The 1AC’s claims of Russia as a security threat are means of legitimizing neoliberal power
Levytskyy ‘11
(Andriy Levytskyy, DePaul University college for Liberal Arts and Social Sciences; “Security misread: A critical analysis of Ukraine's debate on NATO”, DePaul University, 11/11, DOA 6/21/22)//nm
The Russian perception of the Atlantic Alliance and its enlargement elicits an antagonistic reaction from Moscow and is an important factor in Ukraine‟s desire to join NATO. In the minds of the Russian political elite as well as the average Russian, the prospect of a new wave of NATO expansion to include Ukraine indicates a “continuation of the policy aimed at pushing Russia out of its traditional spheres of influence, and a move that signifies Russia‟s encirclement with international protectorates or mandate territories of a Bosnia-Kosovo type.”117 For Russia, on the basis of the historical assumptions, the process of NATO‟s eastward enlargement seems to be motivated by the Western intentions to exploit Russia‟s weakness and should not be viewed as a peaceful process. In fact, a strong opposition to the idea of Ukrainian membership in NATO and the Alliance‟s continuous expansion all the way to Russia‟s borders is a clear sign of NATO‟s dismissal of Russian interests, and therefore evokes a harsh reaction from the Russian political establishment. If the inclusion of three Baltic countries heightened Russia‟s sense of isolation, the Ukrainian accession to NATO, according to the average Russian, would be decisive evidence of Western attempts to isolate and subordinate Russians at the same time.118 The point is that while Western World perhaps views NATO as being transformed into a political organization, in Russia, the Alliance is considered in purely military terms. From the Russian perspective, plans to incorporate Ukraine into the Western military alliance along with the American proposal to deploy anti-ballistic missile (ABM) components in Eastern Europe are grounded on realist reasoning and are targeted against Russia, regardless of whether there is an authoritarian or democratic form of government. Western behavior has been interpreted as aggressive, and an extension of NATO‟s influence as a threat to Russia‟s security Within Russian society it is generally accepted that the process of NATO enlargement is connected to Western perceptions of Russia as being a potential enemy.119 Such an assumption is based on anti-Russian opinions, prevalent mostly in the United States and Eastern Europe, which are rooted in the past dating back hundreds of years, and which since the end of the Cold War have continued to be full of hostility.120 The growth of Russia‟s defense spending, its attempts to preserve its traditional sphere of influence and its elimination of domestic opposition have contributed to an image of Russia as a potential threat. This view of Russia as a source of danger was recently reinforced by the depiction of war in Georgia by the Western mass-media. While rejecting Georgia‟s role in starting the conflict along with ignoring the importance of the U.S. material support to Saakashvili's regime, Western journalists, according to historian Herbert Bix, “Fostered Russophobic sentiment by disseminating completely one-sided war news, demonizing Russia as the evil aggressor, and championing „democratic‟, peace-loving Georgia.”121 While realizing that it is not possible to completely grasp the objectivity and being willing to adjust myself to the relativity of truth claims, I tend to agree with this viewpoint. Moreover, this debate clearly demonstrates how power relations contribute to the formation of certain knowledge and leads to conclude that perceptions play a critical role in the issue of Ukraine‟s incorporation into NATO. As seen from Moscow, a new round of hostility towards Russia clearly confirms that the West‟s struggle against communism and the Soviet Union had not ideological, but exclusively geopolitical meaning. This viewpoint finds its support in different schools of thought regarding the strategic geopolitical importance of the area of the former Soviet bloc precisely to the United States. Nevertheless, to provide a clear and a strong explanation for NATO‟s engagement with the countries of the former Soviet Union, it is necessary to refer to the geopolitical views of one of the prominent advocates of NATO‟s membership for Ukraine which is motivated by the resentment toward Russia. Zbigniew Brzezinski, former national security advisor in the Carter administration, has portrayed Russia‟s exercise of its influence on neighboring states as a extension of uncivilized and “proto-imperial approach”, and has argued for the adoption of the Western policy of “geopolitical pluralism” that should seek as its primary objective to guarantee that Russia would not become a “mighty supranational state and a truly global power.”122 According to Brzezinski, the political, military and economic integration of the newly independent states of Central and Eastern Europe should be a basic strategy of the Western geopolitical approach.123 Furthermore, in terms of Russian-Ukrainian relations, Brzezinski confirms this mode of thinking by arguing that “Without Ukraine, Russia ceases to be an empire, but with Ukraine suborned and then subordinated, Russia automatically becomes an empire.”124 Therefore, as it can be seen from this realist analysis of the role and place of once-Soviet states in Europe, it is clear that NATO‟s engagement with Ukraine is a part of a broader policy directed to oppose Russian interests in the region. Unfortunately, being great supporters of Ukraine‟s NATO membership, the majority of Western thinkers and policymakers such as Brzezinski simply ignores both the real interests of ordinary Ukrainians and their everyday reality and has been consciously pushing Ukraine into a culturally driven conflict with Russia.125