Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The field of cybersecurity reinforces patriarchal norms through threat construction and constraints within the industry

Millar, Shires, and Tropina 21

Katharine, Assistant Professor of International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science; James, Assistant Professor with the Institute of Security and Global Affairs at the Leiden University, the Netherlands, and a fellow with the Cyber Statecraft Initiative at the Atlantic Council; Tatiana, Assistant Professor in Cybersecurity Governance with the Institute of Security and Global Affairs at Leiden University. “Defence.” Gender approaches to cybersecurity: design, defence and response. United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research 2021. Pg 28-36. LJS

How we think about defence – that is, what it means to defend and the common-sense actions we take to defend – is gendered. It reflects a series of norms associated with masculinity (e.g. protection, technical competence, autonomy, etc.) that derive from military understandings of national security.63 This is often positive since it makes cybersecurity intelligible for a wide range of non-experts through the use of parallel concepts and language. It can also, however, have negative effects. Many of the challenges associated with gender and cybersecurity defence derive from a mismatch between conventional understandings of national defence and cybersecurity, which is premised upon mitigating and managing, rather than eliminating, risks. Masculine norms and expectations that relate to using force to produce physical safety, for instance, may lead policy makers to downplay nonphysical harms in cybersecurity.64 Masculine gender norms around vulnerability can make admitting error, seeking help or working cooperatively more difficult.65 This can lead to reluctance to actively pursue cybersecurity defence or to be adequate transparent about failures to clients, employees or citizens. Such norms can also lead to the prioritization of some individuals and organizations – often those seen as socially prestigious or valuable for defence and protection (such as the State, the military or large corporations) – over others (such as civil society organizations and individuals, notably women and LGBTQ+66 people).67 A full gender perspective on cybersecurity defence recognizes that civil society and groups representing women and LGBTQ+ people have a need for, and a right to, cybersecurity defence – including the State resources (in terms of capacity-building, expertise and enforcement) needed to provide it. More specifically, different elements of cybersecurity defence raise separate gender issues. Threats need to be monitored through the continuous evaluation and analysis of networks, infrastructure and devices for potential intrusions or deliberate disruption.68 Following from this, at a basic level, what is considered to be a threat is gendered. Cybersecurity is typically concerned with military and corporate security (and thus threats relating to espionage and economic theft). A gendered understanding of cybersecurity threat, however, recognizes that those “traditional” threats, such as denial of service attacks on State services, have gendered outcomes.69 It also recognizes that intimate partner violence, doxing, cyberstalking and the non-consensual dissemination of intimate images (i.e. “revenge porn”) are also threats that can arise from the intrusion into or disruption of personal devices and networks.70 In terms of technical processes, insofar as threat monitoring relies on machine learning it is vulnerable to importing the gendered issues that typify the machine learning field, including gendered assumptions built into algorithms and biased data.71 Even this largely automated process rests on human judgments about organizational priorities, allocation of resources and capacity building – all of which open the potential for the creation or intensification of inequalities. For instance, an automated email filter that identifies potentially harmful emails should flag romantic scams as well as phishing emails and financial scams.72 The processes of preparing for and responding to threats are also gendered. Threat simulations, for instance, such as the common practice of fake phishing emails, often involve gender stereotyping (e.g. a woman in an assistant role, a man as CEO).73 There is a lack of gender-disaggregated data on phishing victims, which makes the gender consequences of phishing difficult to assess. But such an assessment is essential since, if many cybersecurity breaches result from human error, policy makers need to have a variety of approaches to the “human” making the errors. Bug bounty programmes, which are a spectrum of ways for “friendly” hackers to identify an organization’s vulnerabilities and defence responses through digital, social or physical vectors, raise associated issues. As these contests are designed to be anonymous, only pseudonymic data (i.e. pertaining to hackers’ aliases) is available on prolific bounty hunters and their payments. The consequences of this anonymity are unclear: it may make it easier for women and LGBTQ+ people to participate or it may exacerbate the gendered inequalities of cybersecurity and hacking culture more generally (see the case study below). Furthermore, the characterization of threats themselves, from the hooded hacker popular in media portrayals to code names and pictures used in cybersecurity technical reports, also often