2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Germline Genetic Engineering
Andrew Joseph, 6-5-2019, (Andrew Joseph is a general assignment reporter at STAT. Prior to joining STAT at its founding in 2015, he worked for the San Antonio Express-News and the San Francisco Chronicle. He was part of the STAT team that was named a Pulitzer Prize finalist for their reporting on the early days of the Covid-19 pandemic. Andrew graduated from Dartmouth College and has covered everything from crime to health policy.) "Congress Revives Ban on Altering the DNA of Human Embryos Used for Pregnancies", Scientific American, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/congress-revives-ban-on-altering-the-dna-of-human-embryos-used-for-pregnancies/ lilw-msdi2022
A House committee on Tuesday restored to pending legislation a ban on altering the genomes of human embryos intended for pregnancies, despite calls from some scientists to lift the ban and allow the Food and Drug Administration to review applications for new technologies. Lifting the prohibition could have opened the door to clinical trials of babies being made with genetic material from three people or with genomes that had been changed in ways that would be passed on to future generations. The ban has been attached to bills that fund the Food and Drug Administration in the form of an amendment, or rider, since December 2015. But last month, a subcommittee of the House Appropriations Committee dropped the ban from the legislation. At a hearing Tuesday, supporters of the ban framed it as a necessary barrier to prevent experiments like the one announced last year in which a Chinese scientist created the world’s first gene-edited babies with the technology CRISPR. The work drew worldwide condemnation for skirting ethical and regulatory guidelines and for using scientific tools that were not yet ready to be used in people. “The ethics hadn’t caught up with the science, and… the science has not caught up with the science,” said Rep. Robert Aderholt (R-Ala.), who introduced the rider in 2015 and again at Tuesday’s hearing. He said that for now, genetically editing embryos had “too many unknowns, too many unintended consequences.” The rider blocks the Food and Drug Administration from considering clinical trial applications “in which a human embryo is intentionally created or modified to include a heritable genetic modification.” Scientists and ethicists who advocated for dropping it argued that doing so would simply allow the FDA to review research requests, as it does any other innovative therapy. Some Democratic lawmakers who had appeared supportive of dropping the ban earlier — and who had criticized the inclusion of the ban in 2015 without debate — said they felt it was time for Congress to debate the underlying ethical and scientific issues. But they said that should be done separately from the appropriations process. The chairwoman of the committee, Democrat Nita Lowey of New York, said she “reluctantly supported” returning the ban to the bill. She acknowledged that editing embryonic DNA had some potential risks, but added that it could cure and prevent genetic disease. “We have a moral obligation to allow advances in science so that fewer parents have to watch a child die,” she said. Some scientists had called on Congress to modify the legislation to allow so-called three-parent embryos but maintain the ban on the direct editing of embryonic DNA. The three-parent technology, more precisely called mitochondrial replacement therapy, or MRT, has the potential to prevent severe diseases that result from abnormal mitochondria, energy-producing cellular structures. It involves transferring the nucleus of an unfertilized egg with defective mitochondria into one with healthy mitochondria and then fertilizing it via IVF. Because mitochondria have a small bit of their own DNA, the resulting embryo has genes from three people. The technology is being studied in some countries, including Britain, as a way to halt the inheritance of genetic diseases that stem from the DNA in the mitochondria. Rep. Sanford Bishop Jr. (D-Ga.), who chaired the subcommittee that approved the bill without the ban last month, said he wanted Congress to discuss allowing MRT, “but today is not that time, and this appropriations committee markup is not that place.” He supported adding the ban back to the bill. The committee approved the amendment to reinsert the ban on a voice vote, but one Democrat who voted against it was Rep. Debbie Wasserman Schultz of Florida. She carries a variant of the BRCA2 gene that raises her risk of certain cancers (she was diagnosed with breast cancer in 2007) and said her children would have to get tested to see if they carried the mutation. “If we ever have an opportunity when they have children or when they decide to have a family, to have research advanced to a point where you could have their genetic material, when combined with their partner, altered so that that mutation could be cut off in our family tree and that risk of death and massive health care implications could be eliminated, that’s incredibly important,” she said.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Germline Genetic Engineering
Lev Facher, 6-18-2019, (Lev Facher is a Washington correspondent for STAT, reporting on the politics of health and science. Since joining STAT in 2016, he has written extensively about the federal government’s response to the Covid-19 pandemic, the opioid crisis, and the pharmaceutical industry’s influence on Capitol Hill.) "Why Democrats reopened the debate about germline gene editing", STAT, https://www.statnews.com/2019/06/18/democrats-reopened-debate-about-germline-editing/ lilw-msdi2022
