Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

2024 election will be a disaster following 2020 election crisis – election deniers have gained a foothold in secretaries of state offices.

Michael Waldman, 2/1/2022. Michael Waldman is president of the Brennan Center for Justice at NYU School of Law. Waldman was director of speechwriting for President Bill Clinton from 1995 to 1999, serving as assistant to the president. He was responsible for writing or editing nearly two thousand speeches, including four State of the Union and two inaugural addresses. He was special assistant to the president for policy coordination from 1993 to 1995. "How Bad Could the 2024 Election Be?" Brennan Center for Justice, https://www.brennancenter.org/ourwork/analysisopinion/howbadcould2024electionbe //JSAM

Some­times, like a Shakespeare anti­hero confiding in the audience, Donald Trump blurts out his true motives. This week he did it again. Lawmakers who want to tweak the Electoral Count Act, accord­ing to Trump, are essen­tially admit­ting that “Mike Pence did have the right to change the outcome. And they now want to take that right away. Unfortunately, he didn’t exer­cise that power. He could have overturned the election!”

All this came after Trump told a Texas rally that prosecutors investigating him are “racist” and urged supporters to stage massive, menacing protests in the cities where he faces legal action.

In a Q&A for Sunday’s Washington Post, Jennifer Rubin asked me for the worst-case scenario for the 2024 election. The truth is that as bad as 2020 was, it could be worse next time around. Trump’s coup try was clownish, incompetent, chaotic. (Remem­ber the Four Seasons Total Landscaping? Or hair dye mixed with flop sweat pour­ing down Rudy Giuliani’s face?) Since then, the professionals have taken over. State legislatures dominated by proponents of the Big Lie have laid the legal found­a­tion for a genu­ine constitutional crisis in 2024.

How could it happen?

Election deniers are running for secretary of state or attorney general in many states. The central argument for their candidacy is that they would not have certified the 2020 election results, as required by law, after voters chose Joe Biden. If elected, they would not hesitate to try to block certification in 2024. Some are seeking jobs as elections administrators, where they could use their authority to tilt turnout. They could, for example, selectively reject provisional ballots from communities of color.

Separately, lawmakers are scheming for the power to nullify elections. Some believe (bizarrely) that the Constitution itself gives them the power to reject elec­tion results. In seven states, legislators have proposed bills to form­ally give them­selves that authority. Fortunately none has passed, and, under any reasonable reading of the Constitution, those bills would be unconstitutional. But this disregard for constitutional norms is alarming and dangerous.

The smallest tech­nical dispute could trigger a nullification attempt. In 2020, some Wisconsin legislators argued that the results were invalid because elec­tions offi­cials offered mail-in ballots to residents of nursing homes without first visit­ing the facilities, as required by statute. (Of course, the pandemic made such visits impossible.) A similar technical legal violation could serve as a pretext for a state official to reject future results.

And new laws in Arkansas and Georgia recently gave state authorities the power to remove and tempor­ar­ily replace local elec­tion offi­cials. They could, for example, remove elec­tion offi­cials in Fulton County, Geor­gia, on a pretext, install their own candid­ate, and throw out ballots in the Atlanta area.

Would the Supreme Court step in to protect the sanc­tity of our elec­tions? The Court declared most recently in 2020 that once a state legis­lature has decided that voters choose the president, it cannot step in and undo their votes. That’s encour­aging. But in the last decade, the justices have refused to strike down even a single restrict­ive voting law. I would prefer not to test their commit­ment to voting rights in a crisis.

Fixing the Electoral Count Act — a good idea — would not stop these mach­in­a­tions in the states. Far more import­ant would be clear national stand­ards on things such as vote by mail and when ballots must be coun­ted. The Free­dom to Vote: John Lewis Act is the most import­ant step to stop election subversion of all kinds.

For the first time, a national leader argues that our demo­cracy is fake. Over a year after the elec­tion, 70 percent of Repub­lic­ans think Trump really won. That’s new and scary. But some­thing else — some­thing more encouraging — is also happening. A democracy movement, galvanized by Trump’s lies, mobil­ized around the campaign for federal legis­la­tion. It’s the biggest push for voting rights in half a century — a coali­tion of breadth, diversity, and depth. Perhaps the story of the next two years will be the rising righteous anger of this movement fight­ing for democracy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.