Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Democratic backsliding undermines law

Wolkenstein 20[Fabio Wolkenstein is an Assistant Professor of "Transformations of Democracy" at the University of Vienna. I work on democratic theory, political parties, representation, ideologies, and the political theory of the EU. Previously I was Associate Professor of politics at Aarhus University and affiliated researcher in political theory, “Transnational Complicity in Democratic Backsliding”, Global Justice: Theory Practice Rhetoric, 12-2-20, https://www.theglobaljusticenetwork.org/index.php/gjn/article/view/206] SL

This leads to another question that must be clarified before moving on: why is democratic backsliding a form of wrongdoing? I have so far just postulated that democratic backsliding is a ‘wrong,’ and relied on readers’ intuitive agreement with this conjecture. But why exactly is it a wrong? The most straightforward answer, I suggest, is that Hungary and Poland violate their duty to obey EU law when they undermine democracy and the rule of law. That duty arises because both states have democratically ratified the EU treaties, thereby having accepted the treaties as (1) a framework for dealing with a specified range of issues and a source of normative demands on national institutional configurations.8 Of course, this is not the only answer that could be given to this question. It is probably possible to mount a more general case against democratic backsliding that shows that governments who undermine democracy and the rule of law engage in wrongdoing irrespective of which treaties they may have signed. This could be achieved by invoking a moral requirement that states ought to secure citizens’ public and private autonomy through well-functioning democratic and legal institutions.9 But though I am sympathetic to this line of reasoning, I simply lack the space to develop such an argument here. The more ‘legalistic’ (and possibly less controversial) argument from treaty-based obligations suffices for our purposes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.