Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO is a tool for neolib expansion through free market reforms

Levytskyy ‘11

(Andriy Levytskyy, DePaul University college for Liberal Arts and Social Sciences; “Security misread: A critical analysis of Ukraine's debate on NATO”, DePaul University, 11/11, DOA 6/21/22)//nm

NATO as a Dutiful Agent of Neoliberalism While the IMF and World Bank have been the most powerful advocates of neoliberal reforms in the developing world over the last three decades, NATO, WTO and the European Central Bank joined the race to spread neoliberalism shortly after the collapse of the communist regimes in Eastern Europe. If Central and Eastern Europe‟s integration into the Western Alliance‟s institutional framework was recently accomplished and consolidated, Ukraine‟s reorientation has attained an advanced stage in the economic and political spheres. Rachel Epstein argues that international institutions have had a significant influence on post communist countries which have set themselves on a free market reform trajectory.405 According to Epsein, the liberal, or as I call it neoliberal, worldview that currently prevails in the minds of political and economic elites of Eastern and Central Europe is supported “by a perception of where authority is grounded.” 406 For most parts of Eastern and Central Europe, the transition to political pluralism and free market enterprise “has been marked by a shift from domestic sources of authority, such as historical experience and nationalist striving to international sources of authority, such as the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, the European Union, and the Bretton Woods institutions.”407 Epstein‟s claim that “Domestic actors view international institutions as authoritative sources of information and, as a consequence, seek their approbation,” is very persuasive.408 International institutions not only exercise power over policymaking elites and consequently determine an international orientation of states, they also influence the “domestic balance of power among groups in society.” 409 International institutions, whose main priority is to develop new policy programs, persuade and shape the actions of domestic actors and should be viewed as active agents of domestic and global change.410 While I realize that a number of different theoretical approaches can be relevant for the evaluation of the role of the state in today‟s internationalized world and extremely useful for our understanding of how international institutions and regimes can transform political dynamics, this section attempts only to highlight the point that international organizations have promoted consensus around the neoliberal policy manifestations in the countries undergoing transition. More important, the point is that multilateral institutions play a key role in regional and global processes of monitoring and implementation of free market-oriented knowledge structure while disciplining alternative knowledge, ideas, policy options, and practices. As previously mentioned, for Ukraine, Euro-Atlantic integration means not only being a member of collective security system, but fostering of economic development through a neoliberal political and constitutional framework. If for Walt, Ukraine‟s participation in the transatlantic cooperative security arrangement can increase the state‟s strength in relation to Russia and enhance its regional influence, according to Brett Leed‟s and Andrew Long‟s hypothesis, Euro-Atlantic integration means more for Ukraine than just being an associate of military organization.411 Leeds and Long assert that military allies unconditionally have positive economic consequences, and members of the collective security system are expected to facilitate economic growth, development and trade.412 For scholars, the security externality and the reaction of commercial institutions are the main motives and explanations for intensive engagement in mercantilism. Leeds and Long conclude that “When firms feel secure that conflict between their state and that of their trading partners is unlikely to occur and that the states will work together to promote commerce between their respective businesses, they are more likely to invest in trade.”413 As determined by the liberalist theoretical perspective of international relations, Ukraine‟s membership in NATO will provide a well-balanced and secure framework for regional and international economic activity, and thereby will encourage close trading relationships and reassure the international community that economic cooperation remains safe. Namely, the liberal view with its ideas of complex interdependence and functionalism ascribes to NATO a crucial role in driving states to collaborate in a much more widespread way than they had done before. Liberal explanations for the incorporation of Ukraine into NATO derive from the idea that all states are bound to benefit from interdependency and cooperation. This argument stresses that while NATO reduces the threat for nascent democracies and thereby promotes and extends the liberal community, the Alliance also continues to play a security role. Liberal scholars see NATO as one of many multilateral mechanisms to promote security and transnational cooperation through reinforcing democracy and free market economies. In fact, my point is that the only arguments which demonstrate security advantages for Ukraine joining NATO seem to rely more on particular Wilsonian liberal internationalism or constructivist notions about the constitutive role of alliances rather than realist conventional wisdom. According to Epstein, countries who are not even members of the Alliance yet, but have joined the path to its membership, already demonstrate their devotion to Western political and economic models. Through the Partnership for Peace, a program directed at creating trust between NATO and non-members, a process of denationalization of defense planning and foreign policy in majority of countries of Eastern and Central Europe has already taken place.414 Furthermore, while the partnership commits to extend defense cooperation between a non-member state and the Alliance, it pushes a cooperative non-member state to transform power relations from an executive-led model to a model of democratic civil-military relations.415 One of the main focuses of NATO has always been the establishment of “a system of check and balances in which the executive, government, parliament, and society, through the media and nongovernmental organizations would share in oversight.”416 Moreover, particular transformations in defense will not only lead to further distributional consequences, but signify a transformation of “previously contested ideas into commonly held assumptions.”417 It follows, therefore that NATO uses its membership requirements not only to regulate the behavior of societies, but also to define new tasks, create new categories of actors and shape social reality in ways that favor a market-oriented approach. Alexandra Gheciu‟s book NATO in the “New Europe” The Politics of International Socialization After the Cold War is an analytical examination of NATO‟s role in building of construction of Western liberal norms and practices in former Communist states. While analyzing the practices of NATO in Eastern and Central Europe, Gheciu argues that NATO has been deeply involved in socializing “Central and Eastern European political, military, and functional elites into adopting Western-defined liberal democratic norms and building corresponding institutions in their states.”418 Through NATO‟s involvement in the numerous processes of domestic politics, the organization has “played an important role in post-Communist efforts in Central and Eastern Europe to (re) draw boundaries between reasonable/unacceptable definitions of national identity and interests”419 While Gheciu unifies a great number of arguments that are useful for my study, the claim that NATO has been deeply engaged in a relatively broad set of activities aimed at projection of a particular kind of liberal state identity in Central and Eastern Europe, “while simultaneously rejecting alternative norms and institutions as inherently flawed” is important. 420

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.