WASHINGTON — A rogue Chinese scientist stunned the world last year when he announced the birth of genetically modified twin girls, prompting widespread outcry from the broader scientific community and calls for a “global moratorium” on editing human embryos that result in births. Yet months later, Democrats on Capitol Hill surprised many science policy experts when they attempted to roll back a related, 4-year-old ban on altering the DNA of embryos intended for pregnancies. To many health policy experts here, and research advocates across the country, the timing — just months after the biggest genome editing scandal in world history — was inexplicable. Several Republicans criticized the proposal by playing up concerns of “maverick bioengineers” operating with little oversight and without ethical norms. And while some scientists supported the effort, others expressed open confusion, in particular at the breadth of the change Democrats sought. Within weeks of proposing to eliminate their plan, Democrats largely backed off. But their sudden effort to reverse what seemed to some like a basic ethical protection serves as a case study in how Washington regulates science — and the immense influence lawmakers, regardless of their scientific expertise, often wield over federal research. “In terms of ‘Why now,’ it does seem odd given there is so much international conversation in the scientific community about how to limit germline editing,” said Remy Brim, a scientist and former Democratic Capitol Hill aide who works at the D.C. lobbying firm BGR. The United States has banned germline editing with the aim of starting a pregnancy since 2015, the result of bipartisan opposition to the practice and preemptive scientific concern about the implications of the gene-editing technology CRISPR. Republicans in particular have supported the ban due to conscience concerns similar to those surrounding the use of fetal tissue in research and using federal funds for abortion — some argue that germline genome editing requires the creation of human embryos that will eventually be discarded. When Democrats took control of the House of Representatives in last year’s midterm elections, they saw an opening to repeal a measure that many felt was overly restrictive. As the House Appropriations Committee considered the spending package that funds the Food and Drug Administration, lawmakers excluded the brief provision that has banned the consideration of certain genome-editing trials — a change that would have essentially lifted the ban, if the law had passed. Republicans quickly criticized the change, calling it hasty and ill-advised — even specifically citing China’s “CRISPR babies” scandal, in which He Jiankui drew worldwide criticism for using the technique to alter the genes of twin girls.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Emily Bohatch and Joseph Bustos, 1-3-2020, (both reporters) "SC’s Republicans in Congress applaud Trump drone strike that killed Iranian general", U.S. Representative William Timmons, https://timmons.house.gov/news/documentsingle.aspx?DocumentID=35 lilw-msdi2022
As news broke that an American drone strike killed a major Iranian general was reported Friday, South Carolina’s Republicans in Congress praised President Donald Trump. Meeting with reporters at his West Columbia office, U.S. Rep. Joe Wilson, R-Springdale, called the commander in chief’s order to bomb a Baghdad airport and kill Maj. Gen. Qassem Soleimani “courageous.” Wilson called Soleimani “one of the great terrorists of our era.” The general was the head of the Quds Force of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps and was instrumental in Iranian military and intelligence operations. Wilson’s comments echoed praise offered by other Republican leaders, from U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham to former S.C. governor and ambassador to the United Nations Nikki Haley. Meanwhile, the state’s top Democrat in Congress criticized Trump’s decision to order the airstrike. U.S. Rep. Jim Clyburn, a Columbia Democrat and House majority whip, said in a statement on Twitter on Friday the president’s action put the country at risk. “His failure to even consult Congress—entrusted by the Constitution to authorize military force—is alarming,” Clyburn said. “Congress must uphold our responsibility to protect national security.” U.S. Rep. Joe Cunningham, D-Charleston, called for transparency between the Trump administration and Congress. “Last night’s airstrike was unprecedented with incalculable consequences that will play out over the coming days, weeks, and months,” Cunningham said, according to a statement. “Given the immense gravity of this situation, Congress needs to hear from the Administration about the intelligence that led to this airstrike and how it fits into our broader strategy to counter Iran’s destabilizing presence in the region, consolidate our gains in Iraq, and combat violent extremism.” The U.S. airstrike is the latest development in a series of incidents of violence in Iraq. On New Year’s Eve, demonstrators who support the Iranian-backed group Kataib Hezbollah stormed the U.S. embassy in Baghdad, breaching the exterior walls and starting fires. The protesters, said to be angered over U.S. airstrikes that killed members of the group, later retreated as the president ordered more troops to the region. The U.S. Department of State reported that U.S. personnel were safe. The drone strike has raised concerns of further escalation in the United States’ conflict with Iran. Wilson also compared the United States’ involvement in the Middle East to the war against communism, calling it a “generational conflict” that cannot be ended until America is delivered a decisive victory. “We’re at greater risk today than ever, and that’s why the president is taking this firm action,” Wilson said, adding, “It’s quite appropriate that President Trump take the action to rid the world of this person who is a threat to America’s national security and a threat to American families. I’m just so proud of the president’s leadership to act so decisively.” After the news of the airstrike broke, U.S. Sen. Lindsey Graham, one of Trump’s staunchest allies, had quickly applauded Trump and issued a warning to the government in Tehran. “To the Iranian government: if you want more, you will get more,” Graham said, according to a statement. “If Iranian aggression continues and I worked at an Iranian oil refinery, I would think about a new career.” Graham said that Trump’s actions were in “direct response to Iranian aggression,” including the recent killing of an American contractor in Iraq. The rocket attack was aimed at an Iraqi military base, and believed to be orchestrated by Iran-backed groups. “To the Iranian government: if you want to stay in the oil business, leave America and our allies alone and stop being the largest state sponsor of terrorism in the world,” Graham said, according to the statement. U.S. Sen. Tim Scott called the move “a calculated and proportional response to Iran’s belligerent aggression towards the United States and our allies. “Iran and Soleimani continued to attack and kill Americans, sieged our embassy in Baghdad, and carried out acts of violence to destabilize the region as a whole,” Scott said, according to a statement. “The President was absolutely within his authority to approve this operation and we will not be deterred