2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Cyborg Fem › General
Patricia Melzer 20 is an associate professor of German and Gender, Sexuality and Women’s Studies at Temple University. She is the author of Science Fiction and Feminist Thought (2006) and Death in the Shape of a Young Girl: Women’s Political Violence in the Red Army Faction (2015). Her research interests are in gender and technology in popular culture, feminist and queer theory, and women in radical social movements. (“Cyborg Feminism,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 35, p296) //le
Feminist cyberpunk criticism recognizes the potential of cyberpunk to expand the concept of the feminist subject to include intersectional identities. In other words, feminist cyberfiction departs from the oppositional figuration of the material and virtual that dominates traditional cyberpunk, a framework that inherently privileges patriarchal definitions of technoscience. Instead, we see socially responsible hacking, individuals in intimate relationships with trusted partners, and a central focus on the importance of communal social relationships. Technology is depicted as linking the physical body to virtual/digital spaces that form new realms of experiences. Impor- tantly, as Foster argues, the “telepresence” (130) within feminist cyberfiction locates the body as a point of reference for any presence in cyberspace; the goal is very rarely, if at all, to escape the body completely. Cyborg bodies and the presence of AIs (often embodied by the cyborg/android) display complex and shifting racialized, gendered, and classed identities while transgender char- acters, paired with cybernetic body modifications, create metaphors for gender queerness, as do gender non-binary-coded AIs. Embodiment, in particular the female body, is thereby central to the narratives; however, even in virtual reality where the person’s digital avatar relies on some form of visual representation of the self, these characters represent partial subjects that inhabit a technological space, a fragmentation of the self that allows an engagement with the assemblages that make up our relationship to technology: “This [erosion of boundaries] signifies a complete deconstruction of the body. People are made of bits and pieces—human, animal, mechanical, and mystical pieces that loosely coalesce into a self” (Cadora 368). Subjectivity is therefore envisioned as unstable and constantly shifting, as developing from a symbiotic relationship between technol- ogy and the material body—a relationship that offers new, posthuman assemblages of becoming.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Cyborg Fem › General
Patricia Melzer 20 is an associate professor of German and Gender, Sexuality and Women’s Studies at Temple University. She is the author of Science Fiction and Feminist Thought (2006) and Death in the Shape of a Young Girl: Women’s Political Violence in the Red Army Faction (2015). Her research interests are in gender and technology in popular culture, feminist and queer theory, and women in radical social movements. (“Cyborg Feminism,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 35, p295) //le
The refusal of the body (i.e., the material more broadly, including animals, nature, etc.) to disappear in humans’ relationship to technology is central to feminist cyberfiction, and these narratives are contemporaneous with cultural theories influenced by cyborg feminism4 that place resistance at the conflicting and imploding intersections of the cultural and the natural in techno- science. Among other things, these theories place feminist cyberfiction in the broader context of what Anne Balsamo refers to as “technologies of the gendered body” and treat it as a space where the relationship of body and technology is explored in ways that “offer a vision of post-human existence where ‘technology’ and the ‘human’ are understood in contiguous rather than opposi- tional terms” (“Feminism” 684). Instead of conceptualizing technology as a medium to erase or overwrite the body, Balsamo argues, innovative feminist texts, such as Pat Cadigan’s oeuvre,5 offer “alternative vision[s] of technological embodiment that [are] consistent with a gendered history of technology: where technology isn’t the means of escape from or transcendence of the body, but rather the means of communication and connection with other bodies” (“Feminism” 703). Here it is not the riddance of the ‘meat’ that forms the underlying, self-denying, ultimately unfulfilled desire of the narrative. Instead, the goal becomes a mediation of embodiment and technology that refuses to treat technology based interactions as abstractions.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Critical Race Theory › Afrocyberpunk – Perm
Isiah Lavender III 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. (“Critical Race Theory,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 37, p311) //le
Despite cyberpunk’s evolution from its earliest forms in the 1980s, however, the apparent permanence of racism prevails in the 21st-century cyberpunk as well. Technology sublimates race, and this misdirection becomes relevant in equating posthuman futures with white-only spaces. From a critical race theory viewpoint, “preconceptions and myths, for example about black criminality, shape mindset” (Delgado and Stefancic 42). American readers have unthinkingly consumed such images for years, and it becomes exceedingly difficult to talk back to culturally embedded stereotypes seen not only in America but all across the world. Instead, white culture reinforces itself with familiar patterns of ‘black=bad’; therefore, that which is different or danger- ous must be quarantined, if not eliminated outright. Efforts to break resistance to white-authored stories deemed as truth and to effect change in sf and fantasy must continually come from fans, scholars, and authors alike. In other words, while cyberpunk signals social media’s runaway de- velopment, the digital revolution, and the increasing importance of technoculture, its portrayal of race remains frozen in most, if not all, of its powerful future projections. From this perspective, critical race theory applied to cyberpunk—i.e., Afrocyberpunk—provides today’s answers to new questions being asked about the social construction of racialized identities imagined by the likes of Gibson, his contemporaries, and their inspired offspring.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Critical Race Theory › Afrocyberpunk – Perm
Isiah Lavender III 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. (“Critical Race Theory,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 37, p308-309) //le
Cyberpunk explores the near future; loosely articulated, it wrestles with computing questions such as networking, hacking, virtual reality, and artificial intelligence (AI), as well as cyborgs that represent the human/machine continuum and the emergence of the posthuman. These high- tech notions represent the cyber half of the definition. The punk half often signifies street life, dealers and addicts, the contract workers and precariat, the poor and have-nots with no material benefits, sometimes quite literally homeless people living in the streets, relegated far down the socioeconomic scale on the other side of the digital divide and hustling to survive. Although one might think of black folks here because of the disproportionate number of blacks in America op- pressed by poverty and living on the downward slope of the socioeconomic scale, the cyberpunk movement largely ignores this reality. Instead, the punks scholars may think of are the Panther Moderns from William Gibson’s monumental novel Neuromancer (1984), the white hacker street gang prowling through the urban sprawl adorned with micro soft buds implanted behind their ears and face-changing skin grafts.
