Open evidence library

Search the archive.

Everything before 2025 is free and unlimited. Free accounts can also open 10 cards from 2025 or newer each day.

Matching cards
2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia – Econ Low

Russia crude oil price cap thumps

Maximilian Hess 23- Fellow at the Foreign Policy Research Institute, 12-13-2022, "Putin’s plan to take on the world economic order hits a wall," Aljazeera, https://www.aljazeera.com/opinions/2022/12/13/putins-plan-to-take-on-the-world-economic-order-hits-a-wall //nvb

On December 5, a $60 per barrel price cap on Russian seaborne oil – agreed upon by the European Union, the G7 and Australia just a few days earlier – came into effect, marking the beginning of a new phase in the economic war between Russia and the West.

The price cap may be one of the most significant ripostes to Russia’s weaponisation of its energy reserves since the beginning of its all-out invasion of Ukraine, but what it entails and hopes to achieve appear to be widely misunderstood.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia – Econ Low

Russia economy declining now

Georgi Kantchev 23- foreign correspondent for The Wall Street Journal based in Berlin; and Evan Gershkovich- reporter for The Wall Street Journal, where he covers Russia, Ukraine and the former Soviet Union., 3-28-2023, "Russia’s Economy Is Starting to Come Undone," WSJ, https://www.wsj.com/articles/russias-economy-is-starting-to-come-undone-431a2878 //nvb

MOSCOW—The opening months of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine last year drove an increase in oil and natural-gas prices that brought a windfall for Moscow. Those days are over.

As the war continues into its second year and Western sanctions bite harder, Russia’s government revenue is being squeezed and its economy has shifted to a lower-growth trajectory, likely for the long term.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia Turn – Empirics

More empirics.

Daniel Gros ’15, Director of the Institute for European Policy-Making at Bocconi University, January 16, “The price of oil and Soviet/Russian aggressiveness”, https://aei.pitt.edu/59748/1/DG_Oil_price_and_Russian_behaviour.pdf] calista

There has been much speculation about the reasons that prompted President Putin’s increasingly hostile reaction in 2012-13 to the negotiations on an EU-Ukraine association agreement. The chain of events is well known. Russian pressure led the then President of Ukraine, Viktor Yanukovich, to decline to sign an Association Agreement with the EU, which sparked the Euro Maidan in Kyiv. These protests were then used a pretext for the annexation of Crimea and the support for anti-Maidan rebels in the Donbass region, which was then followed by an outright, even if covert, invasion. It is often argued that Russia is reacting to a perceived encroachment of the EU/NATO on an area that it considers its own neighbourhood (and President Putin said as much during his annual end-of-the-year press conference in December). However, history suggests that the underlying reason for Russian aggressiveness is simpler: A decade-long period of a steadily rising oil prices (and that of other raw materials) created a feeling of strength, bordering on invulnerability, which made Russia more assertive, and ready to use any opportunity to deploy its military power. The abrupt reversal of this trend since the summer of 2014 will thus be the harbinger of a much less aggressive Russian stance as long as oil remains at present levels.

One needs to go back only 40 years to find a similar development. The 1970s had seen a similar increase in Soviet assertiveness which culminated in the invasion of Afghanistan at the very end of the decade. This came also at the tail of a decade of sharply increasing oil prices (and Soviet oil production). Between 1965 and 1980, the value of Soviet oil production went up by a factor of almost 20 (from about $20 billion annually in 1965 to almost $400 billion in today’s purchasing power in 1980). This was due in large part to the oil price increases following the first oil embargo. But there was also a large increase in Soviet oil production. In the 1960s, Soviet oil production had been lower than that of the US, but thanks to the discovery of some large fields it became much larger by 1980. This combination provided the main growth elements of the Soviet economy, making its regime much more credible, and not only in the eyes of its own population. The resulting increase in the real resources available to the Soviet elites was spent to a large extent on the military budget, allowing the Soviet Union to become a much more credible threat. The increase in relative, and absolute, economic and military strength emboldened an ageing (and therefore naturally not adventurous leadership) to become more assertive abroad. The invasion of Afghanistan appeared also at first sight to be an improvised reaction to a local development (a putsch in Kabul). The parallel to Putin’s reaction to the Euro Maidan is instructive. In both cases, a seemingly low-cost opportunity was seen as yielding a large strategic gain, at least in the short run.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia Turn – Empirics

Empirics go aff---Russian aggression is correlated with high oil prices.

