OCO enabled Intelligence is essential for counterterrorism
Bronk 17—Assistant Professor of computer and information systems at the University of Houston’s College of Technology [Dr. Chris Bronk and Gregory Anderson (Master’s candidate for the Information Systems Security program at the University of Houston and is currently a research assistant under Dr. Chris Bronk and Dr. Arthur Conklin), Winter 2017, “Encounter Battle: Engaging ISIL in Cyberspace”, The Cyber Defense Review, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 93-108, https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/26267403.pdf, Accessed through the Wake Forest Library] AMarb
There will no doubt be difficulties incorporating cyber operations components into overall US strategy countering ISIL and other non-state adversaries; however, it is clear national security leadership in Washington will leverage cyber capabilities more significantly. One issue that will continue to dog offensive cyber operations and intelligence activities is the equities question—should the US government turn over knowledge it accrues regarding cyber vulnerabilities to the technology industry so that they may be repaired. For instance, is it more desirable for USCYBERCOM and the National Security Agency (NSA) to keep information regarding broken encryption implementations or software as was alleged in the Heartbleed bug in the OpenSSL software libraries? Issues such as this will be a major policy question to consider.
Ultimately, the cyber conflict against ISIL will serve as a template for future cyber action against terror groups, insurgents, and violent transnational criminal syndicates. Looking backward, we can see the effective application of robust signals intelligence capabilities have been. Consider US support of Colombian operations against the Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarias de Colombia (FARC). There can be little doubt that the Colombian military and police were made significantly more effective with the addition of US intelligence capabilities. Policymakers are keen to eradicate or at least damage ISIL but will need to ask how cyber weapons can frustrate it as much as anything else can. The more cyber tactics can short-circuit ISIL’s operational capabilities, the better. What is necessary for US cyber operators are clear objectives from senior leadership on what they want to produce. The engineers that build USCYBERCOM’s tools and the hackers that serve as its operational forces can easily enough push back on what they believe is the art of the possible.