when American lives and American interests are in jeopardy.” U.S. Rep. Jeff Duncan also said he approved of Trump’s actions. “This action shows Iranian attacks and aggression against Americans will not go unnoticed under President Trump’s leadership,” Duncan said, according to a statement. “Our military is the best of the best, and may God bless them for their efforts in making the world a safer place without murderous terrorists like Qassem Soleimani.” U.S. Rep. William Timmons, R-Greenville, called the president’s actions decisive and appropriate. “That said, Americans at home and abroad should remain vigilant,” Timmons said in a statement. “We know the Iranian government is eager to strike back, and if they choose to do so, they will go after our most vulnerable citizens and assets. The Iranians would be smart to proceed with extreme caution. Our military presence in the Middle East remains strong, and further aggression against us will not be tolerated.” U.S. Rep. Ralph Norman, R-Rock Hill, called the operation a much needed step for security in the Middle East. “Under Obama, we saw that accommodating Iran with a horribly flawed nuclear deal and even billion-dollar ransom payouts failed to change their hostile behavior,” Norman said. “In fact, the unwillingness to confront this terrorist regime head-on only emboldened its leaders, leading to a steady escalation which included attacks on American personnel, equipment, and most recently our embassy in Iraq.” U.S. Rep. Tom Rice, R-Myrtle Beach, echoed the sentiment.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Kyle Lynaugh, 3-9-2022, (Kyle Lynaugh joined the Council in January of 2022 as a spring intern with the Public Opinion team. He is currently a graduate student at the Harris School of Public Policy at the University of Chicago, studying public policy while focusing on global conflict and policy analysis.) "Public Opinion on Civilian Casualties in the War on Terror", The Chicago Council, https://www.thechicagocouncil.org/commentary-and-analysis/blogs/public-opinion-civilian-casualties-war-terror lilw-msdi2022
Americans tend to favor airstrikes against terror-linked targets, rather than risking US service members’ lives in ground operations. For example, according to the 2015 Chicago Council Survey, 77 percent of Americans favored the use of airstrikes against terrorist training camps and other facilities, while only 60 percent favored using US ground troops against those targets. However, Americans are still concerned with the civilian casualties that are more likely to result from increased airstrikes. In a Washington Post poll conducted in conjunction with YouGov in 2019, 64 percent of Americans agreed that “The US should NOT use airstrikes if it meant killing innocent civilians.” Although, a notable portion of the population (36%) disagreed with that statement. Furthermore, a subsection of voters that identified as supporting Donald Trump in the 2016 primary election held opposite views, with nearly three-quarters disagreeing with that same statement (74%). This disparity between the general US population and early Trump voters alludes to a larger partisan disagreement amongst the American populace concerning counterterrorism and the tools to combat it. While all Americans have an aversion to civilian casualties the willingness to use lethal force differs between Republicans and Democrats. Republicans tend to favor more military interventions while Democrats are more wary of the use of force. The type of military intervention does not affect this overall trend. The 2021 Chicago Council Survey finds that 40 percent of Republicans say the United States is not using military tools like drone strikes and military interventions enough, nearly double the 20 percent of Democrats who say the same. Democrats are much more likely to say that the United States uses military tools like drone strikes too much (39%), while very few Republicans feel this way (14%). This discrepancy relates to civilian casualties as air and drone strikes are more likely to kill civilian bystanders. The above Washington Post Poll that finds a partisan subjection of the population may be more willing to accept some civilian casualties could be a potential reason as to why political party seems to affect the preferred amount of air and drone strikes.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
John Burgess Everett, 4-23-2015, (John Burgess Everett is the co-congressional bureau chief for POLITICO, specializing in the Senate since 2013. He’s a native Mainer, a University of Maryland graduate and one of those people who goes by his middle name. Before covering the Senate, Burgess covered transportation policy for POLITICO and served on the production team. He’s also an alum of the Gazette in suburban Maryland and the Portland Press Herald in Maine.)"GOP strongly backs drone strikes, despite accident," POLITICO, lilw-msdi2022
Congressional Republicans remain staunchly committed to anti-terrorism drone strikes despite a January drone operation that accidentally killed a U.S. civilian and an Italian in Pakistan. Hawkish Republicans said Thursday that the death of Warren Weinstein was tragic but that it was collateral damage in the global war on terror. Asked in interviews whether the killing of an American citizen should cause the United States to reconsider its use of drones against overseas combatants, GOP lawmakers said unequivocally that it should not. “Not at all. Collateral damage is part of war,” said Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.). “We’re at war.” “There are consequences to war, and we’re in one,” said Senate Intelligence Chairman Richard Burr (R-N.C.). “When you look at our experience with collateral damage, it’s minimal.” While Senate Judiciary Chairman Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa) wondered why the White House had waited until April to announce killings that took place in January, Burr said he had already reviewed the timeline for the release of the information as well as the particulars of the drone strike in question and said he will continue to do so. But everything Burr has seen so far points to a “very appropriate” use of drones in this instance. Other top Republicans on national security issues backed Burr’s assertion, along with a war on terror that increasingly involves the use of unmanned drones to kill top terrorist targets. “It’s not gonna cause us to quit using drones,” said Sen. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.). “I’m so committed that we have to have drones.”
