Data collection is now a form of capital used to fuel digital capitalism
Sadowski 19, (Jathan Sadowski, Senior Research Fellow in the Emerging Technologies Research Lab // Department of Human Centred-Computing // Faculty of Information Technology // Monash University. January 7, 2019 “When data is capital: Datafication, accumulation, and extraction” Sadowski, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/2053951718820549)-Cayden Mayer
The goal of transforming everything into data and the search for new sources of data echoes imperialist modes of accumulation (Luxemburg, 1951; Thatcher et al., 2016). In short, as capitalism faces crises of accumulation, there is a need to find new sources of value and new places to offload goods. ‘Old strategies of accumulation are re-attempted in new spaces and new strategies are crafted through trial and error in the never-ending quest to surpass or displace the internal contradictions which lead to crisis’ (Greene and Joseph, 2015: 224). This could mean subjecting previously noncommodified and non-monetised parts of life to the logic of capitalism or colonising new territories so they are brought into the global capitalist web as sites of extraction (Moore, 2015). We can see this dynamic of ‘data colonialism’ when technology corporations like Facebook and Google move into territories like India and Africa (Thatcher et al., 2016). They do so under the guise of providing subsidised services that connect marginalised people to the Internet, yet the companies also benefit greatly by opening markets, locking people into their platforms, and tapping sources of data (Solon, 2017). These new places with new people provide new opportunities for data accumulation. The same imperialist tactics are being replayed now, but updated for the digital age. As we can see, this growing body of research on critical data studies (Dalton et al., 2016) has shown how the production, distribution, and use of data is situated within an emerging political economy that has wide-ranging implications across society: from the restructuring of cities and the state (Kitchin et al., 2015; Leszczynski, 2012), to the (re)development of electrical and computational infrastructure (Levenda et al., 2016; Pickren, 2018). Equipped with the findings of this literature, this paper can be seen as a call to go back to basics by further analysing foundational questions in the political economy of data: What is the economic form of data? How can value be derived from data? Importantly, these characteristics of data capital mean it can be continually captured and circulated, thus data collection is driven by the logic of capital accumulation as described by Marx. ‘The circulation of money as capital is an end in itself, for the valorization of value takes place only within this constantly renewed movement. The movement of capital is therefore limitless’ (Marx, 1990: 253). This unending accumulation of capital, represented by M-C-M0-C-M00-C-M-. . . , is a defining feature of capitalism. In digital capitalism, data is not a substitute for money, but is rather elevated and put ‘on the same level as financial capital,’ as a report by Oracle and MIT Technology Review Custom (2016: 2) states. The imperative, then, is to constantly collect and circulate data by producing commodities that create more data and building infrastructure to manage data. The stream of data must keep flowing and growing. Ultimately, continuing the cycle of data capital becomes an intrinsic motivation, a driving force, for firms. As Marx explains, ‘Use-values must therefore never be treated as the immediate aim of the capitalist; nor must the profit on any single transaction. His aim is rather the unceasing movement of profit-making’ (Marx, 1990: 254). The same can be said of data. The capitalist is not concerned with the immediate use of a data point or with any single collection, but rather the unceasing flow of data-creating. This point is illustrated by the fact that data is very often collected without specific uses in mind. Indeed, the practice of collecting data first and figuring it out later is increasingly a core part of how businesses and government bodies operate. ‘It does not matter that the amounts [of data] collected may vastly exceed a firm’s imaginative reach or analytic grasp. The assumption is that it will eventually be useful, i.e. valuable’ (Fourcade and Healy, 2017: 13). At a public talk in early 2017, Andrew Ng, an artificial 4 Big Data & Society intelligence researcher who has held top positions at Google, Baidu, and Coursera, was candid about this prevailing logic of data accumulation: ‘At large companies, sometimes we launch products not for the revenue, but for the data. We actually do that quite often ... and we monetize the data through a different product’ (Stanford Graduate School of Business, 2017). The conditions needed to convert data capital into economic capital may never arrive, but that does not stop the cycle of accumulation.