Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Thayer is wrong – evolutionary biology’s relation to realism is premised on false notions of warfare and warrantless

Lebow, PhD, 13

(Richard Ned Lebow is a fellow of the British Academy is an American political scientist best known for his work in international relations, political psychology, classics and philosophy of science. He is Professor of International Political Theory at the Department of War Studies, King's College London, Bye-Fellow of Pembroke College, University of Cambridge, and James O. Freedman Presidential Professor Emeritus at Dartmouth College, you can’t keep a bad idea down: Evolutionary biology and international relations, 8-14, Palgrave Macmillan UK // NC)

Thayer’s thesis is flawed at every stage of its construction. It rests on the assumption that offensive realism is an accurate depiction of international relations rather than an ideology without much empirical support. The same might be said for hegemonic stability theory, a justification for the American imperial project that is empirically problematic. Thayer insists that these approaches to international relations are successful because they build on correct assumptions about human nature. There is no discussion whatsoever of efforts to reduce war and ethnic conflict through conflict resolution, institution building, development and humanitarian intervention. They are presumably in conflict with our nature and doomed to failure. Thayer’s arbitrary choice of what is human and what is not is offered without any evidence, as is his claim that war as the most important of all human activities affecting evolution. We are given no mechanisms that would account for the increase in brain capacity warfare that is said to stimulate. Successful warriors are assumed to breed more successfully, another claim unsupported by evidence. We must assume that group advantages, conferred by individual characteristics such as aggression, bravery and loyalty, are somehow passed on through warrior genes and that natural selection does this rest. At the outset, Thayer claims that his approach is both scientific and readily falsifiable. I think we must accept the latter claim. A final word about warfare. Thayer barrages us with evidence about its near universality but offers no nuanced discussion of its diverse causes or roles it serves for societies. He assumes a single materialist motive: the protection of resources or the acquisition of additional ones. There is no recognition of the role of honor, standing, revenge, or war as a route of upward mobility, source of group cohesion or simply an adventure. Thayer weds a crude model of biology to a crude realist one of war and international relations.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.