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Lauren Fox, 4-23-2015, (Lauren Fox is a congressional reporter at U.S. News. Her work has appeared in Salon, MSNBC, and Columbia Journalism Review.) “Congress: We're Sorry Innocent People Were Killed. But Drone Strikes Are Here to Stay.” The Atlantic, lilw-msdi2022
The White House's drone program is not going anywhere. The Obama administration revealed Thursday that two hostages—including one American—were killed in a counterterrorism incident earlier this year and two other Americans who were known to be working with al-Qaida were also killed, accidentally. The Wall Street Journal reported Thursday that a drone strike was responsible for the casualties. On Capitol Hill, the incident has brought into sharp focus the unintended consequences and risks associated with the president's drone program—a cornerstone of his counterterrorism strategy in the Middle East. Yet, the same Congress that spent years reviewing and chronicling the enhanced-interrogation techniques administered under the Bush administration does not appear to be moved to overhaul the lethal drone program over Thursday's revelations. Nor, do they seem to think the program is fundamentally flawed in a major way. "The collateral damage has been extraordinarily low," says Sen. Dianne Feinstein, the ranking member of the Senate's Intelligence Committee. "That is really a fact. I only wish I could tell you what it was. That is the irony here. This is all classified." Feinstein says the committee is still reviewing the incident, and other committees will also consider engaging in reviews. But the CIA's drone program has become such a consequential tool in the country's war on terrorism that even Republicans who are quick to fault Obama for anything else are extremely hesitant to lodge criticisms against it. "We made a mistake. You know I have been a big critic of President Obama's. I am not going to blame him for this. I blame al-Qaida," Republican Sen. Lindsey Graham said Thursday. "We are not going to terminate this drone program. I am sorry these innocent people were killed. I am glad these two Americans collaborating with the enemy were killed. Please understand, we are at war. This is the way war works. It is a nasty, terrible business, but I am in it to win it." Unlike so many other foreign policy decisions the president has made, from relaxing relations with Cuba to negotiating a nuclear deal with Iran, Republicans are not lining up to attack the president over a program they say has proved to be effective at taking out top targets. "We are in a war with individuals who are hiding with civilians," says Republican Sen. James Lankford, a member of the Intelligence Committee. "[The administration] does an extremely good job of trying to check and recheck their systems, and when they do a strike, it is not flippant. They are very, very efficient and very, very careful." Even Republican presidential contenders Ted Cruz, Rand Paul, and Marco Rubio have so far resisted the urge to blame the Obama administration for the outcomes of the mission. "It is a tragedy that these American hostages lost their lives. My prayers and thoughts are with their families," Paul said in a statement from his office. Cruz said that blame for the death of the hostages sat squarely with "the terrorists who kidnapped them and forcibly held them in their command center." Democratic Sen. Ron Wyden—a constant voice of caution when it comes to America's drone program—said in a statement that he wanted to "learn more about this operation before arriving at any final judgements about how it was carried out." As the administration has sought to end the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan and scale back troops on the ground, drones have become one of the essential tools at the president's disposal. "We are still very much in the counterterrorism business, and as long as there are threats around the world, we will continue to be involved in that," Sen. Richard Burr, the chairman of the Senate's Intelligence Committee, said of the role the drone program fills.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Baobao Zhang, 12-10-2019, (Zhang is an assistant professor of Political Science at the Maxwell School of Citizenship and Public Affairs at Syracuse University. She is also a CIFAR Azrieli Global Scholar and a research affiliate with the Centre for the Governance of AI. She graduated with a PhD in political science (2020) and an MA in statistics (2015) from Yale University. In 2020-2021, she worked as a Klarman Postdoctoral Fellow in the Cornell Society of Fellows. In 2019-2020, she worked as a postdoctoral fellow in MIT’s Political Science Department and a fellow at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet and Society at Harvard University.) "Public opinion lessons for AI regulation", Brookings, https://www.brookings.edu/research/public-opinion-lessons-for-ai-regulation/ lilw-msdi2022
Lethal autonomous weapon systems can identify and engage targets without human intervention; the technology is currently being developed but has not yet been deployed on battlefields. A coalition of nongovernmental organizations, the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots, has advocated for an international ban on fully autonomous weapons. Critics of the technology argue that lethal autonomous weapons are unethical and unsafe. Some suggest that an arms race to develop the technology would exacerbate tensions between major powers; at the same time, non-state actors, including terrorists, could adopt the technology for malicious uses. Twenty-six countries have publicly expressed support for a pre-emptive international ban on fully autonomous lethal weapons; the U.S., along with several major powers (e.g., Russia, the U.K., Israel) currently opposes such a ban. While only a slim majority of Americans oppose the use of fully autonomous weapons systems in wars, according to a 2019 Ipsos/Human Rights Watch survey, opposition grew by 7 percentage points since 2018. The U.S. public’s opposition is slightly lower than the opposition by the public in other countries of the UN Security Council, as seen in Figure 3. Research shows that political messaging can affect American attitudes toward lethal autonomous weapons. For instance, support for autonomous weapons increases when the public is told that other states or non-state actors are developing them. On the other hand, explaining the security risks of a military AI arms race can reduce support for investment in military applications of AI. The Campaign to Stop Killer Robots has adopted some of the publicity strategies that the International Campaign to Ban Landmines used to successfully lobby for an international ban on landmines. But researchers point out that persuading the public to oppose lethal autonomous weapons could be more challenging than convincing them to oppose landmines; the former has yet to cause any causalities while the latter has led to gruesome deaths and injuries.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
AFP in Geneva, Dec 2 2021 US rejects calls for regulating or banning ‘killer robots’ https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2021/dec/02/us-rejects-calls-regulating-banning-killer-robots
The US has rejected calls for a binding agreement regulating or banning the use of “killer robots”, instead proposing a “code of conduct” at the . Speaking at a meeting in Geneva focused on finding common ground on the use of such so-called lethal autonomous weapons, a US official balked at the idea of regulating their use through a “legally-binding instrument”. The meeting saw government experts preparing for high-level talks at a review conference on the Convention of Certain Conventional Weapons from 13 to 17 December. “In our view, the best way to make progress ... would be through the development of a non-binding code of conduct,” US official Josh Dorosin told the meeting. The United Nations has been hosting diplomatic talks in Geneva since 2017 aimed at reaching an agreement on how to address the use of killer robots. Activists and a number of countries have called for and making the final kill order. In November 2018, the UN chief, António Guterres, joined the call for a ban, but so far countries do not even agree on whether there is a need to regulate the weapons. During Thursday’s debate, a number of countries, including India and the United States, criticised the idea of a legally binding agreement.