The Economist ’16, The Economist Data Team, January 21, “Oil price and Russian politics: a history”, https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/2016/01/21/oil-price-and-russian-politics-a-history] calista

IN DECEMBER 1979 Soviet troops invaded Afghanistan. The oil price at the time was at its peak of $101 a barrel. The high price combined with fast-growing production of oil in Western Siberia provided the Soviet Union with unprecedented revenues. Instead of saving this money for a rainy day, the Soviet government financed foreign adventures and imports of food. Seven years later the Brent crude oil price fell to around $30 a barrel and Mikhail Gorbachev launched the policy of Perestroika (restructuring) and convergence with the West. The high oil price coincided with Soviet aggression, but as the price fell the Soviet Union became more democratic and friendly to the West.

That the oil price correlated with Soviet politics is not surprising – in the uncompetitive command economy oil and gas revenues accounted for 67% of all exports. But the correlation remained just as strong after the end of the Soviet Union and transition to a market economy, and oil and gas remained the main source of Russian export revenues. When Vladimir Putin came to power the price of oil was $25 a barrel. Mr Putin allied himself with America, did not object to NATO’s enlargement that took in the Baltic States and saw September 11th 2001 as Russia’s chance to get closer to NATO. Seven years later, when the oil price was at $105 a barrel, Russia invaded Georgia, and its relationship with America deteriorated dramatically. Thanks to the global financial crisis, oil prices soon fell to $67 a barrel, and Russia accepted Barack Obama's attempted "reset" (though that effort soon went sour).

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia Turn – Ukraine War

Russia’s declining revenue is hampering its ability to finance Ukraine.

Sam Meredith ’23, Correspondent at CNBC International in London, covering climate, energy markets and international politics, January 11, “The West’s oil war against Russia is starting to take its toll — sparking calls for tougher measures”, https://www.cnbc.com/2023/01/11/ukraine-war-russias-fossil-fuel-earnings-fall-in-december.html] calista

Russia’s revenue from fossil fuel exports collapsed in December, according to a new report, significantly hampering President Vladimir Putin’s ability to finance the war in Ukraine.

The findings, Ukrainian officials and campaigners say, illustrate the effectiveness of targeting Russia’s oil revenue and underscore the urgent need for Western policymakers to ratchet up the financial pressure on Moscow in order to help Kyiv prevail.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia Turn – Ukraine War

Low oil prices are key to preventing Russian military projects and spending.

Jim Tankersley ’23, Jim Tankersley is an economics reporter who covers the White House. He has been tracking the Biden administration’s efforts to limit Russia’s oil revenues for the past year., May 18, “An Untested Oil Price Cap Has Helped Choke Revenue to Russia”, https://www.nytimes.com/2023/05/18/business/economy/g7-biden-oil-price-cap-russia.html] calista

In early June, at the behest of the Biden administration, German leaders assembled top economic officials from the Group of 7 nations for a video conference with the goal of striking a major financial blow to Russia.

The Americans had been trying, in a series of one-off conversations last year, to sound out their counterparts in Europe, Canada and Japan on an unusual and untested idea. Administration officials wanted to try to cap the price that Moscow could command for every barrel of oil it sold on the world market. Treasury Secretary Janet L. Yellen had floated the plan a few weeks earlier at a meeting of finance ministers in Bonn, Germany.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Russia Turn – Ukraine War

High oil prices are the only thing sustaining Putin’s extreme aggression and petro-nationalist authoritarian power.

Kirill Rogov ’23, Russian political scientist, journalist and writer. He is a fellow at the Institute for Human Sciences in Vienna and the founder of Re: Russia, a policy network, April 19, “Only a sustained fall in oil prices will break Vladimir Putin’s regime, argues Kirill Rogov”, https://www.economist.com/by-invitation/2023/04/19/only-a-sustained-fall-in-oil-prices-will-break-vladimir-putins-regime-argues-kirill-rogov] calista

President vladimir putin boasts about the strength of the Russian economy in the face of Western sanctions, citing estimates by international financial institutions that Russian gdp shrank only modestly in 2022. The Russian leader’s bullishness is hardly surprising, and he is not alone: it is a widely held view that the sanctions imposed on his regime have had little economic impact.