What has often gone overlooked is black writers’ contribution to cyberpunk, even if that contribution is overshadowed by mainstream cyberpunk. For example, consider Aubry Knight, the black protagonist of Steven Barnes’s Streetlethal (1983) who, as a former mafia enforcer and present Nullboxer (a zero gravity variation of the sport), is inhumanly strong and has a penchant for wearing dark (mirror)shades. Published a year before Neuromancer, this oft-overlooked novel trades in many of cyberpunk’s hallmarks: Barnes perfectly balances cyberpunk’s posthuman street ‘cool’ with the glitz and grime of a near-future dystopian Los Angeles, and Aubry would be at home in any mainstream cyberpunk setting, whether Gibson’s Night City (Neuromancer) or the crowded Los Angeles streets of Ridley Scott’s Blade Runner (1982). Unfortunately, Streetlethal is very rarely ascribed to the cyberpunk movement (or any of its various ‘punk’ siblings, such as ste- ampunk, splatterpunk, or biopunk), instead foreshadowing Afrocyberpunk or cyberfunk, recent divergences made by black writers from cyberpunk’s norms. These more recent variations on cyberpunk distort this mode as a deliberate means of expressing black discontent with the world, global capitalism, and the information age, acutely demonstrating that cyberpunk is not for whites only. Blacks, too, have been, and want to continue, experimenting in their writing as a way of protesting social conditions as a countercultural critique.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Critical Race Theory › Anti-Blackness Link
Isiah Lavender III 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. (“Critical Race Theory,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 37, p310) //le
Just as they do in the physical world, colorblindness and the digital divide reinforce race and racism in the technocultures of cyberpunk, where cyberspace, criminality, computers, com- panies, and corporeality rule.2 That is why, as Alondra Nelson writes, “the racialized digital divide narrative that circulates in the public sphere and the bodiless, color-blind mythoto- pias of cybertheory and commercial advertising have become the unacknowledged frames of reference for understanding race in the digital age” (6). Cyberpunk’s claim to a post-racial future where human bodies are simply “meat” prisons and human minds can escape to “the bodiless exultation of cyberspace” (Gibson 6), all the while socializing with other post-human technicities,3 is misguided at best. Unhinged from the race and racism of the past, the cy- berpunk future champions high tech low life that renders racial identities obsolescent, as if cyberspace is not a racially coded environment. Instead, cyberspace, imagined as an “eighth continent” where anything goes, reproduces and reifies whiteness in virtual reality’s fictional- ized landscape (Chude-Sokei 6).
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Critical Race Theory › Alt – Discussion
Isiah Lavender III 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. (“Critical Race Theory,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 37, p308-309) //le
The notion of the digital divide at the turn of the 21st century has become a master narrative of race in our time that is in desperate need of ongoing confrontation. The digital divide con- cerns disparities in access to computers and the internet between whites and blacks, a point Alicia H. Hines et al. reflect on in Technicolor: Race, Technology, and Everyday Life, remarking how “the digital divide has become a self-fulfilling prophecy, confirming that people of color can’t keep pace in a high-tech world that threatens to outstrip them” (1–2). In his novel Blood Brothers (1996), Barnes anticipates the digital divide but dismantles it with his black hacker/ game designer Derek Waites who goes by the alias Captain Africa. Simply put, Barnes demon- strates how words can deconstruct this master narrative by organizing the novel around a black man with exceptional computer skills, a black hacker as skilled as mainstream cyberpunk’s oft- white hacker elites. Barnes purposely disrupts this image of the digital divide, one founded on the racist assumption that “in image after published image, the face of that [digital divide] is black” (Kevorkian 39), via his counter-story which affords his readers a subaltern view of race in cyberspace.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Critical Race Theory › General – Afrocyberpunk
Isiah Lavender III 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. (“Critical Race Theory,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 37, p314-315) //le
In closing, Afrocyberpunk is very much like Afrofuturism, a distinct African American mode of futurism,7 in that it represents another way to describe black speculative cultural practices, only with particular attention to cyberspace, simulations, and/or virtual realities (technical or bi- ological) as sites of revolution and social reform informed by critical race theory. Afrocyberpunk stories by Delany, Butler, Barnes, Hopkinson, and Okorafor register on our collective senses, vibe
with our hearts, minds, and spirits. Call it an embodiment of a soul feedback loop. Undeniably, acknowledgement of Afrocyberpunk amplifies and expands the bandwidth of race studies in sf. Afrocyberpunk divests whiteness as the norm of our technological imaginings without elimi- nating white people. Indeed, these black writers offer us consciously racialized settings in their imaginings, resolutely challenging the whiteness of cyberpunk.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Critical Race Theory › General – Afrocyberpunk
Isiah Lavender III 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. (“Critical Race Theory,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 37, p312-313) //le
