Biotechnology only works to reaffirm the power of commodities over individuals- it’s use to implement control over other countries as the ideology of imperialism is instead presented as a question of science and objectivity
Jasanoff ’06 (Sheila Jasanoff, Pforzheimer Professor of Science and Technology Studies at the Harvard Kennedy School, has authored more than 130 articles and chapters, founded and directs the security technology and sciences Program at Harvard, served on the AAAS Board of Directors and as President of the Society for Social Studies of Science, holds AB, JD, and PhD degrees from Harvard, and honorary doctorates from the Universities of Twente and Liège; 2006, “Biotechnology and Empire: The Global Power of Seeds and Science”, JSTOR, https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/507145?seq=1 DOA 6/25/22)//nm
Legibility Advertisements for agricultural biotechnology frequently show fields of grain laid out in neat parallel lines, illustrating both the fertility and the increased control that genetic modification can allegedly deliver. One could hardly find more compelling images of the “legibility” described by Scott. Intrusive weeds, barren patches, unruly growth have all been eliminated in favor of healthy, predictable, quantifiable yields— achieved through the precision of genetic control. However, just as the midcentury grand planners’ dreams of legibility were achieved at a cost, so legibility in modern GM agriculture demands unseen labors of standardization, and consequent elimination of ambiguity, to achieve its surface regularity. Four dimensions of standardization are worth noting: ontologies, epistemologies, socio-ecologies, and forms of life. All four maintain traditional relations of power between center and periphery, and all can be illustrated through the case of “golden rice,” the poster crop for a new generation of nutrient-enriched GM crops to feed the developing world.60 The name was given to a strain of rice bioengineered to produce beta-carotene, which colors the grain a pale gold; when ingested, it converts to vitamin A in the body and protects consumers against vitamin deficiency leading to possible blindness. For the products of GM agriculture to locate themselves securely in global markets, there has to be broad agreement on what these entities actually are. This ontological question may seem straightforward at first—proponents of golden rice, for instance, claim that it is nothing more than a more nutritious plant variety—but food crops straddle too many categorical boundaries for their identity in the political domain to be anything but hybrid. There are, to begin with, regulatory classifications. Should a crop engineered to produce ingredients of medicinal value be considered a food or a drug? Even if such issues can be settled by formal administrative definitions, the North-South debate surrounding GM crops shows how difficult it is to achieve ontological closure around a commodity that is at once a natural kind (a plant with specific genes and traits) and a social kind (a product of particular economic and political orderings, and a potential reorganizer of society).61 How one should know the properties of GM crops is similarly open to question. U.S. authorities have insisted that the only proper basis on which to evaluate the impacts of these novel entities is through science-based risk assessment. Yet, as the dispute between the United States and Europe at the WTO graphically illustrates, vast disagreements persist about the epistemological status of risk assessment. Is it a “science” at all, in the sense of being a well-demarcated, uncontroversial, paradigmatic (in a Kuhnian sense) method of representing the world; or is it instead a patently political and culturally constructed instrument for managing the uncertainties that inevitably accompany large projects of reconfiguring nature or society?62 To accept producers’ contention that crops such as golden rice are “safe,” one has to buy the former, not the latter, characterization. If, however, risk assessment is an expression of political culture by other means, then one should not be surprised if that form of analysis does not travel friction-free across political and cultural boundaries.63 GM crops are developed in the laboratory, usually in science-rich Western nations, tested in the field, and transported thence for commercial propagation in both naturally and socially variable environments. Monsanto, in this respect, is like the Kew Gardens of the nineteenth century: a metropolitan “center of calculation”64 from which standardized products flow out to take root in the world’s economic and political peripheries. Key to sustaining this mode of production is the assumption that socioecologies are as standard as the crops grown within them—put differently, that social and ecological circumstances at the periphery are not so radically different from those at the metropolitan center as to defeat the project of global technology transfer. Yet accidents occurring even within the boundaries of single nation-states show that transfers from the laboratory to the field can bring unpleasant surprises. For example, in one costly U.S. episode, ProdiGene, a GM corn variety containing an insulin precursor, trypsin,65 was planted in an unmarked field in rural Iowa. The manufacturer agreed with the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which