Populists use nuclear weapons irresponsibly
Meier and Vieluf 21 [Oliver Meier is a senior Researcher at the Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy. Prior to this, he was Deputy Head in the International Security Division of the German Institute for International and Security Affairs. Maren Vieluf is a researcher at Institute for Peace Research and Security Policy. December 16, 2021, "Upsetting the nuclear order: how the rise of nationalist populism increases nuclear dangers", The Nonproliferation Review, https://doi.org/10.1080/10736700.2020.1864932] SL
Nationalist populists, by contrast, often speak loosely about nuclear weapons, which complicates a “reading” of their statements.52 This concerns both style and substance, which coincide with their personalistic style of leadership53 and their desire to flout the rules of what they deride as “political correctness.”54 Donald Trump has again led the way—for example, through his excessive tweeting on nuclear-weapon issues.55 Other nationalist populists have also deviated from previous rhetorical styles by bragging about their nuclear weapons. In April 2019, shortly after an escalation of the Pulwama crisis between India and Pakistan had been averted, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi suggested that his country was ready to use nuclear weapons against Pakistan: “Every other day they used to say ‘we have nuclear button, we have nuclear button’. What do we have then? Have we kept it for Diwali?”56 President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s October 2019 statement that it is unacceptable for Turkey not to have nuclear weapons because “[t]here is no developed nation in the world that doesn’t have them”57 is another typically populist statement, conflating strong views with half-truths or lies. Such loose talk may have several purposes. By emphasizing nuclear weapons, nationalist populists can set themselves apart from the established elite discourse. Donald Trump boasted of having gained knowledge of nuclear weapons not through a formal education but through his uncle, a professor of engineering at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.58 Thus, the US president believed that he did not need to rely on the expertise and experience of the nuclear elite. This ignorance of nuclear lessons by virtue of not “being socialized to the dangers of nuclear weapons”59 derived from the past is a trademark of nationalist populists, but is also part and parcel of a general loss of expertise in executives and parliaments in nuclear-weapon states and nuclear-allied countries.60 Nationalist populists also like to make strong statements on nuclear issues because they may believe that this impresses their main target audience—that is, their domestic power base. Thus, Putin has several times used his regular direct encounters with the Russian public to highlight the importance of nuclear weapons for Moscow’s standing in the world. In March 2018, Putin, in his speech to the Federal Assembly of Parliamentarians, policy makers, religious leaders, public figures, and members of the media, boasted about Russia’s nuclear capabilities and in true populist fashion even invited “[t]hose interested in military equipment … to suggest a name for this new weaponry, this cutting-edge” nuclear-weapon system.