Biden administration opposes restrictions on LAWS
Democracy Now, 2021 U.S. Shuts Down International Calls to Ban “Killer Robots” HEADLINE DEC 03, https://www.democracynow.org/2021/12/3/headlines/us_shuts_down_international_calls_to_ban_killer_robots
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
DAN ROBITZSKI Jan 28 2021 / ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE https://futurism.com/the-byte/congressional-panel-build-killer-robots
Tasked with deciding whether the United States military should be able develop autonomous killer robots capable of using deadly force, a congressional advisory panel decided that the government should keep its options open. Using similar logic to a parent convincing to get their toddler to try vegetables, members of the National Security Commission on Artificial Intelligence concluded that Congress should at least consider giving killer robots or artificial intelligence systems a chance, . Otherwise, the military might never know if they actually perform so well that they kill fewer innocent people, according to the logic of the panel, which made this decision despite to . Moral Imperative The committee's decision doesn't directly shape U.S. policy, but the group, led by former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, does have Congress' ear, according to Reuters. And its decision aligns with actions the military has already taken, like that don't call for much more than making sure that killer AI actually works. Arguing that an effective AI might take actions that result in fewer casualties than human soldiers, committee vice chairman and former deputy secretary of defense Robert Work said that "it is a moral imperative to at least pursue this hypothesis," according to Reuters.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Kelley M. Sayler Analyst in Advanced Technology and Global Security July 17, 2020 Emerging Military Technologies: Background and Issues for Congress July 17, 2020 https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/AD1105857.pdf
Members of Congress and Pentagon officials are increasingly focused on developing emerging military technologies to enhance U.S. national security and keep pace with U.S. competitors. The U.S. military has long relied upon technological superiority to ensure its dominance in conflict and to underwrite U.S. national security. In recent years, however, technology has both rapidly evolved and rapidly proliferated—largely as a result of advances in the commercial sector. As former Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel observed, this development has threatened to erode the United States’ traditional sources of military advantage. The Department of Defense (DOD) has undertaken a number of initiatives to arrest this trend. For example, in 2014, DOD announced the Third Offset Strategy, an effort to exploit emerging technologies for military and security purposes as well as associated strategies, tactics, and concepts of operation. In support of this strategy, DOD established a number of organizations focused on defense innovation, including the Defense Innovation Unit and the Defense Wargaming Alignment Group. More recently, the 2018 National Defense Strategy echoed the underpinnings of the Third Offset Strategy, noting that U.S. national security will likely be affected by rapid technological advancements and the changing character of war…. New technologies include advanced computing, “big data” analytics, artificial intelligence, autonomy, robotics, directed energy, hypersonics, and biotechnology—the very technologies that ensure we will be able to fight and win the wars of the future. The United States is the leader in developing many of these technologies. However, China and Russia—key strategic competitors—are making steady progress in developing advanced military technologies. As these technologies are integrated into foreign and domestic military forces and deployed, they could hold significant implications for the future of international security writ large, and will have to be a significant focus for Congress, both in terms of funding and program oversight.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Restricting Lethal Autonomous Weapons
Kelley M. Sayler, Analyst in Advanced Technology and Global Security Updated November 17, 2021 Defense Primer: U.S. Policy on Lethal Autonomous Weapon Systems https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11150
In addition, approximately 30 countries and 165 nongovernmental organizations have called for a preemptive ban on LAWS due to ethical concerns, including concerns about operational risk, accountability for use, and compliance with the proportionality and distinction requirements of the law of war. The U.S. government does not currently support a ban on LAWS and has addressed ethical concerns about the systems in a March 2018 white paper, “Humanitarian Benefits of Emerging Technologies in the Area of Lethal Autonomous Weapons.” The paper notes that “automated target identification, tracking, selection, and engagement functions can allow weapons to strike military objectives more accurately and with less risk of collateral damage” or civilian casualties.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Funding Vaccine Research
Alan Fram, 6-1-2022,(AP News reporter) "Congressional stalemate makes a quick compromise on COVID funding unlikely", PBS NewsHour, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/congressional-stalemate-makes-a-quick-compromise-on-covid-funding-unlikely lilw-msdi2022
