Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Gender Hierarchy represents the ordering principle of an anarchical system of IR – states operate according to constructed gendered identities where association with masculinity signals power, domination, honor, and chivalry in contrast to “weak” and “craven” femininities – this binary structure justifies the infinite exploitation and subordination of the feminized.

Sjoberg 17

Sjoberg, British Academy Global Professor of Politics and International Relations at Royal Holloway University of London. “The invisible structures of anarchy: Gender, orders, and global politics,” Journal of International Political Theory. 2017.

The argument that gender is a constitutive element of the international system is an argument that assumptions about gender are embedded in the ordering principles of the international system. This is consonant with feminist observations of global politics, which have characterized the global political arena as a “patriarchal structure of privilege and control” (Enloe, 1993: 70). Others see the global political arena a place where “the structure of political communities has assumed gendered forms” (Steans, 2003: 43), and ordered by “gender relations [which] structure social power” (Pettman, 1996: 43). These observations are rooted in feminist work which shows gender operating in how political leaders are chosen (Tickner, 1992), how state governments work (Peterson, 1992), how militaries function (Enloe, 1989), and how economic benefit is distributed (Pettman, 1996). States have been shown their relative military prowess, judged and asserted their relative power, and demonstrated and adjusted their relative economic status through gendered competition using gendered language (e.g. Cohn, 1987). The gender hierarchy in the world “out there” can be read as replicated in the “commonsense ground” or traditional theorizing in IR, which feminist theorists (e.g. Tickner, 1988) have characterized as partial at best and unrepresentative at worst because it often analyzes the perspectives and lives of only a small, elite, male portion of the global population. Paralleling Waltz’s understanding that anarchy can be seen manifested in the function of units (states) in the international arena, in the distribution of relative capacities among those units, and in the execution of political processes, Sjoberg (2012) argued that gender is a constitutive factor in what states do, important in the distribution of states’ relative capacities, and formative of political processes among states. In substantiating the claim that gender is a constitutive factor in what states do, Sjoberg (2012) builds on previous feminist empirical work around the world3 to suggest that states define their identities in gendered ways, where gender and national identity are inextricably linked, as “all nationalisms are gendered” (McClintock, 1993) and women are often the essence and symbols of the reproduction of state and/or national identity (e.g. Yuval-Davis, 1997). Hegemonic masculinities are among the influences that constitute nationalisms as gendered, where there is an ideal-typical notion of masculinity that both states and the men in them are expected to live up to, creating a relationship between militarism, masculinity, and full citizenship (Connell, 1995; Young, 2003). For the influence of gender on distribution of capacity in the international arena, Sjoberg (2012) builds on the feminist argument that “the structural and ideological system that perpetuates the privileging of masculinist” in IR is “a principle cause for so many of the world’s processes [such as] empire-building, globalization, modernization” (Enloe, 2004: 4, 6). Differences between dominant gender presentations and subordinated gender presentations play a role in hierarchies in the international arena, where it can be commonplace “to infantilize, ignore, trivialize, or even actively cast scorn on what is thought to be feminized” (Enloe, 2004: 5). What is thought to be feminized is not just women but also states and other political actors. Feminist research has shown that association with gender-based characteristics has been used as a marker of relative power in many policy discourses in diverse places around the world (e.g. Agathangelou, 2002; Banerjee, 2012; Eichler, 2012; Weber, 1999; Zalewski, 1994). In support of the argument that gender matters in shaping political processes, Sjoberg (2012) discusses feminist work on a number of different processes in global politics, including diplomacy (Enloe, 2000), interstate jurisprudence (Charlesworth et al., 1991), international institutions (Moser and Moser, 2005), interstate competition (Peterson and Runyan, 2010), and militarization (Alexander, 2010). Feminist work on militarization, for example, has shown that gender norms are used to shape the will to fight, to sharpen training, to build group solidarity, and to condition responses to battlefield injury (e.g. Alexander, 2010; Eichler, 2012; Enloe, 1993, 2000; Goldstein, 2001; Sjoberg and Peet, 2011). While this section is not the place to definitively explore the nature, direction, and contour of the influence of gender on how the international system works, this short outline of existing evidence suggests that gender itself is an ordering principle in global politics, both influencing the identity of actors and organizing them along hierarchies within anarchy. Feminist research provides significant evidence that gender hierarchies are prevalent in global politics, and matter in not only the results but also the constitution of interstate interactions. It provides a mandate to consider gender hierarchy as an important part of the ways that we think about hierarchy in global politics. One can see these gender hierarchies manifest in a number of the everyday (violent) features of global politics— places where women are being held unequal to men at the local, state, and global levels. From rape culture to human trafficking, unpaid care labor to gender-based violence, nowhere in the world are women socially, economically, or politically held equal to men. That is hierarchy based on gender—gender hierarchy in global politics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.