) or “not much” (27%) prepared to accept loss of lives of U.S. troops. This holds across the partisan American divide, but Republicans are much more likely to “not at all” accept casualties (47%), compared to Democrats (33%). 6 U.S. policy toward Ukraine has impacted the public perceptions of Biden and former President Donald Trump more negatively than positively, driven by highly partisan attitudes. Thirty-six percent say they now have more favorable views of Biden, 23% say their views are unaffected, while 41% say they have more negative views, including 80% of Republicans. Thirty-four percent say they now have more positive views of Trump, 26% say their views were unaffected, while 40%, including 72% of Democrats, say they have more negative views of Trump. 7 Although U.S. government messaging on Ukraine has been partly focused on defending democracy around the world, most Americans across the partisan divide don’t believe the U.S. is now a good model for democracy. Only 27% say that democracy in the U.S. is a good example for other countries to follow, including 28% of Democrats and 29% of Republicans. A large majority, 61%, say the U.S. “used to be a good example but has not been in recent years”, including 64% of Republicans and 58% of Democrats. 8 Americans are divided on whether their country should be leading the international opposition to the Russian invasion, with 47% saying the U.S. should be the one to lead (42% of Republicans and 55% of Democrats), while 53% say it should not (58% of Republicans and 45% of Democrats). 9 Overwhelmingly, Americans across the partisan divide blame Russia for the crisis and few blame Ukraine. At the same time, a significant percentage also blame the U.S. Ninety-eight percent say Russia is to blame, 29% say Ukraine bears at least some of the blame, and 36% say the U.S. bears at least some of the blame, including half of Republicans. 10 While Americans say NATO’s expansion played a role in Russian behavior, most don’t think this was the key to Russia’s invasion of Ukraine. Thirty-eight percent say the expansion of NATO played a key role in the Russian invasion of Ukraine, 41% say NATO expansion played “a small but not a key role,” while 21% say it played no role. 11 Most Americans (57%) say the post-Cold War era has ended. Among those who hold that view, most blame Russian behavior, but a smaller majority also blame American behavior. Ninety-two percent say Russian behavior contributed to the demise of the post-Cold War era (64% say “a lot” and 28% say “somewhat”), while 73% say American behavior contributed (30% say “a lot” while 43% say “somewhat”).

2022 Michigan Disadvantage
Midterms DA – GOP Good › Links › L – Russia

Russia is public enemy number 1, if it gets hurt, the plan will be popular.

Richard Wike et al 22, 4-6-2022, Doctorate in Political Sciences and well-respected researcher, "Seven-in-Ten Americans Now See Russia as an Enemy," Pew Research Center, https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2022/04/06/seven-in-ten-americans-now-see-russia-as-an-enemy/ -RayS

