Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Liberalism is structurally opposed to imperialism—liberal organizations are vehicles for anti-colonial and anti-patriarchal struggle

Ikenberry 2020

G. John, the Albert G. Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University. “Mastering Modernity.” A World Safe for Democracy: Liberal Internationalism and the Crises of Global Order. Pp 240-243. LJS

Third, the international organizations established after the two world wars created platforms and capacities that experts and activists could use in their struggles against empire. While the League of Nations and, later, the United Nations helped Britain and other European states secure what remained of their imperial holdings, they also served as institutional sites for activism and repositories of universalistic norms and principles that opponents of empire could deploy in their struggles for self-rule. Both the league and the United Nations created institutional channels for groups that previously had little input into diplomacy or the shaping of international rules and practices to provide a counterweight to the old imperial order. These groups included women’s organizations, international activists, and non-Western governments and peoples.91 As I have noted, the Great War did not quell the European appetite for empire, and the League of Nations was widely seen in Europe and Great Britain as an opportunity to strengthen the prestige and administration of imperial rule. But the league also played a role—if a conflicted and awkward one—in moving the world toward the end of empire and the spread of selfdetermination. “If one considers its work in stabilizing new states and running the minorities protection and mandates system,” Susan Pedersen argues, “the League appears as a key agent in the transition from a world of formal empires to a world of formally sovereign states.”92 Pedersen looks specifically at the league’s Permanent Mandates Commission, the system established in 1921 to manage the territories in Africa, the Middle East, and the Pacific that Germany, Austria-Hungary, and the Ottoman Empire had lost in the war. The mandates system did not directly alter the aims of the remaining imperial powers, which sought to preserve their colonies and continued to see empire as a civilizing mission. “What was new,” Pedersen argues, “was the apparatus and the level of international diplomacy, publicity, and ‘talk’ that the system brought into being.” The mandates system was a vehicle for “internationalization”—a process “by which certain political issues and functions are displaced from the national or imperial, and into the international realm.”93 Unintended by its architects, the mandates system became a vehicle by which those favoring self-determination and revision of the Versailles settlement could press their claims. It provided a platform for internationalists, humanitarians, nationalists, and others who sought to expose the dark side of imperial rule. The wider league complex of institutions had the same effect, drawing international commissions, organizations, lobbyists, and experts into a sprawling and ongoing debate about the future of European empire and the normative foundations of statehood.94 It would take decades and another world war to bring about a global system of sovereign states. But the league pointed the way. India took advantage of the League of Nations to gain rights and recognition before its independence in 1947. Great Britain, in an effort to strengthen its presence and voting share at Versailles, overcame the opposition of the other great powers to gain separate representation for its dominions, including India. Although still a British dependency, India—along with Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and South Africa—actively participated in the conference’s deliberations and signed the peace treaty on the basis of “legal equality.”95 Because the Covenant of the League of Nations was part of the peace treaty, India acquired the right to become a founding member of the league, the only state among the thirty-one original members that was not legally self-governing. India’s internal and external relations continued to rest with the British government, but as one observer notes, “for the first time in the modern period, [India] came into direct and formal contact with the outside world.”96 Between 1919 and 1947, India’s position within the international legal system remains anomalous. While formally not a sovereign state, India exercised treaty-making power and participated in almost every international conference after 1920. As a league member, India attended the Washington Conference on Naval Armaments in 1921, signed the Washington treaty, and was admitted to the International Labour Organization, the Permanent Court of International Justice, and other league-related organizations. It signed numerous multilateral treaties, including the KelloggBriand Pact of 1928.97 In 1945, India was invited to the San Francisco Conference of the United Nations, and it became a founding member of the new world organization. Over this period, India’s self-governing status remained limited and many Indian nationalist leaders saw their country’s presence in these international bodies as a capitulation to British imperialism. Nonetheless, India took advantage of the status it gained over these decades to pave the way for independence, consolidating India as a diplomatic unit and giving its nationalist movement international recognition.98 The United Nations was even more explicit in facilitating the transition away from empire. It formally enshrined the idea of universal membership in a world of sovereign states and provided the legal and political framework for the recognition and integration of new states into the postimperial Westphalian order. As decolonization accelerated, the United Nations rapidly expanded from 51 original members in 1945, to 100 in September 1961, and to 159 by the end of 1985. Ironically, the United Nations is widely seen as the embodiment of internationalist ideas, but its greatest achievement may be the global triumph of the sovereign state system. Adam Roberts notes the United Nations’ importance in providing a framework for decolonization: The UN sometimes assisted the process of decolonization through referenda, and also through General Assembly resolutions—most notably the 1960 Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples. But its most important contribution was in providing a framework for entry into international society of the numerous new and reconstituted states, many of which were intensely vulnerable. For them, the UN was not just the main means of securing diplomatic recognition, but also a world stage, a negotiating forum, a provider of well-paid jobs, and a source of symbolic protection. The UN embodies principles, including racial equality and the sovereign equality of states, that were vital to the decolonization process.99

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.