include gendered qualities and harmful stereotypes.74 Finally, attempts to protect organizations (and, to some extent, individuals) from the costs and harms arising from cybersecurity attacks, predominantly through cybersecurity insurance policies, should also be assessed for gender implications.75 As with all insurance, it is important that threat assessments include gender analysis; that the criteria for being insurable can be met by women, men and non-binary people; and that pricing for organizations and individuals does not rely on gender stereotypes or produce discriminatory gender outcomes.76 4.1 Case study: talent and expertise Talent and expertise is a widely recognized issue in the cybersecurity industry. Although the question of talent and expertise obviously pertains to all aspects of cybersecurity, we focus here on the practice of “defence” (i.e. implementing security) since it is typically understood as cybersecurity’s central activity. Issues around talent and expertise are often expressed as a “gap” in cybersecurity expertise, meaning that the number of positions available is greater than the number of people qualified to fill them.77 As demonstrated by research by organizations such as the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise, this talent gap is global, although pressures are expressed differently in different local contexts.78 Many States have taken steps to incentivize people to join the cybersecurity industry and improve their level of skill once there. This is frequently complicated by competitive pressure between governments and the private sector, as government positions struggle to compete with private sector salaries.79 These issues with talent and expertise are exacerbated by gendered inequality, harms and visibility. Due to space constraints, this section discusses these dynamics quite generally. Understanding how and why gendered gaps, inequalities and harms operate in context, however, requires intersectional gender analysis that looks at how gender, race, sexuality, class, and rural or urban location, among other factors, interact to support the participation of some groups in cyber fields while marginalizing others. A recent survey by the International Information System Security Certification Consortium indicated that 24 per cent of cybersecurity professionals worldwide are women.80 The 2017 Global Information Security Workforce Study found that this lack of representation was accompanied by various forms of inequality, with 87 per cent of women reporting unconscious discrimination and 19 per cent overt discrimination.81 This is a widely recognized problem, with many websites and social media accounts creating “women in cybersecurity” networks and events specifically for women.82 Similar events, networks and capacity-building initiatives also exist to support the equality, equity and participation of queer people in cybersecurity.83 Following criticism of a lack of representation and visibility in cybersecurity conferences,84 events such as the RSA Conference – a prestigious series of international information technology (IT) events – have sought to ensure gender parity in keynote speakers and to increase the participation of women overall.85 We split the gender issues for cybersecurity talent and expertise into three separate areas: the broader gender dynamics in science, technology, mathematics and engineering (STEM) professions; gender in computer science and coding; and gender in the cybersecurity industry specifically. We recognize that not all cybersecurity positions are STEM or “technical” positions; the prominence of these positions within cybersecurity reflects a gendered valuation of jobs understood as “masculine” above others. These positions are also, however, where gender disparities are most evident, and so we focus on these positions in this section. 4.1.1 Gender dynamics in STEM Gender issues within STEM professions – again understood as a “gender gap” between men and women – are well-researched and typically understood in terms of pipeline and retention.86 It should be noted that much of this research and policy follows a binary, often heteronormative understanding of gender; much more needs to be done to understand the experiences and support the equitable participation of non-binary and queer people within STEM and cybersecurity. The causes of the “gender gap” are complex and context specific. Generally, barriers to gender equality in STEM include (a) disparities in access to infrastructure and education; (b) individual- and family-level financial constraints and priorities; and (c) the persistence of sociocultural and institutional gender norms that suggest STEM professions are predominantly for men.87 In some contexts, such as Malaysia and the Middle East, women’s participation in STEM education is considerable but is not translated into STEM careers.88 In the United States of America and the United Kingdom, in contrast, girls remain less likely to be encouraged to pursue study of STEM subjects and less likely to regard themselves as holding STEM talent or expertise.89 Many of the policies aimed at increasing the participation of women in STEM can also be applied to the cybersecurity industry. These include greater incorporation of STEM skills into girls’ education;90 the promotion of STEM university programmes to girls and women;91 actively recruiting women through campus visits and social media campaigns;92 offering mentoring and continuing education to women and girls already employed within