A recent overview of the Russian economy by the Re: Russia Project, a network of experts, challenges this thesis. The report, prepared by a group of economists including former top figures from Russia’s finance ministry and central bank, a professor at the University of California and myself, finds that sanctions have indeed had a big effect: they have led to capital outflows from Russia equivalent to 12% of its gdp. Under normal circumstances, that would precipitate an economic disaster. However, there is a powerful force that mitigates the effect of sanctions, namely high energy prices.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Escalation

No Middle East war – lack of interest, fear, disproportionate US power

Annalisa Merelli 20, Senior reporter at Quartz, where she covers the intersection of public health, the healthcare business, and inequality, 01/02/2020, “One thing unites Americans and Iranians: Nobody wants a war,” https://qz.com/1778828/one-thing-unites-americans-and-iranians-nobody-wants-a-war //SBM

US president Donald Trump’s critics spent the decade’s end worrying a presidential tweet could trigger World War III. But as soon as 2020 put a foot in the door, it was a good old-fashioned targeted killing that put everyone on edge.

The US Department of Defense confirmed it killed major general Qassem Soleimani, the head of Iran’s elite Quds Force unit, on Friday. Soleimani is one of the most important figures in Iran, and has shaped events across the Middle East for decades, often at America’s expense.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Escalation

No escalation – U.S. committed to decreasing tensions in the Middle East with Navy, Air Force, and Marines

Todd Lopez 6/5/23, reporter for the DoD, an executive branch department of the federal government of the United States charged with coordinating and supervising all agencies and functions of the U.S. government directly related to national security and the United States Armed Forces, 6/5/23, “Defense Official Says U.S. Remains Committed to the Middle East,” https://www.defense.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/3417495/defense-official-says-us-remains-committed-to-middle-east/ //SBM

With over 30,000 troops in the Middle East at multiple locations, the United States' commitment to the Middle East hasn't changed — despite the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan and its significant drawdown in Iraq, said the deputy assistant secretary of defense for the Middle East.

"The significant capabilities across our Navy, our Air Force, our Army and our Marines — it's still in the region," Dana Stroul told the Jerusalem Post during an interview yesterday in New York City. "And they're still doing those important activities every day."

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No War

No Middle East impact to oil prices – economy diversifying now

Marina Blinda 23 , 5-3-2023, "Saudi Arabia's economic transition: major reduction in oil dependence ," https://www.atalayar.com/en/articulo/economy-and-business/saudi-arabias-economic-transition-major-reduction-oil-dependence/20230503115456184150.html

The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has pointed out that Saudi Arabia's economy faces a sharp slowdown in growth this year. However, it has also stressed that government-led reforms and increased private investment in new sectors will help to support non-oil economic growth in the country. On the other hand, the IMF also stressed that the development of non-oil sectors, such as technology and tourism, is key to economic diversification and reducing dependence on oil.

Last year, Saudi Arabia's economy grew by 8.7 per cent thanks to high oil prices, generating higher revenues and enabling the country to post its first budget surplus in almost 10 years.Despite this strong growth, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) forecasts that the country's GDP growth will more than halve to 3.1% this year, which is in line with projections for other Middle Eastern oil exporters. Although this growth rate is lower than last year's, it is higher than the IMF's January projection of 2.6% growth. The IMF has noted that while high oil prices have boosted economic growth, it is important that the country continues to diversify its economy to reduce its dependence on oil and increase its long-term economic stability. In this regard, Saudi Arabia has been implementing economic reforms and investing in non-oil sectors, such as technology and tourism, as part of its Vision 2030 programme.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No War

No middle eastern destabilization – dying oil dependency

Rachna Uppal 23, 5-2-2023, "Saudi economy edging closer to reducing dependence on oil, IMF official says," Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/world/middle-east/saudi-economy-edging-closer-reducing-dependence-oil-imf-official-2023-05-03/ //nvb

DUBAI, May 3 (Reuters) - Government-led reforms and the growth of private investment in new sectors will help support non-oil economic growth in Saudi Arabia amid an expected sharp slowdown in overall growth this year, a senior IMF official said.

The Saudi economy grew 8.7% last year, as high oil prices boosted revenue and led to the kingdom's first budget surplus in almost 10 years.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No War

No Middle East war– laundry list of de-escalation initiatives to preserve peace

Sanam Vakil and Neil Quilliam 04/14/23, Director of the Middle East and North Africa programme in 2023, she was previously the programme’s deputy director and senior research fellow, and led project work on Iran and Gulf Arab dynamics; and an energy policy, geopolitics and foreign affairs specialist, with extensive knowledge and experience of the Middle East and North Africa (MENA) region, 04/14/23, “Will reconciliation across the Middle East bring lasting change?” https://www.chathamhouse.org/2023/04/will-reconciliation-across-middle-east-bring-lasting-change //SBM

On 10 March 2023, Saudi Arabia and Iran announced their intention to restore diplomatic relations over a two-month period, in a deal brokered by China. Riyadh’s reconciliation with Bashar al-Assad in Syria is also underway, and its behind-the-scenes engagement with Israel has increased.