Led by Delany’s example, established black writers like Barnes, Octavia Butler, Nalo Hopkinson, and Nnedi Okorafor have responded strongly to white cyberpunk by challenging racial hierarchies. Afrocyberpunk clarifies significant moments in American history and enables us to begin thinking through complicated questions of racial inequality, citizenship and rights, freedom, and justice. Counter-stories abound in Afrocyberpunk neutralizing the various racial stereotypes projected across a white cyberpunk while its cyberspace networks, hackers, and cy- borgs look entirely different from mainstream cyberpunk and its racial shortcomings. That’s the
beauty of Afrocyberpunk: It does not at all have to look like cyberpunk, all the while deploying familiar motifs common in cyberpunk. As a result, black writers create entire black planets with which to explore alternative life experiences.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Empire › General
John Rieder 20 is the author of Colonialism and the Emergence of Science Fiction (2008) and Science Fiction and the Mass Cultural Genre System (2017). He received the Science Fiction Research Asso- ciation’s Pioneer Award in 2011, and the Pilgrim Award in 2019. After receiving his Ph.D. at Yale University in 1980, he taught at the University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa until his retirement in 2018. (“Empire,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 40, p339) //le
What happens when the land of discovery is cyberspace? In an essay on Gibson and cyberpunk, Istvan Csicsery-Ronay distinguishes between the expansionist fantasies of early sf, based on co- lonialism and Social Darwinism, and the postmodern and cyberpunk counter-movement he calls implosion, where the rationality of instrumental reason is ground into fragments. In Gibson’s cyberspace, however, a lot of expansionist elements survive. The hackers in “Burning Chrome” (1982) and Neuromancer (1984) use invasive software developed by the military, signaling a world where technological development continues to be driven by military competition, with infor- mation rather than land now the stakes of battle. Gibson’s hacker protagonists are ‘cowboys,’ invoking the expansionist mythology of the American Western. At the end of the entire Sprawl series, in the concluding moments of Mona Lisa Overdrive (1988), an AI, an uploaded cowboy, and a software construct board a virtual vehicle bound for another solar system. Many of the critics less enamored with cyberpunk have complained about the way such plot elements blunt the critical edge of Gibson’s depiction of a dystopian near future. Csicsery-Ronay, for instance, says that the cyberpunks “write as if they are both the victims of a life-negating system and the heroic adventurers of thrill” (192). One might well argue, then, that in Gibson’s cyberspace it is not so much that the tired and wrongheaded ideologies of American self-congratulatory fantasy are abandoned or overcome as that they are restylized and recirculated—combined, first of all, with the cyni- cism that recognizes the ‘life-negating’ environmental and social consequences of contemporary capitalism at the same time as it continues to exploit its expansionist ethos for thrill and adventure. Thus, arguably, Gibson’s Sprawl fictions do not demystify the discoverer’s fantasy but rather recast it with cyberspace as the new frontier. We know very well, the reformulated fantasy would then go, that this space is an artifice constructed by the collective efforts of the corporate economy and supported by the material infrastructure of the entire computing technology of contemporary society, but we act as if were an autonomous realm that sustains itself as an independent reality and is available to appropriation and inhabitation by those able to adapt themselves to its environment. And so the Tessier-Ashpool AIs, the software construct of Julius Deane, and the uploaded minds of Bobby, the cowboy, and Angie, his girl, become in the end the natives, or rather the indige- nized settlers, of a newly opened interstellar frontier.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Empire › General
John Rieder 20 is the author of Colonialism and the Emergence of Science Fiction (2008) and Science Fiction and the Mass Cultural Genre System (2017). He received the Science Fiction Research Asso- ciation’s Pioneer Award in 2011, and the Pilgrim Award in 2019. After receiving his Ph.D. at Yale University in 1980, he taught at the University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa until his retirement in 2018. (“Empire,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 40, p339) //le
Sterling’s summary of body and mind invasion makes clear that cyberpunk’s tropes of invasion are all about the permeability of boundaries that formerly seemed solid. As Donna J. Haraway observed in her “A Manifesto for Cyborgs,” written in the same years and in response to the same social upheaval as the fiction of the cyberpunk coterie, the boundaries between organism and ma- chine, human and animal, and the physical and non-physical turn out to be porous and unreliable in the society taking shape around cybernetic command and control. The invasion of the body by prosthetics and of the mind by digital data and software highlights not only the contingency of individual identity but perhaps even more the vulnerability of the employee or citizen to forces of control that are mediated by technology but structured by several centuries of symbiosis between capitalism and colonialism. As the regime of flexible accumulation takes hold in the 1970s and 1980s, stripping U.S. labor of industrial and manufacturing jobs and cheapening production by exploiting formerly colonized labor markets, domestic labor and citizenship are systematically devalued by neoliberal attacks on the power of labor unions and the entitlements of citizens. If Moylan is right about the importance of the re-structuring of labor to cyberpunk’s construction of characters, the boundaries being violated in the fictions respond to this systematic invasion of boundaries formerly relied upon to protect the livelihood of first world workers. Cyberpunk’s array of hackers and meat puppets hyperbolizes the insecurity of the Rust-Belt-era labor market and the immense asymmetry of power that leaves workers increasingly at the mercy of multinational corporate strategies.
