Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Russia is an offensive realist that acts irrationally through force

Dayspring 15 [Chief Warrant Officer 4 Stephen Dayspring is a Special Forces Warrant Officer with 17 years of operational experience in 10th Special Forces Group (Airborne). He is currently completing a Master of Science in Defense Analysis at the Naval Postgraduate School in Monterey, California, “TOWARD A THEORY OF HYBRID WARFARE: THE RUSSIAN CONDUCT OF WAR DURING PEACE”, Naval Postgraduate School, December 2015, https://www.hsdl.org/?view&did=790442] SL

There are two traditions regarding the relationship between conflict and politics: realism and liberalism. “For the realist, the central problem of international politics is war and the use of force, and the central actors are states.”52 The realist is pragmatic in that he expects that others will try to take what he is unable to defend so he must demonstrate strength to ensure his sovereignty. By maximizing one’s own power, one minimizes the ability of other states to threaten one’s security.53 At a certain point however, the realist becomes strong enough that he begins considering what he might be able to take from a weaker neighbor. The “offensive realist” does not even think there is a choice; the only way he can better his odds of survival is to have more relative power than his potential enemies, a gulf he can widen by physically reducing his adversary’s strength.54 Realists see the contemporary international system as anarchic—there is no central or governing power- so the only things that enforce order are the individual states’ ability and willingness to fight to maintain the status quo. Neo-liberalism envisions “a global society that functions alongside the states and sets part of the context for the states.”56 Liberalism promotes the view not just of international governing bodies and legal restraint, but also that interdependent trade, monetary systems, and cross border communication have evolved into a transnational society where conflict is less likely. This is the essence of globalization, and is the preferred view of the world generally held in the West. Realists counter that there will always be a potential for a future state of war and one had better be ready to protect against it. Offensive realism is not a popular concept in the liberal-minded West because it tends to be at odds with our traditionally optimistic values.57 It is the difference in world view of relation power that explains why a country like Russia would suddenly seize Crimea, or why China would rapidly expand into its neighbors’ territorial waters. If a state views the world through the realist lens, specifically from the position of offensive realism, that state’s actions often appear irrational to liberal outsiders as those actions undermine the best interests of the international community. They appear much more pragmatic when they are seen to increase the relative power, and therefore the chances of survival, of the aggressor state. While this realist perspective might be depressing, “it behooves us to see the world as it is, not as we would like it to be.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.