Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Sanctions effective – they create internal pressure for Putin to change behavior.

Elizabeth Goitein and Benjamin Waldman 4-11-2022, "How the Russia Sanctions Work and What Congress Needs to Know," Brennan Center for Justice, https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/how-russia-sanctions-work-and-what-congress-needs-know

The Biden administration  in late February that Russia’s economy will “go[] backwards as long as President Putin decides to go forward with his invasion.” The threat of widespread financial distress was borne out immediately after institutional blockades and asset freezes took effect. The ruble lost  of its value, spurring the central bank to , implement draconian restrictions on capital conversion, and  the stock market . It was as if more than $300 billion in central-bank reserves had , limiting Putin’s ability to weather the effects of sanctions. Soon, one senior American official , we will “see inflation spike and economic activity contract.” Expert assessments are sobering: Russia’s GDP will  9% in 2022, its debt has been  to “junk,” and a default may be . Total financial collapse, however, is less certain. Understanding that the United States and its allies retain a weighty interest in Russian energy production, OFAC   “related to energy” from the  of its sanctions package. Bipartisan pushback led the administration to ban imports of Russian oil and natural gas, but whether this measure will choke “” remains unclear. As OFAC , Russia’s energy sector remains relatively unencumbered, particularly since European nations have been   to follow Biden’s lead. That means —  — Putin can still rely on  to  his war posture. Moreover, Russia has found receptive trading partners beyond the West. India, for instance, has begun snapping up , thereby extending Russia’s economic viability.

In the meantime, ordinary Russians will experience the sharp sting of sanctions. Fear that the ruble will collapse has already precipitated a race to withdraw deposits, drawing  across the country; restrictions on consumer banks have left travelers  abroad, their credit cards worthless;  no longer processes transactions in Russia, cutting freelancers off from their incomes; and export controls have contributed to soaring prices of , commencing a vicious cycle of price-gouging. Secretary of State Antony Blinken explicitly  this dynamic: “We regret that tens of millions of Russians will suffer because of the dangerous decisions made by a tiny circle of corrupt leaders.”

To its credit, OFAC has issued general licenses for humanitarian aid. It has authorized the operation of , including the International Committee of the Red Cross, and approved the   of agricultural commodities and medicine. Nevertheless, as experts have observed  and , sanctions nominally targeted at governing elites often exact the most severe toll on the people most attenuated from governmental decision-making. These sanctions on Russia — issued in response to brazen violations of international law — will likely be no exception. Indeed, that might be the point. Rather than an unintended byproduct of sanctions aimed at government actors, mass hardship might represent an intended “” to Putin. Declining standards of living in Russia could generate a groundswell of popular , force Putin’s attention inward, and  the energy and resources required for war. This is “sanctions from the bottom up,” and it appears to be a larger part of the United States’ playbook with each passing day. Biden’s advisors had previously disclaimed “even the appearance of targeting” ordinary Russians. Testifying about the measures imposed on Russia following its invasion of Crimea, Daleep Singh, now a core member of Biden’s economic team,  the importance of “limit[ing] unwanted spillovers” and “avoid[ing] causing widespread panic and impoverishment among the general public.” But speaking from the White House podium last month, Singh took a conspicuously : “any leader, whether you’re an autocrat or a small-‘d’ democrat, has to pay attention to the living standards of your country. And already, we’re seeing the effects of these measures.” It is clear that spillover effects will not be limited to the Russian people. The uncertainty induced by war and the shock of sanctions have already  a global surge in oil and gas prices,  the cost of some grains and metals, and  supply-chain capacity for critical commodities. American families will likely continue to notice higher prices at the gas pump and the grocery store, despite Biden’s efforts to  market disruptions. In the longer term, sanctions might fuel inflation and  economic growth across the United States and Europe. The contours of sanctions’ second-order effects are, as always, , but global reverberations are all but certain.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.