The U.S. is headed for “a lot of unnecessary loss of life,” the Biden administration says, if Congress fails to provide billions more dollars to brace for the pandemic’s next wave. Yet the quest for that money is in limbo, the latest victim of election-year gridlock that’s stalled or killed a host of Democratic priorities. President Joe Biden’s appeal for funds for vaccines, testing and treatments has hit opposition from Republicans, who’ve fused the fight with the precarious politics of immigration. Congress is in recess, and the next steps are uncertain, despite admonitions from White House COVID-19 coordinator Dr. Ashish Jha of damaging consequences from “every day we wait.” Administration officials say they’re running low on money to stock up on, or even begin to order, the latest vaccines, tests and treatments. Also lacking are funds to reimburse doctors treating uninsured patients and to help poor countries control the pandemic. House and Senate Democrats have been wrangling over how to resolve the stalemate and even over which chamber should vote first. It’s an open question whether they’ll ever get the GOP votes they’ll need to pull the legislation through the 50-50 Senate, and prospects in the narrowly divided House are unclear as well. “There is still an urgency to pass a COVID relief package,” Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y., said last week. “It’s very, very much needed.” Optimists hope the measure could start rolling once Congress returns next week. Pessimists say without quick resolution, Democrats may not have enough leverage to push the money to passage until early fall. That’s when they could stuff it into legislation that will probably be needed to finance government — a bill that would avert a federal shutdown, a pre-election distraction Republicans will be desperate to avoid. The heap of sidelined Democratic initiatives has grown this year, a victim of GOP opposition and rebellions by centrists like Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va. Casualties include bills on voting rights, health care, environment, taxes, gun curbs, abortion rights, policing tactics and an investigation of the 2021 Capitol storming by then-President Donald Trump’s supporters. While lawmakers have approved massive packages financing federal agencies through September and helping Ukraine counter Russia’s invasion, other priorities are dead or drifting, even as Democrats’ days running Congress are likely dwindling. Republicans are favored to win House control in November’s elections and could grab the Senate as well, and Democrats’ frustration is clear. “So far it hasn’t moved,” Sen. Mazie Hirono, D-Hawaii, said of Biden’s latest $22.5 billion request for COVID-19, which he initially sent Congress three months ago. “But then neither has sensible gun legislation, neither has voting rights.” “The 50-50 Senate sucks,” she said. The COVID money is needed quickly, officials say. Their warnings have come with over 1 million U.S. deaths from the disease and a fresh variant that daily is hospitalizing over 100,000 Americans and killing more than 300. Both numbers are rising. Officials say that lacking fresh funds, the U.S. is falling behind other countries that are already lining up for supplies needed for fall and winter. That’s prompted Jha to plan for the chance that Congress provides no new money at all, threatening painful choices about what to do if there aren’t enough vaccines or therapeutics for all who need them. “It would be terrible,” Jha told reporters recently. “I think we would see a lot of unnecessary loss of life if that were to happen.” Congress has provided $370 billion for purchasing supplies, for research and other public health initiatives to combat the pandemic, according to administration tallies obtained by The Associated Press. Around $14 billion of it was unspent or not committed to contracts as of April 5, the documents show, serious money but an amount the administration says falls below the ultimate need. Most Republicans are skeptical about added pandemic funding. “I have a hard time believing that there’s not enough money and not enough flexibility already” to use it, said Sen. Kevin Cramer, R-N.D.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Funding Vaccine Research
Jonathan Chait, 5-12-2022, (Jonathan Chait is an American pundit and writer for New York magazine. He was previously a senior editor at The New Republic and an assistant editor of The American Prospect. He writes a periodic column in the Los Angeles Times.) "Why Senate Republicans Want to Save Money by Skimping on Vaccines", Intelligencer, https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/05/republicans-want-to-save-money-by-skimping-on-vaccines.html lilw-msdi2022
An ominous sign for continued funding of COVID-19 vaccines and therapeutics came this week when the Biden administration decided to split off these funds from a bill supplying Ukraine with military aid. It was an indication that funding COVID vaccines, once a matter of bipartisan accord, was losing Republican support. But this was merely an indirect measure of the Republican position. A more direct indication comes from Caitlin Owens, who explains why Senate Republicans are haggling over spending money on vaccines and therapeutics. The answer is that they’re concerned about wasting money. Owens’s reporting gets into the Republican view in more detail than any previous report. One Republican concern is that the current funding strategy prioritizes access over efficiency. The vaccines are distributed in multidose vials that, once opened, must be used or thrown away, leading to some spoilage. “Republicans say the current strategy is wasteful,” Owens reports, “and it would be better to rein in accessibility so that more doses are likely to be used.” A second concern is that the vaccines, while highly effective against hospitalization and death, are proving less effective against transmission. Therefore, Republicans don’t want to spend too much on them. “Republicans are skeptical of using federal money to buy more vaccines that are proving not to last very long and questions remain if they will work against future variants,” a senior GOP Senate aide told Owens. “We’re saying that the current shot and boosters are reducing in effectiveness. New vaxx isn’t ready and it’s unclear where they are in the plan,” the aide added. “Since there is no plan, we don’t want to give them [a] blank check.”
