Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The 1AC’s focus on violence as the event of war recreates everyday forms of violence

Wibben 19

Annick T.R., Professor of Gender, Peace & Security at the Swedish Defence University. “Everyday Security, Feminism, and the Continuum of Violence.” Journal of Global Security Studies. 2019. LJS

Innovative work on global security issues comes not just from different traditions within security studies (global or not), but by talking across fields of study. This might include engaging peace and conflict studies, geography, anthropology, and more. Feminist security studies (FSS) is a case in point: whereas it is often read as a subfield or particular approach within security studies, it was certainly not conceived as such since “feminist aims and the scope of their concerns explodes its confines at every possible turn” (Wibben 2011, 113; see also Sjoberg and Lobasz 2011; Shepherd 2013; Elias and Roberts 2015; Chisholm and Stachowitsch 2017). From the outset of feminist engagements with global politics, security issues were a key concern—whether in the 1980s when feminist international relations (IR) scholars began to make their mark on the field (see Wibben 2017 for an overview of FSS) or in their much earlier engagements in attempt to first prevent World War I and, later, to mitigate its effects (see, e.g., Confortini 2012; Owens 2018; Tickner and True 2018). Feminist scholars would maintain that gendered (security) relations, while instantiated differently across the globe and over time, could fulfill Jon Western’s (2016, 100) litmus test for being both global in scale, “worldwide in either cause or effect,” and global in reach, though “their impact is usually local or regional.” Hence, traditional security scholars ignore gender relations and feminist scholarship and uncover their role in relation to security studies at their own peril—traditional security scholars are, as Cynthia Enloe (e.g., 2015) would formulate it, not being particularly realistic. Paying attention to gendered (security) relations often involves moving beyond states, even as state practices are also deeply gendered (Peterson 1992; Parashar, Tickner, and True 2018). Consequently, the space provided by journals such as JoGSS is crucial to push the conversation forward. Of course, many critical security scholars have long questioned the state as the primary referent object of security studies: debates about broadening and deepening security in the 1990s (see, e.g., Lipschutz 1995; Krause and Williams 1997) opened up conversations about the study of security as fundamentally a political project (Wibben 2016a), thus making room for scholars to look not just at individual and human security, but everyday and vernacular security as well (VaughanWilliams and Stevens 2016; see also Benzig, this issue). At the same time, feminist scholars in a variety of disciplinary traditions also increasingly started to frame their conversations about peace, violence, and the war system in terms of security (e.g., Tickner 1992; Reardon 1993). Noting that, “until women have control over their own security, a truly comprehensive system of security cannot be devised” (Tickner 1992, 30), feminist scholars tend to pay close attention to the impact of security policies on the everyday lives of people (see, e.g., Sylvester, 2011, 2013; Wibben 2016b; Gentry, Shepherd, and Sjoberg 2018; Ní Aoláin et al. 2018). Departing from a large part of traditional security studies research, feminist scholars challenge common sense notions that wars are fought to protect vulnerable populations and show that civilians are, especially in ethno-nationalist wars, explicitly targeted (Enloe 1998; Hansen 2000, 2001, 2006; Carpenter 2005; McLeod 2016). Rather than offering security for all their citizens, states may threaten their own populations through direct or structural violence reflected in war-fighting priorities embedded in a variety of state institutions (Reardon 1985; Peterson 1992; Tickner 1992; Enloe 1993, 2000; Young 2003). Feminists contribute to debates about the increasing import of sophisticated technologies into the practice of war, from nuclear strategy to drones, which asserts that it depersonalizes killing, offers the illusion of clean warfare, and obscures accountability (Cohn 1987; Masters 2005; Wilcox 2015; Bayard de Volo 2016; Clark 2018). Some scholars also directly engage traditional theories of security (Sjoberg 2010, 2013; Wibben 2011; Detraz 2012) and security policy (Stachowitsch 2012; MacKenzie 2015). An ever-increasing amount of research looks at the impact of UN Security Council Resolution 1325 and subsequent resolutions (Shepherd 2008; Gizelis and Olsson 2015; McLeod 2016), as well as efforts to address sexualized violence in war (Eriksson Baaz and Stern 2013; Cohen 2016). Other scholars have made important contributions to the study of private military companies from a feminist perspective (Stachowitsch 2012; Eichler 2015). While many traditional sciences assume gender neutrality, feminists make gender, that is, the socially constructed femininity/masculinity distinction that shapes our perception of, and response to, the world, a central category of analysis. They are concerned, above all, with gendered power relations and also note how they are molded by intersecting axes of oppression (Collins 2000). Consequently, feminist scholars argue that concepts and ideas about security, as well as security practices and institutions, are shaped by gender: gender (along with class, caste, race, sexuality and more) structures the hierarchies that dictate what and who is taken seriously. To analyze these power relations, feminist security studies “includes approaches, for instance, that pay attention to the workings of gender in order to ask questions about security; it also includes scholarship that refuses any line of distinction that separates ‘security’ from the workings of gender” (Stern and Wibben 2014, 2). Journals such as the International Feminist Journal of Politics and Security Dialogue as well as, more recently, Critical Military Studies and Critical Studies on Security have published excellent work in this area, which should be included in more global security syllabi. This past year brought us two new handbooks on gender and