The thematic centrality of figures of invasion in early cyberpunk is rivaled by its attempts to imagine totality, or as Sterling puts it in the Mirrorshades manifesto: “the tools of global integration—the satellite media net, the multinational corporation—fascinate the cyberpunks and figure constantly in their work” (xiv). The plot of invasion itself is often driven by an un- derlying transformation of the concept of totality from some kind of spatiotemporal aggregation into disembodied information. In the re-structuring of the global economy this means that the tactical importance of occupying territory gives way to monopolizing access to employment, rights, resources, and information. The Sprawl trilogy responds with a plot built entirely on breaking into corporate data banks and breaking down the barriers that separate and fragment the totality of information in them. But at the same time as cyberpunk often fantasizes niches of resistance or escape (e.g. in Mirrorshades: “Freezone” [1985], Lewis Shiner’s “Till Human Voices Wake Us” [1984], Sterling and Gibson’s “Red Star, Winter Orbit” [1983]), it seldom imagines the possibility of a structural transformation in economic or political terms. Instead, the transfor- mation in Gibson takes place at the level of informational totality with the merging of the two Tessier-Ashpool AIs, while for the workers and citizens of the Sprawl, nothing changes: “Things are things,” as the transformed Wintermute puts it at the end of Neuromancer (270). What has often been said but bears repeating is that neocolonial capitalism has here turned into ‘things’ as such. All too often in cyberpunk, capitalism tends to operate as if it were nature itself, and the premise of capitalist growth as the underlying engine of history may be precisely the reason the Sprawl trilogy reverts to expansionist space travel at its conclusion.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Indigenous Futurisms › Solvency
Corinna Lenhardt 20 is a postdoctoral researcher and lecturer at the University of Münster, Germany, where she also earned her Ph.D. in American studies in 2018. Her research and teaching interests include ethnic studies and African American studies, race, gender, and gothic fiction. She has published articles and chapters on Indigenous fiction, film, and online activism. (“Indigenous Futurisms,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 41, p345) //le
Given her understanding of Indigenous futurisms as intersection of survivance and sf, as renun- ciation of hegemonic dominance through continuous and creative practices of cultural identity and resistance, it is not surprising that Dillon is also the first scholar to hint at the possibility of cyberpunk narratives by Indigenous artists. Arguably, cyberpunk’s punk attitude commits this sf subgenre to showing “how and why dominant ideologies marginalize dispossessed strata of the population” (Cavallaro 20). Cyberpunk’s mostly dystopian, technologically enhanced, urban societies in which “globalization and capitalism have led to the rule of multinational conglomerates, while margin- alized individuals live in a post-industrial setting defined by cold metal technology, virtual reality, and crime” (Lavigne 11), lend themselves to the Indigenous practices of survivance in the face of oppression and marginalization while subjected to dystopian colonial realities. Dillon’s anthological inclusion of Red Spider White Web (1990), an important novel by Misha (Métis) that “interpenetrates the cyberpunk” with Indigenous tribalism (Dillon, Walking 185), has triggered a necessary inquiry into the possibilities and limits of Indigenous cyberpunk cultural practices. In 2018, this inquiry fueled Brian K. Hudson’s (Cherokee) “Indigenous Cyberpunk Manifesto”:
Gibson constructed the console cowboy, but we are the digital Natives. We are the original Natives of the web, the tech-savvy NDNs weaving in and out of discussion threads, the warriors with keyboards who carry sparks into cyberspace.3 We are the coders who create sovereign virtual worlds, the digital code talkers who braid Indigenous tongues into networks of resistance. We’ve navigated the webs of branching nodes since time immemorial—before kubernētēs became cybernetics and before punk was ponk. Our digital allies boost our signals. We are Indigenous cyberpunks.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Indigenous Futurisms › 1NC
Corinna Lenhardt 20 is a postdoctoral researcher and lecturer at the University of Münster, Germany, where she also earned her Ph.D. in American studies in 2018. Her research and teaching interests include ethnic studies and African American studies, race, gender, and gothic fiction. She has published articles and chapters on Indigenous fiction, film, and online activism. (“Indigenous Futurisms,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 41, p344-345) //le
Dillon’s optimism regarding sf’s potential to “honor Native traditions, to dig into history lingering behind myth, and to share with readers the ramifications of indigenous diasporas in ways that recognize their accountability” (“Miindiwag” 236) intersects with the work of Gerald Vizenor (Anishinaabe) and his oft-cited concept of “survivance.” Survivance com- bines Indigenous ‘survival’ with ‘endurance’ and ‘resistance.’ It implies an “active repudiation of dominance, tragedy, and victimry” (Vizenor, Fugitive 15), that is both a rejection of estab- lished images of ‘the Indian’ and connected narratives of victimization and an insistence on
Indigenous continuance and adaptability. This insistence neither denies the historical process of colonization nor its contemporary impact; rather, it refuses to see Indigenous peoples defined by these processes as perpetual victims without agency. Translated to the context of sf, survivance entails pride, optimism, and (self-)empowerment in the face of white mainstream practices of stereotyping and exclusion—Indigenous peoples and cultures are alive and kicking, today as well as in fantastic futures.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Indigenous Futurisms › 1NC
