States’ tendencies towards aggression and selfishness are derived from the evolutionary need to maintain dominance hierarchies
Thayer, PhD, 4
(Bradley A., Department of Political Science and Geography at UT San Antonio. Darwin and International Relations : On the Evolutionary Origins of War and Ethnic Conflict, University Press of Kentucky, 2004. ProQuest Ebook Central,
Evolutionary theory can also explain domination. Like egoism, the desire to dominate is a trait. In the context of evolutionary theory, domination usually means that particular individuals in social groups have regular priority of access to resources in competitive situations. For most social mammals, a form of social organization called a dominance hierarchy operates most of the time. The creation of the dominance hierarchy may be violent and is almost always competitive. A single leader, almost always male (the alpha male), leads the group. The ubiquity of this social ordering strongly suggests that such a pattern of organization contributes to fitness. Ethologists categorize two principal types of behavior among social mammals in a dominance hierarchy: dominant and submissive.56 Dominant mammals have enhanced access to mates, food, and territory, increasing their chances of reproductive success.57 Acquiring dominant status usually requires aggression.58 Dominance, however, is an unstable condition; to maintain it, dominant individuals must be willing to defend their privileged access to available resources as long as they are able. Evolutionary anthropologist Richard Wrangham and ethologist Dale Peterson explain why an individual animal is motivated to vie for dominant status: "The motivation of a male chimpanzee who challenges another's rank is not that he foresees more matings or better food or a longer life."59 Rather, "those rewards explain why ... selection has favored the desire for power, but the immediate reason he vies for status ... is simply to dominate his peers."60 Dominant animals often assume behavior reflecting their status. For example, dominant wolves and rhesus monkeys hold their tails higher than other members of their group in an effort to communicate dominance. A dominant animal that engages in such displays is better off if it can gain priority of access to resources without having to fight for it continuously.61 Such signaling behavior is found among submissive social mammals as well. They often try to be as inconspicuous as possible and recognize what is permitted and forbidden given their place in the hierarchy. This behavior shows that the subordinate accepts its place in the dominance hierarchy and-at least temporarily-will make no effort to challenge the dominant animal. Ethologists argue that dominance hierarchies evolve because they help defend against predators, promote the harvesting of resources, and reduce intragroup conflict.62 A species that lives communally has two choices. It can either accept organization with some centralization of power, or engage in perpetual conflict over scarce resources, which may result in serious injury and deprive the group of the benefits of a communal existence, such as more efficient resource harvesting.63 Ethological studies have confirmed that a hierarchical dominance system within a primate band minimizes overt aggression and that group aggression often increases when the alpha male is challenged.64 For primates and especially humans, the dominance hierarchy may have produced a fortuitous result: great intelligence.65 As cognitive psychologist Denise Dellarosa Cummins argues, it has had a profound effect on human evolution: "The fundamental components of our reasoning architecture evolved in response to pressures to reason about dominance hierarchies, the social organization that characterizes most social mammals."66 Her study and others have found that dominance hierarchies have contributed to the evolution of the mind, which in turn has contributed to fitness. According to Cummins, submissive individuals can detect, exploit, and circumvent the constraints of domination. If an animal can take what it wants by force, it is sure to dominate the available resources-unless its subordinates are smart enough to outwit it. To survive, a subordinate must use other strategies: deception, guile, appeasement, bartering, alliance formation, or friendship. Thus intelligence is particularly important to the survival of subordinates. "The evolution of mind emerges," Cummins writes, "as a strategic arms race in which the weaponry is ever-increasing mental capacity to represent and manipulate internal representations of the minds of others."67 From their studies of chimpanzee societies, ethologists have learned that the struggle for survival is best characterized as a struggle between those who are dominant and those seeking to outwit them, i.e., between recognizing an opponent's intentions and hiding one's own. The following example illustrates how a subordinate chimpanzee, Belle, who knows the location of hidden food, attempts to deceive Rock, who is dominant: Belle accordingly stopped uncovering the food if Rock was close. She sat on it until Rock left. Rock, however, soon learned this, and when she sat in one place for more than a few seconds, he came over, shoved her aside, searched her sitting place, and got the food. Belle next stopped going all the way [to the food]. Rock, however, countered by steadily expanding the area of his search through the grass near where Belle had sat. Eventually, Belle sat farther and farther away, waiting until Rock looked in the opposite direction before she moved toward the food at all, and Rock in turn seemed to look away until Belle started to move somewhere. On some occasions Rock started to wander off, only to wheel around suddenly precisely as Belle was about to uncover some food .... On a few trials, she actually started off a trail by leading the group in the opposite direction from the food, and then, while Rock was engaged in his search, she doubled back rapidly and got some food. 68 Despite the "arms race" described by Cummins to outwit dominance, the subordinate members of the group continue to participate in the dominance hierarchy because doing so increases the chances of survival. As ethologist David Barash explains, if subordinates "are more fit by accepting" subordinate "ranking than by refusing to participate, then some form of social dominance hierarchy will result."69 Humans and other primates evolved a mental architecture to address the difficulties they encountered in dominance hierarchies. These problems, which "directly impact survival rates and reproductive success," include two crucial needs: "the necessity to recognize and respond appropriately to permissions, obligations, and prohibition," and the necessity "to circumvent the constraints of hierarchy by dint of guile, particularly through successfully forecasting others' behavior. "70 Because human mental architecture was created through evolution, it remains part of human behavior today, as cognitive psychology studies show. 71