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Funding Vaccine Research
Tolbert, et.al. 2022 , , and Published: Mar 28, 2022 Implications of the Lapse in Federal COVID-19 Funding on Access to COVID-19 Testing, Treatment, and Vaccines https://www.kff.org/coronavirus-covid-19/issue-brief/implications-of-the-lapse-in-federal-covid-19-funding-on-access-to-covid-19-testing-treatment-and-vaccines/
A current impasse in Congress threatens continued funding for COVID-19 testing, treatment, and vaccines. The White House asked Congress for an additional to support domestic and global COVID-19 efforts. During the recent negotiations to fund the federal government for FY 2022, Congress reduced this amount to $15.6 billion and it was subsequently stripped from the final bill. Without additional resources, the that several programs will need to be discontinued, including the Health Resources and Services Administration (, established to reimburse health care providers for the costs of delivering COVID-19 testing and treatment services and administering vaccines to those who are uninsured. HRSA has announced that due to lack of funding, the program stopped accepting reimbursement claims for COVID-19 testing and treatment services on March 22, 2022 and will stop accepting claims for vaccine administration on April 5, 2022. In addition, the federal government has said it does not have funding to purchase additional COVID-19 tests, treatments, and vaccines once current supplies run out, and that it does not currently have a sufficient supply for vaccines to if they are eventually recommended (also the subject of a recent KFF ). The lack of additional COVID-19 funding has broad implications for access to these services, particularly for people who are uninsured, and could undermine efforts to ensure equitable access to these resources.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Funding Vaccine Research
GABY GALVIN April 13, 2022 at 6:00 am ET https://morningconsult.com/2022/04/13/global-covid-vaccine-funding-priority-data/
The findings come as a bipartisan deal for an additional $10 billion for the federal pandemic response in Congress through the Easter holiday. Earlier, Senate negotiators for global vaccinations from the deal, leading health officials that their work to help vaccinate the world could be hampered in the coming months. The White House has also said that from Congress, the federal government doesn’t have the money to buy enough COVID-19 shots for all Americans to get a fourth dose. Federal vaccine advisers are a framework for potential booster shots this fall.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Funding Vaccine Research
05/13/2022 04:30 AM EDT https://www.politico.com/news/2022/05/13/white-house-vaccines-covid-funding-impasse-00032319
A painful and foreboding reality is setting in for the White House as it enters a potentially dangerous stretch of the Covid fight: It may soon need to run its sprawling pandemic response on a shoestring budget. Just two months after the administration unveiled a nearly 100-page roadmap out of the crisis, doubts are growing about Congress’ willingness to fund the nation’s fight. It has forced Biden officials to debate deep cuts to their Covid operation and game out ways to keep the federal effort afloat on a month-by-month basis.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Ban Offensive Cyber Operations
William Jackson, 9-5-2012, (William Jackson is a Maryland-based freelance writer.)"Dem, GOP platforms expose divide over cyber defense", GCN, https://gcn.com/cybersecurity/2012/09/dem-gop-platforms-expose-divide-over-cyber-defense/280953/ lilw-msdi2022
With the failure of Congress to pass legislation aimed at bolstering the nation’s cybersecurity, the Democratic platform asserts the president’s willingness to act on his own through executive order. “President Obama has supported comprehensive cybersecurity legislation that would help business and government protect against risks of cyber attacks while also safeguarding the privacy rights of our citizens,” says the platform adopted Sept. 4 by the Democratic National Convention. “And, going forward, the president will continue to take executive action to strengthen and update our cyber defenses.” The Republican platform, adopted last week, also recognizes the importance of securing cyberspace, calling for the United States to develop an offensive cyberattack capacity to deter would-be enemies. “We will pursue an effective cybersecurity strategy, supported by the necessary resources, that recognizes the importance of offensive capabilities,” against nations, terrorists and criminals, the platform says. The two platforms reflect the partisan differences that have divided the 112th Congress and prevented the passage of meaningful cybersecurity legislation despite the efforts of leaders on both sides to move bills. Republicans see cybersecurity largely as a business issue and object to any regulations on industry establishing requirements for securing IT infrastructure and systems. They would place responsibility for overseeing civilian and private-sector cybersecurity in the military. The National Security Agency is often mentioned as the most likely home.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Ban Offensive Cyber Operations
Chris Bing, 7-19-2016, (Christopher J. Bing is a cybersecurity reporter for FedScoop. He has written about technology and policy for DC Inno, International Policy Digest and The Daily Caller, among other outlets. While at DC Inno, Chris focused on covering innovative technology businesses that are based in the D.C.-area. In June 2014, he founded a foreign policy blog called The Grey Cut, which monitored the influence and activity of petro-dictatorships across the globe. Chris is an alumnus of St. Marys College of Maryland.) “Experts: GOP cyber platform “detrimental to global stability” Fedscoop, lilw-msdi2022
The U.S. must “stop playing defense and go on offense” online in order to avoid a “cyber Pearl Harbor,” according to the newly released Republican Party platform. “Despite their promises to the contrary, Russia and China see cyber operations as a part of a warfare strategy during peacetime,” the platform states, adding, “We will … make clear that users have a self-defense right to deal with hackers as they see fit.” Security and policy experts, however, have serious reservations about the platform which was authored by Republican lawmakers and party faithful alike, and released in tandem with the GOP Convention kick-off on Monday night. One scholar fretted that Republicans would end up “destroy[ing] the internet in order to save it.” “There is a distinct lack of clarity about rules of the road for peacetime, and the norms and laws that do and will govern offensive cyber operations in peacetime [are] still highly malleable,” explained Robert Morgus, a policy analyst with D.C.