Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Technology designs spill out to create gendered cybersecurity that causes violence and victim-blaming

Millar, Shires, and Tropina 21

Katharine, Assistant Professor of International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science; James, Assistant Professor with the Institute of Security and Global Affairs at the Leiden University, the Netherlands, and a fellow with the Cyber Statecraft Initiative at the Atlantic Council; Tatiana, Assistant Professor in Cybersecurity Governance with the Institute of Security and Global Affairs at Leiden University. “Design.” Gender approaches to cybersecurity: design, defence and response. United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research 2021. Pg 18-20. LJS

Over and above the specific context of cybersecurity, technology design is gendered: it misunderstands, omits and consolidates certain gendered uses, it privileges perceived masculine practices over feminine ones, and it stereotypes femininity in problematic ways.25 These gendered aspects have direct impact on cybersecurity. Many technology designers are aware of the gendered implications of their work, and there are entire subdisciplines, including user experience and user-centred design, that seek to improve technology design along gendered lines.26 The following are select examples of gendered technology design: » Virtual reality prototypes have, like many technologies, omitted women almost entirely as their intended users.27 » The choice of women voice assistants for phones, smart speakers and devices, and satellite navigation has been shown to reinforce harmful assumptions about gendered power relationships.28 » The design of technologies directly marketed to women, known as “femvertizing”, often “prey[s] on women’s assumptive need to correct problematic behaviors or unacceptable physical deviancies”.29 Gendered assumptions about what is “normal” are deployed in advertising material to encourage women to purchase products that enable them to conform or minimize “abnormal” physical and personal characteristics. » There are gendered differences in academic and industry research on technology, as in other fields, including in citation practices.30 These broader gendered aspects of technology design influence cybersecurity in several ways. Most basically, the conception of cybersecurity employed in technological design is gendered. For example, the design of smart household devices has not adequately included intimate partner violence in the “threat modelling” phase of design, meaning that supposedly secure smart devices increase gendered risks.31 Even services designed to prevent this problem, such as online resources about leaving abusive relationships, can themselves be a risk to individuals if the abuser discovers the tool. Therefore, the designers of such tools – such as emergency “exit” buttons on the websites of victim organizations – have to take these risks into account in their threat models.32 To reduce the occurrence of these inadvertently dangerous blind spots, it is thus important that the design and threat-modelling processes include diverse perspectives and people from minoritized groups.33 Another example can be found in contemporary cybersecurity measures aimed at protecting individuals from privacy breaches or identity theft, which rely on the use of personal information as the backup for passwords and online account access. These assume that the “bad actor” is a stranger without other access to the middle name of a parent or the name of a first pet – an assumption not met in instances of intimate partner and family violence.34 The design of online identity-verification procedures thus has gendered effects due to the conception of “threat” they employ (and, in this case, omit). The burden of cybersecurity work is also gendered. Privacy settings on social media are more likely to be activated by women, especially for images.35 Women are expected to exercise near-total control over their own digital footprint (such as changing passwords and deleting social media accounts, etc.) in order to reduce their vulnerability to digital coercive control.36 Failing to act as a perfect digital user – due to a lack of time or literacy, or a reliance on technology for support and social connections – becomes a source of victim-blaming.37 There is also a trade-off here between different cybersecurity goals: permitting companies to design applications that access location and other data can be a way of preventing other privacy threats, even though the companies use this data commercially, which can itself be a threat. Finally, the advertising of cybersecurity technologies is gendered. Software that can remotely monitor phones and other devices is marketed as designed for child protection, enabling families to track the movements of their children online.38 But this software is also used in situations of intimate partner violence (and is often termed “stalkerware”).39 Google has banned all advertising of stalkerware to combat this dual-use problem.40 Overall, cybersecurity design inherits the gendered omissions, biases and reinforcement of gendered assumptions that are evident in technology design. The threat models, reporting and user-control procedures, and advertising of cybersecurity technologies mean that women (or the most vulnerable gender groups in a particular context) are more likely to have cybersecurity threats downplayed or omitted; more likely to have additional security burdens; and more likely to be affected by disingenuous cybersecurity advertising.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.