The CP creates an effective European cybersecurity network – solves the aff
Lete ’19 [Bruno Lété currently serves as a transatlantic fellow, security and defense at The German Marshall Fund of the United States in Brussels. He provides analysis and advice on trends in geopolitics and on international security and defense policy. “THE EU AND NATO: the Essential Partners”. 2019. European Union Institute for Security Studies. https://drive.google.com/file/d/18Um8tOva0YQLiUGAjjzkkuUnIIXx-TGZ/view?usp=sharing. Accessed 6-22-2022; MJen]
~ Evolving to a joint model The priority for the EU and NATO is to now find agreement on how to mitigate cyber- security threats which are becoming more frequent and more sophisticated. EU-NATO : cooperation is essential to allow European and transatlantic governments to become better at preventing, detecting, and deterring cyberattacks, as well as to hold those that engage in malicious cyber activities accountable. As such, both organisations must continue to seek new ways of cooperation that deepen and broaden their engagement. The following recommendations are achievable, some immediately and others in the long term. But given the scale of the threat, it is necessary to think ambitiously. Create an EU-NATO cyber threat information hub Joint structures that combine EU and NATO resources or expertise are nothing new. The European Centre of Excellence for Countering Hybrid Threats in Helsinki is a good example of how, with the necessary good will, the EU and NATO can work together un- der the same roof. The creation of an EU-NATO Cyber Threat Information Hub could be another step in this vein. The mission of such a hub would simply be to improve information sharing by building relations and networks between the EU, NATO, mem- ber states and partners. It could do so first of all by advising technical and operation- al level Standard Operating Procedures (SOP) for information exchange between the EU and NATO entities, and identifying how to enable secure lines of communication to share confidential cyber intelligence. In addition, it could assist the EU and NATO in defining what type of information needs to be shared, who needs to receive it, when the information needs to be shared, and making sure the information is released in a timely and appropriate manner. In this regard, the hub could make active recommendations concerning the growing role of automated information sharing in identifying rele- vant information more quickly, but also in automating threat mitigation in real time. Automated sharing of security and threat information could also help the EU and NATO to standardise their threat intelligence. The hub could identify adequate informa- tion-sharing platforms or information-storage clouds that can withstand increasingly complex attacks, based on open industry specifications. Such platforms bring several benefits. They enable rapid communication and peer-based sharing, they reduce cost, and increase the speed of cyber defences by substituting manual responses for auto- mated processes. In this regard, the hub could make active proposals on how to use the EU’s Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO) or the European Defence Fund (EDF) to develop this type of technological capacity. The recent proposal of eight EU member states to develop a ‘Cyber Threats and Incident Response Information Sharing Platform’ under PESCO encourages more thinking in this direction. The success of EU- NATO cooperation in preventing, detecting and deterring cyberattacks will ultimately be defined by the ability of the two organisations to share information more effectively. Cautious steps in this direction have already been taken; for instance the EU was grant- ed access to the NATO Malware Information Sharing Platform. But both organisations will need to continue to explore bold initiatives if they are to address today’s informa- tion-sharing gap. Establish an EU-NATO Taskforce for cyber crisis response coordination To efficiently synchronise their cyber crisis response mechanisms the EU and NATO : will need to create additional capacity. The existing structures that allow the EU and - NATO to come together are still limited, ranging from formal and informal meetings ~ between the North Atlantic Council (NAC) and the EU Political and Security Committee (PSC), exchanges at ministerial meetings, cross briefings to respective Committees and i - Councils, and informal staff-to-staff interaction, for instance between the European External Action Service and NATO’s International Staff. These interactions are valu- : able, but they do not represent a solid basis for guaranteeing an efficient and smooth | ~ collective response in the event of a real cyber crisis. A roadmap for collective response is therefore needed. An immediate way to achieve this would be to create a structure — like a joint taskforce — that brings together the EU Cyber Crisis Response Framework ~ and NATO’s Crisis Response System. This taskforce would be convened when a ma- jor cyber incident strikes multiple EU member states and NATO Allies or EU/NATO institutions. To prepare this taskforce for operational duties, in a first stage, its task would be | to map the full spectrum of EU and NATO competencies for cyber defence, to clari- fy responsibilities at national and supranational levels for issues like attribution and countermeasures, and based on this information to create a common template of cyber crisis management phases. Once such a common template is created, in a second stage,% ~ the taskforce could then be convened to respond to cyber incidents. This taskforce! could also be useful in many other ways. For instance, it could make recommenda ~ tions on how to synchronise joint strategic communication among EU and NATO in- stitutions, or make proposals on how to use EU PESCO and NATO structures to supporti countries before, during and after crises. It