approved the field trials, that the field would be quarantined the following year so as to remove any volunteer plants.66 In fact, the fields were not properly isolated and an undetermined quantity of the GM crop was harvested along with about 500,000 bushels of soybeans during the following season. Similar failures resulting from unforeseen couplings of technology, environment, and human behavior are all the more probable when transfers occur across disparate cultures of farming and of hazard control. Expanding on this point, it has become clear that complex technological systems are forms of life, uniting human and nonhuman components in a common purposive framework, as much as they are targeted attempts to improve upon aspects of human life by physical or biological means. Thus, transportation systems do not only move people about from place to place. They remake social structures and self-understandings. A car culture, for example, gives rise to different visions, and valuations, of time, distance, autonomy, community, environmental quality, and the cost of life than a culture dependent chiefly on bicycles or public transportation does. Similarly, industrial agriculture is organized and managed on different principles from small family farms; the two systems of production rest on different economic, social, and technological infrastructures, and their impacts on human solidarity and on the environment are correspondingly divergent. Conventional risk assessment methods take little or no account of the social and ethical ramifications of technological systems, including the threats they pose to long-settled patterns of living. This blindness to technology’s disruption of established forms of life, underwritten by the allegedly scientific power of risk assessment, has fueled much of the criticism of agricultural biotechnology in the global South.67 Identity and Community Empires, no less than nation-states, engender and depend on feelings of belonging. Devices for producing imperial imagined communities have included, besides the grand, polarizing, ideological discourses of the cold war, mundane practices such as performing national celebrations,68 teaching a common language, training administrative and judicial élites, and building infrastructures for commerce and communication. Science and technology, we have seen, have long served as agents of imperial governmentality, helping to produce the mission consciousness and the associated forms of knowledge and skill that serve as instruments for extending power. Modern biotechnology, similarly, provides a discourse of development that continues colonial traditions, although the agents, recipients, and specific mechanisms of the development project have been partially reconfigured in modern times. The discovery of Africa as a site for biotechnological development, through the propagation of crops such as golden rice, offers perhaps the clearest illustration. In the rhetoric of development specialists, and the scientific and industrial institutions that serve them, Africa is represented through tropes of crisis and charity that render the continent’s condition as dire and the offers of scientific and technological solutions as salvationary.69 In one instructive example, Gordon Conway, former president of the Rockefeller Foundation, and a colleague wrote an article in the prestigious journal Science on biotechnology’s capacity to help Africans. Though presented as scientific, the article merged the empiricist register of science with a narrative register that was little short of missionary. At the center of the discussion was a fictional African housewife, “Mrs. Namurunda,” who the authors said was not a real person but “a composite of situations existing in Africa.”70 The story begins with Mrs. Namurunda, a farmer and single mother, eking out a hard-scrabble existence on fields infested with every form of insect blight, under adverse conditions of drought and soil degradation. It ends with scientific biotechnology solving her problems, enabling her to turn a profit and secure a brighter, better educated, more enlightened future for her children. This script follows Foucault’s delineation of biopower with uncanny precision. An entire continent becomes a medicalized body, requiring urgent therapeutic intervention, both as a collective and for its individual members. The fictional person of Mrs. Namurunda, unveiled in the pages of one of the world’s leading scientific journals, becomes a symbol for Africa’s “composite” ailments. Advanced societies’ power to develop and deliver the requisite treatments offers them the right, indeed the obligation, to engage in a new mission civilisatrice—built on a biomedical ethic of cure rather than, as in earlier times, a religious model of grace. But, this time, eschewing the forceful, state-led constellations of power that undergirded colonial rule, the neoliberal state works through a lightly regulated global industry and a largely selfregulating scientific community. Their expansion into new territories carries the promise of better jobs and higher incomes back in the home country, thereby allowing the economically more powerful state to justify itself where votes are counted, in its own national community of citizens. The sick and incapacitated recipient, however, has little or no say in either the diagnosis or the treatment of the alleged pathology