Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Liberalism is key to checking imperialism—liberal ideology elevates universal rights

Ikenberry 2020

G. John, the Albert G. Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University. “Mastering Modernity.” A World Safe for Democracy: Liberal Internationalism and the Crises of Global Order. Pp 231-234. LJS

If liberal internationalism had an urge for empire, it also had an urge to oppose it. In the late nineteenth century, liberal thinkers in the United States and Europe added their voices to movements against empire and colonialism. After the world wars, many liberal internationalists, particularly in the United States, championed the League of Nations and the United Nations as institutions that enshrined principles of self-determination and sovereign equality—and thus offered a path away from empire. As the twentieth century unfolded, liberal internationalists grew increasingly committed to postimperial forms of order. These changes in orientation played out in the struggles between the United States and Britain during and after World War II over imperial preferences and global spheres of influence. The shift away from empire emerged as part of the general reimagining of liberal internationalism in the 1940s and during the Cold War, when the United States put its weight behind a world organized around sovereign states as it pursued its expanding geopolitical interests and built postwar order. In important respects, however, it was not the West that turned liberal internationalism against empire and imperialism but the non-West, which seized upon ideas and principles—universal in character but often instrumental in origin and purpose—and applied them to struggles over sovereignty, rights, and rules. Wilson-era liberal internationalism had offered global ideas, but it retained an old-style Western parochialism. The vision of liberal order put forward by Wilson and his peers was more “civilizational” than “universal.” The League of Nations would be open to the wider world, but it was organized around the Western liberal democracies. States that were considered insufficiently mature to join the community of sovereign states would have to wait until they were ready. As Edward Keene argues, the League of Nations entailed the “internationalization” of civilization—so there were limits on the universal or global scope of membership and standing. “Although ideological concerns were beginning to become more important in defining the boundaries of the civilized world, racial discrimination was still a major element in deciding which peoples were entitled to membership in the new organization and thus to have their sovereign status recognized.”62 With the rebuilding of order after World War II and the establishment of the United Nations, this civilizational view—the distinction between the “family of civilized nations” and the rest of the world—gave way to a more universalistic and inclusive conception. Keene argues, “Simply put: the United Nations was envisioned as, or quite rapidly became, an organization of all the world’s peoples, with universal participation in the projects of preserving peace and developing global civilization, whereas the League had, above all, been an organization of civilized nations, working collectively for all the world’s peoples.” Postwar notions of states, peoples, sovereignty, and civilization were becoming less based on nineteenth-century notions of the social hierarchies of peoples. As Keene notes, “the development of the UN system reflected a much more inclusive attitude toward non-European peoples, in keeping with the recognition that they were no less civilized than their European counterparts.”63 What changed between 1919 and 1945 was the conception of how peoples and societies from different regions and civilizations related to each other as moral and legal entities, a move driven in part by a fuller acknowledgment of the universal reach of the notion of sovereign equality.64 But it was also driven by the growing salience of the “rights of peoples”—the spread of the claim that all human beings, by virtue of being human, have fundamental and inalienable rights. Behind this shift were changing views of modernity and civilization. Civilization itself was weakening as an intellectual construct, and modernity was not seen simply as something spreading outward from its Western center. The new divide was not the West versus the non-West—which had become untenable—but the liberal democratic world versus the illiberal world. Modernity empowered both sides of this political universe. In World War II, the great struggle on behalf of civilization had been against Nazi Germany, a European power that was itself employing scientific theories of race to legitimate its violence and aggression—ideas that had been used in the nineteenth century to defend European imperial domination over “backward” non-European peoples.65 In this sense, the old civilizational justification for two world orders—a Western system of civilized states and a backward and uncivilized world beyond—did not fail because non-European peoples gradually joined the “family of civilized nations.” It collapsed when civilized states—Germany, Japan, and Russia—joined the noncivilized world.66 As I noted in chapter 5, this shift in thinking occurred in the United States during the war years and continued during the Cold War. The rise of fascism and totalitarianism led Roosevelt and his contemporaries to let go of their notions of civilization, race, and nation and rethink the nature of liberalism and modernity. With threats to the liberal capitalist order now coming from inside the West, what it meant to be civilized could no longer be defined by race or culture or geography. This sentiment was captured by Leonard Woolf in a short book published in 1939, Barbarians at the Gate, in which he argued that civilization was not a geographical or even a cultural construction but a way of regulating individual behavior within human communities. Europe might have found a distinctive approach to restraining violence, tyranny, and predation, but civilization was distributed more widely around the world—and so too was the antithesis of civilization, or what Woolf called barbarism. Writing on the eve of World War II, Woolf argued that “the barbarian is, therefore, not only at the gates; he is always within the walls of our civilization, inside our minds and our hearts.”67 This new sense that the dangers to the liberal democratic world came from inside that world forced American and European internationalists to rethink their principles and projects. American liberal internationalists began to make more serious efforts to separate their project from the legacies of European imperialism. This separation was driven by evolving ideas about sovereignty and self-determination, grand shifts in geopolitical interests, depression, and wartime politics within Western liberal democracies, as well as by more immediate struggles brought on by the war and the way it changed the Anglo-American relationship. The United States did not have the same attachments to empire as the British, and cracks opened up within the West on whether and how the world would transition away from empire.68 This was seen most clearly at the Atlantic Charter meeting in 1941, where Roosevelt and Churchill disagreed over the future of the British imperial preference system and the principles of sovereign rights and self-determination.69

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.