Centering a critical reading of imperialism is key to unite theory and praxis- it moves analysis beyond the nation-state and gives us the tools needed to carve out spaces of resistance
Anthony Pahnke in 2021
Associate Professor of International Relations at San Francisco State University; Regrounding Critical Theory: Lenin on Imperialism, Nationalism, and Strategy; International Studies Review, Volume 23, Issue 1, March 2021, Pages 181–203; https://academic.oup.com/isr/article/23/1/181/5850500
The argument put forward in this article is that we need to recapture key elements from the Critical Theoretic tradition—namely, a concern with strategy—to explore the nature of emancipation in our current historical moment. I agree with others who recognize the indispensable place of First Generation Frankfurt School thinkers in this tradition (Yalvaç 2015), yet also see the need to recognize that the Critical Theoretic project predates their work. Marx and Engels, for example, are integral, for not only providing concepts to analyze social relations, but also for intervening into affairs in ways similar to some ethnographers (Murphy 2007, 131–132). Marx's often referenced eleventh thesis on Feuerbach—philosophers have only interpreted the world, in various ways; the point is to change it—includes a proviso that sits at the center of work on emancipation. Specifically, contemplation is insufficient for changing social relations. Emancipation, in following Fraser's understanding of the concept, is rooted in ambivalent claims of social movements to “erode” some form of domination in favor of transformation (2013). Ambivalence combines with transformation because there are no guarantees when seeking emancipation—collective efforts to fundamentally alter social relations may end in defeat or reversal. Kevin Anderson recognizes such qualities in Lenin's efforts to connect theoretic work with practical activity, leading him to state that the Russian Revolutionary deserves greater attention in the Critical Theory tradition (1995).¶ My central argument, in building from Anderson's comment, foregrounds Lenin's work as a way to reground Critical Theory. The reason I turn to Lenin is analogous to Fraser's concern that we cannot reckon with our many crises—political, economic, and environmental—with the received thinking from the regularly cited Critical Theorists (2017). Yet, where Fraser turns to Polanyi, I propose calling upon Lenin, with special attention to his theorization of and political practice concerning imperialism. His multi-dimensional work around the concept, from writing theoretical texts and pamphlets, to organizing conferences and events (e.g., The Third Communist International, or Comintern), provides a way to reconsider the Critical Theoretic tradition within International Relations. Intrinsic to Lenin's work, as I argue, is a way to conceive of strategy. This concept, which speaks to Marxist discussions of praxis, ties abstract theorizing to political and economic analysis, as well as to movement building projects. Critical Theory of the Frankfurt School variety and after has moved steadily away from discussions of strategy to the promotion of dialogue. This tendency represents depoliticization, which as Schmitt described, elevates neutrality and privacy as values ([2008] 1929, 89–90). This development also characterizes some seemingly radical endorsements of civil society.¶ This article contains five parts. In the first and the second, I detail the Theory of Communicative Action, featuring Habermas and Honneth, while also including the work of some International Relations theorists. I argue that this popular current of thought in the discipline depoliticizes Critical Theory by neglecting strategic considerations on internationalism, while also reifying the state/society divide. Section 3 focuses on the research of Cox and Ashley, as well as others, locating the presence of a more internationalist and engaged political sensibility within Critical Theory when compared to the proponents of Habermas’ discourse ethics. Still, these works feature flawed assumptions pertaining to civil society and political engagement. The fourth section introduces Lenin's thought as a way to address these concerns, particularly his work on imperialism. I offer a political reading of his work—both the famous pamphlet, as well as his extensive notebooks on the concept—detailing his preoccupation with organizers, intellectuals, and movements. I return to how nationalism connects to liberation in the fourth and fifth sections. Lenin's dual understanding of nationalism—as potentially a conservative force and an emancipatory one—moves us beyond taking the nation as the principal unit of politics. I do not argue for rejecting nationalism as a collective political project, but with Lenin's insights, show how such movements can bridge with more emancipatory struggles. Ultimately, Lenin pushes discussions of emancipation into moving beyond the state and the nation.