Corinna Lenhardt 20 is a postdoctoral researcher and lecturer at the University of Münster, Germany, where she also earned her Ph.D. in American studies in 2018. Her research and teaching interests include ethnic studies and African American studies, race, gender, and gothic fiction. She has published articles and chapters on Indigenous fiction, film, and online activism. (“Indigenous Futurisms,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 41, p344) //le
Since Grace L. Dillon (Anishinaabe) published her watershed anthology of Indigenous science fiction (sf) writing, Walking the Clouds: An Anthology of Indigenous Science Fiction (2012), Indigenous futurisms—the plural indicating the vast variety of culture-specific negotiations and inventions from Indigenous peoples across the globe1—conceptualizes two distinct, yet intimately related aspects of Indigenous speculative cultural productions. First, creators of “Indigenous futurisms sometimes intentionally experiment with, sometimes intentionally dislodge, sometimes merely accompany, but invariably change the perimeters of sf” (Dillon, Walking 3). Grappling with mainstream sf’s troubling persistence in settler colonial fantasies2 and hegemonically configured and reinforced race discourses, Indigenous futurisms provide an alternative to the “steady diet of the feathers and the fantasy” fed to non-Indigenous audiences “as what it supposedly means to be a ‘real Indian’” (Adare 1). This by no means entails only the inclusion of authentic Indigenous characters as part of futurist texts; rather, “they are generated by and inspirational for Native peoples” (Medak-Saltzman 143). This latter aspect already implies the second key aspect prevalent in Indigenous futurisms; that is, the understanding of Indigenous futurisms as age-old Indigenous cultural practices predating western concepts of sf easily by thousands of years: As Dillon writes, “[m]any experimental narrative tech- niques that cutting-edge SF authors congratulate themselves for discovering have actually been around for millennia in Indigenous storytelling” (“The People” Pos. 116). She goes on to remark that “[s]lipstreams, alternative realities, multiverses, time traveling—the stock tropes of mainstream SF are ancient elements of Indigenous ways of knowing” (“The People” Pos. 116). By working from within Indigenous spiritual, cultural, and scientific worldviews and traditions, which entail concepts that have not just been dismissed in mainstream sf, but in the wake of the western Enlightenment generally, Indigenous futurist texts position indigeneity at the heart of both scientific progress and sociocultural futurity. In sum, Indigenous futurisms indigenize mainstream sf by re-envisioning its tropes and motifs from complex, culture-specific Indigenous perspectives; the historically and still predominately white genre is mobilized from both within and without to push Indigenous peoples from the stereotype-ridden margins to the center of sf and, thus, into futurity.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Afrofuturism › Perm
Isiah Lavender III* and Graham J. Murphy^ 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. ^is a professor with the School of English and Liberal Studies (Faculty of Arts) at Seneca College (Toronto). In addition to more than two dozen articles published in a va- riety of edited collections and peer-reviewed journals, he is also co-editor of Cyberpunk and Visual Culture (2018) and Beyond Cyberpunk: New Critical Perspectives (2010), and co-author of Ursula K. Le Guin: A Critical Companion (2006). (“Afrofuturism,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 42, p359-360) //le
Although space prevents a full analysis of Afrofuturism and Afrocyberpunk in other media, it would be remiss not to at least point to the cyberpunk influences in Afrofuturist art and fashion. For example, aside from the fact King T’Challa’s suit in Black Panther is a cybernetic enhance- ment, turning him into a cyberpunk-styled cyborg,7 the Afrofuturist fashion that was lauded when the film was released is a central component of black cultural identity in the 21st century. As Connie Wang writes, “it’s easy enough to spot: powerful Black men and women dressed in Besotho blankets, Himba braids, Maasai collars, as well as Egyptian anks and crowns inspired by Yourban deity Oshun—remixed with superhero textiles, gravity-defying jewelry, and technicolor hair,” some of which is reminiscent of cyberpunk visual motifs. Fashion is also a key draw to the immensely successful Afropunk Festival which, inspired by the documentary Afro-Punk (Spooner 2003), provides opportunities to showcase black arts in all forms of cultural expression. Similarly, the Afrofuturist art show “In Their Own Form” at the Museum of Contemporary Photography in Chicago (12 April, 2018, to 8 July, 2018) featured more than a dozen contemporary artists, includ- ing Senegalese Alun Be whose “Edification” series includes photographs of young black children wearing virtual reality goggles (Sayej). Or, as Pamela Phatsimo Sunstrum points out, Kiluanji Kia Henda’s photo-based project, Icarus 13 (2006–08), imagines Angolan astrophysicists preparing for the first expedition to the sun, weaving the Icarus myth and Apollo 13 that “provides another example of a creative practice that collapses myth into sf while simultaneously igniting African postcolonial imaginings” (118). Even something as mundane as searching for Afrofuturist fashion on Pinterest reveals cyberpunk influences in the litany of images. Afrocyberpunk remains a viable and ongoing strain in the larger Afrofuturist field, particularly when it comes to the visual splen- dor on display in fashion and the visual arts.