could also look at creating linkages betweeni the EU ‘Cyber Rapid Response Teams’ currently being developed under PESCO and the! existing NATO Rapid Reaction Team to Fight Cyber Attacks. Finally the taskforce couldi also make suggestions on how to include NATO into the EU Commission ‘Blueprint toi respond to large-scale cybersecurity incidents and crises’. The EU and NATO have a§ wide array of crisis management tools at their disposal, but they are disconnected. An% ambitious, but much needed step, would now be to align those different instruments and to create an EU-NATO ‘playbook’ on how to react to cyber incidents and crises. Develop EU-NATO triggers for a collective response to cyberattacks Talking openly about active and reactive responses in cyberspace is no longer taboo fori EU or NATO member states. And the policy instruments to conduct an offensive strategy or to sanction adversaries are steadily increasing. NATO for instance has already ~ recognised that a serious cyberattack on a member state could be a potential triggeri for Article 5. At its November 2017 defence ministerial the Alliance also agreed to cre ate a Cyber Operations Centre that will facilitate the integration of cyber capabilities with conventional military capabilities. The EU for its part created in 2017 its Cyber Diplomacy Toolbox, a framework for a joint EU diplomatic response to malicious cyber activities. In May 2019, EU countries also agreed that individuals and groups conducting cyberattacks from outside the bloc may be hit with potential sanctions, including travel bans and asset freezes. These measures have boosted the EU’s and NATO’s individual capacity to hit back at cyber adversaries. But there is today no template on how to synchronise these different EU and NATO tools, nor is there agreement on the conditions that would trig- ger the collective use of these tools. In other words, the circumstances in which the EU and NATO would work together to adopt a responsive or offensive posture are still éambiguous. While NATO and the EU have to an extent consciously embraced ambigu- éity for its strategic value, the absence of a clearer definition of an offensive posture, : and of the circumstances, degree, and manner in which counter-measures can or should be taken if member states perceive a cyber threat or suffer a cyberattack, make 1t more difficult for the EU and NATO to respond collectively. The conditions to use Ethe EU Cyber Diplomacy Toolbox or the trigger for NATO to launch an offensive cyber : campaign may be clear if a member state faces a large-scale, devastating cyber cri- ésis. However, most cyberattacks fall below the threshold of being perceived as a clear act of aggression. Formulating a proportionate response in this grey zone constitutes the biggest problem. Russian ‘active measures’ in Europe are for instance clearly de- ésigned to exploit these grey zones, and the Kremlin has acquired some sophistication i in avoiding red lines that would trigger a common response from EU or NATO member Estates. Russia is also not the only potential adversary capable of similar tactics. There is thus an acute need to define when and how the EU and NATO must respond against i day-to-day cyber intrusions. The development of a set of EU-NATO basic principles, or (non-binding) guidelines that would trigger a joint response would be a good first step. The Tallinn Manual® published by the NATO Cyber Defence Centre of Excellence could offer inspiration on how the EU and NATO can define these principles while respecting the application of international law. Currently the EU and NATO need to assess each individual cyber threat or cyberattack on a case-by-case basis without the support of standard measurement tools and indicators that can help them formulate a swift and proportionate response. This considerably slows down the decision-making process. However, if the EU and NATO were to dispose of a set of pre-agreed principles, it would significantly improve their joint reactiveness and resilience. Intensify joint cyber exercises, foster a culture of mutual trust Exercising, training and learning together is key to better understand each other’s institutional processes, to develop common responses, and to cultivate a culture of trust. In their history, the EU and NATO have found it difficult to adopt such a mind- ~ set. They held only one joint crisis management exercise in 2003, which prioritised politico-military priorities and did not include cyber assets. The EU and NATO also planned, but failed, to implement more exercises in 2007, 2010, and 2014. The Joint ~ Declarations of 2016 and 2018 have nevertheless turned the tide and today both organi- sations exercise, train and learn together more than ever before. But the rapprochement is in many cases still cautious. A key example are the EU and NATO ‘coordinated and parallel’ crisis management exercises — EU PACE and NATO CMX. Synchronising EU and NATO flagship exercises is a commendable step to develop more interaction but : working in parallel is still a very different concept than a ‘joint exercise’. De facto, EU | PACE and NATO CMX remain independent initiatives, they constitute only one signif- icant occasion per year where the EU and NATO exercise together, and they are not conducted at the same moment in time which represents an important disconnect with a joint crisis response in reality. A more realistic approach to creating a fully-fledged - EU-NATO joint exercise is perhaps to think small-scale. A useful angle in this respect would be to have EU-NATO staffs exercise how to align specific technical cyber inci- i dent information (from computer security incident response teams — CSIRTs) with ~ military intelligence threat assessments. Moreover, exercises must also go hand-in- ~ hand with joint training and education opportunities. The EU and NATO have already opened up their cyber courses to each other’s