-based think tank New America. “This means that operations conducted by the U.S. and others are highly influential in shaping those rules, and pushing the red line too far — while useful for short-term strategic goals like disrupting the Iranian nuclear program — may prove detrimental to global stability in the long run,” he added. The platform’s ambiguous call to action, noted Morgus, offers no details about what it defines as going on cyber offense — “it’s important to draw a line between offensive cyber operations conducted for espionage or intelligence gathering purposes and offensive computer network operations,” he said. Espionage, Morgus said, is an expected reality for nation-states but offensive computer network operations — like the Stuxnet cyberweapon which crippled Iran’s nuclear program — could easily cross the threshold into “armed attack.” In international law, nations are permitted to respond militarily to an armed attack. Moreover, observed former NSA IT architect Will Ackerly, the platform would give other nations political cover for launching cyberwar operations. “The way that this section of the Republican platform is written sounds as though it’s rationalizing the use of force following a cyber-attack by way of defending the country. To that end, any offensive practice would give everyone else in the room the latitude to justify their offensive actions based on the United States’ rhetoric,” explained Ackerly, who left the NSA to become co-founder and CTO of cyber start-up Virtru. “It is tempting for the United States, with its advanced offensive cyber capabilities, to think the best defense is a good offense, but this is not true when it comes to our most likely adversaries,” said Brown University Academic Director for Law and Policy Tim Edgar. “Offensive cyber operations carry a host of risks and unintended consequences for the security and stability of the internet. The United States is uniquely vulnerable to these risks. Offensive operations should be tightly controlled,” Edgar told FedScoop. “We don’t want to destroy the internet in order to save it.” Among other cybersecurity-related topics addressed, the party platform specifically advocates for stronger energy infrastructure security, the birth of a global free market in cyber insurance and for Congress’ to lead efforts to create an encryption “solution.” The party platform is drawn up by the RNC Arrangements Committee whose leadership is appointed by RNC Chairman Reince Priebus. The committee is comprised by roughly 150 elected officials and prominent party allies who also helped organize other aspects of this year’s convention. The platform is not binding on the president or his appointees.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Ban Offensive Cyber Operations
Kate Morton, 4-5-2022, (reporter for WIS politics, graduated from University of Wisconsin) "U.S. Rep. Gallagher: Cyberspace solarium co-chairs urge President Biden to maintain cyberdeterrence posture", WIS Politics, https://www.wispolitics.com/2022/u-s-rep-gallagher-cyberspace-solarium-co-chairs-urge-president-biden-to-maintain-cyberdeterrence-posture/ lilw-msdi2022
WASHINGTON, D.C. – Rep. Mike Gallagher (R-WI) and Senator Angus King (I-ME), Co-Chairs of the Cyberspace Solarium Commission (CSC), are urging President Joe Biden to keep a key cyberdeterrent in place after reports indicated that the administration is considering changes to the policy. In a letter to President Biden, Gallagher and King lay out the critical importance of National Security Presidential Memorandum – 13 (NSPM-13), which established an agile workflow allowing the Department of Defense to plan and conduct time-sensitive offensive cyber operations. The pair of lawmakers stress that changes to the policy would undermine the United States’ national security and highlight the essential deterrent NSPM-13 provides against adversaries like Russia. “As the Co-Chairmen of the Cyberspace Solarium Commission, we are very concerned by press reporting that your Administration may be considering changes to the governing policy document, National Security Presidential Memorandum – 13, with an intent to limit the Secretary of Defense’s freedom of action to plan and conduct offensive cyber operations,” said CSC Co-Chairs Rep. Gallagher and Sen. King. “Any effort to alter and possibly weaken NSPM-13 signals to our adversaries a lack of credible willingness to use offensive cyber capabilities which undermines the credibility of our deterrent,” the CSC Co-Chairs concluded. “It is for these reasons we urge in the strongest possible terms that you to not alter the existing processes and policies that allow for an agile, effective planning process for the conduct of offensive cyber operations – the security of our national critical infrastructure may very well depend upon it.” As Co-Chairs of the Cyberspace Solarium Commission (CSC), Gallagher and King are recognized as two of Congress’s leading experts on cyberdefense and are strong advocates for a forward-thinking cyberstrategy that emphasizes layered cyberdeterrence. Since it officially launched in April 2019, dozens of CSC recommendations have been enacted into law, including the creation of a National Cyber Director.
2022
SDI
Disadvantage
MSDI Politics – China › Link Extension › Links – Ban Offensive Cyber Operations
Erica D. Lonergan and Mark Montgomery | 01.25.22 PRESSING QUESTIONS: OFFENSIVE CYBER OPERATIONS AND NATO STRATEGY https://mwi.usma.edu/pressing-questions-offensive-cyber-operations-and-nato-strategy/
NATO’s shift to incorporating offensive cyber operations into existing strategy and policy has focused on integrating offensive effects into conventional military plans and operations in the context of a conflict. While NATO’s updated strategy is a positive development, its limited focus on conflict scenarios for employing cyber power fails to accurately account for the cyber threat environment NATO faces—particularly the mismatch between the alliance’s clear distinction between wartime and peacetime and the approach of adversaries like Russia, who adopt a competition-conflict continuum. Additionally, the focus on employing offensive cyber during a high-end conventional fight is also not consistent with how several NATO members are already engaged in gray zone offensive cyber operations.
The primary to NATO allies in the cyber domain is not from high-end, decisive cyberattacks. Instead, cyber threats more frequently and effectively manifest as gray zone tactics designed to have a corrosive effect without rising to the level of warfare. There are numerous examples of this type of threat. For instance, in July 2021, NATO publicly a range of malicious cyber behavior, including the Microsoft Exchange hack (which NATO attributed to China) and ransomware attacks targeting critical infrastructure. Russia has leveraged cyber and disinformation operations to interfere in democratic elections in the in 2016, 2018, and 2020; in 2017; and Germany in and —to name just a few examples. Russia also conducted distributed denial-of-service cyberattacks against government websites in during the lead-up to, and following, Montenegro’s ascension to NATO in 2017. And when NATO forces were positioned in the Baltics beginning in 2017 as part of NATO’s , two threat actors, and , conducted a of disinformation campaigns.