EU-NATO coop needed now – squo cyber relations are not enough.
Lete 19 [Bruno Lété currently serves as a transatlantic fellow, security and defense at The German Marshall Fund of the United States in Brussels. He provides analysis and advice on trends in geopolitics and on international security and defense policy. “THE EU AND NATO: the Essential Partners”. 2019. European Union Institute for Security Studies. https://drive.google.com/file/d/18Um8tOva0YQLiUGAjjzkkuUnIIXx-TGZ/view?usp=sharing. Accessed 6-22-2022; MJ]
The EU and NATO are targeted by the same cyber threat vectors that undermine all levels of society in member states, threatening civil, political, econom- ic and military security. The vast increase in the number of cyberattacks and the emergence of cyberspace as a new battlefield has motivated the EU and NATO to launch initiatives to strengthen their cyber resilience, and to increase their mutual consultations and coordination in the cyber domain. While the recent progress in EU- NATO cyber relations is commendable, this chapter nevertheless argues that the EU and NATO will eventually need to evolve from today’s coordinated approach to a more ambitious and integrated joint model of cooperation if they are to respond adequately to the security threats that shape today’s digital age. The first part of this chapter out- lines the history of EU-NATO cooperation in cyberspace. The second part highlights the present-day challenges that prevent a more ambitious EU-NATO cooperation agenda. The third part formulates concrete recommendations on how to move from a coordi- nated approach to a joint model for EU-NATO cooperation in cyberspace. EU and NATO responses to cyber insecurity Cybersecurity and defence have long been part of the EU and NATO calculus but it is only gradually that the issue moved to the top of their policy agendas.! The first game-changer for Europe came in 2007, when a series of coordinated cyberattacks on Estonia forced both institutions to think more seriously about this type of threat. With the aftermath of Estonia in mind, in 2008 NATO developed its very first Cyber Defence Policy. Five years later, in 2013, the EU followed suit by adopting its first ~ Cybersecurity Strategy. Another wake-up call for Europe came with the 2014 crisis in Ukraine. Russia’s an- | nexation of Crimea and semi-clandestine military actions in Donbass lent new urgency ~ to cyber defence and readiness because Russia’s hybrid aggression against Ukraine also - included sophisticated cyberattacks.? Since then, cybersecurity has loomed increasing- ly large in NATO and EU priorities and both institutions’ initiatives in the cyber domain ~ have increased exponentially. NATO endorsed an enhanced cyber defence policy and action plan in 2011, and it decided to operationalise cyberspace as a domain of defence policy and planning in 2016. That same year all Allies also made a Cyber Defence Pledge to enhance their cyber resilience as a matter of priority. At its last Brussels Summit in July 2018, the Alliance - also announced the creation of a new Cyberspace Operations Centre as part of NATO’s strengthened Command Structure. The EU for its part made the fight against cyber- crime one of the three pillars of the European Agenda on Security, and recognised cy- bersecurity as a priority for the 2016 Global Strategy for the European Union’s Foreign - and Security Policy. The same year the EU Directive on the Security of Network and ~ Information Systems introduced important legal measures to boost the overall lev- : el of cybersecurity in the EU. In addition, in 2017 Brussels adopted a ‘Cybersecurity - ~ Package’ including the revised Cybersecurity Strategy and the introduction of a Cyber : ~ Diplomacy Toolbox.> In November 2018 the EU also updated its 2014 Cyber Defence Policy Framework to strengthen European strategic autonomy in cyberspace. Finally, ' in May 2019, member states adopted a list of ‘EU cyber sanctions’ targeting individuals ~ or groups that engage in cyberattacks against the bloc. In this climate of urgency, the EU and NATO have started to see each other as com- plementary partners in the endeavour to build up their cyber resilience. In order to foster operational-level information sharing, NATO and the EU signed a Technical Arrangement on Cyber Defence in February 2016 between NATO’s Computer Incident Response Capability (NCIRC) and the EU’s Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT). The most significant step was made with the signing of two EU-NATO Joint Declarations, in July 2016 and in July 2018, that create a concrete framework for coop- eration in the sphere of security and defence. With regard to cyber, the implementation plan of the EU-NATO Joint Declarations recognises four areas of cooperation: integra- tion of cyber defence into missions and operations; training and education; exercises; and standards. A common set of new proposals was added in 2017 to foster exchange between staffs’ relevant good practices concerning the cyber aspects and implications of crisis management and response, as well as operational aspects of cyber defence, with a view to improving understanding and synergies between the EU and NATO.* Since neither organisation possesses the full range of capabilities to tackle contem- porary security challenges, there is a serious incentive for the EU and NATO to cooperate in times of crisis. And in the field of cybersecurity and defence the past few years have indeed brought significant change. The EU and NATO share many of the same priorities in cyberspace, their policies are largely identical — based on the principles of resilience, deterrence and defence — and their tools are becoming increasingly complementary. Active interaction in the field of cyber has significantly improved with exchanges be- tween staffs on concepts and doctrines, information on training and education courses, ad-hoc exchanges on threat assessments, cross-briefings, including on the cyber as- pects of crisis management and regular meetings, and featuring an annual high-level EU-NATO staff-to-staff dialogue.® Another concrete achievement is the fact that since 2017 the EU and NATO flagship crisis management exercises — respectively called EU PACE and NATO CMX - are being coordinated and held in parallel with options for mu- tual participation of EU and NATO staffs. Coordinating EU PACE and NATO CMX reflects the overall desire to develop more interaction between both organisations.