In closing, with its focus on “issues of social justice in a global and technology-intensive world” (Lavender, Afrofuturism Rising 3), Afrofuturism has grown more complex since Dery’s “Black to the Future” and has become a useful analytical tool that has, in many ways, evolved beyond its early roots in cyberpunk, at least conceptually or theoretically. For example, as Bould demonstrates in his work on Afrocyberpunk cinema, Afrofuturism anticipates “a transformation” in sf studies, all the while working against “the typical cyberpunk acceptance of capitalism [and] assimilation of certain currently marginalized peoples into a global system that might, at best, tolerate some relatively minor (although not unimportant) reforms” (182) by breaking with the colorblind future of sf. Sim- ilarly, Afro-British philosopher Kodwo Eshun discusses how Afrofuturism establishes a “webbed network,” an historical matrix reflecting black people’s “perpetual fight for human status, a yearn- ing for human rights, and a struggle for inclusion within the human species” which continues beyond chattel slavery far into the future as it connects black people across time (More Brilliant 00[- 006]). Elsewhere, Eshun identifies such connections as “countermemories that contest the colonial archive, thereby situating the collective trauma of slavery as the founding moment of modernity” (“Further” 288). Thus, Afrofuturism recuperates a seemingly stolen past that many people would like to forget—the scene from Black Panther when Erik Killmonger (Michael B. Jordan) lectures the white museum curator about stolen African history comes immediately to mind—and creates options for cultural analysis. Or, as Kilgore notes, “Afrofuturism can be seen as less a marker of black authenticity and more a cultural force, an episteme that betokens a shift in our largely uncon- scious assumptions about what histories matter and how they may serve as a precondition for any
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Afrofuturism › Janelle Monáe
Isiah Lavender III* and Graham J. Murphy^ 20 is the Sterling-Goodman Professor of English at the University of Georgia, where he researches and teaches courses in African American literature and science fiction. His books include Afrofuturism Rising: The Literary Prehistory of a Movement (2019) and Race in American Science Fiction (2011), as well as the edited collections Dis-Orienting Planets: Racial Representations of Asia in Science Fiction (2017) and Black and Brown Planets: The Politics of Race in Science Fiction (2014). He is a co-editor of the oldest science fiction journal Extrapolation. ^is a professor with the School of English and Liberal Studies (Faculty of Arts) at Seneca College (Toronto). In addition to more than two dozen articles published in a va- riety of edited collections and peer-reviewed journals, he is also co-editor of Cyberpunk and Visual Culture (2018) and Beyond Cyberpunk: New Critical Perspectives (2010), and co-author of Ursula K. Le Guin: A Critical Companion (2006). (“Afrofuturism,” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 42, p358) //le
Arguably, the most obvious descendant of Sun Ra is American R&B artist Janelle Monáe, whose explicitly Afrofuturist/Afrocyberpunk work on The ArchAndroid (2010), The Electric Lady (2013), and Dirty Computer (2018) shows a deep awareness of how racial identity politics blended with sound technology can impact an ever-quickening global popular technoculture defined by race. As Christine Capetola writes in her contribution to this collection, Monáe “creates her own black, queer, and feminist version of cyberpunk through interfacing her body and musical technology” (246) and, in so doing, partakes in an “Afrocyberpunk project of using (music) technology” to free herself and her listeners from racist, sexist, heteronormative power structures (247). Monáe’s oeuvre is loosely organized around the struggles of her android alter ego, Cindi Mayweather, in a dystopian near future where the freedom to love is circumscribed by the pow- erful Droid Authority, prompting Mayweather’s growth from the persecuted Other in Metropolis: The Chase Suite (2007) to the revolutionary icon of an android underground in The ArchAndroid, a time traveling icon who may have gone missing in Electric Lady but has proven inspirational to “droids from all across Metropolis [who] gather in nightclubs [...] and barbershops where they revel in the otherness that separates them from humans” (Pulliam-Moore). “The android,” Monáe explains in an interview with Dorian Lynskey, “represents a new form of the Other [...] And I believe we’re going to be living in a world of androids by 2029. How will we all get along? Will we treat the android humanely? What type of society will it be when we’re integrated? I’ve felt like the Other at certain points in my life. I felt like it was a universal language that we could all understand.” This focus on the ‘universal language of the Other’ fuels Monáe’s Dirty Computer and its accompanying film, or what Monáe calls an emotion picture, that depicts an oppressive future where humans who don’t conform to ‘proper’ codes of behavior are quarantined by New Dawn agents and forced to undergo a “cleansing,” a euphemism for a techno-chemical lobotomy where rebellious memories are wiped away and the subject reprogrammed accordingly. Having revealed that Dirty Computer is definitely part of the larger Cindi Mayweather narrative universe,6 Monáe’s Afrofuturist and Afrocyberpunk promises to expand her artistic oeuvre in exciting and much-anticipated directions.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Baudrillard › General
Haar* and McFarlane^ 20 -- *received her Ph.D. from the University of Tübingen, Germany. She conducted research on simulation and virtuality in theory, as well as technology and media representations in postmodern society. She studied modern German literature, media studies, and musicology. Aside from media history, media, and film theory, her areas of research comprise game studies and comic studies. ^ is a British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at Glasgow University with a project entitled “Products of Conception: Science Fiction and Pregnancy, 1968–2015.” She has worked on the Wellcome Trust-funded Science Fiction and the Medical Humanities project and holds a Ph.D. from the University of St Andrews on William Gibson’s science fiction novels. She is the editor of Adam Roberts: Critical Essays (2016) and has served as blog and reviews editor for the journal BMJ Medical Humanities. (Rebecca, Anna, “Simulation and Simulacra” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 31, p261) //le
The issues of alienation from ontological meaning as a result of social media simulation is taken up in many more contemporary post-cyberpunk texts. For example, the anthology series Black Mirror (2011–) repeatedly returns to the possibilities for ontological meaning in a world dominated by the simulations and simulacra of online identity, and again in ways that act as commentary on contemporary socio-political realities and possibilities. The episode “Nosedive” (2016) features a social system that has been compared to China’s Social Credit System which aims to assign each citizen a rating that can be affected by feedback on one’s social activities.4 The episode shows the quick decline of one woman’s social credit as she attempts to attend a friend’s wedding but finds herself embarrassed and socially bankrupt. The episode concludes with the woman imprisoned, having hit rock bottom. She begins an exchange with the occupant of the cell next to her own, and the episode ends with them shouting increasingly creative insults at each other, culminating in them angrily and gleefully shouting “fuck you” at one another. Of course, the premise of the episode is not based on a future social credit system, whether the one under development in China or any other; rather, the episode critiques the attention to appearances that must be paid in order to develop social capital on social media and suggests a freedom that can be found in being ex- cluded from these systems, in becoming an outcast. In this relatively liberatory ending, the show offers some hope for an authentic encounter with others and with one’s own being.
