Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US liberalism was key to anti-imperial struggle—opposition to imperial powers and building platforms for state sovereignty

Ikenberry 2020

G. John, the Albert G. Milbank Professor of Politics and International Affairs at Princeton University. “Mastering Modernity.” A World Safe for Democracy: Liberal Internationalism and the Crises of Global Order. pp 243-245. LJS

Finally, the deepest and most far-reaching force separating liberalism from empire has been the struggle over the global expansion of the Westphalian state system. A world of sovereign states was a precondition for the spread of liberal internationalism. Therefore, the struggle to extend sovereign rights of statehood to peoples and nations was the real bulwark against empire. By building on and reinforcing this grand shift from empire to the nation-state, liberal internationalism ultimately placed its “project” within the Westphalian system—it became, in a sense, the set of ideas for organizing the world once the world finally shed its imperial foundations. Empire had ordered the world for centuries, and when the twentieth century asked what would replace empire as the world’s organizing logic, liberal internationalism stepped forward as the alternative. How the Westphalian state system came to encompass the world is a question that still requires scholarly attention.100 The sovereign state arrived quite late for most regions outside the West—essentially in the twentieth century, after the world wars. For most of the past five hundred years, European great powers were not eager to export or universalize the Westphalian order. They held on to empire and colonies until forced to give them up. In this sense, the spread of Westphalia is not a story of the imposition of a Western idea on the rest of the world, but of the failure of the European state system to sustain empire.101 To pursue movements for independence and selfdetermination on their own, peoples and societies outside Europe took advantage of the cracks and clashes in the European imperial system. As noted earlier, Edward Keene argues that great wars between liberal and totalitarian states discredited the old civilizational vision of sovereignty and imperial hierarchy. Christian Reus-Smit finds, in the universalization of norms of sovereignty and self-determination after two hundred years of struggles over individual rights, a story of the “evolution and transmission of the legitimating institutions that sustain sovereignty.”102 This surely is part of the explanation. But it remains to be explained why empires, as a form of global order, failed. John Darwin argues that empires have tended to fail for four reasons: “external defeat or geopolitical weakness; ideological contagion and the loss of legitimacy; domestic enfeeblement at the centre of empire—the loss of political will and economic capacity; and colonial revolt.”103 All of these triggers of imperial crisis seemed to be present in the twentieth century. Considered as wars of empire, the world wars decisively weakened and brought to an end the European system of empire. In this drama, the United States played an important role in both undercutting empire and promoting the Westphalian state system. It did this first during the two world wars, by joining and later leading coalitions of allies that ultimately defeated states with expansive imperial projects. In World War I it was Imperial Germany, which had conquered a large area of Eastern Europe and seized much of the Russian Empire’s western territories. This war resulted in the collapse of four long-established European empires: Romanov Russia, Habsburg Austria-Hungary, Hohenzollern Germany, and Ottoman Turkey. World War II effectively finished off the Japanese empire and severely weakened the British and French empires, though the latter two, because they were on the winning side, took a couple of decades to dissolve. During the Cold War, the United States also engaged in balancing against the Soviet Union—seeking to contain the expansion of Soviet power and influence as well as thwarting communist coups and revolutions in many weak, independent states. At the same time, as noted earlier, the United States played a variety of roles in facilitating states’ ability to survive as independent members of international society. It led efforts to institutionalize Westphalian norms of nonaggression and sovereign independence, first with the League of Nations and then with the United Nations Charter. In the second half of the twentieth century, the American-led international order institutionalized open trade and multilateral cooperation, providing the infrastructure for a global economic system, which in turn strengthened the smaller states’ ability to sustain their sovereignty. Also in the second half of the twentieth century, the American system of military alliances dampened violent conflicts among allied states, particularly in Europe and East Asia, and this prevented the Westphalian system from falling back into violent conflict and empire building.104 Thus the “American century” was also the century of the global spread of the nation-state. They were different political projects, but each helped the other gain ground.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.