staffs. As a next step, they could further explore how to integrate NATO cyber defence courses with the recently launched EU - Cyber Education, Training and Exercise platform - an initiative from the European Security and Defence College to harmonise and standardise cyber defence education for - EU member states. Coherent training and joint exercises will be key to create a mutual ~ culture of trust and understanding. Create a common Cyber Trust Fund for partner countries Today the EU and NATO work individually with their partner nations on cybersecuri- ty and defence programmes. But EU and NATO programmes could become more effi- cient if both institutions coordinate their assistance in order to create more synergy and avoid duplication. The EU and NATO could coordinate their assistance for partners around issues like technical cyber capabilities, information networks, and standards. A coordinated approach would also enable partners to more efficiently share with the EU and NATO their firsthand information, expertise, and experience. To complement or bundle the efforts of various EU or NATO assistance providers, an independent Cyber Trust Fund, supported by the EU and NATO, could be created. Access to the Trust Fund could be granted to EU Associated Countries or partner countries of the NATO Euro- Atlantic Partnership, Mediterranean Dialogue, Istanbul Cooperation Initiative and Global Partnerships. The management of EU-NATO donations and screening of project proposals could be managed by an independent private law foundation — for instance based on the model of the European Endowment for Democracy. The Trust Fund could address an important gap by focusing on the buildup of local and grassroot cyber skills and enable various stakeholders in partner nations to attend EU or NATO cyber courses, seminars, training sessions and conferences, or to organise similar types of activities in their homeland. The Trust Fund could adopt new approaches towards the develop- ment of local skills (government, corporate or civil society), for instance by requiring local partners to be involved in the project, and avoid situations where European or American contractors simply export their technology or knowhow to the partner na- tions. In this light, the Trust Fund could only support projects proposed by the partner nations, rather than copying the EU and NATO approach of pre-defining specifics for trust fund projects. The EU and NATO have worked together on financial assistance programmes in the past, such as the regular EU contributions to NATO trust funds for the disposal of unexploded ordnances, and anticorruption initiatives. In this light, the development of an independent EU-NATO Cyber Trust fund may not be such a far- fetched idea after all. Shape global norms around state behaviour in cyberspace To sustain global peace and security, much capacity to prevent irresponsible state be- haviour already exists in traditional domains such as nuclear, chemical or biological warfare. But the legal tools to stop governments across the world from engaging in malicious cyber activities are still limited. The lack of international agreement on rules regulating state behaviour in cyberspace or triggers for ‘digital self-defence’ com- plicates efforts to manage cross-border cyberthreats. As such, the EU and NATO, as two rather like-minded bodies with overlapping memberships, have the opportunity to shape their own common vision for responsible nation state behaviour in cyber- space and project it to the world stage. Today, the most significant platform to clarify the application of legal frameworks in cyberspace probably remains the UN General Assembly’s First Committee, which deals with disarmament and international security. In this context the EU and NATO should have a common dialogue on how they can assist the work done by the United Nations Group of Governmental Experts on Information Security (UNGGE) — a UN platform designed to debate the applicability of internation- al law in cyberspace. EU-NATO cooperation could also be used to advance ideas about transparency and accountability in cyberspace in other international platforms, from the G20 to the OECD or OSCE.” The current volatile geopolitical relations on cyber- ~ security between major powers such as Russia, China, the US or the EU, means that | finding global compromise around the rules of state behaviour in cyberspace remains : very much an open question. The EU and NATO have an opportunity here to lead the way and use their combined political weight to promote their ideas on this issue on the global stage. Adapting together The accelerating change of the digital age, and the challenges it brings, is placing new pressures on the traditional structures of intergovernmental organisations like the EU or NATO. It also highlights how these traditional structures can find it difficult to co- : ordinate with each other, even if the political will to do so is there. However, both the EU and NATO will continue to face threats emerging from cyberspace. For a long time, : ~ both found themselves ill-adapted to deal with this new reality, but change is on the horizon. And common responses are slowly but surely being developed to assert EU and NATO credibility in cyberspace in the eyes of their members, partners — and, in- deed, adversaries. Clearly, bold initiatives are needed. The EU and NATO must transit : from an agenda that strengthens their coordination, exchange and consultation mech- anisms, to initiatives that improve their joint force-multiplying functions, their cyber | ~ capabilities, their communication and decision-making structures in cyber exercises, crises and conflicts, and their interoperability with partners in cyberspace. EU-NATO : cooperation in cyberspace has taken its first small steps, but it will take a bigger leap ~ forward to adapt to a digital age that is constantly, and rapidly, evolving.