In conclusion, technological simulation today has successfully mapped ‘reality’ in its entirety, from the capabilities of Google Earth to the tracking of human individuals via their social media accounts. We have entered, according to Christoph Kucklick, a granular society in which the digital begins to replace reality (10). Kucklick understands granularity as a measure of resolu- tion, the precision of data, because through digitalization our world is already mapped and the changes now are in the finesse of the resolution (10). Such a view reflects Baudrillard’s diagnosis that we are living in a hyperreal simulacrum and that the differences that will be made to that situation are merely those of degree. In the more optimistic exemplars of post-cyberpunk there are suggestions that the real is not gone forever and might be accessed, either through worker solidarity or through reconnecting with others without the mediation of social networks. Hopes such as these represent a departure from Baudrillard’s bleak outlook and show that cyberpunk and, perhaps more effectively, post-cyberpunk continue to engage with the concepts of simula- cra and simulation but in different ways, attempting to open out new ways forward. As cyber- punk and post-cyberpunk continue to show, we can refuse to be stranded in the deserts of the electronic night.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Baudrillard › General
Haar* and McFarlane^ 20 -- *received her Ph.D. from the University of Tübingen, Germany. She conducted research on simulation and virtuality in theory, as well as technology and media representations in postmodern society. She studied modern German literature, media studies, and musicology. Aside from media history, media, and film theory, her areas of research comprise game studies and comic studies. ^ is a British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at Glasgow University with a project entitled “Products of Conception: Science Fiction and Pregnancy, 1968–2015.” She has worked on the Wellcome Trust-funded Science Fiction and the Medical Humanities project and holds a Ph.D. from the University of St Andrews on William Gibson’s science fiction novels. She is the editor of Adam Roberts: Critical Essays (2016) and has served as blog and reviews editor for the journal BMJ Medical Humanities. (Rebecca, Anna, “Simulation and Simulacra” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 31, p260-261) //le
The importance of virtual worlds in mediating social encounters and managing, if not out- right shaping, the political spectrum is evidenced in the controversies surrounding Cambridge Analytica, foreign troll farms, and Russian interference in the 2016 American presidential elec- tion. These instances, and the management of the perception of authorities in dictatorships
or Communist systems, such as Chinese and North Korean censorship of internal computer networks, emphasize the importance of cyberpunk’s critique. For example, Blade Runner 2049 (Villeneuve 2017) evokes nothing so much as the desperation of an individual who knows their reality is a simulacrum but continues to function through the cruel optimism it offers, since this is the only defense against a slide into nihilistic solipsism. Even though K (Ryan Gosling) knows he is a replicant he fantasizes about being something more; even though he knows his companion, Joi (Ana de Armas) is a hologram he believes the positive feedback she offers.3 The desperate need for the validation of the newsfeed is dramatized as he moves through his lonely world in which the hustle and bustle of the multicultural cityscapes in Blade Runner (Scott 1982) is replaced with a world in which K is most often pictured alone. Ryan Gosling’s distancing affect portrays K as perhaps most alone when interacting with others onscreen. Blade Runner 2049 reflects a world in which the replacement of life with its simulation—through replicant identity, which acts as an analogy for living through the simulated identities created through social media—is complete, and as a result a meaningful identity is impossible to inhabit and K is left with the distinct sen- sation that his world has been emptied out, with meaningful action that might change society happening ‘out there,’ out of his control.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Baudrillard › General
Haar* and McFarlane^ 20 -- *received her Ph.D. from the University of Tübingen, Germany. She conducted research on simulation and virtuality in theory, as well as technology and media representations in postmodern society. She studied modern German literature, media studies, and musicology. Aside from media history, media, and film theory, her areas of research comprise game studies and comic studies. ^ is a British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at Glasgow University with a project entitled “Products of Conception: Science Fiction and Pregnancy, 1968–2015.” She has worked on the Wellcome Trust-funded Science Fiction and the Medical Humanities project and holds a Ph.D. from the University of St Andrews on William Gibson’s science fiction novels. She is the editor of Adam Roberts: Critical Essays (2016) and has served as blog and reviews editor for the journal BMJ Medical Humanities. (Rebecca, Anna, “Simulation and Simulacra” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 31, p255-256) //le
Cyberpunk texts use technological simulations in order to analyze the increasingly mediated and hyperreal nature of our environment, but in the meantime, technology has been catching up to the science-fictional imaginary, albeit sometimes in unexpected ways. At the beginning of the 2000s, VR barely had any cultural sway but since then games have tried to bring players into a virtual world, as far as the technical possibilities allow. The development of the Internet as an encompassing space thanks to WiFi and satellite navigation technologies, a development that some sf writers (and readers) anticipated but could otherwise barely have been imagined in the 1990s,
makes VR possible as an everyday technology. In this context the 2000s can be thought of as a cultural turning point from a medial society, one in which reality was shaped and constructed through the media, to a digital society, one in which digital technologies allowed new possibilities for active user participation while also excluding such participation through the hidden work done by inaccessible coding. The move from the medial to the digital required a change in user behav- iors, as humans learned to navigate the new digital landscape (or were left behind by it), as well as economic responses as digitization affected industries (and nations) of all kinds. Digitization was not so much a goal as a tool, but a tool that enabled new forms of work and changed communi- cation through new information technologies, enabling the emergence of new networks as well as the exacerbation of social cleavages, notably in the socioeconomic divisions impacting social classes vis-à-vis access to technologies and the friction caused by First vs. Third World geopolitics that has repeatedly seen the technological wonders of the former predicated upon the cheap, if not exploitive, labor of the latter.
