Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No internal link --- the economy is not directly reflected in legitimacy --- ideology outweighs

Zeng, 16 – PhD in Politics and IR, Associate Fellow at the Centre for the Study of Globalisation and Regionalisation at the University of Warwick, and Lecturer in Politics and IR at Royal Holloway, University of London [Jinghan, “The Chinese Communist Party’s Capacity to Rule,” Oct 29, 2015 Palgrave Macmillan Critical Studies of the Asia-Pacific, Academia]

Economic performance is the most frequently mentioned element of performance legitimacy. The conventional wisdom of Western scholar- ship holds that economic achievement is a principal (if not the sole) pillar of legitimacy in contemporary China (Krugman, 2013; Laliberté and Lanteigne, 2008b; Perry, 2008; Shambaugh, 2001; Wang, 2005a; Wang, 2005b; Zhao, 2009; Yang and Zhao, 2014). In a major textbook on Chinese politics, Tony Saich (2004: 347) argues that “[CCP] legitimacy is currently based on the capacity to deliver the economic goods.” Economic performance is absolutely important. However, empirical studies show that while economic performance matters, there is no strong evidence to prove that it is the sole, let alone the principal, pillar of legitimacy (Chu, 2013; Lewis-Beck, et al., 2013; Munro, et al., 2013; Yang and Tang, 2013). In addition, if economic prosperity leads to high levels of popular support for the government, why do not other coun- tries that enjoy economic prosperity – such as India and Brazil – also have high levels of support, as China does (Tang, et al., 2013)? Based on a 2010 national survey in China, Dickson (2013) finds a negative rela- tionship between economic development and popular support. In addition to economic performance, social stability is another essen- tial element of government performance, and it has also been widely accepted as a fundamental pillar of the CCP’s legitimacy (Breslin, 2009; Dickson, 2011; Laliberté and Lanteigne, 2008b; Shue, 2004; Sandby- Thomas, 2011). Shue (2004), for example, argues that the CCP “stakes” its legitimacy on its ability to maintain social stability. Needless to say, social stability and economic growth are interdependent. Without a stable social order, the economy cannot grow rapidly; conversely the welfare materials delivered by economic growth might help to enhance social stability. This interdependence suggests that the rules of modern states are based on different combinations of legitimacy sources rather than on any one pillar. Legitimacy by nature has many dimensions, and its sources are often interrelated. Ideology in particular plays a crucial role in influ- encing other sources of legitimacy. Arguably, a fatal weakness of the performance legitimacy approach is its insufficient attention to ideo- logical factors. As mentioned, the mainstream approach overempha- sizes economic growth, and many assume that market reform has also rendered ideology obsolete. This misguided view has underestimated the role of ideology in contemporary China. Legitimacy generated from government performance is not directly through government performance per se but from citizens’ subjective perceptions of this performance. Ideological factors play a crucial role in shaping those perceptions. Thus, economic performance – crisis or growth – is not directly reflected in legitimacy (Gilley and Holbig, 2010); the performance will be framed by ideological factors and transformed by conductive ways into people’s subjective perceptions of economic performance. If economic performance became the sole legitimacy pillar in China, then economic deterioration would unavoidably lead to political crisis. However, the financial crisis of 2008 enhanced rather than weakened the CCP’s rule (Holbig, 2011). By using the Chinese media to highlight the good performance in coping with the financial crisis domestically and the disaster this crisis caused in other countries, the CCP managed to manipulate this debacle as an opportunity to gain legitimacy and achieve its political purposes – such as marketing its then-official ideology, the “Scientific Outlook of Development” (Holbig, 2011).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.