Liberalism is ideologically opposed to imperialism—the right to self-determination created an anti-colonial feedback loop between liberal democracies, former colonies, and oppressed groups within great powers
Ikenberry 2020
G. John, the Albert G. Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University. “Mastering Modernity.” A World Safe for Democracy: Liberal Internationalism and the Crises of Global Order. pp 237-240. LJS
A second force separating liberal internationalism and empire was the ideas themselves, filtered through political movements both in the liberal democracies and outside the Western world. Roosevelt’s Four Freedoms and the Atlantic Charter, the most sweeping of these ideas, can be seen as efforts by wartime democratic leaders to mobilize their people for war. In this sense, they served an instrumental purpose. For Roosevelt, the Atlantic Charter was a way to legitimize for the American people their imminent entrance into the war. It was an effort to counter Nazi propaganda by offering subjugated nations and neutrals in Europe a sweeping liberal democratic vision of a better world to come. But even if universalist principles are uttered for instrumental reasons, once they enter into the discourse they become part of the contested ideological landscape upon which political struggles are waged.76 To be sure, some liberal internationalists were deeply committed to presiding over liberalism’s separation from empire. Roosevelt’s closest adviser on postwar planning, Sumner Welles—the driving force behind the Atlantic Charter and later the United Nations—earnestly sought to use wartime negotiations with the British to escort Britain’s empire offstage. He and other Wilsonians had spent the 1930s reflecting on the failures of 1919, looking for new ways to build a cooperative global order that, as Welles put it, “implies the juridic equality of every nation and the acceptance of a moral order and of effective international law.”77 Welles sought to lay down principles that would weaken the political standing of empire in the postwar world.78 But it was the wider use of self-determination and sovereign equality that gave these principles impact. This struggle was waged on many fronts, driven by geopolitical and ideological clashes and movements within the West and between it and the non-West. It is not simply—or primarily—a story of the West “externalizing” its ideas and institutions to the rest of the world. NonWestern peoples and societies seized on the principles and institutions that the West had developed for itself and adapted them for their own purposes in their struggles for independence. Witnessing the decolonization movements in 1964, Rupert Emerson observed that when non-Western people “press for equality, democracy, and the right of self-determination, they are asking their present and erstwhile rulers to live up to the ideals which these same rulers have transmitted to them and proclaimed as their own. . . . The nationalism which developed in the imperial West in the nineteenth century, with its implied right of self-determination, can in this sense be seen as one of the key sources of anti-colonialism.”79 Westphalian and liberal internationalist ideas were both pushed and pulled into the rest of the world. The “reception and remolding of Western ideas” by peoples and societies in the non-West, C. A. Bayly argues, “set limits on the nature and extent of their domination by European power-holders.”80 The formal and informal unraveling of empire and colonialism is one of the great dramas of the post-1945 era. From the 1950s to the early 1960s, the previous century’s era of imperial expansion underwent a radical reversal. Robin Winks notes, “One after another, the colonized territories tried to establish their independence from European control. From Guinea to Somalia, from Morocco to India, the flags of France, Britain, Italy, Holland, Belgium, Spain, and Portugal came down. In their place were hoisted newly designed flags of the newly sovereign states. By the mid-1980s, no substantial area was under colonial rule, although the radically discriminatory regime prevailed in the Republic of Africa.”81 The predominant view in Europe at the end of the nineteenth century was that the imperial system would remain the core organizing logic of world order. Yet, in less than a hundred years, these empires—along with the Soviet Union—had disappeared.82 Political movements in the United States and the other liberal democracies also had a behind-the-scenes impact on their government’s policies toward empire. In the nineteenth century, the British anti–slave trade movement pressed the Parliament to abolish the slave trade throughout the British Empire. During and after World War I, the women’s suffrage movement in the United States and Britain became increasingly active in international affairs. The war itself affected the lives of women, galvanizing the suffragist movement and illuminating the role of war in modern society. Many in the movement made a direct connection between the right to vote and campaigns for peace and worldwide social justice.83 During the war, women’s groups on both sides of the Atlantic, led by figures such as Jane Addams and Emily Greene Balch, actively participated in debates on the postwar settlement.84 Together, Addams and Balch became leaders of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom, devoted to peace education, international dialogue, and socially progressive causes, for which they later received the Nobel Peace Prize.85 This group and others explicitly linked the denial of women’s rights and social justice in their societies to the pursuit of militarism and imperialism abroad. During the 1940s, domestic political struggles—particularly over civil rights—and the continuing activities of progressive movements reinforced liberal internationalist efforts abroad. Americans struggling for civil rights explicitly linked their causes with anticolonial movements.86 The linkage showed itself, for example, in June 1942, when Walter White, representing the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, met with Sumner Welles and urged the Roosevelt administration to call a “Pacific Conference” devoted to ending colonial rule in Asia. White wanted FDR to meet with Indian leaders such as Nehru and Gandhi and the Chinese nationalist leader Chiang Kai-shek to announce America’s support for Asian statehood and national self-rule. White also suggested that, with the “Pacific Charter” in hand, a delegation of Americans, led by Wendell Willkie and a “distinguished American Negro whose complexion unmistakably identifies him as being a colored man,” should go to India and announce American support for the Indian struggle.”87 The idea did not have great support in the administration. Even those who took issue with the British Empire were unwilling to take steps that might weaken Britain’s position in the struggle with Nazi Germany. After World War II, the American civil rights movement and social justice campaigns drew connections between their struggles and the struggles of nationalist and anti-imperialists abroad. In 1947, W. E. B. Du Bois used the platform of the United Nations for “An Appeal to the World,” describing the injustices of racial segregation and inequality in the United States and associating the struggles of African Americans with the victims of colonialism in Africa and elsewhere. “Our treatment is not merely an internal question for the United States,” he argued, “it is a basic problem of humanity.”88 Not only did civil rights activists appeal to international audiences for support and solidarity, many US political leaders also saw progress on civil rights as integral to fighting the Cold War. During these decades, the American government’s relationship to civil rights legislation was shaped by the sense that it was necessary to manage its international image. As the historian Mary Dudziak argues, “the need to address international criticism gave the federal government an incentive to promote social change at home.”89 The connections also ran in the other direction as the American civil rights movement, along with other social justice advocates, put pressure on the US government to support anticolonial causes abroad.90