organizations; and altering human resources policies to prioritize hiring and retaining women (e.g. by requiring that at least one woman be interviewed for all open positions; by improving parental leave policies, etc.).93 Disparities are often found in senior positions in STEM and technology start-ups and, given that cybersecurity is a young and fast-evolving field, the gendered dynamics of entrepreneurship are highly relevant.94 4.1.2 Gender in computer science and coding Fields that centrally involve computers and “coding” (an unsatisfactorily generic term for a wide range of distinct skills) have well-documented gendered problems. Although, again, it differs across contexts, there is a global digital literacy gap95 between women and girls and men and boys.96 Worldwide, “327 million fewer women than men have a smartphone and can access the mobile Internet”, while women are four times less likely than men to be IT professionals.97 It is worth remembering that early computing was relatively open to women and came to be seen as a masculine profession only as it rose in social prestige through its increasing importance to the economy.98 Research has demonstrated that some online communities arranged around coding – including gaming and hacking – demonstrate a masculinist culture that emphasizes aggressive language and individuated approaches to problem-solving and technical mastery, while devaluing characteristics perceived to be associated with femininity, such as empathy and the expression of emotion.99 These cultures can be explicitly misogynistic and homophobic, referring to women primarily as sex objects and to LGBTQ+ people in hateful and exclusionary terms.100 As these communities are often seen as a talent pool for cybersecurity expertise, there is a risk that cybersecurity recruitment will import anti-feminist and exclusionary norms (i.e. attitudes and practices that oppose and devalue gender equality and racial, ethnic and sexual inclusivity) into the workplace.101 This makes work environments uncomfortable (or hostile) to those who do not conform.102 The 2017 Global Information Security Workforce Survey found that 51 per cent of women in the field had experienced discrimination, compared to 15 per cent of men.103 This primarily affects women and marginalized groups, but may also affect men who do not identify with such norms.104 Workplaces that do not have an explicitly anti-feminist culture may still be organized and operated on the assumption that most workers are men and that values and practices associated with masculinity are neutral or “normal”.105 Although often without discriminatory or conscious intent, this perpetuates the gendered structure of cybersecurity expertise and thus influences hiring, opportunities for promotion and the ability to determine policy. Where women do enter these fields, their contribution is often framed with reference to essentialist characteristics such as emotional and social skills. Although these are positive attributes, framing women’s contributions predominantly in terms of, for example, empathy or caring solidifies gender stereotypes without necessarily increasing the value attributed to emotional, social and caring aspects of cyber expertise.106 A greater presence of women (and other members of marginalized groups) working in cybersecurity is believed to have two benefits. First, it can contribute to creative problem-solving and better policy governance and implementation through the introduction of diverse perspectives.108 Second, it is believed that these perspectives will lead to a gender perspective in cybersecurity overall.109 Research indicates that this can occur but that, without support, women and members of other minoritized groups may instead feel pressure to adapt to the workplace norm.110 Tokenized incorporation of women and members of minoritized groups, without recognizing their contributions or in ways that reinforce stereotypes, do not contribute to meaningful participation or greater equality.111 4.1.3 Gender in the cybersecurity industry Some gendered issues relate specifically to the cybersecurity industry. As the field of cybersecurity is growing in importance, influence and prestige, women’s participation in cybersecurity is a matter of equality and equity in terms of opportunities for success, recognition and earning potential. Some working practices in cybersecurity, such as the shift requirements of Security Operation Centres, require further analysis to assess their gendered implications. Similarly, many cybersecurity certification programmes require intense sprints with long hours, which is an impractical work model for people (more likely to be women) with childcare responsibilities.112 More subtly, the cultivation of work environments, institutional cultures and management styles that are skeptical of traditional or conventional authority, although often praised as a characteristic of an innovative workforce, agile organization and dynamic socio-technological sector, can facilitate a narrow understanding of masculinity (and discrimination) akin to the wider fields above.113 Addressing the “gender gap” in cybersecurity expertise therefore requires policies that promote the inclusion and participation of women and gender training to reduce harassment and discrimination and to support organizational and cultural shifts to value a variety of activities and capacities, including those usually more associated with femininity.114

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.