conflict/security (Gentry, Shepherd, and Sjoberg 2018; Ní Aolaín et al. 2018), joining previous efforts to provide an overview of the field (e.g., Detraz 2012). A key theoretical contribution feminist peace and conflict studies scholars have made to feminist understandings of security is the notion of a continuum of violence between peace and wartime that also transgresses the boundaries of private/public and international/domestic realms (see, e.g., Moser 2001; Cockburn 2004). Violence against women, as feminist scholars have pointed out with increasing frequency, is part of a multidimensional continuum of violence (Cockburn 2004; see also O’Rourke 2013; Pratt and Richter–Devroe 2014) that “extends from violence in the home, to the structural violence of poverty, to the ecological violence associated with the depletion of our planetary resources and natural disasters, to the violence of war and its aftermath” (True 2012, 5; see also Tickner 2001). Working with these notions, and paying attention to gendered (and intersecting) power hierarchies, has allowed feminist scholars to note important continuities from the pre- through the postwar environment (Jacobs, Jacobsen, and Marchbank 2000; Meintjes, Pillay, and Turshen 2001; Moser and Clark 2001; Giles and Hyndman 2004; Cohn 2013). For example, as Henshaw also notes in this issue, existing societal expectations about gender roles shape not only women’s positions during wartime, but also significantly mold war’s aftermaths. Importantly, while there are always conflicting notions of femininity, the way in which gender roles (for women, men and trans*, given that gender is a relational category where changes always affect the full spectrum) change during and after wars is not straightforward. While the disruption of violent conflict offers new openings, for example, for women to take on roles as combatants or new positions in the formal economy, it simultaneously can lead to greater scrutiny of their activities, such as their sexual relations (Sylvester 1993; Pettman 1996; Ahäll 2015 ˚ ; Gentry and Sjoberg 2015). Literature is accumulating regarding women’s participation in fighting forces (e.g., Stiehm 1996; Alison 2009; MacKenzie 2012; Sylvester 2013; Parashar 2014; Gentry and Sjoberg 2015; Henshaw 2017; Vastapuu 2018), which provides manifold insights into the ways in which these venues of participation in war are shaped not just by gendered expectations, which influence whether women take on only support or also combat roles, but also by age, race, class, indigeneity, and more. Leena Vastapuu’s (2018) study of disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration (DDR) processes in Liberia is a case in point: she examined how young women, who were fairly empowered during their time in the fighting forces despite their often traumatic entry into this life, found the aftermath difficult to navigate. Paying attention not just to gender, but also to social status (class) and differences in rural and urban locations, provides for greater insight into everyday (in)securities and the need to account for these in interventions by the international community. What we learn from Vastapuu (2018), and what other scholars have also described (MacKenzie 2012; Mazurana and Cole 2013; Basini 2016; Mazurana, Krystalli, and Baaré 2018; Henshaw, this issue), is that peace negotiations and settlements that structure war’s aftermaths leave much to be desired when examined from a feminist perspective. Crucially, a focus on armed actors in violent conflicts often exclude women from the negotiating table to begin with. What is more, if little attention is paid to gender and its intersections with class or race, “peace” tends to imply a “return” to prewar societal relations (which can reinforce societal exclusion as Benzig notes in this issue), or, worse, it may institute new fundamentalisms. This postwar gender anxiety, as Henshaw (this issue) calls it, can have dire consequences for women who took on varied new roles during the violent conflict. At the same time, it has proven impossible to put the genie back in the bottle in its entirety, so to speak: many women will refuse to return to their old roles in postwar societies (Berry and Rana 2019). Indeed, permanent shifts in societal norms can be expected. Paying attention to these conflicts at the everyday, microlevel is important to understand complex contemporary global phenomena such as the ability of extremist movements to recruit young men to enact violence as a way of (re)asserting their masculinity in the face of (perceived or actual) threats to their traditional livelihoods (Parpart and Zalewski 2008; Kimmel 2018). Deeply contextual historical case studies by area experts, which are a traditional strength of feminist scholarship, are needed to most accurately assess specific security environments, as Emy Matesan (this issue) shows in relation to Islamist movements (for a feminist take, see Brown 2011, 2018; Eggert 2016). This kind of research requires the inclusion and, indeed, promotion of a variety of methods (see also Fiona Adamson, this issue) to capture the experiences of people from all walks of life in order to name, as well as challenge, the long colonial histories of their grievances (Chowdry and Nair 2004; Agathangelou and Ling 2009; Tuhiwai-Smith 2012; Rutazibwa 2016). Using innovative methods like autophotography (Vastapuu 2018), narrative analysis (Wibben 2011; Shepherd 2012; Mehta and Wibben 2018), or poetic reimaginings (Sylvester 1993; Zalewski 2013; Ling 2014) should become as much part of the toolbox of global security scholars as survey research or experimental methods. What is more, being curious about what has heretofore been taken for granted and also being willing to be surprised, as Cynthia Enloe (2004) urges, can lead to the production of new knowledges, as Bettina Benzig (this issue) finds when challenging overly optimistic assessments of vernacular security. Similarly, studying sexualized violence in the Congo, Maria Eriksson Baaz and Maria Stern (2013) developed a “methodology of unease” when “little was as we had (unwittingly?) expected it to be, and the unease that ensued from then on served as our methodological guide and compass”(Eriksson Baaz and Stern 2016, 124).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.