This rapprochement with Iran and other regional efforts matter because they shed light on a significant region-wide trend of de-escalation that has been underway since the resumption of high-level UAE–Iran relations in 2019. In the wake of geopolitical tensions and distraction, it also marks a shift towards direct Middle East regional conflict management which – should it last – is a first for countries in the region.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – Resilient

Chinese diplomacy is ironing out tensions.

Ross Harrison 23, senior fellow at the Middle East Institute and on the faculty of the University of Pittsburgh6-26-2023, “The Middle East Might Be Moving Toward Stability,” https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/06/26/iran-saudi-arabia-china-middle-east-diplomacy/, oj

China’s new diplomatic role in the Middle East is another factor that could help sustain trends of de-escalation. Beijing eschews the U.S. approach of offshore balancing against Iran via Saudi Arabia and Israel; it sees such an approach as escalatory. Rather, China is taking a more neutral approach to regional conflicts, on the premise it will calm rather than stoke tensions.

Several Iranian sources have highlighted China’s emerging critical role as a regional stabilizer. Iranian state-run media reported that after Iran attacked Saudi petroleum assets in 2019, China warned Tehran that such acts undermine its interests, given Beijing’s energy security policy is based on unhindered import of Saudi and Gulf oil.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – Resilient

Regional cooperation and independence are spurring conflict resolution.

Ross Harrison 23, senior fellow at the Middle East Institute and on the faculty of the University of Pittsburgh6-26-2023, “The Middle East Might Be Moving Toward Stability,” https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/06/26/iran-saudi-arabia-china-middle-east-diplomacy/, oj

One theme of the present moment is that countries in the Middle East are making deals based on their own national interests rather than dancing to the tune of outsiders. This independence is paradoxically because of great power rivalry in the region, not despite it. With heightened rivalry between great powers, regional powers have more options and are acting more as free agents than committed allies of global powers

For example, Israel and Saudi Arabia are showing considerable independence from the United States on issues ranging from energy policy to approaches toward Russia’s war in Ukraine. Iran, in the context of its role in supplying drones to Russia for the Russia-Ukraine war, is also feeling more confident.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – Diversifying Now

Saudi is diversifying now and leading the rest of the Middle East.

Nirmal Narayanan 23, journalist with over 10 years of experience for Arab News, 7-17-2023, “Saudi Arabia spearheading the energy transition in Middle East,” https://www.arabnews.com/node/2242961/business-economy, oj

The need for energy security has never been more critical in the history of mankind. Amid heightened political tensions, energy diversification programs and sustainability initiatives are a key part of the global agenda today, and countries are working hard to achieve their net-zero targets within the stipulated deadline.

As the world continues its journey to achieve zero emission targets, Saudi Arabia, a country that has been dependent on oil for several decades, is spearheading the energy transition mission in the Middle East region.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Stability

Conflicts between Palestine, Israel, Iran, and Hezbollah make stability impossible

Anthony Cordesman and Nicholas Harrington 18, the Emeritus Chair in Strategy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). He has previously served in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, the National Security Council, the State Department, and the Department of Energy, 04/09/18, “Stability in the Middle East: The Range of Short and Long-Term Causes”, https://www.csis.org/analysis/stability-middle-east-range-short-and-long-term-causes#:~:text=The%20Middle%20East%20has%20long,of%20political%20tensions%20and%20divisions //IS

The immediate sources of instability are clear. Most of the region has some form of internal conflict, faces rising external threats, or is dealing with violent extremism. The violence and wars that have resulted from the political upheavals in 2011 will at best leave lasting challenges for unity and development even if the fighting ends. All the major causes of violent extremism remain, and there are few prospects that the fight against ISIS will eliminate the extremist threat in even one MENA country. Tensions between Israel and the Palestinian persist, each side has seen rising internal political barriers to a compromise peace, and the tensions between Israel and Iran and Hezbollah are creating new military threats.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Stability

Middle east stability is low—political tensions, poor governance corruption and econ failures all thump

Anthony Cordesman and Nicholas Harrington 18, the Emeritus Chair in Strategy at the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS). He has previously served in the Office of the Secretary of Defense, the National Security Council, the State Department, and the Department of Energy, 04/09/18, “Stability in the Middle East: The Range of Short and Long-Term Causes”, https://www.csis.org/analysis/stability-middle-east-range-short-and-long-term-causes#:~:text=The%20Middle%20East%20has%20long,of%20political%20tensions%20and%20divisions //IS

The Middle East has long been one of the most unstable regions in the world, and there are no present prospects for change in the near future. This instability is the result of ongoing conflicts and tensions, and a variety of political tensions and divisions. It also, however, is the result of a wide variety of long-term pressures growing out of poor governance, corruption, economic failures, demographic pressures and other forces within the civil sector.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Stability

The Middle East is a tinderbox and instability will skyrocket. Rising authoritarianism, oppression, US withdrawal, environmental challenges, resource shortages, international meddling, economic insecurity, and military aggression. It’s the most comprehensive card on this issue, it speaks to every single Middle East country.