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine has led to a dramatic shift in American public opinion: 70% of Americans now consider Russia an enemy of the United States, up from 41% in January. And on this topic, Democrats and Republicans largely agree, with 72% of Democrats and 69% of Republicans describing Russia as an enemy. A new Pew Research Center survey, conducted March 21-27, finds that just 7% of U.S. adults have an overall favorable opinion of Russia. Only 6% express confidence in its leader, President Vladimir Putin. In contrast, 72% have confidence in Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy. The ongoing war has brought renewed attention to NATO. Ukraine is not a NATO member, but it borders several member states, and NATO leaders have worked together in recent weeks to coordinate their responses to the crisis. Attitudes toward the alliance have grown more positive since Russia’s invasion: 67% express a favorable opinion of the organization, up from 61% in 2021. Meanwhile, 69% say the U.S. benefits a great deal or a fair amount from being a NATO member. While both Democrats and Republicans (including those who lean to each party) hold largely positive views about NATO and U.S. membership in the organization, Democrats are consistently more positive, especially liberal Democrats. For instance, 85% of liberal Democrats think the U.S. benefits a great deal or a fair amount from NATO membership; among conservative Republicans, only 51% hold this view. Still, partisan differences over NATO have shrunk somewhat over the past year. The share of Democrats and Democratic leaners with a favorable overall opinion of NATO has held steady at nearly eight-in-ten, but among Republicans and GOP leaners, positive views have increased from 44% in spring 2021 to 55% today. The partisan gap on Russia favorability has also decreased. In 2020 – the last time this question was asked – there was a 17 percentage point difference between the share of Democrats with a very unfavorable opinion of Russia and the share of Republicans with that view; now the gap is only 5 points. Democrats and Republicans are also now more closely aligned on views about the threat posed by Russia. In the current survey, 66% of Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents say Russia is a major threat to the U.S., similar to the 61% registered among Republicans and Republican-leaning independents. However, when this question was last asked in 2020, only 48% of Republicans considered Russia a major threat, compared with 68% of Democrats. These are among the key findings of a new survey conducted by Pew Research Center on the Center’s nationally representative American Trends Panel among 3,581 adults from March 21 to 27, 2022. Most Americans have a very unfavorable opinion of Russia Public opinion of Russia is overwhelmingly negative: 92% of Americans say they have an unfavorable view of the country, including 69% who have a very unfavorable view. Since the last time this question was asked on Pew Research Center’s online panel in 2020, almost two years prior to Russia’s recent invasion of Ukraine, this strongly negative sentiment has increased by 28 percentage points. Before switching to online surveys, Pew Research Center tracked Americans’ ratings of Russia in phone surveys between 2007 and 2020. In that time, assessments of Russia were never very positive, but they turned sharply negative in the spring of 2014, immediately following Russia’s annexation of Crimea, which few countries have recognized – and never recovered. While negative sentiment toward Russia has increased substantially among both Democrats and Republicans since 2020, Republicans’ views have changed more drastically. Around a third of Republicans and Republican leaners had a very unfavorable view of Russia in 2020, compared with 67% who now hold this view – a 35 percentage point increase. In the same period, the share of Democrats with a very negative view of Russia increased by 23 points. A small partisan gap in views of Russia remains, but Republicans and Democrats are not as divided on Russia as they once were. Americans ages 65 and older (83%) are much more likely than adults under 30 (55%) to have a very unfavorable view of Russia. A large majority of Americans now see Russia as an enemy Changes in overall views of Russia have come alongside changes in how Americans perceive relations between the two countries. Just two months ago, Americans were more likely to describe Russia as a competitor of the U.S. rather than its enemy (49% vs. 41% at the time). Now, Americans overwhelmingly call Russia an enemy: 70% say so, with just 24% preferring to call Russia a competitor of the U.S. Merely 3% of Americans see Russia as a partner, down from 7% two months ago. While broad cross-sections of Americans primarily see Russia as the United States’ enemy, those ages 65 and older are especially likely to hold this view, with 83% saying so. And while a majority of the youngest adults polled agree that Russia is an enemy (59%), they are far more likely than older adults to label Russia as a competitor. More educated Americans are also particularly likely to name Russia an enemy – 77% of those with a postgraduate degree say this, while roughly two-thirds of both those with some college education and those with a high school degree or less education say the same. While Democrats and Republicans largely agree that Russia is an enemy, there are some differences between partisan and ideological camps. Moderate and liberal Republicans are the least likely to name Russia an enemy (63% say this), while liberal Democrats are the most likely (78%). Perception of Russia as a major threat at all-time high With most Americans viewing Russia as an enemy, the share who believe that Russia is a threat to the U.S. is higher now than it has ever been since the Center first began polling on this topic in 2008. Overall, 64% of Americans say that Russia’s power and influence is a major threat to their country, 30% say it is a minor threat and only 5% say Russia is not a threat. Mirroring overall views of Russia, Americans became more wary of the country in 2014, when just over half said it was a major threat to the U.S. At that time and in 2016, Republicans were more likely than Democrats to be concerned. This partisan difference both widened and flipped in following years, however, with Democrats much more likely than Republicans to view Russia as a major threat in each survey between 2017 to 2020. Since then, the share of Republicans who see Russia as a threat has increased, narrowing the partisan gap. Though views of Russia as a major threat have shifted somewhat over time, the share of Americans who say Russia is not a threat to U.S. interests has never been higher than 10%. Majorities of adults in all age groups see Russia as a significant threat, but this view is even more common among adults ages 65 and older (70% vs. 57% among those ages 18 to 29). Amid Russia-Ukraine war, Americans positive on NATO, though partisan divides persist As NATO faces increased scrutiny in light of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, the political and military alliance is seen in a positive light by most Americans. Two-thirds have a favorable opinion of NATO. This marks a significant increase from the roughly six-in-ten who said the same of the organization in 2020 and 2021. Prior to 2020, U.S. opinion of NATO was somewhat mixed. Roughly half or more of Americans expressed a favorable view of the organization, with opinion ranging from 49% in 2013 and 2015 to 64% in 2018. However, these figures are from phone surveys and are not directly comparable to more recent online American Trends Panel data. While Democrats and Republicans are both generally more favorable toward NATO than not, Democrats and Democratic-leaning independents are more likely than Republican counterparts to have a positive view. About eight-in-ten (78%) Democrats see NATO in a positive light, compared with 55% of Republicans. This pattern was observed in 2021, though Republicans have grown somewhat more favorable on NATO since this question was last asked.