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Baudrillard › General
Haar* and McFarlane^ 20 -- *received her Ph.D. from the University of Tübingen, Germany. She conducted research on simulation and virtuality in theory, as well as technology and media representations in postmodern society. She studied modern German literature, media studies, and musicology. Aside from media history, media, and film theory, her areas of research comprise game studies and comic studies. ^ is a British Academy Postdoctoral Fellow at Glasgow University with a project entitled “Products of Conception: Science Fiction and Pregnancy, 1968–2015.” She has worked on the Wellcome Trust-funded Science Fiction and the Medical Humanities project and holds a Ph.D. from the University of St Andrews on William Gibson’s science fiction novels. She is the editor of Adam Roberts: Critical Essays (2016) and has served as blog and reviews editor for the journal BMJ Medical Humanities. (Rebecca, Anna, “Simulation and Simulacra” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 31, p255-256) //le
Perhaps the most important voice in theorizing the entanglement of ontology, reality, virtuality, and simulation is that of Jean Baudrillard, whose work intertextually influences cyberpunk at some of its key moments and even acts as a kind of cyberpunk theory, blurring the lines between the fiction and its commentary, the territory and the map. Baudrillard’s key text is Simulacra and Simulation in which he develops some of his most important concepts, including that of the hyperreal. Baudrillard argues that we are living in an increasingly mediated world, constructed
of simulations and simulacra: While simulations are intended to represent or to copy objects or systems, simulacra are simulations with no corresponding original. By drawing attention to the proliferation of simulacra and their impact on the human mind, Baudrillard’s work suggests a dystopian society as humans live under the illusion that they are engaged with some kind of ‘truth’ when actually there can be no access to such a thing in our so-called reality; in fact, ‘truth’ cannot exist in our current state, an idea that rings increasingly true in the era of fake news, false accusations of fake news, and the proliferation of conspiracy theories via social media. Rather than merely predicting a future dystopia, Baudrillard’s work argues that dystopia had already been realized at the time of writing. He coins the term ‘hyperreality’ to describe this society in which simulacra shape the human life world and a pretense at a reference to reality is no longer required. Baudrillard’s work resonates with the almost-contemporaneous development of cyberpunk as a cultural mode: While some cyberpunk grappled with the new frontiers represented by cyberspace, Baudrillard saw VR technology as the acceleration of the destruction of the real by its hyperreal double (Perfect Crime 47).
2022
Michigan
Kritik
Cyberpunk Themes w/ Camp K’s › Gothicism › General
Heise-von Der Lippe 20 is an assistant lecturer with the chair of Anglophone Literatures at the University of Tübingen, Germany. Her research focuses on the parallels between monstrous corporeality and monstrous textuality, as well as the intersections of the Gothic and critical post- humanism. Recent publications include her co-edited collections Posthuman Gothic (2017) and Literaturwissenschaften in der Krise (2018). She is one of the series editors of Challenges for the Human- ities for Narr, Tübingen. (Anya, “Gothicism” The Routledge Companion to Cyberpunk Culture, Chapter 32, p270-271) //le
This kind of abject body horror, which casts the human body as soulless raw material for bio-technological experiments, can be traced back to Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein (1818). As Veronica Hollinger argues, in contemporary re-readings, Shelley’s novel “has been transformed into a precursor text of cyberculture” (192). Dongshin Yi, for instance, reads Frankenstein as a key text in the Genealogy of Cyborgothic [sic], as Victor Frankenstein’s “workshop of filthy creation” (Shelley 32) conjures questions of creation and (identity) production, as well as creative and nar- rative authority. Shunned by society and abandoned by his creator, Frankenstein’s creature ulti- mately begins to reflect on his existence and the manner of his creation—a query mirrored in the novel’s epigraph from Milton’s Paradise Lost (1667): “Did I request thee maker from thy clay to make me man? Did I solicit thee from darkness to promote me?” The novel, like its cybergothic descendants, draws attention to how the infinite possibilities of technoscientific creation tend to destabilize human individuality and our sense of self, origin, and purpose to the point where we begin to question our concept of humanity as a rational, clearly demarcated species. Cyber- gothic texts, from Frankenstein’s proto-posthuman Gothic explorations of these questions on- ward, take these destabilizations and anxieties and aestheticize them to create fully fleshed (or bio-technoscientifically engineered) monstrous horrors. As Cavallaro argues, “the bodies that populate these worlds are themselves intrinsically uncanny [...] threshold phenomena precariously suspended between materiality and immateriality” (172) Cavallaro associates this liminality of cyberpunk bodies with Gothic forms of embodiment: “An intricate and befuddling incarnation of often repressed desires and fantasies, the Gothic body eludes labelling and its appeal is accordingly
complex. Above all, it is boundless; this condition is most famously epitomized by the formless pulp of the unfinished female creature that Dr Frankenstein ends up scattering over the floor of his laboratory” (172).