Maha Yahya 22, Foreign affairs director of the Malcolm H. Kerr Carnegie Middle East Center, works focuses on political violence, identity violence, and social justice, the Middle East Is on the Brink Again, Foreign Affairs, 3-22-2022, https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/middle-east/2022-03-22/middle-east-brink-again/, yao

A little more than a decade after the Arab Spring swept away many autocratic regimes in the Middle East and plunged others into chaos, a new authoritarian order is settling over the region. Egypt and Tunisia, the first two countries to rid themselves of longtime dictators in 2011, have weathered coups that pulled them back toward authoritarianism. Sudan, which had to wait until 2018 for its revolution to succeed, has also seen its once-promising transition to democracy derailed by a coup. Meanwhile, Iran has expanded its sphere of influence across the Middle East, especially in Iraq, Lebanon, and Yemen, while China, Russia, Turkey, and the Gulf states have increased their sway over many of the region’s weakest states. Thanks in part to these trends, President Bashar al-Assad’s brutal regime in Syria is being quietly eased back into the Arab fold.

This is partly a story of authoritarian backlash. Alarmed by unprecedented scenes of citizens taking to the streets to demand their rights, the autocratic regimes that survived the first wave of the Arab Spring cracked down on those who joined pro-democracy protests and offered handouts to win over those who were considering doing so. Bahrain’s promises of jobs and pay raises in early 2011 and subsequent assault on demonstrators in Manama—aided by troops from Saudi Arabia—was the first example of this approach. It was followed by far more brutal crackdowns that ended in civil conflicts in Libya, Syria, and Yemen, and a mix of repression and co-optation in other countries that saw minor protest movements, such as Jordan and Morocco. Later, authoritarian leaders would claw back power in Egypt, Sudan, and Tunisia.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Stability

Iran deal sets the brink. Instability now causes collapse.

Mohammed Salisu Danjuma et al. 23, Human Resources Manager at the Federal Inland Revenue Service in Nigeria, Iranian Nuclear Deal and Middle East Politics: Unveiling the Implications, African Journals Online, 6-1-2023, Vol. 16 No. 1 (2023), 10.4314/ajpas.v16i1.16, yao

This paper assessed the implications of Iranian nuclear deal on the politics of Middle East from the realist theoretical perspective. Data for the paper were generated from secondary sources such as books, journals, newspapers/magazines, and online materials among others. The contents of these secondary data were qualitatively analyzed. The results of this analytical discourse reveal that the deal means more of co-operation is likely to take place in the Middle East even though Iran is still perceived as a potential threat. Also, the eventual deal means the emergence of a more empowered Iran capable of dominating the region and pursuing her interests at the expense of other states. It further showed that the tendency of Iran pursuing regional hegemony is very high. The paper concludes that Iranian nuclear crisis is an indication that the intention for nuclear armament is not yet over. Based on these findings and conclusion drawn, the paper recommended that the security balance of the Middle East must be maintained in order not to experience a sudden collapse of peace and stability in the region. States in the region must be made to realize the dangers of taking measures that could lead to a race for arms, especially nuclear armament.

2023 Michigan Disadvantage
Aff › Internal Link › 2AC – Middle East – No Stability

Tensions are simmering. Internal strife, aggression, and military buildup.

Jay Solomon 23, chief foreign affairs correspondent for The Wall Street Journal, The Middle East’s shadow war amps up, Semafor, 4-13-2023, https://www.semafor.com/article/04/12/2023/middle-easts-shadow-war/, yao

Iran’s long-simmering proxy war with the U.S. and Israel is quickly heating up, and it’s forcing the Pentagon to shift more naval and air assets to the Middle East as a deterrent.

Tehran-backed militias have launched a string of attacks on American bases in northern Syria since late March, killing one U.S. contractor and leaving at least six others with traumatic brain injuries. The Palestinian militant group Hamas and other Iranian proxies fired missiles into Israel this month in a coordinated strike from three separate borders — Lebanon, Syria, and the Gaza Strip.