NATO-EU coop fails-- unresolved Cyprus-Turkey conflict and opposing institutional goals leave all projects in a deadlock.
Raik and Järvenpää ’17 (Dr Kristi Raik is the Director of the Estonian Foreign Policy Institute at ICDS since February 2018. She is also an Adjunct Professor at the University of Turku. Dr. Pauli Järvenpää, a former Finnish diplomat and a senior government official, joined International Centre for Defence and Security on 1 May 2013. As a Senior Research Fellow at ICDS, he focuses on the security of the Baltic Sea and Nordic region and on issues related to NATO, the EU and transatlantic cooperation, as well as on the security and development of Afghanistan. “A New Era of EU-NATO Cooperation How to Make the Best of a Marriage of Necessity,” International Centre for Defense and Security, May 2017, https://icds.ee/wp-content/uploads/2018/ICDS_Report_A_New_Era_of_EU-NATO.pdf)- HL
In spite of the promising start that created a solid framework for cooperation, by the early 2010s the EU-NATO relationship had produced very limited tangible results and was mired in structural obstacles. The main impediments, especially at the operational level, were created by the standoff between Cyprus and Turkey over the unresolved conflict on Cyprus. Furthermore, there was a tendency on both sides to see the relationship between NATO and the CSDP in terms of competition – even as a zero-sum game – which obviously did not encourage cooperation.21 Since its accession to the EU in 2004, Cyprus has put brakes on Turkey’s accession negotiations and blocked its participation in EUled missions, membership of the EDA and generally a more active role in CSDP. At the same time, Turkey has been able to block the use of NATO capabilities and assets by the EU and has not allowed the participation of the Republic of Cyprus, which it does not recognise, at formal EU-NATO meetings. Hence, meetings between the North Atlantic Council and the PSC have been held rarely (the latest took place in September 2015) and with a narrow agenda.22 This deadlock practically turned the Berlin Plus arrangements into a dead letter and 21. Drozdiak 2010. It should also be said that the Americans were not at that point particularly helpful. 22. In the 18 months to August 2015, four PSC-NAC meetings were organised: one formal meeting on EUFOR Operation Althea, two informal meetings on Ukraine, and one informal meeting on the eastern and southern neighbourhoods. See Dakic 2015. prevented more ambitious strategic cooperation. Berlin Plus arrangements have been used only for two operations: Operation Concordia in the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia (FYROM), which ended in September 2003, and EUFOR Operation Althea in Bosnia and Herzegovina, an operation deployed since 2004. While formal cooperation was limited, in practice a division of labour in crisis management took shape, roughly along the lines of soft/civilian and hard/military security. Although the CSDP was created to carry out both civilian and military crisis management tasks, the EU did not become the preferred instrument for more ambitious military operations. Member states limited the use of CSDP to softer, non-combat operations, whereas NATO took care of militarily more demanding environments and combat tasks. This division was evident in the two locations where both organisations had an operation running simultaneously: Kosovo and Afghanistan. Staff-level cooperation between the missions on the ground worked reasonably well, thanks to individual efforts to find flexible and creative ways to work around the formal obstacles.23 It was also a setback to the CSDP that EU Battlegroups were never deployed due to the lack of political will to actually use this new tool. One of the hurdles was the reluctance of member states to finance their deployment. As of today, discussions on improved usability and more effective financing of the Battlegroups continue, but the issue has been pushed down the list of priorities by new, more promising areas of defence cooperation, to be described below. Apart from the structural hurdles, the EU side was simply not very interested in close cooperation. The EU nurtured an ambition to be a different kind of international actor, described as a civilian, normative, ethical or soft power.24 This aspiration favoured taking a step back from NATO, characterised by many as a relic of the Cold War that was struggling to find a new purpose.25